AE911 Truth plans their own model

egalicontrarian

Scholar
Joined
Nov 23, 2013
Messages
65
See here.

Under "New Research Initiatives":
• Conduct sophisticated computer modeling of World Trade Center Building 7 to demonstrate, first, the impossibility of the collapse initiation mechanism put forth by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and, second, that a controlled demolition more readily replicates the observed destruction.

• Research, write, and publish monthly technical briefs.

• Publish and market a book based on psychologist Frances Shure’s groundbreaking series, “Why Do Good People Become Silent—Or Worse—About 9/11?”​

I take it that this would contribute to attempting to satisfy a perennial demand of debunkers, that AE911 produce its own research?
 
As if this will actually happen... Probably a marketing ploy to suck in more cash.
 
• Publish and market a book based on psychologist Frances Shure’s groundbreaking series, “Why Do Good People Become Silent—Or Worse—About 9/11?”

Maybe I should publish and market a book called, "Why Do Professional* Conspiracy Theorists Continue To Spread Lies And Lunacy About 9/11?"


*FWIW, a quick Google search of Francis Shure uncovered no independent verification of his credentials-but many, many links to a plethora of 9/11 Truth websites citing him as an "expert." Figures.
 
Last edited:
Conduct sophisticated computer modeling of World Trade Center Building 7 to demonstrate, first, the impossibility of the collapse initiation mechanism put forth by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and, second, that a controlled demolition more readily replicates the observed destruction.

Creating a model to demonstrate what you already assume to be true is not scientific.
 
See here.

Under "New Research Initiatives":
• Conduct sophisticated computer modeling of World Trade Center Building 7 to demonstrate, first, the impossibility of the collapse initiation mechanism put forth by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and, second, that a controlled demolition more readily replicates the observed destruction.​

So abandoning a search for truth and focussing on proving their predetermined conclusion.

• Research, write, and publish monthly technical briefs.
Good idea. The application and consistency remains to be seen.


• Publish and market a book based on psychologist Frances Shure’s groundbreaking series, “Why Do Good People Become Silent—Or Worse—About 9/11?”
There's that predetermined conclusion once again.

I take it that this would contribute to attempting to satisfy a perennial demand of debunkers, that AE911 produce its own research?[/QUOTE]

Oh I think you are very correct in your assessment.
 
• Publish and market a book based on psychologist Frances Shure’s groundbreaking series, “Why Do Good People Become Silent—Or Worse—About 9/11?”

And, of course, its sequel, "Why Do Explosives Become Silent - Or Invisible - On 9/11?"

Yes, it would be a start for them to make at least a token effort at serious research, if they can find anything to research that isn't immediately refuted by indisputable evidence. The implication being, of course, that they haven't even reached the start line of a sensible discussion yet. However, I suspect they'll try to isolate some subset of the observations of the collapse and demonstrate that it's marginally better fitted by a controlled demolition than by the precise sequence identified by NIST, while ignoring both the overall body of observations that refute their hypothesis and the possibility that the collapse was indeed caused by fire and impact damage but that the NIST model was less than a perfect description of the collapse. In other words, more of the same.

Dave
 
Maybe I should publish and market a book called, "Why Do Professional* Conspiracy Theorists Continue To Spread Lies And Lunacy About 9/11?"


*FWIW, a quick Google search of Francis Shure uncovered no independent verification of his credentials-but many, many links to a plethora of 9/11 Truth websites citing him as an "expert." Figures.

Tried it myself, again to no avail.
 
See here.

Under "New Research Initiatives":
• Conduct sophisticated computer modeling of World Trade Center Building 7 to demonstrate, first, the impossibility of the collapse initiation mechanism put forth by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and, second, that a controlled demolition more readily replicates the observed destruction.

• Research, write, and publish monthly technical briefs.

• Publish and market a book based on psychologist Frances Shure’s groundbreaking series, “Why Do Good People Become Silent—Or Worse—About 9/11?”​

I take it that this would contribute to attempting to satisfy a perennial demand of debunkers, that AE911 produce its own research?

Given AE911's previous attempts at research,my expectations are extremely low.
 
http://www.grof-holotropic-breathwork.net/profile/FrancesThompsonShure
So, what is holotropic breathework?

http://www.grof-holotropic-breathwork.net/page/hb-faqsTE
.Holotropic Breathwork combines accelerated breathing with evocative music and close one-on-one
supervision in order to access insight and healing in non-ordinary states of consciousness.
Holotropic Breathwork is presented by facilitators certified by Grof Transpersonal Training.
With the eyes closed and lying on a mat, each person uses their own breathing – supported by the
music -- to enter a non-ordinary state of consciousness. Holotropic breathing is faster and deeper than usual; generally no other specific instructions are given before or during the session as to the rate, pattern, and nature of breathing. The experience is entirely internal and largely non-verbal,without interventions.

This looks like deep woo to me.
 
*FWIW, a quick Google search of Francis Shure uncovered no independent verification of his credentials-but many, many links to a plethora of 9/11 Truth websites citing him as an "expert." Figures.


Frances Shure is a woman, usually referred to as Fran Shure.

A recent interview in a woo-friendly paper:

http://washingtonparkprofile.com//index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=3195&Itemid=44


Dunno whether she's any relation to the Shure that posts here though...


Here's her 'Medical Professionals for 9/11 Truth' profile:

http://mp911truth.org/#FShure



She was one of the founders of Colorado 9-11 Visibility, but there seems to have been some kind of ideological split, and now she's involved with Colorado 911Truth.

It's all a bit 'Judean Peoples Front'.
 
Last edited:
I'm confused by remarks like "Creating a model to demonstrate what you already assume to be true is not scientific."

Is there some reason, in principle, why their stated goal could not be achieved? That goal is to "Conduct sophisticated computer modeling of World Trade Center Building 7 to demonstrate, first, the impossibility of the collapse initiation mechanism put forth by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and, second, that a controlled demolition more readily replicates the observed destruction." They are explicit about using computer modeling to demonstrate what they "already assume to be true." But is there any reason why a computer model couldn't do such a thing in this context?

As for Frances Sure, she seems to have an M.A. in something, probably counseling or psychology, and is a licensed counselor. But perhaps I should have made clear in the post I was just trying to draw attention to the computer modeling bit, not the other stuff, which I just included for context.
 
...
*FWIW, a quick Google search of Francis Shure uncovered no independent verification of his credentials-but many, many links to a plethora of 9/11 Truth websites citing him as an "expert." Figures.

Frances Shure is a lady ;)
 
...
Is there some reason, in principle, why their stated goal could not be achieved? That goal is to "Conduct sophisticated computer modeling of World Trade Center Building 7 to demonstrate, first, the impossibility of the collapse initiation mechanism put forth by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and, second, that a controlled demolition more readily replicates the observed destruction." They are explicit about using computer modeling to demonstrate what they "already assume to be true." But is there any reason why a computer model couldn't do such a thing in this context?
...

I had found this AE911T agenda several days ago - here. Due to some derailing attempts and mod action, responses got scattered - here and following posts.

I outlined in this post what I expect of the upcoming study. Allow me to copy&paste this, so it can be found in the new dedicated thread:

A collapse model/simulation that starts with the assupmtion "intentional demolition by explosives and/or incendiaries" would have to include as a published set of assumptions the specific demo charges - their locations, chemical and physical properties, sizes, timing. Equivalent to NIST's input of fuel loads and fire szenarios.

Now I believe / assume (can anyone confirm or refute this?) that NIST checked these assumed fire szenarios against observations - where were fires and smoke visible at what times? Analogously, I'd expect the AE sim to also check the other effects against available observational data - particularly sound level of explosives at locations of video cameras that caught the collapse.
NIST's models computed how heat from fires propagated in the steel, and the effects thereof. Analogously, I'd expect the AE models to compute the effects of explosive shockwaves or the heat propagation of incendiary devices to melt through steel, and how that effects the steel's performance over time.
In addition to all this I of course expect AE to model fire szenarios, match them against observation, and compute their effects on the steel - and on the demo devices.
​


Now you ask: "Is there some reason, in principle, why their stated goal could not be achieved?"
Yes, there is: They have no actual plans yet to do the study.
I had a short email exchange with Tony Szamboti about this on January 17th. I have no doubt that IF Gage assembles a team to do such a study, Tony would be asked to join, if not to lead.
The central bit of the talk:
[Oystein:] Has AE911T formally set up a project? Are you involved in the endeavour, and if so, in what capacity? Is there a dedicated project leader - who?
[Tony:] There is nothing specific that I know of at the moment, just talk.​
 
I tried to find where to buy “Why Do Good People Become Silent—Or Worse—About 9/11?” using Google and failed. As far as I can work out it is nothing but a blog. Nothing groundbreaking about it.
 
Thanks for the relevant and informative reply, Oystein. I don't follow this forum diligently enough to have come across those other posts, so thanks also for linking them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom