Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, so we agree then the standard Whipple’s model from the 50’s is 🌵?

Nope, since I don't know what "🌵" means nor that Whipple's reference to a 'dirty snowball' would actually be considered either a "model" or "standard". Certainly some variations in accreted aggregate content would be expected and if by "Whipple’s model" you simply mean comets as an accreted aggregation of dust and ices form the stellar nebula, then that is still the prevailing model even exemplified in those very papers you've quoted.


One wonders if you could agree that EC currently lacks any projected values to apply to any model?
 
Sol88: A lying question to detail from his comet delusions

Yeah, so we agree then ...?
13 December 2017 Sol88: A lying question to detail from his comet delusions - he knows that the standard Whipple’s model from the 50’s was updated to be todays model of comets.
 
Sol88: More lies to derail from his comet delusions

Not sure I quite see it that way. ...
13 December 2017 Sol88: More lies to derail from his comet delusions - none of the papers state that comets are not ices and dust.

13 December 2017 Sol88: Idiocy that anyone is afraid of the ignorant and deluded Velikovsky who is the crank who is the start of his comet delusions

13 December 2017 Sol88: A lie that Whipple was wrong - comets are still made of ices and dust as more and more comet missions have shown.

13 December 2017 Sol88: Stupidity that anyone would include his delusions as mechanisms to lift dust from comets.

13 December 2017 Sol88: Total idiocy expecting I would reply to yet another pathetic derail from his comet delusions.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.
 
Sol88: Poor old Sol88 cannot stop lying to derail from his comet delusions

Poor old ...
13 December 2017 Sol88: Poor old Sol88 cannot stop lying to derail from his comet delusions.
I did not write not "Skorov" - it is YV Skorov et. al. - there are multiple authors, i.e.. Yu. V. Skorov, L. Rezac, P. Hartogh and H. U. Keller.
Just the usual lies.
"The model I’d dead right there" is his persistent lie that the "Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko" paper by YV Skorov et. al. means that there is no ice on comets.
I did not say that the YV Skorov et. al. paper was in my "bad books" - that is his lie.
The paper may be correct in which case there are physically possible mechanisms to also eject the smaller dust grains (jets, outbursts, etc.). The paper may be wrong and there is no problem for grains of any size - gas drag ejects them all. What makes the paper a bit dubious is that a paper that should be ground breaking has only been cited 1 time in the last year and that paper includes Skorov and Keller as authors.
Seasonal mass transfer on the nucleus of comet 67P/Chuyumov–Gerasimenko by H. U. Keller et. al.
We collect observational evidence that supports the scheme of mass transfer on the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko. The obliquity of the rotation axis of 67P causes strong seasonal variations. During perihelion the southern hemisphere is four times more active than the north. Northern territories are widely covered by granular material that indicates back fall originating from the active south. Decimetre sized chunks contain water ice and their trajectories are influenced by an antisolar force instigated by sublimation. OSIRIS observations suggest that up to 20 per cent of the particles directly return to the nucleus surface taking several hours of traveltime. The back fall covered northern areas are active if illuminated but produce mainly water vapour. The decimetre chunks from the nucleus surface are too small to contain more volatile compounds such as CO2 or CO. This causes a north–south dichotomy of the composition measurements in the coma. Active particles are trapped in the gravitational minimum of Hapi during northern winter. They are ‘shock frozen’ and only re-activated when the comet approaches the sun after its aphelion passage. The insolation of the big cavity is enhanced by self-heating, i.e. reflection and IR radiation from the walls. This, together with the pristinity of the active back fall, explains the early observed activity of the Hapi region. Sobek may be a role model for the consolidated bottom of Hapi. Mass transfer in the case of 67P strongly influences the evolution of the nucleus and the interpretation of coma measurements.

13 December 2017 Sol88: Idiocy of "official story" from a person who has drunk the deluded Thunderbolts Kool-Aid :eye-poppi!

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.

13 December 2017 Sol88: Usual lie of no ices on comets (surface this time).

13 December 2017 Sol88: Usual lie of "discharges" on comets

13 December 2017 Sol88: More pathetically obvious attempts to derail from his comet delusions.
 
Last edited:
If the comet is rock how do the EC advocates get round the lack of density?
That is easy - just read Sol88's posts where ignorant delusions and lies "beat" basic science every time :p!
In this case it is the delusion that electricity magic makes different techniques for measuring comet mass and thus density wrong all in the same way (measured density too low). My post Comets have measured densities that are much less than that of rocks (asteroids) list 2 general techniques (Kepler's laws + orbit perturbation by jets), Deep Impact ejecta plume trajectory, 2 measurements for 67P.

He is parroting his heroes at the Thunderbolts cult. David Talbott and Wallace Thornhill are ignorant and deluded Velikovsky followers who have expanded on his imaginary worlds. Wallace Thornhill is a documented liar. The electric comet delusions are the tip of the iceberg of delusions that is the Thunderbolts dogma. For example, they believe that
  • The Grand Canyon was blasted out by electrical discharges between the Earth and Venus.
  • Black holes cannot exist so no gravitational waves have been detected.
  • Neutron stars do not exist (ditto for the latest gravitational wave detection!).
  • The Sun is powered by electric currents from outer space (first year astronomy students work out that a star has to have an internal heat source in order to be stable).
The parroting of the Thunderbolt cult ignorance, delusions and lies in this thread alone (continuation of a thread that is now 8 years of delusions from Sol88)
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
 
Last edited:
... And circuit modeling is just the long-wavelength approximation of plasma physics.
Its almost OT for the way this thread has panned out, but your above comment has been stuck in my head since you posted it.
I'm intrigued and curious .. would much appreciate a little more on the concept(s) you're alluding to here, (if possible)?

Cheers & Rgds.
 
Which reminds me of the collection of ignorant cranks that is the EU conferences. The last one I commented on was EU2015 will be yet another collection of mostly cranks
EU2016 had
Wallace Thornhill: the chief liar for Thunderbolts (it is now 12 years of lying about confirmed Deep Impact predictions) is the keynote speaker.
David Talbott: touted his deeply deluded book The Saturn Myth, etc.
Donald Scott: ignorant about astronomy delusions about an electric sun.
Montgomery Childs: delusion of fusion and "CME like" eruptions in an unpublished plasma experiment.
Ben Davidson: a lawyer's delusions about the electric universe.
Subhon Ibadov: an actual astrophysicist goes nuts about electrical discharges on comets.
Tom Wilson: musing on the geocentric Ptolemaic system passes into what looks like stupidity about dark matter.
Michael Clarage: A lie that SAFAIRE is about "how electricity manifests in solar systems" (it is a fairly standard plasma experiment) and then Clarage exposes his ignorance of astrophysics - his experiment will not reveal anything about astrophysical processes..
C.J. Ransom: Looks like lunacy about crank "catastrophic models".
Kongpop U-yen: Yet another electrical engineer going off the deep end! This time it is that space weather can predict earthquakes, volcanic eruptions and storm formations.
Eugene Bagashov: the delusion of electric comets.
Alexander Fournier: looks like an "electricity of life" cancer cure crank.
Andreas Otte: an IT guy with electric geology delusions.
Bruce Leybourne: a geologist with a crank "Platonic solids", etc. presentation.
Gary Schwartz: A professor of psychology, medicine, neurology, psychiatry and surgery idiotically goes on about the Hubble Ultra Deep Field image.
Ev Cochrane: Stupidity of a "green” or turquoise-colored sun in former times" based on ancient pictographs.
Chris Reeve: Looks like a delusion about the Apollo missions.
A.P. David: Tries to make an inane connection between Homer’s poetry and cosmology - as if Homer knew what we know about the universe!
 
Which reminds me of the collection of ignorant cranks that is the EU conferences. The last one I commented on was EU2015 will be yet another collection of mostly cranks
EU2016 had
Wallace Thornhill: the chief liar for Thunderbolts (it is now 12 years of lying about confirmed Deep Impact predictions) is the keynote speaker.
David Talbott: touted his deeply deluded book The Saturn Myth, etc.
Donald Scott: ignorant about astronomy delusions about an electric sun.
Montgomery Childs: delusion of fusion and "CME like" eruptions in an unpublished plasma experiment.
Ben Davidson: a lawyer's delusions about the electric universe.
Subhon Ibadov: an actual astrophysicist goes nuts about electrical discharges on comets.
Tom Wilson: musing on the geocentric Ptolemaic system passes into what looks like stupidity about dark matter.
Michael Clarage: A lie that SAFAIRE is about "how electricity manifests in solar systems" (it is a fairly standard plasma experiment) and then Clarage exposes his ignorance of astrophysics - his experiment will not reveal anything about astrophysical processes..
C.J. Ransom: Looks like lunacy about crank "catastrophic models".
Kongpop U-yen: Yet another electrical engineer going off the deep end! This time it is that space weather can predict earthquakes, volcanic eruptions and storm formations.
Eugene Bagashov: the delusion of electric comets.
Alexander Fournier: looks like an "electricity of life" cancer cure crank.
Andreas Otte: an IT guy with electric geology delusions.
Bruce Leybourne: a geologist with a crank "Platonic solids", etc. presentation.
Gary Schwartz: A professor of psychology, medicine, neurology, psychiatry and surgery idiotically goes on about the Hubble Ultra Deep Field image.
Ev Cochrane: Stupidity of a "green” or turquoise-colored sun in former times" based on ancient pictographs.
Chris Reeve: Looks like a delusion about the Apollo missions.
A.P. David: Tries to make an inane connection between Homer’s poetry and cosmology - as if Homer knew what we know about the universe!
Ahh RC .. you're priceless matey!

What a classic list of a gaggle of inmates, presumably let out for a day's excursion! :D:)
 
What a classic list of a gaggle of inmates, presumably let out for a day's excursion! :D:)
The Thunderbolts web site is even worse than you can imagine. Starts with selling a video of the ignorant and deluded presentations at the 2017 conference :eye-poppi!
There is the idiocy of argument by crank YouTube videos (black holes do not exist delusions, etc.). Picture of the day stupidity from ignorance that high cliffs cannot be created by geological processes and so must be created by electrical discharges. Argument from incredibility and probably ignorance here that desert mounds are created by lightning.
 
Last edited:
The Thunderbolts web site is even worse than you can imagine. Starts with selling a video of the ignorant and deluded presentations at the 2017 conference :eye-poppi!
There is the idiocy of argument by crank YouTube videos (black holes do not exist delusions, etc.). Picture of the day stupidity from ignorance that high cliffs cannot be created by geological processes and so must be created by electrical discharges. Argument from incredibility and probably ignorance here that desert mounds are created by lightning.
Here's a goody ... (How's the caveat at the end of the page containing the 2017 Conference YouTube):
Quote from the Thunderbolts ProjectTM site:
The ideas expressed in videos presented on The Thunderbolts ProjectTM YouTube Channel do not necessarily express the views of T-Bolts Group Inc or The Thunderbolts ProjectTM.
.. err .. well ... ok then ...
Exactly who's views do they represent, and why are they on the Thunderbolts ProjectTM website in the first place, then? :boggled:
(Sort of like the caveated interviews with actors one gets when one buys a DVD movie, then, eh?)
But this tripe is intended to be taken seriously ... :rolleyes:
 
Nope, since I don't know what "🌵" means nor that Whipple's reference to a 'dirty snowball' would actually be considered either a "model" or "standard". Certainly some variations in accreted aggregate content would be expected and if by "Whipple’s model" you simply mean comets as an accreted aggregation of dust and ices form the stellar nebula, then that is still the prevailing model even exemplified in those very papers you've quoted.

To quote myself from my review paper that will appear (hopefully) in the first half of next year:

me said:
Whipple [1950] combined all spectral observations and published the now well-known “dirty snowball” model of comets. In this model the nucleus of the comet is seen as a conglomeration of volatile ices (such as H2O and CO2) bound in a solid rocky body of meteoritic material. Actually, this model was developed to explain the non-Keplerian behaviour of comets (specifically comet 2P/Encke);

Whipple, F. L. (1950), A comet model I. the acceleration of comet Encke, Astrophys. J., 111, 375 – 394. (freely available)

Actually Whipple published another paper in 1999: Note on the structure of comet nuclei, of which I unfortunately do not have a pdf.
 
circuit model (a short OT digress)

Its almost OT for the way this thread has panned out, but your above comment has been stuck in my head since you posted it.
I'm intrigued and curious .. would much appreciate a little more on the concept(s) you're alluding to here, (if possible)?

Cheers & Rgds.

Basically, if you have a plasma system with magnetic fields and currents etc. you can simplify stuff.

One of the great achievements of Alfvén was to see that for ideal plasmas (i.e. with infinite conductivity) you can average the plasma physical equations over distances larger than the largest gyro radius and over time scales longer than the longest gyro period. Thus he developed MHD.

Now, you can go even a step further, which can be rather useful.
I will demonstrate it with an example, because that makes it more visible. Let's take the Io flux tube magnetically connecting Io with Jupiter. The plasma in Jupiter's magnetosphere is near corotation, and the length scales of Io and other stuff is large and even though Jupiter rotates rather fast, the time scale to pass by Io is still relatively long. So we could actually describe the interaction using MHD (when we neglect ion pick-up processes and slowing down, which we will do in this case).
Still to model the connection between Io and Jupiter, even with MHD, is not an easy task, if e.g. you only want to know the total power that is delivered into Jupiter's ionosphere to create the auroral footpoint of Io.
So, if you are not really interested in the gory details of the interaction, you can argue the following way:
  • The magnetic field moves by Io at a velocity v, inducing an electric field over the moon given by vxB, this is a power source or battery
  • This will of course drive a current along, and we assume that that current uses the magnetic field lines as current wires, going up at the Jupiter side of the moon and going down at the other side
  • Along the field lines there is probably no resistivity
  • The Jovian magnetosphere, however, is "dense" and the currents have to close across the field lines, giving a certain resistivity R
  • Now you have all the ingredients for a circuit description

Naturally, you can do this more complicated, e.g. at the Sun, or even better for a connection between an accretion disk and a black hole with a magnetic loop where you may define an induction L of the loop.

So, basically, getting the large scale properties of your system, V, R, L, possibly a double layer, you can build an circuit model of the plasma system. Naturally, you will have to go into the gory details as some point, to calculate e.g. the resistivity R (see the appendix of the black hole paper, freely available).

So, that are the basics of circuit theory in a nutshell.
 
Basically, if you have a plasma system with magnetic fields and currents etc. you can simplify stuff.

One of the great achievements of Alfvén was to see that for ideal plasmas (i.e. with infinite conductivity) you can average the plasma physical equations over distances larger than the largest gyro radius and over time scales longer than the longest gyro period. Thus he developed MHD.

Now, you can go even a step further, which can be rather useful.
I will demonstrate it with an example, because that makes it more visible. Let's take the Io flux tube magnetically connecting Io with Jupiter. The plasma in Jupiter's magnetosphere is near corotation, and the length scales of Io and other stuff is large and even though Jupiter rotates rather fast, the time scale to pass by Io is still relatively long. So we could actually describe the interaction using MHD (when we neglect ion pick-up processes and slowing down, which we will do in this case).
Still to model the connection between Io and Jupiter, even with MHD, is not an easy task, if e.g. you only want to know the total power that is delivered into Jupiter's ionosphere to create the auroral footpoint of Io.
So, if you are not really interested in the gory details of the interaction, you can argue the following way:
  • The magnetic field moves by Io at a velocity v, inducing an electric field over the moon given by vxB, this is a power source or battery
  • This will of course drive a current along, and we assume that that current uses the magnetic field lines as current wires, going up at the Jupiter side of the moon and going down at the other side
  • Along the field lines there is probably no resistivity
  • The Jovian magnetosphere, however, is "dense" and the currents have to close across the field lines, giving a certain resistivity R
  • Now you have all the ingredients for a circuit description

Naturally, you can do this more complicated, e.g. at the Sun, or even better for a connection between an accretion disk and a black hole with a magnetic loop where you may define an induction L of the loop.

So, basically, getting the large scale properties of your system, V, R, L, possibly a double layer, you can build an circuit model of the plasma system. Naturally, you will have to go into the gory details as some point, to calculate e.g. the resistivity R (see the appendix of the black hole paper, freely available).

So, that are the basics of circuit theory in a nutshell.
Thanks kindly for that very considered explanation on the high level approach to circuit modelling in an astronomical context there, Tusenfem. :) 'Tis the Alfvén ideal plasma context (your second paragraph) which I think I need more time to ponder (and follow up on).

If I were an enthusiastic EU Acolyte, mind you, (:eek:), I would make full use of all that to follow up on the type of questions you suggest: Ie: 'what might be the total power that is delivered into Jupiter's ionosphere to create the auroral footpoint of Io?', or better still, maybe even use it to quantify just what might be needed to make some fantasies, such as those related to the sci-fi story of the EC, actually 'work'!? :eek:

(Actually, in thinking about what you wrote, I came across this diagram of the Faraday disc (induction) generator in Wiki, here, which I'm sure could be adapted to give a visual model along the guidelines you mention, for the Jupiter-Io example(?)).

Thanks again .. its a privilege to be able to gain a glimpse (or some insight) into how you folk translate all of this physics into practical models that can actually make a difference in leading towards real scientific understanding.

Rgds
 
To quote myself from my review paper that will appear (hopefully) in the first half of next year:



Whipple, F. L. (1950), A comet model I. the acceleration of comet Encke, Astrophys. J., 111, 375 – 394. (freely available)

Actually Whipple published another paper in 1999: Note on the structure of comet nuclei, of which I unfortunately do not have a pdf.


Exactly, the point Sol88 seems to be missing or perhaps just deliberately ignoring and supported by all Sol88's quote mined citations. Is that these models and formulations, even the thermodynamic one where the case referenced in the quote didn't match well with observations. Still match observations better than any EC models and formulations. Simply because EC has no projected values to model and no formulations to obtain or relate to anything. Heck, even now after all these years just guessing at values is more accurate than EC speculations that still, again most likely deliberately, lack any quantitative values to apply to any models and formulations whatsoever. Fact remains that while EC proponents may feel that without quantitative projections they can't be proven wrong. However, without such quantitative projections they can't even be as close to being right as any quantitative projection that is demonstrably wrong. So they are even worse than wrong or as Wolfgang Pauli is thought to have put it "Not even wrong".
 
Last edited:
EU2017 had
Wallace Thornhill: the chief liar for Thunderbolts (it is now 12 years of lying about confirmed Deep Impact predictions) with the insanity that his cult does science and Immanuel Velikovsky's stupidity that gravity is electromagnetic.
David Talbott: The delusion that myths are a valid source of "extraordinary natural phenomena ". Touted his deeply deluded book The Saturn Myth.
Donald Scott: His delusion that Birkeland currents "power many galaxies in deep space" :eye-poppi.
James Ryder: Vague description implying a New Age fantasy of "interconnectedness of all things".
Gerald Pollack: A biomedical engineer with an "EZ water" idea talking about weather who does not even know how clouds float :eye-poppi! Exclusion zone water suggested that he not associate with the anti-vaxxer Dr. Mercola and here he is doing much worse.
Montgomery Childs: delusion of fusion and "CME like" eruptions. Proposed in 2012, the SAFIRE project results are an abysmally ignorant web site and 1 published paper in 5 years!
Ben Davidson: a lawyer's delusions about the electric universe.
Jacqueline Greenfield: A naturopath is deluded about plasma, Pollack's EZ Water delusion and biology :eye-poppi.
Garrett Hill: A motorsports "entrepreneur".
Eileen McKusick: A sound therapist.
Andrew Hall: Delusions about lightning bolts, etc.
Franklin Anariba: His usual ignorant fantasies bout electrochemical activity on comets.
Jerry Tennant: A surgeon with the delusion that "emotions are stored in and around the body as magnetic fields".
Stephen Crothers: A deluded gardener (the page lies about "preeminent mathematician") with a basic knowledge of GR that he abuses to deny that black holes exist. Idiocy that gravitational waves have not been detected. Utter stupidity that SR is not internally consistent when that is one of its strongest aspects.
Bill Mullen: A Velivosky crank.
Irving Wolfe: A Velivosky crank.
Andrew Fitts: A Velivosky crank.
Peter ‘Mungo’ Jupp: Delusion of "instant fossilization". Has an obviously deluded web site ("Mankind has been repeatedly destroyed and reborn from time immemorial."!) with a blog that looks like incoherent ranting about basically unassociated events and myths.
Edwin Kaal: Ignorant delusions about atomic structure.
Johnny Godowski: A Velivosky crank.
Peter Moddel: Philosophical musing about the distinction between mass and matter. Perhaps the only not ignorant or deluded talk at the conference!
C.J. Ransom: Sounds like the ignorance that science must get things right the first time. It is the "surprises" in probe results from the 1950's that helped form modern plasma physics.
Ev Cochrane: Venus and Mars mythology.
 
Last edited:
Basically, if you have a plasma system with magnetic fields and currents etc. you can simplify stuff.

One of the great achievements of Alfvén was to see that for ideal plasmas (i.e. with infinite conductivity) you can average the plasma physical equations over distances larger than the largest gyro radius and over time scales longer than the longest gyro period. Thus he developed MHD.

Now, you can go even a step further, which can be rather useful.
I will demonstrate it with an example, because that makes it more visible. Let's take the Io flux tube magnetically connecting Io with Jupiter. The plasma in Jupiter's magnetosphere is near corotation, and the length scales of Io and other stuff is large and even though Jupiter rotates rather fast, the time scale to pass by Io is still relatively long. So we could actually describe the interaction using MHD (when we neglect ion pick-up processes and slowing down, which we will do in this case).
Still to model the connection between Io and Jupiter, even with MHD, is not an easy task, if e.g. you only want to know the total power that is delivered into Jupiter's ionosphere to create the auroral footpoint of Io.
So, if you are not really interested in the gory details of the interaction, you can argue the following way:
  • The magnetic field moves by Io at a velocity v, inducing an electric field over the moon given by vxB, this is a power source or battery
  • This will of course drive a current along, and we assume that that current uses the magnetic field lines as current wires, going up at the Jupiter side of the moon and going down at the other side
  • Along the field lines there is probably no resistivity
  • The Jovian magnetosphere, however, is "dense" and the currents have to close across the field lines, giving a certain resistivity R
  • Now you have all the ingredients for a circuit description

Naturally, you can do this more complicated, e.g. at the Sun, or even better for a connection between an accretion disk and a black hole with a magnetic loop where you may define an induction L of the loop.

So, basically, getting the large scale properties of your system, V, R, L, possibly a double layer, you can build an circuit model of the plasma system. Naturally, you will have to go into the gory details as some point, to calculate e.g. the resistivity R (see the appendix of the black hole paper, freely available).

So, that are the basics of circuit theory in a nutshell.

I remember the Membrane Paradigm for black holes by Kip Thorn when it first came out in Scientific American (got his black hole book as a result).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Holes_and_Time_Warps

It had a simple (the Membrane paradigm) circuit description of a black hole as a dynamo for the polar jets.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Astrophysical_jet


Thanks kindly for that very considered explanation on the high level approach to circuit modelling in an astronomical context there, Tusenfem. :) 'Tis the Alfvén ideal plasma context (your second paragraph) which I think I need more time to ponder (and follow up on).

If I were an enthusiastic EU Acolyte, mind you, (:eek:), I would make full use of all that to follow up on the type of questions you suggest: Ie: 'what might be the total power that is delivered into Jupiter's ionosphere to create the auroral footpoint of Io?', or better still, maybe even use it to quantify just what might be needed to make some fantasies, such as those related to the sci-fi story of the EC, actually 'work'!? :eek:

(Actually, in thinking about what you wrote, I came across this diagram of the Faraday disc (induction) generator in Wiki, here, which I'm sure could be adapted to give a visual model along the guidelines you mention, for the Jupiter-Io example(?)).

Thanks again .. its a privilege to be able to gain a glimpse (or some insight) into how you folk translate all of this physics into practical models that can actually make a difference in leading towards real scientific understanding.

Rgds

The problem is, SelfSim, as tusenfem notes, once you get into the down and dirty details those large scale more simplistic applications no longer apply. As they deliberately ignore or conglomerate those fine dynamic details. A point I was trying to make before with the electromagnetic properties of space -time. The devil is in the details. However, without even EC values for the large scale components, the projected charge difference between the sun and the comet (Sol88's excess electrons), even the large scale factors remain oblivious in that regard.

While photo-ionization takes place on the nucleolus of the comet that sill doesn't give it 'excess electrons' in relation to the sun. However, the freeing of electrons will increase the polarized repulsion of remaining ions (like Sol88's dust levitation). As I mentioned up thread that would tend to reduce cohesive forces between dust particles and the surrounding portions of the nucleolus itself (if also having photo-ionization) (not even considering the ion to surrounding electron gas attraction). Perhaps making neutral gas drag sufficient to lift particles smaller than 1mm significantly further away from the nucleolus. I don't recall seeing anything about photo-ionization or such local free electron affects in the paper Sol88 likes quoting for that model's limit on neutral gas drag (while apparently ignoring the papers own stated limit and gas neutrality) but then I only gave it a quick glance.


ETA: Sorry, forgot one link.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Membrane_paradigm
 
Last edited:
^^^^^^^^^
Good Stuff there, you mob. Very interesting.

But back OT,


Basically, if you have a plasma system with magnetic fields and currents etc. you can simplify stuff.

One of the great achievements of Alfvén was to see that for ideal plasmas (i.e. with infinite conductivity) you can average the plasma physical equations over distances larger than the largest gyro radius and over time scales longer than the longest gyro period. Thus he developed MHD.

Now, you can go even a step further, which can be rather useful.
I will demonstrate it with an example, because that makes it more visible. Let's take the Io flux tube magnetically connecting Io with Jupiter. The plasma in Jupiter's magnetosphere is near corotation, and the length scales of Io and other stuff is large and even though Jupiter rotates rather fast, the time scale to pass by Io is still relatively long. So we could actually describe the interaction using MHD (when we neglect ion pick-up processes and slowing down, which we will do in this case).
Still to model the connection between Io and Jupiter, even with MHD, is not an easy task, if e.g. you only want to know the total power that is delivered into Jupiter's ionosphere to create the auroral footpoint of Io.
So, if you are not really interested in the gory details of the interaction, you can argue the following way:
  • The magnetic field moves by Io at a velocity v, inducing an electric field over the moon given by vxB, this is a power source or battery
  • This will of course drive a current along, and we assume that that current uses the magnetic field lines as current wires, going up at the Jupiter side of the moon and going down at the other side
  • Along the field lines there is probably no resistivity
  • The Jovian magnetosphere, however, is "dense" and the currents have to close across the field lines, giving a certain resistivity R
  • Now you have all the ingredients for a circuit description

Naturally, you can do this more complicated, e.g. at the Sun, or even better for a connection between an accretion disk and a black hole with a magnetic loop where you may define an induction L of the loop.

So, basically, getting the large scale properties of your system, V, R, L, possibly a double layer, you can build an circuit model of the plasma system. Naturally, you will have to go into the gory details as some point, to calculate e.g. the resistivity R (see the appendix of the black hole paper, freely available).

So, that are the basics of circuit theory in a nutshell.

So where do the circuits close in relation to the nucleus of 67P?

See

Currents in Cometary Comae Martin Volwerk
Current sheets in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko’s coma M. Volwerk1, G. H. Jones2;3, T. Broiles4, J. Burch5, C. Carr6, A. J. Coates2;3, E. Cupido6, M.3 Delva1, N. J. T. Edberg7, A. Eriksson7, C. Goetz8, R. Goldstein5, P. Henri9, H. Madanian10,H. Nilsson11, I. Richter8, K. Schwingenschuh1, G. StenbergWieser11and K.-H. Glassmeier8
Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet Jan Deca,1,2,* Andrey Divin,3,4 Pierre Henri,5 Anders Eriksson,4 Stefano Markidis,6 Vyacheslav Olshevsky,7 and Mihály Horányi1,2

Where would one find Alfvén's "ideal plasmas (i.e. with infinite conductivity" in a space environment?

When Alfvén's statement
III. DOUBLE LAYERS AND FROZEN-IN MAGNETIC FIELD LINES A. Frozen-In Field Lines B A Pseudo-Pedagogical Concept In Cosmical Electrodynamics, I tried to give a survey of a field in which I had been active for about two decades. In one of the chapters, I treated magnetohydrodynamic waves. I pointed out that in an infinitely conductive magnetized fluid the magnetic field lines could be considered as "frozen" into the medium -- under certain conditions -- and this concept made it possible to treat the waves as oscillations of the frozen-in medium. The "frozen-in" picture of magnetic field lines differs from Maxwell's views. He defined a magnetic field line as a line which everywhere is parallel to the magnetic field. If the current system which produced the field changes, the magnetic field changes and field lines can merge or reconnect. However, if the current system is constant the magnetic field is also constant. To speak of magnetic field lines moving perpendicular to the field makes no sense. They are not material.
Double Layers in Astrophysics
H.Alfvén


Fascinating and extremely complex :D

Plasma, love the stuff! :thumbsup:

but what we are really doing here is defining a new model?
"What is urgently needed is not a refined mathematical treatment (referring to Chapman-Cowling) but a rough analysis of the basic phenomena" (referring to the general knowledge of plasmas).

Circuit theory must be taken into account around a comet!

Is this correct Tusenfem, JD116, The Man, Self Sim?
 
Last edited:
We can then move onto the RPC observation of the development and evolution of plasma interaction boundaries at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

When one see this
In the cometosheath, solar wind and cometary pickup ions are
both present. During the Giotto flyby of Halley, several unexpected
features were observed in the electron measurements: three outer
regions and two inner regions within the cometosheath. The central
outer region was named the ‘mystery region’ and was characterized
by enhanced electron temperatures and densities that dropped suddenly
when crossing a ‘mystery’ boundary inbound to the comet

then onto

VII. CONCLUSIONS
Overall, ion sheaths in single-ion species weakly collisional
plasma with eV/Te@1 are better understood than
electron sheaths. Both ion and electron sheaths can exist and
the Child–Langmuir law provides good fits to potential vs
position when eV/Te@1. Electron sheaths are much less
common than ion sheaths because they require that a sufficient
area be available in the plasma chamber for the ion loss
current and many chambers are not big enough. The characteristics
of potential dips preceding many electron sheaths
are not well understood.
Sheaths: More complicated than you think Noah Hershkowitzb


Mmmm.....thinking thinking....
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom