(Merged Thread) Facts and fictions in acupuncture

yrreg

Master Poster
Joined
Nov 24, 2005
Messages
2,420
We want to find the facts and locate the fictions in acupuncture.

Facts are independent of man's mind, fictions are in the mind of man and enacted outside.

Why bother to find the facts and the fictions in acupuncture? Perhaps in the process we will realize for a categorical certainty that it is all fictions, or realize that it is both facts and fictions, as in almost everything in man's endeavors.

If we should find out that acupuncture is all fictions, then that is a very good step forward in the advancement of medical knowledge, saving time and trouble and labor to thousands who do take recourse in acupuncture, and give testimonies of their deliverance from bodily pain and discomfort and dysfunction, otherwise not susceptible to successful treatment and medication through conventional scientific medicine.

If on the other hand we should find out at least that there are facts beneficial at that, then we will absolutely also contribute to the advancement of medical knowledge for the relief of suffering -- which is the eternal concern of Buddhists: for Buddhists here, that is one great solution to your quest, so no need to spend time and patience and torture in meditation.

It is a win win exercise, the search for the facts and the fictions in acupuncture.

----------------

I have already a very rough approach to this study.

1. Get some current news reports of people who are so relieved to have their medical complaints finally answered successfully with acupuncture.

2. Divide their treatment history into three phases:

---- a. condition prior to acupuncture,
---- b. event of acupuncture treatment,
---- c. condition post acupuncture.​
3. Seek the factors whatever they be that might be in any way the intervening component in the treatment event that changes the condition prior to acupuncture to the beneficent condition post.​
In step 3 we want to imagine everything imaginable of however negligible connection to the complaint and however unimaginable causality with the healing of the patient.

What are all these possible components, conditions, circumstances, incidental details during the treatment period, that might have an efficacious link in any manner and degree with the successful outcome of the treatment?

Things like for example the weather, or even the body odor of the acupuncturist. Yes, laugh, but we are not going to forgo any of the categories of being in the investigation.

So, first task is to gather some successful accounts of acupuncture treatment done specially by certified practicing MD's who also go into acupuncture as a complementary skill.


Please stay posted, and remember we will change the approach as we proceed when modifications of perspectives and strategies are dictated for the sake of making the exercise more promising and easier and quicker, and of course more easy to apprehend on the part of non-partisan observers.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Butai.
putai26eo.gif
 
I have already a very rough approach to this study.
1. Get some current news reports of people who are so relieved to have their medical complaints finally answered successfully with acupuncture.​
Right there you have a badly designed experiment before you start. A self-selected group of "successful" patients, after the fact, with no control group.

Better to look at some studies already done. Such as this one. Or this one.
 
Yrreg, do you have any idea of what an experiment is? It's a prospective, controlled test, not a retrospective uncontrolled one. First, we need to know if acupuncture works, before we try to work out why. The jury is pretty much still out on the former.
 
Right there you have a badly designed experiment before you start. A self-selected group of "successful" patients, after the fact, with no control group.

Better to look at some studies already done. Such as this one. Or this one.
You may as well not bother, I (and many other posters) have already tried to get through to yrreg how poor his experimental design is. Apparently my arguments where invalid because I was "too emotional" and my post was not in the correct format.
see here ( http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=51856 )
Yrreg is immune to any evidence which does not meet his exacting standards, one of which seems to be that it confirms what he already believes.
 
Not one hit, all these millennia of acupuncture practice?

I said at the start that I would look up news accounts of successful acupuncture treatments. But no, no longer will I continue to pour over the news accounts of successful acupuncture treatments, because they are too many to cover all of them, and almost everyday brings new ones, and I am one guy in a hurry.

So we will instead adopt this wholesale approach, namely, the question:

Is one at least one successful acupuncture treatment fact, or all are fictions?​

Why just ask for only one successful acupuncture treatment? Because the adversaries of acupuncture insist with all certainty that in all these millennia of acupuncture practice, there has not been accomplished on genuine truly medically authentic successful cure.

Consider these categorical universal pronouncements from the adversaries of acupuncture:

Research during the past 20 years has not demonstrated that acupuncture is effective against any disease. -- NCAHF
http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/acu.html

Research during the past twenty years has failed to demonstrate that acupuncture is effective against any disease. -- NCAHF
http://www.ncahf.org/pp/acu.html

Science doesn't have to explain the effects of acupuncture, because so far the acupuncturists cannot show an effect. -- Brodski
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1448143&postcount=57

There is zero evidence that acupuncture successful in treating any medical conditions. All evidence supporting acupuncture is for symptoms, more specifically only subjective symptoms. There is zero evidence for acupuncture being successful with objective symptoms. -- 3logic
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1448295&postcount=61
​

Well, what do you guys say here, who are adamant with complete and absolute certainty that acupuncture has not produced in all the millennia of its practice one successful medical cure, that can hurtle all the criteria of a successful treatment as demanded by today's conventional scientific medicine?


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude
putai26eo.gif
 
Since you seem to be of the opinion that we all possess only the fiction of acupuncture, Yrreg, why don't you provide us with the facts?

What is acupunture? What does it do? Why does it work?

I have a feeling that when you provide us with answers to these questions, we'll have to rewrite all the biology books.
 
I said at the start that I would look up news accounts of successful acupuncture treatments. But no, no longer will I continue to pour over the news accounts of successful acupuncture treatments, because they are too many to cover all of them, and almost everyday brings new ones, and I am one guy in a hurry.
The problem with anecdotal accounts of "successful treatments" is that there is no way of knowing whether the treatment or some other factor was responsible for the "success". The mere fact that someone gets better after a treatment does not mean that the treatment caused the recovery. An anecdotal report of someone recovering after receiving treatment tells us nothing about whether the treatment is effective. We need to know how many other people have been treated and what proportion of them got better; we also need to know what proportion of people suffering from the same condition get better without receiving the treatment. To do this you need to conduct properly controlled trials.

So we will instead adopt this wholesale approach, namely, the question:

Is one at least one successful acupuncture treatment fact, or all are fictions?​

Why just ask for only one successful acupuncture treatment? Because the adversaries of acupuncture insist with all certainty that in all these millennia of acupuncture practice, there has not been accomplished on genuine truly medically authentic successful cure.
It is impossible to establish that a treatment like acupuncture works from an individual case. To establish whether or not a treatment has been successful, you need to eliminate other causes for recovery. You need to be prepared to put in the work, and carry out properly controlled trials (blinded to eliminate the placebo effect). This is the only approach that will eliminate the possibility of other causes for recovery. Unfortunately, being "one guy in a hurry" does not suit you to this sort of methodical approach.
 
Unfortunately, being "one guy in a hurry" does not suit you to this sort of methodical approach.

Fortunately for our "guy in a hurry", acupuncture has already been tested against placebo, several times, so he doesn't have to waste his precious time looking for anecdotal evidence to shore up his preconceived notions of efficacy. unfortunately for our "guy in a hurry" the results indicate that acupuncture is no more effective than any other placebo response arising from a "complex intervention".
That and the fact that these studies probably don't meet Yrregs exacting grammatical, formating and geographical requirements.
 
...the results indicate that acupuncture is no more effective than any other placebo response...
I think you'll find that constitutes an emotional response.

I am still waiting for an answer to my question to Yreg - What is it about emotional responses that worry him, what does he feel is wrong with robust debate?

People on this list presumably feel strongly about alternative medicine, why cannot Y.reg debate on this level. If confrontation makes Y.reg so unhappy all he needs to do is go to a more pro-acupuncture list. If Y.reg really cares about the points on debate he should start answering some questions. I would rather listen to mild sarcasm and the occasional passionate outburst than to veiled insults.

Yuri
 
If Y.reg really cares about the points on debate he should start answering some questions.

I've debated Yrreg ever since he first came to the JREF forums, mostly in the Religion & Philosophy subforum on Buddhism.

For some reason, he also dragged me into this subforum to an acupuncture thread (See here and and here).

I just wanted to say that there's one thing you have to get used to right away, Yrreg never answers questions and he never provides sources for his claims.

ETA : The funny thing is, in his critique on Buddhism, he demands scientific evidence that it works, but with acupuncture anecdotal evidence and confirmation biased research is enough.
 
Last edited:
Well, what do you guys say here, who are adamant with complete and absolute certainty that acupuncture has not produced in all the millennia of its practice one successful medical cure, that can hurtle all the criteria of a successful treatment as demanded by today's conventional scientific medicine?

Well, why don't you just prove that acupuncture has some medical benefits and win a million dollars?

This thread got stupid quick; now I can't read it anymore.
 
We want to find the facts and locate the fictions in acupuncture.

Claim:
Jane the consumer has meridians/points and stimulating/unblocking these
can result in "good Ch'i/Qi flow" and improve her softball game.

Fact: This requires volume, mass, and bioactivity, and would be observable
by western doctors; even assuming that wasn't the case, it would have been
discovered and would be part of medical literature today.


Claim: Some people can cultivate Ch'i/Qi/Serpent Power/Kundalini and
demonstrate it.

Fact: Certain practitioners of esoteric schools develop a degree of
psychosomatic control over their body through years of physical
discipline, primarily heart rate and body temperature. This causes
a person to factor in additional things into their physical health
when training. If you can make parts of your body hotter than
others, it explains why some vitalists refer to it as a type of
energy. In these cases it is medically valid, but extremely rare,
but you would likely have to travel to Tibet, India, or the
mountains of China to find someone you could use acupuncture on.
 
There is emotion and emotion.

I think you'll find that constitutes an emotional response.

I am still waiting for an answer to my question to Yrreg - What is it about emotional responses that worry him, what does he feel is wrong with robust debate?

People on this list presumably feel strongly about alternative medicine, why cannot Y.reg debate on this level. If confrontation makes Y.reg so unhappy all he needs to do is go to a more pro-acupuncture list. If Y.reg really cares about the points on debate he should start answering some questions. I would rather listen to mild sarcasm and the occasional passionate outburst than to veiled insults.

Yuri

Emotional responses of the kind in which people are called stupid and to be engaged in stupidity, are inhibitive to productive discussion, because they cloud the creative faculty of the mind to arrive at solutions to questions which solutions could be workable even though not in accordance with scientific doctrines of today -- in which case we have to broaden into new directions our concept and practice of science.

Consider war, it is not a rational answer to the conflict among men, but an emotional one. That's why we have to avoid emotionalism in our discourse here, if we want to be productively useful to each other instead of slaughtering each other.

However, there is emotion and emotion. The emotion that drives people to find the programming that exists or might exist or should exist in everything, that is one emotion that should always dwell in the hearts of men, who are given to the quest for knowledge wherever the quest leads them.

People on this list presumably feel strony about alternative medicine, why cannot Y.reg debate on this level. If confrontation makes Y.reg so unhappy all he needs to do is go to a more pro-acupuncture list. If Y.reg really cares about the points on debate he should start answering some questions. I would rather listen to mild sarcasm and the occasional passionate outburst than to veiled insults. -- Yuri​

That is where and why people here are wrong, and I am right to be here, because I am a super skeptic with a demanding scientific critical attitude, i.e., open to all directions except fanaticism and bigotry.

Here is a saying from my favorite student of human behavior, Pes Oir Amsus:

Be not like unto frogs which chant in unison.
​

This is a rhetorical question: Has anything radically new ever been found by dwelling on the present doctrines of science and confining one's mind to them as to exclude all other avenues of thought imaginable and unimaginable?

Yrreg said:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=1448085#post1448085
CE 16th February 2006, 05:14 AM post 55

I am modesty aside a super skeptic: where everyone is in the bandwagon, like taking up Buddhism or bashing acupuncture, then I will take the opposite tack.


About answering questions, I am always in a hurry, so I have to choose what questions to answer in order to benefit all parties here, of whatever persuasion or sympathy, specially visitors who seek to read something of help to themselves, and not be bored with endless nitpicking that totally forgets the big picture which can be set forth in the short statement.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude
putai26eo.gif
 
Please answer this question, else please just read, don't post.

( . . . )

Is one at least one successful acupuncture treatment fact, or all are fictions?​

Why just ask for only one successful acupuncture treatment? Because the adversaries of acupuncture insist with all certainty that in all these millennia of acupuncture practice, there has not been accomplished one genuine truly medically authentic successful cure.

Consider these categorical universal pronouncements from the adversaries of acupuncture:

Research during the past 20 years has not demonstrated that acupuncture is effective against any disease. -- NCAHF
http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/acu.html

Research during the past twenty years has failed to demonstrate that acupuncture is effective against any disease. -- NCAHF
http://www.ncahf.org/pp/acu.html

Science doesn't have to explain the effects of acupuncture, because so far the acupuncturists cannot show an effect. -- Brodski
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1448143&postcount=57

There is zero evidence that acupuncture successful in treating any medical conditions. All evidence supporting acupuncture is for symptoms, more specifically only subjective symptoms. There is zero evidence for acupuncture being successful with objective symptoms. -- 3logic
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1448295&postcount=61
​

[More categorical universal statements to the same end can be found and presented here, but the above are enough.]

---------------

Well, what do you guys say here, who are adamant with complete and absolute certainty that acupuncture has not produced in all the millennia of its practice one successful medical cure, that can hurdle all the criteria of a successful treatment as demanded by today's conventional scientific medicine?

Well, what do you guys say here, who are adamant with complete and absolute certainty that acupuncture has not produced in all the millennia of its practice one successful medical cure, that can hurdle all the criteria of a successful treatment as demanded by today's conventional scientific medicine?​

Just please answer that question or participate by reading but don't post -- unless and until you want to answer that question.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude
putai26eo.gif
 
Consider war, it is not a rational answer to the conflict among men, but an emotional one. That's why we have to avoid emotionalism in our discourse here, if we want to be productively useful to each other instead of slaughtering each other.
You can kill people by email?.. Cool

Here is a saying from my favorite student of human behavior, Pes Oir Amsus:

Be not like unto frogs which chant in unison.
​

This is a rhetorical question
Just as well you said, I didn't think it was even an ordinary question.


Has anything radically new ever been found by dwelling on the present doctrines of science and confining one's mind to them as to exclude all other avenues of thought imaginable and unimaginable?

Where do you want me to start? Oops, sorry, more questions...

About answering questions, I am always in a hurry, so I have to choose what questions to answer in order to benefit all parties here?


...bored with endless nitpicking...

Who could possibly be bored with such a thing?

Yuri
 
I am still waiting for someone with something positive to contribute.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1453461&postcount=15

Please answer this question, else please just read, don't post
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Originally Posted by yrreg :

( . . . )

Is one at least one successful acupuncture treatment fact, or all are fictions?​

Why just ask for only one successful acupuncture treatment? Because the adversaries of acupuncture insist with all certainty that in all these millennia of acupuncture practice, there has not been accomplished one genuine truly medically authentic successful cure.

Consider these categorical universal pronouncements from the adversaries of acupuncture:

Research during the past 20 years has not demonstrated that acupuncture is effective against any disease. -- NCAHF
http://www.quackwatch.org/01Quackery...opics/acu.html

Research during the past twenty years has failed to demonstrate that acupuncture is effective against any disease. -- NCAHF
http://www.ncahf.org/pp/acu.html

Science doesn't have to explain the effects of acupuncture, because so far the acupuncturists cannot show an effect. -- Brodski
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php...3&postcount=57

There is zero evidence that acupuncture successful in treating any medical conditions. All evidence supporting acupuncture is for symptoms, more specifically only subjective symptoms. There is zero evidence for acupuncture being successful with objective symptoms. -- 3logic
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php...5&postcount=61

[More categorical universal statements to the same end can be found and presented here, but the above are enough.]

---------------

Well, what do you guys say here, who are adamant with complete and absolute certainty that acupuncture has not produced in all the millennia of its practice one successful medical cure, that can hurdle all the criteria of a successful treatment as demanded by today's conventional scientific medicine?


Well, what do you guys say here, who are adamant with complete and absolute certainty that acupuncture has not produced in all the millennia of its practice one successful medical cure, that can hurdle all the criteria of a successful treatment as demanded by today's conventional scientific medicine?



Just please answer that question or participate by reading but don't post -- unless and until you want to answer that question.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.

putai26eo.gif
 
Well, what do you guys say here, who are adamant with complete and absolute certainty that acupuncture has not produced in all the millennia of its practice one successful medical cure, that can hurdle all the criteria of a successful treatment as demanded by today's conventional scientific medicine?



Just please answer that question or participate by reading but don't post -- unless and until you want to answer that question.
I have already explained what I say to this, but presumably you didn't understand. I'll reiterate: an anecdotal report of someone recovering after receiving treatment does not tell us that the treatment is effective. It just tells us that they got better (or that someone thought they did) after receiving the treatment.

It is not possible to demonstrate that a treatment works for a single case. Other factors need to be eliminated. The fact that someone got better after receiving a treatment does not prove that the treatment caused the improvement. We need to know how many other people have been treated and what proportion of them got better; we also need to know what proportion of people suffering from the same condition get better without receiving the treatment. Quite apart from anything else, it is possible for a patient's condition to improve spontaneously without intervention.

To demonstrate that a treatment actually works, you need to carry out a controlled trial. You take two groups of patients, but only give the treatment to one group. The only difference between the two groups is that one has been given the treatment and the other hasn't, so if there is a difference between the outcomes for the groups, you can be reasonably certain that the difference was caused by the treatment, as long as you have designed your trial properly. Of course you also need to randomise and double blind the study to eliminate the placebo effect and observer bias.
 
Possible demonstration or possible effectivity

I have already explained what I say to this, but presumably you didn't understand. I'll reiterate: an anecdotal report of someone recovering after receiving treatment does not tell us that the treatment is effective. It just tells us that they got better (or that someone thought they did) after receiving the treatment.

It is not possible to demonstrate that a treatment works for a single case. Other factors need to be eliminated. The fact that someone got better after receiving a treatment does not prove that the treatment caused the improvement. We need to know how many other people have been treated and what proportion of them got better; we also need to know what proportion of people suffering from the same condition get better without receiving the treatment. Quite apart from anything else, it is possible for a patient's condition to improve spontaneously without intervention.

To demonstrate that a treatment actually works, you need to carry out a controlled trial. You take two groups of patients, but only give the treatment to one group. The only difference between the two groups is that one has been given the treatment and the other hasn't, so if there is a difference between the outcomes for the groups, you can be reasonably certain that the difference was caused by the treatment, as long as you have designed your trial properly. Of course you also need to randomise and double blind the study to eliminate the placebo effect and observer bias.

So, according to you in your own words:

Mojo said:
It is not possible to demonstrate that a treatment [acupuncture ] works for a single case [cure].

Or you really wanted to state that:

It is not possible (...) that a treatment [acupuncture] works for a single case [cure]. [Removing the phrase "to demonstrate"]

Please be more specific.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude
putai26eo.gif
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom