Medicine should be taught in high school

Wow. I was prepared to agree with your entire post.

Then you ruined it with...


If you think you have learned half the stuff doctors know then you have a very poor understanding of what doctors are required to know.

LOL. I know. I exaggerated. But I sure know one heck of a lot more than the day I got out of high school, that is for sure. I learned such great stuff later as how you can tape your wounds together (no stitches), and not go to the doctor, and use an Exacto knife like a scalpel to perform surgery successfully on yourself. :)
 
Kids need to learn the importance of preventive medicine as in eating healthy food, exercising to strengthen the body and immune system. Learning the body "mechanics" is also fundamental. Working to plug them with chemicals right from the start and condition them to seek them even when there's no need for them is rather as callous and dishonest.

From reading all the posts so far, I'd say the consensus is that school is not the place to be teaching medicine. However, I believe that enough needs to be taught that can have definite ramifications on choices made, that can lead the student onto a more healthy and safe life, and be able to avoid some common things that only took a mention to make them aware of.

Major diseases and causes and symptoms.

Exposure to the elemnts. How to avoid. What to bring with, etc.

Obesity.

Second hand smoke.

Lymes disease.

Outdoor poisons.

Maybe some chemicals that cause reactions in many people that one should be aware of. The grapefruit juice one I mentioned in a previous post was good.

What a person might do to help prevent getting a kidney stone and what not to eat if you have had one or more.

Any known benefits to drinking water over even that of juices.

How to be careful when bending over so that your protruding butt does not catpult you to your death, down the stairs or off a building (that has happened).

About washing your hands often and not coughing on people and other easy things a person can do to aid in stopping the spread of some pandemic.

In general thinking and awareness where you don't do dumb things like step on dog poop, and then untie your shoe laces that you didn't realize scraped init also, and then go tright for the bag of potato chips your whol family eats out of and reach in there and dig in. Stuff like that.

The limitations of protective gear, like helmets.

How important it is to wear eye protection in certain instances.

Realistic claims of losing hearing due to exposure to decibles.

How that if you decide to be a roofer, that even though you may not be afraid of heights, you must be aware that one trip up there might be the last trip you ever make.

To think before you remove paint and certain building materials as they may contain lead, mercury or asbestos.

Places known to be high in radon, and if you should have a new home tested where you live. (Second leading cause of lung cancer I hear once.)

If you have a well, as opposed to city water, to learn about having well tested for bacteria and chemical analysis, as a lifetime on this water source may prove to be not so good. (A system I ran in Tezxas was so high in sodium we had to tell people not to drink it.)

If you get an unknown reaction, say your lip swells up 4 times the normal size, or get hives... what possible things to be aware of that maybe you got into, and what maybe you can do. About beingtested for allergies and potential risks of beign allergic more than normal to insect bites/stings, peanut butter and how to be aware that even in small doses as a lesser ingredient in some other product could prove deadly.

What autoimmune or other diseases are likely to be hereditary and maybe how you need to be tested if parents or sibling has a certain something.

Realistic dangers or non-dangers of hanging aroudnpeople with HIV/AIDS or the Hepatitis family. How to avoid mono and meningocacol diseases.

About how to walk on ice to lessen the risk of slipping backwards and cracking your head open. And how to be aware of icicles hanging from tall buildings and overhangs.

Common farm, tractor, mower, chain saw accidents and what to be careful of.

The awareness of not only CO gas but of methane gas buidup and to not enter sewer pipes (kids do this some times).

How to brush the teeth and floss for like 2 minutes for it to really do good, and about the gums also.
 
From reading all the posts so far, I'd say the consensus is that school is not the place to be teaching medicine.

I would have no problem with it if if were taught by qualified professionals in a proper manner. However, I don't think the high schools could afford that (med school is far more expensive than high school for many reasons). It doesn't seem the community colleges can afford it either (I actually have no idea what their excuse is for it being taught the way it is, but I'm thinking they are cheaping out).
 
Iamme, all of that stuff is indeed good to teach kids. Amazingly, most educators agree. And that is indeed what is taught in a large percetange of schools around the globe.

Again, it would sound ridiculous if people here started a discussion suggesting that apple farmers would do better if they put fertilizer on their apple trees and watered them often. I'm sure we've all experienced poor teaching done by a poor education system. And I'd be the first to say science education falls short of where it should be in many systems. Yet, in the majority of cases, the curriculum itself covers all of the above quite well.

Athon
 
I would have no problem with it if if were taught by qualified professionals in a proper manner. However, I don't think the high schools could afford that (med school is far more expensive than high school for many reasons). It doesn't seem the community colleges can afford it either (I actually have no idea what their excuse is for it being taught the way it is, but I'm thinking they are cheaping out).

If 'medicine' means teaching students how to practically prescribe medications, of course it's ludicrous.

However, I get the feeling that people here are suggesting basic health awareness is what educators should be covering. And, as I've said, that's pretty much what happens.

Athon
 
If 'medicine' means teaching students how to practically prescribe medications, of course it's ludicrous.

However, I get the feeling that people here are suggesting basic health awareness is what educators should be covering. And, as I've said, that's pretty much what happens.

Athon

Unfortunately what also happens (with the educators not having the education and background) the educators also teach their own opinions too (already mentioned in my previous post).

I figure it should be taught right, or not at all. Who monitors what is actually taught to students? Those girls came out of high school hating conventional medicine, and the current secondary education is only contributing to that hatred. All of the anticonventional junk you can find on the internet (what my teachers call "research") has been brought into our classroom and into the high school classes. I kid you not. My teachers actually tell us that "big pharma is suppressing cancer cures". The high school teacher actually taught her students that herbal supplements are better for you than drugs, as all drugs are unnatural. My teacher actually told us to not even take Buckley's (it has drugs in it-acetominephine) and told us to take zinc lozenges instead. She only shares horror stories about doctors, and what the fda apparently allows to go on.

I guess it is the same cunundrum as when I was taught science in High school. I had a creationut teacher. Now the "medical"/basic health awareness is anti-conventional. Our high school system is scary, there are no checks on what is being taught, or what is being taught is somehow acceptable to our current provincial standards (horrifying thought).

So, no, my classmates and I are not taught any "medicine", but as far as what is taught along those lines in our high schools and this secondary institution at beginner level courses is not helping things at all. These teachers have no idea what they are talking about (not having the educational background that MDs get) but they are allowed to teach complete crap to the classes.

So, I figure they only way to clean up this mess is to get people who know that there is no reason aspartame could cause MS (yep that is something my teacher told the class) to teach facts instead. I feel only qualified people from the field would not be apt to believe stupid things and teach it to the classes.

Here are some examples of what my teacher has given to the class as extracurricular research, what she and my other teacher have presented as factual:
http://members.warpnet.net/spierce/Aspartame/ -aspartame is horribly poisonous

http://foodasmedicine.blogspot.com/2007/01/plastic-health-dioxin-and-cancer.html -freezing water in plastic will cause cancer

http://www.homeopathy-soh.org/about-homeopathy/what-is-homeopathy/ -homeopathy is awesome

(we also went to Deepak Chopra's site and did his questionnaire)

http://www.tidesoflife.com/er4ybt.htm -eat right for you blood type.

http://mb.rxlist.com/rxboard/vicodin_arc3.pl?noframes;read=41661 -swiffer products kill

None of this stuff is in our curriculum, but we are taught it all, and more. We had an altie loving lady come to our class and present to us even (she impressed my teacher with all her internet research on alternatives, but she told us she wasn't able to complete the ND degree). Two seconds on the internet debunks most of this junk, but we get it taught as factual.

Do you think a real healthcare professional with any actual knowledge of real medicine and even of beginner organic chemistry (taught to pre-med students) would share this stuff as factual? I don't think so. Even pharmacists get 7 years of education, and my store's pharmacist debunked the aspartame junk in 2 minutes flat. Even a pharmacist would do better teaching these students. Someone, anyone with some degree of background that could tell this crap from facts would be better qualified to teach these classes than the current crop of rotters.

That is my only request, that someone teaching high school students and other secondary school students getting any kind of health related teaching get taught by someone qualified enough to know fact from fiction (and not tell students to take supplements over standardized meds, when meds tested & regulated for safety & efficacy but supplements are not).
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately what also happens (with the educators not having the education and background) the educators also teach their own opinions too (already mentioned in my previous post)..*snip*

Indeed. However, this has to do more with teacher training and less to do with the curriculum, as such. It also includes greater focus in schools on skill based learning rather than pure content, where students see content is malleable and open to evaluation in the face of learning to apply critical literacy skills. This is a trend which dominates the pedagogy of most systems, but falls apart in the hands of the educator behind the closed doors of the classroom.

How do we address this? Welcome to my job :D. Any ideas will be gratefully read and discussed. Like any evolution, it's gradual but progressing.

Athon
 
:( Can you imagine what I'm going through right now, seriously. My teacher is even diffusing fraccin oils, and they caused me to break out BAD. She did at least agree to stop diffusing them for now. I am clearing up again after a week of no *#$&#(&$ oil diffusion.

Not only that, but with the other students coming out of the high school program already prepped for the crap, I'm on my own. I bite my tongue all day long. I paid 12 grand for this. The curriculum is great, but the teachers have their own ideas.

What would you do? My tongue is and jaw is paying the price. I only have 6 weeks left though.

How long should we wait for things to change so most of the population isn't actually taught such horrendous things in the classroom as impressionable students?

And we wonder why people are so misinformed?
 
Last edited:
... learned such great stuff later as how you can tape your wounds together (no stitches), and not go to the doctor, and use an Exacto knife like a scalpel to perform surgery successfully on yourself. :)

In a crisis, super-glue makes a great instant suture. WARNING! Bonds skin instantly!

....I believe that enough needs to be taught that can have definite ramifications on choices made, that can lead the student onto a more healthy and safe life, and be able to avoid some common things that only took a mention to make them aware of.

....

Great post. Thanks.

How long should we wait for things to change so most of the population isn't actually taught such horrendous things in the classroom as impressionable students?

And we wonder why people are so misinformed?

Good question. It is exceedingly hard to change school curriculum's. I'm thinking the Internet would be a good place to offer basic medicine/health education, making it open and accessible to most everyone, and cheap.
 
Good question. It is exceedingly hard to change school curriculum's. I'm thinking the Internet would be a good place to offer basic medicine/health education, making it open and accessible to most everyone, and cheap.

There is nothing at all wrong with the curriculum. The curriculum is perfect, awesome, wonderful. It is the misinformed teachers that use things like the INTERNET/email-chaincrap for this awful extracurricular horror that we are seeing in the classroom.
 
Originally Posted by Iamme
... learned such great stuff later as how you can tape your wounds together (no stitches), and not go to the doctor, and use an Exacto knife like a scalpel to perform surgery successfully on yourself. :)

In a crisis, super-glue makes a great instant suture. WARNING! Bonds skin instantly!

:eye-poppi :boggled:

*tries to rub horror off eyes*

Seriously guys, please stop.
 
Don't get too freaked out. There's an actual medical product out there that is very similar to super glue, I think they call it 'liquid suture". My wife was an ER nurse for the longest time, she tells me it is just slightly less adhesive than the glue you buy at the store, but it is otherwise more or less the same thing.
 
(previous post slipped in)

I'm not kidding about the super glue. It really does bond skin instantly, so if you ever use it as an emergency suture, be very careful. Word is, super glue like substances are being developed for surgery etc to replace stitches. Because of some cool properties of using adhesives rather than needle and thread.

How cool is that?
 
Ever imagine that medical "super glue" is quite different than stuff you'd buy to stick things like plastic together?
 
Last edited:
That was sort of cool. I didn't edit my post, even after I saw the one that slipped in. Liquid suture. Cool name.

Many years ago a buddy of mine who is an EMT told me they carried superglue on the truck, just in case. I think it was a Doctor who first used superglue to save himself after an accident.

Desperation, is the father of invention.
 
Ever imagine that medical "super glue" is quite different than stuff you'd buy to stick things like wood together?
You wouldn't use super glue for wood...

And, no, not really that much different, as I understand it. And, in any situation that I would use glue instead of going to the hospital, the assumption is that the hospital isn't an immediately practical option. For instance, I've carried glue when in the woods for that purpose, as a temporary emergency fix.
 
Damn, another slippage. Super Glue was invented by some guys at NASA. The original version, (which is still used), is a lot stronger than what you can buy. And there is nothing that can dissolve it after it sets. It was, and is, for attaching metal to metal, without a weld.

The commercial superglue isn't really that strong. I'm sure the medical versions are even more forgiving.
 
You wouldn't use super glue for wood...

And, no, not really that much different, as I understand it. And, in any situation that I would use glue instead of going to the hospital, the assumption is that the hospital isn't an immediately practical option. For instance, I've carried glue when in the woods for that purpose, as a temporary emergency fix.

Can you demonstrate the differences/similarities of superglue used in hospitals compared to the stinky stuff on store shelves?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom