For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

hi david,

more on precip below. i am not sure how familiar you are with the cliamte literature but this one

The troposphere is not warming faster than the the surface, a definite prediction by all AGW climate models.

is so wrong that the UK MetOffice has listed it on one of their five "Climate Myths" http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/corporate/pressoffice/myths/index.html


Precipitation levels were way off as well.

rain projections do not even agree between models (so they sorta off to be off), and this is widely discussed and the uncertainty is highlighted in one of the few figures in IPCC Summary for Policy Makers. it certainly limits the extent to which one might sensibly interpret models literally for decision support.

of course, all modellers agree with the rather well established observation that warmer air holds more water vapour than cooler air, and that the immediate effect of this is to provide a positive feedback, increasing surface temperature.

but your second point is generally agreed: while much of that extra water is expected to fall back to earth over land, we are clueless as to where, in detail, it is going to fall.
 
Perhaps I should explain what is meant by "validation". It is a term used by computer engineers to describe the rigorous testing process that is necessary before a computer-based model can be put to use. It must include successful prediction over the entire range of circumstances for which it is required. Without this process it is impossible to find out whether the model is suitable for use or what levels of accuracy can be expected from it.

this is a nice ivory-tower definition. but using phrases like "before a computer-based model can be put to use" and "successful prediction over the entire range of circumstances" are not only false but would, if held to be true, prevent most real-world models from ever being used in practice.

it would be nice if we could achieve this in circumstances where it does not conflict with the problem-statement inhand, but we rarely (?if ever?) get there.
 
i think so too. information is the key work.

what do you think Pipirr?


Yes, of course. It would be odd, I think, if climate scientists were not using models. Developing models of climate as a way of understanding atmospheric processes and how changing parameters will alter those processes, that's been an obvious thing to do from Arrhenius on.

I certainly don't think models can be dismissed outright, as mhaze does.

How can we study the climate and not develop models? Neither observations alone, nor models alone, would be the correct approach, but both approaches can and do inform the other. Models are essential and integral to climate science. It would be an impoverished field without them.
 
Last edited:
Yes, of course. It would be odd, I think, if climate scientists were not using models. Developing models of climate as a way of understanding atmospheric processes and how changing parameters will alter those processes, that's been an obvious thing to do from Arrhenius on.

I certainly don't think models can be dismissed outright, as mhaze does.

How can we study the climate and not develop models? Neither observations alone, nor models alone, would be the correct approach, but both approaches can and do inform the other. Models are essential and integral to climate science. It would be an impoverished field without them.

I certainly don't think models can be dismissed outright, as mhaze does.

Fortunately, people have the ability to continue thinking. Thus incorrect ideas like this one can be corrected, with time and patience.:)

Here is the first level of the problem. Note this and prior discussions about models. Semantically, these discussions are completely without value.

Consider an analogy -
"One should not believe in God because..." yada-yada-yada.

Presupposes that the phrase God is understood in a similar way by all in the conversation. Alternately, uses a straw man "God" construct to knock down and make a point. In fact, to state the obvious, the vast multiplicity of concepts within this three letter phrase is as wide as the human imagination.
​
Yet another analogy.
"Computer languages are hard to learn". yada-yada-yada.

Presupposes that a crass generalization can be made across the range of assembler, Fortran, all the way to modern object oriented languages? Yeah right.
​
Back to the subject.
"Climate models are of great value". yada- yada-yada.
​
Now we have seen various people pontificating about "models". I can't think of any place where someone has said "The 5 km grid spacing of climate model XYZ has a lot of merit, but it doesn't handle aerosols as well as YZZ or ZZZ".

Discussions about "models" have little or no information content and no value. Wise pontificating about the "value" of models is empty air without adding to it substance. The burden of proof is on the asserter to add that substance.

It's quite a different thing to say the models have no value than to say that discussions about them are without meaning. It's yet again different to say that assertions made with them are without meaning.

A climate model could be validated and have merit accordingly. The fact that it (they) have not been reflects on the naivety of their users and doesn't say much about the model itself - the model remains relatively unknown, as it has not been validated.
 
Yes, of course. It would be odd, I think, if climate scientists were not using models. Developing models of climate as a way of understanding atmospheric processes and how changing parameters will alter those processes, that's been an obvious thing to do from Arrhenius on.

I certainly don't think models can be dismissed outright, as mhaze does.

How can we study the climate and not develop models? Neither observations alone, nor models alone, would be the correct approach, but both approaches can and do inform the other. Models are essential and integral to climate science. It would be an impoverished field without them.

Repeating my prior request -
I'd like to actually be shown a climate model run that shows something.

This would imply a complete list of the input parameters, versions of databases used by the system, versions of all code used, and the full output. Then of course there would be interpretations and analysis of the output.

However, I have never seen such a thing. Rather we hear all this chatter about "the models show this" or the "models are dead on". It certainly would seem that with the value of gigabytes being measured in (almost) pennies, that this could and should be made available.

What I have asked for here is what is expected in medicine, engineering, criminology/forensics, and many other fields where the results of action or inaction have serious consequences. The work is verifiable by independent outsiders. However, I have never seen such a thing with a climate model.

Have you?

On the contrary what we all have seen is smearing of the likes of Steve McIntyre, true believers scoffing at anyone who would be so rude as to wish to audit scientific work.

So...consider that the above definition is what I consider a climate model. Inputs, outputs, versions, databases. Can you simply point me to where these exist for a particular run or several runs? I doubt it, but await a reply.
​
And your reply is -
I certainly don't think models can be dismissed outright, as mhaze does.
​
But what your reply does not do is simply what I requested, provide a link to a comprehensive climate run that is fully understandable in terms of inputs and outputs.

Glib pontificating, generalities, no actual content to bite into and establish the merits of - these things can abe dismissed outright.
 
this is a nice ivory-tower definition. but using phrases like "before a computer-based model can be put to use" and "successful prediction over the entire range of circumstances" are not only false but would, if held to be true, prevent most real-world models from ever being used in practice.

it would be nice if we could achieve this in circumstances where it does not conflict with the problem-statement inhand, but we rarely (?if ever?) get there.

Reverse your assertion to make it true and accurate. This is the difference between scientists playing with models and engineering using computer models to do actual useful work to standards. Your "climatologists with their models" are the ones in the "ivory towers".
 
hi david,

more on precip below. i am not sure how familiar you are with the cliamte literature but this one



is so wrong that the UK MetOffice has listed it on one of their five "Climate Myths" http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/corporate/pressoffice/myths/index.html




rain projections do not even agree between models (so they sorta off to be off), and this is widely discussed and the uncertainty is highlighted in one of the few figures in IPCC Summary for Policy Makers. it certainly limits the extent to which one might sensibly interpret models literally for decision support.

of course, all modellers agree with the rather well established observation that warmer air holds more water vapour than cooler air, and that the immediate effect of this is to provide a positive feedback, increasing surface temperature.

but your second point is generally agreed: while much of that extra water is expected to fall back to earth over land, we are clueless as to where, in detail, it is going to fall.

IPCC cannot possibly derive an uncertainty from climate models because of the aforementioned problems with them.

The double standards on the AGW side are numerous. On the one hand it is claimed there's all this evidence supporting the AGW hypothesis, yet in nearly every thread on this subject we get links to opinions, news articles and speculation.

No less than three peer reviewed articles on climate models have been presented, the latest from November 2007. We have yet to see one single peer reviewed climate model study demonstrating climate models to be skillful predictors of long term climate, let alone weather.

Climate models are the underpinnings of AGW, not empirical evidence. Positive feedback dominates in the models because that is the assumption.

There has yet to be one peer reviewed article in support of the surface station network showing it to be both reliable and meet minimum WMO standards. I have provided no less than three peer reviewed articles how UHI and land use change significantly affects thermometer readings.

Now you say Met O was wrong to include tropospheric temps? That is one of the main tenants of AGW present in every model used by IPCC!

As for the RealClimate link, add it to the list of things caused by global warming. If AUP, CD and whoever else is going to condemn other blogs that disagree with their world view, then it's only right to say RealClimate is a clearing house for AGW and not a legitimate source for referencing. RC censors and filters dissenting views and is basically a place for the choir to circle jerk.

Also, it is not up to others to go on a hunt for data (ex. Australia). If data is there, post it, otherwise it is considered speculation.


So what's going to be the standard? Peer review or a free-for-all link fest?

A complete list of things caused by global warming
Agricultural land increase, Africa devastated, African aid threatened, Africa hit hardest, air pressure changes, Alaska reshaped, allergies increase, Alps melting, Amazon a desert, American dream end, amphibians breeding earlier (or not), ancient forests dramatically changed, animals head for the hills, Antarctic grass flourishes, anxiety, algal blooms, archaeological sites threatened, Arctic bogs melt, Arctic in bloom, Arctic lakes disappear, asthma, Atlantic less salty, Atlantic more salty, atmospheric defiance, atmospheric circulation modified, attack of the killer jellyfish, avalanches reduced, avalanches increased, bananas destroyed, bananas grow, beetle infestation, bet for $10,000, better beer, big melt faster, billion dollar research projects, billions of deaths, bird distributions change, bird visitors drop, birds return early, blackbirds stop singing, blizzards, blue mussels return, bluetongue, boredom, bridge collapse (Minneapolis), Britain Siberian, British gardens change, brothels struggle, bubonic plague, budget increases, Buddhist temple threatened, building collapse, building season extension, bushfires, business opportunities, business risks, butterflies move north, cancer deaths in England, cardiac arrest, caterpillar biomass shift, challenges and opportunities, childhood insomnia, Cholera, circumcision in decline, cirrus disappearance, civil unrest, cloud increase, cloud stripping, cockroach migration, cod go south, cold climate creatures survive, cold spells (Australia), computer models, conferences, coral bleaching, coral reefs dying, coral reefs grow, coral reefs shrink , cold spells, cost of trillions, cougar attacks, cremation to end, crime increase, crocodile sex, crumbling roads, buildings and sewage systems, cyclones (Australia), damages equivalent to $200 billion, Darfur, Dartford Warbler plague, death rate increase (US), Dengue hemorrhagic fever, dermatitis, desert advance, desert life threatened, desert retreat, destruction of the environment, diarrhoea, disappearance of coastal cities, diseases move north, Dolomites collapse, drought, drowning people, ducks and geese decline, dust bowl in the corn belt, early marriages, early spring, earlier pollen season, Earth biodiversity crisis, Earth dying, Earth even hotter, Earth light dimming, Earth lopsided, Earth melting, Earth morbid fever, Earth on fast track, Earth past point of no return, Earth slowing down, Earth spinning out of control, Earth spins faster, Earth to explode, earth upside down, Earth wobbling, earthquakes, El Niño intensification, erosion, emerging infections, encephalitis, equality threatened, Europe simultaneously baking and freezing, evolution accelerating, expansion of university climate groups, extinctions (human, civilisation, logic, Inuit, smallest butterfly, cod, ladybirds, bats, pandas, pikas, polar bears, pigmy possums, gorillas, koalas, walrus, whales, frogs, toads, turtles, orang-utan, elephants, tigers, plants, salmon, trout, wild flowers, woodlice, penguins, a million species, half of all animal and plant species, not polar bears, barrier reef, leaches), experts muzzled, extreme changes to California, fading fall foliage, famine, farmers go under, fashion disaster, fever,figurehead sacked, fir cone bonanza, fish catches drop, fish catches rise, fish stocks at risk, fish stocks decline, five million illnesses, flesh eating disease, flood patterns change, floods, floods of beaches and cities, Florida economic decline, food poisoning, food prices rise, food security threat (SA), footpath erosion, forest decline, forest expansion, frostbite, frosts, fungi fruitful, fungi invasion, games change, Garden of Eden wilts, genetic diversity decline, gene pools slashed, gingerbread houses collapse, glacial earthquakes, glacial retreat, glacial growth, glacier wrapped, global cooling, global dimming, glowing clouds, god melts, golf Masters wrecked, Gore omnipresence, grandstanding, grasslands wetter, Great Barrier Reef 95% dead, Great Lakes drop, greening of the North, Grey whales lose weight, Gulf Stream failure, habitat loss, Hantavirus pulmonary syndrome, harvest increase, harvest shrinkage, hay fever epidemic, hazardous waste sites breached, health of children harmed,heart disease,heart attacks and strokes (Australia),heat waves, hibernation ends too soon, hibernation ends too late, homeless 50 million, hornets, high court debates, human development faces unprecedented reversal, human fertility reduced, human health improvement, human health risk, hurricanes, hurricane reduction, hydropower problems, hyperthermia deaths, ice sheet growth, ice sheet shrinkage, illness and death, inclement weather, infrastructure failure (Canada), Inuit displacement, Inuit poisoned, Inuit suing, industry threatened, infectious diseases, inflation in China, insurance premium rises, invasion of cats, invasion of herons, invasion of midges, island disappears, islands sinking, itchier poison ivy, jellyfish explosion, Kew Gardens taxed, kitten boom, krill decline, lake and stream productivity decline, lake shrinking and growing, landslides, landslides of ice at 140 mph, lawsuits increase, lawsuit successful, lawyers' income increased (surprise surprise!), lightning related insurance claims, little response in the atmosphere, lush growth in rain forests, Lyme disease, Malaria, malnutrition, mammoth dung melt, Maple syrup shortage, marine diseases, marine food chain decimated, marine dead zone, Meaching (end of the world), megacryometeors, Melanoma, methane emissions from plants, methane burps, melting permafrost, Middle Kingdom convulses, migration, migration difficult (birds), microbes to decompose soil carbon more rapidly, monkeys on the move, Mont Blanc grows,monuments imperiled, more bad air days, more research needed, mountain (Everest) shrinking, mountains break up, mountains taller, mortality lower, mudslides, National security implications, new islands, next ice age, Nile delta damaged, no effect in India, Northwest Passage opened, nuclear plants bloom, oaks move north, ocean acidification, ocean waves speed up, opera house to be destroyed, outdoor hockey threatened, oyster diseases, ozone loss, ozone repair slowed, ozone rise, Pacific dead zone, personal carbon rationing, pest outbreaks, pests increase, phenology shifts, plankton blooms, plankton destabilised, plankton loss, plant viruses, plants march north, polar bears aggressive, polar bears cannibalistic, polar bears drowning, polar bears starve, polar tours scrapped, porpoise astray, profits collapse, psychosocial disturbances, puffin decline, railroad tracks deformed, rainfall increase, rainfall reduction, rape wave, refugees, reindeer larger, release of ancient frozen viruses, resorts disappear, rice threatened, rice yields crash, riches, rift on Capitol Hill, rioting and nuclear war, rivers dry up, river flow impacted, rivers raised, roads wear out, rockfalls, rocky peaks crack apart, roof of the world a desert, Ross river disease, ruins ruined, salinity reduction, salinity increase, Salmonella, salmon stronger, satellites accelerate, school closures, sea level rise, sea level rise faster, seals mating more, sewer bills rise, sex change, sharks booming, sharks moving north, sheep shrink, shop closures, shrinking ponds, shrinking shrine, ski resorts threatened, slow death, smaller brains, smog, snowfall increase, snowfall heavy, snowfall reduction, societal collapse, songbirds change eating habits, sour grapes, space problem, spiders invade Scotland, squid population explosion, squirrels reproduce earlier, spectacular orchids, stormwater drains stressed, street crime to increase, suicide, taxes, tectonic plate movement, teenage drinking, terrorism, threat to peace, ticks move northward (Sweden), tides rise, tourism increase, trade barriers, trade winds weakened, tree beetle attacks, tree foliage increase (UK), tree growth slowed, trees could return to Antarctic, trees in trouble, trees less colourful, trees more colourful, trees lush, tropics expansion, tropopause raised, tsunamis, turtles crash, turtles lay earlier, UK Katrina, Vampire moths, Venice flooded, volcanic eruptions, walrus displaced, walrus pups orphaned, war, wars over water, wars threaten billions, water bills double, water supply unreliability, water scarcity (20% of increase), water stress, weather out of its mind, weather patterns awry, weeds, Western aid cancelled out, West Nile fever, whales move north, wheat yields crushed in Australia, white Christmas dream ends, wildfires, wind shift, wind reduced, wine - harm to Australian industry, wine industry damage (California), wine industry disaster (US), wine - more English, wine -German boon, wine - no more French , winters in Britain colder, wolves eat more moose, wolves eat less, workers laid off, World bankruptcy, World in crisis, World in flames, Yellow fever.

and all on 0.006 deg C per year!
 
Originally Posted by lenny
this is a nice ivory-tower definition. but using phrases like "before a computer-based model can be put to use" and "successful prediction over the entire range of circumstances" are not only false but would, if held to be true, prevent most real-world models from ever being used in practice.

it would be nice if we could achieve this in circumstances where it does not conflict with the problem-statement inhand, but we rarely (?if ever?) get there.


​
Reverse your assertion to make it true and accurate. This is the difference between scientists playing with models and engineering using computer models to do actual useful work to standards. Your "climatologists with their models" are the ones in the "ivory towers".

On thinking this over, I'm not sure that perhaps skeptics (not just me) are being too harsh on the "climate models and merits of them". For example - if the standard processes of validation include testing which is impossible due to the global climate being a one way, one time process (cannot test over the full range of circumstances) then a reasonable semi-validation test set for climate models should be established which takes these real world factors into account.

Sure that the criticisms over the climate models and the trust in them is valid, but what should be required in the testing process - You have to separate those that hold the data from those that run the models, but what else?
 
You act as though droughts and floods (which by the way were worse during the late 19th century) were uncommon prior to this decade. Do you have actual empirical evidence (measured data), not anecdotal, to support your claim the droughts in Australia are unprecedented in its recorded history? I don't flush anecdotal evidence down the toilet, but you've been talking about how bad it is (I'm not challenging your sincerity), however what do the actual records (past and present) show for Australia as a whole? What has the population growth curve been for the last 100 years? There are more variables involved here than just rising CO2 levels, which nobody has yet to provide direct evidence causes any significant increase in temperature. Wind pattens, ocean circulation and no doubt countless other factors are involved.

Australia has worse individual years of drought, or pairs of years, on record, (but not by much). What is different now is the prolonged period of drought. It's as if the climate had changed.

http://www.bom.gov.au/climate/current/statements/scs14.pdf
 
Last edited:
Australia has worse individual years of drought, or pairs of years, on record, (but not by much). What is different now is the prolonged period of drought. It's as if the climate had changed.

http://www.bom.gov.au/climate/current/statements/scs14.pdf

Given that we all know you have a unique ecosystem down under (fairly dry, no hill over 5000 feet elevation in the country, people living on the southeast and east almost exclusively) what is the chance that this is related to the 60-80 year climate cycle?
 
On thinking this over, I'm not sure that perhaps skeptics (not just me) are being too harsh on the "climate models and merits of them". For example - if the standard processes of validation include testing which is impossible due to the global climate being a one way, one time process (cannot test over the full range of circumstances) then a reasonable semi-validation test set for climate models should be established which takes these real world factors into account.
agreed. if the question posed is one of extrapolation (as in climate) then requiring "full validation" allows you to attack anyone who engages with the problem, one would be attacking the problem statement.

and even when is it possible in principle, it is rare that one attempts to "validate" big computer codes (they'd just fail): energy companies and finance companies trade millions on the outputs of "unvalidated" weather models every day.

but no one would build a bridge over the Thames in this millennium without using fully validated code. and, of course, windows products are always fully validated before they are released...
Sure that the criticisms over the climate models and the trust in them is valid, but what should be required in the testing process - You have to separate those that hold the data from those that run the models, but what else?
great question. i think it brings up rather deep (unanswered) mathematical questions and requires decision making under ambiguity (not merely under uncertainty). how do we do that?
 
On thinking this over, I'm not sure that perhaps skeptics (not just me) are being too harsh on the "climate models and merits of them". For example - if the standard processes of validation include testing which is impossible due to the global climate being a one way, one time process (cannot test over the full range of circumstances) then a reasonable semi-validation test set for climate models should be established which takes these real world factors into account.

Sure that the criticisms over the climate models and the trust in them is valid, but what should be required in the testing process - You have to separate those that hold the data from those that run the models, but what else?

I would propose climate models be required to run the first have of the 20th century to observations say up to 1940. Any and all parameterizations, tuning etc. would be acceptable. Then they would run the second half through 2006 without any tuning or fudging allowed.

All code would be subject to scrutiny.

Question: Is a model robust if it predicts the correct outcome for the wrong reasons?
 
I would propose climate models be required to run the first have of the 20th century to observations say up to 1940. Any and all parameterizations, tuning etc. would be acceptable. Then they would run the second half through 2006 without any tuning or fudging allowed.

All code would be subject to scrutiny.

Question: Is a model robust if it predicts the correct outcome for the wrong reasons?

IIRC, that's the obvious thing to do, and it's been done for years.
 
Last edited:
Question: Is a model robust if it predicts the correct outcome for the wrong reasons?
​
IIRC, that's the obvious thing to do, and it's been done for years.
​
Cite the models and the study. Thank you.

It's got to stop, doesn't it? The misuse of science, scientists and models for political purposes. Essentially, to justify tax schemes, to shift blame outside of local irresponsible politics to "global polluters and emitters", and to rule by fear.

Just put the all data and parameters for climate models, and the scenario for each climate model run, under a forced archiving umbrella ran by ClimateAudit.
 
agreed. if the question posed is one of extrapolation (as in climate) then requiring "full validation" allows you to attack anyone who engages with the problem, one would be attacking the problem statement.

and even when is it possible in principle, it is rare that one attempts to "validate" big computer codes (they'd just fail): energy companies and finance companies trade millions on the outputs of "unvalidated" weather models every day.

but no one would build a bridge over the Thames in this millennium without using fully validated code. and, of course, windows products are always fully validated before they are released...

great question. i think it brings up rather deep (unanswered) mathematical questions and requires decision making under ambiguity (not merely under uncertainty). how do we do that?

Here is a look at the matter. Not that we cannot and should not engage in decision making under conditions of ambiguity (we should) but that possibly we cannot trust the governments of nations individually or collectively (UN) to guide us in such a pursuit.

To understand this (I might be wrong, but exploring this line of thought a bit and no, this is not a conspiracy theory:)) suppose nation ABC ratifies Ultimate Kyoto Plan of 2015 and establishes a Ministry of Truthy Climate and Greenhouse Gas Control.

Is any unbiased, scientifically accurate science on climate going to come out of that nation? Just as when a jury decides guilt in a murder trial, then there exists guilt, "legally". In the same fashion, once the plan is ratified and the Ministry established, "legally", AGW exists. Of course, this means AGW of the "control the CO2" variety, and ignore all the other factors.

In this direction we go from a beginnings, that was a discussion of decision making under ambiguity?
 
20 foot "wall of water", does IPCC science support this if so over what time frame.
mhaze, more than once I've asked you to clarify who you're quoting with this "wall of water" business. I understand why my question has gone unanswered -- because you're quoting another forum member (who, I suspect, was making a sarcastic comment) in a different thread and now you're trying to hang it on the IPCC by inference.

I guess that's what happens when you rely on agenda-driven propagandists -- you lose track of which drivel you're echoing.

One word: shameless.
 
Last edited:
mhaze, more than once I've asked you to clarify who you're quoting with this "wall of water" business. I understand why my question has gone unanswered -- because you're quoting another forum member (who, I suspect, was making a sarcastic comment) in a different thread and now you're trying to hang it on the IPCC by inference.

I guess that's what happens when you rely on agenda-driven propagandists -- you lose track of which drivel you're echoing.

One word: shameless.
My, my you are in a great mood for a Monday morning.

Why don't you just go to AIT to find out more about the big wall of water? Your friends at Environmental Defense League? Greenpeace? Hansen? We've discussed this matter here several times, actually I've gotten pretty bored of it. Or if you have a specific point, what is it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom