Israel to attack Iran to draw in USA?

No he did not.



Compared to bombing (or attempting to bomb) Syria?



Compared with arming Fatah?



The threat of a nuclear bomb might have ended the war with Iran in Iraq's favour at a time when Iraq was pro-American. You know, back when Rumsfeld was shaking Saddam's hand and giving the nod to attacks with chemical weapons.



You're paranoid.



Like I said, it sounds paranoid.
Use of nukes (accept possibly by America) would be suicide.



All the talk of war against Iran slows down social reform. It gives the Iranian government an external enemy. That is one reason why Iranian university students (most of them women) say that "Our struggle is twofold, against internal oppression and external foreign threats."

The other, more vital reason, is they do not want to be "liberated" like Iraq was "liberated". Who would? They can gain their freedoms in better ways.
I don't even know where to start with this one. It's all wrong, top to bottom, twisted to fit your view and out of context all together.
I don't think I have the time to clean up your mess here.
 
Seeing as it was you who made the assertion, instead of bothering a Muslim I'll ask you.

How is Islam not a religion?

Ask a Muslim. You may learn something.

You seem to think I am some kind of Islamaphobe. Far, far from it. I simply wish for you to understand something more than your limited knowledge already.
 
Ask a Muslim. You may learn something.

You seem to think I am some kind of Islamaphobe. Far, far from it. I simply wish for you to understand something more than your limited knowledge already.

I thought so.
You can't substantiate your claims.
 
I thought so.
You can't substantiate your claims.

I can, but I'm going to give you the chance not to act like such a dim witted chap in the future and find things out for yourself.

Then, you will find my claims backed up.
 
An inconsequential preacher in the US says that the US should assasinate Hugo Chavez, and people go ballistic and denounce it for all it's worth. The President of Iran declares that Israel should be wiped off the face of the earth while pursuing a nuclear program and people scramble to make excuses for him and criticize Israel for contemplating action, go figure. :rolleyes:
 
I can, but I'm going to give you the chance not to act like such a dim witted chap in the future and find things out for yourself.

Then, you will find my claims backed up.
Like this? http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Front_Page/FH10Aa01.html
Ali Sina of www.faithfreedom.org. Sina writes: "Islam is not a religion. Considering Islam a religion is a foolish mistake that could cost millions of lives. Islam is a political movement set to conquer the world.

The author by the way disagrees with your assertion that Islam is not a religion.
 
An inconsequential preacher in the US says that the US should assasinate Hugo Chavez, and people go ballistic and denounce it for all it's worth. The President of Iran declares that Israel should be wiped off the face of the earth while pursuing a nuclear program and people scramble to make excuses for him and criticize Israel for contemplating action, go figure. :rolleyes:

The president of Iran didn't say that... but even if he did, your example is meaningless and dishonest.
 
JoeEllison said:
Originally Posted by WildCat
An inconsequential preacher in the US says that the US should assasinate Hugo Chavez, and people go ballistic and denounce it for all it's worth. The President of Iran declares that Israel should be wiped off the face of the earth while pursuing a nuclear program and people scramble to make excuses for him and criticize Israel for contemplating action, go figure. :rolleyes:

JoeEllison said:
The president of Iran didn't say that...
wrong!

Quote:
Ahmadinejad Says Britain, Israel, US To 'Vanish Like The Pharaohs'

from http://www.hyscience.com/archives/20...inejad_say.php


Quote:
Ahmadinejad: Destroy Israel, End Crisis

from here: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn...080300629.html


Quote:
Ahmadinejad: Israel acting like Hitler

from here: http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satelli...=1150886014306


Quote:
Israel and the United States will soon be destroyed, Iran's President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said Tuesday during a meeting with Syria's foreign minister

from here: http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7...356154,00.html


JoeEllison said:
but even if he did, your example is meaningless and dishonest.
I'll help you with that: but even if he did (and he did and does and will continue to) you will still support Iran. You are like the woo believers of this forum. Nothing will ever change their (and your) mind no matter how much counter evidence they (you) are confronted with.
go figure:rolleyes:.
 
Last edited:
I can, but I'm going to give you the chance not to act like such a dim witted chap in the future and find things out for yourself.

Then, you will find my claims backed up.

So you either can't be bothered to, or you realise you're wrong.

Here's an equally crazy claim. I'm the second coming of Jesus Christ.
No, I'm not going to substantiate that. Instead I'm going to give you the opportunity to "find things out for yourself".
That's how you're operating here.
 
So you either can't be bothered to, or you realise you're wrong.

Here's an equally crazy claim. I'm the second coming of Jesus Christ.
No, I'm not going to substantiate that. Instead I'm going to give you the opportunity to "find things out for yourself".
That's how you're operating here.

It is not so much, 'I cant be bothered' but because it is a more complex discussion than one can have between two men who are not speaking to an educated Muslim.

The activity I suggest may also feed you with some fresh air. Trolling the forums night in, night out cannot be healthy.
 
I'll help you with that: but even if he did (and he did and does and will continue to) you will still support Iran. You are like the woo believers of this forum. Nothing will ever change their (and your) mind no matter how much counter evidence they (you) are confronted with.
go figure:rolleyes:.
I asked you to stop lying about my position. Why can't you do that? I don't "support Iran".

There's plenty of reason to object to Iran's government: piss-poor human rights, links to extremists, etc. But, there's no reason to demonize them in order to object to them.

Your need to create a fantasy world of hatred to support your position is the only thing "woo" here.
 
It is not so much, 'I cant be bothered' but because it is a more complex discussion than one can have between two men who are not speaking to an educated Muslim.

So you don't have access to an "educated Muslim", but you still go ahead and conclude that Islam is not a religion. Well done on that.
I don't have access to an educated astronomer or geographer.. so I guess I can conclude that the Earth is flat.

The activity I suggest may also feed you with some fresh air. Trolling the forums night in, night out cannot be healthy.

You could accuse most people here of that, including yourself. How silly.
 
JoeEllison said:
I asked you to stop lying about my position. Why can't you do that? I don't "support Iran".

There's plenty of reason to object to Iran's government: piss-poor human rights, links to extremists, etc. But, there's no reason to demonize them in order to object to them.

Your need to create a fantasy world of hatred to support your position is the only thing "woo" here.
I don't make up reality for Iran and I don't need to demonize it. Its beliefs, actions and support speak for itself.
 
I asked you to stop lying about my position. Why can't you do that? I don't "support Iran".

There's plenty of reason to object to Iran's government: piss-poor human rights, links to extremists, etc. But, there's no reason to demonize them in order to object to them.

Your need to create a fantasy world of hatred to support your position is the only thing "woo" here.


Are you aware that the Iranian government was displaying banners reading "Death to America!" and "Death to Israel!" at the big military parade they held the other day?

They most definitively are trying to start a war of sorts against Israel, the US, and the West by trying to drive everyone in the region against us (as well as sponsoring terrorism.) Iran needs to tone down the rhetoric if it's going to be possible to have rational negotiations with them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom