We want to find the facts and locate the fictions in acupuncture.
Facts are independent of man's mind, fictions are in the mind of man and enacted outside.
Why bother to find the facts and the fictions in acupuncture? Perhaps in the process we will realize for a categorical certainty that it is all fictions, or realize that it is both facts and fictions, as in almost everything in man's endeavors.
If we should find out that acupuncture is all fictions, then that is a very good step forward in the advancement of medical knowledge, saving time and trouble and labor to thousands who do take recourse in acupuncture, and give testimonies of their deliverance from bodily pain and discomfort and dysfunction, otherwise not susceptible to successful treatment and medication through conventional scientific medicine.
If on the other hand we should find out at least that there are facts beneficial at that, then we will absolutely also contribute to the advancement of medical knowledge for the relief of suffering -- which is the eternal concern of Buddhists: for Buddhists here, that is one great solution to your quest, so no need to spend time and patience and torture in meditation.
It is a win win exercise, the search for the facts and the fictions in acupuncture.
----------------
I have already a very rough approach to this study.
What are all these possible components, conditions, circumstances, incidental details during the treatment period, that might have an efficacious link in any manner and degree with the successful outcome of the treatment?
Things like for example the weather, or even the body odor of the acupuncturist. Yes, laugh, but we are not going to forgo any of the categories of being in the investigation.
So, first task is to gather some successful accounts of acupuncture treatment done specially by certified practicing MD's who also go into acupuncture as a complementary skill.
Please stay posted, and remember we will change the approach as we proceed when modifications of perspectives and strategies are dictated for the sake of making the exercise more promising and easier and quicker, and of course more easy to apprehend on the part of non-partisan observers.
Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha
---------------
From Nirvana with love, Butai.
Facts are independent of man's mind, fictions are in the mind of man and enacted outside.
Why bother to find the facts and the fictions in acupuncture? Perhaps in the process we will realize for a categorical certainty that it is all fictions, or realize that it is both facts and fictions, as in almost everything in man's endeavors.
If we should find out that acupuncture is all fictions, then that is a very good step forward in the advancement of medical knowledge, saving time and trouble and labor to thousands who do take recourse in acupuncture, and give testimonies of their deliverance from bodily pain and discomfort and dysfunction, otherwise not susceptible to successful treatment and medication through conventional scientific medicine.
If on the other hand we should find out at least that there are facts beneficial at that, then we will absolutely also contribute to the advancement of medical knowledge for the relief of suffering -- which is the eternal concern of Buddhists: for Buddhists here, that is one great solution to your quest, so no need to spend time and patience and torture in meditation.
It is a win win exercise, the search for the facts and the fictions in acupuncture.
----------------
I have already a very rough approach to this study.
1. Get some current news reports of people who are so relieved to have their medical complaints finally answered successfully with acupuncture.
2. Divide their treatment history into three phases:
In step 3 we want to imagine everything imaginable of however negligible connection to the complaint and however unimaginable causality with the healing of the patient.2. Divide their treatment history into three phases:
---- a. condition prior to acupuncture,
---- b. event of acupuncture treatment,
---- c. condition post acupuncture.
3. Seek the factors whatever they be that might be in any way the intervening component in the treatment event that changes the condition prior to acupuncture to the beneficent condition post.---- b. event of acupuncture treatment,
---- c. condition post acupuncture.
What are all these possible components, conditions, circumstances, incidental details during the treatment period, that might have an efficacious link in any manner and degree with the successful outcome of the treatment?
Things like for example the weather, or even the body odor of the acupuncturist. Yes, laugh, but we are not going to forgo any of the categories of being in the investigation.
So, first task is to gather some successful accounts of acupuncture treatment done specially by certified practicing MD's who also go into acupuncture as a complementary skill.
Please stay posted, and remember we will change the approach as we proceed when modifications of perspectives and strategies are dictated for the sake of making the exercise more promising and easier and quicker, and of course more easy to apprehend on the part of non-partisan observers.
Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha
---------------
From Nirvana with love, Butai.