Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Meaning one agency? .

No! It is not ONE agency. You have consistently misrepresented this.

There have been at least TWO reports of the combined intelligence agencies.

Both reports saw nothing that confirms or refutes anything in any intelligence about the sick WIV workers.

Look, this is the first one [link]

Look what it says:

"This assessment responds to the President’s request that the Intelligence Community (IC) update its previous judgments
on the origins of COVID-19. "

Intelligence Community is not a single agency.

Look what they said:

The IC assesses that information indicating that
several WIV researchers reported symptoms
consistent with COVID-19 in autumn 2019 is not
diagnostic of the pandemic’s origins. Even if
confirmed, hospital admission alone would not be
diagnostic of COVID-19 infection.

If they knew Ben Hu had been sick with Covid, don't you think that would swing things a little?

And yet, after Shellenberger et al release those names, the SECOND report from the IC came out.

LOOK! Link


In March, the IC updated its analysis on core intelligence questions related to
COVID-19 origins, to include whether the first human infection with SARS-CoV-2—the virus
that causes COVID-19—was the result of natural exposure to an infected animal or a laboratoryassociated incident. Variations in IC analytic views on the origins of the COVID-19 pandemic
largely stem from differences in how agencies weigh intelligence reporting and scientific
publications and intelligence and scientific gaps. All agencies continue to assess that both a
natural and laboratory-associated origin remain plausible hypotheses to explain the first human
infection.

So they continue to say that both are plausible. But as you can see again, the Intelligence Community is NOT made up of a single entity.

But what do they say about the sick WIV workers...?

Several WIV researchers were ill in Fall 2019 with symptoms;
some of their symptoms were consistent with but not diagnostic of COVID-19. The IC continues
to assess that this information neither supports nor refutes either hypothesis of the pandemic’s
origins because the researchers’ symptoms could have been caused by a number of diseases and
some of the symptoms were not consistent with COVID-19.

AND...

We have no indications that any of these researchers were
hospitalized because of the symptoms consistent with COVID-19. One researcher may have been hospitalized in this timeframe for treatment of a non-respiratory medical condition.

AND....

While several WIV researchers fell mildly ill in Fall 2019, they
experienced a range of symptoms consistent with colds or allergies with accompanying
symptoms typically not associated with COVID-19, and some of them were confirmed to have
been sick with other illnesses unrelated to COVID-19. While some of these researchers had
historically conducted research into animal respiratory viruses, we are unable to confirm if any
of them handled live viruses in the work they performed prior to falling ill.

So what have we got?

Nothing! And this was supposed to be a big bombshell.
 
Because it's China, not the US. Speaking out is rarely done..

I'm not talking about people in China! Duh!

I am talking about whoever these anonymous US government sources are.

Isn't this supposed to be somewhat important?

So why are these morons issuing little packets of information like Q Drops to the kinds of journalists who will swallow anything from UFOs to the importance of the Hunter Biden laptop to RFK Jr talking points about bioweapons?

If these people in the US government have information about Ben Hu getting sick with Covid, then surely someone can get them to come to Congress and testify on oath? If not, why not?
 
Because the FBI and other intelligence agencies in the US have free access to everything that goes on in China. :rolleyes:.

Huh!? What does this even mean?

Either there is evidence that Ben Hu got sick with Covid or there is not.

I want to see the goddamn evidence.

You seem to be going down the path of believing the lack of evidence is itself evidence which makes literally no sense.

Why are we talking about Ben Hu getting Covi?

Why? Give me something!

Don't point to grants for coronaviruses, because that says NOTHNG about whether he got sick.

We are now in Trumpian territory. "people are saying Ben Hu got sick" is apparently evidence that Ben Hu got sick.

Is that what we have? If there is more then give me more.

Tell me the evidence!
Tell me who knows about the evidence!

Put them on the goddamm stand and make them hold up their hands and swear on the Bible! There is no reason and no excuse for these people to be engaging in Chinese whispers if they have evidence.
 
No! It is not ONE agency. You have consistently misrepresented this.

There have been at least TWO reports of the combined intelligence agencies.
So two out of six?

Who is misrepresenting inconvenient facts? The FBI did not change their assessment did they? Just because the latest assessment differed?

This is not a relevant argument to be having. How many times do I need to point out the ill workers is one tiny bit in the evidence puzzle. You are fixated on it, IMO, because you don't have consistent arguments supporting the spillover.

Several references were in recent citations that Worobey did not have a true representation of the earliest cases. Start there. Show us he did.

And I'm not finding Kumar supported Worobey's work, I didn't look carefully at it a few weeks ago but now that I'm looking at the genetic evidence I can't see where Kumar suggests the market was the initial crossover source.

And it looks like the A lineage preceded the B lineage (as I noted earlier) as opposed to the 2 being evidence of 2 separate spillovers.

There is a lot of evidence that doesn't support a market spillover. There is still evidence supporting the fact it was a super-spreader site as was believed from the beginning.

There's a lot more productive evidence for you to work on rather than being fixated on who, if any, staff were sick in Nov 2019 as the State Department cable said.
 
Last edited:
Huh!? What does this even mean?
It means China is not an open society.

"Put them on the stand"? In which country do expect this to occur? :boggled:

If you want evidence keep pressuring the WHO to pressure Shi to release the raw data on all those COVID antibody tests she did on her staff.
 
I'm not talking about people in China! Duh!

I am talking about whoever these anonymous US government sources are.

Isn't this supposed to be somewhat important?
That cannot be done because freedom of the press protects reporters from revealing anonymous sources.

Your UFO analogy has been addressed a few posts back.
 
So two out of six?
Who is misrepresenting inconvenient facts? The FBI did not change their assessment did they? Just because the latest assessment differed?

This is not a relevant argument to be having. How many times do I need to point out the ill workers is one tiny bit in the evidence puzzle. You are fixated on it, IMO, because you don't have consistent arguments supporting the spillover.

Several references were in recent citations that Worobey did not have a true representation of the earliest cases. Start there. Show us he did.

And I'm not finding Kumar supported Worobey's work, I didn't look carefully at it a few weeks ago but now that I'm looking at the genetic evidence I can't see where Kumar suggests the market was the initial crossover source.

And it looks like the A lineage preceded the B lineage (as I noted earlier) as opposed to the 2 being evidence of 2 separate spillovers.

There is a lot of evidence that doesn't support a market spillover. There is still evidence supporting the fact it was a super-spreader site as was believed from the beginning.

There's a lot more productive evidence for you to work on rather than being fixated on who, if any, staff were sick in Nov 2019 as the State Department cable said.

What???

We are discussing a piece of evidence, yes. I am not fixated on it. I am explaining why I don't find it compelling.

And no, not TWO out of SIX. This makes no sense. The two reports come from the Intelligence Community.

Are you even reading my posts?
 
It means China is not an open society.

"Put them on the stand"? In which country do expect this to occur? :boggled:

If you want evidence keep pressuring the WHO to pressure Shi to release the raw data on all those COVID antibody tests she did on her staff.

Again, are you reading my posts? I am not talking about putting China on the stand.

I can't help but think you are being deliberately obtuse.
 
That cannot be done because freedom of the press protects reporters from revealing anonymous sources.

Cannot be done!?! Or the people with the information are refusing to go public. Instead they are going semi-public. Whispering it to Shellenberger.

I'm not talking about forcing the press to out their sources.

Jeeez! I'm saying that if the people with this information had any integrity, it seems to me to be their solemn duty to inform the world.

What could their reason possibly be for not wanting to expose the lab leak?

What's holding them back?

Your UFO analogy has been addressed a few posts back.

This is one of your favourite constructions.

"It's been addressed" in the passive voice as if it settles the matter.

It's called lampshading. When a movie has a plot hole, you just mention "oh sure, the UFO thing looks weird, but it's different mmmkay!?"

It's not different. It speaks to the reliability of the source.
 
Come on Soba, move on.

Addressed: Yes, cherrypicking out Shellenberger as unreliable doesn't impeach the cable the US embassy staff in China sent back in 2020.

In addition it is only minimally relevant.

Please support your assertion this one bit of evidence (the 3 ill WIV workers and/or their identities) is somehow crucial to the origin debate.

I'm not seeing it.
 
Come on Soba, move on.

Addressed: Yes, cherrypicking out Shellenberger as unreliable doesn't impeach the cable the US embassy staff in China sent back in 2020.

In addition it is only minimally relevant.

Please support your assertion this one bit of evidence (the 3 ill WIV workers and/or their identities) is somehow crucial to the origin debate.

I'm not seeing it.

The “cable” is your invention. I called you on this before and you backtracked. Now you bring back this “cable” even though it is merely your invention.

Now, what is the evidence for Ben Hu being sick with Covid? You want to claim it as fact but cannot substantiate it so you tell me to move on.

I’ll move on when you find evidence for this cable.
 
The “cable” is your invention. I called you on this before and you backtracked. Now you bring back this “cable” even though it is merely your invention.

Now, what is the evidence for Ben Hu being sick with Covid? You want to claim it as fact but cannot substantiate it so you tell me to move on.

I’ll move on when you find evidence for this cable.
You don't recall the cable where we first heard the report of 3 WIV workers being hospitalized in Nov 2019? Or you just haven't seen the actual report? :boggled:

Did you bother with a basic Google search? Here, let me Google that for you.

From the first hit:
This reporting adds a new level of detail to the information put out in a Department of State fact sheet last year, which said the United States had confirmed that researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology had fallen ill.

So from there try a search for the "Fact Sheet" because the cable was in 2020, not 2021. There is at least one cite of it in the thread, maybe a couple IIRC.

I have not claimed anything about said workers as a 'fact'. Could you please quote where I said that so I can see what you misread or what I wasn't clear on?
 
Last edited:
You don't recall the cable where we first heard the report of 3 WIV workers being hospitalized in Nov 2019? Or you just haven't seen the actual report? :boggled:

Did you bother with a basic Google search? Here, let me Google that for you.

From the first hit:

So from there try a search for the "Fact Sheet" because the cable was in 2020, not 2021. There is at least one cite of it in the thread, maybe a couple IIRC.

I have not claimed anything about said workers as a 'fact'. Could you please quote where I said that so I can see what you misread or what I wasn't clear on?

Literally nothing about a “cable” which is a figment of your imagination.

Just reference to that “Fact sheet” put out by Pompeo and the Wall Street Journal article by Michael “WMD in Iraq” Gordon. And again it relies on those anonymous sources.

Indeed we have gone over this. There is a cycle. You periodically reassert the claims about the sick workers and claim that it is now “corroborated” and go down the rabbit hole of assuming the more recent details are true. Then I push back and say the evidence is very unreliable and from unreliable sources. You’ll say it is from a “cable”. I’ll say where’s the cable? You’ll throw some links at me and avoid admitting there is a cable and anyway who was even talking about these sick co-workers, not me SG, I never claimed anything….

Rinse and repeat.
 
Gawd all these sidetracks. :rolleyes: Back to the current issue, just what do the grant applications and progress reports say about the research the WIV was doing on SARS-r CoVs before the pandemic.
I'm going to post the descriptions of what work was planned under the grant. No, the fcs is not mentioned specifically but there are relative references to manipulating RBDs. People can decide for themselves.

From the 2014 initial grant application: Understanding the Risk of Bat Coronavirus Emergence

Here's the whole abstract, I highlighted the most relevant parts.
Abstract Text
DESCRIPTION (provided by applicant): This project will examine the risk of future coronavirus (CoV) emergence from wildlife using in-depth field investigations across the human-wildlife interface in China, molecular characterization of novel CoVs and host receptor binding domain genes, mathematical models of transmission and evolution, and in vitro and in vivo laboratory studies of host range. Zoonotic CoVs are a significant threat to global health, as demonstrated with the emergence of pandemic severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus (SARS-CoV) in China in 2002, and the recent and ongoing emergence of Middle East Respiratory Syndrome (MERS-CoV). Bats appear to be the natural reservoir of these viruses, and hundreds of novel bat-CoVs have been discovered in the last two decades. Bats, and other wildlife species, are hunted, traded, butchered and consumed across Asia, creating a large scale human-wildlife interface, and high risk of future emergence of novel CoVs. This project aims to understand what factors increase the risk of the next CoV emerging in people by studying CoV diversity in a critical zoonotic reservoir (bats), at sites of high risk for emergence (wildlife markets) in an emerging disease hotspot (China). The three specific aims of this project are to: 1. Assess CoV spillover potential at high risk human-wildlife interfaces in China. This will include quantifying he nature and frequency of contact people have with bats and other wildlife; serological and molecular screening of people working in wet markets and highly exposed to wildlife; screening wild-caught and market sampled bats from 30+ species for CoVs using molecular assays; and genomic characterization and isolation of novel CoVs. 2. Develop predictive models of bat CoV emergence risk and host range. A combined modeling approach will include phylogenetic analyses of host receptors and novel CoV genes (including functional receptor binding domains); a fused ecological and evolutionary model to predict host-range and viral sharing; and mathematical matrix models to examine evolutionary and transmission dynamics. 3. Test predictions of CoV inter-species transmission. Predictive models of host range (i.e. emergence potential) will be tested experimentally using reverse genetics, pseudovirus and receptor binding assays, and virus infection experiments across a range of cell cultures from different species and humanized mice.

So tested experimentally, not just using computer models. Claiming they were not working with live viral cultures was a blatant lie.
And by the same token there were multiple reports the WIV collected hundreds of SARS-r CoVs which doesn't match the number of those genomes in their database. To turn around and say there was no evidence of a precursor virus is not credible. To say the Chinese, Shi and Daszak have not disclosed all the genomes which might include that precursor virus is credible.

Moving on to the 2018-2019 grant progress report the planned work with CoV RBDs is spelled out in more detail. It's long but I thought people should see the whole thing. I split it up into quote blocks because it otherwise was one big wall of text.

Page 33: B.1 WHAT ARE THE MAJOR GOALS OF THE PROJEC
.... The wildlife reservoirs of SARS-CoV were identified by our group as bat species, and since then hundreds of novel bat-CoVs have been discovered (including >260 by our group). These, and other wildlife species, are hunted, traded, butchered and consumed across Asia, creating a large scale human-wildlife interface, and high risk of future emergence of novel CoVs.
So more than 260 identified by their group. Are all these genomes now in the data bank?


To understand the risk of zoonotic CoV emergence, we propose to examine 1) the transmission dynamics of bat-CoVs across the human-wildlife interface, and 2) how this process is affected by CoV evolutionary potential, and how it might force CoV evolution. We will assess the nature and frequency of contact among animals and people in two critical human-animal interfaces: live animal markets in China and people who are highly exposed to bats in rural China. In the markets we hypothesize that viral emergence may be accelerated by heightened mixing of host species leading to viral evolution, and high potential for contact with humans. In this study, we propose three specific aims and will screen free ranging and captive bats in China for known and novel coronaviruses; screen people who have high occupational exposure to bats and other wildlife; and examine the genetics and receptor binding properties of novel bat-CoVs we have already identified and those we will discover. We will then use ecological and evolutionary analyses and predictive mathematical models to examine the risk of future bat-CoV spillover to humans.
No one has said Daszak and Shi were not well intentioned.


This work will follow 3 specific aims: Specific Aim 1: Assessment of CoV spillover potential at high risk human-wildlife interfaces. We will examine if: 1) wildlife markets in China provide enhanced capacity for bat-CoVs to infect other hosts, either via evolutionary adaptation or recombination; 2) the import of animals from throughout Southeast Asia introduces a higher genetic diversity of mammalian CoVs in market systems compared to within intact ecosystems of China and Southeast Asia; We will interview people about the nature and frequency of contact with bats and other wildlife; collect blood samples from people highly exposed to wildlife; and collect a full range of clinical samples from bats and other mammals in the wild and in wet markets; and screen these for CoVs using serological and molecular assays.
No one has denied the wet markets were significant for multiple reasons.


Specific Aim 2: Receptor evolution, host range and predictive modeling of bat-CoV emergence risk. We propose two competing hypotheses: 1) CoV host-range in bats and other mammals is limited by the phylogenetic relatedness of bats and evolutionary conservation of CoV receptors; 2) CoV host-range is limited by geographic and ecological opportunity for contact between species so that the wildlife trade disrupts the ‘natural’ co-phylogeny, facilitates spillover and promotes viral evolution. We will develop CoV phylogenies from sequence data collected previously by our group, and in the proposed study, as well as from Genbank. We will examine co-evolutionary congruence of bat-CoVs and their hosts using both functional (receptor) and neutral genes. We will predict host-range in unsampled species using a generalizable model of host and viral ecological and phylogenetic traits to explain patterns of viral sharing between species. We will test for positive selection in market vs. wild-sampled viruses, and use data to parameterize mathematical models that predict CoV evolutionary and transmission dynamics. We will then examine scenarios of how CoVs with different transmissibility would likely emerge in wildlife markets.
Compare how Daszak now describes the work compared to the initial grant proposal.


Then the work is described sans an extensive description of how they manipulated the RBDs.
Specific Aim 3: Testing predictions of CoV inter-species transmission. We will test our models of host range (i.e. emergence potential) experimentally using reverse genetics, pseudovirus and receptor binding assays, and virus infection experiments in cell culture and humanized mice. With bat-CoVs that we’ve isolated or sequenced, and using live virus or pseudovirus infection in cells of different origin or expressing different receptor molecules, we will assess potential for each isolated virus and those with receptor binding site sequence, to spill over. We will do this by sequencing the spike (or other receptor binding/fusion) protein genes from all our bat-CoVs, creating mutants to identify how significantly each would need to evolve to use ACE2, CD26/DPP4 (MERS-CoV receptor) or other potential CoV receptors. We will then use receptor-mutant pseudovirus binding assays, in vitro studies in bat, primate, human and other species’ cell lines, and with humanized mice where particularly interesting viruses are identified phylogenetically, or isolated. These tests will provide public health-relevant data, and also iteratively improve our predictive model to better target bat species and CoVs during our field studies to obtain bat-CoV strains of the greatest interest for understanding the mechanisms of cross-species transmission


Daszak admits they were manipulating SARS-r CoV RBDs and testing them in vivo in different cell lines and in humanized mice. And all of the potential precursor SARS CoV 2 genomes have not been disclosed.
 
Literally nothing about a “cable” which is a figment of your imagination.

Just reference to that “Fact sheet” put out by Pompeo and the Wall Street Journal article by Michael “WMD in Iraq” Gordon. And again it relies on those anonymous sources.

Indeed we have gone over this. There is a cycle. You periodically reassert the claims about the sick workers and claim that it is now “corroborated” and go down the rabbit hole of assuming the more recent details are true. Then I push back and say the evidence is very unreliable and from unreliable sources. You’ll say it is from a “cable”. I’ll say where’s the cable? You’ll throw some links at me and avoid admitting there is a cable and anyway who was even talking about these sick co-workers, not me SG, I never claimed anything….

Rinse and repeat.
You need to stop this nonsense and look up how embassy staff communicate using cables and what it entails. It's politics 101.

It's a WAPo link but I had access to it.

State Department cables warned of safety issues at Wuhan lab studying bat coronaviruses
Two years before the novel coronavirus pandemic upended the world, U.S. Embassy officials visited a Chinese research facility in the city of Wuhan several times and sent two official warnings back to Washington about inadequate safety at the lab, which was conducting risky studies on coronaviruses from bats. The cables have fueled discussions inside the U.S. government about whether this or another Wuhan lab was the source of the virus — even though conclusive proof has yet to emerge. ...

... What the U.S. officials learned during their visits concerned them so much that they dispatched two diplomatic cables categorized as Sensitive But Unclassified back to Washington. The cables warned about safety and management weaknesses at the WIV lab and proposed more attention and help. The first cable, which I obtained, also warns that the lab’s work on bat coronaviruses and their potential human transmission represented a risk of a new SARS-like pandemic.

“During interactions with scientists at the WIV laboratory, they noted the new lab has a serious shortage of appropriately trained technicians and investigators needed to safely operate this high-containment laboratory,” states the Jan. 19, 2018, cable, which was drafted by two officials from the embassy’s environment, science and health sections who met with the WIV scientists.


Now put 2 and 2 together and don't have a hissy fit these 2 cables weren't the ones from 2020. Learn how to refine your search string. I already posted a cite for this, I'm not obligated to post it multiple times.
 
Last edited:
You need to stop this nonsense and look up how embassy staff communicate using cables and what it entails. It's politics 101.

It's a WAPo link but I had access to it.

State Department cables warned of safety issues at Wuhan lab studying bat coronaviruses



Now put 2 and 2 together and don't have a hissy fit these 2 cables weren't the ones from 2020. Learn how to refine your search string. I already posted a cite for this, I'm not obligated to post it multiple times.


No, it is your claim to prove, not mine to search.

You cannot find any evidence of these cables at all.

You have literally no idea how to support the claims and have taken to making up claims about "cables" because this is the second time I have called BS on this specific thing and you have NOTHING in response. Instead you think that I am at fault for being unable to find what you are unable to find.

But it is YOUR responsibility to substantiate your claims. Not mine. And you are unable to do it.

It's Hitch's razor: that which is asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.
 
I posted a cite about the cable re the three ill workers from the WIV in Nov 2019 earlier in the thread. Where do you think the original report came from?

[/end of silly debate]
 
Now put 2 and 2 together and don't have a hissy fit these 2 cables weren't the ones from 2020. Learn how to refine your search string. I already posted a cite for this, I'm not obligated to post it multiple times.


My searches of this thread turned up the quotations that appear below.

I posted a cite about the cable re the three ill workers from the WIV in Nov 2019 earlier in the thread. Where do you think the original report came from?

[/end of silly debate]


It is indeed silly to pretend a cable sent in 2018 constitutes evidence for something that allegedly occurred in 2019. But that's what Skeptic Ginger is still doing. The following quotations tell the story, with my highlighting.

The information on those sick workers from the WIV was in a cable sent from embassy staff in China to the US gov. I don't recall if some of the cable was redacted or the original not shown at all, only reported on.

Could you give me the source of this? Or a link to the actual cable?

The "cables" initially were in 2018 warning the US government of the lax safety controls and dangerous research at the WIV. I have a mixed memory but every bit of this was discussed earlier in the thread.

....snip....

Later an intelligence report said there was evidence of the ill workers in Nov 2019 at the WIV.

Huh? The cable about sick WIV workers in Novermber 2019, was released in 2018?

This makes literally no sense.

When you get around to actually reading my post, let me know. :(

I read it. I asked where the information came from.

You said "a cable"



Where is this cable?

Are you now moving away from your claim it was in a cable, but not admitting it?

Where is this cable that you said the information about the sick workers came from?

SG: Wind, are you there?

Wind: Yes, SG.

SG: Can you get back to me tomorrow after you rest or sober up or whatever it is you do when you are in one of these states? Your posts fluctuate between being rational and being bonkers, a definite pattern. I prefer a discussion with the rational you.

I still don't understand where the claim of sick WIV workers came from.

You said a cable.

Okay, where is the cable?

Then you talked about a 2018 cable.

Do you not think this is confusing?

It could be that I am missing something, but I honestly have no idea what it is.

It could be that someone other than you is missing something, with no idea what it is.

I'll try again tomorrow if you can't figure it out from actually reading my posts. :rolleyes:

I asked where the information about sick WIV workers came from and was told it came from a cable.

When pressed, SG started talking about a cable from 2018. This cannot be the cable that the info about sick WIV workers came from.

When pointed out, SG then says I don't seem to be rational or sober. So apparently my very mental health is being questioned because I cannot make any sense of SG's claims.

This is absolutely gaslighing.

You don't read what I post and now you resort to insulting me? Was my post #235 really that difficult to understand? :rolleyes:


Skeptic Ginger's post #235 was the one in which she cited a 2018 cable as evidence for something that allegedly happened in 2019.

I agree that it is not at all difficult to understand that Skeptic Ginger's use of that 2018 cable as evidence for something she believes to have occurred in 2019 was nonsense, and that her insistence that a search of this thread would support her account is gaslighting.
 
Last edited:
My searches of this thread turned up the quotations that appear below.




It is indeed silly to pretend a cable sent in 2018 constitutes evidence for something that allegedly occurred in 2019. But that's what Skeptic Ginger is still doing. The following quotations tell the story, with my highlighting.



Skeptic Ginger's post #235 was the one in which she cited a 2018 cable as evidence for something that allegedly happened in 2019.

I agree that it is not at all difficult to understand that Skeptic Ginger's use of that 2018 cable as evidence for something she believes to have occurred in 2019 was nonsense, and that her insistence that a search of this thread would support her account is gaslighting.

W.D. Clinger I really appreciate you going back and doing this as I was not looking forward to having to do it myself.

In particular, it is nice to have a sanity check when another poster is calling mine into question.

It might not seem important whether or not the claim of sick WIV workers came from a cable either from the US Embassy or, later, The State Department.

Skeptic Ginger said:
History of the evidence:
First it was reported in a cable from the US Embassy that 3 people from the WIV got sick and were hospitalized in Nov 2019

There's a lot more productive evidence for you to work on rather than being fixated on who, if any, staff were sick in Nov 2019 as the State Department cable said.

But the important thing is if someone is going to claim evidence I want to know where it comes from.

Instead of answering the question directly, I am sent all round the houses with links to various news sources, none of which mention a cable, or passive-aggressively am given a "Let Me Google That For You" link, or that I need to learn to use Google or how to refine my Google searches, or get told I am drunk, or somehow mentally incompetent or that the citations have already been given, or that I am now "fixated" and won't change the subject.

This is a thoroughly obnoxious way of arguing:

1.) Make a claim
2.) Send people to sources that don't back up the claim, yet swear that they do.
3.) Say the evidence has already been given
4.) Claim the person who persists in pointing out that the evidence has not been provided that they are "fixated".

All this effort in the service of refusing to admit that a claim was false.

This is all it woulf take, and yet instead SG wants to claim that I am the one with some kind of problem.

Anyway, W.D. Clinger, once again thank you for reassuring me that I am not insane.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom