mhaze
Banned
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2007
- Messages
- 15,718
Ice cover is the area covered by ice. The thing that jumps out in this article is the unsubstantiated claim that ice cover equtes to ice thickness. IDenying climate change based on ice thickness measurements is therefore a classic strawman argument.
The article is as CD says, probably too old to be relevant to the situation today. It's importance if any may be in that it actually tries to establish the thickness. If this is related to AGW/anti-AGW it is very, very tangential and I don't see it as worth discussing.
The general issue of Arctic sea ice is believed to be important:
The February 2007 report from the U.N.-sponsored Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), warned that without drastic changes in greenhouse gas emissions, Arctic sea ice will "almost entirely" disappear by the end of the century.
But this speculation by the IPCC is subverted into assertions in the media and in scientific journals, although more so in the media, that GHG/AGW is causing the current melting of Arctic ice. Properly stated, that would mean that the man made GHG effects were swamping the natural variability and cycles.
Leaving aside the issue of whether ice is at a historical minimum for 300 years (probably not) or 30 years (probably so, ignore thickness ramifications) is there any actual support, outside of computer models, for this argument that AGW has caused the current Arctic ice melt?

