Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have a hunch that the report in CNN could be a bluff to make China more willing to open up adn give them an incentive to try to get ahead of the story, but of course, this is pure speculation on my part.
That's pretty far-fetched for speculation.

It looked to me like the data is now in the hands of the US National Security Agency or whichever agency is doing that 90 day investigation, I lose track.

I suspect that like Bloom found data in the cloud, the data that was accessible which the Chinese took down was still accessible via other routes.

But last I checked there's still no more news about it. Time will tell.
 
I thought you wrote it in GIANT letters?

Acknowledge, not "concede", and I have pointed out what I consider to be the area where it is reasonable to say "conflict of interest". Not everyone agrees with that. It's fine.

Yeah...no. His company had millions of dollars in grant money that would dry up in a flash if it turns out the WIV was the origin.

This is the usual cynical interpretation. Everything anyone does must be for the worst possible motivation you can think of, right?

Except how is it that Peter Daszak could then also pay off all the other scientists in the world? This is where you step into the world of conspiracy theory.

I assume people in this thread could discriminate better than that.

So would I, except you have been equating spillover with alien attacks as if the likelihood were the same. You don't like it, then don't engage in it.

Of course. But evidence has been posted ad nauseum here. If you still think I haven't what would me posting more do? Stop with this ******** telling me to support something I have supported MULTIPLE TIMES!!!!!!!!!!

Enough is enough. Seriously.


And there you ******* go again with that same crap. Oh for pity's sake.

Daszak referenced how easy it was to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab. What do you suppose he meant by that?


As for not attacking me, this thread is in the science forum. And as much as I know some of you are just chomping at the bit to drag it back into the CT forum it's about the evidence and the science and not about Ginger and all those attempts to discredit me when you should be discrediting the cited evidence.

He never "incriminated" himself. This is you being hyperbolic.

What he was talking about was exactly what had been printed in black and white in science journals - and he was referencing work done in Ralph Baric's lab.

You have attempted, as with other Covid Truthers, to cobble together a narrative in which he accidentally let the cat out of the bag and then hushed up. These are the allegations you made and they are lies. If you lie, expect to get called on it. Don't start acting shocked and wondering why you are suddenly a target.
 
Repeating unsupported assertions does not make them true, Skeptic Ginger. Read what you wrote: As for the assertion the spillover is generally supported by scientists, that is no longer true ...
Thus What is your evidence that the majority of scientists support a lab leak, Skeptic Ginger?
The evidence that I cited is that the majority of scientists support a zoonotic origin with a lab leak being a remote possibility. A "spillover" is still generally supported by scientists. A remotely possible lab leak was always an alternative.

Give your evidence that Peter Daszak "did his best to slant the consensus", Skeptic Ginger?
Insulting Daszak as dishonest is not that evidence which might be as simple as a link to where in this thread that evidence is presented.

Even the head of the WHO has questioned the conclusions of the WHO investigation is also wrong.
WHO calls for further studies, data on origin of SARS-CoV-2 virus, reiterates that all hypotheses remain open. WHO Director-General Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus agreed with the report conclusions, including the need for further studies. This is obvious. If we have not found the zoonotic source of a virus, more study is needed. If we have a very unlikely lab leak, more study is needed.

You wrote a "The report was from the head of the WIV over Shi" error (The head of the WIV is Dr. Wang Yanyi ) error.

A "Daszak has a serious conflict of interest" lie there is no serious conflict of interest (and some may have the opinion there is no conflict of interest at all) in Addendum: competing interests and the origins of SARS-CoV-2.

There was a salary from EcoHealth Alliance which is funded by the US NIH and USAID. Daszak never received Chinese money. Daszak was an independent expert in a private capacity in the WHO investigation.
You are repeating a BS pattern where one needs to challenge what people post and make accusations.

Just stop. Address the cited evidence. Stop trying to find some gotchas or whatever you are trying to do.

Is your issue that I don't know what I said because you didn't understand it?:rolleyes:

I have said on numerous occasions including multiple times recently that the issue for me and for many others is that neither origin has been ruled in or out. You think I said something else it's not my problem.

As for Daszak, how many times do I have to post the same evidence over and over? There is a point where it amounts to too many times. There is no point. No one has made unsupported accusations about Daszak.

As for who is whose boss, why does that ******* matter? It doesn't. Look at the citation for what it is. Address what is in the citation. Period, full stop.


I'm not sure what your other issues are. Your posts are hard to read. Take my name out of your posts and address the evidence. This thread is not about me.
 
Last edited:
You are repeating a BS pattern where one needs to challenge what people post and make accusations....
BS pattern nonsense that does not address my questions or the obvious "Daszak has a serious conflict of interest" lie. He had an indirect, non-financial link to WIV that he explained fully when the Lancet asked him to expand on it in interests of transparency that was not a conflict of interest because he was an independent expert in a private capacity in the WHO investigation.

You do not have to post the same information many times. You can link to where you posted that information in this thread. The inability to do that simple act suggests that this information does not exist here.
This forum also has a search function. Looking for "Daszak conflict" shows gives posts among others.
You just accepting a Taiwan News article with a "millions of dollars" over 20 years from the WIV claim. The lack of a number is a hint there is something wrong. The article is wrong. Daszak never received any money from the WIV. Daszak's salary from EcoHealth Alliance might sum up to millions over a period of 20 years which would be reasonable for their President and a director.
You make up "there is a serious conflict of interest there." because Eco Health Alliance (from which Daszak has a salary) partnered with the Wuhan lab.
You cite a press release on a blog. Jamie Metzl Statement on WHO COVID-19 Wuhan Press Conference on Feb 10, 2021 has a fact less opinion that Peter Daszak has a "clear conflict of interest". Jamie Metzl obviously lies with "no evidence has yet been found indicating that COVID-19 stems from a transmission between animal hosts in the wild". The investigation listed the evidence indicating animal transmission. Jamie Metzl is a non-biologist who has been touting the lab leak theory since January 2020 :eek:!
 
Last edited:
Once again though I don't know why the hell I am bothering:

Emails show scientists discussed masking their involvement in key journal letter on Covid origins
EcoHealth Alliance President Peter Daszak, the head of an organization involved in research that genetically manipulates coronaviruses, discussed hiding his role in a statement published last year in The Lancet that condemned as “conspiracy theories” concerns that the COVID-19 virus may have originated in a research lab, emails obtained by US Right to Know show.

The Lancet statement, signed by 27 prominent scientists, has been influential in tamping down suspicions by some scientists that COVID-19 could have ties to China’s Wuhan Institute of Virology, which has a research affiliation to the EcoHealth Alliance.

Daszak drafted the statement and circulated it to other scientists to sign. But the emails reveal that Daszak and two other EcoHealth-affiliated scientists thought they should not sign the statement so as to mask their involvement in it. Leaving their names off the statement would give it “some distance from us and therefore doesn’t work in a counterproductive way,” Daszak wrote.

Daszak noted that he could “send it round” to other scientists to sign. “We’ll then put it out in a way that doesn’t link it back to our collaboration so we maximize an independent voice,” he wrote.

The two scientists Daszak wrote to about the need to make the paper appear independent of EcoHealth, are coronavirus experts Ralph Baric and Linfa Wang.

British doctor Peter Daszak who tried to gag Wuhan lab leak theory is FIRED from UN commission investigating COVID after he was exposed for organizing letter denying leak claim in The Lancet medical journal
Earlier this month, it emerged he'd organized a letter co-signed by scientists and published in prestigious medical journal The Lancet denouncing lab leak theory
Daszak did so despite having strong professional ties to the Wuhan Institute of Virology - the Chinese lab COVID may have leaked from ...

Daszak's passionate defense of the Wuhan lab's work has raised eyebrows
He said the idea that COVID-19 could have escaped from the lab was conspiracy
Daszak insisted live bats were not kept at Wuhan, but now admits they may ...

Daszak's presence on a number of bodies investigating the origins of COVID has proved controversial because he has links to the Wuhan Institute and its chief researcher Dr Shi Zhengli - dubbed 'Batwoman'.

He helped organize a letter published in prestigious medical journal The Lancet that was signed by 27 scientists, including Daszak himself, and denounced the lab leak claim as a 'conspiracy theory,' and 'nonscientific.'

Daszak has since faced conflict of interest claims over his ties to the lab investigators increasingly believe COVID may have leaked from.

Daily Caller or not, it is a fact he was removed from the UN Commission. It is a fact he is seen now as having manipulated the Lancet article and the scientists who signed the letter.

Under-fire Lancet admits conflict of interest on lab-leak letter
After criticism that it failed to declare Peter Daszak’s work with the Wuhan Institute of Virology, journal has also ‘recused’ zoologist from its coronavirus origins taskforce


The rest you have to register to read. The Lancet doubled down last year when these accusations were made and claimed they were in full support of fellow researchers at the WIV. But at least one signatory to the Lancet letter has withdrawn his name

Peter Daszak’s EcoHealth Alliance Has Hidden Almost $40 Million In Pentagon Funding And Militarized Pandemic Science

Sounds CTish until you look and see it was a pitch for funds for his company from the Pentagon during the Bush admin.

For his part, Daszak has repeatedly dismissed the notion that the pandemic could have a lab origin. In fact, a recent FOIA by the transparency group U.S. Right To Know revealed that Peter Daszak drafted an influential multi-author letter published on February 18 in the Lancet. That letter dismissed lab origin hypothesese as “conspiracy theory.” Daszak was revealed to have orchestrated the letter such as to “avoid the appearance of a political statement.” ...

To be strictly fair to the media, Daszak’s EcoHealth Alliance obscures its Pentagon funding. On its website EcoHealth Alliance states that “A copy of the EHA Grant Management Manual is available upon request to the EHA Chief Financial Officer at finance ( at ) ecohealthalliance.org”. But an email to that address and numerous others, including Peter Daszak’s, requesting that Manual, as well as other financial information, was not returned. Neither were repeated voicemails. ...

Meticulous investigation of U.S. government databases reveals that Pentagon funding for the EcoHealth Alliance from 2013 to 2020, including contracts, grants and subcontracts, was just under $39 million. Most, $34.6 million, was from the Defense Threat Reduction Agency (DTRA), which is a branch of the DOD which states it is tasked to “counter and deter weapons of mass destruction and improvised threat networks.” ...

The full funding breakdown is available here and is summarized by year, source, and type, in a spreadsheet format.

Pdf versions of this the spreadsheet are available to download. The summary is here and all Federal grants and contracts are here.
Those links are in the link.


Oh that's right, posting overwhelming evidence is supposedly a gishgallop. No wonder you all keep asking for the same evidence over and over. Well, I better stop here then. :rolleyes:
 
Once again though I don't know why the hell I am bothering:

Emails show scientists discussed masking their involvement in key journal letter on Covid origins

British doctor Peter Daszak who tried to gag Wuhan lab leak theory is FIRED from UN commission investigating COVID after he was exposed for organizing letter denying leak claim in The Lancet medical journal



Daily Caller or not, it is a fact he was removed from the UN Commission. It is a fact he is seen now as having manipulated the Lancet article and the scientists who signed the letter.

Under-fire Lancet admits conflict of interest on lab-leak letter
After criticism that it failed to declare Peter Daszak’s work with the Wuhan Institute of Virology, journal has also ‘recused’ zoologist from its coronavirus origins taskforce


The rest you have to register to read. The Lancet doubled down last year when these accusations were made and claimed they were in full support of fellow researchers at the WIV. But at least one signatory to the Lancet letter has withdrawn his name

Peter Daszak’s EcoHealth Alliance Has Hidden Almost $40 Million In Pentagon Funding And Militarized Pandemic Science

Sounds CTish until you look and see it was a pitch for funds for his company from the Pentagon during the Bush admin.



Those links are in the link.


Oh that's right, posting overwhelming evidence is supposedly a gishgallop. No wonder you all keep asking for the same evidence over and over. Well, I better stop here then. :rolleyes:

On the other hand you could say that Daszak is perhaps the world expert on genetic manipulation of coronaviruses, and familiar with work at WIV, thus his opinion should be taken seriously. Just because one can find a potential conflict of interest does not mean someone is lying. Unfortunately, especially in a capitalist environment most experts can be found to have a conflict of interest. Most still speak the truth.
 
I know what you are saying Soba. I have not failed to understand your premise. I can't see any evidence whatsoever to keep that market on the origin table.

Did you miss this post where a year ago even the Chinese dismissed the seafood market?

That's a really weak article. They are trying to argue that because they tested animals that were in the market at the end of Jan that there were no infected animals there at the end of Oct. This just doesn't make sense. You'd need a lot of luck to find infected animals even if you got there on time, 2-3 months later there is no realistic expectation of finding infected animals.

There were however environmental samples that suggest the presence of infected animals at some point
 
Read what I wrote and you quoted.
Back to politics, not science, Skeptic Ginger. That is a report from politicians with their own agenda and ignoring that places like laboratories have ongoing maintenance and renovation.
These politicians have no evidence that needs to be collaborated! They cite the expected maintenance and renovation on functioning equipment.

Indeed.
Regular maintenance is occurring:
"See! There are clearly problems with the lab. that need to be fixed! China can not be allowed to have advanced laboratory facilities! "

Regular maintenance is not occurring:
""See! They are not performing important maintenance on the lab so it will inevitably break down! China can not be allowed to have advanced laboratory facilities!"

Either way it works as justification for right wing jingoistic rhetoric an politics.
 
No science in a slightly paranoid US Right To Know article

Skeptic Ginger. cites a slightly paranoid article from a "US Right To Know" website. Daszak and two other EcoHealth-affiliated scientists discussed leaving their names off the Lancelet open letter to "maximize an independent voice". Daszak does not want their opinion that the origin is not from a lab leak to influence other possible signees. He wants as many independent voices signing as possible. The hint of paranoia is that a letter from 27 scientists could change the evidence that thousands of scientists on which based their opinion. Along with "genetically manipulate coronaviruses" with no explanation. The EcoHealth Alliance is partially funded to enable research into the emergence of disease from wildlife. The genetic manipulation is standard research conducted in labs around the world. For example, gain-of-function research is used to predict what a mutation may do to increases the range of infection such as transmission to a new species.

USRTK is an anti-bioresearch, pro-organics organization.US Right to Know (USRTK): Organic industry funded anti-bio group attacks researchers
 
Skeptic Ginger cites a Daily Mail tabloid article basically lying about Peter Daszak

This is the Daily Mail. Skeptic Ginger does not understand that this article basically lies about Peter Daszak
Daszak recused himself from The Lancet's inquiry commission focused on COVID-19 origins, after concerns were raised over his links to the Wuhan Institute of Virology.[41]
These are basic facts that any reporter would have found. The article repeats the lie in the title and adds idiocy. An open letter is not secret. Organizing one is not a firing offence in the Lancelet or UN. Daszak does not have any conflicts of interest.
Addendum: competing interests and the origins of SARS-CoV-2 published June 26, 2021 which is 2 months before this news report. A "public expert on disease ecology, in particular on zoonosis" will have connections to scientists researching zoonosis. A connection with the WIV is no surprise.

Note that the "after concerns were raised over his links to the Wuhan Institute of Virology.[41]" is not the cause of the recursion. No reason for Daszak recusing himself was given.
 
Last edited:
A "it is a fact he was removed from the UN Commission" error from Skeptic Ginge

Daily Caller or not, it is a fact he was removed from the UN Commission.
A "it is a fact he was removed from the UN Commission" error when it is an easily found fact that Daszak recused himself.
Reference [41] is to The Telegraph article UK scientist with links to Wuhan lab 'recuses himself' from inquiry into Covid origins on 22 June 2021.
On the commission’s website it states that Dr Daszak has “recused himself from Commission work on the origins of the pandemic” but gives no further information.
The list of commissioners has been updated since then to remove Daszak. The Wayback Mahine has a copy from 22 June 2021 with that note.
 
Skeptic Ginger cites a slightly idiotic "The World University Rankings" web page.

Skeptic Ginger cites a slightly idiotic "The World University Rankings" web page. Needs registration but look at what is available
After criticism that it failed to declare Peter Daszak’s work with the Wuhan Institute of Virology, journal has also ‘recused’ zoologist from its coronavirus origins taskforce
The implied idiocy that journals investigate authors for conflicts of interest. Actual idiocy that the Lancelet ‘recused’ Daszak when it published that he had no conflict of interest.
In June 2021, Daszak recused himself from The Lancet's inquiry commission focused on COVID-19 origins, after concerns were raised over his links to the Wuhan Institute of Virology.[41] may be wrong with "himself". Recursion can be from the person or imposed (at least in the legal sense).
 
Last edited:
Skeptic Ginger cites a irrelevant, paranoid article.

Skeptic Ginger cites a irrelevant, paranoid article.
Paranoia that funds are hidden when they found them in US government databases. EcoHealth Alliance not listing every individual donor is not hiding donors when anyone can find them
The Pentagon will be interested in the transmission of diseases from animals to humans because they employ humans! The Pentagon gave trivial (to them) funds to the EcoHealth Alliance ($39 million over 17 years). Maybe paranoia that just getting money from the Pentagon means EcoHealth Alliance must be funding bioweapons?
 
Last edited:
Anyone denying Daszak's conflict of interest and manipulation suppressing the lab leak hypothesis can't possibly be paying attention.

It's unbelievable. ******* unbelievable. It's also tiring.

There'll be more evidence pinning down lab or natural origin. I can wait.
 
Skeptic Ginger's repeated "not paying attention" nonsense.

Anyone denying Daszak's conflict of interest and manipulation suppressing the lab leak hypothesis can't possibly be paying attention.
Did the Lancet did not pay attention? Do you want Daszak to be gagged so he cannot express his opinion, Skeptic Ginger :p?
The Lancelet accepted that Daszak had no conflict of interest: Addendum: competing interests and the origins of SARS-CoV-2
Daszak expressing his (incorrect in my opinion) opinion about a lab leak is not manipulation or suppression.

Skeptic Ginger's repeated "not paying attention" nonsense. Here is me paying attention to Skeptic Ginger's lack of evidence.
No science in a slightly paranoid US Right To Know article
Skeptic Ginger cites a Daily Mail tabloid article basically lying about Peter Daszak
A "it is a fact he was removed from the UN Commission" error from Skeptic Ginger
Skeptic Ginger cites a slightly idiotic "The World University Rankings" web page.
Skeptic Ginger cites a irrelevant, paranoid article.

Maybe there will be "more evidence pinning down lab or natural origin". We may have all the evidence that we will ever get. Hopefully we can find more animal and human samples closer to the probable animal origin. More evidence of the very unlikely lab leak is more unlikely (think about the GOP report coverup assertion).
 
Last edited:
This is page 50 of this thread. All of that was addressed multiple times in the thread, RC. You act like this is the first time you've heard of any of this.
 
From Feb to review:

Jamie Metzl Statement on WHO COVID-19 Wuhan Press Conference
Although I remain a steadfast supporter of the World Health Organization and its Director General, Dr. Tedros Adhanom, I am appalled by the WHO expert committee’s announcement in its ill-advised February 9 Wuhan press event that the possibility of an accidental lab leak does not merit further investigation. While no evidence has yet been found indicating that COVID-19 stems from a transmission between animal hosts in the wild or from frozen foods, as the committee entertains, significant evidence points to an accidental leak from the Wuhan Institute of Virology as being a possible origin of the pandemic.

That the Chinese government had veto power over who from the international community could participate in the investigation and stage managed the investigation process itself, as well as the clear conflict of interest of WHO investigator Peter Daszak, raise fundamental questions about the credibility of the investigation as currently construed.

While the failures of many governments and international organizations during the pandemic must all be analyzed and addressed, knowing how this crisis started is the essential foundation for prioritizing next steps and building a safer future for all. To help gain this understanding, we urgently need a full and unrestricted international forensic investigation into the origins of COVID-19 with full access to all relevant records, samples, and personnel. Without that access and overly managed by Chinese authorities, the WHO investigation in its present form does not meet that standard.

I therefore call on WHO Director General Dr. Tedros Adhanom, whom I greatly respect and admire, to remove Peter Daszak from the investigation team, announce that all hypotheses will be fully examined, including the possibility of an accidental lab leak, and renegotiate the terms of reference for the investigation to ensure that a full and unrestricted examination of the pandemic’s origins will be possible.

Note: The day after I released this statement, on February 11, 2021, WHO Director General Adhanom wisely stated in a briefing event for member states: “I want to clarify that all hypotheses remain open and require further study.” It is certainly my hope that this statement makes clear that all hypotheses, including the possibility of an accidental lab leak, be fully explored by the WHO expert committee and others.


I'm pretty sure Daszak's conflict of interest and attempts to distract from any investigation of the lab origin are well known.
 
Wikipedia says that Mr. Metzl holds a Ph.D. in Southeast Asian history from Oxford University and a J.D. from Harvard Law School. Speaking outside of one's area of expertise is de rigeur in the conspiracy theory realm.
 
This is page 50 of this thread. All of that was addressed multiple times in the thread, RC. You act like this is the first time you've heard of any of this.
I have heard of most of this before. That does not address your errors.
  1. No science in a slightly paranoid US Right To Know article
  2. Skeptic Ginger cites a Daily Mail tabloid article basically lying about Peter Daszak
  3. A "it is a fact he was removed from the UN Commission" error from Skeptic Ginger
  4. Skeptic Ginger cites a slightly idiotic "The World University Rankings" web page.
  5. Skeptic Ginger cites a irrelevant, paranoid article.
Daszak had no conflict of interest and is free to express an opinion in that open letter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom