Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just out of curiosity, what are Jamie Metzl's qualifications in virology? I looked, but he seems to be mostly involved in politics, public relations, and human rights, along with being a sci-fi author.
I cited Metzl as supporting evidence of Daszak's attempt to steer the WHO investigative team away from the lab accident origin. Metzl has the opinion like many others do that the origin is not yet determined either way.

As a recognized advisor to the WHO Metzl has been taken very seriously.

[caps are from the source] PBS treanscipt: OUR NEXT GUEST IS AN ADVISOR TO THE W.H.O.'S COMMITTEE ON HUMAN GENOME EDITING.
Metzl: SO THE REASON WHY I'VE BEEN SUCH A CRITIC OF THOSE TWO LETTERS. [Lancet letters]

FIRST WAS IN THE LANCET IN FEBRUARY IS THAT THESE SCIENTISTS WERE CLAIMING A CERTAINTY THAT WASN'T SUPPORTED BY THE AVAILABLE EVIDENCE.

SO BY SAYING IN THE LANCET LETTER THAT IT WAS EXTREMELY LIKELY THAT THIS HAD A NATURAL ORIGIN AND THAT ANYONE, PEOPLE LIKE ME WHO WERE WITH THE BEST OF INTENTIONS IN TRYING TO HAVE THE MOST OPEN MIND POSSIBLE, ANYONE WHO IS SUGGESTING THE POSSIBILITY OF A LAB INCIDENT EVEN A SCENARIO WHERE IT WAS VERY BENIGN, CHINESE RESEARCHERS WORKING TO DEVELOP VACCINES WHO HAD AN ACCIDENTAL INCIDENT, ANYONE WAS A CONSPIRACY THEORIST.

THAT'S WHY I'VE BEEN SUCH A CRITIC OF THAT LETTER.

I'VE CALLED IT SIGNIFICANT PROPAGANDA, NOT SCIENCE. ...

I THINK THAT THAT LETTER AND THAT PAPER CROSSED THE LINE FROM DATA DRIVEN SCIENCE INTO POLITICS BASED ON A DESIRED OUTCOME.
It doesn't take a PhD in virology to note something so obvious as a non-scientific evidence supported conclusion.

Read Metzl's description of the WHO team's trip to China in that interview. One need not be a virologist to see it's pretty clear there was no significant investigation.

In addition to his position as advisor to the WHO, here is his educational credentials:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamie_Metzl
He is a magna cum laude and Phi Beta Kappa graduate of Brown University.[8] He holds a Ph.D. in Southeast Asian history from Oxford University (1994),[14] and a J.D. from Harvard Law School.[15]

Yes, people in this thread have tired to dismiss Metzl before as if his statement about Daszak had no corroborating evidence. The idea only a small subset of expertise is valid in this discussion makes it easy to dismiss any POV you don't like.

Redfield is a virologist, he thinks a lab accident is the most likely. Oh wait, let's dismiss his opinion because he's too political.

Chinese virologist says Fauci’s emails ‘verify’ her Wuhan lab leak claims

Salon interview
To better understand this issue, Salon spoke with Dr. Stanley Perlman, a professor of microbiology and immunology, as well as of pediatrics, at the University of Iowa. He has studied coronaviruses for 39 years. As usual, the following transcript has been lightly edited for clarity and context. ...

Why do you feel the lab accident idea has gained more credibility?

Partly because we've had a lot of trouble finding these intermediate animals [harboring coronaviruses]. We know that people found them: a [similar] virus was found in a cave, and some of the people infected with it became ill. We know that that virus is similar to SARS-CoV-2 — it's 96% similar — but viruses mutate at a certain rate per year and this virus was a thousand nucleotides different from the SARS-CoV-2. So it is not the direct precursor by any means to SARS-CoV-2. If it was taken into a lab and somehow made into a clone and then manipulated, you still wouldn't end up with SARS-CoV-2. It's not possible to do that.

So that's why I think the thinking has changed — because it's been very, very difficult to find these intermediate animals or that virus that is close to SARS-CoV-2
 
Skeptic Ginger repeats the error pf citing Jamie Metzl's biased blog

Skeptic Ginger repeats the error pf citing Jamie Metzl's biased blog. A skeptic would learn who Metzl is and what he has believed before there was any evidence, not just accept whatever he says.
Jamie Metzl Statement on WHO COVID-19 Wuhan Press Conference on Feb 10, 2021 has a fact less opinion that Peter Daszak has a "clear conflict of interest". Jamie Metzl obviously lies with "no evidence has yet been found indicating that COVID-19 stems from a transmission between animal hosts in the wild". The investigation listed the evidence indicating animal transmission. Jamie Metzl is a non-biologist who has been touting the lab leak theory since January 2020 :eek:!
Here is the transcript of the COVID-19 Virtual Press conference transcript - 9 February 2021
A reporter asks "Of the four hypotheses, the only one you decisively rejected was the laboratory incident. Can you explain the evidence or the reasoning for discarding that hypothesis?". No one replies that there will be Metzl's "does not merit further investigation". The reply is that they "evaluated this hypothesis in the same way we evaluated the other hypothesis" and "The hypothesis of lab leak is put into the matrix of extremely unlikely".
Second, there may be a leak of the virus from that lab, but in terms of the leaking of the virus, it should be leaking of an existing or no virus. However, in all the laboratories in Wuhan, there is no existing virus of SARS-CoV-2. If there is no existence of this virus, there will be no way that this virus would be linked. In addition, in all the laboratories in Wuhan, including WIV, they upheld a very stringent and high-quality management system. Also proceeding from the current evidence, we regard the lab leak hypothesis as extremely unlikely. Thank you.
Metzl obviously lies with "no evidence has yet been found indicating that COVID-19 stems from a transmission between animal hosts in the wild" and his PLA paranoia in his other "evidence" blog. That "no evidence" is the lie. An animal origin is the leading hypothesis from experts based on the evidence. Investigations into the origin of COVID-19: "Experts have ruled out intentional manipulation of the virus (i.e. biological engineering) as a plausible origin,[1][63][109][110][111] due to a lack of supporting evidence,[63][4][112] and growing evidence in favor of a natural origin.[113][114][115][116]".
 
Last edited:
Here's a different angle on this, these are in peer reviewed journals:

First the tool: 2017: A Systematic Review of Risk Analysis Tools for Differentiating Unnatural From Natural Epidemics

2018: Comparison of the Available Methods of Differentiation Between a Biological Attack and Other Epidemics

Application of the tool to COVID 19: Open Medicine (also peer reviewed): Analysis of COVID-19 outbreak origin in China in 2019 using differentiation method for unusual epidemiological events
The analysis of the unusual COVID-19 outbreak shows that the present official assumption of its natural origin is questionable and pointed out to a probability that the pathogen could have also been accidentally introduced in the human population.

Conclusion
There are no conclusive pieces of evidence about the reservoir of the pathogen or the source of infection. These parameters are essential for the final clarification of the outbreak origin. This study suggests that the COVID-19 outbreak is a consequence of an accidental release of a new COVID-19 virus, probably during the technical accident and/or negligent violation of hygienic norms in the laboratory facility. Further epidemiological, microbiological, and forensic analyses are needed to clarify the COVID-19 outbreak.
 
Skeptic Ginger repeats the error pf citing Jamie Metzl's biased blog.....
Again I repeat: I cited Metzl as supporting evidence of Daszak's attempt to steer the WHO investigative team away from the lab accident origin.

There are many different pieces of evidence in this thread. Some of you would do yourselves a favor to note the problem with tunnel vision.

ETA: Address the evidence please. This fixation with attacking the messenger doesn't move the discussion forward.

Who cares who cited Metzl? The issue is what does the citation have to offer.
 
Last edited:
Metzl has the opinion like many others do that the origin is not yet determined either way.
Metzl and I share that particular opinion. (There are other opinions we do not share.) It is reasonable to ask whether Metzl's opinions on this subject should be taken any more seriously than mine.

In addition to his position as advisor to the WHO, here is his educational credentials:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamie_Metzl
He is a magna cum laude and Phi Beta Kappa graduate of Brown University.[8] He holds a Ph.D. in Southeast Asian history from Oxford University (1994),[14] and a J.D. from Harvard Law School.[15]
If you were trying to convince me that Metzl's opinions should not be taken any more seriously than mine, then you have succeeded.

When combined with the apparent lack of relevant educational and professional experience, the fact that Metzl was a very early proponent of a lab leak origin warns us that Metzl may unconsciously be seeking to confirm his early opinion on this subject, a behavior that is not entirely unknown even within the forum in which we are now conversing.

Who cares who cited Metzl? The issue is what does the citation have to offer.
For reasons explained above, the citation appears to have little to offer.

That does not mean Metzl is wrong. What it does mean is that citing Metzl looks very much like an appeal to false authority.
 
Last edited:
Again I repeat: I cited Metzl as supporting evidence of Daszak's attempt to steer the WHO investigative team away from the lab accident origin.

There are many different pieces of evidence in this thread. Some of you would do yourselves a favor to note the problem with tunnel vision.

So what? What is unusual about someone who doesn't think it's a lab leak arguing against it being a lab leak?

With the "logic" you are using anyone who argues against it being a lab leak should be disregarded on the grounds that they are arguing against a lab leak.
 
Metzl and I share that particular opinion. (There are other opinions we do not share.) It is reasonable to ask whether Metzl's opinions on this subject should be taken any more seriously than mine.
Which doesn't have jack to do with Metzl's expertise to call Daszak out.

I honestly don't see why any of you are choosing Daszak's integrity as a hill to die on.
 
Which doesn't have jack to do with Metzl's expertise to call Daszak out.

I honestly don't see why any of you are choosing Daszak's integrity as a hill to die on.

1. As asked, what is Metzl’s expertise?

2. “I honestly don’t see…” is a terrible argument. We get that you have made up your mind on Daszak. But many of the allegations against him seem trumped up and based on misunderstandings (in some cases honest misunderstandings and in other cases dishonest ones).
 
Which doesn't have jack to do with Metzl's expertise to call Daszak out.

I honestly don't see why any of you are choosing Daszak's integrity as a hill to die on.
I didn't expect to die on that hill, partly because I haven't expressed any opinion whatsoever regarding Daszak's integrity.

I am not at all surprised that you have chosen to interpret my silence regarding Daszak's integrity as some kind of death wish.
 
Again I repeat:...
Nothing to do with ignorantly citing Jamie Metzl's biased blog and his obvious lies. If you learned abut Metzl or read the press interview, you would know that you are repeatedly citing a biased and even lying blog.
Skeptic Ginger repeats the error pf citing Jamie Metzl's biased blog (with a couple of his lies)
This seems to be consistent with your other "evidence".
  1. No science in a slightly paranoid US Right To Know article
  2. Skeptic Ginger cites a Daily Mail tabloid article basically lying about Peter Daszak
  3. A "it is a fact he was removed from the UN Commission" error from Skeptic Ginger
  4. Skeptic Ginger cites a slightly idiotic "The World University Rankings" web page.
  5. Skeptic Ginger cites a irrelevant, paranoid article.
A "ETA: Address the evidence please." lie as this list addresses the evidence you have cited, e.g. you cited an obviously lying Daily Mail article (Daszak was recused, not fired, and no one knows whether he or the commission did that).
 
Last edited:
A dubious paper, Skeptic Ginger.
The author is Vladan Radosavljevic of the Institute of Epidemiology, Military Medical Academy, Crnotravska 17, 11000 Belgrade, Serbia. But he writes a problematic "There are very important issues/questions about COVID-19 outbreak origin" list.
  • "There is no scientific evidence that the COVID-19 virus exists in any animal;" and "Were there dead animals infected with the COVID-19 virus?"
    No one expects our (as he implies) COVID-19 virus to exist in animals because it would have mutated to leap to humans. We do see closely related viruses in animals. That is why bats are identified as a probable reservoir and perhaps direct source.
  • You should have noted the "Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market" error.
    There is no mention of the first known case unrelated to the market.
  • He asks "What happened with the bat hunters and people who prepared and transported the “infected bats” to the market? [2]".
    I doubt whether a seafood market would sell bats.
    Animal sales from Wuhan wet markets immediately prior to the COVID-19 pandemic has no bat sales in any wet market between May 2017 and November 2019.
    The bat transmission scenario seems to be transmission to animals or humans in their habitat and those travelled to Wuhan.
  • He writes "It takes weeks, months, and in some cases years for establishing the complete genome." and complains about the short time it took to get the genome sequence.
    Could it be because Chinese scientists in BSL labs have been studying bat coronaviruses for decades and the COVID-19 virus is related?
  • A "Luc Montagnier publicly announced that the genome sequence was artificially changed. There is no serious scientific denial of it." error.
    Why Nobel Laureate Luc Montagnier’s Arguments for COVID Lab-Leak Don’t Hold Up
    An article published more recently in the journal Nature Medicine analysing the new virus’s genome concluded thus: “Our analyses clearly show that SARS-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct or a purposefully manipulated virus.”
    Andersen, K.G., Rambaut, A., Lipkin, W.I. et al. The proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2. Nat Med 26, 450–452 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-020-0820-9
    Here we review what can be deduced about the origin of SARS-CoV-2 from comparative analysis of genomic data. We offer a perspective on the notable features of the SARS-CoV-2 genome and discuss scenarios by which they could have arisen. Our analyses clearly show that SARS-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct or a purposefully manipulated virus.
  • Some "Chinese officials" did not do stuff assertions.
These are strange errors for someone who should be an expert.
The paper body is basically a statistical analysis of selected papers using a scoring system. Those strange errors possibly affecting his selection of the papers. He writes "Also, the Radosavljevic–Belojevic method was the most suitable to answer questions from Section 1." when he has asked the wrong questions.
 
Last edited:
I didn't expect to die on that hill, partly because I haven't expressed any opinion whatsoever regarding Daszak's integrity.

I am not at all surprised that you have chosen to interpret my silence regarding Daszak's integrity as some kind of death wish.

This is what you said:
It is reasonable to ask whether Metzl's opinions on this subject should be taken any more seriously than mine.
The answer is yes, given he's an adviser to the WHO and that he addressed Daszak's unscientific dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis.

Are you an adviser to the WHO? Why would you have no opinion on Daszak unscientific dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis?
 
This is what you said:The answer is yes, given he's an adviser to the WHO and that he addressed Daszak's unscientific dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis.
Wrong, Skeptic Ginger.
The answer is no because Metzl is not a biologist and neither is W.D.Clinger (or me or seemingly you.
Jamie Metzl is not a advisor to the WHO on epidemics, especially the COVID-19 epidemic. He is a member of the Expert Advisory Committee on Developing Global Standards for Governance and Oversight of Human Genome Editing on the scientific, ethical, social and legal challenges. He has no relevant scientific background so he is advising on ethical, social and legal challenges.
 
Last edited:
I didn't expect to die on that hill, partly because I haven't expressed any opinion whatsoever regarding Daszak's integrity.

I am not at all surprised that you have chosen to interpret my silence regarding Daszak's integrity as some kind of death wish.

This is what you said:
It is reasonable to ask whether Metzl's opinions on this subject should be taken any more seriously than mine.
The answer is yes, given he's an adviser to the WHO and that he addressed Daszak's unscientific dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis.
You are a great deal more impressed by the relevance of those credentials than I am:
  • Metzl "was appointed to the WHO’s expert advisory committee on human genome editing in 2019 and is also the author of Hacking Darwin."
    • The committee is concerned with "human genome editing", which has nothing to do with the origins of COVID-19.
    • Metzl's role on that committee appears to be that of a technological futurist and ethicist, and not the role of a scientist.
    • Reviews of Metzl's book reinforce my impression that Metzl is primarily concerned about the ethics of editing the human genome, and not with the science of gene editing.
  • Anyone at all, no matter how ignorant or misinformed, can address "Daszak's unscientific dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis", as you put it. If there were any doubt about that, it would be dispelled by searching this thread for occurrences of the name "Daszak". So the fact that someone has addressed something Daszak has said or written is no credential at all.

Are you an adviser to the WHO?
I am not an advisor to the WHO.

Why would you have no opinion on Daszak unscientific dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis?
There you go again, writing "Daszak unscientific dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis", although you omitted the possessive this time, perhaps to add some variety.

Let's note also that you phrased your question as though you do not understand the difference between having no opinion on X and expressing no opinion on X.

Why did you ask such a question? Because you want to change the subject. It's as though you secretly desire to lend credence to the idea some have expressed that your arguments in this thread often resemble a Gish Gallop.

I explained why your citation of Metzl as an authority on any of this appears to be an appeal to false authority. You have now made it perfectly clear that you are appealing to Metzl's authority because of his irrelevant education and appointment to an irrelevant committee.

As for why I have not expressed any opinion regarding Daszak (which is not the same as having no opinion about Daszak), you should consider the possibility that I have not expressed an opinion because any opinion I might have about Daszak would be as worthless as Metzl's opinion or your opinion.
 
This is what you said:The answer is yes, given he's an adviser to the WHO
The issue is what does he advise them about and is that relevant? Should we listen to an adviser to WHO about wearing masks when they are a financial advisor? I haven't seen any medical advising in his qualifications, only legal and ethical advising.

and that he addressed Daszak's unscientific dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis.

Which you seem to be accepting of this without question. I see nothing in his background that would lead me to believe that he is able to speak as an expert on scientific matters, or on what is scientific and what is not. Given that others are accusing him of saying things that are at the least inaccurate, then why should I unquestioningly accept what he claims?
 
Last edited:
Skeptic Ginger cites a couple of virologists who believe in the lab leak

Skeptic Ginger cites a couple of virologists who believe in the lab leak, perhaps of a manipulated virus.
Virologists will have different opinions about the source of COVID-19. The majority go for the animal origin.
Andersen, K.G., Rambaut, A., Lipkin, W.I. et al. The proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2. Nat Med 26, 450–452 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-020-0820-9 is 5 people who have scientific evidence that SARS-CoV-2 "is not a laboratory construct or a purposefully manipulated virus.". So not a manipulated virus leaked from a lab.

The first link is a Chinese virologist thinking Fauci’s alleged "may have been 'engineered'" emails support her claim. See above - she is wrong.
Fauci’s emails
“The unusual features of the virus make up a really small part of the genome (<0.1%) so one has to look really closely at all the sequences to see that some of the features (potentially) look engineered,” he wrote.

Andersen also noted that he and others “all find the genome inconsistent with expectations from evolutionary theory” but added that “there are still further analyses to be done, so those opinions could still change.”
This is not her assertion of support for a lab leak of a manipulated virus.

The Salon interview with Dr. Stanley Perlman states that the virus was not manipulated: "If it was taken into a lab and somehow made into a clone and then manipulated, you still wouldn't end up with SARS-CoV-2. It's not possible to do that.". Dr. Stanley Perlman disagrees with the gain-in-function research origin of the virus.
I don't agree with the first part of your sentence. If it originated a lab, it could be one of those bat viruses that was being studied and just happened to be one that can directly infect people. No gain of function, no manipulation, nothing else, just there. Whether that could have directly infected a human efficiently, I would have said not.
Dr. Stanley Perlman says the "two sets of ideas are converging" in that both have a natural virus ending up in Wuhan. Opinions vary on the possibility of each idea.
 
Last edited:
Metzl "addressed Daszak's unscientific dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis"

This is what you said:The answer is yes, given he's an adviser to the WHO and that he addressed Daszak's unscientific dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis.
Cite where Metzl "addressed Daszak's unscientific dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis", Skeptic Ginger.
This thread has 6 results for "Metzl, Daszak, leak". There is link to a YouTube video where he appears on the Joe Rogan Experience.
there was a process where a series of scientists did two things
one they came out with a letter in the in the british medical journal the lancet which we've subsequently learned was highly manipulated by a small number of people who may have had vested interests
and there was a academic paper in a journal called nature communications and both made the case oh this isn't a lab leak and then there was a concerted effort to label anybody else as a conspiracy theorist and so i kind of spent last year in that uncomfortable space...
A bit of idiocy there. Of course open letters are written by a small number of authors and their opinions will be in that letter! The other signees agree with the opinions by signing the letter. That is real life not a "highly manipulated" letter.
A "concerted effort" fantasy.

Statement in support of the scientists, public health professionals, and medical professionals of China combatting COVID-19
We are public health scientists who have closely followed the emergence of 2019 novel coronavirus disease (COVID-19) and are deeply concerned about its impact on global health and wellbeing. We have watched as the scientists, public health professionals, and medical professionals of China, in particular, have worked diligently and effectively to rapidly identify the pathogen behind this outbreak, put in place significant measures to reduce its impact, and share their results transparently with the global health community. This effort has been remarkable.
We sign this statement in solidarity with all scientists and health professionals in China who continue to save lives and protect global health during the challenge of the COVID-19 outbreak. We are all in this together, with our Chinese counterparts in the forefront, against this new viral threat.

The rapid, open, and transparent sharing of data on this outbreak is now being threatened by rumours and misinformation around its origins. We stand together to strongly condemn conspiracy theories suggesting that COVID-19 does not have a natural origin. Scientists from multiple countries have published and analysed genomes of the causative agent, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2),1 and they overwhelmingly conclude that this coronavirus originated in wildlife,2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 as have so many other emerging pathogens.11, 12 This is further supported by a letter from the presidents of the US National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine13 and by the scientific communities they represent. Conspiracy theories do nothing but create fear, rumours, and prejudice that jeopardise our global collaboration in the fight against this virus. We support the call from the Director-General of WHO to promote scientific evidence and unity over misinformation and conjecture.14 We want you, the science and health professionals of China, to know that we stand with you in your fight against this virus.

We invite others to join us in supporting the scientists, public health professionals, and medical professionals of Wuhan and across China. Stand with our colleagues on the frontline!
We speak in one voice. To add your support for this statement, sign our letter online. LM is editor of ProMED-mail. We declare no competing interests.
Condemning lab leak conspiracy theories is obviously scientific. This letter does not condemn the lab leak hypothesis. The only issue is that the letter does not make this clearer. The Support for the Public Health Professionals of China Combatting COVID-19 petition 1 click away from the letter with 20,000 signatures does make it clear that this is actual conspiracy theorists.
Following the events around the emergence of COVID-19 in China, international scientists have been dismayed by the spreading of rumors, misinformation and conspiracy theories on the virus’ origins. These rumors are now specifically targeting scientists and health professionals who have been working extremely hard to fight this outbreak and have shared data with unprecedented speed, openness, and transparency. Some of these scientists have already received threats of violence to their families and themselves. These rumors and conspiracy theories threaten to undermine the very global collaborations that are vital to combat this disease that has already spread across continents, and for that reason have been condemned by many, including repeatedly by the WHO Director-General, and the Director of The Wellcome Trust.

A group of 27 public health scientists from 8 countries have signed an “open letter” in the Lancet to support scientists, public health and medical professionals of China fighting the outbreak of COVID-19 and to roundly condemn conspiracy theories surrounding it. These scientists include Sir Jeremy Farrar OBE, Jim Hughes (former Asst. Surgeon General, former Head of CDC NCID, Rear Admiral US Public Health Service Rtd.), Rita Colwell (former Head of the US National Science Foundation), multiple members of the US National Academy of Medicine, Prof. Sai Kit Lam (Member of Malaysian Academy of Medicine who co-discovered Nipah virus), John Mackenzie (Officer of the Order of Australia, member of WHO GOARN Steering Committee), Dr. Jerry Keusch (former Head of NIH Fogarty International Center), and other leaders in the field of infectious disease research and public health.

Their goals in publishing this open letter are to reach as wide an audience as possible at this critical juncture of the COVID-19 outbreak, so that unfounded rumors may be quashed, and a message of encouragement and solidarity will be read by colleagues in China who are working hard to fight the outbreak as well as by the leaders at governmental agencies in China, USA, and around the world that might otherwise give credence to misinformation and conspiracy theories.
 
Last edited:
The issue is what does he advise them about and is that relevant? Should we listen to an adviser to WHO about wearing masks when they are a financial advisor? I haven't seen any medical advising in his qualifications, only legal and ethical advising.
How is this the least bit relevant to Metzl pointing out Daszak manipulated the propaganda POV that the lab leak was a CT? :confused:

Which you seem to be accepting of this without question. I see nothing in his background that would lead me to believe that he is able to speak as an expert on scientific matters, or on what is scientific and what is not. Given that others are accusing him of saying things that are at the least inaccurate, then why should I unquestioningly accept what he claims?
:dl:

Are we on page 51 yet? [yes we are] I've been reading and posting consistently in this thread for more than 6 months and you think what? I know nothing about Daszak's manipulating except what one person said?

Daszak manipulated the Lancet piece and hid his involvement when recruiting scientists to sign their name to the letter. That has been exposed. He led the WHO investigation to dismiss the lab hypothesis without evidence to support the dismissal. The head of the WHO stated in no uncertain terms the lab hypothesis was prematurely dismissed.

From the WA Po:Timeline: How the Wuhan lab-leak theory suddenly became credible
Feb. 19: A statement is published in Lancet by a group of 27 scientists: “We stand together to strongly condemn conspiracy theories suggesting that covid-19 does not have a natural origin,” the statement says. Scientists “overwhelmingly conclude that this coronavirus originated in wildlife.” The statement was drafted and organized by Peter Daszak, president of EcoHealth Alliance, which funded research at WIV with U.S. government grants. (Three of the signers have since said a laboratory accident is plausible enough to merit consideration.)
 
Skeptic Ginger persists with misunderstanding the Lancet open letter

Daszak manipulated the Lancet piece...
Skeptic Ginger persists with misunderstanding the Lancet open letter which rightfully condemned lab leak conspiracy theories, not the lab leak hypothesis.
Skeptic Ginger persists with irrelevant links. A timeline of the Wuhan lab-leak hypothesis saying nothing about the "manipulated the Lancet piece" nonsense.
A "The head of the WHO stated in no uncertain terms the lab hypothesis was prematurely dismissed." lie.
WHO Director-General's remarks at the Member State Briefing on the report of the international team studying the origins of SARS-CoV-2
Although the team has concluded that a laboratory leak is the least likely hypothesis, this requires further investigation, potentially with additional missions involving specialist experts, which I am ready to deploy.
This is the WHO Director-General agreeing with the report. A least likely hypothesis is a still possible hypothesis. There is a hint that the study recommended no further study but it did not. Page 120:
In view of the above, a laboratory origin of the pandemic was considered to be extremely unlikely.
What would be needed to increase knowledge?
Regular administrative and internal review of high-level biosafety laboratories worldwide. Follow-up of new evidence supplied around possible laboratory leaks.

ETA: This is the study WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part. The "Introduction through a laboratory incident" section begins on page 118.
Arguments in favour are
  • "Although rare, laboratory accidents do happen" and
  • The Wuhan CDC lab moved closer to the Huanan market on 2 December 2019 - "Such moves can be disruptive for the operations of any laboratory.".
Arguments against are
  • "The closest relatives of SARS-CoV-2 from bats and pangolin are evolutionarily distant from SARS-CoV-2."
  • "There is no record of viruses closely related to SARS-CoV-2 in any laboratory before December 2019, ..."
  • The risk of accident culturing of SARS-CoV-2 is extremely low since there is no evidence of circulation among people globally before Decamber 2019.
  • "The three laboratories in Wuhan working with either CoVs diagnostics and/or CoVs isolation and vaccine development all had high quality biosafety level (BSL3 or 4) facilities that were well-managed, with a staff health monitoring programme with no reporting of COVID-19 compatible respiratory illness during the weeks/months prior to December 2019...".
  • No reported "disruptions or incidents" during the Wuhan CDC lab move. "They also reported no storage nor laboratory activities on CoVs or other bat viruses preceding the outbreak"
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom