Religion's value questioned

Religion is so strongly tied to all kinds of denialism. I can't find value in such a thing.
 
Denialism?

There are many examples in this thread about how religion can be valuable. Here's another. Numerous warlike tribes have become peaceful after turning to Christianity. And after all, why wouldn't they? See What The Bible Says About Violence, Anger, Jealousy, Arguments, And Living In Peace With Each Other (it contains several quotations to do with instructions Christians are given.)

Here's an example of people giving up violence after turning to Christianity.

From a collection of reports on the deaths of a couple of missionaries in the late 1960s:

... The society is one of several mission groups working in the interior of West Irian among tribes just emerging from a stone-age culture. A phenomenal response to the message of the Gospel has been witnessed among some of those warring cannibal tribes.

Notably, in the Swart Valley alone, since 1960, some 8,000 of the Dani tribe have become Christians, weapons and fetishes have been discarded and literacy has become widespread.

I'm not suggesting Christianity's the only thing that could have turned them from violence, of course. The point is that if it can work, it's obviously useful.
 
It would help a lot if you did not repeatedly make the mistakes that you accuse me of making!

You're confusing legislation Per Se with the specific type of legislation being tried in some countries. Have a look at recent drug legislation in Portugal. It's rather different from US legislation.

No, I'm not confusing anything! What I'm saying is that prohibition against using, producing, selling or trafficking drugs, i.e. legislation, does not remove the need of the addicts. Same thing in the case of religion.

You simplify/distort both our positions, possibly accidentally. My position all along has been that things tend to be more complex than just "Religion made them do it". Naturally religious issues can be part of what motivates people to do evil things.

Well, in this case clarification implies simplification: The simplification of your absurd position serves to make the absurdity more obvious.
And would you please point out where you think that I say that "Religion made them (!) do it" - i.e. seemingly independent of their own will - as you seem to imply that I do!
By the way, are you now trying to say that "religious issues" can only be "part of" the motivation for acts of cruelty and never the motivation?

I'm sorry, but I am not really interested in your lecture on the Crusades. Find another thread for that one.

It goes more into the religious issues as well.

One thing, Dann, which is obviously not your fault, is that you seem to have difficulty in understanding figures of speech like irony, where people don't mean quite what they say.

Drop your condescending arrogance, thank you. And who the hell is to blame for my alleged misunderstandings if they're not my fault??!

Also it would help with that if you read the whole of a person's post before commenting. For instance, it appears that you opposed the argument you assume Whirligig to be making - that religion should be legislated away, which was actually posed as a question and not an argument at all, - only to discover in the next paragraph that Whirligig's saying something rather different - that religion shouldn't be legislated away. The question was obviously rhetorical.

No, not really. W.'s trick is to ask a question, which seems to imply that somebody in this thread might have had that opinion. Nobody did, however, so W. is obviously having a conversation with his own strawman. And you're welcome to it. My point is that religion not only shouldn’t but actually cannot be ”legislated away.”

You haven't actually explained as yet why you think it would be good for all religion to be eradicated, beyond saying it's a delusion. It seems a little strange that you haven't really explained further, given that the postulation that religion should be eradicated is the whole premise of your argument. You believe religion to simply be a delusion. You will not even allow for the possibility that God exists and that some religion is not a delusion, which makes your position reactionary and ideologue-like rather than skeptical - a true skeptic being one who critically examines evidence rather than just rejecting concepts they don't like without being able to give a good explanation as to why.

Oh, my! No, I don't "believe" that religion is a delusion. I know that it is. There is no God (in the real world outside of religious delusion), there is no Allah, there is no Santa Claus, there is no Easter Bunny. You, however, may consider it a progressive position to believe in the existence of any one or all of them.
However, if you actually think that you've got "evidence", feel free to deliver. There's still a million $$ waiting for you.

Even when I have demonstrated that turning to Christianity has so changed some people's lives that they have turned from violence, shoplifting and other harmful behaviours, you still stick to your position that it needs to be eradicated because it's a delusion, without giving any explanation of why you believe that its benefits shouldn't be taken into account, or at least none in a language most of us can understand. :) You haven't given any reason whatsoever for your outrage at Whirligig's suggestion that non-religious people should join religious organisations to influence people in positive ways. Your response was simply an outpouring of apparent horror with no reasoned argument behind it.

Its alleged benefits! I could come up with a lot of examples of people who have turned into insufferable, reactionary bores after they 'found' religion. Does that convince you of anything? No? Nor do your sob stories about people who became incredibly good after being 'saved' convince me of the alleged benevolence of religion. Just as medicine is not based on the claims of individuals that it helped them, an attempt at a rational research of religion cannot take individual statements about its alleged benefits as proof of anything.
That atheists or skeptics should join the organizations that canvass the very ideas that they are opposed to is to absurd to merit further comment, sorry!

Further, you are limiting your own arguing options by trying to close the debate down to basically one of a simple adversarial nature - basically a "did" "didn't" style of argument. For example, I linked to testimonies of people who gave up lifestyles of violence and other harmful ways when they became Christians. If you'd argued more imaginatively, you could have seen that as a coup d'etat for your position - "Ha! Those testimonies demonstrate that people turn to religion when they're dissatisfied with their lives in some way!" Instead, your argument was a simplistic reactionary one - "I don't want to read any more of those! You're spamming the thread with them!"

And now you've become so patronizing that you actually start giving me advice about how I ought to argue. Very interesting, except for the fact that I don't agree with your argument:
Your "testimonies" from good Christians who once were lost but now are found don't primarily show what some people do when they're "dissatisfied with their lives in some way". Some dissatisfied people do turn to religion and similar superstitions, some to drugs, some to drink, some resign and kill themselves, some find a hobby to invest their spare time in, others get a divorce or a new job. And some actually sit down and analyze what might cause the conditions that make them dissatisfied and some of those actually decide to do something about these causes.
That you are a fan of religious delusion does not make the boredom that your testimonials make me experience "reactionary".

I think it would be better if you reason your position through more and try to think more deeply about the opposition's points.

Yes, you certainly think so!

I'll answer a couple of points you made earlier that I didn't before. You wrote a long post in response to my question as to what you perceive as being wrong with the concept of moral living. I think I can summarise it by saying you believe morality is an abstract concept that can obstruct pragmatism, such as where Christians oppose handing out condoms to men in Africa because they don't want them to be promiscuous, when actually they're going to be promiscuous anyway and why jolly well shouldn't they be, and at least giving them condoms would reduce their chances of catching AIDS.

Yes, they will be promiscuous, Christian or not, but unlike you I would never say that ”they're going to be promiscuous anyway” since I don’t have anything against promiscuousness per se. If people want to have sex with many partners, I don’t see the harm – except in the sexually transmitted diseases and unwanted pregnancies.
You need only look at reality to find out that the Christian (etc.) ideal of abstinence as a way of fighting the spread of AIDS just doesn’t work for the simple reason that people want to have sex. So the preaching of abstinence doesn’t help ”reduce their chances of catching AIDS.” Condoms, however, do!

Actually that premise is not quite right, because the concept of morality is not always immutable, and where it is, it can actually inspire more efficacious policies.

Where ”it”, i.e. the concept of morality, I suppose?, is WHAT? Mutable?

For instance, researching with stem cells from embryos is considered by some to be immoral. But opponents can argue that it isn't immoral and in fact is more moral than not doing it, given that it's being done before the embryos develop enough to be fetuses that would actually feel pain, and the research is being done to benefit fully-developed humans who are in a lot of pain and/or suffering a lot because of disabilities, so isn't trying to eliminate their pain and suffering the most moral choice?

Yes, there’s room for an awful lot of English essays about ”Stem cells – a Blessing or a Curse?”.

It's also possible the controversy over morality can lead to research efforts being made on other types of stem cells which could actually prove very fruitful long-term. For instance, from the latest news items on 'Stem Cell Transplantation'

Yes, that’s possibly possible … and so what?

Some of these could possibly work better than embryonic stem cells in some situations, so scientists might be grateful for being pushed into exploring other avenues by the controversy. Certainly one benefit of taking stem cells from the person being treated, rather than using embryos from people unrelated to them, eliminates the risk of the cells being rejected by the body, though whether the ethical controversy had any impact on the avenues that scientists researching into the rejection issue explored, I don't know. They might have researched alternatives anyway. Still, some finds might not have been made.

Might not but would very likely.

Regarding AIDS in Africa, it's true that a dogmatically moral position that condoms shouldn't be handed out and education should consist entirely of abstinence-only teaching might have led to an increase in the prevalence of AIDS. That's especially if the same thing that's been happening in America has been happening there. From an article about research findings on abstinence-only education vs comprehensive sex education:

It not only shouldn’t ”entirely” consist of abstinence-only teachings. Abstinence-only teaching should not in any way be a part of sex ed.


But it could be argued that it isn't "moral" to refuse information about contraception to people who might not be swayed by abstinence-only education and so put themselves and others at risk.
Also, it may be that sex education without the moral aspect - the teaching on the benefits of abstinence - could be just as harmful as education without information on condoms.

No, that may not be, sorry.


However, your points actually seemed irrelevant to the discussion, since my points were about ordinary people living more moral lives - in other words, lives that benefited their communities rather than harmed them. They weren't about the consequences of the decisions of a few people in the higher echelons of authority. If I were to argue the AIDS/condoms issue you raised along the lines of the previous points I'd made, I'd say it may be that more morality among the populace of Africa would have prevented AIDS reaching epidemic proportions or even getting a foothold, although there are several causes, not all of them to do with immorality.

Yes, if people never had sex nobody would die of AIDS. That’s what the pope says, isn’t it? So the reason why AIDS reached epidemic proportions wasn’t that it is a sexually transmitted disease that people weren’t even aware of and therefore couldn’t protect themselves against. Now the reason is that lack of morality appears to spread HIV.
However, people do have sex, and Africans aren’t any different in this respect than other people.

Talking of morals, ... oh no this is a little different: the moral of a story. :)

Regarding that awful story in Judges 19 you quoted about the couple not stopping for the night in a foreign land but going on to their own native Israel - where the woman was abused all night and killed: I said the story had an anti-prejudice moral in it. You responded by reminding us one and all of what came next in the story - him doing what, in the absence of gory television pictures or even a media to speak of at all, was the next best way to rouse outrage among his countrymen - sending bits of her body to them and calling for them to make war on the tribe that had killed her. You commented that my "defence of the Bible" was becoming more "absurd". In other words, what you seemed to be saying was, "How could you possibly say anything good about such a story!" I'd like to point out that just because a story contains a moral, that doesn't mean that the entire story is moral. Surely you learned that from the Hans Kristian Andersen stories you probably read as a child. :)

I hate many of Hans Christian Andsersen’s stories, in particular The Ugly Duckling. He was a pompous jerk – and actually owned stock in the Danish slave trade.
And, I’m sorry, but I still don’t think that it is a good idea to kill a woman because she was raped and then send the ”bits of her body” to ”rouse outrage among his countrymen” because of the foreigners’ abuse of his private property. And it is incredibly cynical and absurd to use the ”absence of gory television pictures” as an excuse for his behaviour.
Christian apologetics make me sick.

That's a very good point. But as Whirligig suggested, if a destructive person wants to abuse someone, if one means is closed to them, they'll just find another. You can see that extremely clearly in the development of cyber-crime - when one type of software is developed to thwart it, the criminals move on to using new techniques. Why would the potential for abuse mean religion should be scrapped altogether?

You are the one who claims that it’s ”abuse” since you want to distinguish between good (= real Christianity) and bad[/b] Christianity (= not really Christianity but the abuse of Christianity).

People should certainly be warned about ways people abuse others' beliefs. That's very important.

No, people should be warned against beliefs. If they reject their delusional beliefs, these beliefs can’t be abused.

But religion in itself doesn't make a person vulnerable to abuse. Believing in God doesn't necessarily make you vulnerable to the scam of someone telling you God's telling him you need to give him your money, for instance.

Of course it does. Have you ever tried to make an atheist give you money with this argument?

Cliff Richard's a famous Christian. There's the story of how someone knocked on his door one day and told him God had told her he wanted her to become Cliff Richard's housekeeper. Cliff Richard said if that were true, he'd have heard about it himself, and in any case, other people had told him God wanted them to be his housekeeper. If they had all heard from God, what was he playing at? :D Religion doesn't have to disable the critical thinking faculties.

No, but it definitely helps. And who the hell is Cliff Richard trying to fool? How does he know that they hadn’t all hear from God? Who is he to question their belief? Doesn’t he know that God works in mysterious ways?

This gets us back to points similar to some I made earlier - religious figures themselves have campaigned vigorously against abuses perpetrated by other religious figures, for instance, Martin Luther making a bold stand against the Catholic Church's exploitation of the common people by urging them to spend money many could ill afford on a document said to get them or their loved ones out of purgatory faster. It isn't an "us and them" thing.

Yes, they all disagree, and so what? We already know that Martin Luther made a bold stand against the poor German peasants rebelling against exploitation, don’t we?! Or did you already forget that he
rejected the demands of the rebels and upheld the right of Germany's rulers to suppress the uprisings. . Luther based his attitude on the peasant rebellion on St. Paul's doctrine of Divine Right of Kings in his epistle to the Romans 13:1-7, which says that all authorities are appointed by God, and should not be resisted.

Now it’s up to you to tell us if this is an example of good[/] religion or abuse.
 
Please try to address opponents' positions rather more calmly. If it helps, try deliberately relaxing before reading what they say, and having a cooling-off period between the time you read what they've written and replying. It doesn't help your position to caricature that of your opponent, to unthinkingly condemn, and to simply respond with hostility rather than thoughtfully considering what your opponent is saying before reacting. It simply looks petulant, and you let yourself down by not being able to put forward as good a case as you could if you considered what they were saying more carefully. You're beginning to come across as one who can't bear to deal with opposition. The more you dislike what your opponent is saying, the more adviseable it is to consider what they're saying carefully, so you can systematically look for the flaws in it and put together the best case you can against it, rather than doing the equivalent of yelling, "I don't want to hear that", leaving your opponent's case intact, and suggesting to them that though you say you don't want to hear any more, you weren't actually listening very well. Case in point: Being more thoughtful in the way you approach what your opponent says would prevent you from making basic mistakes, like this one:

Dann said:
No, I'm not confusing anything! What I'm saying is that prohibition against using, producing, selling or trafficking drugs, i.e. legislation, does not remove the need of the addicts. Same thing in the case of religion.

No, legislation is not synonymous with prohibition. Since you didn't take a look at Portuguese legislation, as I suggested you did, I'll show you what I was hinting at:

From BBC News: How Portugal dealt with drug reform

... Under the 2001 law, consuming drugs is still illegal, but anyone caught with up to 10 daily doses - defined for each drug, by weight - for their own use is not arrested and cannot go to jail.

Instead they are taken to a police station, their details noted, and they are ordered to attend a hearing at one of 18 regional "dissuasion commissions".

Users caught with less than 10 daily doses of any drug are not arrested

The commission can send an offender for treatment if he or she is an addict, impose a fine, or let him or her off with a warning.

"Portugal's experiment is unique," said Mr Negrao.

"It decriminalises drug use, but leaves administrative penalties in place." ...

In its 2003 report, the EU's drug monitoring agency noted that member states are taking an increasingly pragmatic approach, adapting legislation to facilitate the treatment and rehabilitation of drug users and addicts - even as their security forces are given wider powers to crack down on trafficking.

Dann said:
By the way, are you now trying to say that "religious issues" can only be "part of" the motivation for acts of cruelty and never the motivation?

That's something on the lines of what I was saying, hence the illustration I used - that article on the Crusades, where the motives were mixed. It seems you don't understand what I put it there for, but I thought I'd made it clear.

Dann said:
And would you please point out where you think that I say that "Religion made them (!) do it" - i.e. seemingly independent of their own will - as you seem to imply that I do!


Another lack of recognition of idiom there, as well as a confusion of who is supposed to have done what to whom ... oh no sorry, I think I'm lapsing into schoolroom grammar lesson-speak.

My illustration of the way the Crusaders had mixed motives and weren't simply motivated by religious issues was a response to your comment,

However, again you make the same mistake that BN has been making all along: Crimes committed in the name of religion really aren't religious crimes. Religion is merely abused as a pretence, "in the name of", and the real reason seems to be the "destructive" nature of (some) people, as if, for example, homophobic hate crimes committed or the killing of abortionists by Christians had nothing at all to do with religion.

You seemed to be claiming we wanted to exhonerate religion from all evil. I felt compelled to point out that we only wanted to part-exhonerate it.

I did in fact make that clear at the time. Your failure to realise this seems to indicate that you rushed your response without really thinking your opponent's position through, another illustration of the reason it may be adviseable for you to deliberately calm down before responding.

Dann said:
Drop your condescending arrogance, thank you. And who the hell is to blame for my alleged misunderstandings if they're not my fault??!

Now it could be said that I'm beginning to be condescending. I haven't quite got to arrogance yet. Then, however, I was simply being explanatory. Misinterpreting people's motives must be the cause of quite a bit of the misery in the world. For instance, this self-help article on improving marriages has sections on how quite a bit of conflict in marriage can be caused by anger driven by assumptions about what the other's motives are. Please try to reserve judgment before coming to conclusions. You may be getting angry because of the motives you attribute to your opponents more than because of what they're actually saying. So if you could reserve judgment about their motives, it could be just what you need to keep calmer and to help you analyse what they're saying more so you're more able to find genuine flaws in it if any exist. Surely that's what you'd really like to do.

And whose "fault" do I think it is that you made mistakes, as I saw it? Why does it have to be anyone's fault? Why does blame have to feature at all? It could simply be something to do with less familiarity with the use of idiom in a second language.

Dann said:
However, if you actually think that you've got "evidence", feel free to deliver. There's still a million $$ waiting for you.

I think you'll find I posted a few links to articles about phenomena that various people consider "evidence" for God before. Thus had you been paying more attention, you would not be raising this issue now, but you might have already dispatched the arguments into oblivion with gusto, or modified your own militant position in the light of them and we would have moved on from there. Since you haven't, I'll post some of them again:

Evolution vs. Design: Is the Universe a Cosmic Accident or Does it Display Intelligent Design? (Evidence for God from Science)
Science and the Grand Designer.
Is there any Evidence for the Existence of God?

Here's more evidence I didn't link to before. It's more information about Jackie Pullinger, who I said worked in Hong Kong with gangsters, many of whom were drug addicts, many of whom came off drugs painlessly when they accepted Jesus and prayed in tongues, according to her. You claimed James Randi had debunked that claim, but what you linked to to prove it had nothing at all to do with her or drugs, but was simply a general article on various faith healers he'd debunked. He himself acknowledged that that didn't prove there weren't any genuine ones. And Jackie Pullinger certainly doesn't operate in the style of one of them. Anyone who wants to read more about her work with drug-addicted gangsters and ponder what was really going on, can do so here: Claims of Miraculous Cure From Heroin Addiction Through the Use of the Gift of Tongues.

Basically, what I am saying is that a good case can be made that those things are "evidence" for God. A person would need more than evidence to go for the million dollar challenge. What those articles are not, is absolute proof. And just as no one in the world has absolute proof that God exists, you have no absolute proof that he doesn't. And you would actually be making your position more credible if you were to acknowledge that.

Dann said:
Its alleged benefits! I could come up with a lot of examples of people who have turned into insufferable, reactionary bores after they 'found' religion. Does that convince you of anything? No? Nor do your sob stories about people who became incredibly good after being 'saved' convince me of the alleged benevolence of religion. Just as medicine is not based on the claims of individuals that it helped them, an attempt at a rational research of religion cannot take individual statements about its alleged benefits as proof of anything.

However, if large numbers of people reported that a medication was benefiting them in ways that hadn't been predicted, investigation would be made into why exactly that was, and scientific progress would be made. Similarly, rather than just rejecting religion wholesale because you don't happen to like its effects on some people, even though it has had tremendous benefits for others, is to take a simplistic approach that closes down avenues of exploration into exactly what it is that's benefiting them. Rather than either rejecting or accepting religion wholesale, a more insightful approach would be to investigate what elements of religion make people "bores" or evil, or adopt other negative traits, and what elements of religion can be tremendously good for people and their communities. Here's an example of how that approach can benefit people. From an article called Why faith in God really can relieve pain:

For centuries, religious believers have endured suffering with impressive fortitude.

Now scientists claim to have discovered that faith in God really can relieve pain.

New research at Oxford University has found that the Christian martyrs may well have been able to draw on their religion to reduce the agony of, for example, being burnt at the stake.

It goes on to describe an experiment that was done that found that Catholics experienced less pain in response to controlled electric shocks than atheists.

The next question would be: "Why is that happening?" and when it's been discovered exactly what's going on, the question can be asked, "What can atheists draw on to reduce their pain in the same way?" The article does in fact mention that.

There was a television documentary on a while ago that asked just such a question. It found that religious belief often did seem to help people with painful conditions. As part of their investigation into why, the documentary makers met with some rationalists in India who went around doing demonstrations where they inflicted pain on themselves to prove you didn't need religion to reduce the effects of pain on you. One documentary-maker did what they were doing to himself to see if he could tune the pain out or something. He discovered that when he took the attitude that he didn't mind the pain, it seemed to lessen, possibly because he wasn't tensing his muscles, which could have made it worse, but maybe for some other reason. The atheists doing the demonstration explained that religious figures in temples would make a great ceremony of the skill of being able to tune out pain to some extent, but none of that was necessary, as illustrated by the fact that they could do it.

So, discovering that religion can sometimes do a lot of good, the scientific thing to do would be to investigate as far as possible exactly what's going on when it does, and what and how much of that can be replicated in non-religious settings.

You know, the fact that you dismiss all the evidence I've provided that religion can turn people from violence and other crime as "sob stories" makes me wonder about your motivation for your Communist views and your professed belief that religion impedes the real happiness of the people. If you're really concerned about people's well-being and happiness, I'm puzzled as to how you can so glibly dismiss people's experiences of giving up lifestyles that were harming others and becoming happier as "sob stories". Doesn't less violence in the world mean something good's happening, by whatever means it happens? Why do you ridicule it and refuse to accept the validity of it if it happens the wrong way for you? You clearly must have a reason for your attitudes different from an increase in people's well-being. I'm curious about what it is.

Dann said:
That atheists or skeptics should join the organizations that canvass the very ideas that they are opposed to is to absurd to merit further comment, sorry!

So an atheist should never join an organisation like the Salvation Army or the St Vincent de Paul Society - Turning Concern into Action, which were the examples given - both of which organisations do a lot of charitable work, - atheists shouldn't join such organisations to do charitable work, but only organisations where they can be sure they agree with all the founding principles and policies?

Now, tell me: The bank where you have your money; do you agree with all its policies? Do you even know what it does with your savings? Did you specially choose a bank with policies you could wholeheartedly agree with? No? But atheists must never join charitable organisations if some of their policies conflict with their beliefs?

I find that an interesting position. Of course, an atheist who joined a religious organisation like those just mentioned wouldn't have to go to church every week and sit through lengthy boring sermons. Here's a scenario, which you perhaps think is too absurd to even contemplate, but which I think is rather good:

An atheist and a Christian sit side by side in an office. During their breaks, the Christian bugs the atheist by talking incessantly about how atheists and gays and people who have abortions had better watch it because they're in danger of hell fire! She seems to think it's mainly what Christianity's about. The atheist doesn't say they're an atheist, because they think that'll just make the Christian talk about it more and more. They're fed up with hearing about it. ... But one day, they hit on a cunning plan! :)

Mr Atheist has been contemplating doing some charity work. Mr Atheist suddenly thinks: "Hey, I could join the Salvation Army. I'll work with homeless people for a while. I'll see what it's like, and then I'll invite my work colleague along with me! If it was a non-Christian organisation I was inviting her to, she'd probably refuse. But if they do Christian things there, she can be persuaded that it's a way of furthering her beloved Christianity, and might become quite enthusiastic. She can be kept so busy there that she doesn't have time to scare customers off with her hell fire rants.

The plan works perfectly. Mr Atheist tells Christian work colleague what he's been doing at the Salvation army, says it's following the example Jesus gave, and describes a little Christian talk they gave. Christian work colleague becomes fired up with enthusiasm at this new way to further her walk with the Lord and her influence among the ungodly. So Christian work colleague goes with Mr Atheist to the Salvation Army drop-in centre for homeless people, and enjoys the work. She goes several more times.

It isn't long before Christian work colleague's focus has completely shifted, from spending her breaks at work proclaiming damnation on people to talking about how they're helping the customers. She becomes a much more pleasant person to be around, and has begun to do some genuine good in the world.

Now, please tell me what's "absurd" about that, should you still believe the idea to be absurd.

-------

Oh deary me. I've run out of time. I'll have to respond to the rest of your post tomorrow. :)

If you'd rather I didn't respond at all after that, there's one very easy way to ensure I won't:
The way to stop me responding to your posts is to ... not post yourself. :D The point is that if you haven't made any points of criticism about me or my views that I'm bound to want to respond to, then of course, I'm not going to respond to any. Thus, as the old maxim goes, ... oh no it doesn't; I'm going to have to invent it myself. OK: as the new maxim goes:

He who wants his opponent to shut up will achieve his aim most effectively if he ... keeps quiet.
 
OK, now to continue to the bitter end. :) Remember that new maxim I invented quoted at the end of my last post? ;)

Dann said:
And now you've become so patronizing that you actually start giving me advice about how I ought to argue. Very interesting, except for the fact that I don't agree with your argument: Your "testimonies" from good Christians who once were lost but now are found don't primarily show what some people do when they're "dissatisfied with their lives in some way". Some dissatisfied people do turn to religion and similar superstitions, some to drugs, some to drink, some resign and kill themselves, some find a hobby to invest their spare time in, others get a divorce or a new job. And some actually sit down and analyze what might cause the conditions that make them dissatisfied and some of those actually decide to do something about these causes.

Your arguing style and the way you interpret what your opponent just said can be astonishingly literalistic. An advantage in some circumstances, but not in all of them. ... No, there's something else going on. It's a thing of curiosity to me that someone who argues against religion on the grounds that it is illusionary happiness - a sop that people turn to because of their suffering - should totally miss the point when I tell him he could have seen the Christian testimonies I linked to as proof of just that principle, triumphantly saying: "Yes, those are clearly people who were disatisfied with their lives before they turned to religion - no wonder they did, religion being what it is and all!" I wasn't suggesting all dissatisfied people turn to religion, or I'd probably have converted you by now. :) I was saying you could have seen the testimonies as evidence that religion is a delusion being dissatisfied probably made those people vulnerable to. No, it wouldn't have been a good argument. :) I didn't say it would have been. It would simply have been more imaginative than what you did resort to, and thus just a little bit more challenging for me.

And giving you advice on how to argue is not "patronising". Actually it's enlightened self-interest. You know, that devilish old Capitalist principle! There you go - now you've got two more reasons to dislike what I said. :D

Actually, what I mean is that I'm disappointed by the way you've been arguing; I prefer a challenge, an opponent who raises issues that cause me to think: "That was a good point! Could there be something slightly wrong with my position there? Well, obviously not, because my position's always infallibly correct; but still, let's think this through a bit". :) You know.

Dann said:
That you are a fan of religious delusion does not make the boredom that your testimonials make me experience "reactionary".

I'm surprised you should say those testimonies "bored" you. It's like being bored by stories of people in developing countries working their way out of poverty by being given the means to start small businesses that they'd made profitable. ... But given that would be an endorsement of Capitalism, perhaps you'd experience just the same feeling of boredom you suggest you did when reading about people who left lives of violence and crime. I imagine such an experience might be a bit like this:

A person reads from Breaking Free From Shoplifting

Stealing became one of life's exciting challenges. As a juvenile I was caught on two occasions and had dealings with the police. In my mid-teens, I was
ashamed and distressed when my parents were brought into the picture and I determined not to offend again. However it was not to be, despite my best intentions
and after a few months of restraint, I continued in my old ways. That small weed had taken root and now had a strangle hold on my life. ...

(Becomes Christian and reads the Bible)

I spent the best part of two years and thousands of dollars seeking out and apologising to those that I had stolen from. Some were small businessmen that I knew personally. Some were managers of nationwide retail stores. ... On each occasion those that I had offended against received me graciously. Many were amazed. Some even refused to be compensated for their losses. In these cases I donated the money to charity. Some of the accounting systems of major stores couldn't cope with the situation, as it was that foreign to them.

The person reading that thinks, "Oh, how Boring!!"

Then they read another: From The life of a former gang boss in New York

As I walked along the streets of New York the people were scared of me because I had a bad reputation. I was a gang leader of 205 BOYs and 175 girls. They
did everything I told them to. I controlled them! We did lots of things from murder to bad little delinquents. We did not have any respect for life nor for anything else. ...

I went to hear David Wilkerson preaching. [Oh crikey, please, not Wilkerson again!] :) I went to a Christian meeting for the very first time. I hadn't been in a church in my life and didn't know what these buildings looked like from inside. I took 75 blokes along with me, we had loaded guns with us. I was in a very dangerous area. There were around 2.000 people there. They saw how these animal-like blokes stormed in. They wrecked everything, pushed the people aside, started to swear and made all possible threats. ... [Later]

This preacher had reached me. He had ripped my old heart out and my new heart beat for Jesus! I felt something that I had never felt before: "This bad atmosphere had left me." ...

God had presented me with the biggest and most important gift: love. ... In the world I had come from there was no peace for me. Everything was mixed up. There was lots of loneliness and bitterness. However he gave me his deep and wonderful peace with which he filled my soul. ...

I have experienced it! Now I could close my eyes and say my last prayer - and I could sleep again. God even cared for me in my sleep; there was no more drug addiction, prostitution and no more criminality for me! I did not have to run away anymore or move from one place the next because people could not stand me. No, I had peace and joy all of a sudden! I could go everywhere I wanted and laugh from the heart.

Then the person reading thinks again, with more fervour, "Oh, how boring!!! I can't tolerate any more of this!"

Is that what it's like?

[Actually, that testimony is a "sob story" literally! :D Lots of icky crying in it! Gangsters crying!) So maybe you were right about the "sob story" bit after all. :)

Perhaps this was equally boring:

From Testimony of Carl Dutton - A Captive Set Free

At the age of 16,I was arrested for public drunkenness.* I began drinking to be sociable with the men I worked with and to feel good, never dreaming I would become a drunk. Not long after the drinking began, I started smoking pot and taking pills to feel even better. In a very short time I was a drug addict. Since my wages were only $1.00 an hour, I started dealing drugs and buying and selling stolen property to feed the habit. Every addict in town knew how to find me, to buy drugs and sell stolen property.

Although I was married, I was continually in and out of jail and went to prison twice. Soon I had lost everything, my home, wife, children, humanity, and dignity. ...

Since that time I have not been tempted with drugs and all the thanks goes to Jesus, who set me free!

You could have used This testimony to back up your case that religion is like a drug addiction, saying it demonstrates that a drug addict who becomes a Christian will simply be swapping one addiction for another. ... You Could have used that as an argument, but as you pointed out, my advice to you on how to argue isn't very good. :D No, that wouldn't have been a good argument either. I mean, it's not as if religion, or religious services, put one on a continuous high. Some church services do just the opposite. :eke: :) And if you're a Christian who thinks it's their duty to do charitable work because the New Testament instructs that people do, doing that, though it may give one a sense of fulfilment, is unlikely to put one on a high. "Some opium this is!" they might say. Or if you're a Christian teenager being ridiculed for refusing to go along with the crowd and go to drunken parties, well, sure that's addictive! Or if you're living in a country where you're being persecuted for your faith and some are even being killed, either you have to have an extremely strong addiction for it to be worth holding onto through all that, or your faith means a whole lot more to you than a drug would, for maybe several reasons.

Dann said:
Yes, they will be promiscuous, Christian or not, but unlike you I would never say that ”they're going to be promiscuous anyway” since I don’t have anything against promiscuousness per se. If people want to have sex with many partners, I don’t see the harm – except in the sexually transmitted diseases and unwanted
pregnancies.

And that can be harm enough. But there are also other risks. Here are a few examples:

Part one of this article describes the feelings often suffered by husbands or wives who find out their partner's been having an affair: Healing a Marriage After an Affair.

Another problem is that if teenagers focus all their spare-time energies on sexual encounters, they're losing out on getting involved in activities which could make them more accomplished as well-rounded individuals, and possibly on giving adequate attention to studying. See more on this type of rationale here: Cutting Down the Risk of Getting Into a Bad Relationship.

Having sex with partners without regard for the emotional impact the relationship might have on them can also be harmful. See, for example, Neglected Heart: The Emotional Dangers of Premature Sexual Involvement.

Dann said:
You need only look at reality to find out that the Christian (etc.) ideal of abstinence as a way of fighting the spread of AIDS just doesn’t work for the simple reason that people want to have sex. So the preaching of abstinence doesn’t help ”reduce their chances of catching AIDS.” Condoms, however, do!

While education programs that don't teach about condoms may be ineffective and even harmful, especially where they replace more comprehensive education and so deprive people of information that could save lives that was actually leading to a drop in the AIDS rate before, it would be even more foolish to leave teaching on abstinence out of education programs altogether. Here are a few reasons why:

From an article all about condoms:

On the reasons why using condoms as a method of contraception can be less reliable than it would be ideally:

Condom users may experience breakage or slippage of the condom due to faulty methods of application or physical damage (such as tears caused when opening the package), latex degradation (typically from being past the expiration date or being stored improperly), and from slipping off the penis after ejaculation.

While standard condoms will fit almost any penis, some men may find that use of 'snug' or 'magnum' condoms decreases the risk of slippage, leaking, and bursting.

Measuring yourself is thus important, it would seem. There can't be many people who do that.

Among couples that intend condoms to be their form of birth control, pregnancy may occur when the couple does not use a condom. The couple may have run out of condoms, or be traveling and not have a condom with them, or simply dislike the feel of condoms and decide to "take a chance." This type of behavior is the primary cause of "typical use" failure (as opposed to "method" or "perfect use" failure).

If it's assumed that people are going to have sex no matter what, and that no abstinence education can help them, the main cause of "typical use failure" will never be remedied.

It's an interesting educational article. It covers several reasons people don't use condoms despite having been educated about them, the contrast between the failure rates condoms would have if used perfectly according to all instructions and the failure rates condom use as a method of contraception actually does have, due to a range of reasons, including being the wrong size, being used by people not taking account of all instructions, and people sometimes not bothering to use them. The differences in failure rates between perfect use and typical use are quite wide, according to various surveys carried out by government and other organisations.

The method pregnancy rate of condoms is 2% per year. The actual pregnancy rates among condoms users vary depending on the population being studied, with rates of 10-18% per year being reported.

The article also covers information about sexually transmitted diseases condoms just won't protect against, because they're transmitted by skin contact.

In particular, these include STDs associated with ulcerative lesions that may be present on body surfaces where the condom doesn't cover, such as genital herpes simplex (HSV), chancroid, and syphilis. If contact is made with uncovered lesions, transmission of these STIs may still occur despite appropriate condom use. Additionally, the absence of visible lesions or symptoms cannot be used to decide whether caution is needed.

The article also covers the range of reasons people, even in places in the world where AIDS rates are highest like South Africa, simply refuse to wear condoms.

Condoms are more accessible in developed countries. In various cultures, a number of social or economic factors make access to condoms prohibitive. In some cases, cultural beliefs may cause some persons to shun condoms deliberately even when they are available.

Furthermore, regardless of culture and availability, many men shun condoms simply because they dislike using them. This dislike may be due to reduced sexual pleasure or to practical problems, e.g. difficulty in sustaining an erection hard enough for effective condom use.

It goes into quite a bit more detail about those and several other factors. It says only a small proportion of people worldwide use condoms.

Then there's the problem that even where condoms are available in the developing world, such as where they've been shipped over there as part of aid packages, many have been found to be of very poor quality in the past, at least according to this NY Times article: Faulty Condoms Thwart AIDS Fight in Africa

Out of the depths of the AIDS epidemic sweeping Africa, an ugly truth is emerging: Some condom makers have been dumping their substandard wares here and Africans have been risking their lives on brittle, leaky or ill-fitting condoms. ...

There is no question that a scarcity of condoms and the refusal of many men to use them are to blame for far more of Africa's 23 million H.I.V. infections than faulty condoms are. And experts say most condoms are perfectly good and the influx of bad ones may finally have been stemmed. But the deviousness or sloppiness of some manufacturers and the failure of inspectors to catch them have contributed to the disease's spread.

The article's several years old, so maybe quality control has improved now, although the AIDS rate is still rising, so whether or not it has, there are obviously other factors involved. Later in the article, it says:

All over Africa, everyone from health officers to women's rights advocates to prostitutes complain that it is very difficult to get men to use condoms. Besides the usual complaints about sensitivity and lack of spontaneity, men argue that they are ''not part of African culture.''

''The men dictate what will be done, and the women have very little power to say no,'' said Dr. Neil Miller, an AIDS-education expert with the British embassy in Zimbabwe.

And, because a vast majority of condoms here are handed out free, no choices of size are offered. The problem may sound silly, but condom distributors say it is not. Too-large condoms slip off, putting the user at risk of infection, while uncomfortably small ones discourage men from using them.

And from an article called Beauty and the Brothel: Prostitutes and AIDS in India

Over 7,000 women and girls work as prostitutes in Sonagachi, Calcutta’s largest red-light district. Often forced into the trade by poverty, abandonment or the rampant trafficking business which forcibly transports young girls from Nepal and neighboring Bangladesh, they come from all castes, but have been pushed down the social scale to Sonagachi, a seedy landscape of narrow alleys, the next ground zero in the global AIDS epidemic.

World health officials are calling India the next Africa, forecasting more Indians will die from AIDS in the next decade than all the HIV-related deaths since the disease was discovered in 1981. With an estimated million prostitutes in India, prostitution is the lit match of the AIDS tinderbox. A host of local non-government organizations have collected millions of dollars in aid money to halt the transmission of the disease. Plagued by infighting and corruption, however, little of it has funneled down to the alleys of Sonagachi. There, cheap condoms are readily available, but women remain ignorant of their importance or powerless to make customers use them.

Even with awareness, the financial pressures are too great to refuse customers who won’t use condoms. As a prostitute, Beauty, put it, "So what if I’m afraid? If it’s not that way, they will go away. Some other girl will say, ‘Come, I’ll entertain you without a condom.’ Then it’s my loss."

Dann said:
Yes, if people never had sex nobody would die of AIDS. That’s what the pope says, isn’t it? So the reason why AIDS reached epidemic proportions wasn’t that
it is a sexually transmitted disease that people weren’t even aware of and therefore couldn’t protect themselves against. Now the reason is that lack of morality appears to spread HIV.

But it could be argued that even without knowledge of AIDS, there is a certain callousness in being unfaithful to partners.

And it's unhealthy to have an ideological aversion to the concept of moral living so dogmatic that it isn't prepared to countenance the possibility that behaviour change would help.

Dann said:
I hate many of Hans Christian Andsersen’s stories, in particular The Ugly Duckling. He was a pompous jerk – and actually owned stock in the Danish slave trade.
And, I’m sorry, but I still don’t think that it is a good idea to kill a woman because she was raped and then send the ”bits of her body” to ”rouse outrage among his countrymen” because of the foreigners’ abuse of his private property. And it is incredibly cynical and absurd to use the ”absence of gory television pictures” as an excuse for his behaviour. Christian apologetics make me sick.

Perhaps they'd make you less sick if you made a few more efforts to understand them. Of course it isn't a good idea! And there can't be many people in the world who'd suggest it was. That isn't even what the Bible says. It says she was dead when he found her. Still, of course his behaviour wasn't acceptable. Leaving aside your still-ignorant description of the mistress as private property, you fail to see the point I was making. So again, I'll say the fact that a story may have a moral in it does not mean that everything in it has to be deemed acceptable or good. I don't understand why you're making that mistake. I once read a comment by someone who said that one mistake some people make is to think that if a story's in the Bible it must mean everything in it is supposed to be God-ordained, so for instance, they can imagine that Moses said that God was saying that people shouldn't oppress widows and orphans, and then later read a story about a widow and her children being oppressed, and call that a contradiction, even though the Bible says nothing about God actually ordering that oppression. Perhaps that's similar to what you're doing.

And I wasn't making "excuses" for the man, but simply pointing out that he was using a means of communication that seems gory to us but which he may have deemed the most effective means of communication given the medialess culture he lived in. The culture was vastly different to ours. I could illustrate. Though his actions seem abhorrent, frankly, it would be tempting to call for death and destruction on a great mob of gang rapists!

That's an interesting allegation you make against Hans Kristian Andersen. I didn't know that. I'd heard he was mentally ill, possibly suffering from OCD.

Dann said:
You are the one who claims that it’s ”abuse” since you want to distinguish between good (= real Christianity) and bad[/b] Christianity (= not really
Christianity but the abuse of Christianity).


You will see if you study the matter that Christianity followed according to biblical guidelines would be almost free from the abuses seen in the kinds of churches I linked to information about a few posts ago. So for you to say it's equally bad needs explanation, which you haven't given anywhere near adequately. You claim a psychopath could use religious belief to abuse believers. Then you appear to dodge the question when I ask for further explanation. If your view is correct that all religion no matter how well-intended leaves people open to exploitation by psychopaths, it should be possible to demonstrate that. It should be possible to read the New Testament and explain just how anyone who knows it well is open to exploitation.

For anyone who would like to accept that challenge, here are lots of quotes for starters that are actually protective against psychopaths misleading people familiar with the verses:

What The Bible Says About Violence, Anger, Jealousy, Arguments, And Living In Peace With Each Other.
What The Bible Says About Honesty And The Love Of Money.
A Short Story About Tackling Prejudice, And What The Bible Says About Despising People, Judging By Appearances, And God's Mercy.
What The Bible Says About Love And Caring.
What The Bible Says About Drunkenness and Why It's Wrong.
What The Bible Says About Lies, Gossip, Quarrelling, Insulting Language And Dirty Jokes.
What The Bible Says About Sex And Marriage.
What The Bible Says About Lustful And Nasty Thoughts.
What The Bible Says About Avoiding Sin And Loving One Another, God's Mercy, And The Return Of Jesus Christ.
What The Bible Says About The Life-Changing Power Of The Holy Spirit.

Don't stick to those though. Read the whole New Testament.

Earlier, you accused me of putting "carefully selected" Bible verses on here to illustrate my points, the implication being that my choice was deceptive. So I challenge you to show that's true, if you actually want to insist on it: Find and quote the New Testament verses that urge Christians to be violent, to go to war, to steal, to murder, to fight, to quarrel, to oppress, and so on. Find just one. One clear verse that tells Christians to do any one of those things. If you can't, then you have nothing to back up your suggestion that such things exist.

Even in the Old Testament with its gory stories, Jews were not permitted to invade random people whenever they felt like it with the justification that those people were wicked and deserved it. The closest anyone could get to using biblical justification for war would be to claim that Old Testament passages could be used as a precedent. This article explains why this would be unbiblical: An Attempt to Justify Gruesome Bible Passages. A truly shocking title, I know. A truly shocking article? Those who browse it will know.

And to think I wouldn't have said any of this stuff without provocation/opposition. :)

Me said:
But religion in itself doesn't make a person vulnerable to abuse. Believing in God doesn't necessarily make you vulnerable to the scam of someone telling you God's telling him you need to give him your money, for instance.

Dann said:
Of course it does. Have you ever tried to make an atheist give you money with this argument?

Another epic point-miss. As if religious people are anywhere near all vulnerable to being taken in.

Incidentally, if one were to try to scam an atheist by telling them one was collecting money for some atheist organisation, they'd probably almost all be vulnerable to the scam. Should we shut down atheist organisations because of it? :D That's the logical equivalent of the argument that religion needs to be eradicated entirely because psychopaths can use it as a means through which to abuse others. Much of it needs to be modified, certainly. But scrapped? Bearing in mind how much good it can inspire, there would have to be better reasons.

Dann said:
No, but it definitely helps. And who the hell is Cliff Richard trying to fool? How does he know that they hadn't all hear from God? Who is he to question their belief? Doesn't he know that God works in mysterious ways?

Well, if all the women had heard from God, it proves God's terrible at grammar and should possibly sit in on a few elementary school classes. He told all of them he wanted them to be Cliff Richard's housekeeper (singular??)

Ah, Luther again. Yes, I answered that one in an earlier post, didn't I.
 
He who wants his opponent to shut up will achieve his aim most effectively if he ... keeps quiet.

Well that "piece of advice" certainly doesn't work. I've been very quiet...I havent even posted in this thread, yet you continue to babble on and on with your "holier than thou" attitude. I've been waiting for you to shut up for the past month...so any suggestions on what would actually shut you up would be greatly appreciated.
 
Well that "piece of advice" certainly doesn't work. I've been very quiet...I havent even posted in this thread, yet you continue to babble on and on with your "holier than thou" attitude. I've been waiting for you to shut up for the past month...so any suggestions on what would actually shut you up would be greatly appreciated.

Wow, only 87 posts in eight-and-a-half years. You obviously don't comment unless something's of major importance. Well, in that case, I'm honoured that you consider my behaviour one of the truly momentous events of the past eight years worth your comment. :D

I'm going to invent quote another new old maxim now. Ah yes, here is truly an off-the-cuff barely-thought-through quip the accumulated wisdom of the ages!:

He who doesn't enjoy reading a thread would be well-advised to ... not read it.

And another, an even newer a truly, truly ancient one this time, possibly dating back even to Roman times:

He who makes no useful contribution to a thread on an Internet forum but merely unconstructively complains that a contributor has a "holier-than-thou attitude" can at least be pleased he's right about one thing, even if he got the tense wrong, confusing the consequence of his words with their past attitude.

Since that maxim was minted in Latin or the ancient language of some conquered peoples of the Romans and so might not be quite clear, I'll translate:

One who contributes nothing to the arguments presented in a thread but who thinks a contributor had a holier-than-thou attitude beforehand, is not seeing the past, but in fact spookily foreseeing the future when due to his unconstructive boorish style of contribution, his opponent will in fact acquire a holier-than-thou attitude to him.

Well, if nothing else, it seems you have psychic powers, albeit you obviously haven't developed the gift well yet because you're confusing the past with the future. Still, you may have a promising future ahead of you. Just one word of caution:

It might be adviseable to do a few checks on your clients. There are skeptics out there who have even resorted to suing psychics, and in future it's possible there'll be more of them. See my thread Psychics worried about being "sued by sceptics" in the UK

That one's a fairly recent truly historic thread which I wrote in 1066, on the very eve of the Battle of Hastings.

What this response to you has to do with this thread's topic - religion's value, I don't yet know. So I think I'll end with something to make it relevant:

Here's an example of an atheist who was not shy about making a two-part historical documentary about how Christianity came to Ireland and Scotland and England and civilised them - albeit he says much of the civilising influence came from the literacy skills and new technologies brought by the Christians, which naturally could have been brought by other progressive groups as the Romans had earlier. Interesting documentary. The Telegraph interviews the documentary-maker: Dan Snow: How Britain nearly became the Irish Isles

So what did the Celts do for us? Even the term “Celt”, as Snow concedes, can be a vague, emotive term. For Snow’s purposes, however, the Celts are the people
primarily living in Ireland who came to Britain to evangelise and to trade, and who by so doing gave (what was to become) the UK a common language, a longer life expectancy and, in essence, the beginnings of what we would now call civilisation. ...

Interestingly, however, Snow is no fan of Christianity per se: “I’m an atheist,” he says, “so I’m fairly harsh on the idea that Christianity is a self-evidently brilliant creed that everyone adopts as soon as they’re told about it.”

Through making this series, however, Snow says that in fact his regard for Christianity has grown. “It is fascinating, ideologically, to watch the Iron Age warrior ethos being transformed by Christian thought,” he says. “The old belief was that it was basically only really the warriors who were special. But Christianity told people that they were all special now. Even in this period, it was quite emancipating.” ...
 
I've decided to break my silence for a little while. If you'd like to protest again, R.A.F., I'm sure I'll take great delight in obliging you once again with a response. :D

I'm wondering what happened to this. As posted in April:

bpesta22 said:
Fairly soon, at least two articles will appear in the literature showing that religious belief correlates with negative outcomes; not positive ones. None of it's causal, but I bet over the next few years this relationship will be strongly established.

Baby Nemesis said:
Religion is so diverse as to make any generalisation about its effects impossible.

bpesta22 said:
I think it's possible and been done. I'll post a link once they get published if yer interested.

Baby Nemesis said:
It might be interesting, but I might want to critique it. My horribly gruesome thread Desperation fuels belief in the supernatural is about the worst excesses of that kind of thing. But at its best, I think religion can be a good thing, because it can inspire people to better behaviour, ... a bit like the moderation system on this board.

bpesta22 said:
Critiquing is fine!

It might be a month or so, but I will post a link.

bpesta22 said:
One I reviewed for a leading journal; the other is mine. I hope to send it to a leading journal, get it rejected then find somewhere else that'll take it.

I wonder why he didn't post the link to it in the end. It's possible he thought I'd done such a good job of critiquing the idea that religion leads to nothing but negative outcomes before he put it here that there was no need to put it here for it to be subject to my criticism after all. :D

I can understand the knee-jerk impulse to abolish religion, designating it worthless. I had just such an impulse for a few seconds earlier this week when I read this gruesome article:

Fr Edward, survivor of arson in Orissa: the Hindu radicals are terrorists

Mumbai (AsiaNews) - Fr Edward Sequeira, one of the victims of the violence committed by Hindu radicals in Orissa, does not hesitate to call them "terrorists". Groups connected to Sangh Parivar seized him, beat him for more than an hour, and then shut him inside a room that they set on fire. Fr Edward was able to save himself by taking shelter in the bathroom. Before he passed out, he heard the screams of Rajni Majh, who was tied up and thrown into the flames,
where she was burned to death.

Initial reports said that she was a sister, then a lay missionary. Fr Edward explains that the girl was one of the many orphans he had rescued, and that she lived and worked in the orphanage he had founded. ...

It was only the arrival of firefighters that put an end to the tragedy. But the problems remain: "In rural India", the priest continues, "human rights and religious freedom are non-existent. India has a dual identity, one of emerging economic power - an industrial India - and a parrellel India, the rural poor, the exploited and dispossessed, poverty-stricken Indians without rights, without religious freedom, who are not even considered by the political
powers except as an election vote bank.

"When the Church makes the people aware of their dignity and gives them self-reliance, we are attacked. We are improving the economic status of the poor and marginalised. The dalits and tribals are becoming self-reliant through our education, with some power of decision-making. This is strongly resented and opposed by the local landlords, who are unable to exploit them as cheap farm labour, bonded labour and other forms of oppression.

"Today, religion is completely politicized, and the rural impoverished in India are pawns in the hands of powerful politicians who whip us into religious frenzy for political gain. They are vandals, criminals".

There we seem to see a clear example of religion being used as a vehicle to whip people's feelings into a frenzy so they do terrible things. But does that mean the world would be a better place if religion were to go? Wouldn't those who wanted to rouse a rabble just use a different style of propaganda that whipped up a different kind of bigotry? "Those immigrants! They ..."; "Those foreigners who want to replace our culture with corrupt Western culture where thousands of families break up every week ..." and so on. What I think needs to go is extremism of any form. After all, atheism can just as easily be used as a vehicle through which psychopaths can whip up violence as religion can. Take the Jacobins in France, for instance: France's great paradox to pursue secularism with religious zeal

It began in 1792, with the extremist Jacobins seizing power in France. Jacobinism is a paradox: a mix of revolutionary atheism and authoritarian republican statism. This resulted in a concerted attack on religion, leading to a hideous civil war which claimed hundreds of thousands of victims in the west of France.

The coming to power of Napoleon meant the repeal of much Jacobin anti-clericalism and for a time, there was peace between politicians and the church. However, in 1880 the militantly atheistic Jules Ferry (an ancestor of the present Education Minister, philosopher Luc Ferry) started the war with religion again, expelling all religious staff from public schools, and nuns from hospitals. France seemed set for turmoil again, but fortunately moderate elements intervened.

Does the fact that atheism can be used as a catalyst for violence mean atheism ought to be forbidden? Of course not. It's militancy of all descriptions that can easily be manipulated by people wanting to stir up trouble. Extremism thrives in places where people have grievances, such as where there are big wealth inequalities.

Not long ago, there was a programme on the BBC World Service that asked the question of whether growing prosperity was the key to solving the problem of extremism and thus terrorism, since greater satisfaction with life and more opportunities to do fulfilling things in life would dampen extremist sentiment and divert people who might have been extremists into better things. It was argued on one side that prosperity might not be the key, since the leaders of extremist organisations tended to be prosperous. But someone pointed out that though that tended to be the case, the recruits at the grassroots level tended not to be so prosperous. You can read about the programme here.

I don't see a need to get rid of moderate religion that doesn't hinder the intellectual growth of those who follow it or lead to them becoming anxious because of superstitious belief, or harmed in any other way. If its followers see it as something that only ever affects their lives in positive ways, and the belief isn't so overarching that it makes followers interfere in the lives of others, then I don't see the need for intolerance of it.

On the other hand, it would probably be kept in a more healthy state and more healthily moderate if it was routine for children growing up to be trained to question what they're told by the media and other institutions and generally by adults around them and think about it critically. To give an example of how that could sometimes work, an idea I liked was the idea put forward for science lessons in this old thread here: An investigative topic for kids

A science teacher wrote:

After some discussion within the faculty, here's what we have come up with. ...

3) Does shampoo really make your hair stronger?

Lots of shampoos claim to make hair stronger, so we're going to hang weights on strands of hair and see if washed strands are any.

4) Is telepathy real?

Zenner card reading session. We've done one of these before, and already have all the stuff for it. ...

6) The placebo effect.

Measure resting pulse rate then repeat once a minute for five minutes after drinking a coloured liquid from a bottle marked "High caffeine drink". See if it affects the heart rate, and reveal at the end that it is just water.

7) Dowsing.

Does dowsing work? Why does it seem to work?

8) Comparing name brands to budget brands

We decided to go with kitchen roll testing; absorbancy, tissue strength. ...

A few weeks ago, I heard a Palestinian man talking on the BBC World Service about how restrictive his schooling was. He said the children weren't encouraged to think critically at all. He gave the example of how a teacher asked the class one day what trees could be used for. Most children gave conventional answers like that they were useful for getting wood from, that it was possible to make paper out of. He himself put his hand up and said they could be useful because the ends of a cord could be tied onto two trees some distance apart, and then people could hang washing on the cord. He was scolded and ridiculed for it. The teacher said it would harm the tree, (as if the other things wouldn't). His parents were told what he'd said and they scolded him as well. Experiences like that motivated him to want to improve the education system. So now he's grown-up, he's started classes in schools especially for awkward children who are disruptive in class. They learn science subjects, which he said aren't really taught in Palestinian schools. Of course he didn't sell his education program to the schools as a scheme to teach what was lacking in their education system, but as a scheme to take on awkward children. They can attend a lesson a few times a week.

I've discovered there are other progressive schemes going on there, for instance this:

Summer Camp Stimulates Critical Thinking in Palestinian Youth

The “Extracurricular Enrichment Day Camp” opened its doors to 110 gifted Palestinian youth from West Bank public middle schools, ages 12-16 on June 13, 2009. Implemented by Al Quds University in Abu Dis and funded by the U.S. government, the camp seeks to stimulate critical-thinking, build self-confidence, and prepare participants for a future in higher education. Activities will include hands-on workshops in the fields of biology, chemistry, computer science, physics, and the environment. Students will also develop individual projects with the assistance of a mentor. Also included in the camp’s program are civic-education topics, aimed at fostering greater civic participation by youth in local communities.

It seems to me that the further that kind of attitude spreads the better.

*******

One thing that might be worth clarifying while I'm here:

Apologies to Dann for bringing this up one more time, after I said that if he stopped responding then I'd stop talking, and he obliged. I won't mention it again, unless someone else raises the matter.

I re-read Dann's post on morality from the end of the previous page on Friday night, the one someone nominated for an award and it somehow got to the finals of the Most Informative Post award. :) It was an attack on what was actually a gross simplification of the position I was arguing. I didn't understand how it could have happened at first, but after re-reading it, it occurred to me that he might have been inspired to write it partly by post 76, where I responded to someone who asked me why I thought the Bible was worth holding onto by saying that the New Testament had lots of beautiful and inspirational passages in it that could influence people to make changes for the better in their lives so they no longer behaved in ways that could harm those around them. I went on to illustrate my point by saying that if enough people had been influenced to change for the better, a lot of the world's problems wouldn't be happening. Now, I was talking about the Bible's theoretical potential, using the language of idealism. I was talking hypotheticals. I was not suggesting for a second that all that was needed for the world's problems to disappear was for people to just start reading and acting on those Bible passages, and in fact that everyone who isn't influenced by them should jolly well start reading them because the only way they'll adopt decent values is by doing so, as Dann's post suggested he thought. There's a big difference between saying, "if people had obeyed those Bible passages, there wouldn't be a financial crisis now" and so on, and saying, "If we want to change the world for the better, the only thing we have to do is to encourage everyone to obey the Bible". Yet it seems the distinction was too subtle for Dann to pick up on, despite other things I've said in this thread and the fact that he'd looked at my thread labelled "Witch killing" in my signature which goes into a fair bit of detail about how violence in some parts of the world is being fuelled because of underdevelopment of things like modern healthcare facilities and ignorance of the causes of disease, leading to fears that witches are causing them who are thus a threat that needs to be eliminated, which urged that what needed to happen most was improvements in their living standards, educational standards and access to modern healthcare and other services.

The point is that I'm not suggesting that the value of religion is in the practical ability of the Bible to transform anyone who comes into contact with it or any such thing. Far from it. I was arguing that religion's value is in its potential to change some people's lives for the better and inspire them to adopt values they personally might not have had otherwise. I illustrated my point with stories about people who had in fact been inspired to do just that.

Of course there will be people who have found that the version of Christianity they grew up in was a hindrance to their lives and they felt a great sense of freedom and relief when they left religion. But I don't see that as being relevant to the genuine value religion can sometimes have in turning people's lives around, as if only if a cost/benefit analysis were done and its value far outweighed the dissatisfaction people have felt with it over the centuries could that value be classed as genuine. That would be a very superficial measure indeed in itself, partly because it would make no analysis of the reasons why some people found it so valuable while others found it a hindrance to them, as well as giving suggestions as to how the aspects of religion that had been found to be unsatisfactory or harmful could be modified to mitigate their effects, if indeed they could be. Religion isn't a great monolith that you need to either get rid of or keep in its entirety. Only where there's intransigence on the part of influential extremists can it not be adapted so positive aspects are accentuated.
 
Four pages of counting hit and ignoring misses.

Amazing, why not have a meeting.

Because it works positively for so many people, in ways you wish to either hand wave away or ignore, you pursue bad hits a-plenty, due to a profound pre investigation bias, because it makes you feel good.

Not well played.

DR
 
Was that comment aimed at me, Dann, or both of us? If it was aimed at me, it's even stranger than it appears, since I wasn't even here when the first page of the 4 you refer to was created. :) Sorry, but I hardly understood a word of what you said.

The thread title asks whether religion has value. My point has been that it does for some, in that it can inspire them to change for the better, thus improving the life of the community around them by being inspired to behave in ways that reduce harm to them and increase their well-being. I think I've proven my point well enough. On the other hand, I have pointed out that religion is not a monolith, so its effects cannot be generalised by any means. It can often be harmful, and where it is, wherever possible, people should seek to have it adapted. See a quote of mine from an earlier post:

Doesn't it make more sense not to condemn religion out of hand as an accursed delusion or to praise it unquestioningly, but instead to try to analyse the elements of it that tempt people to do evil and work to have them eliminated, but to be tolerant of it where it can be seen to be doing good and accept that it's a good idea to have certain elements of it preserved, and to work out what those are?

For instance, it may be seen that it wasn't religion in itself that caused people such as Mary Tudor who burned Protestants at the stake to do evil, but the principle that power corrupts, a bigoted mind-set that by no means always accompanies religion, a thirst for revenge on the people affiliated with those who mistreated her and her mother and tried to put Catholicism down, an almost pathological lack of empathy, and so on. If we can tease out the causes
of people's behaviour, we can seek to change those without having to dump the entirety of religion. We might also discover that a lot of what motivated them isn't intrinsic to religion at all. Then we can perhaps seek to modify religion so it can't so easily be used by people as a vehicle for their evil intentions, for instance by seeking to change the structure of it so its authority figures have less power.

On the other hand, if a religion is evil at its core, because it preaches hatred for all non-believers, or it teaches that the poor are poor through Karma, that they deserve what they get and must accept their lot in life, then atheism might bring wondrous enlightenment for those entrapped by that religion, and the quicker it spreads the better.

If you actually have a constructive comment to make, I'd be interested to debate it with you.
 
Was that comment aimed at me, Dann, or both of us? If it was aimed at me, it's even stranger than it appears, since I wasn't even here when the first page of the 4 you refer to was created. :) Sorry, but I hardly understood a word of what you said.

The thread title asks whether religion has value. My point has been that it does for some, in that it can inspire them to change for the better, thus improving the life of the community around them by being inspired to behave in ways that reduce harm to them and increase their well-being. I think I've proven my point well enough. On the other hand, I have pointed out that religion is not a monolith, so its effects cannot be generalised by any means. It can often be harmful, and where it is, wherever possible, people should seek to have it adapted. See a quote of mine from an earlier post:

If you actually have a constructive comment to make, I'd be interested to debate it with you.
After reading four pages of this conversation, I posted what I did in quiet frustration of having seen little to nothing new to chew on, and I suppose my post was directed mostly at dann's opening position.

But quite frankly, I ought to have remained in lurk mode and said nothing, so I apologize for that low quality post.

DR
 
After reading four pages of this conversation, I posted what I did in quiet frustration of having seen little to nothing new to chew on, and I suppose my post was directed mostly at dann's opening position.

But quite frankly, I ought to have remained in lurk mode and said nothing, so I apologize for that low quality post.

DR

Wow, you read all that?! It must have taken you an entire week of your life! Sorry to disappoint after all that. Still, if you compare the misspent week with the entire third of your life you may spend sleeping, you'll maybe get things in perspective and it won't seem so bad. :)

(Aside to myself: Wow, to think what I got away with!)

So: Can you think of anything new you'd like to see? If so, maybe one of us could oblige you. :)
 
OK: It may be that this won't be new to Darth Rotor either, but it might be to other members of my pitifully sparse readership. :)

Here's an illustration of the reason it's unwise to dismiss religious things as valueless without much thought.

Here's an example from another forum I've posted on (under a different name). Someone there posted criticisms of something they'd found on another forum early last year:

Critical forum member said:
Hay street wise dudes. I actually moon light at another forum sometimes these days and this loser has just joined who is precisely the kind of person you DON"T want around. Here is a little taster: ...

To me it is a kind of half understood mysticism; things that have been half read in books; product of superficial religion and that is why I reacted to it as without substance.

If you like the repetition of the same old religious imagery that you can get in any Hari-Krishna hand out fine.

Now here's a sample of what it was he was describing as without substance and such. I found his comments grossly insensitive, and I responded. Here's a quote from what the person whose posts he was belittling actually said:

Religious forum member said:
I have a habit of worrying about people's situations, their state of mind, and where I think they're heading and especially with my close friends and my family, but I don't really have much of a right to do so, right? Worry can drive me crazy sometimes too...the Bible says worry is a sin. When I remembered that, it made me wonder what other way I can look at sin, and then I saw sin in a very different light.

Sin is a plaque, but not because it is only bad, but because it hurts, stands in the way of clarity. To sin shows you are not bad, evil, guilty, or wrong. We all are just in desperate need for hope and clarity, thats all. So from now on, when I think I"m doing something bad, thinking something bad, I'll remember in no way shall I guilt myself, but I shall humble myself to the grace of love and see clearly again whats true.

Here's a very slightly altered version of part of what I said:

Actually, the Bible Doesn't say worry is a sin as such. But this seems to be a person who would have issues with guilt, ...

Far from being "superficial", this could actually be very deep and meaningful for some people. There are people who put themselves through agonies of guilt, forever worrying about whether they've displeased God. In fact, there's a well-recognised psychological condition, OCD, where people continually put themselves through agonies of worry and self-doubt, and one manifestation of it can be a religious one. Where religion is less important in a society, it's more likely to focus itself on other things. But some OCD sufferers have a condition where they're continuously
in fear and torment because they're scared of having offended God, and they mull over everything they've done and said and thought a huge number of times a day, to question themselves about whether they might have offended God.

This is clearly unhealthy. I'm not suggesting the forum member who talked about worry has any such condition as that, but even if they just have a few much more minor issues with unnecessary guilt, then for them to have found something that puts their mind at ease could give them tremendous comfort. It would be a terrible thing for them to have thought worry was evil and yet not know how to stop it, if that's what they were saying.

Here's a self-help article on getting over religious OCD where the sufferer constantly worries about having done things wrong and the consequences for them.

Religious thinking can sometimes cause a lot of problems; but sometimes, alternative forms of it can provide a cure.
 
... Rather than either rejecting or accepting religion wholesale, a more insightful approach would be to investigate what elements of religion make people "bores" or evil, or adopt other negative traits, and what elements of religion can be tremendously good for people and their communities. Here's an example of how that approach can benefit people. From an article called Why faith in God really can relieve pain:

For centuries, religious believers have endured suffering with impressive fortitude.

Now scientists claim to have discovered that faith in God really can relieve pain.

New research at Oxford University has found that the Christian martyrs may well have been able to draw on their religion to reduce the agony of, for example, being burnt at the stake.

It goes on to describe an experiment that was done that found that Catholics experienced less pain in response to controlled electric shocks than atheists.

The next question would be: "Why is that happening?" and when it's been discovered exactly what's going on, the question can be asked, "What can atheists draw on to reduce their pain in the same way?" The article does in fact mention that.

There was a television documentary on a while ago that asked just such a question. It found that religious belief often did seem to help people with painful conditions. As part of their investigation into why, the documentary makers met with some rationalists in India who went around doing demonstrations where they inflicted pain on themselves to prove you didn't need religion to reduce the effects of pain on you. One documentary-maker did what they were doing
to himself to see if he could tune the pain out or something. He discovered that when he took the attitude that he didn't mind the pain, it seemed to lessen, possibly because he wasn't tensing his muscles, which could have made it worse, but maybe for some other reason. The atheists doing the demonstration explained that religious figures in temples would make a great ceremony of the skill of being able to tune out pain to some extent, but none of that was necessary, as illustrated by the fact that they could do it.

So, discovering that religion can sometimes do a lot of good, the scientific thing to do would be to investigate as far as possible exactly what's going on when it does, and what and how much of that can be replicated in non-religious settings.

Further to that, atheists don't have to reject testimonies of people who left lifestyles that were harming themselves or others to become Christians as offensive nonsense, simply because they contain a lot of Christian terminology. The more imaginative and creative atheists can view such things as an interesting psychological/sociological phenomenon that it might be possible to learn from, since it may be that many of the things that influenced those people to give up their harmful lifestyles can be replicated in secular settings with no Christian overtones. In other words, the testimonies might give some insights as to how some lives can be changed for the better by totally secular means, since they might talk about needs that were fulfilled by adopting Christianity that could actually have been fulfilled by other means. Here's an example:

Earlier I linked to the testimony of a former gang boss who gave up his violent ways when he became a Christian. Here are some ways in which his testimony illustrates that such testimonies could be used to gain insights into ways such people's lives could be changed in secular ways:

He first gives a bit of information about his life story. He blames his behaviour partly on ill-treatment and rejection by his family:

At home I was totally left out and sent away by my mother. She had called me the “devil’ son”. I never believed that she would get rid of me. The lifestyle and the situation we lived in really had an effect. The feeling of being left out was so terrible for me! It hurt inside and I was fully torn apart. I was a very lonely BOY on the streets. ...

Since the day when I was 8 years old and my mother threw me out I have rejected everyone who has even tried to show me love. If my mother did not love me I could not expect that any strangers could love me. That’s why I became such a bad man on the streets.

Crikey!

Obviously such accounts will be prone to some of the failings of anecdotal evidence - some of the factors that influenced him to become violent might have been forgotten by him, the testimony won't contain all the facts, and it's possible his experience isn't the least bit representative of that of gang members in general. Still, it could be seen as part of a bigger picture. And if upon research it turns out that many of them have similar accounts, attempts could be made to think up possible solutions to such problems.

It has in fact been found that part of what motivates many teenagers to join gangs is wanting a sense of belonging, to feel as if they're in a family-type group of supportive friends. See this article, for example. So one possible solution would be to try to get individuals thought to be at risk of getting involved in gangs and crime and drugs etc. into alternative activities where they'll be mixing with a group of people they'll hopefully make friends with, who have different goals - who are optimistic that they're going places in life, who enjoy harmless activities, and who might make up a solid friendship network for a boy introduced to them.

The former gang leader also says:

I never would have thought that Jesus could change my life so completely whatever I have done with my hands and have seen with my eyes. I could never have thought it would be possible that it could be so nice to have a personal
loving relationship with him so that we can feel so secure and protected and don’t have to fear anything.

Um, surely he's using hyperbole there. Nevertheless, it seems that something he values in his life is security, protection and freedom from fear, along with the feeling of being loved. In a group of supportive friends who regularly do healthy activities, he'd be more likely to get near-equivalents of such things. But also, such considerations could be taken into account by counsellors/therapists when exploring a delinquent teen's reasons for their misbehaviour with them, and possible solutions could be worked out in collaboration with people like probation officers and community leaders. Here's an example:

There's a book called Solution-Focused Therapy with Children by Matthew Selekman, which contains a story about a ten-year-old boy, who seemed advanced for his age and was hanging around with boys who were involved with gangs, and had been shoplifting for a few years, stealing computer toys. He was also disobedient to his parents and teachers. His parents were at their wits' end and brought him for therapy with the author of the book.

It turned out that in his particular case, that he was being bullied to steal for the older boys, who had told him not to stop or they'd "kick his ass". His parents had had no idea of this. The boy said he'd been scared he'd be caught stealing, and about what the gang would do to him if he stopped.

The therapist and the family met with the boy's probation officer and the school social worker. The probation officer offered to intervene with the older boys on the boy's behalf, and the social worker offered to help out with some means of support and protection.

Another person meeting with the group was the family's church pastor, who offered to get the boy in touch with a certain community leader who was respected by the gangs, who also coached a basketball team the boy could join. The boy was excited about that, since he loved basketball.

The boy's behaviour improved a lot after that. He stopped stealing, and became obedient to his parents and teachers. He joined the basketball team. At the next therapy session, the basketball coach came along, as well as the people who'd been there before. He said the boy was making very good progress. They all praised the boy because of the change in his bhehaviour. The mother even baked a cake to thank them all for their help.

Naturally such an approach wouldn't work with everyone. Still, it would be worth considering for some.

Some psychologists assert that everyone has certain emotional needs, and recommend that therapists always have conversations with their clients about whether those needs are being met in their lives, no matter what they presented as the problems that had brought them to therapy. According to this article, those needs include:

• the need for security (a stable home life and safe territory to live in);
• the need for intimacy and friendship;
• the need to give and receive attention;
• the need for a sense of autonomy and control;
• the need to feel connected to others and be part of a wider community;
• the need to feel competent which comes from successful learning and effectively applying skills (the antidote to ‘low self-esteem’);
• the need for privacy (to reflect on and consolidate our experiences);
• and the need to be ‘stretched’ in what we do, from which comes our sense that life is meaningful.

When some of those needs are identified to be lacking, steps can be taken to find ways of improving the person's life with them so those needs are met.

Obviously that won't work for everyone. Some people will be too far-gone to be expected to change just because their environment is changed. Christian testimonies can also give useful insights into that - illustrations of what works and what doesn't for some people. The testimony of the former gang boss outlines some of that kind of thing, though again, it would have to be simply treated as a pointer to the direction research could take, rather than being treated as an authority on the matter, because it's only one person's opinion.

The testimony also says:

I wanted to know where this Jesus came from. He began to explain this. Anyone who has read the stories in the New Testament will know what a fascinating person Jesus was and still is today. David started off by talking about him as a human version of God, how he had worked so many miracles which could only happen through the holy power of God. On the other hand he suffered like a person - like Nicky Cruz. However he was only filled with the love of salvation.
He always wanted to help and despite this the preacher said: "The human race crucified him!" They were so cruel to him. They did not just want to hurt him but also humiliate him; and then I began to think about how he had felt.

The preacher’s words had hit me hard! He had painted a wonderful picture of Jesus for me.

I had understood how he was ignored and thrown out. I also realised that the people wanted to crucify him; and I could still here my mother’s voice: "You are not my son. I don’t love you. You are the son of Satan!"

I could also hear the voice of society: "Shut him away, kill him, he is sick. He will never amount to anything, he’s too dangerous. The only hope for him is the electric chair!" - Ignored and abandoned! Yes, I knew how Jesus had felt! However there was a big difference between him and me: He was the pure son of God and had sacrificed himself for others.

Nicky Cruz was different! I was a sinner, yes, I was in the clutches of sin and chained by evil.

So he's been faced with the inspirational story of someone who only wanted to help others, and yet was ill-treated and crucified, and yet he's told that this inspirational figure still wants to lovingly change the lives of people other people have rejected - most of them for good reason.

An atheist sociologist/psychologist might be inspired by such testimonies to turn their minds to thinking about how people could be given inspiration on the same theme in secular ways, which they might at least find moving enough so it helps motivate them to change.

For instance, here are a couple of examples of inspirational stories about people who dedicated their lives to trying to improve the lives of prisoners or people on the fringes of the law, and got heavily criticised for it by some, and even threatened with physical attack, and yet they continued to campaign for improvements in other people's welfare.

Here's a quote from a book which is now 100 years old and thus in the public domain, about the life of Josephine Butler, who campaigned tirelessly throughout much of the 19th century for improvements in welfare standards for prostitutes and other disadvantaged women, and faced attack from various quarters for it. The book quotes much of her own writing: Full text of "Josephine E. Butler : an autobiographical memoir"

A public meeting had been arranged for in the theatre. I was with our friends previous to this meeting in a room in a hotel. Already we heard signs of the mob gathering to oppose us. The dangerous portion of this mob was headed and led on by a band of keepers of houses of prostitution in Colchester, who had sworn that we should be defeated and driven from the town. On this occasion the gentlemen who were preparing to go to the meeting left with me all their valuables, watches, &c. I remained alone during the evening. The mob were by this time collected in force in the streets. Their deep-throated yells and oaths, and the horrible words spoken by them, sounded sadly in my ears. I felt more than anything pity for these misguided people.

It must be observed that these were not of the class of honest working people, but chiefly a number of hired roughs and persons directly interested in the maintenance of the vilest of human institutions.

The master of the hotel came in, and said in a whisper, " I must turn down the lights ; and will you, madam, consent to go to an attic which I have, a little apart from the house, and remain there until the mob is quieter, in order that I may tell them truly that you are not in the house ? "

I consented to this for his sake. His words were emphasised at the moment by the crashing in of the window near which I sat, and the noise of heavy stones hurled along the floor, the blows from which I managed to evade.

Our friends returned in about an hour, very pitiful objects, covered with mud, flour, and other more unpleasant things, their clothes torn, but their courage not in the least diminished. Mr. James Stuart, who had come purposely during the intervals of his duties at Cambridge to lend his aid in the conflict, had been roughly handled. Chairs and benches had been flung at him and Dr. Baxter Langley; and a good deal of lint and bandages was quickly in requisition ; but the wounds were not severe. …

COLCHESTER, Nov., 1870.

I have tried several hotels ; each one rejects me after another. At last I came to a respectable Tory hotel, not giving my name. I had gone to bed very tired, and was dropping asleep, when I heard some excitement in the street, and a rap at my door. It was the master of the hotel. He said, " I am sorry, madam, I have a very unpleasant announcement to make."

" Say on," I replied.

He said, " I find you are Mrs. Josephine Butler, and the mob outside have found out that you are here, and have threatened to set fire to the house unless I send you out at once."

I said, " I will go immediately. But how is it that you get rid of me when you know that though I am a Liberal I am practically working into the hands of Colonel Learmont, the Conservative candidate ? "

He replied, " I would most gladly keep you, madam ; undoubtedly your cause is a good one, but there is a party so much incensed against you that my house is not safe while you are in it." He saw that I was very tired, and I think his heart was touched. He said, " I will get you quietly out under another name, and will find some little lodging for you."

I packed up my things, and he sent a servant with me down a little by-street to a small private house of a working-man and his wife.

Another example is Elizabeth Fry who lived a little earlier and was influential in improving conditions for prisoners:

Elizabeth Fry

In 1812 she wrote in her diary 'I fear that my life is slipping away to little purpose'. Not long afterwards, Stephen Grellet came to see her to ask for help. He was a French aristocrat who had gone into exile because of the French Revolution. In America he had become a Quaker. While visiting Britain he had been given permission to visit some prisons, and had been horrified by the conditions he had seen in the women's prison in Newgate. He found prisoners lying on the bare stone floors, and some newborn babies without clothing. He went to Elizabeth Fry, who immediately sent out for warm material and asked other women Friends to help her make clothes for the babies. ...

This was the start of a period of Elizabeth Fry's life when she had extraordinary influence for a woman of her day. In 1818 she was asked to give evidence to a Committee of the House of Common on London prisons, the first woman to do so. Her experience of Quaker Business Meetings meant she was able to give her evidence clearly and well. She described in detail the lives of the prisoners, and recommended that women, not men, should look after women prisoners, and stressed her belief in the importance of useful employment. …

At various times she faced criticism. ... The local authorities grumbled becaused the new Prison Act of 1823 (which contained several ideas of Elizabeth's) meant that they had to spend more money on prisons. Some authorities refused to allow ladies to visit their prisons because they did not want them meddling. She was especially sensitive to the criticism from Friends who thought that she valued public esteem too much, and that she was neglecting her family. Some of her children married non-Quakers, in fact only one of her children remained a Quaker. In 1828 Fry's Bank crashed, which led to her husband being 'disowned' (excluded from membership) by the Society of Friends beause he had put other people's money at risk. Elizabeth was accused by some of the public of using money from her husband's bank for her charitable work. She felt the disapproval of Friends and others very much. The mood of the country was changing, too, and when she gave evidence in 1832 to another House of Commons Committee they chose to ignore what she had to say about the damaging effects of solitary confinement. …

'Through her personal courage and involvement, Elizabeth Fry alerted the nations of Europe to the cruelty and filth in the prisons and revealed the individual human faces behind the prison bars.

It may be that most budding delinquents wouldn't be moved by inspirational stories of people who cared for criminal types; but exposing some to the telling of such stories could perhaps be tried as an experiment with small samples, to see if there might be any promise in it, in combination with things like separating them from peers who are a bad influence on them and getting them involved in harmless activities where they have the opportunity to build up a whole new set of friends, and other things.

Naturally, anyone undertaking research into what might work should study rehabilitation approaches already in use, and consider that any new approaches should be tried in combination with ones that have proven to be beneficial. Studies have been done on what works best in the rehabilitation of prisoners to cut down the re-offending rate, and what isn't so effective.

One prison that doesn't seem to have featured in the studies, and yet gained media interest in the 1990s, was a prison that was run on entirely different lines than most prisons. An article about it was written called A Model Prison

Yet McKean, by several measures, may well be the most successful medium-security prison in the country. Badly overcrowded, housing a growing number of violent criminals, it costs taxpayers approximately $15,370 a year for each inmate. That is below the average for prisons of its type, and far below the overall federal average of $21,350. It is about two thirds of what many state prisons cost. And the incident record since McKean opened, in 1989, reads like a blank slate: No escapes. No homicides. No sexual assaults. No suicides. In six years there have been three serious assaults on staff members and six recorded assaults on inmates. State prisons of comparable size often see that many assaults in a single week. The American Correctional Society has given McKean
one of its highest possible ratings. No recidivism studies have been conducted on its former inmates, but senior staff members claim that McKean parolees
return to prison far less often than those from other institutions, and a local parole officer agrees. According to the Princeton University criminologist
John DiIulio, "McKean is probably the best-managed prison in the country. And that has everything to do with a warden named Dennis Luther." ...

Education may be the most effective way to lower prison costs. DiIulio, who is well known in Washington for his pessimism about rehabilitation, claims, "In some prison systems cost-effective management is possible only because programs keep prisoners busy, with less supervision than you'd need otherwise. Especially with respect to certain types of prison educational programs, you save money by hiring fewer officers in the short run and reducing recidivism in the long run." ...

Numerous studies have shown a correspondence between educational programs and reduced recidivism rates. There is no question that college-level programs at Roosevelt University, in Chicago; Boston University; and Ball State, in Indiana, have had remarkable success with inmates, many of whom have gone on to work in social services and treatment programs themselves. And federal surveys have found a significant difference between those prisoners who participated in classes and those who did not. The trouble with all these studies is that they do not distinguish between inmates for whom education made a real difference and those who were already unlikely to be sent back to prison. The best way to eliminate this problem of self-selection would be to offer education to
prisoners at random, retain an identical control group that did not receive it, and then monitor the progress of the two groups after parole.

Whatever its effect on recidivism rates, education clearly makes prisons easier and less expensive to run. Prison costs are rapidly spinning out of control. ...
 
What is it about this board?...are the mods so afraid of being seen as biased by posters who have a religious "bent" that they will allow this "junk" to be posted without any call for evidence?

What a load of mindless religious crap.
 
What is it about this board?...are the mods so afraid of being seen as biased by posters who have a religious "bent" that they will allow this "junk" to be posted without any call for evidence?

What a load of mindless religious crap.

What a sad response.

We all need to belong. I would rather that a child "belong" to a family or to a Christian church than a gang.
 
What is it about this board?...are the mods so afraid of being seen as biased by posters who have a religious "bent" that they will allow this "junk" to be posted without any call for evidence?

What a load of mindless religious crap.

The most mindless thing of all is that you clearly didn't read it, hence you crashingly missed the point. It seems to me that the mods are even more biased than you think, since they've allowed your response to stay on the board and show up how dim-witted your "arguments" can be. :p Read what I wrote again, properly this time, and provided you have the intelligence to take in the arguments, you'll cringe in embarrassment at your first response.

For anyone who might have a more thoughtful outlook on life, the main premise of my argument was that Atheist social workers/psychologists etc. can possibly learn from testimonies about what made people who gave up violent lifestyles or other ones where they were doing themselves or others harm when they became Christians, about what needs they had in their lives that attracted them to Christianity, and what had made them adopt the harmful lifestyles. Some of the information they glean might be useful in informing secular policies with no overtones of Christianity at all. To give a simple example, if they find a number of people become Christians partly because it makes them feel loved and secure, it might highlight the attention needed to make an increase in security and supportive friendship part of any secular response to the problem of delinquency, by, for instance, separating someone at risk of joining a gang from old peers and giving them the opportunity to join in with harmless activities where they'll enjoy the new lifestyle and build up a whole new set of friends who are a better influence on them. I specified more than once that anything they learned from Christian testimonies would be a "pointer to the direction research could take", not an end in itself.

Of course, that doesn't mean anyone should actually go out of their way to make an effort to learn from Christian testimonies. I mean, take this article for example - it's based on books with no Christian leanings at all, some of which actually recommend the same approach to teenagers getting into delinquency: Raising Difficult Teenagers.
 
Last edited:
So being a Christian actually helps people stop being violent, stop drinking and stop doing drugs? I guess that explains the absence of battered wives, alcoholics and drug addicts in the USA, doesn't it?
However, to Baby Nemesis they are probably just proof of the efficiency of atheists ...
And now we are all waiting for more anecdotal evidence of the wonderful contributions of Christianity to the world, i.e. "Christian testimonies".
 
Last edited:
What is it about this board?...are the mods so afraid of being seen as biased by posters who have a religious "bent" that they will allow this "junk" to be posted without any call for evidence?

What a load of mindless religious crap.

What a sad response.

We all need to belong. I would rather that a child "belong" to a family or to a Christian church than a gang.

What a sad response, Gord! So the only alternative to the "mindless religious crap" is to join a gang??! (Or is it the other way round? That the only alternative to gangs is Christianity?)
Well, I guess that to those of you who seem to think that atheism is evil, you would rather see a child belong to a gang ...

(And to R.A.F: What is the point of your quotation marks: "bent" and "junk"?)
 
Last edited:
What is it about this board?...are the mods so afraid of being seen as biased by posters who have a religious "bent" that they will allow this "junk" to be posted without any call for evidence?

What a load of mindless religious crap.

You must be very cold-hearted if you cannot be persuaded by this brilliant evidence to give up your evil ideas:


You still aren't moved enough? You shouldn't let your knowledge of all the gang bosses that remain Christian and violent distract you!
But how about this:

The boy's behaviour improved a lot after that. He stopped stealing, and became obedient to his parents and teachers. He joined the basketball team. At the next therapy session, the basketball coach came along, as well as the people who'd been there before. He said the boy was making very good progress. They all praised the boy because of the change in his bhehaviour. The mother even baked a cake to thank them all for their help.

I have to admit that baking a cake is much too heathen for my tastes, but consider the mother to be a tool of divine intervention rewarding the reformed devil boy for mending his ways ... :)

If you still aren't moved to tears, I bet you are evil! :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom