Ivan Kminek
Muse
- Joined
- Jun 15, 2011
- Messages
- 906
The perimeter vertical columns fell once, fewer collisions, although other building debris may have fallen atop them, releasing some paint, at ground level. The horizontal trusses collided an average ~ 50 times with the concrete atop, more collisions, paint chips expelled with the building dust. Three of the four faces of the perimeter columns and plates did not suffer from the interior collapse of the slabs. Perimeter columns were seen falling away generally whole.
My opinion is that some the missing paint from the columns is due largely from the salvage, hauling operations, and collisions at the base of the towers.
The dust samples from Millette and Harrit were taken a long distance from the buildings, being carried there by the collapsing dust clouds.
Similar for the vertical and horizontal core members.
Speculation - I'm not familiar with gray rust. Unless you are talking of the Millette, Harrit chips. Remember the Laclede electrocoating process where the paint is electro-chemically bonded to the surface of the steel? Those chips might be paint atop the delaminated electro-bonded steel without a rust layer. This might be a clue that all those chips are Laclede. Other non- electrocoated red primer paint chips might be paint with no steel attached to them ( I don't see why the paint bonding is so strong that it would separate and carry away a layer of steel), or paint attached to a weak oxidized layer (no gray layer but an all rust colored steel layer), not sufficiently magnetically attractive and therefore not studied. But I don't know.
My opinion is that the pinkish color on the steel is red color covered with pressed concrete dust, and/or pressed SFRM (for the columns and beams).
We know all the primer was red colored, therefore the yellowish areas above must be non primer materials pressed onto the steel.
Thanks, I agree, but my question was basically different: Why do you think that the most of the primer is missing on floor trusses, when you look at these photographs from NIST report?
Otherwise, we have agreed months ago that Laclede primer should be the most abundant in the dust, especially at longer distances from Ground Zero: collapses of WTC1/2 (and also of WTC7) should be the main sources of such a "distant" dust.
As for "electrochemically bonded" paint to the steel, I'm not sure (and I've perhaps forgot some important details) , but electrocoating can lead to some changes of the steel surface composition, leading e.g. to the formation of some layer with specific properties and (later) perhaps to the easy formation of its scales with attached paint, when exposed to the strong friction/deformation forces.
Anyway, NIST photographs of floor trusses do not have a resolution good enough for some "analyses" and they were taken probably months after the disaster. And since these trusses were apparently stored exposed to the outer weather (with rather acidic rains etc.) , the visible corrosion had to be to a considerable extent caused just during this storage.
And finally for "pinkish areas" visible in the second image: you can be right that they are e.g. pressed thermal insulation because of whitish "tint", but then, if this is a SFRM foam for protection of trusses (why it should be from perimeter elements?), then (hypothetically) even "better" for us: Laclede red paint could be preserved below this layer.
(The word "better" surely deserves its quotation marks, since these floor trusses are not available for us (for Jim Millette) anyway...)
Last edited:
