My God, why hast thou forsaken me?

Ah who cares! I might debate this with you one day. But it would be going right off the topic of Jesus, so it certainly won't be in this thread. And given the kinds of things I've put up with from some in the religion forum in the past week, I haven't got the stomach for it at the moment. Maybe one day. PM me in a few months' time and maybe I'll consider it.

But I don't really se why you think it's necessary. I'd like to ask you, is what might or might not have happened under the antiquated Law of Moses of such tremendous importance that even if many people are finding Christianity inspirational and it's spurring them on to live better lives that lead to their benefit and the benefit of those around them, they must nevertheless be bombarded with the ancient Law of Moses till they submit and give up the idea of being Christians?

Can you really claim Christianity is not good when it has all this inspirational material to offer?:

What The Bible Says About Violence, Anger, Jealousy, Arguments, And Living In Peace With Each Other.
What The Bible Says About Honesty And The Love Of Money.
A Short Story About Tackling Prejudice, And What The Bible Says About Despising People, Judging By Appearances, And God's Mercy.
What The Bible Says About Love And Caring.
What The Bible Says About Drunkenness and Why It's Wrong.
What The Bible Says About Lies, Gossip, Quarrelling, Insulting Language And Dirty Jokes.
What The Bible Says About Sex And Marriage.
What The Bible Says About Lustful And Nasty Thoughts.
 
Can you really claim Christianity is not good when it has all this inspirational material to offer?:
Fallacy and entirely beside the point.

My argument stands.

I posit that if we assume that the Bible is either correct or it is not then given the events contained therein there can only be one of two possible conclusions. There is no god or god is not good.
Putting a pretty bow on dog**** won't change the fact that it is still dog****.
 
PM me in a few months' time and maybe I'll consider it.
No. The evidence against god stands and I'll leave it to you to decide if you've the temerity to defend the worst of depravity and cruelty. I don't need to beg you. You either will play the devil's (god's)advocate or you won't. It's your choice. I've been here some 9 years. You know where to find me.
 
Perhaps you didn't hear me. I said who cares!

Now you've proved that all you really want to do is be insulting, I don't want to converse with you any more. There hardly seems a point. You obviously don't want to listen, confirming my previous impression.

And if you provoke me some more, I will say somethingyou will regret.
 
I said who cares!
Anyone who cares about decency. Anyone who cares about truth.

Now you've proved that all you really want to do is be insulting...
No. I've stood up for truth and decency.

And if you provoke me some more, I will say somethingyou will regret.
Odd that the words of your supposed god in your beloved book provoke you.

I'm not trying to provoke you. I'm trying to point out that the facts in the Bible condemn the idea of the god of the Bible.

If that provokes then that is your problem.
 
Absolutely.

I posit that if there is a god he has frequently forsaken us and forsaken decency, justice and mercy. I posit that the accounts contained in the Bible, his alleged "word" stands as testimony to his duplicity and atrocity.

I posit that if we assume that the Bible is either correct or it is not then given the events contained therein there can only be one of two possible conclusions. There is no god or god is not good.

I find it necessary to quibble here. While I tend to agree that there is no god, I think you present a poor dichotomy. Either the God of the Bible does not exist, or he is not good. That much seems clear, at least as we understand "good." But the Bible could be entirely wrong without excluding the possibility, far fetched as it may be, that some other god exists or once existed, and the possibility, far fetched as it may be, that that god is either good, or so abstract and impersonal and hard to conceive that the word "good" is simply not appropriate.
 
Last edited:
Anyone who cares about decency. Anyone who cares about truth.

Oh how ironic! There goes RandFan, proclaiming all over the place that the Bible isn't truth; and then when someone says they don't care if it portrays God as cruel, he says they should care if they care about truth! How strange! It's as if he thinks the Bible's true after all, but only lets on when he's off his guard! Whoops, you slipped up there, RandFan. Try not to do it again.

And now, I'm going to report this off-topic tripe, in the hope it gets flung into AAH where it belongs. And you really must learn not to stereotype your opponents as some kind of crazy fanatics just sallivating to read more of the cruelty of the American attack on the women and babies of Hiroshima and Germany who they could have spared with a bit of logistical planning, to say nothing about their cruelty in Iraq ... I mean, the nasty stuff in the Bible. What came over me for a second there!
 
It's as if he thinks the Bible's true after all, but only lets on when he's off his guard! Whoops, you slipped up there, RandFan.
Nonsense. I've said that IF it is true then god must be cruel.

I posit that if there is a god he has frequently forsaken us and forsaken decency, justice and mercy. I posit that the accounts contained in the Bible, his alleged "word" stands as testimony to his duplicity and atrocity.

I posit that if we assume that the Bible is either correct or it is not then given the events contained therein there can only be one of two possible conclusions. There is no god or god is not good.


And now, I'm going to report this off-topic tripe, in the hope it gets flung into AAH where it belongs.
How is it off topic?
 
I find it necessary to quibble here. While I tend to agree that there is no god, I think you present a poor dichotomy.
I honestly thought that I had said "god of the Bible".

That said, we can first decide whether or not the Bile is correct. If not correct then there is no need to procede further for the purpose of my argument since the Bible can't be trusted as a source.

If it is correct then either the god of the Bible is not good or god does not exist.

Thanks.
 
And now, I'm going to report this off-topic tripe, in the hope it gets flung into AAH where it belongs. And you really must learn not to stereotype your opponents as some kind of crazy fanatics just sallivating to read more of the cruelty of the American attack on the women and babies of Hiroshima and Germany who they could have spared with a bit of logistical planning, to say nothing about their cruelty in Iraq ... I mean, the nasty stuff in the Bible. What came over me for a second there!
AAH is not appropriate. If action is taken I would suggest a split thread.
 
RandFan said:
How is it off-topic?

Perhaps you haven't looked at the OP in a long, long, long time! But if you ever do again, you might suddenly realise that it isn't an invitation to explore the minutia of the worst of the worst biblical atrocities - that would be for another thread. The OP is about Jesus' words on the cross and what they really meant. Perhaps you ought to go and remind yourself.
 
AAH is not appropriate. If action is taken I would suggest a split thread.

That would be pointless, since I have no wish whatsoever to debate someone with such an insulting, stereotyping arguing technique as yours. It's very clear you aren't interested in debating facts objectively - you're just behaving like a screaming child insisting and insisting on getting its own view across and not listening to what the other person wants to say.
 
That would be pointless, since I have no wish whatsoever to debate someone with such an insulting, stereotyping arguing technique as yours.
I've not insulted you. I've not stereotyped you.

It's very clear you aren't interested in debating facts objectively
Asserting something doesn't make it true.

...you're just behaving like a screaming child insisting and insisting on getting its own view across and not listening to what the other person wants to say.
False. BTW: The rules dictate that you are not allowed to discuss me.

I've apologized. I'll leave it to the discernment of others to decide if I've acted like a child.
 
I will concede that my posts are off topic as to the OP and I apologize.

"Minutia"? "You strain at a gnat and swallow a camel". --Christ

I mean you seem to want to explore them in every single detail you can dredge up. Oh yes, I bet if you had free reign in this thread, you'd change it from a nice friendly discussion of Jesus to a sickening discussion that went into as much gory detail as your little imagination could muster up, even down to the bits of clothing that might have been stolen by the Israelites as they plundered Canaan.

Incidentally, someone once had as his signature a quote from you that said you believe rape isn't wrong. How can you think it's wrong in the Bible and not wrong in ordinary life?
 
I mean you seem to want to explore them in every single detail you can dredge up.
No, I only want to note that the god of the Bible stands convicted of cruelty to any reasonable person willing to look at the facts in an intelectually honest way. It is my position that an omnipotent, omnicient just and merciful god could not act in such a barbarous manner.


Incidentally, someone once had as his signature a quote from you that said you believe rape isn't wrong.
Obviously you didn't read the signature very well. If you contact the person the signature once belonged to Cain he will confirm that it is taken out of context to mock a typo.

How can you think it's wrong in the Bible and not wrong in ordinary life?
Perhaps you should consider that not all things are as they appear. Cain as a promise to me, provided the link to provide context. Why did you not follow that link and find out the truth?

Here is where Cain promises to provide the link to give context to my statement.

Here is the full context of my statement.

For those who don't follow the link let me make clear that I find rape repugnant.
 
Last edited:
That, RandFan, is an insult, as well as a rule 10 breach.
But I'm not insulting you. I'm insulting the steaming pile of dog**** that is the cruelty of the Bible. God killing infants. God demanding the death of homosexuals and disobedient children. God telling Abraham to kill his son. God standing by while Jephthah murders his daughter to fulfill a promise to god. God punishing David's child for a crime committed by David to punish David. God condoning slavery. They misogyny. The genocide. The xenophobia.

The OT is in many ways offensive and the NT is also not without stain and I stand by my characterization of it. Just watch the video that I posted and tell me that the actions of the character of god in the OT are not offensive. That they don't represent the very worst of human nature much less the nature of an ostensibly merciful and just being.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom