Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Thanks!

So, where is the paper that Sunstealer published?
I don't know where is the paper that Sunstealer published. I know where is the paper that Harrit, Jones et al. published. It turns out to be a vanity publisher that accepts any articles to those who pay. It turns out the editor-in-chief was not informed of the publication and she felt stabbed in the back. It turns out the publisher is infamous in the scientific world for the low quality of the publications it produces. Sunstealer's publication in this forum is on par with the scientific guarantees provided by Bentham. Maybe more: Sunstealer is specialized in materials science, and therefore qualified to identify the material in question; none of the authors of the paper published in Bentham was.

It turns out the paper is full of methodological errors which you have not cared to even attempt to address (which was the topic of this thread in the first place). Where did they compare the samples to the Tnemec primer used to protect the WTC steel? Where is a calorimetric test in absence of oxygen? Where is a categorization of the chips instead of treating them all as the same thing, despite the clear differences in the spectra and shape (see figs. 11 and 14 and photographs 2 and 31)? What are the elements missing in fig. 15? Why do they say it's thermite if the energy density does not correspond to that of thermite? And so and so on...

The only person who was allowed access to the samples for corroboration, a truther too, found no traces of active thermitic material. At best, this debunks their claims that the dust contains high quantities of such active material. To me, it proves that the authors neglected to check the presence of iron microspheres prior to the burning in the samples that went through DSC (which we don't know where they came from as there is no categorization of chips as stated above, but figure 21 proves it's not the same thing as the ones in Fig. 11).
 
If I may, I would like to point out something very wrong in the Jones, harrit, et al paper, Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center Catastrophe. He has a DSC trace of the red/grey chips, soaked in MEK (figure 29) in which he claims the peak to be thermite of some sort. However, 460C just happens to be the autoignition temperature of the methylethylketone.
I am sorry if this is already well known, there is just too much to go through to find out.
Good catch, and it certainly goes along with what a lot of other people with a semblance of competence have said before. The DSC results actually disprove the existence of thermite. Welcome to the forums, by the way.

Actually, no, that is not a good catch. The premise is wrong: The chips whose DSC trace is repeated in fig. 29 is one of the 4 chips plotted earlier in fig. 19, and is NOT the chip that was soaked in MEK.
Besides, ignition point of that sample was slightly below 460°C.
However, in that range, many common organic materials autoignite. For example many resins used for paints. Since we know from Harrit and Co. that their anorganic stuff in the red layer was embedded in an organic matrix, and since we know that the hematite they found is a very common pigment and that the kaolinite they found is a very common ingredient of paints, it stands to reason that indeed a resin, or similar stuff, burned in that DSC, and not a solvent.
 
The refutation is in Harrit's paper. There is no further refutation necessary.

While terse, this is quite literally true. And it's also what Sunstealer had been pointing out all along: The data disproves the conclusion the authors drew. The X-EDS spectra and maps, in conjunction with the scanning electron micrography, rather clearly shows the presence of kaolin and the absence of free aluminum. The refutation to Jones's and Harrit's claims are, quite literally, in the pages before their conclusions.
 
While terse, this is quite literally true. And it's also what Sunstealer had been pointing out all along: The data disproves the conclusion the authors drew. The X-EDS spectra and maps, in conjunction with the scanning electron micrography, rather clearly shows the presence of kaolin and the absence of free aluminum. The refutation to Jones's and Harrit's claims are, quite literally, in the pages before their conclusions.

Didn't they also prove that the substance emitted more energy than therm*te could theoretically release?
 
Didn't they also prove that the substance emitted more energy than therm*te could theoretically release?

Yeah, but they attempted a handwave of an excuse: That the supposed sol-gel binder burnt and was the cause of the energy surplus.

Or in short, they admitted the flaw, but pretended it wasn't one. :rolleyes:

And oddly enough, that excuse is potentially contradicted by their data too: There's only a single exotherm on the calorimeter graph. While (as some here have pointed out to be fair) this could simply mean that two reactions did indeed occur, and one just happened to touch off another, the other explanation is that there was only one, single reaction. And in the context of knowing what was available to burn and what wasn't, I'd personally have to say that the latter is far more likely.

Pseudoscience. That's what the Bentham paper was. Or more accurately, Cargo Cult Science: The superficial rituals of science carried out without the deeper understanding, all to achieve a specific end.
 
While terse, this is quite literally true. And it's also what Sunstealer had been pointing out all along: The data disproves the conclusion the authors drew. ... The X-EDS spectra and maps, in conjunction with the scanning electron micrography, rather clearly shows the presence of kaolin and the absence of free aluminum[/URL]. The refutation to Jones's and Harrit's claims are, quite literally, in the pages before their conclusions.

I am very familar with Sunstealer's efforts, he did a great job!

The problem with Harrits paper is that there are lots of contradictions and some unanswered questions:

1. Why are the chips magnetic? You cannot explain this property on the basis of the presented data.

2. Why are temperatures greater than 3000°C necessary to ignite chips that react violently at 430°C?

3. Why differs the morphology of the investigated chips from the morphology of the nanothermite that was prepared by Gash?

4. In Fig. 21 and Fig. 25 two EDX spectra of DSC residues are depicted. Both spectra differ quite a lot. How can this be explained? Harrit claims that the chips are very similar in their chemical setup and that the reaction conditions were similar, too.

5. What is the composition of the organic part of the chips? It's very astonishing that an organic chemist doesn't examine the residue of the MEK test (NMR or FTIR).
 
The refutation is in Harrit's paper. There is no further refutation necessary.
Yep, the data speaks for itself. Ergo hasn't got the knowledge or experience to make an informed decision nor argue against any points in a refutation.

The paper is trash, easily the worst scientific paper I've ever read by a large margin. Undergraduates would be ashamed of writing such rubbish. The authors haven't continued the work most likely because there's no mileage in it.

8. What Future Studies are Contemplated?

We observe that the total energy released from some of
the red chips exceeds the theoretical limit for thermite alone
(3.9 kJ/g). One possibility is that the organic material in the
red layer is itself energetic. Determination of the chemical
compound(s) involved in the organic component of the red
material would promote understanding. Further studies of the
red material (separated from the gray material) compared to
known super-thermite variants using DSC, TGA, FTIR (etc.)
analyses would certainly be in order. In particular, NMR and
GC-mass spectroscopy and related studies are urged to identify
the organic material.

We have observed that some chips have additional elements
such as potassium, lead, barium and copper. Are these
significant, and why do such elements appear in some red
chips and not others? An example is shown in Fig. (31)
which shows significant Pb along with C, O, Fe, and Al and
displays multiple red and gray layers.

In addition, the gray-layer material demands further
study. What is its purpose? Sometimes the gray material appears
in multiple layers, as seen in Fig. (32).
Has any of this vitally important work ever been carried out?

Now I've read that again I'm falling about laughing. What's the purpose of the mysterious gray layer? Wooooo. Find out after the break as we enter the twighlight zone. Harrit et al hadn't got a clue, they were stumbling around in the dark.
 
You can also tell that they had next to no experience in materials characterisation from Oystein's post here http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7161801&postcount=593

The fact that they had to perform further testing to confirm hematite when a quick visit to wiki (or JREF a couple of days after publishing) would have confirmed it in 5 minutes, shows they had no idea - it's so obvious it's amazing they didn't know.

How anyone falls for the claptrap I don't know.
 
JOnesy et al: "One possibility is that the organic material in the red layer is itself energetic."

Is there any organic material that is NOT energetic??
 
JOnesy et al: "One possibility is that the organic material in the red layer is itself energetic."

Is there any organic material that is NOT energetic??

Nope. Any organic material will combust with oxygen to produce carbon dioxide and water, quite possibly with something left over. Some are more energetic than others, but this reaction is always possible by definition.
 
Now I've read that again I'm falling about laughing. What's the purpose of the mysterious gray layer? Wooooo. Find out after the break as we enter the twighlight zone. Harrit et al hadn't got a clue, they were stumbling around in the dark.

Remember on the Jesse Ventura show when Jones said that when painted onto steel nano thermite becomes a high explosive?

Oh lol!
 
I was reading some of henryco's analysis the other week.

http://www.darksideofgravity.com/redreds.pdf

He's got red/red chips which I think that means just red flakes with no other layer - his methodology and analysis is poor - there's no comparison with data in the harrit paper.

Anyway he claims to have heated these red/red chips to 800/900°C and found that the carbon was being burnt. i.e. less carbon in the spectra post heating.
 
The real question is, why wasn't it the first thing they did? :cool:
Exactly. You would also want confirmation from an independent lab before announcing such an "explosive" discovery. They still won't do that - I think they know that they'd be exposed if they did.
 
Exactly. You would also want confirmation from an independent lab before announcing such an "explosive" discovery. They still won't do that - I think they know that they'd be exposed if they did.

From a scientific viewpoint, the work is woefully incomplete (and incompetently executed as well), but I don't see science and discovery as having been their goals to begin with. The point of the work was to give conspiracy addicts something legitimate looking to use. From a conspiracy peddler's point of view, mission accomplished.

The whole point was never to really, truly identify the chips. They already knew what they wanted to say the chips were. Rather, the goal was to create suspicions, and make conspiracy fantasy look marginally legitimate. Because of that, this work is already a finished product; all that remains is the proselytization of it.

Of course, Sunstealer knows this; I'm just "thinking out loud" for the benefit of other readers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom