jonesdave116
Philosopher
- Joined
- Feb 26, 2015
- Messages
- 6,222
Once again for EC notions the data needed is the quantitative values expected by those notions.
Remember you mentioned “When entering a region of different charge” making your “region of different charge" perhaps more than your ‘comet excess electron’ charge. So just the EC or EU “region” could dominate whatever they consider the charge on the comet (by virtue of its claimed excess electrons) to be, it is still just the data of excepted values for EC/EU that is lacking.
For the mainstream the sun, the solar wind and the comet are fundamentally considered neutral. The math for that is simple as SUM of charges on each of those objects= 0. Any local variations are driven by the, well, local dynamics.
EC however doesn’t assert simple local variations but instead a direct potential difference between the comet and the sun. Without that (the electric part) the Electric Comet is just, well, a comet. So it remains to the proponents of such an eclectic comet to quantify that electric part. Again the math is simple as SUM of charges on each of those objects = anything but 0
And therein lies the EC problem - they won't do the maths, but expect others to work it out. However, how can others work it out when all observation shows that there are no "regions of different charge". So, when we ask what sort of charge they are proposing, they cannot tell us. Are we supposed to make something up?
The whole thing relies on impossibilities - an electric sun, with a varying radial electric field, through which a comet, made of rock, travels picking up charge where the charge is lowest, and discharging it where the charge is highest! It relies on EDM (lol) and electric discharges, and impossible interactions between too low a flux of solar wind H+, and non-existent O-.
It's pointless even attempting the maths, as the whole proposition has been falsified. No radial electric field, no rock, no discharges, and so on. The whole thing is moot.
Which is why I refer back to my previous point; why are we still discussing this? It's dead.
!