Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

You're the one playing loose and fast with what she said. I gave the quote. It fails to match your claim.

Other police tactics and experts say what they did was entirely within the acceptable use and standard procedures of many departments.

I see Katehi has successfully convinced you that the police acted entirely contrary to her explicit orders, even though there were no such orders.


This has been discussed extensively in an earlier thread. Police tactics experts have already weighed in on the issue and their quotes cited as evidence that the Davis police response was appropriate.


That's real fascinating and all... but my comments on this case have nothing to do with 'police tactics', whatever the hell you think you were trying to say with that. I'm talking about about vicarious liability and policy.

Again, read my sig file, I don't care what side you think is right, the case law on use of force isn't up to your imaginary experts ideas of 'appropriate'.

For the issue of vicarious liabiity in law enforcement, right now it doesn't matter who the Chancellor has 'convinced', at this point it doesn't matter if you think she and the 13 others made it up completely, what matters for these cops to be hung out, is that she is on record as claiming she said it.
The links I posted prove that, as do all the other records of her claiming she said it, and you can deny that from behind your keyboard all you want, nobody is going to care.
 
Last edited:
I suppose there were other options the cops could have gone for:


  • Breaking the arms of those blocking them in
  • Tossing those they arrested over those blocking them in
  • Fire hose those blocking them in
  • Sit the people they had arrested down and see if they can wait for an attack of the munchies to break the will of those blocking them in
  • Dogs......just lots of dogs
  • Throw away the rule of law and just release those they had arrested because a large crowd wants them to
 
Please entertain us with this decision, WildCat, and maybe you could also respond to me this time???!!!
Why do you think that decision is applicable? Did you read the reasoning behind it?
 
That's real fascinating and all... but my comments on this case have nothing to do with 'police tactics', whatever the hell you think you were trying to say with that.
Then you are speaking out of ignorance, since you have obviously missed this part of the discussion.

Again, read my sig file, I don't care what side you think is right, the case law on use of force isn't up to your imaginary experts ideas of 'appropriate'.
That would be for the courts to decide if that decision applies in this particular situation. I tend to agree other with the other police policy and tactics experts who say it does not. What they did was done according to policy in other departments, but you wouldn't know about this since you are uniformed on this topic. You really think that other departments would allow this if in fact the court decision prevents it?

For the issue of vicarious liabiity in law enforcement, right now it doesn't matter who the Chancellor has 'convinced', at this point it doesn't matter if you think she and the 13 others made it up completely, what matters for these cops to be hung out, is that she is on record as claiming she said it.
That's just it. Her weaselly, cover-her-ass statement doesn't say what you claim it does.

The links I posted prove that, as do all the other records of her claiming she said it, and you can deny that from behind your keyboard all you want, nobody is going to care.
Proves nothing of the kind. I gave her exact quote. It doesn't match your claim.
 
Good for them. There is no reason to pepper-spray people who are peacefully protesting.
They weren't "peacefully protesting", they were actively obstructing and threatening police officers. They had to stop "peacefully protesting" to do so. They were the aggressors, not the cops.



And as for "blocking a public sidewalk".. do you have evidence? Did they deny anyone from walking? If a person asked to go through, would they not have unlocked arms to let that person through?


No. The cops tried that, even warned them about pepper spray, and they refused to move.
 
Your complete and utter ignorance of the matter is also noted.

The UC Davis Chancellor is on record as saying that she specifically ordered her employees, the police not to use force to make people leave.

ETA: http://articles.latimes.com/2011/nov/21/local/la-me-1122-ucdavis-protest-20111122
...
No, according to the article, she said she did not tell them to use pepper spray. She did not claim that she told them they couldn't use pepper spray. It's a politicians' answer.

You are simply playing semantic games. What the Chancellor ordered was well understood.

http://www.davisenterprise.com/loca...f-huddled-with-13-on-decision-to-remove-camp/

The policy on use of force, which as already mentioned is predicated on case law and specific regulations, limits pepper spray to certain situations.

http://www.davisenterprise.com/local-news/ucd/2002-court-ruling-limits-use-of-pepper-spray/
I saw the UCPD policy the last time this came up. The officers were acting within its bounds. In fact, they had finished to job the Chancellor sent them to do and were attempting to leave peacefully when the students chose to obstruct and threaten them.

The Chancellor ruled out one of those situations (using violence to move the protestors), and the only way that the police would have been authorized to deploy OC would have been as a proportionate response to actual threat of attack.
Incorrect. Police are allowed to use pepper spray to enforce compliance. In addition, they did not spray the entire crowd despite the threats and hostile atmosphere, only the few people who were directly obstructing them. They acted with restraint.

These internet games of 'well this actually could have meant that on a different space-time continuum' are idle speculation.

If you want to actually do something about police abuses, sitting around parroting a bunch of superstitious internet gossip isn't it.
You can't actually disprove the fact that the Chancellor's phrasing was ambiguous and she did not actually say what you say she said, so personal attacks.

Incidentally, the Humboldt case came up too. The UCPD police had no way of removing the students short of pepper spray, and they had systematically tried all lesser force. Just wrestling them apart is actually much more likely to cause harm than pepper spray, especially since that linked arm setup is designed specifically to make it hard to disengage the protesters in question. I'm talking risk of dislocated or broken limbs, here, and it's going to look just as bad to the cameras. In the Humboldt case, the cops put pepper spray on q-tips and applied it directly to the eyes of protestors to make them give up the keys, even though they could have and did just cut them apart. Please note that this was in 1992, long before pepper spray became a standard compliance tool and standards for its use were established.

UC Davis Police Chief Annette Spicuzza, who has since been placed on administrative leave, said after the incident that the situation was a tough one for her officers to walk into.

“This was 50 people and before you knew it, it probably grew close to 200 (protesters),” she said. “When you encircle a group of officers that are just trying to do their jobs, it’s kinda scary, but they did a great job.”

Risher, however, said, “From what I’ve seen, for the police to think they were threatened … it’s very very difficult to imagine that a reasonable officer would be threatened by the students that you see in the video, sitting on the ground with linked arms.”
Note how Risher seems to have a completely different interpretation of the scene from Spicuzza, one which is rather at odds with the reality of dozens of hostile students surrounding and obstructing a handful of officers.

For a guy who's not on a "side", you sure sound like you're on a side.

I find it weird that no one saying this is wrong is able to provide any kind of reasonable alternative, and have to keep strawmanning "the students threatened the police" into "the police felt threatened". I can threaten an Abrams tank while I'm naked and holding a butter knife, but the fact that the only risk to the occupants is death by laughter does not change the fact that I threatened them. And in this case, the crowd of dozens of hostile students presented a credible and serious threat to the officers. If the crowd had tried to attack and the police drew their weapons and responded with lethal force, they would still have been overwhelmed. I still maintain that the officers acted in a restrained and professional manner.

Ask yourself; if the context doesn't manner, why does the most common version of the video start with Pike's response, and not what he was responding to? Why not show the crowd choosing to obstruct the cops?
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the link.

How do you think the two situations are similar?

The environmental activists were essentially immobilized. Tazing them, pepper spraying them, is obviously abusive. The activists at U.C. Davis had surrounded the much smaller number of police, prevented them from the arresting the people you agreed were breaking the law, and were verbally threatening the officers.

So, again, how are the two situations similar?
RandFan never really answered the question. In fact, he spends a good deal of that discussion responding to peoples' questions with his own, and answering the question he thinks they're asking rather than what they are actually asking, no matter how many times he was corrected. He calls it the Socratic method and honestly couldn't understand why this was frustrating people.
 
... For the issue of vicarious liabiity in law enforcement, right now it doesn't matter who the Chancellor has 'convinced', at this point it doesn't matter if you think she and the 13 others made it up completely, what matters for these cops to be hung out, is that she is on record as claiming she said it.
The links I posted prove that, as do all the other records of her claiming she said it, and you can deny that from behind your keyboard all you want, nobody is going to care.
No she isn't. All she does is say that she didn't tell them to use pepper spray. She did not claim that she told them not to use pepper spray. Her statement implies that she told them not to, but it would be equally as correct if she told them nothing at all about use of force, leaving it to their discretion. It leaves her a good deal of wiggle room.

You have provided no links to the UCPD use of force, which actually contradicts your claims of what you say it says.

So much for impartiality.
 
000063 said:
For a guy who's not on a "side", you sure sound like you're on a side.


That's because you are using knee jerks instead of logic. Any factual information that doesn't match your fantasies and uninformed opinions, must be the enemy, and that makes it OK for you to spin, build strawmen, and play all the usual high school debate games.

I'm not playing your game, I'm simply pointing out (since post #3) the obvious fact that this is a vicarious liability case, and no amount of internet sophistry is going to change that.

None of you have provided a single shred of evidence to counter that.

What you have done is tried to argue the future case based on your Google-fu and all the hours you've spent watching TV . That's a boring exercise in futility that has nothing to do with having a life.
 
Last edited:
still ignoring the fact that the students in question went from peaceful protest to flagrant law breaking.....
Now you are simply lying.

At no point have I ever said or implied that the actions of the seated students didn't fit actions that would be illegal in general.
I said that in this particular case, the Chancellor's *published* claim that she told the police not to forcibly remove the protestors, changed things significantly.

Because that claim is on record (and in spite of the delusions that she never said that) the lawyers for the students are going to claim that it was no longer part of the officer's job to proceed in that manner.
Whether the court wiil accept that or not, is unknowable at this point. The Humboldt case cited above has some different factors from these circumstances.

What is known is that doing something perfectly reasonable can still get cops hung out to dry if the administration denies that the actions were approved by policy or by command.

And that is cut and dried vicarious liability.
 
Last edited:
That's because you are using knee jerks instead of logic. Any factual information that doesn't match your fantasies and uninformed opinions, must be the enemy, and that makes it OK for you to spin, build strawmen, and play all the usual high school debate games.
So I'm building strawmen, yet you're reducing my entire post to a single line that wasn't even the main point.

I'm not playing your game, I'm simply pointing out (since post #3) the obvious fact that this is a vicarious liability case, and no amount of internet sophistry is going to change that.

None of you have provided a single shred of evidence to counter that.
Except that is not what you "simply pointed out". You said that the Chancellor claimed something that she did not, in support of your VF conclusion. If the claim is false, it is useless as support for your argument. That is why it is being discussed.

Your complete and utter ignorance of the matter is also noted.

The UC Davis Chancellor is on record as saying that she specifically ordered her employees, the police not to use force to make people leave.

ETA: http://articles.latimes.com/2011/nov/21/local/la-me-1122-ucdavis-protest-20111122

The people who were sprayed were sitting on the ground, not attacking or even offering to attack the police in any manner.

Under UoF policies and case law, that's grounds to file a VL lawsuit anywhere in the country.

'Lawful' would be the direct order not to use force to remove the protestoers.

Disobeying that direct order isn't lawful.
An order which, as has been proven, the Chancellor never actually said she made. The order is also not lawful, even if your interpretation of it were correct, since they did not use force to remove the protestors. They removed the tents, only arrested deliberate obstructors, and tried to leave, whereupon dozens of students decided to become "obstructors" and "threateners" and "an angry mob" instead of merely "protesting". Not using force to attempt to leave risked harm to the officers, prisoners, and the crowd. The police nonetheless remained in a defensive posture until backup arrived, and used force only to remove the people directly obstructing them.

I'm not arguing. I haven't even stated my opinion as to who was 'right', or anything like that. Note my sig file.

I'm pointing out that the use of force policies and case law are a matter of factual record, as is the legal precept of vicarious liability. In the real world, the lawsuit has a factual basis. Under that reality, filing this lawsuit is an obvious step.


You on the other hand are trolling for a pointless internet argument, as proven by your demanding a 'source' after I've already given a link to the LA Times article reporting that the Chancellor said not to use force to remove the people.
I note that you are no longer making this claim, and have backpedalled to claiming you were only speaking about the potential liability case. Is it because it was proved wrong?

Go ahead and play all the breathy and dramatic 'the police were under attack', and 'the students threatened to raise their voices' woo-woo denial that you want, at the end of the day, reality isn't going to care at all about your fantasy constructs and debate games.
Straw men. The claims are that
  1. The police were attempting to leave peacefully.
  2. The students were deliberately obstructing the police, in an attempt to prevent 1.
  3. The students issued what was or what could reasonably be construed as threats.
  4. The students stated their intent to continue to obstruct the police until their demands were met.
  5. The crowd was hostile to the police, to the extent of chanting angrily at them in an attempt to intimidate.
  6. The officers maintained a defensive posture until backup arrived.
  7. When backup arrived, the officers attempted to remove the people directly obstructing their movement.
  8. After trying several lesser options, the police used pepper spray in order to disengage the students obstructing them.
  9. Use of pepper spray in such a manner is consistent with the use of force policies of most American police, as well as those worldwide.

You also argued that they were in violation of the UCPD Use of Force policy, yet presented no evidence to that effect. You also made a comparison to the Humboldt case, and the differences have been specifically pointed out to you. So most of your premises on which you claim the liability suit would be based are incorrect. A house on a sandy foundation.

What you have done is tried to argue the future case based on your Google-fu and all the hours you've spent watching TV . That's a boring exercise in futility that has nothing to do with having a life.
And not a single counter to an actual point I've made, just a blanket dismissal of it as "sophistry". You have been making personal remarks since your first words in this thread. It is also hypocritical to say I'm arguing the future case when your main point is that there is some sort of VL case to be made.
 
Last edited:
Now you are simply lying.

At no point have I ever said or implied that the actions of the seated students didn't fit actions that would be illegal in general.
I said that in this particular case, the Chancellor's *published* claim that she told the police not to forcibly remove the protestors, changed things significantly.

Because that claim is on record (and in spite of the delusions that she never said that) the lawyers for the students are going to claim that it was no longer part of the officer's job to proceed in that manner.
Whether the court wiil accept that or not, is unknowable at this point. The Humboldt case cited above has some different factors from these circumstances.

What is known is that doing something perfectly reasonable can still get cops hung out to dry if the administration denies that the actions were approved by policy or by command.

And that is cut and dried vicarious liability.
Just to be clear, if I say "I never told him to set my house on fire", is that grammatically and/or logically the same thing as saying "I told him not to set my house on fire?" Is it the same as "I never told him not to set my house on fire?"

Because the Chancellor is only making a negative claim about what she did not say, not an affirmative claim about what she did say. She did not tell the police not to forcibly remove the protestors, and the individuals in question were not merely protestors, but people actively obstructing the cops and part of a hostile crowd issuing threats.

Did the chancellor make a statement that is directly equivalent to "I told them not to use force" with no other interpretation?
 
Can I just mention here how completely idiotic it was for the Occupy movement to choose a form of protest they had to put all their energy and resources into defending? All they've really done is defended their right to have their protests (badly). They'd have been better off getting rid of the camps and spending all that time and energy advocating for what they wanted (which was never communicated very well anyway).
 
Here are two of the sprayees, recounting their excellent adventure horrific nightmare:



As you can see, they can barely hold back the smirks tears. This clearly will rank as the greatest most awful moment of their lives.

Look at those traumatized students. They will surely require years of therapy for the deep emotional trauma and physical harm.

This case is going to be interesting, because if UCD doesn't settle, their lawyers are going to tear this lot a new one. Ironic that they're accusing the school of civil code violations and false arrest when they themselves were breaking the law. Of course, the fact that the school dropped the charges because of the backlash from the carefully-edited video will probably hurt their case.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom