Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

I've been in silver since 2000, with an average basis slightly over five bucks.

Good for you, but I don't see how that's possible:

Silver-Chart-10-yr.jpg


Unless you really loaded up early on 2000 to 2003.

I've been sporadically investing in silver since the mid-'80's, and my average basis is closer to $10.
 
...... I have > 10,000oz of silver....

I know that you have a major gain but a $200,000+ paper "loss" gotta hurt, my condolences.

Then again, unless you have a recklessly unbalanced portfolio, the $320,000+ you have invested in silver is a tiny proportion of your multi-million dollar net worth.
 
I know that you have a major gain but a $200,000+ paper "loss" gotta hurt, my condolences.

Thanks. I'm not too worried about the future of silver (or any of the precious metals) though. I could have just as easily sold it arbitrarily at $50 only to watch it advance from there. Hindsight is always 20-20. I am looking at picking up some more SLW though, so it's an opportunity.
 
I didn't even consider selling at this supposed "peak".
Is that because you have no significant position to sell?

I'm not seeing any sort of a bubble in gold prices at this time. Silver, quite possibly.
Silver is unreasonably high right now because it was being touted about 6 months ago as an alternative to gold which was being said to be overpriced.

Is trying to imply that you have a substantial long silver exposure now another of your fabricated trades? You don't lie well enough. :D:D
 
Last edited:
The next time I sell my silver it will be for food and shelter, not dollars.

I hope you'll be holding your silver for a very long time indeed, I suspect you will.

I hope that if you have to try to sell your silver (yike !) there's still a market for it in exchange for food and shelter. If things go that badly, silver may be comparatively useless and indentured labour may be the only freely exchangeable currency. Or guns, guns and ammo.
 
Thanks. I'm not too worried about the future of silver (or any of the precious metals) though. I could have just as easily sold it arbitrarily at $50 only to watch it advance from there. Hindsight is always 20-20. I am looking at picking up some more SLW though, so it's an opportunity.
Sure, but I'm reminded of the almost certainly fictitious quote from a very rich person who attributed their great wealth to selling too soon.
 
Is that because you have no significant position to sell?

Is trying to imply that you have a substantial long silver exposure now another of your fabricated trades? You don't lie well enough. :D:D
Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for rule 11.
Your contrived argument links do not support this, and nothing I've said does. You have an Argument to Nowhere.

Using a straight out Saul Alinksy tactic "personalize the discussion, pin your opponent" like this in a discussion on financial matters is well, weird. Not to mention it would get you thrown out of any actual discussion on these types of subjects.

FYI I find this not offensive, but pitiful.

All because I asked a still unanswered question "How those bonds and T bills doing, Fran?" Let me help you ladle that crow soup:

Jim Rogers to Short Treasuries and Buy Silver
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I hope you'll be holding your silver for a very long time indeed, I suspect you will.

I hope that if you have to try to sell your silver (yike !) there's still a market for it in exchange for food and shelter. If things go that badly, silver may be comparatively useless and indentured labour may be the only freely exchangeable currency. Or guns, guns and ammo.
This is largely a fantasy economic scenario. I say this because of the many past economic crises these things you mention did not come to pass. Here are three recent (of approximately a hundred) examples from Wikipedia.

Russian Federation
In 1992, the first year of post-Soviet economic reform, inflation was 2,520%. In 1993, the annual rate was 840%, and in 1994, 224%. The ruble devalued from about 40 r/$ in 1991 to about 5,000 r/$ in late 1997. In 1998, a denominated ruble was introduced at the exchange rate of 1 new ruble = 1,000 pre-1998 rubles. In the second half of the same year, ruble fell to about 30 r/$ as a result of financial crisis.
​
Argentina
At the beginning of 1975, the highest denomination was 1,000 pesos. In late 1976, the highest denomination was 5,000 pesos. In early 1979, the highest denomination was 10,000 pesos. By the end of 1981, the highest denomination was 1,000,000 pesos. In the 1983 currency reform, 1 Peso argentino was exchanged for 10,000 pesos. In the 1985 currency reform, 1 austral was exchanged for 1,000 pesos argentinos. In the 1992 currency reform, 1 new peso was exchanged for 10,000 australes. The overall impact of hyperinflation: 1 (1992) peso = 100,000,000,000 pre-1983 pesos.
​
Brazil
From 1986-1994, the base currency unit was shifted three times to adjust for inflation in the final years of the Brazilian military dictatorship era. A 1967 cruzeiro was, in 1994, worth less than one trillionth of a US cent, after adjusting for multiple devaluations and note changes. In that same year, inflation reached a record 2075.8%. A new currency called real was adopted in 1994, and hyperinflation was eventually brought under control.
​
Remember that severe or hyper inflation a theft of the REMAINING wealth of the common people, and it's transfer to certain people and government operations. It does not matter that the remaining wealth is continuously decreasing, this does not stem the appetite which remains relatively constant.

Generally, the evidence shows that governments do not learn from history, and in severe inflation they repeat the same mistakes other governments made - Price and wage controls, starting a "new improved currency", blaming the greedy capitalists.

Incidentally, the way that Brazil fixed it's problem was to make it a felony to loan money to the Brazilian government.

I am not saying that guns or ammo may not be good investments, incidentally....as for the "indentured labor" part....hmmmm.....
 
Last edited:
Remember that severe or hyper inflation a theft of the REMAINING wealth of the common people, and it's transfer to certain people and government operations. It does not matter that the remaining wealth is continuously decreasing, this does not stem the appetite which remains relatively constant.

Why should I remember something which is a complete fantasy on your part ?

Admittedly, people who have cash savings in the local currency will lose out, but anyone who owes money will benefit.

You make hyperinflation sound like a deliberate conspiracy as opposed to the results of financial mis-management.

Someone who is concerned about the fragility of the dollar perhaps should move aslo some of their assets into harder currencies like the Euro, Yuan, Rupee rather than just stick with the one currency.

My meagre savings for example are spread across US Dollars, Euro, Pounds and Aussie Dollars
 
Sure, but I'm reminded of the almost certainly fictitious quote from a very rich person who attributed their great wealth to selling too soon.

I think one of the biggest mistakes investors make, is ignoring the power of compound growth. They do this by selling whenever they have a profit, regardless of the underlying fundamentals, thereby creating a taxable event. It's just as important to have a good, fundamental reason to sell as it is to buy. This applies to holding on to losers as well. It's also good to avoid churning your own accounts and paying excessive capital gains taxes and commissions.

I liken monday morning quarterbacks to those people in Vegas who criticize the blackjack play of the player on the anchor. They scowl and give the anchor a dirty look if he takes a card that otherwise would have busted the dealer, sometimes even if the anchor played his hand in accordance with basic strat, or how the critic would have played it. Yet those players never seem to notice when the bad play of an anchor results in a dealer bust. I guess the moral is, the future is mostly unknowable, so just play the game to the best of your ability.
 
Your contrived argument links do not support this, and nothing I've said does. [ . . . ]
I beg to differ. How can you claim silver is unreasonably high and possibly in a bubble in late April and then expect to be believed that you were significantly long right after that? Similarly how can anyone take seriously your claim to have bought gold in June 2009 when you were claiming back then that a correction was definitely in order?

The evidence, posted by yourself, rather makes it look like you are inventing false trades in a futile attempt to appear prescient. Perhaps to draw attention away from your extremely vacuous contributions to discussion.

But you got caught. Twice. So it looks like a most desperate endeavour on your part. You're right about finding it pitiful.

:D
 
Last edited:
As an ignorant commodities person and lurker of this thread since the beginning I have a question.

First of all I would like to thank all sides for their contribuitions to the thread..its been a good read.

My question about silver and inflation is this: Is purchasing silver a hedge against inflation such that when the dollar's value decreases silvers value will remain constant against inflation? In Mhaze's examples above inflation of 1000% or more I'm assuming that my $1.00 that buys me a candy bar now will take $1,000 at some future point, but that if I have $1.00 of silver I still can buy my candy bar after the 1000% inflation?

If this is true than I was thinking that any commodity that I purchase would be a hedge against inflation as a $1.00 in oil now would still be a $1.00 of oil after inflation and still get me my candy bar.

This brings me to my second question I guess..why silver than? Portable? Accepted as money eaiser? Other?

Thanks.
 
In a very contentions thread on $1,500 gold, I posted the following after some opined that precious metals were never a good inflation hedge:


(As a reducto ad absurdo analogy, let me play fast and loose with the numbers - it's the concept and not the particulars that matter).

Two citizens of Germany in early 1923 are given a choice in payment types for services rendered. One accepts a paper mark, the other takes a silver coin worth one mark.

Then this happens:

weimar_hyperinflation2.gif




At the end of the year, both are thirsty for a bottle of wine. They go to a wine shop. A bottle of wine had sold for one mark a year ago, but no longer. The one with a paper mark is told he's short about 999,999,999 marks, and is offered the use of a wheelbarrow if he wants to try to round up that much. The other fellow presents the silver mark coin. The shopkeeper knows the value of the silver in a silver mark coin, and trades the fellow a bottle of wine for the coin.

This seems clear and obvious on the surface. I'd say the fellow that took the silver mark successfully "hedged" against inflation. What applies in times of hyperinflation would be true to a lesser extent in times of humdrum inflation - as we've seen in the price of gold and silver over the recent past.
 
There's no way to tell which commodity will outperform (or underperform) which.

Using your oil example, suppose that tomorrow a process utilizing cold fusion for all our energy needs is announced. The value of oil might be decimated.

But, yes, any commodity can serve as a store of value. Precious metals are simply one convenient way - certainly less of a hassle than pork bellies, let's say!

I don't know if I mentioned it in this thread already, but I was a teenager in 1964 when the silver was taken out of US coinage. Prior to that, you could walk into any bank and buy a roll of 20 silver dollars for $20, or equivalents in quarters and dimes. My dad thought the people lining up to buy those coins before the transition were crazy. Of course, there are investments that might have done better since 1964 (a new Corvette bought for about $4,000 and stored away in Cosmoline would be worth a pretty penny now as well!), but those who bought coins then and stashed them away have certainly hedged against inflation.
 
In a very contentions thread on $1,500 gold, I posted the following after some opined that precious metals were never a good inflation hedge:


(As a reducto ad absurdo analogy, let me play fast and loose with the numbers - it's the concept and not the particulars that matter).

Two citizens of Germany in early 1923 are given a choice in payment types for services rendered. One accepts a paper mark, the other takes a silver coin worth one mark.

Then this happens:

http://www.thepeoplesvoice.org/cgi-bin/blogs/media/weimar_hyperinflation2.gif



At the end of the year, both are thirsty for a bottle of wine. They go to a wine shop. A bottle of wine had sold for one mark a year ago, but no longer. The one with a paper mark is told he's short about 999,999,999 marks, and is offered the use of a wheelbarrow if he wants to try to round up that much. The other fellow presents the silver mark coin. The shopkeeper knows the value of the silver in a silver mark coin, and trades the fellow a bottle of wine for the coin.

This seems clear and obvious on the surface. I'd say the fellow that took the silver mark successfully "hedged" against inflation. What applies in times of hyperinflation would be true to a lesser extent in times of humdrum inflation - as we've seen in the price of gold and silver over the recent past.

Sure, it's a hedge against hyperinflation of a single currency. But, the claim is inflation, not hyperinflation.

And that is where it falls flat. For example, gold went from $850 in 1980 to $256 in 2001, but consumer prices doubled in the same period. You can find other periods where consumer went up 30% or so and gold went up 8x or so. There is no correlation in recent history over time periods of 1-3 decades, our normal long term investment horizon.
 
Sure, it's a hedge against hyperinflation of a single currency. But, the claim is inflation, not hyperinflation.

Have we had hyperinflation between 1964 and the present?

I remember cigarettes being $1.99 a CARTON! In general, prices are up about tenfold, or more, since then.

Someone who squirreled away a bunch of silver at $1/oz did OK, be it inflation or hyperinflation.

And I think being in metals is an OK strategy as part of a balanced portfolio
 
I beg to differ. How can you claim silver is unreasonably high and possibly in a bubble in late April and then expect to be believed that you were significantly long right after that? Similarly how can anyone take seriously your claim to have bought gold in June 2009 when you were claiming back then that a correction was definitely in order?

The evidence, posted by yourself, rather makes it look like you are inventing false trades in a futile attempt to appear prescient. Perhaps to draw attention away from your extremely vacuous contributions to discussion.

But you got caught. Twice. So it looks like a most desperate endeavour on your part. You're right about finding it pitiful.

:D

Nope. You don't have evidence. You have an inferences from cherry picked comments of mine, and you've ignored scope. You've ignored, or made up relevant investment timeframes to support your pre existing convictions. In short, you have created a delusion, and then proceeded to believe it, and post about it.

You've asserted that the sum of these inferences (which occur inside your brain) add up to lying on my part. This is indicative of problems you have, not of lying on my part. I've addressed this before, and don't really understand why you have gone on a personal attack mode when I just simply asked

"How are those Treasury Bills doing, Fran? I know how those metals I bought are doing"

And in fairness, I didn't mention the exact composition of investments I made 2 years ago. So metals could have been 1%, or 100% of those placements. So your comment:

The evidence, posted by yourself, rather makes it look like you are inventing false trades in a futile attempt to appear prescient.


Does not have any basis in reality except if and to what extent it applies singularly to the comparative statement:

"How are those Treasury Bills doing, Fran? I know how those metals I bought are doing"

But your going on the offensive ad hominem, junior high school mode when faced with this question, instead of simply answering it....which you have never done....is quite telling.

And oh, by the way...your mental acumen in this assertion:

Similarly how can anyone take seriously your claim to have bought gold ....

Really is laughable. Here is why. Some people might not take a claim seriously. So what....they don't go accuse the other person of lying.

You do.

And in the doing of it, you've shown unsupported, emotional, and ill logical work. Meanwhile....

"How are those Treasury Bills doing, Fran? I know how those metals I bought are doing"

:)
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
Remember that severe or hyper inflation a theft of the REMAINING wealth of the common people, and it's transfer to certain people and government operations. It does not matter that the remaining wealth is continuously decreasing, this does not stem the appetite which remains relatively constant.



Why should I remember something which is a complete fantasy on your part ?

Admittedly, people who have cash savings in the local currency will lose out, but anyone who owes money will benefit.

You make hyperinflation sound like a deliberate conspiracy as opposed to the results of financial mis-management.

Someone who is concerned about the fragility of the dollar perhaps should move aslo some of their assets into harder currencies like the Euro, Yuan, Rupee rather than just stick with the one currency.

My meagre savings for example are spread across US Dollars, Euro, Pounds and Aussie Dollars

I'm actually not sure how to answer this. You started in the prior post talking about putting money into guns and ammo....now you are talking about multiple currencies. But you say I'm the one making hyperinflation sound like a deliberate conspiracy....while you are the one talking about guns and ammo?

:confused:

I'm not even sure why you'd think a conspiracy was required...a government thinks it needs 1000 units of value every year, and it has the ability to print money so it prints each year, sufficient paper to get the 1000 units of value. The fact that the value in the paper decreases geometrically is simply a numerical reality.

No conspiracy is required.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom