Neanderthals & humans interbred

That is very cool.

Because I don't know enough about DNA research and genes and so forth, I'll ask a dumb question.

Is there a way to know yet what contributions these Neandertal genes made? In other words, were Eurasian humans taller, shorter, stronger, weaker, disease resistant, etc. (probably in some extremely subtle ways) because they had these genes?

I'm curious what difference there would be in a person with 1-4% of these genes, compared to a person who had none. What would we have been like if our distance ancestors hadn't interbred?

As I understand it, the only population of modern humans now known to have bred with neanderthals was the one that left Africa via the Middle East and went on to populate Eurasia and Australasia. Neanderthal genes are not present in humans from sub-Saharan Africa, so I suppose the answer to your question is: 'not much'.
 
Oops just realized I put "neanderthals" instead of "neandertals" in the headline. Sorry for the typo guys!

I'm pretty sure it's spelled either way. Notice the headline of your USA today article: "Neanderthals and humans interbred, fossils indicate."
 
Really appreciated you posting this Cat. Saved me the time of Googling for these links, which I will post elsewhere and credit you as the source. Thanks! :)
I sincerely doubt Schrodinger's Cat was the source of the Neanderthal genes.
Ya think?? :jaw-dropp But how can we know for sure without opening the box?
cheshire.gif
And of course if SC was the source of the Neanderthal genes, not just the links, does this indicate some kind of recursive time travel a la Escher? :boggled:

I remember a study done-seems it was in the last year but perhaps further back-that resulted in a conjecture that Neandertals lost out to our ancestors because they had bigger brains. That there was a correlation between brain size and the length of time required before offspring could begin to reproduce, and basically we won the war of the bed-cave.

Did a GA-search on this but couldn't find it. If any here remember this article/study and could post a link it would be much appreciated. Help a search challenged old man up the digital stairway? :confused: :)
 
That is very cool.

Because I don't know enough about DNA research and genes and so forth, I'll ask a dumb question.

Is there a way to know yet what contributions these Neandertal genes made? In other words, were Eurasian humans taller, shorter, stronger, weaker, disease resistant, etc. (probably in some extremely subtle ways) because they had these genes?

I'm curious what difference there would be in a person with 1-4% of these genes, compared to a person who had none. What would we have been like if our distance ancestors hadn't interbred?

Bigger brains?

http://www.pnas.org/content/103/48/18178.abstract?loc=interstitialskip
 
So, so far,

We have Homo sapiens arising in Africa, modern African races are largely descended from this stock and show no neanderthal influence - they're pure H. sapiens. A few lineages left Africa and fairly early on crossbred with H. neanderthalensis, producing a bunch of neanderthal half-breeds from which the rest of humanity is descended. And in the process they picked up genes which made their brains bigger than the pure H. sapiens lineages.

Is it just me, or is this likely to upset ... just about everybody?
 
That is very cool.

Because I don't know enough about DNA research and genes and so forth, I'll ask a dumb question.

Is there a way to know yet what contributions these Neandertal genes made? In other words, were Eurasian humans taller, shorter, stronger, weaker, disease resistant, etc. (probably in some extremely subtle ways) because they had these genes?

I'm curious what difference there would be in a person with 1-4% of these genes, compared to a person who had none. What would we have been like if our distance ancestors hadn't interbred?

This was the main topic on Science Friday today on NPR. The show also included an archaeologist knowledgeable about Neanderthal interactions with modern humans, and it was a fairly nice example of scientists being able to admit that they might be wrong. Basically, the archaeologist said that he trusted the geneticist to know what he was doing, but that there was no archaeological evidence to support the timeline. Ira seemed to want to start an argument between them, oddly enough... It's worth a listen if you're interested in this sort of thing. I'm having trouble finding the link, perhaps it hasn't been released yet for download.

The researcher who was on the show indicated that they really didn't know what the particular bits of DNA that had been inherited did, or whether they conferred any particular advantage or were merely retained by chance.

Apparently there are only a few sites in our genomes where there are major differences between populations in Africa and outside of Africa. From what the researcher said, of 12 of these 10 matched the Neanderthal closely. I don't know if they only tested 12 sites or if there simply aren't any more known regions in which the populations difference substantially. Just a point that was made that I found interesting.
 
I was about to start a thread on this, but I'm glad others here beat me to the punch. An amazing article!

Michael
 
Apparently there are only a few sites in our genomes where there are major differences between populations in Africa and outside of Africa. From what the researcher said, of 12 of these 10 matched the Neanderthal closely. I don't know if they only tested 12 sites or if there simply aren't any more known regions in which the populations difference substantially. Just a point that was made that I found interesting.

I'm curious what they find out on this. It would be so cool to think that my father's blue eyes (which I didn't inherit) were a lingering bit of DNA from some Neandertal, or something like that. Like watching a wild turkey run across a field and thinking I'm seeing the living offspring of a dinosaur running by. I know it's not that simple, but still...

When is the Stephen Spielburg movie about Neandertals and Homo sapiens sapiens going to be coming out? :D
 
I've often wondered why cro magnon men and neanderthals couldn't get along. Was there not enough game to go around? Actually it always seemed to me that a Neanderthal man or woman would be nice to have with you on a hunt. I'm surprised that evidence hasn't been found of Neanderthals and cro magnons cohabiting the same cave.
 
I've often wondered why cro magnon men and neanderthals couldn't get along. Was there not enough game to go around? Actually it always seemed to me that a Neanderthal man or woman would be nice to have with you on a hunt. I'm surprised that evidence hasn't been found of Neanderthals and cro magnons cohabiting the same cave.

It's all explained in John Grant's "Littlenose" series.


:)
 
I wonder if that discovery might also change the way paleoanthropologists are looking at the Neanderthals in terms of tool use and art. There have been some hilarious attempts at explaining neanderthal skills away by means of "they probably stole that from sapiens".
 
I'm not buying it. They've got no way to define some genes as human genes and some as Neanderthal genes, the amount of our DNA that they're claiming is from Neanderthals is greater than the amount that has previously been said to vary between one modern human race and another, and a handful of earlier genetic studies contradict it, including not only a direct comparison between the two groups but also some assessments of the modern population's diversity which found that we lack genes dating back to within the right time frame.
 
I'm not buying it. They've got no way to define some genes as human genes and some as Neanderthal genes, the amount of our DNA that they're claiming is from Neanderthals is greater than the amount that has previously been said to vary between one modern human race and another, and a handful of earlier genetic studies contradict it, including not only a direct comparison between the two groups but also some assessments of the modern population's diversity which found that we lack genes dating back to within the right time frame.

Do you have a link to those earlier studies? I tried googling it but all I could find was the most recent study in the OP. Thanks in advance!

"They've got no way to define some genes as human genes and some as Neanderthal genes"

The link to science in the OP talks about methodology and gene sequencing techniques.

However, a valid point of contention is that humans are typically thought to differ genetically from eachother only by 1% of our DNA, but this study states 1-4% of Eurasian DNA comes from Neandertals.

But those numbers are not absolute. A few years ago, it was commonly cited that humans were 99.9% identical, but a study in the journal Nature showed that this number was actually too high and humans were significantly more varied than previously thought (about 99% I believe). And that number is not absolute either.

See the study below:

"Global variation in copy number in the human genome"


http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v444/n7118/full/nature05329.html


So considering that humans are thought to be at LEAST 1% different and possibly more, and the findings in this study say that Eurasians inherited 1-4% of their genes from neandertals, these numbers do not necessarily conflict with eachother when accounting for margins of error.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom