Religion's value questioned

So being a Christian actually helps people stop being violent, stop drinking and stop doing drugs? I guess that explains the absence of battered wives, alcoholics and drug addicts in the USA, doesn't it?
However, to Baby Nemesis they are probably just proof of the efficiency of atheists ...
And now we are all waiting for more anecdotal evidence of the wonderful contributions of Christianity to the world, i.e. "Christian testimonies".

This thread is my home now, and no matter what you say, you're not going to persuade me to pack up and leave. :)

Hey, what a crackingly good example you've provided of what can happen when someone pays barely any attention whatsoever to what's going on in the thread he started!

Um, didn't I address something similar to this question two pages ago? I think so. But since you seem to have forgotten, I'm just going to have to do it again, aren't I! What a shame! :)

Of course, I wouldn't have to do any such thing if you didn't frame all your arguments in terms of such polar opposites. This is what your style of argument seems to be based on:

Either one is a militant atheist fighting the good fight, or one is a dreadful Christian fanatic, rampaging around spreading evil Christian propaganda and wishing all atheists into shame-faced silence!

Either one is a good Communist fighting for the cause, or one is a rampant Capitalist who'd sell their own grandmother before doing anything to help the workers!

Either one is a fine upstanding evolutionist speaking out boldly for the cause, or one is a militant creationist who will link to propaganda by their favourite creationist at every opportunity. And everything they link to that might just have a creationist bent is obviously something by their favourite one, even if they haven't actually said they agree with what the article says.

Either one has the correct ideology and knows that schools are all out to stunt the development of their students in order to fill unskilled jobs in factories to feed the Capitalist system, or one is a hopeless incompetent who knows nothing of any worth!

Either one is ideologically correct enough to know the police are all out to oppress the masses to bolster the Capitalist system, or one is in league with them and cannot be trusted!

Goodness this is fun!

But the point is that you have a black-and-white, all-or-nothing arguing style. You can't seem to perceive grey areas. It seems that to you, everything is either one polar opposite or the other.

You don't seem to be able to get a good grasp of what your opponent is actually saying. I link to some testimonies of how people actually state in no uncertain terms that they gave up criminality or other harmful behaviour when they became Christians, and never mind what comments I make about them, you draw the conclusion that I imagine that a Christian testimony is the ultimate proof of the power of the grand institution of Christianity to salvage the world.

To get back to your original points, didn't the infamous and fearsome post 76 disabuse you of the idea that one can be a criminal and a true Christian at the same time? I mean, it should have shown you that just because 507289573923750372 people in America call themselves Christians, it doesn't mean they all follow New Testament doctrine, which is supposed to be the whole idea of being a Christian. If they did, then there wouldn't be 275392613845863 of them out there beating their wives, or 2736503561 of them out there committing other crimes, because they'd obey teaching that says they shouldn't do any such thing.

I suspect anyone who actually chooses to become a Christian will be more likely to try to follow such teaching than people who are born into Christianity and raised not really knowing or caring that much about it and yet thinking of themselves as Christians, because those who've chosen it for themselves will be more likely to want to investigate it and be committed to it when they sign up.

Naturally they might need a bit of help to follow the teaching. What do you think all the self-help articles linked to in my signature are for? :D :p
 
What a sad response, Gord! So the only alternative to the "mindless religious crap" is to join a gang??! (Or is it the other way round? That the only alternative to gangs is Christianity?)
Well, I guess that to those of you who seem to think that atheism is evil, you would rather see a child belong to a gang ...

(And to R.A.F: What is the point of your quotation marks: "bent" and "junk"?)

What an amazingly befuddled response to two stalwarts of atheism! :D This is either a language barrier thing, or it's a case of Dann somehow seriously failing to comprehend what's been going on in this thread for some other mysterious reason. Emotions instantly accelerate to too-high levels to be able to take it in, immediately on impact when brain registers the word "Christianity"? Too lazy to read it? Who knows. But here we have more black-and-white thinking - or is he this time merely unfairly attributing it to others?

It's a pity he didn't notice before commenting that I did in fact link to a lengthy self-help article for parents raising teenagers that I specified had no Christian overtones, which is partly about a few ways of weaning children away from friends involved in gangs that some self-help book recommends: Parenting Difficult Teenagers. ... It's especially for atheists who obviously have no hope of adopting the conventional approach consisting of just exposing their teenager to Christianity and watching them inevitably transform in an instant into good little conformists, as quickly as a jack-in-a-box will suddenly burst out of its box into the sunlight - Ping! :D ... Ah, the power of Christianity! Actually it can even transform bad-taste haircuts into good conformist ones in an instant! Just say "I believe!" and whoosh! Your haircut, your clothing, your manners and your thoughts are all transformed in a split second. ... No hang on, I've been reading too many Harry Potter books.

... Actually, anyone who wants to can read the article really. :D

Now I'm going to really confuse Dann. Just what, I wonder, will he make of my having waved the banner for atheists in this thread here a few days ago! And what will he make of my defence of atheists in This one?! Actually, Dann might find what I said in that one especially shocking and offensive. ... That scandallous quote about the ...
 
This thread is my home now, and no matter what you say, you're not going to persuade me to pack up and leave. :)

Welcome home to my thread, then!

Either one is a militant atheist fighting the good fight, or one is a dreadful Christian fanatic, rampaging around spreading evil Christian propaganda and wishing all atheists into shame-faced silence!

Either one is a good Communist fighting for the cause, or one is a rampant Capitalist who'd sell their own grandmother before doing anything to help the workers!

Either one is a fine upstanding evolutionist speaking out boldly for the cause, or one is a militant creationist who will link to propaganda by their favourite creationist at every opportunity. And everything they link to that might just have a creationist bent is obviously something by their favourite one, even if they haven't actually said they agree with what the article says.

Either one has the correct ideology and knows that schools are all out to stunt the development of their students in order to fill unskilled jobs in factories to feed the Capitalist system, or one is a hopeless incompetent who knows nothing of any worth!

Either one is ideologically correct enough to know the police are all out to oppress the masses to bolster the Capitalist system, or one is in league with them and cannot be trusted!

Goodness this is fun!

It's good that you're able to enjoy your own straw man.

You don't seem to be able to get a good grasp of what your opponent is actually saying. I link to some testimonies of how people actually state in no uncertain terms that they gave up criminality or other harmful behaviour when they became Christians, and never mind what comments I make about them, you draw the conclusion that I imagine that a Christian testimony is the ultimate proof of the power of the grand institution of Christianity to salvage the world.

To get back to your original points, didn't the infamous and fearsome post 76 disabuse you of the idea that one can be a criminal and a true Christian at the same time? I mean, it should have shown you that just because 507289573923750372 people in America call themselves Christians, it doesn't mean they all follow New Testament doctrine, which is supposed to be the whole idea of being a Christian. If they did, then there wouldn't be 275392613845863 of them out there beating their wives, or 2736503561 of them out there committing other crimes, because they'd obey teaching that says they shouldn't do any such thing.

I suspect anyone who actually chooses to become a Christian will be more likely to try to follow such teaching than people who are born into Christianity and raised not really knowing or caring that much about it and yet thinking of themselves as Christians, because those who've chosen it for themselves will be more likely to want to investigate it and be committed to it when they sign up.

Naturally they might need a bit of help to follow the teaching. What do you think all the self-help articles linked to in my signature are for? :D :p

This is what we usually refer to as the no true Christian argument.

And now for some more Christian testimonies and Bible quotations?
 
Ah, the power of Christianity! Actually it can even transform bad-taste haircuts into good conformist ones in an instant! Just say "I believe!" and whoosh! Your haircut, your clothing, your manners and your thoughts are all transformed in a split second. ... No hang on, I've been reading too many Harry Potter books.

... Actually, anyone who wants to can read the article really. :D

Sorry, but all your Bible quotations, Christian testimonies and other anecdotal evidence just don't cut it against actual research:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=46293
http://www.randi.org/jr/200510/102105herbs.html#14
http://moses.creighton.edu/JRS/pdf/2005-11.pdf
 
Dann said:
It's good that you're able to enjoy your own straw man.

It wasn't a straw man. Perhaps a bit hyperbolic, but you do seem to see things in terms of polar opposites. Instead of coolly evaluating arguments and presenting a carefully-considered critique of them, you tend to hastily jump in with a knee-jerk response that simplifies and distorts what your opponent is saying and condemns it with a view which is a polar opposite of it.

And now you want more Bible quotations and Christian testimonies? Ah, how cool is That!!! :p

Dann said:
And now for some more Christian testimonies and Bible quotations?

Yes, OK: Here are links to Thousands of Christian testimonies!! Thousands!

Obviously I haven't read most of them and some might be bunkum, but it sounds as if there's a lot of good revival-rousing inspirational stuff in there! Hooray!

Thanks for asking me to link to those. :)

As for the Bible quotations you requested, Thanks for asking me to put more of those on here as well. :D I'll be happy to oblige, naturally.

I think I'll take this opportunity to refute your "No true Scotsman/Christian" accusation about my argument. You dispute what I said about how no true Christian would go around committing crime, beating their wife etc. Well, it all depends on how you define the word Christian. But if you define it, as I specified, and as I'll illustrate is most reasonable, as someone who makes efforts to obey the teaching in the New Testament that prescribes in a fair bit of specific detail what is and is not Christian behaviour, then to say no true Christian will habitually do such things is absolutely correct. Here's some proof. I can give you much more if you want. :) Of course, if you'd read the fearsome, notorious and dread-inspiring post 76, this might not have been necessary. :) Never mind. It'll be good:

Galatians chapter 5 (NLT)

19 When you follow the desires of your sinful nature, your lives will produce these evil results: sexual immorality, impure thoughts, eagerness for lustful pleasure, 20 idolatry, participation in demonic activities, hostility, quarreling, jealousy, outbursts of anger, selfish ambition, divisions, the feeling
that everyone is wrong except those in your own little group, 21 envy, drunkenness, wild parties, and other kinds of sin. Let me tell you again, as I have before, that anyone living that sort of life will not inherit the Kingdom of God.

Hebrews chapter 12 (NLT)

14 Try to live in peace with everyone, and seek to live a clean and holy life, for those who are not holy will not see the Lord.

1 Corinthians chapter 6 (NIV)





9 Do you not know that the wicked will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: Neither the sexually immoral nor idolaters nor adulterers nor male prostitutes nor homosexual offenders 10 nor thieves nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God.





11 And that is what some of you were. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God.

Colossians chapter 3 (GWT)

5 Therefore, put to death whatever is worldly in you: your sexual sin, perversion, passion, lust, and greed (which is the same thing as worshiping wealth). 6 It is because of these sins that God's anger comes on those who refuse to obey him. 7 You used to live that kind of sinful life.

8 Also get rid of your anger, hot tempers, hatred, cursing, obscene language, and all similar sins. 9 Don't lie to each other. You've gotten rid of the person you used to be and the life you used to live, 10 and you've become a new person. This new person is continually renewed in knowledge to be like its Creator.

Romans chapter 1 (TEV)

18 God's anger is revealed from heaven against all the sin and evil of the people whose evil ways prevent the truth from being known. ...

28 Because those people refuse to keep in mind the true knowledge about God, he has given them over to corrupted minds, so that they do the things that they should not do. 29 They are filled with all kinds of wickedness, evil, greed, and vice; they are full of jealousy, murder, fighting, deceit, and malice. They gossip 30 and speak evil of one another; they are hateful to God, insolent, proud, and boastful; they think of more ways to do evil; they disobey their parents; 31 they have no conscience; they do not keep their promises, and they show no kindness or pity for others. 32 They know that God's law says that people who live in this way deserve death. Yet, not only do they continue to do these very things, but they even approve of others who do them.

Romans chapter 2 (NLT)

1 You may be saying, "What terrible people you have been talking about!" But you are just as bad, and you have no excuse! When you say they are wicked and should be punished, you are condemning yourself, for you do these very same things. 2 And we know that God, in his justice, will punish anyone who does such things. 3 Do you think that God will judge and condemn others for doing them and not judge you when you do them, too? 4 Don't you realize how kind, tolerant, and patient God is with you? Or don't you care? Can't you see how kind he has been in giving you time to turn from your sin? 5 But no, you won't listen. So you are storing up terrible punishment for yourself because of your stubbornness in refusing to turn from your sin. For there is going to come a day of judgment when God, the just judge of all the world, 6 will judge all people according to what they have done. 7 He will give eternal life to those who persist in doing what is good, seeking after the glory and honor and immortality that God offers. 8 But he will pour out his anger and wrath on those who live for themselves, who refuse to obey the truth and practice evil deeds. 9 There will be trouble and calamity for everyone who keeps on sinning - for the Jew first and also for the Gentile. 10 But there will be glory and honor and peace from God for all who do good - for the Jew first and also for the Gentile. 11 For God does not show favoritism. 16 The day will surely come when God, by Jesus Christ, will judge everyone's secret life. This is my message.

The Bible says Jesus himself said:

Luke chapter 12 (TEV)

35 "Be ready for whatever comes, dressed for action ... 36 like servants who are waiting for their master to come back from a wedding feast. When he comes and knocks, they will open the door for him at once. 37 How happy are those servants whose master finds them awake and ready when he returns! I tell you, he will take off his coat, have them sit down, and will wait on them. 38 How happy they are if he finds them ready, even if he should come at midnight or even later! 39 And you can be sure that if the owner of a house knew the time when the thief would come, he would not let the thief break into his house. 40 And you, too, must be ready, because the Son of Man will come at an hour when you are not expecting him."

41 Peter said, "Lord, does this parable apply to us, or do you mean it for everyone?"

42 The Lord answered, "Who, then, is the faithful and wise servant? He is the one that his master will put in charge, to run the household and give the other servants their share of the food at the proper time. 43 How happy that servant is if his master finds him doing this when he comes home! 44 Indeed, I tell you, the master will put that servant in charge of all his property. 45 But if that servant says to himself that his master is taking a long time to come back and if he begins to beat the other servants, both the men and the women, and eats and drinks and gets drunk, 46 then the master will come back one day when the servant does not expect him and at a time he does not know. The master will cut him in pieces and make him share the fate of the disobedient.

Sounds as if Jesus was condemning wife beaters to hell there in a parable.

Really, do you honestly think it's possible to be a Christian and not only violate commands that say Christians shouldn't behave in particular ways, but even behave in ways the New Testament says will exclude people from the Kingdom of God?

If so, what on earth is your definition of a Christian?

I'll get to the rest of what you said later. It still sounds as if you're missing points at every turn. With that many misses, it's just as well you're not on our cricket team - if you batted for us and missed that many balls, Australians would be celebrating you as a hero who guaranteed them the ashes every time. :D ... Or something. Actually I've got no idea what I'm talking about when it comes to cricket. :)
 
No reason to thank me, Babe Nem. You seemed to need to get that out of your system.

And I'm quite impressed by the wisdom of Jesus:
"And you can be sure that if the owner of a house knew the time when the thief would come, he would not let the thief break into his house."
I expected him to ask the house owner to burn another sheik or something. I guess burglar alarms would have been a little anachronistic back then.

A Christian is somebody who believes in Christianity.
 
Dann said:
No reason to thank me, Babe Nem. You seemed to need to get that out of your system.

Well, if you ever suspect I'm feeling the need to do that again, just say so, and I will. :D

Dann said:
And I'm quite impressed by the wisdom of Jesus:
"And you can be sure that if the owner of a house knew the time when the thief would come, he would not let the thief break into his house."
I expected him to ask the house owner to burn another sheik or something. I guess burglar alarms would have been a little anachronistic back then.

Didn't sheiks only come into being with the invention of Islam? ... Hey, you Are a Christian after all! You credit Jesus with the ability to prophesy 600 years into the future! Halleluia! Congratulations! :p :D

What you said reminds me of something. Now, I'm going to give you a lecture on hyperbolic language in the Bible: :)

(Well allright, it's someone else's work)

The bit you reminded me of is at the end. If you don't want any more lectures, you'd better try not to remind me of anything else. :D

... More examples may be found from Rihbany's The Syrian Christ [108ff]. I think this quote from Rihbany is helpful:

Code:
A case may be overstated or understated, not necessarily for the purpose of deceiving, but to impress the hearer with the significance or insignificance of it. If a sleeper who has been expected to rise at sunrise should oversleep and need to be awakened, say half an hour or an hour later than the appointed time, he is then aroused with the call, 'Arise, it is noon already...' Of a strong and brave man it is said, 'He can split the earth.' The Syrians suffer
from no misunderstanding in such cases. They discern each other's meaning.

Rihbany offers other examples of such sayings from daily life. Here is a welcome he received from an old friend when he came to his home: "You have extremely honored me by coming into my abode. I am not worthy of it. This house is yours; you may burn it if you wish. My children are also at your disposal; I would sacrifice them all for your pleasure."

The Westerner who hears this might well be shocked and offended, but what is being said behind the verbiage is no more than "I am delighted to see you; please make yourself at home." Jesus' pledge of faith moving mountains is of the same order (and Rihbany for one takes Ingersoll mildly to task for reading the passage literally -- noting that we have no evidence that Jesus or his disciples ever took up on such a literal offer).

Dann said:
A Christian is somebody who believes in ...

What, the Ruthlesscriticism website has replaced the Bible as the Christian guidebook? So that article you linked to is the Word of God according to Ruthlesscriticism? :D So it could really be rephrased in terms of commandments:

Hear, oh Christians, these are the Ten ... oh sorry, the Eleven Commandments which you must obey:

1. "Thou art not allowed to be too critical of faith itself or the Lord it is devoted to. For thou wilt place thy entire honor in thy faith. As a devout Christian, thou wilt demand that people refrain from being blasphemous, on the strange argument that faith is the innermost and deepest interest which thou wilt pursue in thy thoughts devoted to God. Thou wilt not allow thy belief to be belittled, and when this happens anyway, thou wilt be offended."

2. "Thou wilt even gather proof from thine own person and deduce God's existence directly from thy belief in God. Thou wilt readily perform this “deduction” functionally: Thou must then put forward what thy faith accomplishes – consolation, help, orientation, protection against despair, etc. – as an argument, i.e. thou wilt simply announce thy need for God because God fulfils it."

3. "Thou shalt mobilise thy imagination solely for the purpose of arriving at an extremely bad judgment of thyself by envisaging a highest maker and judge. Whereas God is omnipotent and all-knowing and determines the course of the world eternally and omni-presently, thou shalt make a considerable decision about thyself by choosing to believe in this God and entering a relationship of voluntary servitude to him. Thou shalt charge thyself with thy mortality, consider thyself powerless and ignorant and accuse thyself in all seriousness of only being human."

4. "If thou, a sinner, art doing well, thou shalt pray to God and thank him for the undeserved mercy, for the divine reward; if thou art doing badly, thou dost know this is the fair punishment for thy human worthlessness and therefore thou shalt ask to be given a little piece of the giant cake of divine love in spite of everything."

5. "In all vicissitudes of life, thou shalt interpret what thou art going along with, with great self-assurance, from the point of view of the relationship to God thou hast set up for thyself. And this self-assurance, this effect which thou wilt ascribe so insistently to thy faith – consolation, courage and strength instead of despair and anger about one's earthly brothers who give one such a hard time – is the key to the self-righteousness thou wilt be capable of."

6. "Thou shalt make a quite absolute condemnation of thine own human nature which originates solely in thy relationship to God. Whoever realizes that there is something he does not know or cannot do, becomes self-critical in a rational manner and sets about eliminating the deficiencies which bother him. Whoever attributes his failures to his own inability and is ashamed, runs around with a bad conscience, an inferiority complex or even something worse. But as for thyself, thou shalt condemn thy human nature and consider its striving to be in vain because thou only hast a raison d'etre as a creature and tool of God, hast thought up self-accusation as a sinner as a way of living with thy bad conscience. Everything thou does, everything which is done with and around thyself, wilt either dissolve into the vain work of man – and man's efforts are evil from his youth according to Moses 1 3:21 – or wilt have its sense in God's inscrutable ways. Usually both."

7. "Unlike the self-critical individual who seeks the reasons for his failure in himself and around him; unlike the type who deals with himself psychologically and considers himself to be a washout, thou shalt proceed very thoroughly. Thou shalt yearn to have thy self-accusation understood as an attitude all other people ought to adopt as well, and thou shalt go peddling this attitude like a missionary. And every time thine appeal falls on deaf ears thou canst enjoy the satisfaction of at least exclusively admitting the sinning nature that everyone has. Thou shalt know how to distinguish thyself by thine self-abasement, and wilt be familiar with the stories in the New as well as the Old Testament in which the Godless are hit by some adversity or other much harder and more fairly than the Children of God."

8. "Thou shalt never be so presumptuous as to point out, “all by thyself,” the very worldly economic and political causes of anything thou art not pleased with. The faith in thy Lord, which dost not require any proof and dost not allow for any refutation either, wilt replace for thyself both the knowledge and the will which are necessary to take the wire-pullers of this world to task. Thou shalt take for granted that thou only producest rubbish, being a sinner, but can never do anything wrong, being a religious sinner, as long as thou art not so insolent as to want to change anything about the way the world works."

9. "Thine intellect must achieve more than that of a heathen. On the one hand, it is required just the same for taking care of earthly matters as that of anyone else who must work and budget, marry and vote, sometimes go to war; on the other hand, it must master the additional task of interpreting all the lousy experiences of earthly existence as being the work and will of God. And even though the efforts of thine earthly journey wilt keep thy demand for an absolute spirit alive, under which thou wilt be safe in spite of everything, they wilt also fill thine self with doubts as to the certainty of thy faith."

10. "Thou, inexperienced in the logic of the salvation, wilt keep on following thy materialistic imagination and imagining eternal life as a collection of all earthly pleasures minus the trouble that goes along with them down here …"

11. Thou must even watch out, when celebrating the insight that thine human nature is not worth much, that thine avowal does not contrast too greatly with what thou dost do outside the service, and above all exhibit the sinner attitude without the obvious wish to distinguish thyself in all thine humbleness (Jesus himself already commented on this expertly!). When thou thinkest of it, thou canst have thine self humbled like crazy during the prayers, scolded in the sermon and consoled and uplifted by the singing. When the sacraments are executed thou wilt then swell up into thine highest form. Thou wilt partake of God's grace – and must again watch out like the dickens that thou dost not imagine thou couldst procure thyself anything by participating in the hocus-pocus."

Those, oh Christian, are the Eleven Commandments which God hast decreed that thou must follow.

... Hey, it's funny I should be talking about hyperbole and then read that article.
 
Sorry, but all your Bible quotations, Christian testimonies and other anecdotal evidence just don't cut it against actual research:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=46293
http://www.randi.org/jr/200510/102105herbs.html#14
http://moses.creighton.edu/JRS/pdf/2005-11.pdf

Why don't you take your medicine - i.e. read what you're responding to sometimes?! :p

I have never in my life made the claim that religion is the cure for all ills, yet here you are, for some strange reason linking me to a shocking expose on how America is the most violent country in the entirety of the universe and history, along with being the most religious, which apparently proves religion is a terrible thing that can never do anybody any good. Shocking, I tell you! Why you want to keep picking on America, I don't know! Still, I can't talk, since I did something very similar just the other day! Just look at this!! It's all about how while all those dastardly religionists are out committing crime all over America, almost every good upstanding atheist is keeping out of trouble! ... I have to say my analysis of the situation is somewhat more sophisticated than your knee-jerk protests about how religion is the cause of all evil. I think if you look, you'll just have to agree! ... Hey, why don't I requote it!:

... It probably wouldn't be possible to find reliable data on the percentage of crime committed by theists vs atheists. But there is research that has found that the proportion of theists in prison is very much higher than atheists, certainly in America. In fact, the statistics say atheists are a very small minority of the prison population indeed. Here are some statistics.

That doesn't, naturally, mean religion causes crime. There's also a correlation between poverty and crime in America. And most prisoners will come from poorer backgrounds.

The statistics do suggest atheists aren't any more immoral than theists.

However, one reason the statistics don't tell the whole story is that just because a person labels themselves as belonging to a particular religion, it doesn't mean they have a conviction that that religion's true. They may be a cultural follower - having been born into it and thus assuming they're a member, but not actually following the religion's precepts, never having really thought about it much. However, in a country where religion is the norm, many atheists
will likely be people at least educated enough to have given the matter quite a bit of thought; and on average, the more educated a person is, the less
likely they are to end up in prison.

Also, I've heard that in America, many criminals in prison might declare themselves theists because it makes a good impression on the parole board.

So the statistics would need to be analysed to give a clear picture.

I still don't expect you to get the point, since you haven't got it in all this time. So I'll draw a comparison with divorce rates. Divorce rates are apparently a fair bit higher among theists in America than they are among atheists. Well, :yikes: given what I've just cited, that's hardly a surprise! But Wait! Look at This! Divorce Rates and Religion (denomination and participation level).

That article makes the truly scandallous claim that among couples who actually take their faith seriously - the indications looked for being how often they pray and read the Bible together - the divorce rate is only about 1%! Much lower than that of atheists, or those shocking theists out committing crimes all over the place!

I still don't expect you to get the point, since you haven't ... oh well, never mind. :)

I couldn't read the PDF article you linked to, BTW, because it crashed my PDF reader before I could even read a word! You see what those evil atheist PDF articles can do?! Link me to a nice Christian article and I expect it'll behave itself! :D ... Either that, or if that PDF file's available as an HTML document, perhaps you could give me a link to that instead?
 
You must be very cold-hearted if you cannot be persuaded by this brilliant evidence to give up your evil ideas:



You still aren't moved enough? You shouldn't let your knowledge of all the gang bosses that remain Christian and violent distract you!
But how about this:



I have to admit that baking a cake is much too heathen for my tastes, but consider the mother to be a tool of divine intervention rewarding the reformed devil boy for mending his ways ... :)

If you still aren't moved to tears, I bet you are evil! :)

You know, it's funny you should say this, because at the very same time, there are probably Christians out there, outraged at me for writing that post and a subsequent one, because of what they have interpreted as me daring to propose a way in which atheists can subvert potential new recruits to Christianity into remaining atheists because they're getting all their needs met without feeling the need to turn to Christianity after all! ... "What?" you say.

... Oh, did you miss that? Pity. Perhaps you also miss it when a train rumbles overhead when you're standing under a railway bridge? :p

... Well, you must have been too busy thinking up ways to belittle the very thought that religion can do anyone any good to have noticed. Never mind. It's still there if you ever want to go back and look for it.

But this is quite an astounding claim:

Dann to R.A.F. said:
You still aren't moved enough? You shouldn't let your knowledge of all the gang bosses that remain Christian and violent distract you!

You clearly didn't let the actual point I was making distract you from powering on tirelessly with building your straw man. Still, I'm intrigued: Just how do you know that R.A.F. actually has a knowledge of lots of gang bosses who are Christians? Just what are you suggesting about his character, you evil slanderer! :p ... Hey, if you're a slanderer, and he hangs around with gangs, ... ... well, surely a good upstanding atheist would never do any of those things, since I've discerned from your posts that they're both Christian activities. ... The only logical conclusion is that despite your bellows of protest, ... you are both dyed-in-the-wool, militant, enthusiastic Christians! You've been lying to us all this time, haven't you! :D And that's also how you can have so crashingly missed all the points I was making in your rush to belittle ... what? Christianity? Oh hang on, something doesn't make sense here. ... Aha! Yes it does; it's all part of your dastardly cunning deception isn't it, you shameful militant Christian fanatic! You're trying to hide the truth! :p ... Why? ... Um, ... I haven't quite managed to work that one out yet. But I will! :D
 
You know, it's funny you should say this, because at the very same time, there are probably Christians out there, outraged at me for writing that post and a subsequent one, because of what they have interpreted as me daring to propose a way in which atheists can subvert potential new recruits to Christianity into remaining atheists because they're getting all their needs met without feeling the need to turn to Christianity after all! ...

I'm sure that you'll be able to convince them of your good intentions if you spam them with enough atheist testimonies ...

"What?" you say.

... Oh, did you miss that? Pity. Perhaps you also miss it when a train rumbles overhead when you're standing under a railway bridge? :p

I say "What?" Where do I say "What?"???

Oh, it's just a continuation of your previous straw man, now assuming the form of a fictitious dialogue with yourself.
(Is that how you guys manage to persuade yourselves that you're having actual conversations with your god?)
 
Dann said:
I'm sure that you'll be able to convince them of your good intentions if you spam them with enough atheist testimonies ...

You know, I'm curious: Why is it that not only do you not get the point of most of the things I've said in this entire thread - including the things you could most use to your advantage - but it seems you actually don't want to get the point. It's as if you have a rampantly masochistic desire to make yourself look like as big a fool as you possibly can. Why are you doing that, or would you prefer to leave me guessing? It's as if you want to come across as a Mr Bean-type character. Do you? Well, you certainly manage to provide entertainment by trying. Congratulations.

Dann said:
I say "What"? Where do I say "What"???

Oh, it's just a continuation of your previous straw man, now assuming the form of a fictitious dialogue with yourself.
(Is that how you guys manage to persuade yourselves that you're having actual conversations with your god?)

Are you deliberately missing the irony in accusing me of a straw man fallacy when in fact you're the one guilty of that? Perhaps it's a cheeky little rousse you like to play for fun? What a cheeky little monkey!
 
You know, I'm curious: Why is it that not only do you not get the point of most of the things I've said in this entire thread - including the things you could most use to your advantage - but it seems you actually don't want to get the point. It's as if you have a rampantly masochistic desire to make yourself look like as big a fool as you possibly can. Why are you doing that, or would you prefer to leave me guessing? It's as if you want to come across as a Mr Bean-type character. Do you? Well, you certainly manage to provide entertainment by trying. Congratulations.

Are you deliberately missing the irony in accusing me of a straw man fallacy when in fact you're the one guilty of that? Perhaps it's a cheeky little rousse you like to play for fun? What a cheeky little monkey!

The most mindless thing of all is that you clearly didn't read it, hence you crashingly missed the point. It seems to me that the mods are even more biased than you think, since they've allowed your response to stay on the board and show up how dim-witted your "arguments" can be. :p Read what I wrote again, properly this time, and provided you have the intelligence to take in the arguments, you'll cringe in embarrassment at your first response.

I sure does upset Babe Nem's Christian patience and empathy that her addressees don't buy into her teachings, doesn't it? Since she's so convinced that her message is good something must be seriously wrong with a person who either points out the absurdities or restricts himself to declaring that they are insufferable drivel.
 
I sure does upset Babe Nem's Christian patience and empathy that her addressees don't buy into her teachings, doesn't it? Since she's so convinced that her message is good something must be seriously wrong with a person who either points out the absurdities or restricts himself to declaring that they are insufferable drivel.

Oh you poor thing! Are you really so thin-skinned that even when you've missed the point 16387405782634 times in a mere one thread, and you are obviously making no effort to increase your comprehension but instead compounding the problem by responding with crass obtuseness to everything said, and when someone else comes in and only wants to be rude and destructive, you consider that your opponents must roll you both in cotton wool and treat you with the greatest charm and courtesy? No jokes allowed?

And would you like this to extend to the rest of the forum? - No jokes allowed - unless You're the one making them of course? My goodness, this sounds just like ... ... Communism! The masses must all conform and priviliges are only for the elite. Who'd have thought it, eh, a Communist sounding like ... a Communist! Perhaps that also sheds some light on the fact that you can post on a discussion forum asserting the premise that religion has no value, and when anyone dares to disagree with you by providing evidence that at least for some people, it does have value, you respond with knee-jerk defensiveness and crass repulsive callousness, apparently trying to ridicule them into silence. Is this actually a Communist policy you're trying to implement in this thread - No disagreement will be tolerated!?

And it's funny how you can indignantly try to ridicule Christianity as worthless throughout this entire thread, ... until you decide you're being treated unfairly, ... and then you suddenly have a change of heart. Oh yes, suddenly it's a different story - Christians have "patience" and "empathy"! Christianity has suddenly turned from a monstrous blot on the world that needs to be eliminated without question, to a good influence on people after all!! Funny that. It's as if you're finally coming around to my point of view! :p

Incidentally, I'd just like to point out to you one way in which you have consistently, farsically missed the point throughout much of this thread:

I linked to some Christian testimonies, and you appear to leap with masterful mental athleticism to the faulty conclusion that ... well, who knows what it really was - you didn't say. But it certainly "led you up the garden path". ... (Hey, I'm suddenly adopting R.A.F's penchant for putting colloquialisms in quotation marks - it must be some kind of contageous disease! Help!) :)

Anyway, the point is that your continual insistence that the testimonies are not reliable because they only constitute anecdotal evidence - (again, evidence for what, I'm not sure, since you've never said) - but your claim that they're mere anecdotal evidence for ... - whatever it is - is utterly and totally irrelevant. If you're claiming they're only anecdotal evidence for the idea that religion has value, that's a silly way to argue, since they make it obvious that religion has value for some, and a more sensible approach than knee-jerk defensive denial and attempts to dismiss all matters of human suffering relieved by it with crass ridicule, would be to have a go at investigating just why this is the case, as I argued on the previous page.

Similarly, in a thread about homeopathy, if someone linked to testimonies from people who claimed homeopathy had helped them and said they knew of thousands of people it had helped, knee-jerk defensive denial along with callously repulsive attempts at ridicule and dismissal of real suffering relieved would be equally inappropriate. What would be appropriate would be to discuss just why these people thought homeopathy had helped them. Cool-headed people would do just that, and the results might be enlightening for all. I myself have commented here before on the reasons why going to an alternative/complimentary practitioner of something which has actually been proven totally ineffective scientifically can be appealing/can have value for some:

From here:

... I think the person who posted after you made a good point about how though medical science is error-prone, at least it works a lot of the time, whereas things like homeopathy won't. But I don't entirely agree that such things are never useful, because the placebo effect can be very powerful in some circumstances. What maybe needs to happen is that there needs to be more investigation into why these things sometimes work, so the factors that make them work can be
harnessed. For instance, one reason why such things can alleviate physical pain and increase well-being is because having a lot of attention paid to you by a caring person who prescribes you something you believe in so it reduces your stress, can reduce your muscle tension that might have been causing you pain, and increase your body's ability to fight certain ailments, because stress impairs the functioning of the immune system, so being with someone who helps you relax, if the feeling of relaxation lasts some time beyond the time when you see them, can sometimes improve your lot physically.

And from here:

These types of therapists can be enticing because they have some success with a fair number of conditions, because stress and tension can make conditions worse, and the relaxation people can find under the care of someone who soothes and pampers them, and perhaps teaches them relaxation techniques, can relieve
it. For instance, stress can damage the immune system, obviously reducing the body's ability to fight things. The tension it causes can make pain much worse, and cause pains that weren't there to begin with, partly because tense muscles can start to hurt. So learning to relax and feeling cared-for can cause physical improvements in some conditions.

So exposing such things as what she says as unscientific might help, but it might not be enough. What might help even more is if they learn more about stress management skills and find ways of improving things in their lives so more of their emotional needs get met, so they don't feel so much like turning
to a seemingly caring/soothing person like her for help.

These were almost exactly the kinds of arguments I was using in my posts near the end of the previous page, which you responded to with your revolting crass attempts at callous dismissal and ridicule. Would you like to do the same thing with these, or are you beginning to get my point a little now?
 
Is this actually a Communist policy you're trying to implement in this thread - No disagreement will be tolerated!?

And it's funny how you can indignantly try to ridicule Christianity as worthless throughout this entire thread, ...

You do know that you are not the first fundie to confuse ridicule with intolerance, don't you? Why is it that they don't seem to understand the difference?
And in answer to your question: Yes, of course, like all communists I aim to repress any and all disagreement in this thread, in all threads and in the rest of the world! (How come all my applications for the job as moderator remain unanswered?)

Anyway, the point is that your continual insistence that the testimonies are not reliable because they only constitute anecdotal evidence - (again, evidence for what, I'm not sure, since you've never said) - but your claim that they're mere anecdotal evidence for ... - whatever it is - is utterly and totally irrelevant.

If you're claiming they're only anecdotal evidence for the idea that religion has value, that's a silly way to argue, since they make it obvious that religion has value for some, and a more sensible approach than knee-jerk defensive denial and attempts to dismiss all matters of human suffering relieved by it with crass ridicule, would be to have a go at investigating just why this is the case, as I argued on the previous page.

OK, I'll have a go at it then: I think it's probably because of the cake! If I strain my empathic faculties to the breaking point that is the only real value I am able to detect in your attempts at presenting Christianity as the remedy for "all matters of human suffering".

Similarly, in a thread about homeopathy, if someone linked to testimonies from people who claimed (!) homeopathy had helped them and said they knew (!) of thousands of people it had helped, knee-jerk defensive denial along with callously repulsive attempts at ridicule and dismissal of real (!) suffering relieved (!) would be equally inappropriate.

Again the religious fervour of the Christian zealot makes you present reality as if ridicule of a cure that has no basis in either scientific research of properly conducted tests is a crime against human compassion and all things appropriate.

What would be appropriate would be to discuss just why these people thought homeopathy had helped them. Cool-headed people would do just that, and the results might be enlightening for all.

Won't you please stop telling us what "cool-headed people" would do? Please restrict yourself to telling us what Jesus would do. You are much more reliable when you stick to that.

I myself have commented here before on the reasons why going to an alternative/complimentary practitioner of something which has actually been proven totally ineffective scientifically can be appealing/can have value for some:

I bet that you yourself did so, but I'll spare myself the effort of reading it since I find your screeds extremely boring. (Yes, that's how "callous" etc. I am!)
And it actually isn’t very difficult to see ”why going to an alternative/complimentary practitioner of something which has actually been proven totally ineffective scientifically can be appealing/can have value for some”: People don’t go to scam healers to support science. Most of the time they are not only ignorant of what science has discovered about homeopathy etc; they don't want to know the truth about their favourite health delusions! They go there to be cured of their ailments, and when they go, they have the feeling that they have done something to take control of their own health. And people tend to like that. That the fulfilment of this need may kill them, doesn't occur to most of them. And if it does, it's quickly brushed aside.
Right now hundreds of Danish terminal cancer patients are wasting money, often borrowed, going to China for alleged life-prolonging treatments that science "has proven totally ineffective" – as far as the prolongation of life is concerned, which is what science deals with.
And that is what science and cool-headed skeptics should tell potential victims of the scammers.

I’ll leave the value of their delusions to you, who seems to appreciate delusions.
(And it’s not as if I hadn’t already dealt with the delusions of Christianity! Go back to START!)
I never claimed that you don't get a buzz from drugs, nor would I claim that you don't get one from Christian testimonies ...
 
Last edited:
Dann said:
I bet that you yourself did so, but I'll spare myself the effort of reading it since I find your screeds extremely boring. (Yes, that's how "callous" etc.
I am!)

What a shame, Eh? :D He finds my "screeds" boring, and yet he will insist again, again and again on provoking more of them! :newlol Could it be that he's not very conversant with the scientific process of cause-and-effect? I dunno! All his insistence on how nothing that hasn't been scientifically tested can have validity, and yet his own behaviour is as glaringly unscientific as that! Will he repent and resort to more scientific behaviour in the future? That remains to be seen.

I don't know about you, Dann, but I'm finding this thread increasingly amusing. If you're not, then maybe you should take the advice I once gave you before? It served you well for months!: The wisdom of the ages oh no, it's actually just me who says: He who does not want his opponent to comment on what he says ... would be better off not saying it/keeping quiet. :D

After all, just look at how verbosely I'm capable of responding to a mere one line of a post of yours!:

Dann said:
You do know that you are not the first fundie to confuse ridicule with intolerance, don't you? Why is it that they don't seem to understand the difference?

Bwahahahahahahaha! I point out several times in this thread that you habitually simplify what your opponent has said in your mind and then condemn it, looking at things in black-and-white terms - i.e. one is either a militant atheist fighting the good fight, or one is a destructive Fundie whose views must be crushed - no in between, and as if to oblige me by illustrating my point, you continue to do just that. Despite your protest that what I said was a "straw man", you conveniently endeavour to prove my point for me. :)

How close do you think this characterisation of Communists mirrors your own mind-set? I'll quote what I said in the thread where an atheist complained about a Christian raising the issue of Communist atrocities to criticize atheism the other day. Here's my post:

Baby Nemesis said:
It would be simplistic indeed to attribute the mass murderous inclinations of people like Stalin, Pol Pot and Mao Zedong to their atheism. Obviously they
would all have had multiple motives, and a number of things about their personalities would have inclined them to be like that.

But here are a few thoughts.

From a web page arguing that it wasn't their atheism that made them mass murderers:

Code:
One could make a valid claim that since Stalin attended a Russian orthodox seminary (from 1894 to 1899) as a teenager in Tiflis, the dogmatic black or white outlook of the world influenced his subsequent actions. As the historian Alan Bullock in his book [i]Hitler and Stalin: Parallel Lives[/i] (1991) explained:

The fact that it was a Church education helped to form the mind of a man who was to become known for his dogmatism and his propensity for seeing issues in absolute terms, in black and white. Anyone reading Stalin's speeches and writings will notice their catechistic structure, the use of question and answer, the reduction of complex questions to a set of simplified formulas, the quoting of text to support his arguments. The same Church influence has been noted
by biographers in his style of speaking or writing Russian: 'declamatory and repetitive, with liturgical overtones.'

[i]However[/i] the main influence on all these three men were dogmatic Marxism-Communism. Joseph M. Bochenski in his essay "A Critique of Communism" in the book [i]Outline of Communism[/i] clearly showed what the shortcomings of this system are. 

Firstly, communists are prone to oversimplification. Complex problems of the real world are explained in simplistic terms. Thus the communist eschatology of a classless society leads them to believe that collectivization is the main source of human happiness. Never mind the fact that each human beings have
different - and opposing - dreams, goals and desires. They also believe that all problems of labor can be resolved by nationalization of all industries
and the banning of private ownership. This saps the human spirit of the will to excel. This simplistic outlook spills into their belief about moral issues. Since communism is the ultimate good, anyone who is opposed to it must necessarily be evil. Like religious fundamentalists, to the communists everything is in black and white. "You are either with us or against us."

If you can try to make a cool assessment of the issue, how much of that mirrors your own experiences and mind-set?

Funnily enough - and you might be horribly shocked by this, the article goes on to say that Marx was just as dismissive of atheism as he was of religion!!

Indeed to the founder of communist doctrines, Karl Marx (1818-1883), atheism, was just a stage on the path to communism, and it was ultimately "unreal" and "no longer needed" by socialism and communism. This is what Karl Marx himself said about atheism:

Code:
Atheism as a denial of this unreality; has no longer any meaning, for atheism is a denial of God and tries to assert through this negation the existence of man; but socialism as such no longer needs this mediation...

Shocking! Now you know that, are you going to give up your atheism in furtherance of your discipleship of Karl Marx, or are you going to defy Marx and his doctrines by clinging to your atheism regardless of the fact that he said it's meaningless and no longer needed? Oh, the dilemma! :)

And oh yes, the difference between intolerance and ridicule: The reason there doesn't seem to be a difference in your own case is that you use ridicule as a first resort, with the seeming aim of shaming your opponent into silence, rather than using it to show up errors in specific things they actually said. ... Well that tactic backfired, didn't it. :) Of course, it might simply be that you use it because you have no valid arguments so it's the only thing you feel capable of resorting to. But though that may well be a factor, your intolerance of disagreement can be seen in that without even assessing your opponent's position enough to even have a clear idea of what it is, you use phrases like "insufferable drivel" to describe anything they say with any religious overtones at all.

If you could only try to look at things objectively instead of having them first filtered through the near-pathological hatred of religion you appear to have, your responses could probably be more intelligent.

Of course, I'm not accusing you of the gross intolerance the Communists who led Russia were guilty of. It remains to be seen whether you'd endorse that kind of cruelty. ... Hey! That reminds me of yet another Christian testimony. :big: I know what: I'll tell you about it:

Actually, this is quite gruesome and may be upsetting to some.

First, a quote from Wikipedia:

... In any case, religious beliefs and practices did persist, in the domestic and private spheres but also in the scattered public spaces allowed by a state that recognized its failure to eradicate religion and the political dangers of an unrelenting culture war. The result of this militant atheism was to transform the Church into a persecuted and martyred Church. According to the Soviet government's own statistics, there have been over 20 million new Christian martyrs who have died for the Orthodox Christian Church. ...

The Soviet Union was the first state to have as an ideological objective the elimination of religion. Toward that end, the Communist regime confiscated church property, ridiculed religion, harassed believers, and propagated atheism in the schools. Actions toward particular religions, however, were determined by State interests, and most organized religions were never outlawed.

Some actions against Orthodox priests and believers along with execution included torture, being sent to prison camps, labour camps or mental hospitals.

Many Orthodox (along with peoples of other faiths) were also subjected to psychological punishment or torture and mind control experimentation in order to force them to give up their religious convictions. ...

However, among the general population, large numbers remained religious. In 1987 in the Russian SFSR, between 40% and 50% of newborn babies (depending on the region) were baptized and over 60% of all deceased received Christian funeral services. ...

I once heard a story about a man who was part of a squad raiding underground churches and trying to bully them into giving up Christianity. He said he went in with a whip like the others, and attacked the believers. There was one girl in particular he bullied. But when he went back the next week, she was still there and the meeting was still taking place! He whipped her till her back was seriously bleeding, and they grabbed the New Testaments the believers were using and ripped them up. The people left, but he stayed after they'd gone. He picked up a page of one of the New Testaments that had been ripped up, and read it. And when he did, he wondered why on earth they would be persecuting people for reading things like that! He thought it was beautiful, and ended up becoming a Christian.

Dann said:
OK, I'll have a go at it then: I think it's probably because of the cake! If I strain my empathic faculties to the breaking point that is the only real value I am able to detect in your attempts at presenting Christianity as the remedy for "all matters of human suffering".

Bwahahahahahahahaha! If you spend weeks and weeks trawling this thread and any other on any other forum I've ever posted on, you will not find one place where I have ever said any such thing. I've said following Christian doctrine could make a lot of people behave more ethically so the world would be a better place; but that is not the same at all. Again, you are proving my point about how you simplify your opponent's views. Is it the old Communist mind-set kicking in again? :)

Dann said:
Again the religious fervour of the Christian zealot makes you present reality as if ridicule of a cure that has no basis in either scientific research of properly conducted tests is a crime against human compassion and all things appropriate.

On the contrary, I'm simply displaying the common human response, probably common to most people who've read the posts in question, whether Christian or atheist, of revulsion towards the attitude of someone who can apparently read about people involved in gang violence who gave up their violent lifestyles, thieves who did likewise, someone talking about how his cruel mother's rejection made him bitter and lonely finding new hope when he became a Christian, and so on, merely responding with crass unthinking dismissal of those people and their struggles, as if they're worthy of no more than contempt. You are seriously, seriously losing the propaganda war here! The sooner you realise that, the better for you.

... Oh, and wha'd'you know! There's that simplification of your opponent's position again!

Dann said:
Won't you please stop telling us what "cool-headed people" would do? Please restrict yourself to telling us what Jesus would do. You are much more reliable when you stick to that.

Ah, but I suspect I'm more reliable still at telling everybody what you would do. No, you wouldn't be one of the cool-headed ones who could discuss the details of the reasons why anyone might find value in alternative medicine and put forward ideas on ways of providing those same benefits through more efficacious means. No. ...

Oh no hang on, let's have an illustration of what you would do in your own words! Yes! Great idea.

Here's one I came across only the other day. It doesn't quite fit, but it'll do for now. If you want a more appropriate one, just say so, and I'll gladly find several. But for now: Here's part of a conversation I found where people were disputing with you over your mockery of a million dollar challenge applicant, and Chillzero was condemning you in strong terms for seeming to think intimidation tactics are the way to deal with such people, while Cran was rebuking you for the general personality traits of yours that seem to lead you to take such attitudes: ...

Oh no, actually, since this post is so horribly long already, I'll save it for my next response to you, should you be so unwise as to provoke one.

Dann said:
People don’t go to scam healers to support science. Most of the time they are not only ignorant of what science has discovered about homeopathy etc; they don't want to know the truth about their favourite health delusions! They go there to be cured of their ailments, and when they go, they have the feeling that they have done something to take control of their own health. And people tend to like that. That the fulfilment of this need may kill them, doesn't occur to most of them. And if it does, it's quickly brushed aside.
Right now hundreds of Danish terminal cancer patients are wasting money, often borrowed, going to China for alleged life-prolonging treatments that science "has proven totally ineffective" – as far as the prolongation of life is concerned, which is what science deals with.

Well, that was the first semi-sensible thing you've said for weeks.

Dann said:
And that is what science and cool-headed skeptics should tell potential victims of the scammers.

And I never suggested otherwise. Again, you illustrate your advanced ability to miss points. If you had actually read much at all of what I've posted, instead of jumping to extreme ill-informed conclusions which you admit by implication - having admitted to skipping over important bits - that you do, you'd be very well aware that nowhere have I ever suggested one shouldn't make people aware of the scams involved in such things as alternative medicine - and in fact my take on similar things is well-known here and will make your position seem absurd to anyone who has actually paid attention to several of the things I've written. Anyone who actually did read what I wrote will know I was advocating that people learn from the things that attract people to alternative healers to provide a better mainstream service so a percentage of people won't feel such a need to go to alternative therapists! Just as I was advocating near the end of the previous page that Atheist psychologists can learn from the needs people say were fulfilled in their lives when they became Christians to inform their atheist therapy! What a crashing way to miss a point! You've made a fool of yourself.

Blimey, I'm even boring myself now!

... Now, are you going to greet this post with ... ahem, a "scientific" reaction, ... or are you going to fly in the face of the science you profess to be so all-important and respond by provoking me some more, which will inevitably lead to me responding some more - something you appear not to want? Think about it: Science or temporary ego-gratification doomed to be short-lived? Science or temporary ego-gratification doomed to be short-lived? Science or temporary ego-gratification doomed to be short-lived? ... [The refrain slowly fades away into the mists.]
 
Last edited:
So arrogant and so wrong.
It would be funny if it weren’t so sad.

I doubt that many people still read Babe Nem's tirades, so I’ll have to bring her quotation from Marx again, which she completely misunderstands because of her enthusiasm for what she’d like to believe that he says:
Atheism as a denial of this unreality; has no longer any meaning, for atheism is a denial of God and tries to assert through this negation the existence of man; but socialism as such no longer needs this mediation...

If she had made an effort to read more than a soundbyte, it might have become clear to her that Marx says approximately the same thing here as he does in the quotation in my sigline.
It is apparent to most people who actually read what he wrote:

In short, according to Marx, Feuerbach believed that human emancipation from religion was possible by means of what Marx seemed to think was the shortcut of simple atheism. We saw earlier that Marx was indeed an atheist. But the one thing he was not was a simple atheist. Indeed, he seemed to believe that simple atheism – atheism that rests on the straightforward negation and reversion of what theism claims – is as ideological as the theism it all too simply rejects.
This appears to be the meaning of the following difficult passage, which I have quoted in part several times before and now present in full:

”But since for socialist man the whole of what is called world history is nothing more than the creation of man through labour, and the development of nature for man, he therefore has palpable and incontrovertible proof of his self-mediated birth, of his process of emergence. Since the essensiality of man and nature, man as the existence of nature for man and nature as the existence of man for man, has become practially and sensuously perceptible, the question of an alien being, a being above nature and man – a question which implies an admission of the unreality of nature and man – has become impossible in practice.
Atheism, which is a denial of this unreality, no longer has any meaning, for atheism is a negation of God, through which negation it asserts the existence of man. But socialism as such no longer needs such mediation. Its starting point is the theoretically and practically sensuous consciousness of man and of nature as essential beings. It is the positive self-consciousness of man, no longer mediated through the abolition of religion, just as real life is positive reality no longer mediated through the abolition of private property, through communism. Communism is the act of positing as the negation of the negation, and is therefore a real phase, necessary for the next period of historical development, in the emancipation and recovery of mankind. Communism is the necessary form and the dynamic principle of the immediate future, but communism is not as such the goal of human development -- the form of human society.”

Terrell Carver: The Cambridge Companion to Marx
I’ve added (in bold) a little more of the Marx quotation from: http://www.angelfire.com/or/sociologyshop/marxrel.html

In other words: When ”socialist (!) man” has managed to overcome the conditions of production where he was first dependent on the whims of nature and then reduced to a mere tool for the production of the wealth of others, i.e. when he controls both nature and the conditions of production, then (and not until then) ”Atheism, which is a denial of this unreality, no longer has any meaning” since ”socialism as such no longer needs such mediation.”
That is, when the need for a god has ceased to exist because people have created the conditions where this psychological crutch, this security blanket, is no longer needed and the gods have therefore ceased to exist, atheism, the denial of God, will, of course, no longer be needed and therefore become meaningless.
But maybe Babe Nem just hasn't noticed that these conditions haven't yet been achieved ...

I’m not defensively arrogant and self-important enough to tell her to ”Read what I wrote again, properly this time, and provided you have the intelligence to take in the arguments, you'll cringe in embarrassment at your first response.”
I'll also let her provide her own smilies ...
 
Last edited:
Thank you for providing me with continuing amusement, Dann.

But your behaviour is becoming truly scandallous now! :D So inept are you at reading my posts, it seems, that you have not only missed 1263758362983 points I've made in the past couple of months, but you continue to make crashing blunders. Come on, you are setting yourself up as a Mr Bean character, aren't you! Tell me you are! :D

Thank you for brightening up my day.

OK, your latest missed point involves a bizarre confusion of errors in which you somehow mistake the words of an atheist on a web page for mine. This poor atheist who you're now debunking, quoted that Marx thing in order to try to prove that atheism wasn't responsible for the millions of deaths and all the mayhem committed by Stalin, Pol Pot and Mao Zedong, since their atheism had nothing to do with the reasons they ordered the killing sprees. Poor atheist! He was trying to prove those things had nothing to do with atheism since after all, Marx, whose teaching their doctrines were based on, "repudiated" atheism. And what do you go and do?!!! You go and prove the poor man incorrect! :big: You sweep one of his most important arguments right out from beneath his feet, you traitorous turncoat! What kind of an atheist are you?! This poor atheist said:

It is important to pause for a moment and consider this statement [the Marx one about atheism] carefully. If Karl Marx, the intellectual founder of Marxism and communism, repudiated atheism as meaningless and no longer needed, how then could atheism be considered the cause of the atrocities committed under communism?

It's just not fair! If he finds your post, he'll never be able to use that argument again, and it's all. Your. Fault!

:big:

How can you have so crashingly missed the point that you thought the point of me quoting what Marx said had to do with me wanting to make a case against atheism or something, when in fact the quote was in the context of someone trying to do the exact opposite?! This is so funny! The Marx quote itself really wasn't the issue.

Still, it is interesting to have the correct interpretation of that quote. Thank you.

And it is understandable that you should want to defend Marx.

But how ironic it is that Marx didn't like atheism or theism when they were believed in to an ideological extent, but his own ideologies have been used to justify the deaths of millions! ... No, that's not funny.

Wow, I hardly understood a word of that Marx quote you quoted! If all his writing was as ponderous as that, I'm shaking my head in wonder that it could ever have inspired the fervour to kill millions! ... Ah, but then his Communist Manifesto was phrased in much simpler terms, wasn't it, although I don't think even the rhetoric in that was inflammatory enough to really get people going. What was it, I wonder. What would you say it was? ... Then again, millions of those deaths possibly weren't deliberate or foreseen. That's typical politicians for you - not looking where they're going but leading people there anyway!

Dann said:
I’m not defensively arrogant and self-important enough to tell her to ”Read what I wrote again, properly this time, and provided you have the intelligence to take in the arguments, you'll cringe in embarrassment at your first response.”

No, but you certainly use dirty tactics sometimes, don't you. I could quote those things I promised to, where you were accused of using intimidation tactics on people; I said I'd do so if you responded to my post, but I've decided to be merciful and spare you just this once, ... (or maybe I'll spare you twice or just a few more times), since it's understandable that you should have wanted to respond to the apparent slander against Marx. :)
 
Last edited:
Babe Nem's desperation appears to be directly proportional to the number of smilies contained in her posts.
I suppose that she is unable to understand that I don't find it necessary to defend Marx. Explaining what he wrote to somebody who demonstrates her ignorance of a quotation she brings is a different matter.

It is a contradiction in terms to threaten to post accusations against me of "using intimidation tactics on people", isn't it? Why doesn't she simply go ahead and do so if ad homs are her only alternative to straw-man arguments and misinterpretations? Well, the lord works in mysterious ways ...
 
Last edited:
Wow, not content to miss 176379263856374537825378475327364784 of the points I've made in the last few months in this thread, Dann goes on to deliberately make the error of equating smilies with desperation, and so technically, since he's missed the point of those, he can be accredited with having missed one more; so he's now missed a whopping 2638593628016253745897362967542361 of my points! :D Check the impeccable maths there and you'll see for yourself.

Wow, but now Dann actually wants me to post those quotes? Oh where to begin! I'll oblige him though.

But it's very strange indeed that you should suggest I merely want to do so as a substitute for valid argument, Dann, since if you would only pay attention, you'd see I'm the one who's had all the good arguments in this thread, and you can only miss points - usually about 451 at a time, in the same split second! Yes, that's how he's managed to miss so many!

... Actually, I'll perhaps post those incriminating Dann quotes next time, or some time in the near future. Now, I've got something far more important to say!! *Drum roll, Fanfare:*

... No OK, I'm being a little self-important there. Still, since my arguments about how atheist sociologists/psychologists can use Christian testimonies as pointers to research etc. may become lost in the mists of oblivion - well, they're on the previous page after all, and what is that but a veritable pit of darkness now! - ... What? I'm being a bit melodramatic? Surely not! Anyway, I'll link to my arguments and anyone who missed them first time can do a quality check on them for themselves! :D Here they are.

I'll quote a little from the beginning as inflammatory anti-atheist bait an innocuous little taster:

... Further to that, atheists don't have to reject testimonies of people who left lifestyles that were harming themselves or others to become Christians as offensive nonsense, simply because they contain a lot of Christian terminology. The more imaginative and creative atheists can view such things as an interesting psychological/sociological phenomenon that it might be possible to learn from, since it may be that many of the things that influenced those people to give up their harmful lifestyles can be replicated in secular settings with no Christian overtones. In other words, the testimonies might give some insights as to how some lives can be changed for the better by totally secular means, since they might talk about needs that were fulfilled by adopting Christianity that could actually have been fulfilled by other means. Here's an example: ...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom