For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

IPCC cannot possibly derive an uncertainty from climate models because of the aforementioned problems with them.

showing that less than 66% of the models agree about whether it gets wetter or drier in the 2090's (wet/dry average over a three month season!) clearly estabilishes a level of uncertainty consistent with my claim;
rain projections do not even agree between models (so they sorta off to be off [edit:should have read:have to be off] ), and this is widely discussed and the uncertainty is highlighted in one of the few figures in IPCC Summary for Policy Makers. it certainly limits the extent to which one might sensibly interpret models literally for decision support.
the IPCC does not hide from this uncertainty (SPM, Fig 7)

not sure what you mean by "derive" an uncertainty. (?)
 
showing that less than 66% of the models agree about whether it gets wetter or drier in the 2090's (wet/dry average over a three month season!) clearly estabilishes a level of uncertainty consistent with my claim;
the IPCC does not hide from this uncertainty (SPM, Fig 7)

not sure what you mean by "derive" an uncertainty. (?)


Perhaps calculate would be more appropriate instead of derive?



Presenting different scenarios using various models is clearly not an expression of uncertainty in statistical terminology. If the models are robust, then only one would do.


How do you define uncertainty? When I see the word it can have one of two definitions depending on the context.
    • The condition of being uncertain; doubt, vagueness, ambiguity etc.
    • The estimated amount or percentage by which an observed or calculated value may differ from the true value.
Definition #1 is not difficult to understand. When uncertainty is used in that context, since there is no quantified amount or percentage, whatever the subject matter is should not be assumed reliable.

Definition #2 can be quite complex, however is necessary to achieve any degree of confidence in the measurement reported or predicted. In a nutshell, if the relevant errors are not accounted for and included in the uncertainty calculation, the result is still ambiguous and not to be trusted. Uncertainty is a well established statistical methodology in science as I’d assume you know.

Therefore, until the significant errors and unknowns can be qualitatively and quantitatively determined, it is not possible to assign uncertainty in any meaningful way.

When for instance climate models were way off on precipitation this year as reported in various publications, the source of the error must be accounted for.

Another is Arctic Ice melt. Much ado was about how in the last few years it was much worse than the models predicted. Now new data may be indicating the accelerated melt was due to unusual winds and ocean circulation, not an increase in air temps. The question is then, why were the models wrong?




I contend the reason the models are not matching observations is the low level of scientific understanding of several key factors in climate; clouds (aerosols), precipitation, solar, UHI, land use change etc. and possibly that climate is too chaotic to predict. Until such time as those factors can be accurately and precisely determined, no amount of parameterizations (fudging) will improve the skillfulness of climate models at predicting future climate.



Regional "projections" are another problem for climate models.


Are climate model outputs then the result of well understood climate forcings, feedbacks, established physics etc., or more or less the numerical expression of the programmer’s assumptions?
 
I contend the reason the models are not matching observations is the low level of scientific understanding of several key factors in climate; clouds (aerosols), precipitation, solar, UHI, land use change etc. and possibly that climate is too chaotic to predict. Until such time as those factors can be accurately and precisely determined, no amount of parameterizations (fudging) will improve the skillfulness of climate models at predicting future climate.

Are climate model outputs then the result of well understood climate forcings, feedbacks, established physics etc., or more or less the numerical expression of the programmer’s assumptions?

To their credit, the IPCC asserts the models' outputs as "scenarios", not as forecasts. However, they then proceed to use them as forecasts, since models are a key pillar of AGW. Warmers miss this, and launch into the dead on accuracy of the forecasts. Somewhere back in the chain of mis direction lies honest science and scientists.

But what of a model that is tuned to match the last several decades of temperature? Aerosol and climate sensitivity have been shown to be the key factors in tuning. Now we know that the 1940-1970 cool period was natural, not due to man made aerosols (Tsonis 2007). Tsonis indicates that we are entering another cool period, which should show a temperature decline of about 0.2C by the year 2035.

There go the model outputs that cranked the aerosol parameter up to get the 1940-1970 cool period.

Second, grass roots efforts (Anthony Watts, surfacestations.org, Climateaudit, and many contributers) have documented serious flaws in the surface temperature measurements. Surface measurements are transposed into the grid values used by models, but the original model inputs are still the surface temperatures.

And we now see the first in what may be a large number of papers, criticizing the methods, procedures and use of models by the IPCC and the global warming industry.

Ross R. McKitrick & Patrick J. Michaels 2007, GRL. "Quantifying the influence of anthropogenic surface process inhomogeneities on gridded global climate data" has just been released. Notes on the publication's background are to be found here.

McKitrick says in the Background paper that in regard to comments made by the IPCC on the subject of natural circulation changes, they reject evidence and assert contrary opinions without any scientific basis and to quote "the technical term for this is 'making stuff up.' "...."a plain fabrication by the IPCC".

But these are side issues. Here is what the paper says -
"We can use the statistical model to estimate what the observed temperature trends would have been if everyone had as good circumstances for monitoring climate as the US does. The average trend at the surface in the post-1980 interval would fall from about 0.30 degrees C per decade to about 0.17 degrees."
​
Tuning aerosols to 1940-1970 cooling ..... worthless.

Tuning CO2 sensitivity to match 1970-2006 warming .... worthless.
 
Last edited:
To their credit, the IPCC asserts the models' outputs as "scenarios", not as forecasts. However, they then proceed to use them as forecasts, since models are a key pillar of AGW. Warmers miss this, and launch into the dead on accuracy of the forecasts. Somewhere back in the chain of mis direction lies honest science and scientists.

But what of a model that is tuned to match the last several decades of temperature? Aerosol and climate sensitivity have been shown to be the key factors in tuning. Now we know that the 1940-1970 cool period was natural, not due to man made aerosols (Tsonis 2007). Tsonis indicates that we are entering another cool period, which should show a temperature decline of about 0.2C by the year 2035.

Then that cooling from the thick haze in Bangkok doesn't happen?

There go the model outputs that cranked the aerosol parameter up to get the 1940-1970 cool period.

Second, grass roots efforts (Anthony Watts, surfacestations.org, Climateaudit, and many contributers) have documented serious flaws in the surface temperature measurements. Surface measurements are transposed into the grid values used by models, but the original model inputs are still the surface temperatures.

No, Watts set up the Stephenson box experiment, then promptly forgot about, (or the results weren't what he was looking for).
 
Then that cooling from the thick haze in Bangkok doesn't happen?



No, Watts set up the Stephenson box experiment, then promptly forgot about, (or the results weren't what he was looking for).

That sounds like someone who's been on a steady diet of Eli Rabbet droppings.

Maybe a visit to Watt's blog can help deprogram the brainwashing:
http://wattsupwiththat.wordpress.com/

Watts posted his Stevenson screen findings long ago.

From a recent UCAR meeting:
http://gallery.surfacestations.org/UCAR-slides/index.html

No matter. It does help to actually read what you believe to be in error before coming to a conclusion though. Come up with a good argument for the poorly placed sites; I'm all ears.

Here's another article on UHI, which IPCC says isn't a problem:
http://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2007/11/ca_climate_variability_ladochy.pdf
ABSTRACT: With mounting evidence that global warming is taking place, the cause of this warming has come under vigorous scrutiny. Recent studies have lead to a debate over what contributes the most to regional temperature changes. We investigated air temperature patterns in California from 1950 to 2000. Statistical analyses were used to test the significance of temperature trends in California subregions in an attempt to clarify the spatial and temporal patterns of the occurrence and intensities of warming. Most regions showed a stronger increase in minimum temperatures than with mean and maximum temperatures. Areas of intensive urbanization showed the largest positive trends, while rural, non-agricultural regions showed the least warming. Strong correlations between temperatures and Pacific sea surface temperatures (SSTs) particularly Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO) values, also account for temperature variability throughout the state. The analysis of 331 state weather stations associated a number of factors with temperature trends, including urbanization, population, Pacific oceanic conditions and elevation. Using climatic division mean temperature trends, the state had an average warming of 0.99°C (1.79°F) over the 1950–2000 period, or 0.20°C
(0.36°F) decade–1. Southern California had the highest rates of warming, while the NE Interior Basins division experienced cooling. Large urban sites showed rates over twice those for the state, for the mean maximum temperatures, and over 5 times the state’s mean rate for the minimum temperatures.
In comparison, irrigated cropland sites warmed about 0.13°C decade–1 annually, but near 0.40°C for summer and fall minima. Offshore Pacific SSTs warmed 0.09°C decade–1 for the study period.



This all goes back to the subject of uncertainty and Quality standards, which again IPCC doesn't appear to derive first principles from.
 
Then that cooling from the thick haze in Bangkok doesn't happen?

It does, and it is a problem.

I was referencing the 1940-1970 period, where the old AGW logic held that cool period was the result of man's aerosol emissions. That is proven false.

Asian brown cloud is something we agree on.
Now we know that the 1940-1970 cool period was natural, not due to man made aerosols (Tsonis 2007). Tsonis indicates that we are entering another cool period, which should show a temperature decline of about 0.2C by the year 2035.
​
 
It does, and it is a problem.

I was referencing the 1940-1970 period, where the old AGW logic held that cool period was the result of man's aerosol emissions. That is proven false.

Asian brown cloud is something we agree on.
Now we know that the 1940-1970 cool period was natural, not due to man made aerosols (Tsonis 2007). Tsonis indicates that we are entering another cool period, which should show a temperature decline of about 0.2C by the year 2035.
​

No, Tsonis is saying there are global states that overlay the underlying warming.
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
I was referencing the 1940-1970 period, where the old AGW logic held that cool period was the result of man's aerosol emissions. That is proven false.
Now we know that the 1940-1970 cool period was natural, not due to man made aerosols (Tsonis 2007). Tsonis indicates that we are entering another cool period, which should show a temperature decline of about 0.2C by the year 2035.
​
No, Tsonis is saying there are global states that overlay the underlying warming.

No, he says that there maybe some AGW -that his work does not exclude the possibility.

Thus the house of cards that is man's conception of AGW falls...

Tsonis refutes Hansen, work such as this, to which Hansen was a contributor, and which the IPCC solidly adheres to.

R. J. CHARLSON, S. E. SCHWARTZ, J. M. HALES, R. D. CESS, J. A. COAKLEY JR. , J. E. HANSEN, and D. J. HOFMANN
Science 24 January 1992:Vol. 255. no. 5043, pp. 423-430
DOI:10.1126/science.255.5043.423

.... tropospheric aerosol contributes substantially to radiative forcing, and anthropogenic sulfate aerosol in particular has imposed a major perturbation to this forcing....Current climate forcing due to anthropogenic sulfate is estimated to be –1 to –2 watts per square meter, globally averaged. This perturbation is comparable in magnitude to current anthropogenic greenhouse gas forcing but opposite in sign. Thus, the aerosol forcing has likely offset global greenhouse warming to a substantial degree.....
 
Last edited:
No, he says that there maybe some AGW -that his work does not exclude the possibility.

The paper presents a hypothesis of a mechanism that might cause a variation in global temperatures, despite the underlying anthropogenic global warming.
Unless of course, you read their minds like you did with Tung et al, and magically realized that what they wrote is not what they meant, and what they meant is what you're saying...

Thus the house of cards that is man's conception of AGW falls...

Hazy, how many times did you proclaim a "Gotch'a!!" kind of paper in the several GW threads? How many times did they stand, due to the quality of the paper or the quality of your comprehension of the work?

A theory doesn't fall because of a paper. At most, it can fall after the validation of the initial paper by further work. But you would have to understand how science works to know this.

Nothing in science is a house of cards. There is no cornerstone you can remove to demolish the building. And the most you, hazy, can is throw stones at it...

Tsonis refutes Hansen, work such as this, to which Hansen was a contributor, and which the IPCC solidly adheres to.

Tsonis et al. refutes nothing, at present. It presents a hypothesis of a mechanism that might cause a variation in global temperatures, despite the underlying anthropogenic global warming.

That mechanism might or not exist. That will be validated or falsified by further work. The same way that AGW hypothesis has been validated throughout the last couple of decades, through replication of original work and contributions from other branches of science. And the putative existence of such a mechanism only increases our understanding of the system, it doesn't invalidate what we already know about it.
 
Last edited:
Do you believe that the 1940-1970 cool period was the result of aerosol cooling the atmosphere, those aerosols being man's pollution?
 
No it does not.

I rather think it does. What other measure is there of a model than the accuracy of its predictions?


Gage Repeatability and Reproducibility (GR&R) is a multi-industry standard which indicates consistency and stability of measuring and test equipment.

Repeatability determines if the gage (same apparatus) has the ability to provide consistent measurement results regardless of how many times the same individual repeats the measurement or test.

Reproducibility determines the gage's (the same apparatus)ability to provide consistent measurement results regardless of which individual performs the measurement or test.

There is no similarity being testing equipment and reproducing science. Scientists expect other scientists to attempt to reproduce their work, on different apparatus. Scientific results that can are reproduced on the original lab set-up are of limited value.

The same naturally applies to models. The model is described (as would be apparatus in other cases), the inputs are provided, and the results are reported on. From that others can reproduce the work, or not, with their own model.

If a model were run from say 1901 to 1945, then without any further tweaking and parameterization from 1946 to 2006 and it matched observations, independently verified of course, that would be part of the validation process. Has something like that ever been done?

Of course. Models are routinely run against recorded forcings over the last century to see that they don't go wildly astray. They don't

Which model, specifically, has been validated? To what standard? How was it verified? Who certified it?

The Hansen et al 1988 model predicted warming over the last two decades at about 0.21C per decade (for Scenario B, the emission scenario best matching the outcome) and that's what has come to pass.

The Hadley Centre issued new model predictions this year, quite precise in comparison to early models, enough that we'll be able to judge them in only three-to-eight years time.


You're not going to win this Capeldodger because opinions are not relevant in this discussion.

The only relevant model is the big bad analogue one, which is perhaps why contrarians keep there heads buried in digital models. The BBA model has brought the world to the Bali Conference and to the very brink of serious discussions about establishing the protocols under which final negotiations over a concerted action plan will be conducted. The BBA model clearly has some major clout.
 
Any model that predicted fewer and less severe hurricanes for 2006 and 2007?

You'll have to look to hurricane modellers for an answer, if one is needed. Less than what? And on what measure? 2005 was an exceptional year for cyclonic activity, but I'm not aware it has fallen off very much since.

Of course, a climate model isn't going to predict hurricane activity for a particular year in the future. Only an idiot would expect them to. Climate models predict medium- to long-term climate trends. Hurricanes and cyclones are weather, not climate.
 
No, you can not use models as evidence when discussing cloud feedback, because the grid resolution of the models is huge compared to the average size of clouds.

What is "the average size of clouds"? Are you thinking of the ones you see in Texas? Over here we currently have one cloud stretching from Ireland to the North Sea, and from Scotland to the Channel. There's another one coming in behind it.

Meterologists traditionally record cloud-cover in eighths - eight-eighths being what we've had recently.

Any questions on this or other weather related phenomena that are incorporated into models?

Modern models incorporate many such features, far more than the earlier ones could. There have, after all, been crazy advances in computing power over the last twenty years.

Regarding the refuge in a hypothetically significant negative feedback from clouds, it apparently hasn't kicked in yet despite first being posited twenty years or more back. Unless there's some tipping-point we haven't reached yet it's surely time to give up on it.
 
What is "the average size of clouds"? Are you thinking of the ones you see in Texas? Over here we currently have one cloud stretching from Ireland to the North Sea, and from Scotland to the Channel. There's another one coming in behind it.

Meterologists traditionally record cloud-cover in eighths - eight-eighths being what we've had recently.



Modern models incorporate many such features, far more than the earlier ones could. There have, after all, been crazy advances in computing power over the last twenty years.

Regarding the refuge in a hypothetically significant negative feedback from clouds, it apparently hasn't kicked in yet despite first being posited twenty years or more back. Unless there's some tipping-point we haven't reached yet it's surely time to give up on it.

Clouds are not a hypothetically positive feedback?

We can suppose you have as much faith in the surface temperature networks as the models forced to match them?

What models predicted the current decade non-warming and coming cooling?
 
Clouds are not a hypothetically positive feedback?

We can suppose you have as much faith in the surface temperature networks as the models forced to match them?

What models predicted the current decade non-warming and coming cooling?

Oh, there's "coming cooling?" Do you have perchance a crystal ball or something similar? Maybe some kind of model?
 
Australia has worse individual years of drought, or pairs of years, on record, (but not by much). What is different now is the prolonged period of drought. It's as if the climate had changed.

http://www.bom.gov.au/climate/current/statements/scs14.pdf

From your cite :

"As Figure 1 clearly shows, the majority of those areas across Australia currently experiencing their lowest rainfall totals so far recorded lie within the Basin where only small areas near Moree, Broken Hill and the Mt. Lofty Ranges have received near-average rainfall. When considered in area terms, just over 75% of the land area of the Murray-Darling Basin experienced rainfall that ranked in the lowest 10% of recorded totals (decile 1). This area of decile 1 rainfall was only surpassed during the drought of 1939-1945, when 78% of the Murray-Darling Basin was similarly dry, even though that event had a larger area that experienced above-average rainfall.

For the 2001-2007 event, only 0.5% of the Basin received rainfall that was in the highest 50% of historical totals (i.e. above median) for such a six-year period. There were no areas that recorded a six-year rainfall total in the top 20% of historically recorded values."

David Rodale seems to have assumed that you Aussies would only have anecdotal evidence of your recorded history. It doesn't say much for his opinion of Australia as a sophisticated culture, if you ask me.

Floods are influenced by land-use, a city's water-shortage by profligacy and short-term thinking, but precipitation cuts straight to the chase.

The 1939-45 drought is interesting, being in the 60-80 year range. If that proposed cycle is dominant we should expect to see the drought break quite soon.
 
I rather think it does. What other measure is there of a model than the accuracy of its predictions?




There is no similarity being testing equipment and reproducing science. Scientists expect other scientists to attempt to reproduce their work, on different apparatus. Scientific results that can are reproduced on the original lab set-up are of limited value.

The same naturally applies to models. The model is described (as would be apparatus in other cases), the inputs are provided, and the results are reported on. From that others can reproduce the work, or not, with their own model.



Of course. Models are routinely run against recorded forcings over the last century to see that they don't go wildly astray. They don't



The Hansen et al 1988 model predicted warming over the last two decades at about 0.21C per decade (for Scenario B, the emission scenario best matching the outcome) and that's what has come to pass.

The Hadley Centre issued new model predictions this year, quite precise in comparison to early models, enough that we'll be able to judge them in only three-to-eight years time.




The only relevant model is the big bad analogue one, which is perhaps why contrarians keep there heads buried in digital models. The BBA model has brought the world to the Bali Conference and to the very brink of serious discussions about establishing the protocols under which final negotiations over a concerted action plan will be conducted. The BBA model clearly has some major clout.

Metrology is the science of measurement.

Of course. Models are routinely run against recorded forcings over the last century to see that they don't go wildly astray. They don't
Prove it. Which models? Where are the studies? There are processes by which a model can be validated. One is Independent Validation and Verification. That has never been done. Provide and example of a climate model that meets industry standards for validation. Climate "science" seems to be allowed to live under it's own set of rules.

The models are parameterized to match. Anything can be fudged to agree with anything given enough variables.

You are pulling things out of thin air again.

This is the third time since 2003 that Hadley claims to have a 'new and improved' model. By you saying we have to wait another three to eight years sounds like you are conceding previous models are unreliable. Oh yes, models are skillful, but Hadley wrong again predicting in January 2007 that 2007 would be the warmest year on record.

MHaze and I back what we say with evidence. You give long speeches and defend the indefensible which is nothing less than blathering psycho babble.

You can't provide evidence for climate model robustness because none exists. It's all faith based.
 
Oh, there's "coming cooling?" Do you have perchance a crystal ball or something similar? Maybe some kind of model?

It's the same big orange ball that Met O is relying on.

Capeldodger has a lot of faith in their 'new and improved' model, even though they give no details; there never are. All they say is starting some time after 2009, global warming will return in earnest and temperatures will higher than 1998.

It's the same thing they said in January 2007.

There is going to be cooling regardless of what happens after 2009. Wanna bet? It's happening now. Met O is counting on a strong solar cycle 24 despite Capeldodger's claims to the contrary.

Thus far, there are more indicators for a weak SC24 than strong, but we'll just have to wait and see. There are other signs as well, but who cares right? In 3-8 years we're all doomed.....
 
Last edited:
Clouds are not a hypothetically positive feedback?

They've been hypothesised as a negative feedback since way back, with no sign of any impact yet. The actual impact of changes in cloud-cover in a warming climate is not well-resolved. Cloud has both positive and negative influences on temperature, and the influences are not correlated - albedo and the greenhouse effect being the main ones. Also we don't know exactly how the distribution of cloud will change. When the Himalayan glaciers sign out, for instance, local cloud cover will probably change. Just how is for experts to consider.

We can suppose you have as much faith in the surface temperature networks as the models forced to match them?

How was the Hansen et al 1988 model forced to match climate observations from 1988-2007?

What models predicted the current decade non-warming and coming cooling?

The current decade non-warming is a little over-eager, that would be since '97; '98 is the chosen charm. '07 was way warmer than '97. The warming trend has continued, and will.

You predict a cooling. On what time-scale? How does three-to-eight years sound? It's most of a Solar Cycle, after all, and it's close enough not to be wild conjecture.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom