For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

Ice cover is the area covered by ice. The thing that jumps out in this article is the unsubstantiated claim that ice cover equtes to ice thickness. IDenying climate change based on ice thickness measurements is therefore a classic strawman argument.

The article is as CD says, probably too old to be relevant to the situation today. It's importance if any may be in that it actually tries to establish the thickness. If this is related to AGW/anti-AGW it is very, very tangential and I don't see it as worth discussing.

The general issue of Arctic sea ice is believed to be important:
The February 2007 report from the U.N.-sponsored Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), warned that without drastic changes in greenhouse gas emissions, Arctic sea ice will "almost entirely" disappear by the end of the century.
​
But this speculation by the IPCC is subverted into assertions in the media and in scientific journals, although more so in the media, that GHG/AGW is causing the current melting of Arctic ice. Properly stated, that would mean that the man made GHG effects were swamping the natural variability and cycles.

Leaving aside the issue of whether ice is at a historical minimum for 300 years (probably not) or 30 years (probably so, ignore thickness ramifications) is there any actual support, outside of computer models, for this argument that AGW has caused the current Arctic ice melt?
 
Okay, I understand your point of view. Being realistic, any data that we have from the past will be inferential in nature. It will be from ships logs and how those correlate with AMO, PDO and the 70 year climate cycle. So are not going to have any sense of "certainty" about this subject.

However, we can establish that these climate cycles do operate in the Arctic, and that there were periods when for physical reasons the ice went to similar minima. I posted one article on that, there are others. I am not aware of any that support the claim that current melt is unprecedented historically.

So the "extravagant claim" that I think would need to prove itself up here was that current Arctic ice melting is unprecedented in several hundred years of records.

Current melt is at a minima (or was in late August - early Sept) for 30 years of satellite records.

Don't put too much store in old ships logs that relate to the Northwest Passage. There was a lot of commercial incentive to open that route, so it attracted many conmen with lies to peddle, as Captain Cook found out to his peril when he tried to navigate it. Even in the 18th century, he realised that most of the maps or records were worthless or simple fraudulent.
 
Don't put too much store in old ships logs that relate to the Northwest Passage. There was a lot of commercial incentive to open that route, so it attracted many conmen with lies to peddle, as Captain Cook found out to his peril when he tried to navigate it. Even in the 18th century, he realised that most of the maps or records were worthless or simple fraudulent.

"Farudulent" is such a harsh word. Really, was it wrong for a loyal French Canadian to make some coin from the occupying power? Their credulity begged for it, after all.
 
A certain case of entryism would be Greenpeace, as the founder was interviewed by P&T and discussed this. In particular, he noted it got bent from good causes to anti capitalist, anti corporate causes as the result of individuals.

So I can assert entryism (I might be wrong, but at least I can make a case) in the case of Greenpeace. I've cited some shreds of facts which can be looked up and verified.

Neither you or AUP has cited facts or made a case regarding the asserted stealth infiltration and Leninist entryism takeover of AASC by anti-AGW conspirators.

Greenpeace cries out for entryism; were I so inclined I'd have been on it like smoke. For that reason amongst others this may well be the first time I've ever mentioned Greenpeace, and like the Al Gore thing I'm mentioning it reactively.

I've not been keeping close tabs on this thread, so could somebody out there enlighten me as to when the AACS came into things?
 
Okay, I understand your point of view. Being realistic, any data that we have from the past will be inferential in nature. It will be from ships logs and how those correlate with AMO, PDO and the 70 year climate cycle. So are not going to have any sense of "certainty" about this subject.

Seventy years back may seem deep history to you, but sixty-five years ago relatives I've met were helping ship materiel to the White Sea. We're not talking whalers' logs here, it's not a mysterious period, and there was no sign of the massive decline in ice-extent recently observed.

If you want a source for my claim

"While analysis showed that interannual variability remained almost constant throughout this period, evidence was found of oscillations in ice cover with periods of about 60 to 80 years and 20 to 30 years, superimposed on a continuous negative trend."

(my emphasis)

And that from a 2006 paper, before summer 2007 assaulted the previous (2005) record. And I mean assaulted!

Only three-to-eight years left, and the year's about to turn ...
 
Don't put too much store in old ships logs that relate to the Northwest Passage. There was a lot of commercial incentive to open that route, so it attracted many conmen with lies to peddle, as Captain Cook found out to his peril when he tried to navigate it. Even in the 18th century, he realised that most of the maps or records were worthless or simple fraudulent.

Well....yeah, that is why I said...
Being realistic, any data that we have from the past will be inferential in nature. It will be from ships logs and how those correlate with AMO, PDO and the 70 year climate cycle. So are not going to have any sense of "certainty" about this subject.
​
Leaving aside the conmen (I think most ship logs would be as accurate as might have been possible, but that isn't saying a lot) there is a more basic issue here.

It is not so important to establishing a certainty that there absolutely was a lower ice minima in 1888 (picked that year randomly). Establishing that the ice was probably in the same range of minima every 70 years or so is important.
 
However, we can establish that these climate cycles do operate in the Arctic, and that there were periods when for physical reasons the ice went to similar minima.

Similar, in that they were minima in "oscillations in ice cover with periods of about 60 to 80 years and 20 to 30 years". Not similar in extent since they are detectable "superimposed on a continuous negative trend". A trend that's sustained no serious reverses recently.
 
Seventy years back may seem deep history to you, but sixty-five years ago relatives I've met were helping ship materiel to the White Sea. We're not talking whalers' logs here, it's not a mysterious period, and there was no sign of the massive decline in ice-extent recently observed.

If you want a source for my claim
Quote:
"While analysis showed that interannual variability remained almost constant throughout this period, evidence was found of oscillations in ice cover with periods of about 60 to 80 years and 20 to 30 years, superimposed on a continuous negative trend."

(my emphasis)
​
And that from a 2006 paper, before summer 2007 assaulted the previous (2005) record. And I mean assaulted!

No, I don't consider the 1930s deep history at all. Or the 1880s, either.

But what are you inferring for the phrase "superimposed on a continuous negative trend"? I'd simply say, yep, that's the planet coming out of a little ice age - we know that. You'd say what, AGW? Extending that far back with a basically linear effect? That's a big big stretch of the AGW theory isn't it?

Alternately, to assert AGW you must say, yes, there is a linear trend since the last century downward, that is natural, and yes, there is a trend overlaid on top of that , also downward, which is the 65 year cycle, and then also overlaid on top of that, there is AGW.

It really does seem like in any corner one peeks if there is some effect that can be somehow ascribed to AGW, there is no shortage of people to make the claim.
 
No, I don't consider the 1930s deep history at all. Or the 1880s, either.

But what are you inferring for the phrase "superimposed on a continuous negative trend"? I'd simply say, yep, that's the planet coming out of a little ice age - we know that. You'd say what, AGW? Extending that far back with a basically linear effect? That's a big big stretch of the AGW theory isn't it?

Alternately, to assert AGW you must say, yes, there is a linear trend since the last century downward, that is natural, and yes, there is a trend overlaid on top of that , also downward, which is the 65 year cycle, and then also overlaid on top of that, there is AGW.

It really does seem like in any corner one peeks if there is some effect that can be somehow ascribed to AGW, there is no shortage of people to make the claim.

Surely you've seen the AGW formula:
AGW causes x
x = anything.
That's the irrefutable hypothesis I referred to that went over Pipirr's head like a lead balloon.

http://www.nasa.gov/vision/earth/lookingatearth/quikscat-20071001.html
Nghiem said the rapid decline in winter perennial ice the past two years was caused by unusual winds. "Unusual atmospheric conditions set up wind patterns that compressed the sea ice, loaded it into the Transpolar Drift Stream and then sped its flow out of the Arctic," he said. When that sea ice reached lower latitudes, it rapidly melted in the warmer waters.

"The winds causing this trend in ice reduction were set up by an unusual pattern of atmospheric pressure that began at the beginning of this century," Nghiem said.
The Arctic Ocean's shift from perennial to seasonal ice is preconditioning the sea ice cover there for more efficient melting and further ice reductions each summer. The shift to seasonal ice decreases the reflectivity of Earth's surface and allows more solar energy to be absorbed in the ice-ocean system.
=================================
http://www.nasa.gov/vision/earth/lookingatearth/ipy-20071113.html
A team of NASA and university scientists has detected an ongoing reversal in Arctic Ocean circulation triggered by atmospheric circulation changes that vary on decade-long time scales. The results suggest not all the large changes seen in Arctic climate in recent years are a result of long-term trends associated with global warming.
"Our study confirms many changes seen in upper Arctic Ocean circulation in the 1990s were mostly decadal in nature, rather than trends caused by global warming," said Morison.
Let's look up Arctic temperatures going back to say, the 1930's.

Hmm, 30 year record low hurricane/cyclone activity, waning solar activity, Arctic ocean circulation reversal. What's happening?

On the countless reports by the news media on arctic ice? It appears BBC did a double take.
2007:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/6999078.stm
“The most direct shipping route from Europe to Asia is fully clear of ice for the first time since records began.”
2000:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/world/americas/newsid_918000/918448.stm
“A Canadian police patrol boat has completed a voyage through the fabled Northwest Passage without encountering any pack ice.”
Oops.

As the oceans continue their release of non-replaced heat, I'm content to watch the gullible warmers explain the coming temperature drops and the R2 correlation of CO2 to lower troposphere temp look even more ridiculous. Of course then we'll have to endure years of blaming the cooling on global warming with the next IPCC report warning of a new ice age :) But alas, Capeldodger places his chips on the failed Hadley super duper new and improved climate model which predicted record 2007 temps.

 
Last edited:
Lucifuge is being sneaky with his conclusions from that link he provided ... [words] ... THere's NO denial of GW, or AGW, there, from the leader of the study. Quite the opposite. To claim or imply otherwise is a damnable lie.

reading through the list of evidence, while i found many of lucifuge's interpretations innacurate, i certainly did not find myself lead to believe that lucifuge was interpretating this study as rejecting AGW in anyway. so far as i can recall-- i could go back and look, but i'd rather not, as the room mate is trying to download all of the porn in the world, making page loads c... r... a... w... l...-- lucifuge only suggested that this article's conclusions may suggest that current AGW models are incorrect.

...you damnable liar.

...you damnable liar.

...you damnable liar.

...you damnable liar.

in my experience, emoting the dialogue is the best way to entrench the opposition.
 
You can't even think in terms of cause and effect (CO2 causes more warming) but need to understand things in terms of feedback loops (C02 causes warming and warming causes more CO2), its like studying feedback circuits in electronics which drove me crazy. Consider the question of trees:
1)Trees will remove CO2 from the air (good)
2)Trees will increase evaporation of H2O via transpiration. H2O is a greenhouse gas and will increase global warming but it will also increase clouds increasing Earths albedo decreasing global warming
3)Trees may increase Earths albedo increasing global warming

So are trees good or bad for global warming? I sure don't know.

recent research has found that the increased atmospheric carbon sink from increased organic activity is actually offset by microbial activity that works on decaying organic material. this microbial activity releases atmospheric carbon, and the net result is a slight increase in atmospheric carbon. of course, the microbial activity observed in this study may or may not be typical...
 
reading through the list of evidence, while i found many of lucifuge's interpretations innacurate, i certainly did not find myself lead to believe that lucifuge was interpretating this study as rejecting AGW in anyway. so far as i can recall-- i could go back and look, but i'd rather not, as the room mate is trying to download all of the porn in the world, making page loads c... r... a... w... l...-- lucifuge only suggested that this article's conclusions may suggest that current AGW models are incorrect.

The models are always going to be "incorrect". It's like giving a blind man cane, it won't cure his blindness, but it helps him work out what is ahead.
 
The models are always going to be "incorrect". It's like giving a blind man cane, it won't cure his blindness, but it helps him work out what is ahead.

and i didn't claim otherwise, AUP. i was pointing out that no one had lied regarding the implications of the alleged evidence in question. i was not claiming that anyone claims or expects models to be completely accurate. attempts to model the complex systems that we find on and in the earth are always going to be inherently innacurate to some degree, as it seems utterly impossible to account for every single possible variable. but these simplistic models can be amazingly valuable in both understanding and generalized prediction.

it is this understanding that drives my interest in the evidence in question. ASSUMING accuracy of the linked news article-- an assumption that i'm not willing to make, frankly-- the research may have some serious implications regarding some rather serious AGW predictions. i certainly see some real value in this article, because IF it is as was described, it may help the accuracy of our climate models, and it may lead to newer interpretations and predictions of AGW based climate change. again, IF.

given the time, i'll try to find this on friday. that's another IF...
 
Last edited:
Surely you've seen the AGW formula:
AGW causes x
x = anything.
That's the irrefutable hypothesis I referred to that went over Pipirr's head like a lead balloon.

http://www.nasa.gov/vision/earth/lookingatearth/quikscat-20071001.html
=================================
http://www.nasa.gov/vision/earth/lookingatearth/ipy-20071113.html
Let's look up Arctic temperatures going back to say, the 1930's.

Hmm, 30 year record low hurricane/cyclone activity, waning solar activity, Arctic ocean circulation reversal. What's happening?

On the countless reports by the news media on arctic ice? It appears BBC did a double take.
2007:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/6999078.stm
2000:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/world/americas/newsid_918000/918448.stm
Oops.

As the oceans continue their release of non-replaced heat, I'm content to watch the gullible warmers explain the coming temperature drops and the R2 correlation of CO2 to lower troposphere temp look even more ridiculous. Of course then we'll have to endure years of blaming the cooling on global warming with the next IPCC report warning of a new ice age :) But alas, Capeldodger places his chips on the failed Hadley super duper new and improved climate model which predicted record 2007 temps.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_10323474e3e528a4cf.jpg

http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/images/stories/papers/reprint/chip/chip_sea_ice.pdf

An examination of actual science re. Gore's sea ice chart in the movie and book. Impossible to figure out where his historical sea ice chart came from. It certainly does not look like the ones we have been discussing...
 
Originally Posted by David Rodale
Surely you've seen the AGW formula:
AGW causes x
x = anything.

​
You're just making an idiot of yourself with arguments like that.

Maybe not.

Perhaps he sees farther by standing on the shoulders of dwarves.
 
reading through the list of evidence, while i found many of lucifuge's interpretations innacurate, i certainly did not find myself lead to believe that lucifuge was interpretating this study as rejecting AGW in anyway. so far as i can recall-- i could go back and look, but i'd rather not, as the room mate is trying to download all of the porn in the world, making page loads c... r... a... w... l...-- lucifuge only suggested that this article's conclusions may suggest that current AGW models are incorrect.



in my experience, emoting the dialogue is the best way to entrench the opposition.

While not stooping to krabapple's language, while noting the dead on accuracy of his assertions when applied to NRDC's recent comments on the Bali conference trying to gear up "Maxi Kyoto" -
The Arctic ice cap melted this summer to the greatest extent on record. Scientists say oceans are losing some ability to absorb atmospheric carbon dioxide, the chief industrial emission blamed for warming....... goal is to save the climate.... and head off a scientific forecast of super-hurricanes, collapsing ice sheets and drowning coastlines.

​
 
There are several studies by very pro AGW writers (Tung 2007 comes to mind, this is in LR's list I think) where in spite of their inclination pro AGW, (like it or not), the scientific result is importantly anti AGW. Note the difference: The scientific results versus the opinions of the scientists.

You have no shame, mhaze. You brought this paper up in another thread, thinking it was valuable for your argument. You were wrong then. Now, I can only conclude that you are deliberatly lying. There is nothing in the results in Tung article that is anti AGW, quite the contrary. They show, among other things, that the normal cycle of warming and cooling due to the solar activity as become dificult to see precisely due to AGW.

But of course, since they further explain it in the media in small words, leaving you no room to spin, you resort to lying about them and their work. Par for the course...
 
Last edited:
While not stooping to krabapple's language, while noting the dead on accuracy of his assertions when applied to NRDC's recent comments on the Bali conference trying to gear up "Maxi Kyoto" -
The Arctic ice cap melted this summer to the greatest extent on record. Scientists say oceans are losing some ability to absorb atmospheric carbon dioxide, the chief industrial emission blamed for warming....... goal is to save the climate.... and head off a scientific forecast of super-hurricanes, collapsing ice sheets and drowning coastlines.

​

The judicious application of krabapple's approach may also be contemplated, with reference to our friend UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, speaking about climate at said conference -
"I believe we are on the verge of a catastrophe if we do not act..... drought, severe weather, rising seas, dying species and other consequences".
​
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom