Merged Too Much NoC Evidence?

Caustic Logic

Illuminator
Joined
Apr 24, 2007
Messages
4,494
Exhibit A - The Account of Robert Turcios

First, I am not trying to excuse any of CIT's behaviors or conclusions, and I'm not necessarily making a case for "Pentagon-sponsored disinfo."

But...

I've found myself at odds with other members here over my belief that there is more to their north-path-flyover insanity than the Team itself. I feel a need to explain why I hold these suspicions and haven't abandoned them.

In general, Back in late 2006-early 2007, there was a suspiciously sudden rush of semi-corroborating north-=path evidence, mostly gathered from "human intel" sources in Arlington - the Citgo manager's supposedly removed north-pointing camera, her swearing an employee saw a plane north of the station, the same employee's multiple verification, and the videotaped testimony of this employee and previous NoC witness [via Eastman] Sgt Lagasse, along with the confirming Sgt Brooks, all bolstered and neatly visualized by an NTSB animation showing a NoC path by some unexplained error. There are also timeline clues hinting some sort of coordination in all this, but I'll get back to that.

And then there are additional NoC verifications since then, not as many as or as solid as CIT says, but too many and too consistent for me to call pure honest chance.

I'm not sure how to approach this in the detail it's worth, so I'll start with one point, and a challenge.

Robert Turcios, the Citgo employee. Watch his testimony in The PentaCon, Smoking Crack Gun version [19:00 –30:00]. Is it really so clear that he’s being honest here?

He offers the CIT and their flyover hunger the only pull-up account in the world. He affirms this without hesitation, twice [22:57-23:50, 26:00], and quite clearly. It pitched upward to avoid the sign truss thing, hundreds of feet from the building. He’s not even entirely sure (or strangely vague on) if it impacted because his view was “obstructed still” by nothing I can see [24:00]. And of course it came from the north side of the station when he had been at the south (and yet saw no markings, consistent with a view from below rather than to the side). [22:25]

All this could only be visible at the spot he led to CIT to during the interview, the crest of the mound he ran up to after hearing the plane. The Citgo security video of course all but proves he was under the south canopy the whole time, his view blocked by the mound ahead, and then running inside the store as the impact fireball lights up the area. Simply put, he was not on the mound and couldn’t have actually seen any of the stuff he says. (unless the video is altered of course).

A bad sign: The witness’ behavior is dodgy and unsettled. He fidgets, hands in pockets, the sunglasses of course. In places he’s clearly trying to keep a straight face. Did anyone else catch him starting to bust up at 22:50, right before mentioning the pull-up?

If he’s not lying, that means he honestly believes all the tripe he’s spewing, and must have been thinking of a joke when he nearly laughed. He was presumably present, but in this case must be completely forgetting what he actually saw and did. Was Turcios “led” to these false memories by dishonest researchers? Was his memory just really odd, by sheer accident manufacturing stuff that kinda corroborates the NoC claim while also hinting with unprecedented clarity at the implications (flyover) CIT wanted?

Aside from simple, honest memory error, complete mental manipulation by CIT’s leading questions and the help of Hypno-Toad it seems, there are few options open to explain all this pouring out of this one guy. Mainly, he’s either willfully fabricating this story for their camera, for whatever reason, or his story is correct. This says nothing to intent, but certainly opens the question of it.

It should be clear which way I lean on this issue. I’ll let this one get some discussion going before moving on the other exhibits.
 
Eye-witness accounts are pretty unreliable; he could just be completely mistaken.
 
Eye-witness accounts are pretty unreliable; he could just be completely mistaken.

Thx for the comment. Just to clarify, in light of the points I've included:

He would have seen the plane just south of and nearly over him. He was almost certainly under the canopy until impact (with his view of this "obstructed still"), and then runs inside the store. The video shows this.

He could have just been completely mistaken and remembered himself running up to the mound, seeing it pass off to his right over the north canopy, pull-up before impact without showing any stripes, and having an "obstructed" view of the deduced impact?

I'll have to agree, he could be just mistaken. The real world and all its surrounding parallel universes are composed of "coulds." He "could" have been totally correct and the flyover happened.

And I'll also agree this isn't the best comparison, since memory is far more malleable than the laws of physics.

Beyond that we're disagreeing. I know he's not a "twoofer," but there's something wrong with Robert.
 
Just one possibility here...

If you're standing at the citgo station and looking at the impact point of the pentagon, you'd be looking northeast. The impact point itself is further north than the citgo station, which sits at an angle anyways (the front of the main building faces northeast). I think it's entirely possible that people seeing the impact from near the station may not have seen the plane as it passed the citgo, but they saw the impact, or at least the impact's aftermath, and noting the location of that impact, they very likely could have assumed that the plane was flying a due east heading prior to impact, which would place it passing north of the Citgo station. It's not surprising that his brian would try to "fill in the gaps" of such a traumatic event.....especially when the interviewer asks him leading questions.

I don't think Turcios is lying about what he saw....lying implies that he is deliberatly falsifying his statements. I think he has some fuzzy memories about that day, seemed a little nervous, and his English skills suggested a possible language barrier as well.
 
Mainly, he’s either willfully fabricating this story for their camera, for whatever reason, or his story is correct.
This sentence seems to best summarize your post, but it's pretty obviously a false dichotomy, wouldn't you agree? What about the much more likely explanation that he spent a lot of time on the morning of 9/11/2001 running around the Citgo station, standing on the mound, etc., and six years later had them all jumbled together in his memory?
 
Adam, I know your intentions are honorable, but are you suggesting it is possible to delve into the human mind and determine how or why it works the way it does? Analysis done by a bunch of amateurs? Heck, psychiatrists don't even know. All we can really say with any authority is that eye witness statements are notoriously unreliable. I suggest that will be the final answer no matter how many pages it takes. IMHO, it is a futile quest. There are simply too many unknowns.
 
Adam, I know your intentions are honorable, but are you suggesting it is possible to delve into the human mind and determine how or why it works the way it does? Analysis done by a bunch of amateurs? Heck, psychiatrists don't even know. All we can really say with any authority is that eye witness statements are notoriously unreliable. I suggest that will be the final answer no matter how many pages it takes. IMHO, it is a futile quest. There are simply too many unknowns.

Thanks for the comment Reheat. This does indeed all fall in the realm of mental unknowns, and nothing scientific or quantifiable can be ascertained. However, I am indeed suggesting it is possible to delve into the human mind and TRY TO determine how or why it works the way it does. We all do this when we speculate on the motives and issues of whack-jobs we're debunking.

I have seen some studies and anecdotal evidence about way out memory errors. They do happen, and probably no memory from anyone is clear of some distortion. Witness statements are unreliable, but do usually approximate reality. People usually don't hallucinate entirely different scenarios from reality, as Turcios is thought by some to have.

I'd also like to add that I don't care if anyone here agrees with my suspicions or not. I just wanted to explain them and start an open discussion. Mission accomplished so far.
 
Just one possibility here...

If you're standing at the citgo station and looking at the impact point of the pentagon, you'd be looking northeast. The impact point itself is further north than the citgo station, which sits at an angle anyways (the front of the main building faces northeast). I think it's entirely possible that people seeing the impact from near the station may not have seen the plane as it passed the citgo, but they saw the impact, or at least the impact's aftermath, and noting the location of that impact, they very likely could have assumed that the plane was flying a due east heading prior to impact, which would place it passing north of the Citgo station.

Constructive points, thanks. I think there's a gap between the canopy and mound so he'd see it near over him and just left, but it is possible he didn't see the plane at all. Only then can his north deduction make sense, and then he's embellishing seeing it north and of course the pull up. If he saw it, it boils down to left or right. I have a hard time imagining his seeing it to his left and remembering it right, especially since this means a different vantage point to see it.

I guess "I have a hard time..." doesn't do much tho.

It's not surprising that his brian would try to "fill in the gaps" of such a traumatic event.....especially when the interviewer asks him leading questions.

I don't think Turcios is lying about what he saw....lying implies that he is deliberatly falsifying his statements. I think he has some fuzzy memories about that day, seemed a little nervous, and his English skills suggested a possible language barrier as well.

I doubt language is an issue - he has an accent is all. What else can "pull-up" mean? And that laughter right before he says it - that's the universal language, isn't it? As far as fuzzy, I've compared reality to his statements and that's a lot of fuzz to turn one into the other. Go ahead and review the video. This is not minor discrepancies territory, this is him saying CIT's flight path theory right to them and calling it his memory. If it's an honest mistake it's both neuro-psychologically bizarre and a remarkable coincidence.

Mainly, he’s either willfully fabricating this story for their camera, for whatever reason, or his story is correct.
This sentence seems to best summarize your post, but it's pretty obviously a false dichotomy, wouldn't you agree? What about the much more likely explanation that he spent a lot of time on the morning of 9/11/2001 running around the Citgo station, standing on the mound, etc., and six years later had them all jumbled together in his memory?

That would be a false dichotomy if I hadn't clearly preceded that sentence with
Aside from simple, honest memory error, complete mental manipulation by CIT’s leading questions and the help of Hypno-Toad it seems, there are few options open to explain all this pouring out of this one guy.
Honest natural error, honest led error, dishonest error, or correct. These are the options I listed and although there are others, this is all I felt worth mentioning. Yes, I poo-pooed the honest options a bit, because I feel it's justified and knew everyone else would plug for those plenty. It's the easiest solution after all, that keeps all focus on the dingbats we love to hate. So would you agree your false dichotomy charge was false? It's just how I framed it you didn't like.

I disagree that your explanation is "much more likely," although i'll concede it's quite reasonable and might just be true. I presume you've watched his testimony closely for gestures and clues, and pondered on this?

Alright, so things are going about as expected. Turcios is just in error is the general consensus. If that was all I had, I'd let it drop, but he's just one point on the list. I'm not ready to post on Lagasse yet, but anyone who knows what I'm likely to say can start explaining how he too was just a bit confused and was tricked the evil geniuses at CIT, and Dick Eastman too.
 
I seriously doubt a "conspiracy" between witnesses, the NTSB, and other parties to invent a NOC path. On the part of the witnesses, I think NOC is part of the natural variation in where witnesses placed the plane; we also have witnesses that placed the plane far SOC than the "official path". Did you see my post last week on the effect of trauma on perception in the event itself, and how it would then lead to inaccuracies of locating threatening objects in "revisualizations" and recollections? It may well account for the NOC placements of the plane by those in ANC. Turcios was almost directly in the plane's path, but not exactly, and it would not be unusual if the experience was very traumatizing to him in that moment. If he experienced any of the related phenomena (tunnel vision, loss of depth perception, etc.), he may well not be sure himself of where he was at the time, how far away the plane was, and where the plane was in relation to insignificant background objects. Or in the years since the attack, that initial uncertainty gave way to a new but inaccurate certainty on account of revisualizations of the event. Considering that he worked at the CITGO on a daily basis, he probably had many opportunities to revisualize what he saw and solidify what initially may have seemed more like a blur. The CIT boys were probably not the first people who asked him to show them what he saw. Their belief that people closest to the event are the most reliable is certainly not true. The incongruities with his placement of actual real-world objects and with possibly his own location (as evidenced by the CITGO video) would attest to the fallibility of memory.

ETA: Reheat is right of course, and there is no way anyone could know what was going through his mind at the time of the attack, and in the years since. The above is to point out that there are more possibilities than supposing that Turcios was being dishonest, which I doubt.
 
Last edited:
You always have witnesses who saw something and they are wrong. You don't have to ignore them, they may have some important information when you analyze their statement. I do not trust anything CIT puts out, they are the worse investigators in the world. You understand perception of an event varies. You are taking a fringe witness and a lunatic paranoid group CIT and giving it credence.

I have watched CIT enough to know they make up this junk, and it is funny cause it stems from the working copy of the NTSB animation. They have made up their fantasy based on a working copy where the Pentagon on the animation is not in the real position relative to 77 but has a NoC path depicted and they use this as their idea now. They are stupid when it comes to investigating 9/11. You can't use witness statement to form conclusions when the physical evidence refutes the conclusion you make from the witness statement.

Witness perception, an age old dilemma, innocent people have died when witness statements were WRONG. We have physical evidence and witness statements that are confirmed by the physical evidence on 9/11. So using a witness with obvious false perceptions, is stupid; don't throw out his statement, use it for what it is worth. You must weigh each witness and use physical evidence. You need zero witnesses to prove 77 hit the Pentagon, physical evidence proves this. Witness statement we are in the world of perception, and we all see things differently.

Physics, physical evidence, other witness statements make a NoC impossible. The only thing of interest for this witness who says NoC is the study of witness perception, what makes him think this was the case?
 
Caustic Logic said:
What else can "pull-up" mean?


My own interpretation is that he was describing a change in the attitude of the plane -- from a nose-down to a more level attitude. That would have reduced the steepness of the descent and if it occurred while the plane was passing Route 27, it may have given one the impression (viewing form behind the plane) that the plane was pulling up to avoid hitting short of the building, or to avoid hitting overhead signs on the street. Or maybe he was recalling a wing "pull up", also making it look like it was avoiding something on the street.

There were other witnesses who described some adjustment of the plane as (or just after) it crossed the street. Tom Hovis wrote that the aircraft "put the nose down coming over Fort Myer picking off trees and light poles" and then "leveled out at the last minute and put it square into the building." Albert Hemphill described the plane in a "sharp downward angle of attack" with the "left wing down" but "as he crossed Route 110 [sic] he appeared to level his wings, making a slight right wing slow adjustment as he impacted low on the Westside of the building". Terry Morin, who would not have been able to see the plane past Route 27, described seeing "the tail dip slightly to the right indicating a minor turn in that direction". William Lagasse made his own problematic reference to the plane yawing to the left. Penny Elgas who was on Route 27 described seeing the plane "banked in the slightest turn in front of me, toward the heliport", allowing her to see the underside of the left wing as it "rocked slightly toward the ground." Noel Sepulveda described seeing the plane "struck a light pole, causing it to fly at a 45-degree angle ... The plane tried to recover, but hit a second light pole and continued flying at an angle". Wanda Ramey said "I saw the wing of the plane clip a light post, and it made the plane slant. Then the engine revved up and crashed into the west side of the building." David Marra said that when the plane was 50 feet off the deck it "rolled left and then rolled right" and Afework Hagos said that the plane "was tilting its wings up and down like it was trying to balance" and "it hit some lampposts on the way in". The accounts all vary in the details and Turcios' own unique account would fit into this variation, but I think these are probably reports of some adjustment that the pilot made at around that time.

The references to the engines "revving up" or "powering up" may also suggest that such a sound contributed to an impression of the plane pulling up. Wanda Ramey described the engines revving up as or after the plane hit the light poles. Kat Gaines similarly saw "a low-flying jetliner strike the top of nearby telephone poles" and then heard "the plane power up and plunge into the Pentagon". Mark Bright said that he "heard the plane 'power-up' just before it struck the Pentagon". And Noel Sepulveda said that after the plane tried to recover after hitting lightpoles "you could hear the engines being revved up even higher".

Although he was talking about a point prior to when the plane crossed Route 27, Tim Timmerman makes an interesting reference to the plane "pulling up" on account of the sound of the engines. He said that "the pilot added power to the engines. I heard it pull up a little bit more and then I lost it behind a building". Interesting that the "pulling up" is something he describes hearing, and of course this was not a "pull up" for a flyover.
 
Constructive points, thanks. I think there's a gap between the canopy and mound so he'd see it near over him and just left, but it is possible he didn't see the plane at all. Only then can his north deduction make sense, and then he's embellishing seeing it north and of course the pull up. If he saw it, it boils down to left or right. I have a hard time imagining his seeing it to his left and remembering it right, especially since this means a different vantage point to see it.

I guess "I have a hard time..." doesn't do much tho.



I doubt language is an issue - he has an accent is all. What else can "pull-up" mean? And that laughter right before he says it - that's the universal language, isn't it? As far as fuzzy, I've compared reality to his statements and that's a lot of fuzz to turn one into the other. Go ahead and review the video. This is not minor discrepancies territory, this is him saying CIT's flight path theory right to them and calling it his memory. If it's an honest mistake it's both neuro-psychologically bizarre and a remarkable coincidence.



That would be a false dichotomy if I hadn't clearly preceded that sentence with

Honest natural error, honest led error, dishonest error, or correct. These are the options I listed and although there are others, this is all I felt worth mentioning. Yes, I poo-pooed the honest options a bit, because I feel it's justified and knew everyone else would plug for those plenty. It's the easiest solution after all, that keeps all focus on the dingbats we love to hate. So would you agree your false dichotomy charge was false? It's just how I framed it you didn't like.

I disagree that your explanation is "much more likely," although i'll concede it's quite reasonable and might just be true. I presume you've watched his testimony closely for gestures and clues, and pondered on this?

Alright, so things are going about as expected. Turcios is just in error is the general consensus. If that was all I had, I'd let it drop, but he's just one point on the list. I'm not ready to post on Lagasse yet, but anyone who knows what I'm likely to say can start explaining how he too was just a bit confused and was tricked the evil geniuses at CIT, and Dick Eastman too.

Are you trying to say you think the planes flew NOC?

Reality trumps memory and speculation every time.
 
Let's take a look at what the ANC witnesses said about the C-130 instead of what they said about the path of AA77 for just a moment.

They all stated that the C-130 flew from the NW or N and departed in the same direction. We know for a FACT it did not fly that path as conclusively proven by the Tribby video and Looney photographs. That is not speculation, not contrived logic, and certainly not a strawman (some of the favorite CIT accusations). Did the ANC people all hallucinate the same thing? Gee, their statements are "scientifically corroborated", so there can be no doubt that what they said is correct. Well, they were WRONG about the C-130 path whatever the reasons.

If this is not proof that the witnesses had perception problems due to trauma?, angle of view?, influence of interviewers?, false memory?, or simply outright lying about what they witnessed? From what is known at the current time, I don't think anyone can say with any degree of certainty WHY these witnesses said what they did. The only certainty is that they were WRONG!

If they have been proven wrong on the C-130 path would it not be reasonable to assume they were also wrong about the path AA77 flew?
 
Quickly on the above points - ain't I tenacious like a twoofer?

Mangoose's leveling as pull-up does make sense. The plane did level out at about Route 27, as widely corroborated by individually unreliable but collectively accurate witness testimony. and the revving part could support that.

Again, trauma can cause memories, theoretically, as strange as they come. A witness COULD recall the plane flying upside down away from the Pentagon and NoC. I haven't seen one this odd yet. Someone said it "cartwheeled" into the lawn.

ANC witnesses are a good example of people north or south of the flight path fudging it a bit further north or south from them, and this is to be expected (although if several of them who talked to CIT agree too close on the error, or a C-130 error I'd have to wonder - I haven't watched that video still). It's a whole different error for those ON the dividing line. The simple right or left nature of his claim is the sticking point for me - a totally different side of his body AND the station... yeah, possible, so it must be so?

Tsig: No, the NoC option is the one I listed for logical fullness and I put no stock in. So that's it for Turcios for now. I have less time this week and may or may not post on Lagasse tonight.
 
Precisely. As I said the other day, the witnesses to the C-130 demonstrate that people have erred in placing the position of this plane and its direction.

Consider again the variation in witness accounts of how the plane hit the building. Some said it looked like it the plane hit the helicopter pad or bounced off it. Others said it looked like it it cartwheeled into the building. Others said it flew straight in like a dart without hitting the ground. Some had better views than others and some were certainly misled by their own angle of view, objects that obstructed their view, etc. while others had a clear shot of what happened. NO ONE SAW ANYTHING like the fantasy that CIT promotes of a plane overshooting the Pentagon and happily flying away. Even though they may disagree widely in the details (and that is normal and to be expected), all these accounts agree that the plane did crash into the building.
 
What else can "pull-up" mean?
Most witnesses talk about the planes movements, they all gave me the impressions of erratic movement. As you look at the FDR, you find Hani was going from 0.306 G to 1.673 G in 3 seconds at one point, and he kept doing a PIO in the last 20 seconds of data. That is a pull-up of sorts. In the last 15 seconds of recorded information there were 3 major "pull ups".

The plane was going down, over all, at rates as high as 6000 f/s.
 
Quickly on the above points - ain't I tenacious like a twoofer?

Mangoose's leveling as pull-up does make sense. The plane did level out at about Route 27, as widely corroborated by individually unreliable but collectively accurate witness testimony. and the revving part could support that.

Again, trauma can cause memories, theoretically, as strange as they come. A witness COULD recall the plane flying upside down away from the Pentagon and NoC. I haven't seen one this odd yet. Someone said it "cartwheeled" into the lawn.

ANC witnesses are a good example of people north or south of the flight path fudging it a bit further north or south from them, and this is to be expected (although if several of them who talked to CIT agree too close on the error, or a C-130 error I'd have to wonder - I haven't watched that video still). It's a whole different error for those ON the dividing line. The simple right or left nature of his claim is the sticking point for me - a totally different side of his body AND the station... yeah, possible, so it must be so?

Tsig: No, the NoC option is the one I listed for logical fullness and I put no stock in. So that's it for Turcios for now. I have less time this week and may or may not post on Lagasse tonight.

Well for logical fullness you could have added acts of the gods.

Or grumpy gnomes.
 
Just one possibility here...

If you're standing at the citgo station and looking at the impact point of the pentagon, you'd be looking northeast. The impact point itself is further north than the citgo station, which sits at an angle anyways (the front of the main building faces northeast). I think it's entirely possible that people seeing the impact from near the station may not have seen the plane as it passed the citgo, but they saw the impact, or at least the impact's aftermath, and noting the location of that impact, they very likely could have assumed that the plane was flying a due east heading prior to impact, which would place it passing north of the Citgo station. It's not surprising that his brian would try to "fill in the gaps" of such a traumatic event.....especially when the interviewer asks him leading questions.

I don't think Turcios is lying about what he saw....lying implies that he is deliberatly falsifying his statements. I think he has some fuzzy memories about that day, seemed a little nervous, and his English skills suggested a possible language barrier as well.

Agreed. This hit me a while back. The impact point was north. The more memory fades the more we tend to oversimplify things; north impact=north path.

Ever since all this 911 stuff came up and I started seeing how unreliable the witness testimony and memory of those events can be I have been examining the accuracy of my and my friends memory and I can tell you the accuracy is atrociously bad. This was a real revelation for me. I think it can take many years of life experience and a lot of refection and testing to grok this. (which could explain why the CIT team cannot believe their witnesses could be so wrong)
 
alexg said:
The impact point was north. The more memory fades the more we tend to oversimplify things; north impact=north path.


Good observation. And the Citgo video suggests that Turcios also misremembered his position as well as his actions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom