Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

Not on Rustum Roy's stuff, but I put together some brief comments on Martin Chaplin's paper in the same issue of Homeopathy. Might submit them for publication. Any comments welcome:

Martin F. Chaplin presents an interesting overview on the structure of water1. Disappointingly, though, it seems to contain no useful evidence of a ‘water memory’ effect that would be relevant to the efficacy or otherwise of homeopathic treatments. As is well known, the chance of a 12c dilution (a dilution factor of 1x1024) containing a single molecule of the ‘mother tincture’ used to prepare the remedy is on the order of 1 in 2 billion. So homeopaths require that water (or water/ethanol mixtures) somehow structurally ‘remember’ the mother tincture, and it is this structure that is responsible for any effect of homeopathic preparations. But Chaplin1 appears to be talking about an entirely different effect when he states that “If there is evidence that the history of a sample of water affects its properties, then the ‘memory of water’ concept is proven without the need for a rationale for its action” (p. 146). This apparently broad interpretation explains some of the examples given as “Evidence for the memory of water”, which otherwise appear to have little to do with homeopathic remedies, where the mother tincture must continue to influence water structure even when absent.

For example, Chaplin1 (p. 146) states that “human taste is quite capable of telling the difference between two glasses of water, processed in different ways (eg one fresh and one undrunk for several days)”. There is nothing mysterious about this. It is a result of impurities in the atmosphere (atmospheric gases, particulates, dead skin cells, etc.) becoming dissolved or suspended in the water. This appears to have nothing to do with how a mother tincture diluted out of existence has any effect on water structure. In the homeopathic context, what would be really interesting is if it were possible to taste the difference, say, between two 30c dilutions made from different mother tinctures prepared under identical conditions. Chaplin also refers to the Vybíral and Voráček paper in the special issue of Homeopathy2, stating that the authors “have shown that water changes its properties with time and its previous history”1 (p. 146). There is no doubt that this is an interesting paper, but the authors specifically conclude that their results are a consequence of ions dissolved in the water, as the effect they observe is not present when deionised water is used. Again, it is unclear how this is relevant to cases where mother tinctures are diluted out of existence. What Chaplin seems to be talking about in his paper is how impurities might affect water structure, as illustrated when he states “The water used for dilution is not pure relative to the putative concentration of the ‘active’ ingredient, with even the purest water considered grossly contaminated compared with the theoretical homeopathic dilution levels. This contamination may well have a major influence, and itself be influenced by the structuring in the water it encounters”1 (p. 148). Since the concentration of the mother tincture will always be dwarfed by the concentration of impurities, it is difficult to see why the mother tincture should have an effect more important than the impurities on the water structure. Homeopathic remedies are not ‘just water’: they will contain significant amounts of impurities. But how this would make them different from any sample of water is not clear.

I am in agreement with Chaplin when he states that “simply proving that water does have a memory does not prove that homeopathic medicines work”. The best evidence as to whether homeopathic medicines work or not is to be found in randomised placebo-controlled trials of the medicines. A recent meta-analysis3 has demonstrated that the best-conducted trials show no effect for homeopathic remedies beyond placebo. The structure of water is certainly a fascinating subject, but, in terms of an explanation for homeopathy, it is not relevant as all the best evidence shows that there is nothing to explain.

1. Chaplin, M.F. The memory of water: an overview. Homeopathy 2007; 96: 143-150

2. Vybíral, B. and Voráček, P. Long term structural effects in water: autothixotropy of water and its hysteresis. Homeopathy 2007; 96: 183–188.

3. Shang, A., Huwiler-Müntener, K., Nartey, L., Jüni, P., Dörig, S., Sterne, J.A.C., Pewsner, D., Egger, M. Are the clinical effects of homoeopathy placebo effects? Comparitive study of placebo-controlled trials of homoeopathy and allopathy. Lancet 2005; 366: 726-732.
 
I would tend to lay off the reference to Shang. It's a red rag to a bull, with homoeopaths. The entire thrust of that issue seems to be, the hell with whether or not there is any therapeutic effect, let's just look at whether the remedies could have any odd properties. I'd frame any criticism within those parameters.

The thing I've never been able to get any of them to take on board is, if there really was a genuine effect there, who would be most interested? Medical types would be quite interested, sure, but that's nothing to the attention they'd get from physicists and chemists. Basic sciences would be falling over themselves to be the first to characterise the phenomenon and get the Nobel Prize.

Instead, all we have is this small handful of kooks and weirdos, who can't produce work good enough to get published in any non-woo journal. Conclusions?

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe:

You're right, of course. I'm in two minds as to whether to include the Shang reference myself. The main reason why I think it would be worth including is that the work is published in Homeopathy, so if it's entirely irrelevant to homeopathy, what's it doing there? The point is that water is pretty cool stuff, but if you want to use it to explain homeopathy, there isn't actually anything to explain. You're howling at the moon. I appreciate that Shang et al. hasn't made the homeopaths admit defeat yet, so my bringing it up is unlikely to make much difference.

Conclusions?

Indeed...
 
Bringing up Rustum Roy, he's been in the news again for salt water fuels

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20070911/salt_water_070911/20070911/

Has this been discussed elsewhere? And do his findings have any merit to them WRT salt water? (I now have a very biased impression of his work after reading through these forums)

ETA : *I know this doesn't have to do with homeopathy, but it does seem to be another bomb that RR has dropped on us lately...


I have no ideaTM.

I think you should start another thread on this, it's quite intriguing.

Rolfe.
 
Bringing up Rustum Roy, he's been in the news again for salt water fuels

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20070911/salt_water_070911/20070911/

Has this been discussed elsewhere? And do his findings have any merit to them WRT salt water? (I now have a very biased impression of his work after reading through these forums)

ETA : *I know this doesn't have to do with homeopathy, but it does seem to be another bomb that RR has dropped on us lately...
This is quite beyond the pale. It is one thing to be incompetent at research in an area that is new to him; but he has no excuse not to know the thermodynamics.

RR has always been a loose cannon. Tenty-five years ago, when complaints about cuts in Federal research funding were rising, he called us "welfare queens in white coats." Of course, the money he got was not "welfare." [Note, I think welfare is called "the dole" in the UK. Also, Mythical "welfare queens" were women who had lots of kids in order to get more welfare to support their "lavish lifestyles."]
 
Folks, time for an update on the Rao et al. paper.

In the latest edition of Homeopathy, Rao et al. publish an erratum.

I reproduce it in full, here, and for added excitement, behind a spoiler tag:


ERRATUM

Erratum to: Rao ML, Roy R, Bell IR, Hoover R. The defining role of structure (including epitaxy) in the plausibility of homeopathy.
Homeopathy 96 (2007):175–182

We regret that incorrect details were given for Reference 22 of the above paper. The correct reference details are as follows:

22. Rao ML, Roy R, Bell I. Characterization of the structure of ultra dilute sols with remarkable biological properties. Mater Lett. (in press).


:rolleyes:
 
Have you had any reply to the letter y'all sent to the editors of Homeopathy? If not, have you considered trying to take it to a different audience? It was too good to go to waste.

Linda
 
Folks, time for an update on the Rao et al. paper.

In the latest edition of Homeopathy, Rao et al. publish an erratum.

I reproduce it in full, here, and for added excitement, behind a spoiler tag:


ERRATUM

Erratum to: Rao ML, Roy R, Bell IR, Hoover R. The defining role of structure (including epitaxy) in the plausibility of homeopathy.
Homeopathy 96 (2007):175–182

We regret that incorrect details were given for Reference 22 of the above paper. The correct reference details are as follows:

22. Rao ML, Roy R, Bell I. Characterization of the structure of ultra dilute sols with remarkable biological properties. Mater Lett. (in press).


:rolleyes:


If only that was the only error....

I thought maybe they'd at least realised about the error in the figure that we pointed out, if nothing else.

I've spread the letter as far over the Net as I reasonably can. Wilsontown submitted it electronically as a letter to the editor, to complement my reliance on postage stamps.

What else could we try?

Rolfe.
 
I've spread the letter as far over the Net as I reasonably can. Wilsontown submitted it electronically as a letter to the editor, to complement my reliance on postage stamps.

Ah, I see. I thought you had held off on spreading it around until you heard from them (don't know why I thought that).

What else could we try?

Rolfe.

Did you send it to Randi?

Linda
 
See if it's wanted over at BadScience, Improbable Science (David Colquhoun), Swift, Respectful Insolence, etc. etc...?
 
Folks:

According to the fancy Elsevier electronic submissions website, the status of the letter is "Decision in Process". I'll keep you all posted as to what actually happens to it.

It is a journal submission (even if to a pseudojournal), and these always take a long time to process, to be fair.
 
This very morning I was told that the letter has been accepted for publication in Homeopathy. It won't actually appear until the January issue, but they have actually accepted it.

Cool, eh? Wonder what the response of the authors will be?
 
This very morning I was told that the letter has been accepted for publication in Homeopathy. It won't actually appear until the January issue, but they have actually accepted it.

Cool, eh? Wonder what the response of the authors will be?

:clap: Good work.
 
In our letter (Post #205, this thread) we mention the possible presence of acetone in the "pure ethanol" spectrum. The reason for that guess comes from the absorbance peak at 324 nm, and the fact that acetone-denatured alcohol is a common solvent. It is called Specially Denatured Alcohol 23A. You can see some literature on it by googling "sda 23a". Although I have not found a UV-Vis spectrum for SDA 23A, this liquid does not appear even to be pure SDA because there is still too much absorption on either side of the 324nm peak.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom