The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you for your frank admission.


Good.

So now we can ask the Admins/Mods to either close this thread or move it somewhere else, so no one can possibly be confused that it's about science.

You must be suffering a senior moment or something.


This I’ve told before in this thread, I can’t do the maths.
 
JeanTate said:
Been there, done that, got the T-shirt (it says "Sisyphus had is easy").

Everyone who reads posts in this thread knows that a core part of your idea is the logical fallacy False Dichotomy (it has other names too).

But even we accept your unscientific belief, it still doesn't work!

Why not? Because, so far, you have presented nothing which resembles a model, as in an "Electric Comet model".

So, instead of more trolling, why not roll up your sleeves and work on presenting a scientific case for your Electric Comet idea? You know, what this thread is supposed to be about?
Are you looking for some equation or some thing or something along the lines of Whipples “model”?

Because “Comets are rocky bodies discharging in the solar plasma flow” is not as technical as “A comet is an icy small Solar System body that, when passing close to the Sun, warms and begins to release gases, a process called outgassing. This produces a visible atmosphere or coma, and sometimes also a tail.”

You tell m the difference sweet pea.
It's your idea, Sol88, so it's up to you to present a scientific case.

Why not start with something easy? For example, show - in a scientific manner - that the observational data on comets is consistent with them being ROCK.

To be clear, not a quote from someone, nor some handwaving, but something along the lines of:

- ROCK has a bulk density of X.
- This observational data on Comet Y is consistent with it having a bulk density of between 0.8X and 1.2X.
 
JeanTate said:
Thank you for your frank admission.


Good.

So now we can ask the Admins/Mods to either close this thread or move it somewhere else, so no one can possibly be confused that it's about science.
Are you interested in talking plasma curcuit theory?

Or dummy spit and get your knickers all bunch up?
First, I have no idea what "plasma curcuit [sic] theory" is, and I suspect you don't either.

But most important: it's your idea, Sol88, so it's up to you to present a scientific case for it.
 
JeanTate said:
Thank you for your frank admission.


Good.

So now we can ask the Admins/Mods to either close this thread or move it somewhere else, so no one can possibly be confused that it's about science.
You must be suffering a senior moment or something.


This I’ve told before in this thread, I can’t do the maths.
Thanks.

So, as you are the only person who's posting here about how "The Electric Comet Theory" (or anything resembling it) is scientific, we can definitely ask for this thread to be either closed or moved.
 
Usual insane "continuum" lie to derail from his electric comet insanity

Comets and Asteroids are a continuum!
Usual insane "continuum" lie to derail from his electric comet insanity.

No astronomer has stated that comets re rocks like asteroids. There is a continuum of comet-like behaviors between the few asteroids that show comet-like behaviors and comets.
 
More deluded lies to derail from his electric comet insanity

No you need more than one model to test and compare.

Gravity only has been shown to be inadequate.
More deluded lies to derail from his electric comet insanity.

There is no electric comet model. There is an insane fantasy that comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges. And then Sol88 adds his own touches :eye-poppi!

Gravity works and gives the measured by several techniques density of comets by itself.

The delusional part of the gravity lie is that his electric comet insanity has never shown gravity only to be inadequate.
 
Repeats a lie and delusions about his SAFIRE project insanity

SAFIRE have already had a win and my money’s on them PROVING with peer review papers and the data returned from Parker solar probe.
Repeats a lie and delusions about his SAFIRE project insanity.

They have never published anything about their solar results. There is utter stupidity about plasma being at energy densities of solar plasma when that is common in plasma experiments.

He has a delusion that we have never studied the Sun until the Parker Solar Probe :jaw-dropp! His SAFIRE project insanity will have to produce already known properties of the Sun.
 
A "plasma curcuit theory" delusion to derail from his electric comet insanity.

Are you interested in talking plasma curcuit theory?
A "plasma curcuit theory" delusion to derail from his electric comet insanity.

There is the irrelevant, not common treatment of some plasma using electric circuit theory which is a form of network analysis. Elementary ideas behind plasma physics (1988) describes the textbook use of electric circuit theory for plasma and its limitations to support Alfven's use of it. SAO/NASA Astrophysics Data System (ADS) has a total of 5 abstracts for 'circuit theory comet'!
 
Last edited:
An insult and "I can’t do the maths" stupidity about his electric comet insanity

You must be suffering a senior moment or something.


This I’ve told before in this thread, I can’t do the maths.
An insult and "I can’t do the maths" stupidity about his electric comet insanity.

If he cannot "do the math" then all of his numerical assertions are baseless :jaw-dropp!

If he cannot "do the math" then he cannot verify the math in his electric comet insanity. Lucky for him there is none :p!

If he cannot "do the math" then he has to accept the math done by others, e.g. we can show with math that part of the electric comet insanity is trying to explain away the Rosetta measurement of the mass of 67P with charging the spacecraft or nucleus. There is a limit to spacecraft charging. Charging the nucleus leads to enormous potentials that massively accelerates ions leading to radiation that is obvious and does not exist.
 
2.6 / 5 (5) 9 hours ago
@OldCcode - Conversing with Jones is the equivalent of standing at a fence while on the other side of it a rabid dog barks and snarls at you. He is literally clueless as to the entire branch of physics which governs most observable phenomenon, hence his rabid hatred of it and why he calls anything to do with EM "woo". In this section you have presented logical remarks and even though dealing with an abusive idiot have kept it civil. Well done.

Moderators, why is this useless tool still here aside from the entertainment value for people who like watching a daily train wreck unfold?


Read more at: https://phys.org/news/2018-11-evidence-reveals-heavy-elements-big.html#jCp


Spot on!
 
Idiotic insult from a blog to derail from his electric comet insanity

Idiotic insult from a blog to derail from his electric comet insanity.

New evidence reveals how heavy elements were created after the Big Bang is real science.

Old_C_Code starts with not grasping hat no one knows whether the universe is infinite or not and is abysmally ignorant about the evidence for the Big Bang. Told to start with the CMBR. Delusions about an "electric" sound appear. Repeats abysmal ignorance and fantasies about the CMBR. Later there is what looks like the insanity of the CMBR from the Earth's oceans. Later he does not even know how to read a graph, what a photon is, how spectrometers work, "a photon is an electron visible by the human eye" idiocy, etc. :eek:!

A "RealityCheck" (not me) chimes in with gibberish about the CMBR being microwaves from non-cosmological sources. Abysmal ignorance about what the CMBR is. A delusion that astronomers do not know about and remove microwave sources!

jonesdave asked for more than word from Old_C_Code and got nothing.
jonesdave cited a decent tutorial on what the CMB is, and its history, by Ned Wright.
jonesdave shows people that Ned Wright is a credible source.
jonesdave continues to educate: Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropy

theredpill pops in with an insanely obvious insult and Sol88 quotes it :eye-poppi!
 
Last edited:
An insult and "I can’t do the maths" stupidity about his electric comet insanity.

If he cannot "do the math" then all of his numerical assertions are baseless :jaw-dropp!

If he cannot "do the math" then he cannot verify the math in his electric comet insanity. Lucky for him there is none :p!

If he cannot "do the math" then he has to accept the math done by others, e.g. we can show with math that part of the electric comet insanity is trying to explain away the Rosetta measurement of the mass of 67P with charging the spacecraft or nucleus. There is a limit to spacecraft charging. Charging the nucleus leads to enormous potentials that massively accelerates ions leading to radiation that is obvious and does not exist.

Oh grasshopper, you have much to learn.

I accept the math I don't accept the assumption!

How to you get Q again?

Assume, assume, assume!


PS, Are you sure this is not happening?

Finlay you got something right!!
 
Last edited:
An insult and "I can’t do the maths" stupidity about his electric comet insanity.

If he cannot "do the math" then all of his numerical assertions are baseless :jaw-dropp!

If he cannot "do the math" then he cannot verify the math in his electric comet insanity. Lucky for him there is none :p!

If he cannot "do the math" then he has to accept the math done by others, e.g. we can show with math that part of the electric comet insanity is trying to explain away the Rosetta measurement of the mass of 67P with charging the spacecraft or nucleus. There is a limit to spacecraft charging. Charging the nucleus leads to enormous potentials that massively accelerates ions leading to radiation that is obvious and does not exist.

Do you want the easy math or the hard math?

Easy math use MHD.
 
Usual irrelevant lies to derail from his electric comet insanity

...Easy math use MHD.
Usual irrelevant lies to derail from his electric comet insanity.

MHD is definitely not the "easy math" that he is incapable of doing, e.g. multiplication, division, addition and subtraction of numbers. This is magnetohydrodynamics. It has vectors in it. There are dot and cross products. There are div operators. There is partial differentiation.

MHD has nothing to do with my post: Charging the nucleus leads to enormous potentials that massively accelerates ions leading to radiation that is obvious and does not exist.
That uses Coulomb's law with actually easy math of multiplication and division.
 
Last edited:
A "don't accept the assumption" lie to emphasizes his electric comet insanity

...I accept the math I don't accept the assumption!
A "don't accept the assumption" lie emphasizes his electric comet insanity.

The assumption in the example I mentioned is that the deluded Thunderbolts cult and its followers such as Sol88 may have a point. Rosetta might have a charge. 67P might have a charge. Those charges will cause a force (like charges repel, unlike charges attract :p). So do some easy math using standard physics to see what those charges might be. Find out that 67P gets a charge so enormous that it is totally obvious and will be detected.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom