If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are arguing against NIST. If you were correct, they would not have discussed something that was not favorable to their version of events. If you are so certain you are right, write NIST and have them change their report.
I don't have the slightest interest in having their report changed. If anything, I would have preferred that they did not mess with collapse times at all. It's not the purpose of the report. Probably because it's irrelevant to their conclusions is why they didn't really put much interest into it. Their analysis of the fall speed is lousy.
 
Watch the video. You can infer whatever you want.

Watched it, and I infer that Cole is an incompetent idiot who uses models bearing no similitude to the WTC towers to infer that only explosive demolition can explain what happened to them. I can also infer things about the people who try to defend Cole's fallacious arguments with no understanding of the principles involved.
 
Last edited:
FalseFlag,

Since you're not going to get the correct answer to the question that I asked about Chandler's actual results, let me give it to you.

The ±0.456 is the Standard Deviation of the calculated acceleration.

So, THIS is the correct interpretation of Chandler's results:


  • There is a 68% probability that the average acceleration over that interval was between 9.43 & 10.34 m/sec2.
  • There is a 95% probability that the average acceleration over that interval was between 8.97 & 10.80 m/sec2.
  • There is a 99.7% probability that the average acceleration over that interval was between 8.52 & 11.25 m/sec2.

Now, tell me again. Do you really think that Chandler, with this analysis, proved that WTC 7 came down "at free fall acceleration"?

Now, Chandler got his degree in physics. Like every physics major, he was required to execute, write up & turn in many physics labs. He knows all about error analysis & statistical variation. He knows all about standard deviations.

He 100% KNOWS that, based on the analysis that he did, he can claim nothing other than the probabilities and error ranges that I quoted above.

Please tell me why he has been lying to Truther & everyone else, in all of his presentations, and claiming that this measurement shows that the building collapsed "at free fall"?

Please tell me that.

Perhaps you should ask NIST the same question. Perhaps what you are claiming is true, but not relevant. Maybe, just maybe, the exact value isn't so much the issue. Maybe the approximation is good enough. Maybe the issue is that your trying to confuse the real issue with smoke-and-mirrors tactics.

Again, this is the pressing question. If any of your arguments were valid, why didn't NIST use them?
 
Watched it, and I infer that Cole is an incompetent idiot who uses models bearing so similitude to the WTC towers to infer that only explosive demolition can explain what happened to them. I can also infer things about the people who try to defend Cole's fallacious arguments with no understanding of the principles involved.

Why do you infer this? Where and how is he wrong?
 
Asked and answered earlier by another poster. They did not feel any need to include it but because public questions were put forth about it they ammended the report to invlude a reference to it. Still doesnt make it relevant.
If it wasn't relevant, why is it in the NIST report?
 
If he has a video with 29.97 fps, and he intentionally extracts every 6th frame, and NIST does the same thing, then why on earth would any competent person demand 30 data points per second? Why use less reference points when they exist?
When your measurement error is big, that's one way to reduce the consequences. Unfortunately it also means that the averages are over even bigger intervals.

With feature tracking, the resolution is fractions of pixel, and the full sample rate can be used. The full sample rate data shows unequivocally that the acceleration wasn't constant.

Your claim that that Newton's third law was violated because there was no deceleration during the descent is invalidated since the premise is false: there was deceleration.
 
I don't have the slightest interest in having their report changed. If anything, I would have preferred that they did not mess with collapse times at all. It's not the purpose of the report. Probably because it's irrelevant to their conclusions is why they didn't really put much interest into it. Their analysis of the fall speed is lousy.

Your argument is that a building completely collapses, and the time in which it collapsed isn't relevant. The purpose of the report was to investigate the collapse, but it doesn't matter how long it took for the collapse to happen. Also, it's not relevant to their conclusions because they didn't put much interest in it.

Sure.

OK.

Please explain how you wish to be taken seriously in the future.
 
Last edited:
When your measurement error is big, that's one way to reduce the consequences. Unfortunately it also means that the averages are over even bigger intervals.

With feature tracking, the resolution is fractions of pixel, and the full sample rate can be used. The full sample rate data shows unequivocally that the acceleration wasn't constant.

Your claim that that Newton's third law was violated because there was no deceleration during the descent is invalidated since the premise is false: there was deceleration.

In regards to WTC7, do you mean deceleration after the period of freefall? That is correct. The rate of WTC7's acceleration was less after it constantly accelerated at 9.8m/s/s for a period of approximately 2.25 seconds. Newton's third law was observed during the entire collapse. Because it was observed we know that there was nothing supporting the upper floors for 2.25 seconds, which means every single remaining support column failed simultaneously. Thanks for agreeing with me on this, finally.
 
Last edited:
In regards to WTC7, do you mean deceleration after the period of freefall?
No, I mean there is no period of free fall. The corner gradually accelerated until it exceeded free fall and then went below free fall.

350095033.jpg
 
but it doesn't matter how long it took for the collapse to happen.


The collapse took around 16 seconds or 40% of free fall. SFW



Reposting this here wile I got you on screen so you can't ignore it.





Originally Posted by FalseFlag

Prove the following example is wrong.

Example: A object rests on the surface of the earth. The object is in a vacuum. Since the object is at rest, there is no motion. There is a downward force acting on the object, which is exerted by gravity. Since the object is at rest, there is an opposite force acting on the object in the opposite direction. This force is called the normal force. Since the object is in a vacuum, there is no force exerted by air. The only forces acting on the object are the force due to gravity and the normal force. The forces are balanced, so the net force is zero. As long as the net force is zero, the object will stay at rest.

Once again, prove any part of my example is wrong. Simply saying that I'm wrong doesn't count. You must clearly prove I'm wrong, with an example citing your sources and reasoning.



If your example was truly representative of newtons first law, I should be able to put on a spacesuit, climb inside your vacuum, and give your object a little kick. I'm going to give it an upwards kick like you would a soccer ball. If your example holds true to Newtons first law it should travel in a strait line at a constant speed (uniform motion) forever. Unfortunately you have Earths gravity field in your example, and as soon as I kick it it will start accelerating back towards the surface of the Earth at 9.8m/s/s where it will eventually come to rest.

If your example can't go from rest to uniform motion or vice versa then it is not representative of newtons first law and your application is flawed.

I have clearly proven that you are wrong and here is my source:

Lex I: Corpus omne perseverare in statu suo quiescendi vel movendi uniformiter in directum, nisi quatenus a viribus impressis cogitur statum illum mutare.
 
Yes. Multiple columns failed simultaneously.
And they failed over about 7-8 stories.

And, yes, NIST’s WTC collapse sim shows this.
Please provide a link to this. Which computer model shows complete structural failure over 8 floors, and then the top of the building descending for the same distance.


An enormous permutation of NIST’s assertions could be argued to be correct or incorrect.
So you support a real, independent investigation to resolve all these issues, right? I mean 3 buildings collapsed and thousands died. Don't you think we should be 100 percent correct about every single aspect of the collapse, no matter how minute?

LOL. Gotcha.

The columns supporting the EPH failed many seconds before the global collapse.

Agreed. That's why I said "whatever remaining columns collapsed simultaneously."

So. Not simultaneously. Nearly simultaneously.
Newton disagrees. So does NIST. So does David Chandler.
 
Last edited:
No, I mean there is no period of free fall. The corner gradually accelerated until it exceeded free fall and then went below free fall.

[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/7/2/350095033.jpg?1458364802[/qimg]

If NIST is wrong about freefall, then every single one of their conclusions, measurements, observations and assertions can be called into question. You can't have it both ways.
 
Right. It isn't. Engineers want to put effort in preventing collapses, not in making collapses slower or faster.
OK, but don't you think they need to know how a building collapsed in order to prevent future collapses? Don't you think the time in which a building fell is a clue about how the building collapsed?
 
If your example was truly representative of newtons first law, I should be able to put on a spacesuit, climb inside your vacuum, and give your object a little kick. I'm going to give it an upwards kick like you would a soccer ball. If your example holds true to Newtons first law it should travel in a strait line at a constant speed (uniform motion) forever. Unfortunately you have Earths gravity field in your example, and as soon as I kick it it will start accelerating back towards the surface of the Earth at 9.8m/s/s where it will eventually come to rest.

If your example can't go from rest to uniform motion or vice versa then it is not representative of newtons first law and your application is flawed.

Your logic is flawed. You have demonstrated you do not understand Newton's first law. You are the one who does not understand it. If you would keep things simple to start, you might eventually understand it. Then, once you actually understood it, you could move on to more complex examples. Start small. Understand the basics first, then continue on to more complex concepts.
 
OK, but don't you think they need to know how a building collapsed in order to prevent future collapses? Don't you think the time in which a building fell is a clue about how the building collapsed?
They determined that the core collapsed first. That's what matters. How long it took for the façade to fall doesn't matter.
 
Originally Posted by WilliamSeger
Watched it, and I infer that Cole is an incompetent idiot who uses models bearing so similitude to the WTC towers to infer that only explosive demolition can explain what happened to them. I can also infer things about the people who try to defend Cole's fallacious arguments with no understanding of the principles involved.
Why do you infer this? Where and how is he wrong?

Are you now trying to say that the reason you've ignored so many posts from so many people is that you didn't see them. :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom