Cont: The One Covid-19 Science and Medicine Thread Part 5

New Long-Covid Study - not of veterans but of young Marines

Preprint:
Results: A total of 197/798 (24.7%) study participants developed PASC. Among these, the most prevalent symptoms were loss of taste and/or smell (n=82; 41.6%), shortness of breath (n=74; 37.6%), and cough (n=45; 22.8%). Those with PASC had higher rates and severity of somatic (p<0.001), general depressive (p<0.001), and anxiety (p<0.005) symptoms. Compared to a historic cohort of Marines, participants with PASC scored worse on their physical fitness assessment due to slower run times (p<0.002). Those with PASC continued to have decreased physical performance one year after completing initial training.

Discussion: In this population of healthy young adult US Marines with mostly either asymptomatic or mild acute COVID-19, one fourth reported physical, cognitive, or psychiatric long-term sequelae of infection.
The Marines affected with PASC/LC showed evidence of long-term decrease in functional performance suggesting that SARS-CoV-2 infection may negatively affect health for a significant proportion of young adults.
Clinical and Functional Assessment of SARS-CoV-2 Sequelae Among Young Marines (SSRN, June 6, 2024)
PASC = Post-acute sequelae of COVID-19.

Graph of self-reported of severity of solicited acute symptoms of COVID-19 among CHARM 2.0 participants in this tweet.


An older study (2021) of (obviously young and fit) soccer players:
Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf, Düsseldorf Institute for Competition Economics (DICE), Düsseldorf

The COVID-19 pandemic has caused economic shock waves across the globe. Much research addresses direct health implications of an infection, but to date little is known about how this shapes lasting economic effects. This paper estimates the workplace productivity effects of COVID-19 by studying performance of soccer players after an infection. We construct a dataset that encompasses all traceable infections in the elite leagues of Germany and Italy. Relying on a staggered difference-in-differences design, we identify negative short- and longer-run performance effects. Relative to their preinfection outcomes, infected players' performance temporarily drops by more than 6%. Over half a year later, it is still around 5% lower. The negative effects appear to have notable spillovers on team performance. We argue that our results could have important implications for labor markets and public health in general. Countries and firms with more infections might face economic disadvantages that exceed the temporary pandemic shock due to potentially long-lasting reductions in productivity.
The long shadow of an infection: COVID-19 and performance at work (Econstor.eu)
 
Last edited:
Long Covid (LC)

NASEM news release about Long Covid:
Full Definition
Long COVID (LC) is an infection-associated chronic condition that occurs after SARS-CoV-2 infection and is present for at least three months as a continuous, relapsing and remitting, or progressive disease state that affects one or more organ systems.

LC manifests in multiple ways. A complete enumeration of possible signs, symptoms, and diagnosable conditions of LC would have hundreds of entries. Any organ system can be involved, and LC patients can present with:
* single or multiple symptoms, such as shortness of breath, cough, persistent fatigue, post-exertional malaise, difficulty concentrating, memory changes, recurring headache, lightheadedness, fast heart rate, sleep disturbance, problems with taste or smell, bloating, constipation, and diarrhea.
* Single or multiple diagnosable conditions, such as interstitial lung disease and hypoxemia, cardiovascular disease and arrhythmias, cognitive impairment, mood disorders, anxiety, migraine, stroke, blood clots, chronic kidney disease, postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS) and other forms of dysautonomia, myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS), fibromyalgia, connective tissue diseases, hyperlipidemia, diabetes, and autoimmune disorders such as lupus, rheumatoid arthritis, and Sjögren’s syndrome.


Important features are:
* LC can follow asymptomatic, mild, or severe SARS-CoV-2 infection. Previous infections may have been recognized or unrecognized.
* LC can be continuous from the time of acute SARS-CoV-2 infection or can be delayed in onset for weeks or months following what had appeared to be full recovery from acute infection.
* LC can affect children and adults, regardless of health, disability, or socioeconomic status, age, sex, gender, sexual orientation, race, ethnicity, or geographic location.
* LC can exacerbate preexisting health conditions or present as new conditions.
* LC can range from mild to severe. It can resolve over a period of months or can persist for months or years.
* LC can be diagnosed on clinical grounds. No biomarker currently available demonstrates conclusively the presence of LC.
* LC can impair an affected individual’s abilities to work, attend school, take care of family, and care for themselves. It can have a profound emotional and physical impact on patients and their families and caregivers.
Federal Government, Clinicians, Employers, and Others Should Adopt New Definition for Long COVID to Aid in Consistent Diagnosis, Documentation, and Treatment (NASEM, June 11, 2024)


The lack of a clear and consistent definition for Long COVID presents challenges for policymakers, researchers, public health professionals, clinicians, support services, and patients. As such, the Administration for Strategic Preparedness and Response and the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Health asked the National Academies to assemble a committee of experts to produce a consensus definition for Long COVID. The resulting report, A Long COVID Definition: A Chronic, Systemic Disease State with Profound Consequences, presents the 2024 NASEM Long COVID Definition, developed based on findings reported in existing literature, as well as stakeholder and patient input.
A Long COVID Definition - A Chronic, Systemic Disease State with Profound Consequences (NASEM, June 2024)

pdf version
 
Long Covid

I am not always impressed by the Washington Post editorial board's opinion pieces, but this one is better than the one it based on 60 Minutes' 'investigation' of the 'Havana syndrome':
Long covid, the symptoms that can linger for months or even years after infection with the pandemic virus, is still a subject of considerable uncertainty. The virus can damage the body in a multitude of ways, leading researchers to list more than 200 symptoms, and there is no single diagnostic test or cure. But even with the unknowns, evidence suggests that long covid could burden millions of people. Its effects — on individuals, but also on society at large — could be protracted and expensive.
This is the implication of two just-published studies from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine. The first study, published on June 5, examined the potential impairment and disability caused by long covid. The second study, published on June 11, provided a much-needed consensus definition — there have been numerous different ones previously — to help patients, doctors, researchers and policymakers work from the same page.
(...)
Based on population surveys, the researchers found, in 2022 approximately 8.9 million adults in the United States reported long covid symptoms. Just recently, a separate study found an estimated 6.9 percent of adults — 17.8 million — had ever had long covid as of early 2023.
(...)
These studies are early warnings in what will probably be a long process. The nation must prepare to cope accurately and compassionately with a wave of illness and impairment that might come.
Opinion: Long covid might presage a wave of disability claims. Get ready. (WaPo, June 17, 2024)


Maybe the nation should prepare to cope with the ongoing pandemic and do something to limit the number of people who are still being infected, hospitalized and killed, with or without prior immunization, but that doesn't appear to be the in the works. :-(
 
Data suggest hybrid immunity protects against long COVID

Interesting analysis of long covid (PCC) and infections, re-infections and vaxxes.

https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/data-suggest-hybrid-immunity-protects-against-long-covid

Virus variant type had the greatest influence on developing long COVID. "Any PCC occurred in around 7% after an infection during the Omicron phase for those with a previous infection and in 47% after initial infection with the Wildtype virus," the authors wrote.

The risk of developing any PCC after a second infection if PCC did not follow a first infection was substantially lower compared to after the first infection, resulting in a long-term risk reduction of around 50%, the authors said.

But the risk of developing long COVID was higher in people who were infected less than 3 months following a vaccination, but approximately 50% compared to those who were infected 4 to 6 months after vaccination.
 
Wow, that's almost a recommendation not to get more vaccines.

It's certainly unexpected. Perhaps it's due to the lack of or disfunctional immunity. The vaccine studies out there show boosters provide about 3-4 months of efficacy against symptomatic infection but rapidly declining after that. So that smaller number that get Covid in the first few months might have gotten long covid vaxxed or not.

In any case researchers need to jump on it. Answers are needed.
 
In any case researchers need to jump on it. Answers are needed.

As we've been saying for 3 years.

The most important thing at this stage is the trend, which are all positive, with lower waves and lower rate of hospitalisation being the standouts. Given research lagging the disease by a couple of years, it's probably just as well.
 
As we've been saying for 3 years.

The most important thing at this stage is the trend, which are all positive, with lower waves and lower rate of hospitalisation being the standouts. Given research lagging the disease by a couple of years, it's probably just as well.

Yep. Trend is good and consistent with broadening immunity to severe disease on re-infection. At least for most. In the USA the 2019-20 flu season killed more people under 50 than Covid-19 during 2023. Big drop (10x) from 2021. Another indication of broadening immunity. Initially from vax, now mostly from infection/re-infection.
 
Last edited:
From the CIDRAP article:
[SIZE=+2]"Our findings indicate that the risk of developing PCC was strongly reduced for the second SARS-CoV-2 infection"[/SIZE]
"Our findings indicate that the risk of developing PCC was strongly reduced for the second SARS-CoV-2 infection, if the first infection did not result in PCC," the authors concluded. "It is possible that the occurrence of breakthrough infections shortly after vaccination is linked to a specific vulnerability of the individual towards PCC, and the apparent protection actually results from confoundingData suggest hybrid immunity protects against long COVID (CIDRAP, June 18, 2024)


Notice that, for whatever reason, the emphasized quotation leaves out the if-part of the sentence!

What it actually says is that if you didn't get Long Covid (PCC) the first time (and it's possible that you did), you can still get it the second time, but you are less likely to get it the second time if you didn't already get it the first time. The implication is obvious: Any new infection increases your risk of getting Long Covid, but less so if you didn't already get it.
And the reason why you are less likely to get it the second time, may be due to the "specific vulnerability" of individuals, i.e. some individuals are more likely to get it than others, and you may be one of those who isn't, which is indeed confounding.

I recommend that people don't get the second, third, fourth, and fifth infection and, if still feasible, avoid getting the first infection, too.
As quoted yesterday in post 974 of the other thread, COVID-19 infections aren't good for the immune system:
Dr. David Putrino, Dir. of Rehabilitation Innovation of Mt Sinai Health System:
We know that SARS-CoV-2 is affecting the immune system. Our group along with our collaborators from Yale and Stanford University as well as other groups have published multiple times that even mild Covid infections seem to affect the way that your natural killer cells attack infections. It seems to affect the way that our T-cells attack infections and protect us from infections. So I think while the notion is that we actually need challenges for the longest time:
We have told people that, 'You know, if you get an illness and you recover, it just makes you stronger'. What we're seeing over and over again is, that's not the case with Covid. Every time you get a Covid infection, your immune system seems to suffer. It's kind of like a boxer: Every fight takes a little bit more out of them. They're not getting stronger with every fight. They are not getting stronger with every hit they take. Every single time, there's an increased chance that something bad is going to happen to the immune system. And I think that this influx of illness that we are seeing is related to that.
(...)
Putrino: The only thing that we can do to protect ourselves, our families, our immune systems long-term, is to avoid infection.
 
This is the conclusion that The Atheist jumps to:
Wow, that's almost a recommendation not to get more vaccines.


Maybe The Atheist is unaware that the "hybrid immunity" mentioned in the title of the article implies vaccination! Vaccination is mentioned explicitly in the very first sentence:
A study yesterday in the Journal of Infection shows that hybrid immunity from both a fourth vaccination dose and previous COVID-19 illnesses may offer protection against developing long COVID, or post-COVID condition (PCC).
Data suggest hybrid immunity protects against long COVID (CIDRAP, June 18, 2024)

I don't know why marting doesn't point out these things to him.


ETA: From the highlight of the actual study in the Journal of Infection:
A fourth vaccination offers a strong protection against Post-COVID-19 condition

Does this sound like "almost a recommendation not to get more vaccines"?

Minimizers gonna minimize, antivaxxers gonna antivax.
 
Last edited:
As we've been saying for 3 years.

The most important thing at this stage is the trend, which are all positive, with lower waves and lower rate of hospitalisation being the standouts. Given research lagging the disease by a couple of years, it's probably just as well.


We know what The Atheist has been saying for three years:
I posted this in the science thread yesterday.
... 'Flu deaths here are ~500 a year, and omicron's going to be much lower than that.
Barring a new variant of concern, the pandemic is done and dusted.


And yet the pandemic isn't "done and dusted." The pandemic is still here, it's still maiming and killing far more people than the flu, killing far more people in New Zealand than ~500 a year, and even killing far more people younger than 65.
 
In the USA the 2019-20 flu season killed more people under 50 than Covid-19 during 2023.


And every year since 2020, COVID-19 has killed considerably more people, also far more people under 65, than the flu - including 2023-24.
Or is San Diego an outlier in this respect?!

More interesting data:
In 2023-24, COVID-19 killed 34 0-64-year-olds in San Diego. That is far more 0-64-year-olds than was killed by the flu on average in the years 2007-08 to 2018-19.
See Figure 10. Influenza Deaths by Age and Season (County of San Diego, Influenza Watch)

This under 50 (or under 80 or under whatever) has turned into the favorite goalpost-moving tool for marting and The Atheist, and yet, when you take a closer look, it never really seems to work out to their advantage. Even in the 0-49 age group, there were still more (but just one more!) C19 than flu deaths in the 2023-24 season. There were four times more C19 than flu deaths in 50-64-year-olds and seven times more in the 65+ group.

Done and dusted? I don't think so.
 
And every year since 2020, COVID-19 has killed considerably more people, also far more people under 65, than the flu - including 2023-24.
Or is San Diego an outlier in this respect?!

More interesting data:
In 2023-24, COVID-19 killed 34 0-64-year-olds in San Diego. That is far more 0-64-year-olds than was killed by the flu on average in the years 2007-08 to 2018-19.
See Figure 10. Influenza Deaths by Age and Season (County of San Diego, Influenza Watch)

This under 50 (or under 80 or under whatever) has turned into the favorite goalpost-moving tool for marting and The Atheist, and yet, when you take a closer look, it never really seems to work out to their advantage. Even in the 0-49 age group, there were still more (but just one more!) C19 than flu deaths in the 2023-24 season. There were four times more C19 than flu deaths in 50-64-year-olds and seven times more in the 65+ group.

Done and dusted? I don't think so.

Do you realize that diagnosed flu deaths have been very undercounted in the USA. Not nearly as much as Covid which is regularly tested in all hospitals/urgent care. That ended for Covid last month. And since 2022, most infection tests (case counts) were done at home and not counted. Even when Paxlovid was prescribed. And San Diego, while better than much of the country, is only 1% of the USA's population.

So let's look at the whole USA and compare the last, pre-pandemic flu season with the most recent, full year Covid numbers. In the 2019-20 flu season CDC estimates 25k flu deaths. The CDC also counted 31k covid deaths in 2023. Let's break that down by age.

Sure looks like Flu was worse in every age group under 65 and the 25k total the CDC estimates for Flu is pretty typical of Flu season in the USA.

0-17 Flu: 530, C19: 137
18-49 Flu: 2492, C19: 1444
50-64 Flu: 6200, C19: 4762

And, for those over 65 where Covid is now much more deadly.
65+ Flu:16278, C19:24950

Sources:
https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/2019-2020.html
https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid_weekly/index.htm
 
From Marting's first link to the flu season of 2019-20. (I think most people are aware that COVID-19 didn't make much of an impact until the end of that season, or, if it did, C19 cases might have been misinterpreted as influenza.)
Since then, complete information to estimate the burden of the 2019-2020 flu season has become available. Since testing for flu has increased over time, the adjustment for under-detection of flu was lower and the 2019-2020 burden estimates decreased.

In addition, the death estimates for the 2019-2020 season increased after incorporating information from this season. It is possible that the reason for the increase in the number of deaths is because more deaths were categorized as pneumonia and influenza deaths, despite removing time periods impacted by the emergence of COVID-19. Also, it is possible that the adjustment factors increased because testing for flu decreased during the 2019-2020 season especially as COVID-19 began to surge. Although we excluded data from April 2020 through the end of this season, it is possible that data during the first few months of 2020 could be affected by COVID-19 before it was recognized.

The 2019-2020 season estimates are now considered final. At this time, there are no plans to estimate the flu burden for the 2020-2021 season because there was very little flu activity across the United States.


Marting's bias is conspicuous when he stresses only one side of the equation: "diagnosed flu deaths have been very undercounted in the USA. Not nearly as much as Covid which is regularly tested in all hospitals/urgent care."
Why not quote what the site actually says? Why come up with this biassed summary?

2019-20 when C19 wasn't in the game until the end of the season and testing for it wasn't in place is probably the most idiotic year to use as a comparison of the death toll of the two diseases, flu and C19. The following seasons, when C19 was there from the beginning, show a very different picture: While COVID-19 was killing hundreds of thousands of people, both before and after the mRNA shots, "there was very little flu activity across the United States."
 
Rare cancers

Rare types of cancer are showing up in higher numbers since the Covid-19 pandemic. Doctors suspect that the virus itself may be contributing to the higher cancer rates, despite a solid connection not yet being established. The pandemic may have permanently altered the bodies of those infected, making them more susceptible to cancer. Those affected include people who were otherwise previously healthy.
(...)
What is more alarming is the prevalence of people suffering from more than one type of cancer. "Having multiple forms of cancer at the same time has also become more prevalent. Cancers typically start in one part of the body and spread," the Post said. "It's rare for discrete cancers to begin in different parts of the body during a short window."
Covid might be to blame for an uptick in rare cancers: The virus may be making us more susceptible to certain cancers (TheWeek, June 20, 2024)


Reminiscent of the early 1980s in this respect:
In the early days of the HIV epidemic, some of the first signs of the existence of the virus were incidences of these rare cancers, such as Kaposi sarcoma, in an increasing number of patients.
HIV/AIDS-related cancers (CancerCenter.com, June 2, 2023)


I wonder where C19 minimizers will place the blame this time. On the mRNA vaccines? Immunity debt? Dr. Fauci?

ETA:
A case story - which, of course, serves as illustration only and doesn't prove anything in and of itself:
Then there’s Bob and Bonnie Krall, a couple who in a 14-month stretch endured three types of cancer between them, despite neither having a family history or genetic predisposition.
Cancers typically start in one part of the body and spread. It’s rare for discrete cancers to begin in different parts of the body during a short window of time. Patel said the Kralls and the 78-year-old had coronavirus antibodies “through the roof” in their blood although he’s not sure how that relates to cancer, if at all.
‘Unusual’ cancers emerged after the pandemic. Doctors ask (!) if covid is to blame. (WaPo, June 6, 2024)
Besides, they're also old, so their lives and health don't matter in the minimizer playbook. :mad:
 
Last edited:
Reminiscent of the early 1980s in this respect:



I wonder where C19 minimizers will place the blame this time. On the mRNA vaccines? Immunity debt? Dr. Fauci?

ETA:
A case story - which, of course, serves as illustration only and doesn't prove anything in and of itself:

Besides, they're also old, so their lives and health don't matter in the minimizer playbook. :mad:

It is surprisingly common to find more than one type of cancer at a time. People now get very intensive investigation when they have a cancer diagnosis this often identifies one or more other early cancers.
 
Reminiscent of the early 1980s in this respect:



I wonder where C19 minimizers will place the blame this time. On the mRNA vaccines? Immunity debt? Dr. Fauci?

ETA:
A case story - which, of course, serves as illustration only and doesn't prove anything in and of itself:

Besides, they're also old, so their lives and health don't matter in the minimizer playbook. :mad:

The mutations causing cancer arise several years before cancers become clinically apparent. Cancers diagnosed now likely started before covid. An alternative explanation might be changes in immune surveillance by the body resulting from infection. The body does respond to cancer, and alterations in immune function can cause cancer to progress faster.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom