Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

AUP:
"The Lebanese are not Hizbollah."

You think that matters to the usual suspects? (Rhetorical question of course).


According to Ynetnews, "Israel's most comprehensive, authoritative daily source for 24/7 breaking news", the Israelis have killed at least 421, of which a mere 27 were Hizbollah, while Hizboallah have killed only 41 of which 24 were Israeli soldiers.
(http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3281352,00.html)



Anyway, as for the pretty poor first post in this thread, are people really suggesting that simply because Israel isn't definitely trying to kill AS MANY CIVILIANS AS IT CAN, it isn't trying at all?
Why would they want to kill millions of Lebanese, and get their US funding cut as US public opinion falls away?
Using collective punishment was a favourite tactic of the nazis, and I think collective punishment can be definitely identified with the targeted civilians in Lebanon . Or are some people going to impress us all with brain bending mental gymnastics and deny that too?


I will agree Demon that Israel might be targeting some "civilians" in certain situations....such as when said "civilians" are driving amulances loaded with munitions...or possibly when "children" are firing AKs at Isreali troops...or when the "civilians" are directing fire onto Israeli positions.

The point of my pretty poor post was to point out the absurdity of the "Israel is committing genoicide & war crimes" voices we keep keep hearing so much of. The ultimate absurdity of course are those who keep equating Israel to the Nazis.....such as you seem to be doing.
 
I have friends & relatives in Israel who are getting their country bombed for nothing. I was sent a call-up notice to come back and fight in this war (I am a reserves Sergeant in the IDF).

Yes, I recall from elsewhere that you mentioned your status and former active duty in the IDF. Are you tempted to answer the call and go fight? Just curious.

AS
 
You said yourself that the Christian and the Sunni don't support the Hizbollah, right? Are these people not Lebanese?
 
This is where the "peace now" folks get stumped and change the subject. They are full of ideas about what Israel shouldn't do, but have no suggestions as to what they should do to permanently end the war.

No, the Lebanese were already on a path to normalising relations, standing independently, and living peacefully. The businesses that had been painstakingly built up after the civil war were starting to boom, Lebanon had become a tourist destination again. The start of the war, most Lebanese were angry at Hizbollah for stirring things up again. Time and diplomacy were working, slowly, but towards a good resolution.
 
You said yourself that the Christian and the Sunni don't support the Hizbollah, right? Are these people not Lebanese?

If you want to pretend to have a discussion, backtrack to where we have been and move forward. We seem to have a logical disconnect and this is pointless. A good example of what we read in the news.
 
Yes, I recall from elsewhere that you mentioned your status and former active duty in the IDF. Are you tempted to answer the call and go fight? Just curious.

I don't currently have a "tzav" (draft notice) -- the one I got in June for gaza was deferred at the request of my employer, while I'm in the USA. Considering the duties performed by my unit (MP's), we're not engaged in fighting. We maintain border controls at EREZ & KARNI, we hold captured palestinian prisoners, we enforce military discipline, and we even do traffic patrol for convoys of mechanized armor (as the huge oversize loads of Merkavas, APC's and D9's are transported on flatbeds over the regular roads of Israel, we escort).

Soldiering ain't glamorous. It's not something you get all excited about, or gung-ho about. It's a temporary duty, and is just one of those necessary responsibilites that Israelis shoulder -------- I guarantee that those three divisions of reservists will be perfectly satisfied to be in uniform on stand-by for 2 weeks and not see any action, and go home.

Goldwasser and Regev were on their last day of "miluim" (active reserves) doing routine patrols along a quiet border when all hell broke loose on top of their heads. Whatever is happening in Lebanon, is because of them.
(And whatever is happening in gaza is because of Gilad Shalit).

All else is secondary.
The moment the issue of our hostages is resolved, that's when things will return to quiet.
It's really very simple.


===================================
(eta --- link to website of my most recent stint in the strip)
 
Last edited:
This is where the "peace now" folks get stumped and change the subject. They are full of ideas about what Israel shouldn't do, but have no suggestions as to what they should do to permanently end the war.

sheesh...you "war now" guys..
Is someone in possesion of a plan that will permanently end war and not told me?? Policies you support have failed for how long now? Guess you should just do it twice as hard and it may just start working......someday....soon?
 
sheesh...you "war now" guys..
Is someone in possesion of a plan that will permanently end war and not told me?? Policies you support have failed for how long now? Guess you should just do it twice as hard and it may just start working......someday....soon?


Can someone explain something to me...

I often hear the argument "Israel has tried the same policy of aggression for 60 years and it is never going to work, time to try something else".

To me this makes no sense whatsoever. From my study of the conflict at a fairly basic level, I recall a number of wars, some started by Israel, others by neighbours.

One of the most confusing things seemed to be remembering which happened when, and the borders.

This notion that Israel has been stuck in a perpetual war of aggression for 60 years is complete nonsense. Given the past, if this were true Israel would rule the entire Middle East.

The region has had sporadic activity ranging from full peace to great unrest, and every now and then errupting into full blown war for a while before going back to the same variation of peace and unrest.

It's not that only aggression has worked, and it has failed. EVERYTHING has been tried. By Israel, by the UN, by other nations. NOTHING works. NOTHING. Not peace, not war, not giving land, not taking land. NOTHING has worked.

I can only think of three options that haven't been tried:

1) The international community works together to get rid of all the terrorists so the Israelis and the innocent Muslims can live together
2) The international community works together to get rid of Israel so the terrorists and the innocent Muslims can live together
3) The international community works together to carpet bomb the entire region with nuclear weapons and get rid of everyone.

Now. Which option shall we try first?

-Andrew
 
Right, so there's the UN, and they have an Israeli, a Muslim, and an Islamic Terrorist. The UN have to get all three across a river, but their boat can only carry one of the three at a time (in conjunction with the UN).

How does the UN get them all across without a war breaking out?

-Andrew
 
They let the Islamic terrorist attack the Israeli while they take the Muslim across the river. They get back in time to stop the Israeli from retaliating, and take the terrorist across the river. Then they come back across and don't understand why the Israeli doesn't want to go.
 
sheesh...you "war now" guys..
Is someone in possesion of a plan that will permanently end war and not told me?? Policies you support have failed for how long now? Guess you should just do it twice as hard and it may just start working......someday....soon?


In the circumstances of brutal antagonism of the islamic jihadists towards jews and other infidels, I find it disingenuous for you to ask for a plan that will "end war." Israel has ended war by peace treaty with 2 of its' 4 neighbors.
Lebanon could easily have ended war and Israel was/is fully prepared to do so and these two countries would have gained an incredibly useful peaceful relationship. But, instead of that outcome, you claim that Israel is at fault and we are also at fault for "supporting policies that have failed for how long now?"

That is just so much double-speak.


As for the cynical comment: 'do it twice as hard' ------

See: Qana, today. (Qana, revisited)

Israel is under ballistic missile attack from inside the village.
Civilians were told to leave. They have had plenty of time to do so.
Instead of dropping 500 tons of bombs and making the village disapppear, the IAF tries to pin-point and take out the launchers.
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/744332.html
Defense Minister Amir Peretz has ordered an investigation of the incident.
 
Civilians were told to leave. They have had plenty of time to do so.

Have they? In a situation where there's no organised evacuation, no transport, no prepared routes, no food and water stops, no police protection -- oh, and you can't use a car because then we'll shoot at you, and by the way, you better try to stay away from places that might be attacked, but we're of course not telling you what those are -- would you lock up your home and, together with your 85 year old granddad and your pregnant sister and your three year old kid and everybody else, walk down the road with only the clothes on your back and what you could carry in an easy load? Knowing that when you came back, if you get to come back -- because there are no guarantees, your home might simply be gone?

Yeah, sure. They were told to leave. But they weren't exactly given the means to do so, were they? Oh, who cares? It's not like they're anybody who matters, is it?
 
Have they? In a situation where there's no organised evacuation, no transport, no prepared routes, no food and water stops, no police protection -- oh, and you can't use a car because then we'll shoot at you, and by the way, you better try to stay away from places that might be attacked, but we're of course not telling you what those are -- would you lock up your home and, together with your 85 year old granddad and your pregnant sister and your three year old kid and everybody else, walk down the road with only the clothes on your back and what you could carry in an easy load? Knowing that when you came back, if you get to come back -- because there are no guarantees, your home might simply be gone?

Yeah, sure. They were told to leave. But they weren't exactly given the means to do so, were they? Oh, who cares? It's not like they're anybody who matters, is it?
Perhaps they should have thought that all through before starting a war w/ Israel. Will they now reject Hezbollah in light of what they have brought upon them, or will they continue to support them? The latter guarantees many more such incidents in the future, the former guarantees peace. What will they decide I wonder?
 
Perhaps they should have thought that all through before starting a war w/ Israel. Will they now reject Hezbollah in light of what they have brought upon them, or will they continue to support them? The latter guarantees many more such incidents in the future, the former guarantees peace. What will they decide I wonder?

Juding by other conflicts throughout history, the usual reaction when someone shoots at your family and friends is to get angry at the people doing the shooting, rather than at whomever they are trying to kill.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom