For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

No, I didn't miss that one. Gray didn't write it. Why do you bring it up?

And hypothetically, if I was "only interested in IPCC material", what would be the problem? One can get an excellent overview of the science of AGW from the IPCC reports.

Should one not get information on climate from the IPCC reports?

Some might, you I assume cannot, your essential component of peer review being lacking therein.
 
Policy that's being formulated now, twenty years on, is predicated on the performance of the model, not its details. Bury yourself is 1988 if you like, but as far as the informed decision-makers of the world are concerned AGW is real beyond question.

So what is contemplated? In the diplomatic world, a jam-fest in Bali starting next week. Where the trillions of dollars come into it is anybody's guess, I doubt the cost will push much past $US200m. Even in today's $US.

Nonsense.

Trillions.

But thanks for trying to comfort people who might otherwise worry over the magnitude of the costs of the ineffectual AGW schemes.
 
It's the correlation between the model predictions and the outcome that gives them weight. Gnaw on its foundations as much as you like you won't change that. You will stay grounded in 1988, but maybe that works for you.



Bollocks. That's equivalent to replication of an experiment on the same apparatus, which is nonsensical. The method, data sources, and results were published. That's what was required for replication. Validation has accrued over time.

It's the correlation between the model predictions and the outcome that gives them weight.
No it does not.

Bollocks. That's equivalent to replication of an experiment on the same apparatus, which is nonsensical.
Gage Repeatability and Reproducibility (GR&R) is a multi-industry standard which indicates consistency and stability of measuring and test equipment.

Repeatability determines if the gage (same apparatus) has the ability to provide consistent measurement results regardless of how many times the same individual repeats the measurement or test.

Reproducibility determines the gage's (the same apparatus)ability to provide consistent measurement results regardless of which individual performs the measurement or test.

The only thing that's nonsensical is your propensity to pull things out of thin air, or other places.

Now Google 'Independent Verification & Validation (IV & V)' to see what commercial software industry (including defense contractors) standards are prior to marketing to industries demanding a quality product. The unlicensed software engineers creating climate models would be looking for work elsewhere if they were accountable for their product. See also SQA.


The method, data sources, and results were published. That's what was required for replication. Validation has accrued over time.
No, no and no.
If a model were run from say 1901 to 1945, then without any further tweaking and parameterization from 1946 to 2006 and it matched observations, independently verified of course, that would be part of the validation process. Has something like that ever been done?

Which model, specifically, has been validated? To what standard? How was it verified? Who certified it?

Here's another article on models. If you don't like this one, there are many more:
http://www.jennifermarohasy.com/blog/archives/DavidDouglas2004GL020103_altitude.pdf
We have found that while the models generally agree
with each other, they disagree with the observations. In
particular, the three state-of-the-art greenhouse models
(Hadley, DOE PCM, and GISS SI2000) examined here
show positive temperature trends that increase with
altitude, reaching values greater than the near-surface trends
by as much as 50 to 100 percent. However, the existing
observational data sets show decreasing as well as mostly
negative trends since 1979. We are therefore faced with two
alternatives.
[27] 1. The models are correct and account for all relevant
forcings. If so, then we must conclude that the observational
data sets – MSU, NNR and Radiosondes – are all incorrect.
[29] 2. The models do not fully capture the multitudinous
climate effects (including various feedbacks) of an increase
in greenhouse gases. Since the observed surface temperature
trends (ST) agree with the models, then they too must be
questioned.
[30] It seems improbable that results from satellites
(MSU), NCAR/NCEP reanalysis (NNR), and Radiosondes,
which agree with each other, would all be wrong. Therefore,
it seems more likely that both the models and observed
surface trends are problematic. Their apparent agreement
may be a coincidence or perhaps reflect a ‘‘tuning’’ of the
models to the surface temperature trends
.

You're not going to win this Capeldodger because opinions are not relevant in this discussion.



 
No, I didn't miss that one. Gray didn't write it. Why do you bring it up?

And hypothetically, if I was "only interested in IPCC material", what would be the problem? One can get an excellent overview of the science of AGW from the IPCC reports.

Should one not get information on climate from the IPCC reports?

I was looking forward to your comments on the article. It was not intended to be 'in your face', but you seem to be reluctant to discuss anything outside of IPCC dogma.
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/142244696b7a46ad59.bmp

I don't think that clouds are adequately handled in the summary line above. Perhaps you do. However, recent research seems to show things quite differently.

You can't fall back on models and ther presumed efficacy when discussing cloud feedback, can you?

You can when their is no alternative, and there is no presumed efficacy, they are worked on continuously to improve their accuracy with known temperature records.
 
No it does not.
Gage Repeatability and Reproducibility (GR&R) is a multi-industry standard which indicates consistency and stability of measuring and test equipment.
Repeatability determines if the gage (same apparatus) has the ability to provide consistent measurement results regardless of how many times the same individual repeats the measurement or test.
Reproducibility determines the gage's (the same apparatus)ability to provide consistent measurement results regardless of which individual performs the measurement or test.

The only thing that's nonsensical is your propensity to pull things out of thin air, or other places.

Now Google 'Independent Verification & Validation (IV & V)' to see what commercial software industry (including defense contractors) standards are prior to marketing to industries demanding a quality product. The unlicensed software engineers creating climate models would be looking for work elsewhere if they were accountable for their product. See also SQA.

No, no and no.
If a model were run from say 1901 to 1945, then without any further tweaking and parameterization from 1946 to 2006 and it matched observations, independently verified of course, that would be part of the validation process. Has something like that ever been done?
Which model, specifically, has been validated? To what standard? How was it verified? Who certified it?

Here's another article on models. If you don't like this one, there are many more:
http://www.jennifermarohasy.com/blog/archives/DavidDouglas2004GL020103_altitude.pdf
You're not going to win this Capeldodger because opinions are not relevant in this discussion.

Any model that predicted fewer and less severe hurricanes for 2006 and 2007?
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting...6b7a46ad59.bmp

I don't think that clouds are adequately handled in the summary line above. Perhaps you do. However, recent research seems to show things quite differently.

You can't fall back on models and ther presumed efficacy when discussing cloud feedback, can you?
​
You can when their is no alternative, and there is no presumed efficacy, they are worked on continuously to improve their accuracy with known temperature records.

No, you can not use models as evidence when discussing cloud feedback, because the grid resolution of the models is huge compared to the average size of clouds. Any questions on this or other weather related phenomena that are incorporated into models?
 
I was looking forward to your comments on the article. It was not intended to be 'in your face', but you seem to be reluctant to discuss anything outside of IPCC dogma.


The question "where should we get our information on climate" is non-trivial. I don't want to join in discussion of specifics of climate science in this thread because it puts up a high barrier to participation to other members of this forum. I would like to know how the JREF would answer that question.

Still, in the context of this thread, I'll make a few comments on the paper.

"REVIEW ARTICLE
Cloud Feedbacks in the Climate System: A Critical Review
GRAEME L. STEPHENS"

The author calls for an increased maturity of cloud-climate feedback analysis methods and warns that the two previous approaches, observations alone or theoretical arguments, are insufficient.

He says that climate and precipitation models "represent the most complete description of all the interactions between the processes that presumably establish the main cloud feedbacks", but "the weak link in the use of these models lies in the cloud parameterization imbedded in them."

So to improve these parameterizations, "observationally based methods for evaluating cloud parameterizations are an important element in the road map to progress."

I could summarise all this as 'models are useful, but clouds are still a problem - here are some examples - and here's how we can make progress.'

Looks to me like the scientific process in action. Climate models didn't spring forth, fully formed, from the code of Hansen. It's a process of continuous improvement and refinement. This paper is a good example of that. It's encouraging to see criticism and debate about climate models taking place in the scientific literature. I don't know about you, but it increases my confidence in climate science.
 
No, you can not use models as evidence when discussing cloud feedback, because the grid resolution of the models is huge compared to the average size of clouds. Any questions on this or other weather related phenomena that are incorporated into models?

They can, and they do, and the models work to a degree, which is a lot more than we get by just saying because they aren't prefect, (and they will never be perfect), we will just act like nothing is going to happen, when there are already changes happening.
 
The question "where should we get our information on climate" is non-trivial. I don't want to join in discussion of specifics of climate science in this thread because it puts up a high barrier to participation to other members of this forum. I would like to know how the JREF would answer that question.

Still, in the context of this thread, I'll make a few comments on the paper.

"REVIEW ARTICLE
Cloud Feedbacks in the Climate System: A Critical Review
GRAEME L. STEPHENS"

The author calls for an increased maturity of cloud-climate feedback analysis methods and warns that the two previous approaches, observations alone or theoretical arguments, are insufficient.

He says that climate and precipitation models "represent the most complete description of all the interactions between the processes that presumably establish the main cloud feedbacks", but "the weak link in the use of these models lies in the cloud parameterization imbedded in them."

So to improve these parameterizations, "observationally based methods for evaluating cloud parameterizations are an important element in the road map to progress."

I could summarise all this as 'models are useful, but clouds are still a problem - here are some examples - and here's how we can make progress.'

Looks to me like the scientific process in action. Climate models didn't spring forth, fully formed, from the code of Hansen. It's a process of continuous improvement and refinement. This paper is a good example of that. It's encouraging to see criticism and debate about climate models taking place in the scientific literature. I don't know about you, but it increases my confidence in climate science.

If it increases your confidence in climate science, why do you place confidence in the IPCC?

Clouds are not the only problem.

Here's another one, just published.
http://www.agu.org/pubs/crossref/2007/2007GL031383.shtml
Twentieth century climate model response and climate sensitivity
Abstract

Climate forcing and climate sensitivity are two key factors in understanding Earth's climate. There is considerable interest in decreasing our uncertainty in climate sensitivity. This study explores the role of these two factors in climate simulations of the 20th century. It is found that the total anthropogenic forcing for a wide range of climate models differs by a factor of two and that the total forcing is inversely correlated to climate sensitivity. Much of the uncertainty in total anthropogenic forcing derives from a threefold range of uncertainty in the aerosol forcing used in the simulations.
I don't give as much clout to 'peer review' as you do, but it can be clearly illustrated that climate models should not be relied on for much of anything.

Your condemnation of Vincent Gray as being a shill for big oil/coal or whatever it is you have against him is odd considering the incestuous relationship between those that control the surface temperature records and the modelers as they are one in the same.

AUP's argument that climate models are not perfect, but good enough has absolutely no basis in fact at all.
 
Last edited:
You take refuge is unproven hypotheses shielded from review by active refusal of scientists to reveal source code, data, and methods. You side with the concept of "conclusions" from such work being used to drive or influence public policy.

You missed his point, the real world is already providing proof enough.
 
AUP's argument that climate models are not perfect, but good enough has absolutely no basis in fact at all.

The current warming is fact enough for me, Australia is suffering reduced rainfall in the populated areas, as predicted, and the economic consequences are already being felt. Water and power are rising significantly, if we don't get rain soon, major industries will have to cut back on activity. The argument is always that we can't afford to change our CO2 production, but we end up paying for it either way.
 
The current warming is fact enough for me, Australia is suffering reduced rainfall in the populated areas, as predicted, and the economic consequences are already being felt. Water and power are rising significantly, if we don't get rain soon, major industries will have to cut back on activity. The argument is always that we can't afford to change our CO2 production, but we end up paying for it either way.

What model predicted what, when?

I could say just the opposite in that our crops and forests have benefited greatly from warming, but we're told it's not "global". It is virtually impossible to please everyone everywhere. When it's pointed out that areas of the world are experiencing record cold, we are told it's not "global". Well, Australia is not "global" either.

You act as though droughts and floods (which by the way were worse during the late 19th century) were uncommon prior to this decade. Do you have actual empirical evidence (measured data), not anecdotal, to support your claim the droughts in Australia are unprecedented in its recorded history? I don't flush anecdotal evidence down the toilet, but you've been talking about how bad it is (I'm not challenging your sincerity), however what do the actual records (past and present) show for Australia as a whole? What has the population growth curve been for the last 100 years? There are more variables involved here than just rising CO2 levels, which nobody has yet to provide direct evidence causes any significant increase in temperature. Wind pattens, ocean circulation and no doubt countless other factors are involved.

Hurricane activity was predicted to increase sharply. Instead we have 30 year record lows. Several areas of the world rely on rainfall brought on by guess what.....hurricanes. But you can be sure there's a study or model out there somewhere that predicted global warming would bring fewer hurricanes....part of that "irrefutable hypothesis" analogy. It shouldn't be long until that's trotted out.

The troposphere is not warming faster than the the surface, a definite prediction by all AGW climate models.

Precipitation levels were way off as well.

The list doesn't end there.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by mhaze
You take refuge is unproven hypotheses shielded from review by active refusal of scientists to reveal source code, data, and methods. You side with the concept of "conclusions" from such work being used to drive or influence public policy.
​
You missed his point, the real world is already providing proof enough.

It wasn't a point. It was a claim there were monsters in his closet.

And only in the closet. By the way. We're not screwed, unless and until people fall prey to such a climate of fear.
the real world is already providing proof enough.
​
Ridiculous assertions. Next it will be Chicken Little, and the sky is falling?
 
It wasn't a point. It was a claim there were monsters in his closet.

And only in the closet. By the way. We're not screwed, unless and until people fall prey to such a climate of fear.
the real world is already providing proof enough.
​
Ridiculous assertions. Next it will be Chicken Little, and the sky is falling?

"monsters in the closet"? Can you try to keep this debate rooted in reality?

CD said the world is already showing signs of warming. The 4AR provides plenty of information on why scientists are concerned about the environment being disrupted by global warming, it's not a fairy tale.
 
What model predicted what, when?

I could say just the opposite in that our crops and forests have benefited greatly from warming, but we're told it's not "global". It is virtually impossible to please everyone everywhere. When it's pointed out that areas of the world are experiencing record cold, we are told it's not "global". Well, Australia is not "global" either.

You act as though droughts and floods (which by the way were worse during the late 19th century) were uncommon prior to this decade. Do you have actual empirical evidence (measured data), not anecdotal, to support your claim the droughts in Australia are unprecedented in its recorded history? I don't flush anecdotal evidence down the toilet, but you've been talking about how bad it is (I'm not challenging your sincerity), however what do the actual records (past and present) show for Australia as a whole? What has the population growth curve been for the last 100 years? There are more variables involved here than just rising CO2 levels, which nobody has yet to provide direct evidence causes any significant increase in temperature. Wind pattens, ocean circulation and no doubt countless other factors are involved.

Hurricane activity was predicted to increase sharply. Instead we have 30 year record lows. Several areas of the world rely on rainfall brought on by guess what.....hurricanes. But you can be sure there's a study or model out there somewhere that predicted global warming would bring fewer hurricanes....part of that "irrefutable hypothesis" analogy. It shouldn't be long until that's trotted out.

The troposphere is not warming faster than the the surface, a definite prediction by all AGW climate models.

Precipitation levels were way off as well.

The list doesn't end there.

Have a read of this

http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2007/06/a-saturated-gassy-argument

http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2007/06/a-saturated-gassy-argument-part-ii
 
Do you have actual empirical evidence (measured data), not anecdotal, to support your claim the droughts in Australia are unprecedented in its recorded history?

i have no horse in this race, but this is a bit of an odd request.

if anyone has empirical evidence that there were such droughts, doesn't the debate move faster if they just post (pointers to) it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom