Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Since many of the responses are repetitious, (long comment about how unusual the cookie crumbs are snipped)

WOW! Super post. It really sheds light on how ridiculous Jones' theory that super style nano-thermite matches were used to set off conventional explosives, huh?

The way you put it, that would be like using an atomic powered laser beam to light my grill this weekend. How stupid is that?

Great to see you finally come around.
 
Negative. The preponderance of the evidence very clearly demonstrates that the columns were not severed by any means other than impact force, not incendiaries.

Which would be significant if they examined more than 1% of the steel. Seeing as how the vast majority of steel was whisked off to the Chinese recycling bin before an examination could even take place, no firm claims can be made on this subject. That is, unless you've somehow been exposed to a much larger sample size of the WTC steel than FEMA or NIST.

Which is my whole point: You are the one ignoring evidence when you refuse to come to terms with the existence of verified evidence. And when you attempt to offer poorly supported research who's conclusion has been very strongly and well refuted, then you are the one who is not approaching the issue logically or scientifically.

The amount of times this tripe is linked to does not make it any stronger. Where have you seen a test that demonstrates that MEK can separate aluminosilicates into elemental Al and a Si compound? Nowhere? Me neither. Why do you assume the existence of a reaction for which you've never seen demonstrated somehow trumps detailed scientific analysis? That is the very definition of "pseudoscientific."

You need to acknowledge the evidence. The evidence shows that even if thermite was present, it failed to function. You need to come to terms with that.

The group response I gave earlier is exactly about the misunderstanding you (and others) keep hiding behind in order to avoid the conclusions of the HFJ paper. Namely, the substance they found is NOT thermite. It is "thermitic" meaning is has thermite-like properties but having a much lower ignition temperature and a wide range of burn rates and exothermic variables.

To claim "it's not thermite, therefore they're dumb" is a non-argument in this case. No one is claiming it's thermite except the "debunkers." This is not a conventional material by any stretch of the imagination.

_______

And for the record: Why do you presume that I've "come to terms with the existence of the material"? Did you even read my post? I am very clearly on record as saying that the Jones, Harrit, et. al. What I am confronting is the fantasy that you conspiracy peddlers continue to push despite the fact that it has been refuted.

It's real far from being refuted. Do you think that an examination of 1% of the steel is a "thorough investigation" by which you can make sweeping claims about the condition of the other 99%?

That's shoddy logic.

As I've said before, I don't know how this substance was used in the towers. All that can be said at this point is that it shouldn't be there. So, why is it there and who put it there?


.
 
Just curious: jay, have you come up with an excuse as to why your heroes tested the substance in an oxygen rich environment rather than an inert one? The way I see it there are two possibilities: 1) They knew that it wouldn't ignite in an inert environment, thus they are stunning dishonest. Or. 2) They were unaware that it mattered, thus they are stunningly incompetent. Which is it?
 
Since many of the responses are repetitious, I want to respond to a few overarching considerations in a single post:

One of the problems with having this conversation is that there is a misunderstanding (pretended or real) that the substance we are talking about is "thermite." It is clearly not. It is "thermitic." That distinction is made specifically to keep these substances from being confused--which is happening all too often in regard to the HFJ paper.
The use of the term "thermitic" is, at best, a strategy for obfuscation. Harrit et al are smart enough to know that proving there is thermite in the dust is far more complicated than proving that a material at-one-time may or may not have been part of a thermite reaction process whose definition changes every time Jones publishes a paper.
What never seems to come up in terms of data fabrication or the supposed chain of custody issues is that if they were going to make something up, why not choose something more conventional?

Because Jones is smart enough to know that conventional explosives go BOOM. Since 2003, he's been demanding that thermite or thermate or thermote or thermut was used because it is silent. Jones has been looking for evidence of thermite since 2003, and he's been looking at dust and calling it thermite since 2006.
The fact that this substance, whatever it is, is NOT well understood leads only to more questions about it.
Thermite is actually incredibly well understood. Its reaction, kinetics, thermodynamic properties, composition, chemistry, morphology, methods of production and limitations on use are extremely well understood and available on wikipedia. It's Jones who has made up a new material with "strange" and "unique" properties so that he can point to any material and say (with a straight face, oddly enough) that it's "thermitic." That's the type of intellectual dishonesty that we'd expect from a failed cold fusion wonk like Jones.
If they wanted to fake it, they would have been much better off claiming conventional explosives.
Conventional explosives go boom. There was no boom. That's why Jones needs thermite.
There are only a handful of labs in the US that can even produce elemental aluminum at these sizes.
So what? Has Harrit proved that the aluminum comes from those labs? Has he proved that all nano-elemental aluminum must be produced in a lab?
Instead we see nanometer-sized iron, aluminum and silicon particles mixed very finely in a carbon-based matrix.
What is that consistent with?
The uniformity of these particles is startling,
The sample size presented in the paper is insufficient to make this claim.
as most manufacturing processes on an industrial scale--paints, primers, corrosion protection coatings, etc., cannot afford to design these particles (most especially the aluminum) so precisely for use in products that do not require such specific size/mixture parameters.
This speculation is irrelevant.
It would be an enormously wasteful endeavor to design paints or other common industrial coatings that don't require such fine particles.
According to whom?
The mere prospect is laughable as there isn't a plant manager on the planet that would propose such an unnecessary move. It's not only a sure-fire way to get fired, it would ensure the company would eventually go out of business as well!
According to whom?
The fact that this material is NOT easily manufactured nor well understood should be a glaring red alarm to anyone who is not in complete denial.
It's only important to those who accept opinion over evidence.
There is no good reason that this very unusual material should be found in regular construction material. And anyone who thinks this is some version of paint or an industrial coating is not paying much attention.
Neither of these conclusions have evidence supporting them. The first is prefaced on an argument from ignorance, the second is an ad-hominem fallacy.
For those who doubt the chain of custody, there are roughly 2 possibilities: you must either believe:
False choice fallacy.
1. that it is more probable that all 4 samples were contaminated with similarly strange material (!) or
No one has shown that the material is strange or somehow inconsistent with the dust cloud formed by a building collapsing during a fire.
2. that the HFJ research team unanimously decided to pull a fast one and attempted to implicate some other party in addition to (but separate from) the 19 hijackers as complicit in the murders of 3000 American citizens. (What purpose this last option would serve besides making the researchers very unpopular to the current power structure may be the deepest mystery of all.)
It's an interesting appeal to motive fallacy, but if I were to assign motives to Jones, Harrit et al, I would have to say it's an ego issue. Jones put his scientific career out on a limb with cold fusion. But when scooped by Pons and Fleischman, he ended up playing the part of a footnote to history. Twenty years later, cold fusion has largely been discredited, and Jones is left without the spotlight and without recognition. By allying himself with the 9/11 conspiracy crowd, he's found a group of gullible, yet devoted fans who fawn over him at talks, pay for his travel and speak his name with reverence.

The reason he's interested in implicating another group is because that's what pays the bills.
When combined with the extensive corroborative evidence of the strange exothermic properties of this material,
None of the properties are strange. That is a fabrication of poor data and poor understanding.
its nanometer-sized particular makeup, comparative XEDS spectroscopy and comparative SE microscopy, both chain of custody options become significantly less probable than what the authors of the paper claim.
Chain of custody is not something that becomes irrelevant because the data may be interesting. As I pointed out earlier, the issue is significance. Without chain of custody, significance can't be established. Without significance, the compositional, morphological and thermodynamic data are irrelevant.
 
Since many of the responses are repetitious, I want to respond to a few overarching considerations in a single post:

One of the problems with having this conversation is that there is a misunderstanding (pretended or real) that the substance we are talking about is "thermite." It is clearly not. It is "thermitic." That distinction is made specifically to keep these substances from being confused--which is happening all too often in regard to the HFJ paper. From Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metastable_intermolecular_composite

Ok, lets say for a second that we forget all of the methodological errors made, forget the bad science, and the confirmation bias, and the chain of custody.

If we we forget all that, what they found was "energetic" material and the components of a thermite reaction. So now what? So with all of the bad science and horrible methodology aside, the next step would be to assess and eliminate all possible sources of such...did they do that? NOPE...but we are getting way off track, as it is all useless with their present data, due to the methodology trainwreck.

It cannot be emphasized enough that changing the size of the particles in aluminothermic reactions does indeed change the dynamics significantly. Because of the high cost and difficulty in manufacturing nano-sized elemental aluminum, these traces are anything but "conventional." The fact that they have been identified in the WTC dust signals the existence of a totally unaccounted energy source that can be highly tailored to a wide variety of applications.

Traces of almost anything can be expected, so why would traces of this be unexpected in the dust from a collapsed 110 storey skyscraper that was filled with probably bits of everything? You think the size of SOME of the TRACES of particles he found makes them stand out as man made ordinances??? really? Hydrogen is a fuel that can be tailored to a wide variety of applications.

What never seems to come up in terms of data fabrication or the supposed chain of custody issues is that if they were going to make something up, why not choose something more conventional? The fact that this substance, whatever it is, is NOT well understood leads only to more questions about it. If they wanted to fake it, they would have been much better off claiming conventional explosives. There are only a handful of labs in the US that can even produce elemental aluminum at these sizes.

1. No one, except you, is suggesting anything here. Without a proper chain of custody, the forensic value, and possibly the scientific value (if samples were allowed to spoil, were exposed to elements, etc...) is EXTREMELY reduced.

2. Stop speculating about what they would or would not have fabricated here...why are you doing that? no one else is.

Instead we see nanometer-sized iron, aluminum and silicon particles mixed very finely in a carbon-based matrix. The uniformity of these particles is startling, as most manufacturing processes on an industrial scale--paints, primers, corrosion protection coatings, etc., cannot afford to design these particles (most especially the aluminum) so precisely for use in products that do not require such specific size/mixture parameters. It would be an enormously wasteful endeavor to design paints or other common industrial coatings that don't require such fine particles. The mere prospect is laughable as there isn't a plant manager on the planet that would propose such an unnecessary move. It's not only a sure-fire way to get fired, it would ensure the company would eventually go out of business as well!

1. How were they mixed "very finely". Do we only see nanometer particles? Who said those particles were Deliberately constructed at those sizes? Talk about going off on a speculative tangent based on erronious data.


The fact that this material is NOT easily manufactured nor well understood should be a glaring red alarm to anyone who is not in complete denial. There is no good reason that this very unusual material should be found in regular construction material. And anyone who thinks this is some version of paint or an industrial coating is not paying much attention.

ok, so let us assume (this is taking a leap, but you have been at least civil) that what they found was (A) synthetic, and (B) difficult to synthesize. If that is the case, does it not strike you as odd, no perhaps ALARMING, that (A) no one else, no other lab, found such material, or if they did, did not recognize these "alarming" features you describe, and (B) why with such explosive (no pun intended) evidence, so easy for anyone to see as "alarming", has Jones et al not provided their samples for multiple INDEPENDENT analysis by truly INDEPENDENT labs???

For those who doubt the chain of custody, there are roughly 2 possibilities: you must either believe:

1. that it is more probable that all 4 samples were contaminated with similarly strange material (!) or

2. that the HFJ research team unanimously decided to pull a fast one and attempted to implicate some other party in addition to (but separate from) the 19 hijackers as complicit in the murders of 3000 American citizens. (What purpose this last option would serve besides making the researchers very unpopular to the current power structure may be the deepest mystery of all.)

When combined with the extensive corroborative evidence of the strange exothermic properties of this material, its nanometer-sized particular makeup, comparative XEDS spectroscopy and comparative SE microscopy, both chain of custody options become significantly less probable than what the authors of the paper claim.

Since the only "evidence" of such a claim of contamination or misrepresentation of the samples is the doubt produced by the conclusions (which overwhelmingly implicate forces within the US power structure), then it should be pointed out that incredulity is a poor foundation for a claim against scientific evidence. Compared one-to-one, the science wins this one hands down. Claims to the contrary must bring more than just doubt to bear on this evidence.

.

The above is all speculative, and you are the only one doing this. We are merely saying that in scientific investigation, and even more so in a forensic investigation, CHAIN OF CUSTODY is paramount, and its absence (including a complete detail on storage and exposures) is KEY!!!

TAM:)
 
So you're claiming that it's more likely they pulled several different materials from the WTC dust that were 1. magnetic, 2. layered red/gray and 3. showed very similar elemental compositions?

I admit, it's possible, but not likely.
Ok, 'possible' is enough for now.

But that doesn't increase the reaction temperature of the chips in the DSC.
Only samples 1-4 were analyzed in DSC. If they had weld metal, it could be in a metastable state as described by NIST in NCSTAR 1-3C appendix D p.435, not to forget the problem of potential combustion in air without any 'thermitic reaction'. By the way, see also figure D-4 in page 442 for a potential source of chips 1-4, and compare to this illustration of unknown source, but associated with Jones et al's analysis in Gage's slide show: http://www.ae911truth.org/ppt_web/10min/slideshow.php?i=71&lores=1

Nor does it make the iron-based and silicon-based microspheres vanish. Even if you want to claim that the MEK chip is not the same as the others, there is clearly a highly energetic reaction taking place by which molten iron and silicon are being produced.
So? The gray layer is probably iron-rich itself (the magnet attracted it after all). I'm not sure, but isn't it conceivable that some of it melted during the combustion? I've been told that at these scales the properties of materials are quite different.

The problem with your analysis is that you must ignore the corroboration of data (that an aluminothermic reaction is taking place) by denying that the components of aluminothermic material are present. Your analysis does more to obfuscate the problem than it does to "set the record straight."
What?!

There is no proof of aluminothermic reaction at all.

There are the elements present in thermite, but hey, they are quite common and not everything burns like thermite. There's no proof that they are in a form that would ignite in the absence of oxygen just like thermite does. There's not enough iron oxide together with enough elemental aluminium or silicon anywhere. Most of the oxygen appears to be chemically bound to silicon in the MEK-soaked chip. Most of the aluminium appears to be bound to silicon in samples 1-4.

My analysis merely shows that Jones et al's analysis is a piece of crap that leads nowhere and jumps into conclusions that don't follow from what they have at hand. Just as everybody here has been showing repeatedly. The only obfuscation comes from the analysts' sloppy methods, and that assuming good faith, which I have a reason to doubt as I will show later.

It matters not a wit to the instruments what their intentions were.
Indeed. That's why I am analyzing the data and showing how the interpretation made by the analysts does not follow from it.

Unless you think they are wholesale lying, there is no way around the fact that they found unexploded ordinance in the WTC dust.
Finding a material that burns when heated does not make it ordnance.

The XEDS graph DOES show the contamination.
No, it shows the composition. It doesn't prove that it's contamination.


Yea, I read that too. All that does is point to the hypothesis that these materials were originally layered. Big deal. Does nothing to invalidate their conclusions.
That shows the difference in nature of the chips taken in consideration, casting doubts about the MEK chip and thus about their conclusions that chips 1-4 are not paint. Yes, big deal. The chips should have been categorized first. That's not done. We also have no clue about the composition of the chip that burns in fig. 22.


Yet figure 15 shows no apparent correlation between Fe and O as compared to e.g. Si and O. Even Al and O are more correlated in figure 15 than Fe and O. That makes one wonder if figure 18 has been cherry-picked.
If you think they are manipulating the data, then there's no point having this discussion. You still can't dismiss their conclusions based on your feeling about their methods.
It's not a mere 'feeling'. The first sentence in page 19 reads:

"Oxygen is very consistently found in high concentration with the iron in the red material even after soaking in MEK solvent (Fig. 15)"
​

That is blatantly false. Let's do some math. First, let's show the Fe layer minus the O layer, to see how much unoxidized Fe there is. Note that the subtraction operator I'm using in GIMP clamps at zero.

MEK-chip-XEDS-map-Fe-O.jpg


That alone would suffice as a rebuttal to that sentence. However, as I noted before, there's a strong correlation of O with Si. If the O is really chemically bound to the Si, as I suspect, the following image, showing the O minus the Si, shows how much O is left for everything else:

MEK-chip-XEDS-map-O-Si.jpg


Granted, that's probably exaggerated because the Si probably obscures too much of the O, but since the Si is very localized, it gives us an overview of how much O there is that is not related to the Si.

Now let's see the [Fe-[O-Si]] (the [] denote clamping):


MEK-chip-XEDS-map-Fe-O-Si.jpg


So, what's the basis to assert that "[o]xygen is very consistently found in high concentration with the iron" according to Fig. 15?

Where's the thermite's source of oxygen, if Si is at best a combustible in thermite-like compounds?

Now, if we go to Fig. 18 we find all kinds of things in there, yet the last image shows very little Fe overlapping with O. Is there a reason to think that that XEDS spectrum has been cherry-picked, or not?

And that's not all. This is the addition of all of the elements shown:

MEK-chip-XEDS-map-Al+Si+O+Fe+C.jpg


What are the black areas? Why aren't we shown?


And they go to lengths to avoid being accused of doing anything tricky. For instance, they took a known source of Fe2O3 and tested its elemental composition for comparison to their calculations in the determination of the presence of Fe2O3 in the sample: pg. 19
I agree they try.


How are you making this determination? Because of the XEDS maps of fig. 15? The Fe and O portions are not isomorphic, but there is unarguably overlap between the two. Why are you then discounting the XEDS graphs that accompany the maps? They need only show the existence of some Fe2O3 to claim the sample contains it. Same with elemental Al, which they do. What's the problem?
The problem, as I've shown you, is that they don't claim there's 'some' Fe2O3, they claim Fe and O are 'very consistently' correlated, and that's clearly false.

I am not discounting the XEDS spectrums you mention, I am just saying that they don't prove what they are claimed to prove.
 
... that the substance we are talking about is "thermite." It is clearly not. It is "thermitic." That distinction is made specifically to keep these substances from being confused--which is happening all too often in regard to the HFJ paper. From Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metastable_intermolecular_composite

It cannot be emphasized enough that changing the size of the particles in aluminothermic reactions does indeed change the dynamics significantly. Because of the high cost and difficulty in manufacturing nano-sized elemental aluminum, these traces are anything but "conventional." The fact that they have been identified in the WTC dust signals the existence of a totally unaccounted energy source that can be highly tailored to a wide variety of applications.

...
The fact that this material is NOT easily manufactured nor well understood should be a glaring red alarm to anyone who is not in complete denial. There is no good reason that this very unusual material should be found in regular construction material. And anyone who thinks this is some version of paint or an industrial coating is not paying much attention.

For those who doubt the chain of custody, there are roughly 2 possibilities: you must either believe:

1. that it is more probable that all 4 samples were contaminated with similarly strange material (!) or
...
When combined with the extensive corroborative evidence of the strange exothermic properties of this material, its nanometer-sized particular makeup, comparative XEDS spectroscopy and comparative SE microscopy, both chain of custody options become significantly less probable than what the authors of the paper claim.
...

Changing the size of the thermite does not change the energy from the basic chemical reaction. Jones' paper shows the energy from the samples does not match thermite. The energy is also much less than the energy of office contents; paper has more energy. The jet fuel is ten times the heat energy of thermite, why would anyone need to load thermite material into the WTC and leave evidence; evidence never found by the way! The dust has Al and iron rust, both items are found all over the WTC and even in my own home. The fact is the Jones paper will never be found in a real scientific journal except to expose it as fraud; lucky for Jones and his fellow conspiracy theorists, scientist do not waste time exposing Jones' failed paper to embarrass him needlessly more than the obvious.

There is no good reason that this very unusual material should be found in regular construction material.
Not true for two reasons. First the material is not some super nano-thermite. There is not proof the size had special processing past that of what would be found in an Etch A Sketch, paint, coatings, or other uses in objects found in offices. Second, the materials found in the samples are found in the WTC, there were zero evidence the materials sent to Jones from dust allegedly found in NYC have elements not found from stuff in the WTC. No evidence the dust was engineered past that that would be found at the WTC. Iron rust; found at the WTC. Aluminum and products of Al, all over the WTC, the cladding on the WTC is Al! Even paint contains the junk in Jones dust samples. No one has proved the dust samples are not from objects normally found in the WTC.

totally unaccounted energy source that can be highly tailored to a wide variety of applications.
10 times less energy than jet fuel? The thermite material is not a good energy source. Office contents have more heat energy. ... zero evidence of thermite damage to WTC steel and no termite products found in the WTC.

How can Jones support the thermite in the ceiling tile scenario with remote detonators?


Jones paper says -
Iron oxide appears in faceted grains roughly 100 nm across whereas the aluminum appears in thin platelike structures. The small size of the iron oxide particles qualifies the material to be characterized as nanothermite or super-thermite.
The truth? These particles are not very nano size, they are at the top edge of being nano. The fact is they are exactly like pigments; LOL big time; PIGMENTS!!!
In fact pigments can be more nano sized than the so called super thermite the paper tries to claim. Fe3O4 pigments with a particle diameter of 2 to 100 nm. The paper discovered pigment and proved it when the energy was not the same as thermite. Nano material for coatings is centuries old; There is no proof of the use of thermite to bring down the towers and the dust used by Jones in his paper published in a vanity journal is more like some coating on something in the WTC, even paper auto ignites near 430C, so does the dust; so?

All the facts are found easy on-line. Did Jones find paint pigments, or coating pigments?
 
I made a mistake when I said:

"Where's the thermite's source of oxygen, if Si is at best a combustible in thermite-like compounds?"

SiO2 can also be used as an oxidizer. Still, there's too little oxygen in my view. And we're not shown other elements also present in the sample which could also be bound to the Si and the O.
 
Which would be significant if they examined more than 1% of the steel. Seeing as how the vast majority of steel was whisked off to the Chinese recycling bin before an examination could even take place, no firm claims can be made on this subject. That is, unless you've somehow been exposed to a much larger sample size of the WTC steel than FEMA or NIST.

They examined critical pieces of steel. Once again, the pieces I pointed out were from the collapse initiation zone. You insist that thermite might have been used, but you simultanously argue that it wasn't used to cause the collapse? Seriously? That's the argument you're making? Because if you posit that the steel I present is not significant, then you argue that thermite was not involved in the initiation of the collapse.

One more time: Those pieces of steel were taken from the parts of the buildings where the collapse was known to start. Even truther advocates like Tony Szamboti does not argue against this. And one more time: You concede my argument when you try to write off steel from the collapse initiation zone as "insignificant". You admit that thermite did not cause the collapse when you do this.

The amount of times this tripe is linked to does not make it any stronger. Where have you seen a test that demonstrates that MEK can separate aluminosilicates into elemental Al and a Si compound? Nowhere? Me neither. Why do you assume the existence of a reaction for which you've never seen demonstrated somehow trumps detailed scientific analysis? That is the very definition of "pseudoscientific."

What MEK has done to the paint chip is irrelevant when I noted that the very steel it was used on shows no sign of melting. Why you continually ignore this is beyond me.

You can argue that NIST only investigated 1% of the steel and you'd be correct. You can argue that the paint chips did not dissolve in MEK, and you'd be correct. What you miss is that it's all irrelevant. As mentioned above, steel recovered from the part of the building where the collapse started showed no signs of melting from thermite. None at all. None of your attempts to inject results from irrelevant experiments does not change this. Thermite was demonstrated to have not been involved in causing the collapse. Unless you can show the pieces I presented showed signs of thermite induced melting, then you automatically fail. You concede that the collapse started fine without thermite. And anything else you present is a dodge of that fact.

The group response I gave earlier is exactly about the misunderstanding you (and others) keep hiding behind in order to avoid the conclusions of the HFJ paper. Namely, the substance they found is NOT thermite. It is "thermitic" meaning is has thermite-like properties but having a much lower ignition temperature and a wide range of burn rates and exothermic variables.

And for the third time in this post alone: You have not demonstrated that it actually had an effect on the steel. See above. No effect on the steel where the collapse started. None.

To claim "it's not thermite, therefore they're dumb" is a non-argument in this case. No one is claiming it's thermite except the "debunkers." This is not a conventional material by any stretch of the imagination.

And I'm telling you that it's irrelevant what it is, because I've demonstrated that it had no effect. For the fourth time: Look at the images I pointed out, and tell me which of those columns were melted. If you cannot do that, you fail, since those columns are critical to the collapse due to their location. They are located where the collapse started. Plain and simple.

_______


It's real far from being refuted. Do you think that an examination of 1% of the steel is a "thorough investigation" by which you can make sweeping claims about the condition of the other 99%?

See above. You have completely dodged the argument. You have failed to demonstrate it's effect on the recovered steel.

That's shoddy logic.

I'm not the one ignoring evidence.

As I've said before, I don't know how this substance was used in the towers. All that can be said at this point is that it shouldn't be there. So, why is it there and who put it there?

No, the question is: Why are you truthers obsessiing over this when it is irrefutable that it was not used? For the fifth time: Those columns were where the collapse started. Are you saying that thermite was not involved in causing the towers to collapse? Because that is exactly what you argue if you continue to ignore the significance of columns in the collapse initiation zone showing zero signs of melting.

And as an aside: The substance was not "thermitic", or whatever term you want to slap on it. Kaolinite was demonstrated to be present. Gypsum as well. The presence of kaolinite and gypsum accounts for many of the spectroscopic and chemical properties Jones and Harrit noted. Read the link. In fact, you need to read the thread the linked post is from. Heck, you also need to read the first few pages of this thread; you seem to be ignoring much in your arguments that has already covered. The conclusion that Jones, Harrit, etc. have stated have been demonstrated to be incorrectly drawn. You cannot succeed in your argument without acknowledging what has already been demonstrated.
 
They examined critical pieces of steel. Once again, the pieces I pointed out were from the collapse initiation zone. You insist that thermite might have been used, but you simultanously argue that it wasn't used to cause the collapse? Seriously? That's the argument you're making? Because if you posit that the steel I present is not significant, then you argue that thermite was not involved in the initiation of the collapse.

One more time: Those pieces of steel were taken from the parts of the buildings where the collapse was known to start. Even truther advocates like Tony Szamboti does not argue against this. And one more time: You concede my argument when you try to write off steel from the collapse initiation zone as "insignificant". You admit that thermite did not cause the collapse when you do this.



What MEK has done to the paint chip is irrelevant when I noted that the very steel it was used on shows no sign of melting. Why you continually ignore this is beyond me.

You can argue that NIST only investigated 1% of the steel and you'd be correct. You can argue that the paint chips did not dissolve in MEK, and you'd be correct. What you miss is that it's all irrelevant. As mentioned above, steel recovered from the part of the building where the collapse started showed no signs of melting from thermite. None at all. None of your attempts to inject results from irrelevant experiments does not change this. Thermite was demonstrated to have not been involved in causing the collapse. Unless you can show the pieces I presented showed signs of thermite induced melting, then you automatically fail. You concede that the collapse started fine without thermite. And anything else you present is a dodge of that fact.



And for the third time in this post alone: You have not demonstrated that it actually had an effect on the steel. See above. No effect on the steel where the collapse started. None.



And I'm telling you that it's irrelevant what it is, because I've demonstrated that it had no effect. For the fourth time: Look at the images I pointed out, and tell me which of those columns were melted. If you cannot do that, you fail, since those columns are critical to the collapse due to their location. They are located where the collapse started. Plain and simple.

_______




See above. You have completely dodged the argument. You have failed to demonstrate it's effect on the recovered steel.



I'm not the one ignoring evidence.



No, the question is: Why are you truthers obsessiing over this when it is irrefutable that it was not used? For the fifth time: Those columns were where the collapse started. Are you saying that thermite was not involved in causing the towers to collapse? Because that is exactly what you argue if you continue to ignore the significance of columns in the collapse initiation zone showing zero signs of melting.

And as an aside: The substance was not "thermitic", or whatever term you want to slap on it. Kaolinite was demonstrated to be present. Gypsum as well. The presence of kaolinite and gypsum accounts for many of the spectroscopic and chemical properties Jones and Harrit noted. Read the link. In fact, you need to read the thread the linked post is from. Heck, you also need to read the first few pages of this thread; you seem to be ignoring much in your arguments that has already covered. The conclusion that Jones, Harrit, etc. have stated have been demonstrated to be incorrectly drawn. You cannot succeed in your argument without acknowledging what has already been demonstrated.


Your entire counterargument rests on an argument I've never made. In fact, I've said several times I do not know how this stuff was used.

Finding an unreacted incendiary material in the dust should be reason enough to look further. Attempts to dismiss it as "irrelevant" because it cannot be immediately linked to the recovered 1% of steel is a piss poor reason to look the other way.

And there was indeed strangely corroded steel recovered and studied by the WPI people--as you well know. To categorically dismiss a relation between a thermitic incendiary material and steel that demonstrated "Evidence of a severe high temperature corrosion attack on the steel, including oxidation and sulfidation with subsequent intergranular melting" would be negligent.

(FEMA/BPAT study, appendix C, pg. 1)

Did the thermitic material cause this? I don't know. Could it have? It's certainly possible. There may be reason to look further. Just maybe.


.
 
So it seems the issue is: IF the material examined by Jones & Co. was actually from GZ, and IF the "nano-sized" particles are indeed unusual, and IF the volitility of the substance did not require external oxygen...

Well, we can stop right there. A properly designed scientific experiment would eliminate all these IFs. Clearly, there was not enough expertise in Jones' "Dream Team" of scientists to accomplish that.
 
So it seems the issue is: IF the material examined by Jones & Co. was actually from GZ, and IF the "nano-sized" particles are indeed unusual, and IF the volitility of the substance did not require external oxygen...

Well, we can stop right there. A properly designed scientific experiment would eliminate all these IFs. Clearly, there was not enough expertise in Jones' "Dream Team" of scientists to accomplish that.

Exactly. And beyond that, this was done by many other entities. There are numerous other studies of WTC dust. Seriously, if there was an "explosive incindiary" in the WTC dust in any significant amount (and Jones et al claims there was LOTS OF IT), do you not think at least one, if not more, of these other groups of scientists would have mentioned it? Or are the truthers SO DUMB as to think that the bits of "thermite" were simply ignored.

They were not IGNORED, because they were NOT THERE. You can spin it all you want. You either have to draw the conclusion that (A) Jones and his group of bias scientists warped their findings through manipulation and bad science, to fit their preconceived theories, or (B) that numerous other, independent groups of scientists with no similar agenda, simply missed this material...multiple times.

Come on jay, for the love of god.

TAM:)
 
Your entire counterargument rests on an argument I've never made. In fact, I've said several times I do not know how this stuff was used.

You don't even know of any of "this stuff" was used. Bad methodology in the experiment and an inability to use independent labs which could tell you in 2 weeks EXACTLY what it is for $100. Why do you truthers insist on reinventing the wheel (and in a square shape too?)

Finding an unreacted incendiary material in the dust
stop right there. From this "paper" we have NO idea what was recovered in the dust. You have admitted it is riddled with methodological errors. Any paper or "paper" which is riddled with errors makes it impossible to take any of their findings, results or conclusions as valid.

throw out this junk and do it right.

should be reason enough to look further. Attempts to dismiss it as "irrelevant" because it cannot be immediately linked to the recovered 1% of steel is a piss poor reason to look the other way.

bad argument based on a bad starting point. You have demonstrated a full lack of understanding of any scientific principles. Hey what did that experimental design professor (or even a chemistry professor) tell you when you described trying to use a study riddled with methodological errors as the basis of your argument? I await that answer with baited breath (even though we both know you didn't and won't do what I suggested)

And there was indeed strangely corroded steel recovered and studied by the WPI people--as you well know. To categorically dismiss a relation between a thermitic incendiary material and steel that demonstrated "Evidence of a severe high temperature corrosion attack on the steel, including oxidation and sulfidation with subsequent intergranular melting" would be negligent.

Ah more datamining and not reading for comprehension. 1. no "thermetic incendiary" will cause "high temperature corrosion attack on the steel, including oxidation and sulfidation with subsequent intergranular melting." Do you even know what that means? That isn't how "thermetic incendiaries" work. Lack of reading for comprehension. Try again.

(FEMA/BPAT study, appendix C, pg. 1)

Did the thermitic material cause this? I don't know. Could it have? It's certainly possible. There may be reason to look further. Just maybe.
.

again and again, what THERMITIC material? So far you have NO PROOF that there was ANY THERMETIC materials in the dust.

Ok, lets go over basic experimental design for dummies. REady?
First you start with a hypothesis (HA). HA= The dust is filled with thermite/thermitic materials/pixie dust/godzilla poo. Next you set up your NULL hypothesis (HO). The null hypothesis states that wht you are looking for is nothing more than chance. The easiest way to state your HO is to state it is NOT the HA. So in this case the HO is NOT thermite/thermic materials/pixie dust/ or godzilla poo.

Now that we have set up the HA and the HO, we must do EVERYTHING we can do to eliminate the HO, to REJECT the NULL. Not to PROVE the HA.

So in order to even make the claim that there is ANYTHING there, we first have to ELIMINATE EVERY OTHER POSSIBLE EXPLAINATION.

Have you done that? Can you eliminate paint? YEs or no? No we can't. Why? Because this "paper" is riddled with so many different errors, we don't even know what the control paint was. Oops. can you eliminate paint in anyway, shape or form? No you cannot.

Why can you not eliminate paint? Oh, because the methodology of this "paper" is so ****ed up, that you can't eliminate something basic like paint. Oops.

Fine, lets ignore paint. (which you can't do. Since you can't eliminate it, you can't claim that it is "thermitic", but lets humor it). We ignore paint. Can you eliminate ANY OTHER POSSIBLE reason for this "material" to be in the dust? For example can you eliminate that it was planted in the dust?

What? You can't? Why not? Oh because you don't have a good chain of custody... damn... that is a whole other can of worms. Fine. Lets ignore the chain of custody (which you can't do. Since you can't eliminate it, you can't claim it is any thing, but lets humor it)

Can you eliminate that it is anything combusing in oxygen? (after all all forms of thermite/thermate/super duper inviso clean your room make your lunch nanothermite has its own oxygen and burns in a vacuum) What do you mean you can't eliminate any of that either? What? You did a test which doesn't show anything but something buringing in air?

Fine lets ignore that (which you can't because the mehtodology is ****ed up so is any conclusions you wish to draw, but lets humor it)

Can you show that it reacts like any "thermitic" materials? (as you have pointed out, you use nanothermite to tailor the materials) As it would be nanosized particles, I'm sure that when it was burned it released nearly identical amounts of energy per unit of materials, right? OH wait... it didn't do that either? How does a tailor made explosive/incendiary have wildly different energy released during the test? If it is nanosized it is done so to keep things consistent.

Now we have gone over the basics of the hypothesis, the null hypothesis and then tried to eliminate the null hypothesis. Can we eliminate the null hypothesis? No we cannot. Therefore we cannot claim that what was found was "thermitic", nor can we claim it is pixie dust or godzilla poo. (I bet godzilla is glad to be found innocent there... it was MOTHRA damn it.)

Go back to school and take some simple experimental design courses and you will then see why with over 20 methodological errors, NOTHING in this "paper" is valid.
 
Last edited:
(FEMA/BPAT study, appendix C, pg. 1)

Did the thermitic material cause this? I don't know. Could it have? It's certainly possible. There may be reason to look further. Just maybe.
.

The main argument of Jones to propose thermate was that appendix from FEMA report. The original argument is that thermate did it. In fact, he has not retracted from that yet, AFAIK

If you agree with all the thermite stuff , you must also agree that the thermite did that to the columns.
 
Finding an unreacted incendiary material in the dust should be reason enough to look further. Attempts to dismiss it as "irrelevant" because it cannot be immediately linked to the recovered 1% of steel is a piss poor reason to look the other way.

It's not that I linked it to only 1% of the steel. It's that I have demonstrated that "thermitic material" wasn't involved in causing the collapse to begin with. You can phrase it as "1%" all you want (which is hyperbole, BTW), but that ignores that these are columns who's condition clearly show how the collapse started. You ignore that with a glib "1%" statement; what matters is their significance, not their cumulative percentage. If you think "themitic material" was used, then it would have had to have been used on those columns. It would have had to have been those because they were the first to fail, and once the failures occurred, then Bazant and his colleagues established that the collapses would've progressed all the way to the ground. If the first columns to fail were not intentionally demolished, then the entire collapse is natural, not intentional demolition. Thermite use after the initiation of the collapse would not matter because the collapse would go all the way to completion once it started. Yet, "thermitic material" clearly was not the cause because those columns were clearly not severed via melting. It does not matter that you believe you "never made that argument", the fact remains is that you think "thermitic material" is involved somehow. What I am showing you is that if it was truly there - which it wasn't - then it didn't even have any effect. And you cannot refute that by saying "1%" over and over again like some parrot trained to repeat something without understanding its significance.

The only way you can counter this is to propose that the collapse started naturally, not via intentional demolitions, but would have arrested had not lower supports been severed. To do that, you have to refute Bazant and demonstrate that the collapse would have arrested, and only then is the fact that the studied core columns were untouoched by thermite become irrelevant. Unfortunately, you're not perceptive enough to make this argument. Your opponent has to make it for you, which speaks poorly about your level of knowledge regarding the event.

You cannot prove an argument when you do not know enough information to defend it properly. And that's what you're doing: You are failing to defend your argument properly because you are attempting to cite points that are not relevant. You are ignoring established knowledge and isolating your argument from all the context that actually establishes the boundaries of what could have been possible. You can continue to dodge all this all you want, but that doesn't help you establish your argument.

On top of all that: What Jones and Harrit "found" was not "thermitic" material. This has been established.
This post will form part of the rebuttal to Jones' paper. I've collated the information quickly in order to show JREF posters and any lurkers as soon as possible, but the evidence is quite damning.

Jones claims that samples a-d are essentially the same material and I agree with him. His paper's EDS spectra are very close and this confirms that the materials are identical.

Quote:
An analysis of the chips was performed to assess the similarity of the chips and to determine the chemistry and materials that make up the chips.

Quote:
All of the chips used in the study had a gray layer and a red layer and were attracted by a magnet.

Quote:
Similarities between the samples are already evident from these photographs.

We also have information from another source of Jones' chips namely a chip that has also had SEM and EDS analysis performed on them.

http://darksideofgravity.com/marseille.pdf

Comparing this report and Jones' we see from these SEM photo-micrographs that samples a-d are identical to the chip in the above report.

picture.php


We can now closely look at the morphology of the chips a-d and compare the structures therein to see whether there are any similarities between observed structures in the sample and known structures.

Jones' paper clearly examines these structures in samples a-d and notes

Quote:
The results indicate that the small particles with very high BSE intensity (brightness) are consistently 100 nm in size and have a faceted appearance. These bright particles are seen intermixed with plate-like particles

Quote:
By placing the beam on a cluster of plate-like particles, the spectrum in Fig. (11a) was generated. The spectrum in Fig. (11b) was acquired from a cluster of the smaller bright faceted grains. Again it was observed that the thin sheet-like particles are rich in Al and Si whereas the bright faceted grains are rich in Fe. Both spectra display significant carbon and oxygen

Quote:
The results indicate that the smaller particles with very bright BSE intensity are associated with the regions of high Fe and O. The plate-like particles with intermediate BSE intensity appear to be associated with the regions of high Al and Si. The O map (d) also indicates oxygen present, to a lesser degree, in the location of the Al and Si. However, it is inconclusive from these data whether the O is associated with Si or Al or both.

Until now.

The following photo-micrograph shows samples a-d (on the left) and Kaolinite (on the right).

picture.php



Examining the two side by side clearly shows similarity in size, crystal shape and thickness between the two groups of plate-like particles. Note the exact same style of grouping where platelets have "sandwiched" together in the top middle of b) and the top left of c) in Jones' samples and the exact same phenomenon in the photo to the right. This indicates very strongly that these particles are indeed Kaolinite.

There are many such photo-micrographs of Kaolinite available.

Therefore it is now essential that we examine EDS data of known samples of Kaolinite and compare them with the EDS data generated in Jones' paper. Note that I also include data from the chip sent in the report linked earlier. I have scaled these SEM spectra as best I can in a short space of time in order that the KeV scale matches across spectra.

One of Jones' claims, as is that of the author of the above linked report, is that the EDS spectra of the red layer show signs of contamination

Quote:
The resulting spectrum, shown in Fig. (14), produced the expected peaks for Fe, Si, Al, O, and C. Other peaks included calcium, sulfur, zinc, chromium and potassium. The occurrence of these elements could be attributed to surface contamination due to the fact that the analysis was performed on the as-collected surface of the red layer. The large Ca and S peaks may be due to contamination with gypsum from the pulverized wallboard material in the buildings.

Gypsum is a naturally occurring mineral and aswell as being used in wall board or drywall is also used in the manufacture of paint. The following are EDS spectra from Kaolinite with Gypsum, Fig 7 c) of Jones' paper and finally slide/page 14 of the above link.

picture.php


It is abundantly clear that the spectra share more than enough characteristics to say that not only is gypsum present, but that Kaolinte is too.

The plate-like structures seen in the photo-micrographs, of both "thermite chip" samples, share not only the same crystalline morphology and grouping, but also the same EDS signature.

This means that there is very little doubt remaining as to what these platelets are. In light of this evidence it is safe to say that these platelets consist of Kaolinite, which does not contain any "elemental aluminium". The SEM examination in Jones' paper does not show any other particle type (other than the rhomboidal Fe2O3) and no other data in the EDS spectra for samples a-d indicate it's presence.

Therefore these samples CANNOT be thermite.

QED.

For Jones to now claim that elemental aluminium is present then the only way to confirm this is by XRD analysis or a suitable equivalent.

We can also say that because Kaolinite is present and that it is embedded in a Carbon based matrix with Rhomboidal Fe2O3 that a more likely explanation for the red material is paint.

When we look at the material that the "red layer" in the samples is attached to and the notable difference in the structure compared to the "red layer" along with it's EDS spectra it is clear to see that this is a form of Iron Oxide. The corresponding Carbon peaks and the possibility of Mn peak at 5.9KeV indicate the source of this oxide as being steel.

If you also not in the second photo on this page you can clearly see this oxide layer is also attached to a crystalline fibrous material that again does not share morphology with the "red layer" or the "gray layer". The French paper linked has EDS data of this layer. Notable we do not see the underside of the "gray layer/iron oxide layer" in samples a-d in Jones paper.


Addition.

We can also see the EDS spectra of pure Kaolin for comparison and untreated clay which will explain any queries with the Carbon peak also noting that Carbon is closely associated with Fe in steel.

http://www.scielo.org.ar/scielo.php?...pt=sci_arttext

We can also confirm the presence in other spectra by comparing them eg Fig 11a), Fig 14 (noting the correlating high Ca, O and S peaks - gypsum), etc.
You cannot continue to assert the present of "thermitic material" when such material's presence has been contradicted. Again: Reread the first pages of this thread. And read the parent thread that lead to this one. You continue to argue points that have been refuted. You are behind us in your level of knowledge; all the counterarguments you've given are old hat, and were answered in that and this thread some time ago. Until you read the links we give you and confront what has already been established, then you get nowhere. You need to increase your level of knowledge before you proceed.
 
(continued)

And there was indeed strangely corroded steel recovered and studied by the WPI people--as you well know. To categorically dismiss a relation between a thermitic incendiary material and steel that demonstrated "Evidence of a severe high temperature corrosion attack on the steel, including oxidation and sulfidation with subsequent intergranular melting" would be negligent.

(FEMA/BPAT study, appendix C, pg. 1)

Did the thermitic material cause this? I don't know. Could it have? It's certainly possible. There may be reason to look further. Just maybe.

No, "thermitic material" did not cause this. You "don't know" because you're ignoring evidence, as well as discussions we've had over this in the past. While looking for previous posts where eutectics were discussed, I stumbled across this one by Ryan Mackey addressed to you. Odd that you cite the FEMA and WPI information, yet ignore what Ryan told you near the end of his post.

You act as though no one's ever looked into 9/11 before. You cite the WPI studies and ignore the fact that they were specifically conducted because of the observations FEMA noted in their Building Performance Study. You also conveniently seem to not remember that those Worchester researchers established the presence of a eutectic caused by sulfidation. Do you realize that the presence of that eutectic formation contradicts the whole notion of "thermitic material" being used? The maximum temperature that a eutectic can reach before it's destroyed must be above the melting point for the lowest melting-point "ingredient" in the mix (in this case, the iron sulfide), but at the same time must be below the temp for the item(s) that has(have) the highest melting point (in this case iron oxide). That presents an envelope of conditions that tell researchers what the minimum and maximum temperatures were. Do you realize that "thermitic materials" would exceed that? Do you realize that "thermitic material" would've destroyed the eutectic? Do you realize that those Worchester Polytechnic studies eliminate the possibility that the erosion Astaneh-Asl noted and FEMA recorded could have been caused by thermite?

Remedial reading on the subject:

"Thermitic material" (that's truther-speak for "A fantasy material that fits the properties necessary for me to propose a conspiracy") could not have caused that erosion. Once you study the properties of steel sulfidation and iron oxide-iron sulfide-steel eutectics, you will understand this. Unless you acknowledge that "thermitic materials" melt steel, and that the erosion very clearly was not molten steel but a chemical process, and that temperatures that melt steel would destroy eutectics, then you will continue to fail to understand the event.
 
aggle-rithm said:
So it seems the issue is: IF the material examined by Jones & Co. was actually from GZ, and IF the "nano-sized" particles are indeed unusual, and IF the volitility of the substance did not require external oxygen...

Well, we can stop right there. A properly designed scientific experiment would eliminate all these IFs. Clearly, there was not enough expertise in Jones' "Dream Team" of scientists to accomplish that.

Exactly. And beyond that, this was done by many other entities. There are numerous other studies of WTC dust. Seriously, if there was an "explosive incindiary" in the WTC dust in any significant amount (and Jones et al claims there was LOTS OF IT), do you not think at least one, if not more, of these other groups of scientists would have mentioned it? Or are the truthers SO DUMB as to think that the bits of "thermite" were simply ignored.

They were not IGNORED, because they were NOT THERE. You can spin it all you want. You either have to draw the conclusion that (A) Jones and his group of bias scientists warped their findings through manipulation and bad science, to fit their preconceived theories, or (B) that numerous other, independent groups of scientists with no similar agenda, simply missed this material...multiple times.

Come on jay, for the love of god.

TAM:)

So your reason to dismiss this as not real is that you sincerely believe that the HFJ team made or found this material and are simply claiming they found it in the dust?

What evidence do you have that they did not find this material in the dust? If your only reason to doubt that is that you don't like the conclusions, that's not good enough.

When Jones was claiming the microspheres were evidence of thermite, everyone here was doubting that because they claimed there wasn't enough evidence to make that determination. Now here is strong corroborative evidence to support that claim and the best you can do is double down on your doubt without any supporting evidence.

If you don't think this stuff was in the dust, then just quit writing. There's nothing more to talk about.



.
 
They examined critical pieces of steel. Once again, the pieces I pointed out were from the collapse initiation zone. You insist that thermite might have been used, but you simultanously argue that it wasn't used to cause the collapse?

This will surely not be the last time I need to spell this out, as no one here seems capable of reading this sentence: I don't know how the stuff was used. Do you understand me?

That is NOT equivalent to saying it wasn't used in the collapse of the buildings. Do you acknowledge that?

You are implying that if this material was used, then it was necessarily used in the collapse region and it was the only substance used. Neither of those necessarily follow. All the rest of your post I omitted is just a restatement of this basic misunderstanding (pretend or real) of what I'm saying. Until you understand what I'm saying, you're just arguing at cross-purposes.

We can't even start speculating about the possibilities of how this stuff was used until we can all agree that this stuff was in fact in the WTC dust.

Can we agree on that?

And as an aside: The substance was not "thermitic", or whatever term you want to slap on it. Kaolinite was demonstrated to be present.

Back with the kaolinite again... Kaolinite was never "demonstrated to be present." It was demonstrated that kaolinite has a similar morphology to the plate-like structures in the red part of the WTC dust chips. Until it has been demonstrated that MEK causes a chemical reaction in aluminosilicates that causes the aluminum to become unbound from the silicon, the only thing being demonstrated is an inability to understand basic chemistry.


.
 
Back with the kaolinite again... Kaolinite was never "demonstrated to be present." It was demonstrated that kaolinite has a similar morphology to the plate-like structures in the red part of the WTC dust chips. Until it has been demonstrated that MEK causes a chemical reaction in aluminosilicates that causes the aluminum to become unbound from the silicon, the only thing being demonstrated is an inability to understand basic chemistry.
Once again, the MEK chip was different to samples 1-4. Samples 1-4 were proved within a very ample confidence margin to have kaolinite. None of samples 1-4 was soaked in MEK, thus there's no proof that the Al was not chemically bound to the Si in the MEK chip. The MEK chip contained, at best, very little iron oxide, especially compared to samples 1-4, making hard to believe both that they are of the same nature and that they are made of thermite. Therefore, there's no basis to hold the conclusions of the article.

The burden of proof was on them to rule out kaolinite in these samples, given the likeliness for it. They neglected to do that, and instead chose to soak a different, claimed-to-be-contaminated chip in MEK, with a composition that is not similar to that of samples 1-4, without showing the claimed contamination. Given the extraordinary likeliness of kaolinite, it required extraordinary proof to prove it wrong and show the separation; instead, they dipped one finger and tasted another.

That just piles up on top of all that TruthersLie has already noted.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom