Pentagon ran secret anti-vax campaign to undermine China during pandemic

dann

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Feb 2, 2004
Messages
24,850
It is old news that the CIA ruined people's trust in vaccination campaigns when it was trying and eventually managed to track down Osama bin Laden:
CIA's hunt for Osama bin Laden fuelled vaccine hesitancy in Pakistan (NewScientist, May 11, 2021)

But this is news to me:
At the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, the U.S. military launched a secret campaign to counter what it perceived as China’s growing influence in the Philippines, a nation hit especially hard by the deadly virus.

The clandestine operation has not been previously reported. It aimed to sow doubt about the safety and efficacy of vaccines and other life-saving aid that was being supplied by China, a Reuters investigation found. Through phony internet accounts meant to impersonate Filipinos, the military’s propaganda efforts morphed into an anti-vax campaign. Social media posts decried the quality of face masks, test kits and the first vaccine that would become available in the Philippines – China’s Sinovac inoculation.

Reuters identified at least 300 accounts on X, formerly Twitter, that matched descriptions shared by former U.S. military officials familiar with the Philippines operation. Almost all were created in the summer of 2020 and centered on the slogan #Chinaangvirus – Tagalog for China is the virus.
Pentagon ran secret anti-vax campaign to undermine China during pandemic (Reuters, June 14, 2024)


AlJazeera about Reuter's report: US ran secret anti-vax campaign to undermine China’s COVID efforts: Report (AlJazeera, June 14, 2024)
A devious way of promoting antivaxxer sentiments.
 
Yay for politicians playing silly games with people's lives.
They should all be exiled to a leper colony.
 
Yes, and without access to the internet!
"... at least 300 accounts on X, formerly Twitter, that matched descriptions shared by former U.S. military officials familiar with the Philippines operation ..."
I'm surprised that we even hear about this. The media usually tells us only about Russian bot farms.
 
Then it seems as if MAGA's attempts to discredit face masks and the mRNA vaccines in the USA were much more successful than Pentagon's attempts to discredit China's face masks, test kits and the Sinovac vaccine:
The US Defence Department did not deny a report accusing the Pentagon of orchestrating a secret campaign meant to discredit Chinese Covid-19 vaccines, and suggested that the move was an attempt to counter “malign influence campaigns” run by Beijing.

The department said on Sunday, in response to a query about a Reuters report that the Pentagon tried to discredit the quality of Chinese face masks, test kits and the country’s Sinovac vaccine, that it conducts “a wide range of operations, including operations in the information environment (OIE), to counter adversary malign influence”.

The report said the campaign to discredit the Chinese vaccine began in the spring of 2020 and expanded beyond Southeast Asia before it was terminated in mid-2021, several months into the administration of US President Joe Biden.
(...)
Sinovac, whose vaccine was the first Covid-19 jab to become available in the Philippines, reacted quickly to the report, calling the Pentagon campaign a “wrong attack that will create enormous disaster”.
Pentagon not denying secret campaign to discredit Chinese vaccines (South China Morning Post, June 17, 2024)

Beijing calls on Washington to ‘stop fabricating and disseminating false information against other countries’ (South China Morning Post, June 17, 2024)

Is this the American way of winning the hearts and minds (Wikipedia) of the Chinese population?

ETA: Forbes and Newsweek have the story, but I don't find anything from CNN, CBS, NBC, MSNBC, NYT or WaPo.
 
Last edited:
Yes, but he wasn't in a hurry to do so!
From the first article:
The military program started under former President Donald Trump and continued months into Joe Biden’s presidency, Reuters found – even after alarmed social media executives warned the new administration that the Pentagon had been trafficking in COVID misinformation. The Biden White House issued an edict in spring 2021 banning the anti-vax effort, which also disparaged vaccines produced by other rivals, and the Pentagon initiated an internal review, Reuters found.
(...)
Spokespeople for Trump and Biden did not respond to requests for comment about the clandestine program.
(...)
The military argued that many of its fake accounts were being used for counterterrorism and asked Facebook not to take down the content, according to two people familiar with the exchange. The Pentagon pledged to stop spreading COVID-related propaganda, and some of the accounts continued to remain active on Facebook.
Nonetheless, the anti-vax campaign continued into 2021 as Biden took office.
Angered that military officials had ignored their warning, Facebook officials arranged a Zoom meeting with Biden’s new National Security Council shortly after the inauguration, Reuters learned. The discussion quickly became tense.
“It was terrible,” said a senior administration official describing the reaction after learning of the campaign’s pig-related posts. “I was shocked. The administration was pro-vaccine and our concern was this could affect vaccine hesitancy, especially in developing countries.”
Pentagon ran secret anti-vax campaign to undermine China during pandemic (Reuters, June 14, 2024)


Not something to be proud of, is it?

Some examples of the U.S. anti-vaxxer propaganda:
TRANSLATION FROM ARABIC
This is what the #United_States is offering to help countries, including Arab countries, obtain #Coronavirus (#Covid_19) vaccines and mitigate the secondary effects of the pandemic. Compare this with #Russia and #China using the pandemic excuse to expand their influence and profit even though the Russian vaccine is ineffective and the Chinese vaccine contains pork gelatin

TRANSLATION FROM RUSSIAN
Can China be trusted if it tries to hide that its vaccine contains pork gelatin, and distributes it in Central Asia and other Muslim countries, where many people consider such a drug “haram”?
[See illustration in the article]
Text: In this post, created by the U.S. military, a Chinese flag conceals pigs from a group of Muslims who are about to be vaccinated. The propaganda sought to convince Muslims in Russian-speaking countries that China’s COVID vaccines were “haram,” or forbidden.

TRANSLATION FROM RUSSIAN
Muslim scientists from the Raza Academy in Mumbai reported that the Chinese coronavirus vaccine contains gelatin from pork and recommended against vaccination with the haram vaccine. China hides what exactly this drug is made of, which causes mistrust among Muslims.
[See foto in article]
Text: The secret U.S. military propaganda campaign intensified fears among Muslims that the China-made vaccine was “haram,” or forbidden. Public health experts say the messaging put lives at risk for geopolitical gain.

TRANSLATION FROM TAGALOG
WE SHOULD NOT TRUST THOSE MED SUPPLIES BY CHINA REALLY. Everything is fake! Face mask, PPE, and test kits. There is a possibility that their vaccine is fake…
COVID came from China. What if their vaccines are dangerous??
It’s normal for Filipinos not to trust China, given the number of problems they gave us??
The U.S. military’s secret propaganda sought to sow doubt about China’s efforts to help fight COVID in the Philippines, one of the hardest hit countries in Southeast Asia.

TRANSLATION FROM RUSSIAN
Turkmenistan residents report that the Chinese vaccine causes severe side effects. Those vaccinated with the Chinese drug experience severe nausea, vomiting and diarrhea. Some called ambulance services and ended up in intensive care.


Nothing seems to indicate that these examples were MAGA-made!
 
A new Reuters article about China's reaction to Reuters' investigation:
MANILA, June 18 (Reuters) - China's embassy in the Philippines accused the U.S. military of "hypocrisy, malign intention and double standards" in response to a report of secret U.S. campaign to undermine confidence in a Chinese vaccines and other aid during the COVID-19 pandemic.
(...)
The investigation found the U.S. military aimed to sow doubt about the safety and efficacy of vaccines and other life-saving aid supplied by China. Through phony internet accounts meant to impersonate Filipinos, the military's propaganda efforts morphed into an anti-vax campaign, according to the report.
(...)
"While talking about respecting human rights, the United States does just the opposite regarding the fundamental human rights of life and health of the Filipino people."
China accuses U.S. of "malign intention" to discredit its COVID vaccines (Reuters, June 18, 2024)


By the way, Pentagon's disinformation campaign doesn't seem to have discouraged the Philippine government from using the Chinese vaccine:
November 21 – Senate president Vicente Sotto III revealed senator Panfilo Lacson and Leyte congressman Martin Romualdez were the first high officials who had been inoculated with a COVID-19 vaccine
(...)
December 27
President Duterte revealed that many already received the Sinopharm BIBP vaccine, including military men despite it has yet to get approval from FDA
Timeline of the COVID-19 pandemic in the Philippines (2020) (Wikipedia)

Duterte claims Philippine military, others received Sinopharm vaccine (GMA News Online, Dec 27, 2020)

I wonder if the USA accomplished anything other than, possibly, to alienate allies with its disinformation stunt.

As for Pentagon's reaction to Reuters' report:
A Pentagon spokeswoman was cited in the report as saying the U.S. military "uses a variety of platforms, including social media, to counter those malign influence attacks aimed at the U.S., allies, and partners." She also said China had started a "disinformation campaign to falsely blame the United States for the spread of COVID-19."


That was a very stupid thing to do, but apropos of countering: Did the American accusations against China of having created the virus in a lab and then let it loose on the world come before or after China started blaming the USA for spreading C19?!
 
Quoting your own post:
Nonetheless, the anti-vax campaign continued into 2021 as Biden took office.
So, the incoming president, barely into the seat. And we know how non-forthcoming and opaque the outgoing Trump team were in handing stuff over. They provided sweet Fanny Adams in the way of anything helpful. Much more interested in railing about some imaginary rigged election than being professional.

Angered that military officials had ignored their warning, Facebook officials arranged a Zoom meeting with Biden’s new National Security Council shortly after the inauguration, Reuters learned.
Well, there you go. One of the first things to hit Biden's new desk, it seems. And they promptly stopped it.

Please stop trying to convince us this was a Trump program that the Dems continued. It wasn't; they didn't.
 
It was a Pentagon program that the Biden administration continued - until it was stopped.
"Barely into the seat" is hyperbole!
Quoting my own post:
... continued months into Joe Biden’s presidency, Reuters found – even after alarmed social media executives warned the new administration that the Pentagon had been trafficking in COVID misinformation.


Please stop trying to pretend that Biden is wonderful.
Fascism is obviously worse, but there is no reason to pretend that the world presents you with only two alternatives and your only option is to choose between the two, or three, of them. But that's a political discussion and probably doesn't belong in Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology.
 
Last edited:
Reuters reports today that the US Defense Department spread anti-vaccine messaging across Southeast Asia during COVID as part of an effort to discredit Chinese-manufactured vaccines. General Dynamics was contracted to author social media posts in the Philippines decrying the quality of Chinese face masks, test kits, and the Sinovac inoculation. The propaganda campaign was later expanded to audiences across Central Asia and the Middle East.

China was far more generous than the US in sharing vaccines early in the pandemic so that, in countries like the Philippines, the COVID vaccine choice in 2021 was Sinovac or nothing. The Defense Department operation encouraged people across Asia and the Middle East to choose nothing, lying that vaccines contained pork gelatin, didn't work, and had terrible side effects. This will have cost lives at the time, and it will have added to growing global distrust of vaccines, costing more lives into the future.
(...)
At the least, the Administration should amend EO 12333 to mandate that no US intelligence or psychological warfare operation will involve or interfere with public health efforts, including vaccination programs.
It’s Time to Ban Intelligence Operations from Interfering in Public Health (Center for Global Development, June 14, 2024)


The Biden administration also interfered with the Cuban vaccination program by exacerbating the blockade. That also meant that thousands of lives were lost that could otherwise have been saved by the country's own vaccines.
Why didn't Biden propose something like this?
Moreover, there was a better model. It’s often forgotten but the elimination of smallpox from the planet, one of humanities greatest feats, was a global effort spearheaded by the United States and….the Soviet Union.
…even while engaged in a pitched battle for influence across the globe, the Soviet Union and the United States were able to harness their domestic and geopolitical self-interests and their mutual interest in using science and technology to advance human development and produce a remarkable public health achievement.
We could have taken a similar approach with China during the COVID pandemic.
The Pentagon’s Anti-Vax Campaign (MarginalRevolution, June 17, 2024)
 
Last edited:
It should be noted that it took a special permission for the Pentagon to run a psyops, which it's not supposed to do unless during wartime.
Something the Trump White House signed off on.
 
It was a Pentagon program that the Biden administration continued - until it was stopped.
"Barely into the seat" is hyperbole!
Quoting my own post:

Please stop trying to pretend that Biden is wonderful.
Fascism is obviously worse, but there is no reason to pretend that the world presents you with only two alternatives and your only option is to choose between the two, or three, of them. But that's a political discussion and probably doesn't belong in Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology.

I am not. You should know why not by now too. He has many ongoing faults and failings I do not like. Whereas the Trump team is ALL faults and failings...and crime.

Again, given the huge amount of rubbish the incoming Biden administration had to clear out from the recalcitrant Trump administration, "a few months" to uncover and halt a covert program is "almost immediately".

You do realise that the Trump office failed to hand over just about anything when the incoming president took office? Almost no transition at all. For the Dems, it was like walking into a rental house after the previous tenants had trashed it then fled. First, they had to clean up some immediate dungheaps before repairing the plumbing.
 
By the way, Pentagon's disinformation campaign doesn't seem to have discouraged the Philippine government from using the Chinese vaccine:
So not quite the effect Trump was hoping for.

I wonder if the USA accomplished anything other than, possibly, to alienate allies with its disinformation stunt.
Trump alienated many allies, but the damage is slowly being repaired.

That was a very stupid thing to do, but apropos of countering: Did the American accusations against China of having created the virus in a lab and then let it loose on the world come before or after China started blaming the USA for spreading C19?!
Tit for tat. This is standard practice in the diplomatic world.

As for silly, Trump was president so silly was the norm. It will take decades to undo the damage he and his supporters did - assuming he loses this election.
 
You do realise that the Trump office failed to hand over just about anything when the incoming president took office? Almost no transition at all. For the Dems, it was like walking into a rental house after the previous tenants had trashed it then fled. First, they had to clean up some immediate dungheaps before repairing the plumbing.


Yes, I do realize that. But I also realize that you keep making excuses for Biden & Co. while ignoring things like this:
"months into Joe Biden’s presidency, Reuters found – even after alarmed social media executives warned the new administration."

Apparently, it was not considered to be 'some immediate dungheap' that an allied country was being fed propaganda lies about C19 vaccines by the Pentagon. And only one year later, in February 2022, "repairing the plumbing" meant telling Americans and the rest of the world that the pandemic was over while making sure that the 'plumbing' in the White House was top notch!
 
So not quite the effect Trump was hoping for.


I doubt that Trump took much of an interest in this project. The Philippines would be just another one of the many "****hole countries" to him. He was busy making up nicknames for the pandemic, which seems to be his preferred way to tackle everything: the 'Gina virus'. I don't know who may have come up with the idea; if it was somebody in the Trump administration or if Pentagon came up with it on their own.
On the other hand, he's a big fan of retaliation, so maybe ...

Trump alienated many allies, but the damage is slowly being repaired.

Tit for tat. This is standard practice in the diplomatic world.

As for silly, Trump was president so silly was the norm. It will take decades to undo the damage he and his supporters did - assuming he loses this election.


When I said "That was a very stupid thing to do," I meant what China did: blaming the USA for having spread the virus. (Even though the herd-immunity-by-infection strategy certainly encouraged spreading it.) It was as stupid as when RT tried to turn the accusation that Russia had zapped U.S. diplomats' brains against the USA by claiming that the CIA had tested its DEWs on its own staff and thus damaged their brains.
I can see why it would be tempting to use the enemy's argument against himself, but Cuba showed the way to do it, Science, bitch! in the case of the pandemic as well as the 'syndrome'.

Let's return to the science of the pandemic and of pandemic disinformation campaigns.
 
Yes, I do realize that. But I also realize that you keep making excuses for Biden & Co. while ignoring things like this:
"months into Joe Biden’s presidency, Reuters found – even after alarmed social media executives warned the new administration."

Apparently, it was not considered to be 'some immediate dungheap' that an allied country was being fed propaganda lies about C19 vaccines by the Pentagon. And only one year later, in February 2022, "repairing the plumbing" meant telling Americans and the rest of the world that the pandemic was over while making sure that the 'plumbing' in the White House was top notch!

Stop that, please. I am not making excuses for any of them, and made that very clear. Again, have a good think why I could not make excuses for them even if I wanted to.

I just pointed out that this was just one of the literally thousands of things they had to deal with cleaning up after Trump and getting the ship of state the right way up, not sinking and back on course. Even now, not everything Trump broke has been fixed. There's finite resources, things take time, priorities need to be set, and the GQP have been actively throwing logs across the road.

That does not mean this subject never happened, and was not important. But it was not the only one.


BTW. Vaccine hesitancy has been rife in Pakistan from long before COVID. For many decades if not over a century. The main perpetrators have been the local homoeopaths, preying on uneducated gullible folk, dressing it up with ayurvedic nonsense and anti-British invective.
 
Last edited:
I read an article about this and like dann find it disgusting. I was thinking about starting a thread but, well, I guess I didn't get around to it. So thanks dann for starting this thread. It's an important issue.

https://www.cgdev.org/blog/its-time-ban-intelligence-operations-interfering-public-health
Sadly, this is not the first time the US national security apparatus has ignored that fact: The CIA used the cover of a vaccination drive to try to gain intelligence on the whereabouts of Osama bin Laden. When this leaked, anti-vaccine sentiment in South Asia spiked. In December 2012, ten polio vaccination workers in Pakistan and Afghanistan were shot, and the vaccination drive was suspended. At the time, I proposed an amendment to Presidential Executive Order 12333, which covers restrictions to US intelligence operations including against assassination, to cover child health programs. The CIA did subsequently ban the use of vaccination drives as cover in their operations. But clearly this was inadequate.

At the least, the Administration should amend EO 12333 to mandate that no US intelligence or psychological warfare operation will involve or interfere with public health efforts, including vaccination programs.

I think the highlighted is probably something we can all agree on here.
 
Stop that, please. I am not making excuses for any of them, and made that very clear. Again, have a good think why I could not make excuses for them even if I wanted to.

I just pointed out that this was just one of the literally thousands of things they had to deal with cleaning up after Trump and getting the ship of state the right way up, not sinking and back on course. Even now, not everything Trump broke has been fixed. There's finite resources, things take time, priorities need to be set, and the GQP have been actively throwing logs across the road.

That does not mean this subject never happened, and was not important. But it was not the only one.


BTW. Vaccine hesitancy has been rife in Pakistan from long before COVID. For many decades if not over a century. The main perpetrators have been the local homoeopaths, preying on uneducated gullible folk, dressing it up with ayurvedic nonsense and anti-British invective.


You are still making those excuses while claiming that you don't make them.
As for Pakistan, see the first link to New Scientist in the OP.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom