Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

Returns since the OP:

-28% real return. -37% annualised return.
Those figures are correct if you take the peak price in April as the base.

More accurately, the price today is about the same as it was 12 months ago. (That was when a relative advised me to buy silver. I'm rather relieved that I didn't miss out on a massive profit after all).

The worst you could say about silver is that it was in a bubble in 2011.
 
Those figures are correct if you take the peak price in April as the base.

More accurately, the price today is about the same as it was 12 months ago. (That was when a relative advised me to buy silver. I'm rather relieved that I didn't miss out on a massive profit after all).

The worst you could say about silver is that it was in a bubble in 2011.

these types always pick the the top of the previous or best peak to compare to, it's Numpty SOPs
 
these types always pick the the top of the previous or best peak to compare to, it's Numpty SOPs
To be fair, stilicho correctly pointed out that the price of silver fell after michaelsuede (that's not you is it? ;)) predicted the price would continue rising and he didn't say it was about the you know who.
 
To be fair, stilicho correctly pointed out that the price of silver fell after michaelsuede (that's not you is it? ;)) predicted the price would continue rising and he didn't say it was about the you know who.

lol no michaelsuede isn't me, not Tippit, nor anyone else, I have but just one user ID on this board.

and if he didn't mention the youknowwhos in this post I'm sure he will again shortly
 
Sprott back in the market, up 12% in 10 days, touched $33.92 in trading, closed at $33.80, ..the slingshot cometh..?

When asked about his latest PSLV offering, Sprott stated, “We closed on $349 million. The underwriters did exercise the over-allotment in rather short order. We have committed to purchase it (silver). I think the deal was very successful. Obviously the premium has come down here (on PSLV), but it’s typically traded at a 16% premium and right now it’s at 8%. It takes a little while to digest the stock that was issued, but I’m hopeful we will get back to where we were.

There’s been a big move since we did the issue....

“We’ve all heard the reports that it’s pretty tight (in terms of supply). Every data point I see suggests people and institutions want to buy silver in the same dollar amount as they are buying gold.

We see the US Mint has sold 5.6 million ounces so far in January and I’m sure they will have a record high month. We’re selling as many dollars of silver coins as we are gold coins by the mint, which means we are selling 50 times more physical volume of silver. The availability (of silver to gold) is 7 to 1 in physical, but people are buying it at like 50 to 1. So something has to give there.

I would love to share with your viewers I was speaking with a company, this is a gold company, who is trying to organize a dividend payment being made in gold or silver and/or cash. Apparently 60% of the people (asked) were opting for the precious metal and half of those agreed to take it in silver. Again, another confirmation of silver buying. Our last tranche (in PSLV) we raised $349 million. Our last tranche in gold we raised $312 million. Again, one to one buying, so I’m pretty upbeat about where silver should be going.

As you know I always thought we would go back to the 16 to 1 ratio to gold, which means based on today’s prices silver should be $100. I really do believe silver was going to blow through $50 back in April/May when, all of the sudden, margin rate increases came through and one billion ounces of paper silver was sold that day.

I’m of the feeling that it will go back through $50 this year. Once it goes through $50 I think it could take on a whole new life and really energize itself. Longer-term my target is 16 to 1 to gold and I’m very upbeat on gold. I’m sure gold is going north of $2,000 this year, so obviously silver can get up to $150 in due course.”

When asked if there has been traction with regards to his call to silver companies to hold physical silver instead of cash, Sprott replied, “There has been traction. One company, Endeavor Silver, only sold 1/3 of their output in the December quarter because they thought the price was being depressed. They decided to wait and sell it at a different time.

We did have one silver producer actually participate in the PSLV (offering), which was very encouraging to me. I think we’re making a little bit of momentum on that front. Of course, I’ve given lots of chats to silver producers about what I think has gone on in the silver market. I think we’re making some progress.”
 
Sprott back in the market, up 12% in 10 days, touched $33.92 in trading, closed at $33.80, ..the slingshot cometh..?

Maybe, it is still a few months away from May.

Besides, I question Sprott's "It's hard to buy silver" stance when lately I could easily nab silver without a huge premium. Sprott's secondary offering paid at spot price, so where is this premium to justify the low supply high demand of silver?
 
Maybe, it is still a few months away from May.

Besides, I question Sprott's "It's hard to buy silver" stance when lately I could easily nab silver without a huge premium. Sprott's secondary offering paid at spot price, so where is this premium to justify the low supply high demand of silver?

presumably you are talking about nabbing smallish amounts, not large multiples of good delivery bars?

and May? hes taking about last May there?

now that the Fed have laid the groundwork for this years money printing Im pretty confident my $7x prediction wont be too far out.
 
presumably you are talking about nabbing smallish amounts, not large multiples of good delivery bars?

He has a shelf of $1.5 billion waiting for him, yet he takes a tiny fraction. Why?

and May? hes taking about last May there?

Sell in May and go away.

now that the Fed have laid the groundwork for this years money printing Im pretty confident my $7x prediction wont be too far out.

The extra circulation doesn't mean it will go straight to commodities. For all we know, it could go into investing emerging markets instead.

This is not to say I don't view silver as a bad investment, since I'll admit I have a stack of them myself, but I see it as a hedge against inflation and most importantly, increased demand for it because of emerging markets like Brazil and China. I just don't trust Sprott since a lot of his claims go against his actions. If there was a shortage as much as he says there is, he would be buying his bulk with a premium, not at spot, and he would be exercising his shelf more extensively.
 
Last edited:
He has a shelf of $1.5 billion waiting for him, yet he takes a tiny fraction. Why?
no idea, sure he knows what he's doing though.

Sell in May and go away.

this is not always infallible is it? last year in fact you needed to be selling Silver in April, it was bargain time in May, I personally was buying at $34 in May and selling at +20% in August.

The extra circulation doesn't mean it will go straight to commodities. For all we know, it could go into investing emerging markets instead.

hmm. just the merest sniff of it on Wednesday kind of indicates the contrary doesnt it, plus the evidence from the last 2 rounds shows its more likely than not IMO.

I just don't trust Sprott since a lot of his claims go against his actions.

I think he understands that he, like the central planners can affect markets with his words and plays the game to his (own fund's) benefit, to the best of his ability. higher silver prices are clearly in his interests, so as a physical stacker that puts him on my side as far as I'm concerned.

If there was a shortage as much as he says there is, he would be buying his bulk with a premium, not at spot, and he would be exercising his shelf more extensively.

is he not under legal obligation to buy at the best prices? besides which as the Sprott team have large amounts of their own money invested in their funds I'm sure they're not looking to overpay wherever possible.
 
is he not under legal obligation to buy at the best prices?

I still hold that "best prices" will only be known in retrospect.

If the latest machinations turn out to have been a final dip before silver shoots to the moon, then buying sub $30 silver would have been bought at a "best price".

Would it still be defined as such if silver had slipped to $12?

I'm shy about posting graphics, but look at some of the charts here:

http://silverprice.org/silver-price-history.html

I hold that every buyer at every point on every graph was hoping he or she was buying at the "best price". Whatever that means.

Frankly, I don't think that "best price" even means anything in a freely traded commodity.
 
no idea, sure he knows what he's doing though.

I'm sure he does, but not for the greatest of reasons.

this is not always infallible is it? last year in fact you needed to be selling Silver in April, it was bargain time in May, I personally was buying at $34 in May and selling at +20% in August.

Historically speaking it is true though, but I understand what you are saying.

hmm. just the merest sniff of it on Wednesday kind of indicates the contrary doesnt it, plus the evidence from the last 2 rounds shows its more likely than not IMO.

I'm not saying silver will be put on the sidelines, completely ignored, but silver/gold isn't the only places money can go.

I think he understands that he, like the central planners can affect markets with his words and plays the game to his (own fund's) benefit, to the best of his ability. higher silver prices are clearly in his interests, so as a physical stacker that puts him on my side as far as I'm concerned.

Well of course he is going to talk about how awesome silver is, since his career is based on selling it. When was the last time a realtor told you it was a bad time to buy a house?

is he not under legal obligation to buy at the best prices? besides which as the Sprott team have large amounts of their own money invested in their funds I'm sure they're not looking to overpay wherever possible.

Of course he is, but you are missing my point. If there was such a shortage of silver as Sprott has been claiming for ages, it would be difficult for him to grab a hefty supply of silver at spot price for his trust AND he would be trying to nab as much as possible before the supply runs out instead of taking tiny bits at a time. Many sites like Zerohedge and TFmetals claim that it is hard to nab silver without paying high premiums, while at the same time promoting Sprott who is nabbing that same silver without paying these same high premiums (while expecting people to buy his trust at, one point, 30% premiums when other places like SLV is much closer to the spot price). Like I said, his claims are different than his actions.
 
Last edited:
Of course he is, but you are missing my point. If there was such a shortage of silver as Sprott has been claiming for ages, it would be difficult for him to grab a hefty supply of silver at spot price for his trust AND he would be trying to nab as much as possible before the supply runs out instead of taking tiny bits at a time.

so if we step back up to this post

50-100 million Oz purchased for investment per annum = $1.5-$3 billion

do you think it's feasible that one investor can attempt to buy 50-100% of the annual supply of silver available for investment in one go, without spiking the price and having to pay considerably more for it? indeed if they're even allowed to, position limits, market cornering etc?

its no secret China would like a few thousand tonnes more gold, but they can hardly go to the market and just steam in with their currency reserves without affecting price can they?

how do we know he hasn't got orders in with producers to take as much as they can supply of the rest of the shelf?

Many sites like Zerohedge and TFmetals claim that it is hard to nab silver without paying high premiums, while at the same time promoting Sprott who is nabbing that same silver without paying these same high premiums (while expecting people to buy his trust at, one point, 30% premiums when other places like SLV is much closer to the spot price). Like I said, his claims are different than his actions.

the premium is what investors were/are willing to pay to know their silver is there, I don't think Sprott really expected it so high, but it shows the level of mistrust over the alternatives doesn't it?
 
do you think it's feasible that one investor can attempt to buy 50-100% of the annual supply of silver available for investment in one go, without spiking the price and having to pay considerably more for it? indeed if they're even allowed to, position limits, market cornering etc?

But Eric keeps spouting on how awesome silver is and how there is a massive shortage of it. If he has a 1.5 billion shelf, and if there is a limited supply of silver running out, why would a company that runs a closed ended physical silver trust fund be holding back on purchases of silver? And if he had no intention of exercising his shelf, why did he put it up in the first place? Finally, he can buy some shares of SLV and redeem for the physical!

Also, you have to understand the importance of a closed-end fund. SLV allows authorized participants to bring in wholesale silver to redeem it for newly created shares. PSLV only creates shares based on the manager's decision as opposed to the delivery/redeem of physical silver. Again, why?

its no secret China would like a few thousand tonnes more gold, but they can hardly go to the market and just steam in with their currency reserves without affecting price can they?

And? So you're saying Sprott should wait for his competition to buy the precious metals? That doesn't make sense.

how do we know he hasn't got orders in with producers to take as much as they can supply of the rest of the shelf?

I'll believe it when I see it. Like I said, Sprott is acting strange for someone who claims silver is the next big thing and we are running out.

the premium is what investors were/are willing to pay to know their silver is there, I don't think Sprott really expected it so high, but it shows the level of mistrust over the alternatives doesn't it?

I think he does, considering the fact that his hedge funds were holding onto a significant portion of PSLV. Think about it....if he offers a secondary offering, it would reduce the premium of the PSLV shares, therefore hindering his hedge fund's performance. Instead, the hedge fund sells them to the investors on the market place rather than holding onto it!

Also, his gold physical trust also had an interesting 20% premium at one point as well, until the secondary offerings came in.

Throw in the fact it is a closed-end fund, which means its extremely hard to short it and a good portion of the investors are going long, and of course premiums will increase over the time even to stupid levels like 30%. Throw in some stories about "cartel manipulating silver" which just happens to be your competition and well....you've seen the results.
 
Last edited:
Also, you have to understand the importance of a closed-end fund. SLV allows authorized participants to bring in wholesale silver to redeem it for newly created shares. PSLV only creates shares based on the manager's decision as opposed to the delivery/redeem of physical silver. Again, why?

I'll believe it when I see it. Like I said, Sprott is acting strange for someone who claims silver is the next big thing and we are running out.

I think he does, considering the fact that his hedge funds were holding onto a significant portion of PSLV. Think about it....if he offers a secondary offering, it would reduce the premium of the PSLV shares, therefore hindering his hedge fund's performance. Instead, the hedge fund sells them to the investors on the market place rather than holding onto it!

Also, his gold physical trust also had an interesting 20% premium at one point as well, until the secondary offerings came in.

Throw in the fact it is a closed-end fund, which means its extremely hard to short it and a good portion of the investors are going long, and of course premiums will increase over the time even to stupid levels like 30%. Throw in some stories about "cartel manipulating silver" which just happens to be your competition and well....you've seen the results.

I'll admit, I don't understand the importance of a closed trust, you appear to know more about Sprott (and his hedge fund?) than me.

did you see, and what do you think about this analysis? http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article14756.html

if we are (and we are IMO) heading into a global recession, and as silver is a byproduct in most mining operations, supply is likely to reduce along with the other base metals its mined with as global demand falls?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom