Right, let's test what we already know. I'll use Tom Bridgman's results from here:
http://dealingwithcreationisminastronomy.blogspot.com/search?q=comet
Let Q be the charge on the comet, and q be the charge on the spacecraft, in Coulombs.
Tom comes up with 3.65 x 10
-4 Coulombs
2 for Qq.
Therefore, rearranging, we get: Q = 3.65 x 10
-4/ q.
So, we need to find the charge on q (spacecraft). We know the voltage was around -10V, at the time Harvey did his calculation, here:
http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/04/09/giada-investigates-comets-fluffy-dust-grains/#comment-432278
So, Harvey gets a capacitance for Rosetta of ~ 1 x 10
-9 Farads. If you want to dispute that, you'll need to show why.
So, as Q = CV, then q = 10
-9 F x -10V = -10
-8 Coulombs.
So, let's get back to Tom's results. As previously shown, Q = 3.65 x 10
-4/ q.
So now we can obtain Q (charge on comet) as being 3.65 x 10
-4/ -10
-8 = -3.65 x 10
4 Coulombs.
We now need to convert Coulombs into Volts. We therefore need to estimate the capacitance of 67P. Harvey does this and gets 3 x 10
-7 F. That looks accurate to me. The capacitance of a sphere is calculated using the formula 4pi ε
0 r,
where ε
0 is the electric constant; 8.85418782 × 10
-12 m
-3 kg
-1 s
4 A
2.
So, as Q = CV, we can obtain the voltage by rearranging to give V = Q/C.
So, V = -3.65 X 10
4 C/ 3 x 10
-7 F = ~ -1.2 x 10
11 V.
That is 120 gigavolts! As Harvey mentioned, we might have noticed that!
In Tom's calculations, he uses 2000 km/m
3 for the EU claimed density, and 400 kg/m
3 for the measured density. The measured density is actually ~ 530 kg/m
3, so we can reduce the charge a little bit! Not enough to alter the fact that this kind of voltage is impossible, though.