God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

If you do not at all care to come with me to mutually accepted concepts of God, universe, existence, evidence, then please leave at your earliest convenience, for you are wasting readers' time, who care to read something that is relevant to the issue of God or no God logically expounded.


Yrreg

Ok, I'm imagining another concept of a god who created the universe. She commanded men to be subservient to their wives. Women were to be the head of the household. Is that the same concept of god you were thinking of?

She was destroyed in the Big Bang but her words lived on.
 
Here is the development of the argument the universe is the evidence for God's...

Hey yrreg, you're doing it again.

That post you keep attributing to dlorde was written by me, not dlorde.
(Proof that I wrote it)


To address your post, I will agree that "The nose of man is a part and parcel of the universe".

Now, will you please present your argument? It really isn't necessary for ypu to try to string us along like puppets. Just state your points (assumptions, arguments, definitions, whatever) and use them to reach your conclusion. Ideally, provide justification for your arguments, too. That way you'll actually get somewhere, and we can get down to seeing if your argument is convincing, where it is strong, and where it could use more thought.



Here is the development of the argument the universe is the evidence for God's existence.



That is most gentlemanly on your part, [dlorde] X; yes let us proceed further.



At the cost of being accused of repetitiousness, let me just the same repeat the concept of God and the concept of the universe from yours truly, which you elorde have agreed to accept for the purpose of this exercise, to prove the existence of God from the fact of the existence of the universe as evidence.

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

​


Okay, here we go, into the expedition to find evidence in the universe pointing to the existence of God corresponding to the concept as maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


The nose of man is a part and parcel of the universe, can you agree with me on that?


You say, "To address your post, I will agree that "The nose of man is a part and parcel of the universe".


Now, do you also agree that the nose has a beginning and an ending, the one in your face as also in everyone's face?



Yrreg
 
...all my concern is with the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe, and I have defined my concept of the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe as:

God = Maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.


I agree, you have defined a god, specifically the kind of god you wish to discuss. You have also made a leap of faith that such a god exists and an even larger leap of faith that it is the Christian god as described in Biblical texts.

And even though your definition fits many gods that have been and are believed in, I accept your definition for the purposes of this discussion.


And my definition of the concept of the universe is:

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.


I accept your definition of the universe apart from the subject of man's imagination and discourse. Man imagined gods. That does not mean that gods are part of the universe or that they exist outside the universe.


So, essentially, I accept your definition of a god, but do not share your belief in one, and I accept your definition of the universe with the exception of the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

What's next?
 
Yes. The nose has a beginning ("bridge", or "glasses-hanger") and ending ("tip", or "useful tool for finding walls in the dark").



---


I honestly don't see why you can't just state your premises all in one post, like anyone else would.

For example, the first-cause argument for god:
Premise 1) Everything that begins to exist has a cause.
Premise 2) The Universe began to exist.
Conclusion 1) It follows from Premise 1 and Premise 2 that the Universe had a cause.
Definition 1) The cause of the universe is defined by some as "god".
Conclusion 2) Based on Conclusion 1 and Definition 1, god can be assumed to exist.


See? It isn't necessary to demand we agree with each and every sub-point in order. Just post up your argument, in it's entirety.
 
Ask yourself if you are an author what is the fundamental concept of an author in relation to his literary works?

The clue is in the name. It's both a noun and a verb isn't it? The author authors (writes) them. The author is the author of his/her literary works.
 
Yes. The nose has a beginning ("bridge", or "glasses-hanger") and ending ("tip", or "useful tool for finding walls in the dark").



---


I honestly don't see why you can't just state your premises all in one post, like anyone else would.

For example, the first-cause argument for god:
Premise 1) Everything that begins to exist has a cause.
Premise 2) The Universe began to exist.
Conclusion 1) It follows from Premise 1 and Premise 2 that the Universe had a cause.
Definition 1) The cause of the universe is defined by some as "god".
Conclusion 2) Based on Conclusion 1 and Definition 1, god can be assumed to exist.


See? It isn't necessary to demand we agree with each and every sub-point in order. Just post up your argument, in it's entirety.
.
"Noses were made to have a place to rest our spectacles"...Rev. Paley...
Also the author of the "blind watchmaker" idea.
 
You know about division in the Christian faith, tell me what you know about the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in God's fundamental relation to the universe.

Unless your concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe and mine jibe, it is illogical for me to continue with you, because you will be talking in another dimension, but not in my concern here in this thread.

Can you comprehend that, that it is illogical for me as for you, for us to talk about God, unless we want to talk past each other's head, which is a waste of time and labor and bandwidth except to display whatever of vanity silly vanity to readers here.

Um, that's why I was asking you what you believe about the Christian god. I mean, do you believe in the trinity? Are you a gnostic, meaning you believe that the nature of god can be known and understood? Do you believe in the Pope as the representative of gods law in this world and the keeper of the keys of heaven? Do you believe that the laws of the old testament no longer apply? There are so many questions that come with someone saying they are Christian, it's not a monolithic religion by any stretch of the imagination.

It is easier for you to simply tell me about your god than for me to play 20 questions with you trying to figure out which bits of Christianity you do and don't believe in. Christianity has a few thousand years of alterations, revisions and heresies behind it. I can make no assumptions about what someone believes based on them saying they are Christian. I mean, there are self professed Christians who don't believe Jesus was divine! At that point anything goes.
 
Don't dwell in the past anymore, are you not going to reply to my latest message addressed to you, here below, 8 hours earlier, or you really don't care to keep on track?
Sadly it's you who is not keeping track. Your question was asked of someone else whose post you prefixed with mine and confused yourself into believing the whole assembly was mine. It wasn't, as I told you 13 hours ago, and the other party told you 11 hours ago.

It's your thread; please try to keep up. Anyone would think you're not taking it seriously.
 
Um, that's why I was asking you what you believe about the Christian god. I mean, do you believe in the trinity? Are you a gnostic, meaning you believe that the nature of god can be known and understood? Do you believe in the Pope as the representative of gods law in this world and the keeper of the keys of heaven? Do you believe that the laws of the old testament no longer apply? There are so many questions that come with someone saying they are Christian, it's not a monolithic religion by any stretch of the imagination.

It is easier for you to simply tell me about your god than for me to play 20 questions with you trying to figure out which bits of Christianity you do and don't believe in. Christianity has a few thousand years of alterations, revisions and heresies behind it. I can make no assumptions about what someone believes based on them saying they are Christian. I mean, there are self professed Christians who don't believe Jesus was divine! At that point anything goes.

I'll help you out: Yrreg is a Filipino and a Catholic.
 
I will make a list of the people who agree with me on the concepts of God and the...

Here again are my concepts of God and the universe:


God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.


For those who accept them for the purpose of this thread, that the universe is the evidence for the existence of God, we are now into effecting an agreement on whether in nose in our face has a beginning and an ending.



I have to make a list of such posters who agree with me on my concepts of God and the universe.


The rest of you who don't agree with me, there can be no logical exchange with you because you are talking about other things.

So there is no sense with me giving you any attention whatsoever.




Yrreg
 
I have to make a list of such posters who agree with me on my concepts of God and the universe.


Why don't you just post your argument, premise to conclusion?
It would give you a chance to actually state it (a position I honestly cannot recall you ever having reached before), and it would not give the "wastrels" time to distract you with their banter.
 
Okay, it's been nearly two years, so let's sum up: God is the maker of everything in the universe except himself, and the nose has a beginning and an end.

Maybe in two years time, we'll get some further points.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom