Why don´t you just answer the questions? Did you not check for yourself before you threw mud at the tests in air?
Hehe
I read "superthermite papers" cited in Bentham papers many months ago. Just... follow me.
Sometimes, authors did some "tests" even under air, since they could be sure that they had a kind of thermite.
But important in our respect is the plain fact that Harrit et al compared their DSC curves
with one single "superthermite" curve published in paper 28. And since this curve was measured
under pure nitrogen, and Gash explained in detail why in his e-mail, it was
a duty of Bentham authors to run their DSC experiments under inert as well. They did not do that, hence they
failed to follow original protocol. And all their DSC results are fully compatible with the combustion of polymer binder under air
They did perform tests on paints, which goes further than just checking papers for theoretical behavior. I agree they should have included a DSC trace for those samples to compare.
Sigh... Tests
(namely solubility tests) on unspecified paints are pretty idiotic, as I have tried to explain you several times. Some
paints (binders in them) are
insoluble, some are
soluble, some
swell to various extent in a good solvent. Bentham team provided by these tests only one info: they did not know what they were talking about
And as predicted it is possible to get curves that are close to the Bentham peaks before those epoxies are mixed with flame-retardants, but then they start to get much fatter and as you say sometimes you have multiple peaks spreading over a wide range. What we need is an epoxy paint sample, see comment below.
I mentioned that other MCC curves for other polymers than epoxy can have sometimes even two well separated peaks or can be broad. But for epoxy resins, curves I saw are pretty close to Bentham DSC curves. Some of them are shown in my post 1410. It is very apparent for anyone who does not suffer temporary blindness that they represent a very good match with DSC curves in Bentham paper, in a clear contradiction with the curve of superthermite from paper of Tillotson and Gash
What Harrit says is quite clear. NIST did tests on Tnemec which show that this paint is thermally stable to something like 700 degrees, i.e. it does not ignite at those temperatures, which does NOT suggest that chips of this paint with a ray layer would ignite at 430 and produce spheres. Maybe LaCLede would be more likely?
No, you are
wrong and Harrit was
wrong as well. I repeat, if Tnemec contains organic polymer binder (alkyd-linsees resin), this binder is
inevitably combusted at some temperature range under air, but fairly below 700 degrees.
I can easily bet all my money that I am right
But you can be right that Tnemec is not the source of microspheres we see in Bentham paper. Who knows.
You have anyway brought here one interesting info. You quoted Jones who claims that some chips are non-glossy and hard
(and are WTC paint according to Jones, probably Tnemec, since Jones owned the samples of Tnemec for comparison). Others are more glossy and softer/more flexible, according to Jones, who thinks that they are thermitic. This could mean that they form microspheres when heated. And they can be Laclede paint, as you noted. All this might be a good clue how to separate chips suitable for possible heating tests
Perhaps it's a time to ask Jim Millette (with a necessary help of
Chris Mohr): please, have you observed that some of your chips (their red layers) look glossy under microscope, whereas others are non-glossy/dull?