Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

In what way? We can't naturally see into the more interesting wavelengths but we can measure and simulate. Dolphins have evolved an echolocation system that works just fine. I personally have no problem with the concept that if we had always had a denser, less translucent atmosphere that we'd have evolved matching sense organs.

Before making discoveries with instruments that look at different wavelengths, we did (and of course still do), make discoveries in the visible spectrum.

So life as we know it, would have issues.

Other life, sure, could have evolved differently.
 
Originally Posted by eri :
I have to ask, since you have no respect for anyone on the boards and consider us all to be morons, why ARE you still here?

As hammegk says, hope springs eternal.

I try to show people on here the errors in their thinking processes, not because it is easy, but because it is hard.
 
As hammegk says, hope springs eternal.

I try to show people on here the errors in their thinking processes, not because it is easy, but because it is hard.

Oddly enough, I think that's why most of the rest of us are here too.
 
Originally Posted by Interesting Ian :
I try to show people on here the errors in their thinking processes, not because it is easy, but because it is hard.

PixyMisa
Well, any time you're ready...

Hard I said, not impossible as is the case with you.
 
Hmm. Haven't we done this before? If you assert you are 100% materialist, there likely few errors if any in your thinking processes based on that assumption.

The choice of monism is yours to make (well, given you have faith in free-will...;)). :)
 
Hmm. Haven't we done this before? If you assert you are 100% materialist, there likely few errors if any in your thinking processes based on that assumption.
Agreed. I do argue that it is easier to construct a practically useful view of the world under materialism than under idealism, and that is why I choose to assume materialism. That does not mean that materialism is right or idealism is wrong, just that I see a pragmatic reason for the choice.

Ian, however, thinks he can refute materialism.
 
I just wanted to state how in awe I am of this poster - who has single handedly brought up points that evolutionary biologists are just stumped over, and have no answer for.

Finally the veil has been lifted and we can start to learn from ID! So
VonNeuman, let's get started. Please name one prediction the Theory of ID makes and show me an experiment or math that tests it? What's first?
Starrman, you misspelled my name.

First off, if you believe RM/NS is a natural mechanism that is responsible for the wide diversity of life then you attribute a creative power to RM/NS that surpasses human intelligence. I submit that you believe RM/NS is intelligent if it is more intelligent than we are. I also submit that the word 'design', while it imparts connotation of purpose, is still a term biologists often use while describing the subject of function and process. I understand that the paradigm of evolution excludes purpose, but submit that it has all appearances of 'design'. If not, then why do all the texts use the word so much. It is a very good word for expressing and conveying theory on biological systems. Therefore, if RM/NS is 'intelligent' and it performs 'design', then RM/NS is theoretically an agent that creates via intelligent design.

I think this blind spot, or cognitive dissonance that proponents of evolution have, where excluding teleology but nevertheless not able to describe biological theory without using teleological terms such as 'design', indicates that proponents of evolution believe in ID also. The brand of ID is naturalistic.

I think that true IDers are just saying there is purpose in the design and RM/NS are insufficient to be the source. At least I can speak for myself and that's all I'm saying.

Now you ask for a prediction? That's easy. However if you have the cognitive dissonance you are too 'inside the box' to see it, perhaps. If I design many things, some very similar things, some less similar, you may find the following characteristics manifest. Lets use a computer program as an example of what I design:
1. there is evident modularity
2. always write with the same codes (same language)
3. sometimes transcribe whole chunks of code from one application to another.
4. sometimes cut and paste and snip and patch.
5. sometimes have dead wood and unreachable code.
6. you can see my signature or style in my work.
7. I do not always do things the best or most efficient way
8. I reuse the some of the same code over and over
9. Where I store my code, I have some redundancy check to help catch and repair data errors.
10 My code gets translated by another mechanism that also runs by executing code a designer wrote
11. sometimes my code gets published or shared with other designers who use my code in their designs
12. Some of my code is so clever that it is hard for others to easily understand how it works
13. Many times when I write a new program, I don't start from scratch, I start with a program I wrote before and add and delete.
14. My designs are not perfect

Most if not all of these things that I would predict you could observe in looking at human designed programs, you do in fact observe in biotic code. darwinists think it is evidence of common descent, but common design predicts these things as well. There are too many examples of non-linear (discontinuities and restarts) in the fossil record to make it good evidence for evolution. Especially the sudden appearances are more of what you would expect from design. How do sudden appearances fit with the prediction of evolution? It doesn't. Evolution predicts gradual developments - they are not found. Ergo: design fits the evidence better than evolution does.

Evolutionary biologists ARE stumped, and history occasionally shows they admit it. You didn't know that?
 
f) How do you mathematically determine whether `biological information' has increased or decreased between two generations. What is the measure?
You don't know and I don't know. I don't think we can make progress there.

We could try this... weren't there some new organs, new micro-organeles, protein machines, 'invented' by evolution sometime in the past 500MY? Can we say there was an increase of information in the collective genomes on earth?

If so, then there were some smaller steps of increase of information along the way? Just because we cannot determine information increase across generations, we can deduce some rate of change.
___
Switching the subject. Could it be stated that you think the genesis of new information lies in the random alteration of the code sequence, where nonsense is culled out and only 'good' information survives? If not, where lies the origin of new information, in your thinking?
 
You don't know and I don't know. I don't think we can make progress there.

We could try this... weren't there some new organs, new micro-organeles, protein machines, 'invented' by evolution sometime in the past 500MY? Can we say there was an increase of information in the collective genomes on earth?

If so, then there were some smaller steps of increase of information along the way? Just because we cannot determine information increase across generations, we can deduce some rate of change.

New genes get produced all the time through gene duplication - the duplicate then mutates over time and develops a function that may be related to or quite different from the original gene. As an example, there is good evidence that the blood clotting cascade is produced by such duplications.

I don't believe that the concept of information is meaningful when studying the DNA of biological organisms, but I'll talk in those terms anyway.

If the DNA can display a non-zero increase in information per generation, then what is to stop it gaining a lot of information over many generations?

Could it be stated that you think the genesis of new information lies in the random alteration of the code sequence, where nonsense is culled out and only 'good' information survives? If not, where lies the origin of new information, in your thinking?

Whether something is `Good' or `bad' information is purely a function of the environment. If you have a mutation that causes your fur to become lighter, for example, this would be good in the arctic but bad in many other places ;)

Also, it is important to remember that the vast majority of mutations are neutral because altering a few amino acids in a protein is unlikely to alter its shape much, if at all. It is this redundancy that allows evolution to happen - if each mutation always caused a huge change in function then it would be difficult for evolution to occur.

Yes, though, you are broadly correct - the variation produced by mutation/recombination etc. is acted on in a probabilistic fashion such that those more suited to the environment have an increased chance of reproduction. The gene pool will then move further towards the mode of fitness distribution, like a genetic algorithm. In a sense, the population as a whole `learns' from the environment, and it is this which corresponds to your information increase.

Toy example:

Consider two buttons, one of which gets you punched in the face and the other which gets you a cookie. You'd learn pretty quickly was the better button - I think most people would agree that you had gained some information through this process? Now imagine a very simple population with no ability to learn but that just pushes a button depending on something within their genome. Given heritable variation and the need to eat cookies to reproduce, in a very small number of generations the population would almost exclusively press the correct button. Surely this must also be a gain in information?

In this example your intelligence and the natural selection acting on the population have provided the exact same result.

____________________________________

I've yet to hear a critique of why the evidence for ape/human common ancestry isn't compelling, or are you just bouncing around between subjects until you find one that no one understands adequately? ;) Remember, any theory that would replace evolution would also need to explain the evidence I described at least as well as the Theory of Evolution.
 
Starrman, you misspelled my name.

First off, if you believe RM/NS is a natural mechanism that is responsible for the wide diversity of life then you attribute a creative power to RM/NS that surpasses human intelligence. I submit that you believe RM/NS is intelligent if it is more intelligent than we are. I also submit that the word 'design', while it imparts connotation of purpose, is still a term biologists often use while describing the subject of function and process. I understand that the paradigm of evolution excludes purpose, but submit that it has all appearances of 'design'. If not, then why do all the texts use the word so much. It is a very good word for expressing and conveying theory on biological systems. Therefore, if RM/NS is 'intelligent' and it performs 'design', then RM/NS is theoretically an agent that creates via intelligent design.

I think this blind spot, or cognitive dissonance that proponents of evolution have, where excluding teleology but nevertheless not able to describe biological theory without using teleological terms such as 'design', indicates that proponents of evolution believe in ID also. The brand of ID is naturalistic.

I think that true IDers are just saying there is purpose in the design and RM/NS are insufficient to be the source. At least I can speak for myself and that's all I'm saying.

Now you ask for a prediction? If I design many things, some very similar things, some less similar, you may find the following characteristics manifest.

Most if not all of these things that I would predict you could observe in looking at human designed programs, you do in fact observe in biotic code. darwinists think it is evidence of common descent, but common design predicts these things as well. There are too many examples of non-linear (discontinuities and restarts) in the fossil record to make it good evidence for evolution. Especially the sudden appearances are more of what you would expect from design. How do sudden appearances fit with the prediction of evolution? It doesn't. Evolution predicts gradual developments - they are not found. Ergo: design fits the evidence better than evolution does.

Evolutionary biologists ARE stumped, and history occasionally shows they admit it. You didn't know that?

People have a tendency to anthropomorphise things, or hadn't you noticed? Your argument that `biologists secretly accept ID' is pure bunkum.

Tsk tsk... assuming attributes of the Designer is a big no-no in ID, or didn't you get the memo? All the Christians supporting ID will be a bit pissed if you carry on saying that God makes mistakes ;)

OK, I would be willing to accept that Evolution is an agent in some sense if, and this is an enormous if you could show that it didn't follow naturally from the laws of physics as we currently understand them.

Unfortunately, it does.

If you have a reproducing organism X that produces heritable variation, it will be naturally selected to its current environment - you can examine the problem mathematically and, hell, with common sense, and natural selection is the inevitable result.

Let's look at your common design argument - is there any piece of evidence that couldn't be retrofitted to something that vague? Of course there isn't! No piece of evidence could ever show it wrong, which makes it completely pointless.

Evolution demands a tree of descent, both in terms of fossils, when they existed, and genetic relatedness, and that is what it has. Lots of evidence could completely screw over the entire theory (pre-cambrian rabbit, anyone?) and yet it's never been observed.

Yes, there are some proper controversies in evolution, but none of them bring into question the basic fact of evolution. Hell, DNA was only discovered about 40 years ago, so what do you expect?

Why is it always the people that use the term `cognitive dissonance' that seem to suffer from it the most? :rolleyes:
 
VonNeumann - You've got a lot of nerve using that user name. You don't appear to have any of the qualities that the actual von Neumann had.
 
Evolutionary biologists ARE stumped, and history occasionally shows they admit it.
Certainly, evolutionary biologists, like all scientists, are "stumped" (as you put it) on some issues. This will always be the case. The response of proper scientists, when they find something they don't understand, or that appears to be inexplicable in terms of current theory, is to go and do some work, and find out what is actually going on. This happens all the time, and is how science makes progress.

IDers, on the other hand, look for anything that current theory (as they understand it) doesn't appear to explain, and just say "it must have been designed!"

That's not science.
 
VonNeumann said:
When it comes to trying to fill in the gaps between the fossil record, the members of the darwin-faith club (which is a religion club as you called it, not a science club)

I submit you have no idea what a religion is, then.

ARE afraid to leave the void hanging and ARE afraid to take fossil evidence at face value. You must not be aware of this. They DO just conjure farfetched ideas just to fill the gaps.

Well, we do have to fill the gaps somehow. Sometimes, "I don't know" just doesn't work when you have to formulate and test theories. But at least our speculations are based on what we know, not what we don't.

Problem: gaps in the fossil record:

Idiotic. The vast majority of animals who die never become fossils. It's already fortunate that we have SOME fossils, as it is.

1. Cambridge explosion.

I don't doubt it.

Yes chipmunk, you are exactly correct IMO. I do think the darwin-faith club behaves like a religion-club. If you are a scientist as I am, you should be insulted that they call themselves scientists. Kick them out.

I submit that you have no idea what science is, then.

VonNeumann said:
Let's assume that 100 years from now we find some weird stuff with quantum physics or something and we determine that we live in a simulation. Perhaps some of the simulator starts showing through in some quantum experiments we do. Maybe we find that this simulation we live in is, by design, incapable of calculating 'intelligence' and 'creativity'. Imagine that our universe is like the graphics card, but the CPU (where our 'selves' are) is where our self awareness and creativity calculates. The material universe (the graphics card) is what we've been studying all along and our brains are a sort of remote-terminal that joins our CPU selves with our graphics-card simulation. The creators of the simulation chuckle to think we are dumb enough to think that everything self-created in the limited graphics card and that so many of us believe the delusion that the graphics card is all there is. Some are imaginitive enough to suspect that there must be another domain and other agents (the programmers of the simulation) but are angrily dismissed by those who believe the delusion.

I'm offering this as a metaphor so that you might consider that ID is for everyone. Open your mind but think critically. Maybe the darwinists are the ones who believe in the tooth fairy.

Well, I think this is just drivel, but if evidence comes along that proves Gunderscored exists, I'll accept it. I'm not losing any sleep over that thought, however.

VonNeumann said:
Established science is a whore. You are probably too young to have figured that out yet.

Well that has to be the most insulting bit of patronizing I've seen so far, aside from Iacchus claiming to be an authority in physics.

Unless you are a paleontologist/zoologist and know the facts but are too entrenched to admit evolution is wrong, then you could not possibly have educated yourself nor studied the relevant evidence with an open mind.

I submit you have no idea what an open mind is, then.
 
First off, if you believe RM/NS is a natural mechanism that is responsible for the wide diversity of life then you attribute a creative power to RM/NS that surpasses human intelligence. I submit that you believe RM/NS is intelligent if it is more intelligent than we are. I also submit that the word 'design', while it imparts connotation of purpose, is still a term biologists often use while describing the subject of function and process. I understand that the paradigm of evolution excludes purpose, but submit that it has all appearances of 'design'. If not, then why do all the texts use the word so much. It is a very good word for expressing and conveying theory on biological systems. Therefore, if RM/NS is 'intelligent' and it performs 'design', then RM/NS is theoretically an agent that creates via intelligent design.
(emphasis mine)

I love the use of the word "therefore" here.

Remember that your logical conclusion is sound only if your premises are. But, to borrow a line I thought I only had to use for Iacchus, you are quite simply wrong. Your understanding of RM/NS is fundamentally flawed if you meaningfully ascribe "intelligence" to it. To call it a "creative power" is even a stretch, although I can accept it as a metaphor. You also conflate two uses of the word "design"--even while properly saying that scientists use it descriptively, you then stretch that into a causal version of design. The two uses are worlds apart.

I submit that your two premises--that RM/NS is "intelligent", and that descriptive and causal "design" can be interchanged, are baseless. Therefore, your conclusion is incorrect.
 
Unfortunately the correct image is of throwing a dart randomly at a white wall whose surface area is in the range of something like a googolplex times a googolplex square miles, with one tiny black spot on it, and the dart landing dead centre in this black spot.

Interesting Ian said:
This is the anthropic principle. To the skeptic the anthropic principle is all powerful. Even if the prior probability of something is 1/googolplex, this doesn't surprise them in the slightest.

I used this argument to explain to them that my birth effectivelly couldn't have happened. Not one of them could understand what I was talking about.

I'm not even sure that YOU understand what you're talking about. What are the odds that you'd be born where you were at that precise instant, etc. ? You are loading the question by assuming that other results could have occured. As far as we know, the odds for our particular universe could very well be 1/1.

Two things should be borne in mind.

a) Skeptics are incorrigibly stupid.

b) Thier minds are set in concrete.

Discussing anything with them is a waste of time.

Funny, I had the same thought about you.
 
c) Humans apes share common ancestry? I'm surprised our genome is minimally a few million codes different than some apes. It is interesting that it takes that much information to revise an ape into a human - I might have thought it would take less.

Something that you may not know, is that chimps and humans not only share the vast majority of their DNA, but also their USELESS DNA bits, which points even more to common ancestry. Otherwise, why would we share the same vestigial code ?

VonNeumann said:
DNA/RNA part of what explanation? The explanation you suggest is that thousands of bits of information appeared out of nowhere?

Nowhere ? I submit ... never mind.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom