Is bossnapping OK?

Is kidnapping your boss, to try and save your job, acceptable?

  • Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures

    Votes: 18 15.0%
  • No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

    Votes: 102 85.0%

  • Total voters
    120
Perhaps they are in negotiations and do not wish to get even more aggro from their negotiating partners? (Especially if the public/government/police is not behind them to the extent that they would be in America)

Look at it this way, in america if people did this they wouldn't have to worry about a job for a long time. Their room and board would be provided for free by the state. Sounds like a winning situation. After all not being free to go is not much a a problem for them, so being in prison shouldn't bother them much.
 
I'm still not seeing this as anything more than a protest. At worse, forced negotiations.

All a riot is is a protest. So the riots after the rodney king verdict were no big deal, right?

Just because it is a protest does not mitigate their actions. This is getting very close to terrorism after all.
 
I don't know. Are you actually talking about a machine to lighten the burden of having to perform a simple mindless job day in and day out, or are you talking of a machine to lighten the expenses of factury owner for the wages of workers performing simple mindless jobs?
For some weird reason the act of depriving people of their livelihood is usually referred to with very different words.
The two are the same.

No, they definitely aren't! And when you describe it, it becomes obvious that the burden that is ligthened is the wages received by the workers who are now removed from the factory floor as well as from the payroll:
A company might be able to do something with one worker instead of 10. This is very good for the company as it reduces the cost, it is also good for the economy because it increases productivity. If you want to get on the workers side, you need to take back a lot of modern technology that makes people more productive.

I want to eliminate jobs.

Exactly!

By making it so that people can individually do much more work you need fewer people to do the same amount of work.

The work of the the few remaining workers is intensified - and the rest don't have an income.
 
What I will say is that these bosses could 1) hire private security 2) press charges 3) lobby the government for stricter penalties 4) try to leave, if violence was used to keep them to stay, the practice would end tomorrow 5) fire everyone involved in the activity, instead of hiring them back and continuing to work with them and 6) complain about somewhere instead of having their spokespeople describe it as nothing to worry about.

Why it is clear that society is not going to protect them, and does not want to protect them. They just have to take the infringements of their rights.
 
Define harm. You are ok with depriving people of some of the liberties after all, so your definition of harm and mine are clearly different.

No, I'll agree that it's a harm, just not one serious enough to worry about. All harms are not created equally.

But who's going to compare keeping you boss in the building for a night and bringing dinner to Hilter. You know you want to, who's going to do it first?
 
Why it is clear that society is not going to protect them, and does not want to protect them. They just have to take the infringements of their rights.

For once, just once, please, please find a goddamn fact to support what you say.

Society isn't "protecting" them because there's nothing to protect them from. It isn't even as bad as a mild frat hazing.

The fact that you guys view this as an unacceptible violation of basic rights means that you are wimps on a level that would embarass the French. Think about that for a second: the French are a hardier breed than you. Wow.
 
No, they definitely aren't! And when you describe it, it becomes obvious that the burden that is ligthened is the wages received by the workers who are now removed from the factory floor as well as from the payroll:

Yes it also makes it possible to reduce the cost of the product.


Bring back the good old days, when it was common for middle class to think that they would never be too poor to afford servants but not ever be rich enough to afford a car.


The work of the the few remaining workers is intensified - and the rest don't have an income.

Not really. I am always amazed when people argue against technological innovation on the internet.

They are getting the production of 10, but they are not necessarily working any harder than any one of those 10.
 
For once, just once, please, please find a goddamn fact to support what you say.

Society isn't "protecting" them because there's nothing to protect them from. It isn't even as bad as a mild frat hazing.

A good reason to remove assault as a crime, just have battery or nothing.

What is wrong with hitting people as long as you don't hospitalize him, it is no worse than mild frat hazing.

Of course frat hazing tends to be something voluntarily entered into. This is kidnapping.
The fact that you guys view this as an unacceptible violation of basic rights means that you are wimps on a level that would embarass the French. Think about that for a second: the French are a hardier breed than you. Wow.
No it means that we care about individual rights more than the french do.
 
A good reason to remove assault as a crime, just have battery or nothing.

What is wrong with hitting people as long as you don't hospitalize him, it is no worse than mild frat hazing.

Assault: A crime that occurs when one person tries to physically harm another in a way that makes the person under attack feel immediately threatened. Actual physical contact is not necessary; threatening gestures that would alarm any reasonable person can constitute an assault.

The definition is basically the same in France. So why do you think no one has been arrested? They know the perps, the crime isn't in question, and no one flees the crime scene. Thus, all one would need to do is press charges or file a lawsuit. Why hasn't this happened in the more than 40 years the French have been doing this?

This is what I mean by bringing a fact to the table. You're making stuff up based on your own assumed cowardly reaction to such an incident. Provide something of substance or stop whining.


Of course frat hazing tends to be something voluntarily entered into. This is kidnapping.

No it means that we care about individual rights more than the french do.

Notice that I didn't say it was a frat hazing, I said it wasn't even as bad. But thanks for distinguishing two things I never linked with analogy or metaphor.

And the French just have a different idea of what rights are guarded as individual, health care and child services, for example. You can disagree, fine, but I really don't see why you care what the French do in their negotiations.

Once again (to forestall your obvious, silly reaction), this is different from the tradition in some Muslim countries of tossing acid in their faces of their women because there is no real damage being done.
 
Assault: A crime that occurs when one person tries to physically harm another in a way that makes the person under attack feel immediately threatened. Actual physical contact is not necessary; threatening gestures that would alarm any reasonable person can constitute an assault.

The definition is basically the same in France. So why do you think no one has been arrested? They know the perps, the crime isn't in question, and no one flees the crime scene. Thus, all one would need to do is press charges or file a lawsuit. Why hasn't this happened in the more than 40 years the French have been doing this?

This is a felony, they victims shouldn't need to press charges that is what the police and prosecutors are for. But they clearly don't care. I wonder if they are afraid of more riots, the french do seem to riot at the drop of a hat(another of those cultural quirks I guess)
Notice that I didn't say it was a frat hazing, I said it wasn't even as bad. But thanks for distinguishing two things I never linked with analogy or metaphor.

And consent makes things so different, it changes assault into sexual fun.
 
This is a felony, they victims shouldn't need to press charges that is what the police and prosecutors are for. But they clearly don't care. I wonder if they are afraid of more riots, the french do seem to riot at the drop of a hat(another of those cultural quirks I guess)

Yes, exactly, no one cares, it isn't a big deal. Not only do the cops not care, but if you had read the articles I linked, you would read quotes from the "victims" where they explain that it's not a big deal.

But I'm disapointed, I thought you would launch into a "leave brittney alone"-esque explanation of how it was worse than the gulags.
 
Yes it also makes it possible to reduce the cost of the product.
I.e. to make not only your own workers redundant but also those of the competition:
I want to eliminate jobs. By making it so that people can individually do much more work you need fewer people to do the same amount of work.
This is definitely truth in advertising.

I am always amazed when people argue against technological innovation on the internet.
You are?! I'm not, since it's very easy to confuse technological innovation with its purpose in capitalism. With more rational conditions of production the introduction of more efficient would enable workers to produce more, consume more and have more spare time on their hands. Instead they lose their jobs altogether, and with their jobs they lose their income, and with the competition from the unemployed, the few remaining workers are easier to pressure into working more instead of lightening the burden of work.
All this does not result from technological innovation. It is a result of the capitalist purpose of technological innovation.
By the way, I am never amazed that whenever people argue against the purpose of capitalist production and innovation, they are met with the strawman: "Luddites!" Apparently Luddites are not the only ones who like to confuse things ...

They are getting the production of 10, but they are not necessarily working any harder than any one of those 10.

It is a necessity of capitalism, not of nature or technology:
It is a devastating judgment on this mode of production that the impoverishment of people is just as useful as the development and enlargement of the well-springs of wealth. Both perform the same service for this economic mode. The productive power of labor increases so that more use values result per unit of time; this is just as useful as simply paying less wages.

The increase of productive power has a strange benefit in capitalism. The entrepreneur increases the productive power of labor to save labor. He does this, however, not to save the worker work, but to save himself the costs of paid work. He saves on labor, but only for the purpose of saving on labor costs. To save on labor costs means to separate the workers yet another little bit farther from their product.

This division happens in two ways: one part of the staff produces with, say, doubled productivity, now the old staff performs a doubly good service for the enterprise for the same wage or the same service as previously but for half the wage. All "labor-saving" investments do not save on labor – on the contrary, as a rule it becomes more intense – but on paid labor, by making the applied work more productive; the quantity of commodities for sale per wage payment rises. The other half of the staff becomes unemployed because their work has become superfluous. The creation of disposable time, the creation of free time – which should actually be the positive side of an increase in productive power – actually happens in this society in the form of unemployment.
http://www.ruthlesscriticism.com/Marxwealth.htm
 
When the heck did half the population start thinking that being cheesed off with someone gives you the right to kidnap them?
When they remembered the old "ask a stupid question" adage. :rolleyes:
 
Yes, exactly, no one cares, it isn't a big deal. Not only do the cops not care, but if you had read the articles I linked, you would read quotes from the "victims" where they explain that it's not a big deal.

But I'm disapointed, I thought you would launch into a "leave brittney alone"-esque explanation of how it was worse than the gulags.

No, it is just that people know that the police will not protect them and that they do not care about the law. The suitable reference was when the KKK was harrassing and killing civil rights workers. The law didn't care about those violations of rights either.
 
I.e. to make not only your own workers redundant but also those of the competition:This is definitely truth in advertising.

You are?! I'm not, since it's very easy to confuse technological innovation with its purpose in capitalism.

Not at all. Look at steam trains vs diesel trains. The steam trains had much more highly skilled maintnence and operation requirements, so it was wrong to switch to diesel trains for ecconomic reasons, because it cost people jobs.

All technological shifts cause changes in jobs that results in the loss of specific jobs.

With more rational conditions of production the introduction of more efficient would enable workers to produce more, consume more and have more spare time on their hands. Instead they lose their jobs altogether, and with their jobs they lose their income, and with the competition from the unemployed, the few remaining workers are easier to pressure into working more instead of lightening the burden of work.

It lets them do the first too, as it makes more jobs skilled. And americans tend to favor more money and consuming more as opposed to more time off.

By the way, I am never amazed that whenever people argue against the purpose of capitalist production and innovation, they are met with the strawman: "Luddites!" Apparently Luddites are not the only ones who like to confuse things ...

You are against change that will cause people to loose their jobs, as this is all significant change it seems a position of a lack of change is exactly what you want.

Look at the old days when a computer was a woman, the introduction of electronic computers destroyed the jobs of people who did nothing but add numbers all day long. Spreadsheets used to employ many people, not they are a program on a computer and it employs no one.


It is a necessity of capitalism, not of nature or technology:

It is the nature of improvements in technology. With the loss of steam trains what do all the pipefitters, boiler makers and so on that were part of their building and maintnence do now?
 
Not at all. Look at steam trains vs diesel trains. The steam trains had much more highly skilled maintnence and operation requirements, so it was wrong to switch to diesel trains for ecconomic reasons, because it cost people jobs.

All technological shifts cause changes in jobs that results in the loss of specific jobs.

Yes, due to the purpose of the "technological shifts", not due to the technology. It is a necessity of capitalism.

It lets them do the first too, as it makes more jobs skilled. And americans tend to favor more money and consuming more as opposed to more time off.

Which is why so many of them have more than one job, I guess. This is a question of poverty, not choice.

You are against change that will cause people to lose their jobs, as this is all significant change it seems a position of a lack of change is exactly what you want.

Because you appear to be unable to understand any other change than the one an employer introduces in order to save expenses.

Look at the old days when a computer was a woman, the introduction of electronic computers destroyed the jobs of people who did nothing but add numbers all day long. Spreadsheets used to employ many people, no they are a program on a computer and it employs no one.

What is your point?

It is the nature of improvements in technology.

No, it isn't. It is the nature of improvements in technology in capitalism!
See earlier post.


With the loss of steam trains what do all the pipefitters, boiler makers and so on that were part of their building and maintenance do now?

Decompose? :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom