God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

I fear you are in the wrong thread, please leave at your earliest convenience.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Start with my concept of God, present your objections in logical statements.

One thing at a time.

Better, think over your objections against my concept of God, and connect them together to get to the real point you want to make, instead of throwing out so many things without any mutual linkage.

Yrreg



OK, but it seems a little off that you put many things out at once while wanting me to confine myself to one point at a time. I raised no more points than you did in the post to which I was responding.

The definition of God you have presented is not distinguishable as Christian, only as a male universe maker, but you keep bringing up his Christian nature when there's nothing in the definition that establishes that nature. I think you should leave Christianity out of it until you've done more to link the concept with Christianity. Otherwise you're treating your definition as really being 'the Christian God who is the maker of the universe', which is not nearly as simple a concept as the one you initially proposed.



Okay, you tell me then what is your concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.


You don't want to talk about the Christian God?

But that is what I am concerned with, or you want to talk about the gods of other religions?

In which case I must ask of you to depart from this thread because all my concern is with the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe, and I have defined my concept of the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe as:

God = Maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.


And my definition of the concept of the universe is:

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.


I fear that you are in the wrong thread, please leave at your earliest convenience.

Otherwise I will seriously suspect that you are into mockery, parody, and evasions, more in particular, evasions.




Yrreg
 
In which case I must ask of you to depart from this thread because all my concern is with the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe, and I have defined my concept of the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe as:

God = Maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.

And yet you describe the Big Bang. Is that all your god is? The Christian god is simply the Big Bang? Ok, if you want to call it that.
 
Otherwise I will seriously suspect that you are into mockery, parody, and evasions, more in particular, evasions.

What has caused you to suspect, reckon, guess, surmise, conjecture, conclude, have a hunch that you are the target of ridicule, derision, jeering, sneering, contempt, scorn, scoffing, teasing, taunting, sarcasm?
 
You guys just keep on shooting out with your mouths, not reading with comprehension.

Originally Posted by yrreg
You see, reality is made up of two things: potential entities and actual entities.

An actual entity cannot come to existence unless there is a possible concept of it.





No. An actual entity exists whether or not anyone has a concept of it.

For example, the Galilean moons of Jupiter were first observed by Galileo in 1609 and 1610. Before this there was no concept of moons orbiting any planet other than the Earth. But the moons of Jupiter (and of Mars, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune) all existed long before this.


You are not reading with genuine comprehension, read again what I said and try to be relevant, othewise I will seriously suspect that you are into mockery, parody, and evasions -- and derailing the thread.

Read again what I said about potential entities and actual entitites.


You guys so many of you just keep on shooting out your mouths without having read with comprehension.




Yrreg
 
David, you seem to be level-headed, I invite you to interact with me.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Now we want to come to agreement on the concept of the universe.


Here is my concept of the universe:

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

Do you have your concept of the universe? so that we can work out together to come to the common concept of the universe we both can use to arrive at the existence of God from the universe as the evidence.



Yrreg





I would mostly agree with this, as long as we keep imagination inside people's heads.



David, you seem to be level-headed, I invite you to interact with me.


Here are the two concepts I like you and me to work out together to come to their final formulation, and then we will take the expedition to search for evidence in the universe leading us to the ascertainment of God’s existence:


God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

​


Have you noticed that atheists just keep on and on avoiding to first come to agree on concepts, before proceeding to the exercise of searching for evidence or to the demonstration by reason that God exists or does not exists in actual reality.



Yrreg
 
Don't dwell in the past anymore, are you not going to reply to my latest message addressed to you, here below, 8 hours earlier, or you really don't care to keep on track?


Gerry, why don't you stop with the arrogance directed toward atheists, mmmkay? You have done this before in the past and it's not productive in moving a discussion forward.



Please be attentive, otherwise I will suspect very seriously that you are just into mockery, parody, and evasions, instead of genuine sincere interaction on the issue of God or no God.

I have a suggestion here; Why don't you become more personable and engage people in a more productive way? Your assessment below shows contempt and the real reason why you won't go point, counter-point with people. You don't know how or just don't want to, which is it?

That is why this issue of God or no God never ends with atheists because they are into mockery, parody, and evasions, for example by not being attentive sincerely attentive to the reasoning from people who do take the interest and care to try to reason with them.
 
I ascertain that Gerry will use the words mockery, parody and evasive many times...;)


You reckon?

Please don't engage in mockery, parody, and evasions.
Otherwise I see nothing in your post but mockery, parody, and evasions.
Otherwise, you are going the direction of atheists who are completely and exclusively into mockery, parody, and evasions instead of rational logical substantially relevant speech in the issue of God or no God.
You are not saying anything useful, except to go into mockery, parody, and evasions.
Okay, you are serious and relevant, then say your message again sans the mockery, parody, and evasions.

Put on top of your message this inscription in bold font: Yrreg, I am serious, no mockery, parody, and evasions here.
Please be attentive, otherwise I will suspect very seriously that you are just into mockery, parody, and evasions, instead of genuine sincere interaction on the issue of God or no God.

That is why this issue of God or no God never ends with atheists because they are into mockery, parody, and evasions, for example by not being attentive sincerely attentive to the reasoning from people who do take the interest and care to try to reason with them.
I fear that you are in the wrong thread, please leave at your earliest convenience.

Otherwise I will seriously suspect that you are into mockery, parody, and evasions, more in particular, evasions.
You are not reading with genuine comprehension, read again what I said and try to be relevant, othewise I will seriously suspect that you are into mockery, parody, and evasions -- and derailing the thread.
 
You don't want to talk about the Christian God?


You seem to be unwilling or unable to provide a definition of the Christian God that is capable of distinguishing it from any of a large number of other entities. Define it adequately, and maybe we can discuss it.
 
Have you noticed that atheists just keep on and on avoiding to first come to agree on concepts, before proceeding to the exercise of searching for evidence or to the demonstration by reason that God exists or does not exists in actual reality.



Yrreg

Have you noticed that you didn't do what I told you to do? You should calm down and start using logical arguments.

Now, tell me more about this Big Bang god of yours. Other than starting up the universe, does it have any other properties?
 
You know about division in the Christian faith, tell me what you know about the...

If you are talking solely about the Christian god than we are getting into a totally different discussion. There have been so many divisions and sects in Christianity by this point that you really need to first define which Christian viewpoint you are describing this god from.

Don't feel bad about the Christian god not being a self evident concept. All gods become like this as they mature. Even the sun goddess Amaterasu has a lot of debate over her nature, including what gender she is and exactly how the Japanese royal family are related to her.

Take your time and try to compose what exactly you mean by the Christian god. Just creator of the universe is not enough of a definition really, the Bible has two different creation stories. Once you have a clearer definition we can begin to discuss it.


You know about division in the Christian faith, tell me what you know about the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in God's fundamental relation to the universe.


Unless your concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe and mine jibe, it is illogical for me to continue with you, because you will be talking in another dimension, but not in my concern here in this thread.


Can you comprehend that, that it is illogical for me as for you, for us to talk about God, unless we want to talk past each other's head, which is a waste of time and labor and bandwidth except to display whatever of vanity silly vanity to readers here.




Yrreg
 
You know about division in the Christian faith, tell me what you know about the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in God's fundamental relation to the universe.


Unless your concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe and mine jibe, it is illogical for me to continue with you, because you will be talking in another dimension, but not in my concern here in this thread.


Can you comprehend that, that it is illogical for me as for you, for us to talk about God, unless we want to talk past each other's head, which is a waste of time and labor and bandwidth except to display whatever of vanity silly vanity to readers here.




Yrreg

So you only want to talk to people who already believe in your personal Big Bang god?
 
I am saying that you have the wrong comprehension, because you are careless.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Read again what I said about potential entities and actual entitites.





I've read it. It's wrong.



What have you read that is wrong?

I am saying that you have the wrong comprehension.

So, tell me what you have comprehended from my words, and don't neglect to reproduce my words faithfully.




Yrreg
 
Hey yrreg! Read this!

Don't dwell in the past anymore, are you not going to reply to my latest message addressed to you, here below, 8 hours earlier, or you really don't care to keep on track?


Hey yrreg, you're doing it again.

That post you keep attributing to dlorde was written by me, not dlorde.
(Proof that I wrote it)


To address your post, I will agree that "The nose of man is a part and parcel of the universe".

Now, will you please present your argument? It really isn't necessary for ypu to try to string us along like puppets. Just state your points (assumptions, arguments, definitions, whatever) and use them to reach your conclusion. Ideally, provide justification for your arguments, too. That way you'll actually get somewhere, and we can get down to seeing if your argument is convincing, where it is strong, and where it could use more thought.
 
How to abuse of message titles using an editorial like style, ending with ellipsis...

Yrreg reloaded. As always, everything boiling down to concerns related to power, all wrapped up in a deified fashion and a godly disguise. Another stay for the same boring corset.
 
Owing to so many who are into useless prattle, I have to adopt a quick criterion.

Owing to so many who are into useless prattle, I have to adopt a quick criterion whom to give attention to.


There are posters here in this thread who are confirmed wastrels of my time and labor, so I do not read them anymore, it is a loss of time and labor from my part; I don't maintain an answering service to give them the attention they crave, for I am only one and they are legion.

Now with people who appear to be into logical rational productive substantial speech, I will read them but when I judge from the first say 50 words that they are not in their rational mood but into mockery, parody, and evasions, or seeking to derail the thread, I stop reading and proceed to the next post.


Sometimes I get mixed up with the identity of the poster I am replying to.

In which case I regret sincerely, but that is unavoidable when there are a legion of you atheists, whose heart and mind is not truly sincerely attentively substantially seriously relevantly truth-seeking-ly into the issue of God or no God, but into mockery, parody, evasions, and now attempts at derail or sabotage, to stop the thread from taking off at all, or to obstruct its development.


Now, as regards my getting mixed up with the identity of the poster I am responding to, just the same if you get my message, please react.

For example one poster agrees to accept my concepts of God and of universe, but I thought it was another one, so that poster whoever who agrees with me, we can continue further on to work together to the disquisition of my thesis that the universe is the evidence for God's existence.


But regrettably what I witness next time around with that poster, is that that poster lapses into mockery, parody, evasions, instead of proceeding from the agreed on concepts to work together with me to the resolution of the question, the universe is the evidence for God's existence.


So, atheists who are truly after the facts and the truth, exert your utmost efforts to abstain from your self-inured instinct to dwell on mockery, parody, evasions, and all other kinds of gimmicks in order to avoid altogether the issue of God or no God.


Start with working out with me on the mutually accepted concepts of God as of the universe and also all other concepts which are crucially vital in the resolution of the issue God or no God.




If you do not at all care to come with me to mutually accepted concepts of God, universe, existence, evidence, then please leave at your earliest convenience, for you are wasting readers' time, who care to read something that is relevant to the issue of God or no God logically expounded.


Now, here is a term that might be of interest to readers to mull on, namely. atheists are laboring under the burden of conceptual xenophobia, when they are not at all keen on and even hostile to the logical first step in an exchange of thoughts, namely: get to come with all contending parties to mutually accepted concepts crucially vital in the resolution of the issue.




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom