WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Not to mention that it has been explicitly stated, multiple times, by the original commissioner of Millette's study, that the intent was NOT to reproduce the Harrit et al. study. Chris Mohr went to Millette and said, "See if there is any thermite in this dust." Millette only followed Harrit et al. in the process of selecting chips which were supposed to be thermitic - the rest of the study was done according to his own discretion as far as how to determine if the chips were thermite.

first ya need to find out if you have the same chips.....ignite some of them, see if they produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.
 
This makes no sense on its face. Reproducibility is, as you quote, an ability -- or perhaps we should say a property. It is highly desirable for experiments to be reproducible, but it does not follow that all researchers are obligated to follow all the same steps. See above.

Not to mention that it has been explicitly stated, multiple times, by the original commissioner of Millette's study, that the intent was NOT to reproduce the Harrit et al. study. Chris Mohr went to Millette and said, "See if there is any thermite in this dust." Millette only followed Harrit et al. in the process of selecting chips which were supposed to be thermitic - the rest of the study was done according to his own discretion as far as how to determine if the chips were thermite.

Sure, but I was trying to keep my post focused on Senenmut's argument, such as it is. The issue at hand isn't whether Mohr asked Millette to test for thermite or to reproduce Harrit et al. It's whether not asking Mohr to reproduce Harrit et al. violates the principle of reproducibility. No, it doesn't. (It may be generous to construe that as an "issue," but it's what Senenmut brought to the table.)
 
first ya need to find out if you have the same chips.....ignite some of them, see if they produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.

Who cares about thermite anymore, it's all about iron and silicon rich microspheres.

Next it will be because Millette was wearing a different brand of shoes when he carried out his experiments :D
 
Who cares about thermite anymore, it's all about iron and silicon rich microspheres.

Next it will be because Millette was wearing a different brand of shoes when he carried out his experiments :D

jones tells us how they got iron and silicon rich microspheres. millette did not get a reaction that produced iron and silicon rich microspheres.

what did millette find in his chips to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres?
 
Sure, but I was trying to keep my post focused on Senenmut's argument, such as it is. The issue at hand isn't whether Mohr asked Millette to test for thermite or to reproduce Harrit et al. It's whether not asking Mohr to reproduce Harrit et al. violates the principle of reproducibility. No, it doesn't. (It may be generous to construe that as an "issue," but it's what Senenmut brought to the table.)

he can do all the experiments he wants to do but first he needs to be sure they are the same chips which he did not do.
 
Posted by Senenmut

Originally Posted by Spanx
Who cares about thermite anymore, it's all about iron and silicon rich microspheres.

Next it will be because Millette was wearing a different brand of shoes when he carried out his experiments :D

jones tells us how they got iron and silicon rich microspheres. millette did not get a reaction that produced iron and silicon rich microspheres.

what did millette find in his chips to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres?
Can someone with greater knowledge of chemistry help me out here? Is burning a substance a common part of identifying the composition of that substance? More importantly, is it possible to tell whether two substances have the same composition without burning them?
 
Last edited:
if you were not sure it was aluminum....sure..why not. you would then have one more clue that what you have is aluminum.

(Ducks goalposts.)

It might be amusing to consider the circumstances under which making a Drano bomb would be a good way to determine whether a substance is aluminum foil. But it isn't an inherent scientific obligation to make a Drano bomb. This distinction isn't exactly subtle.

one needs to make sure they are the same chips. that is, that they produce iron and silicon microspheres.

(Ducks goalposts.)

"One needs to be sure that the foil really is aluminum foil. That is, that it produces a Drano bomb."

You can state your argument over and over, but it isn't improving through repetition.
 
Senenmut: After Sunstealer has clearly shown you again that Millette's chips (most of them) are strikingly similar to Bentham chips (a) to (d), what do you basically think?

- Those Millette's chips are the same as those Bentham chips, but in all of them, there is no kaolinite; instead, these stacking platelets are some supersecret form of nanoaluminum embedded in some compound of silicon and oxygen. Just by accident, these "composite platelets" with Al, Si and O look exactly like kaolinite and have its XEDS signature.

- Those Millette's chips are not the same as Bentham chips (a) to (d). In Millette's chips, there is really kaolinite, but in Bentham chips, there is just this supersecret... blabla, which looks exactly like kaolinite and has its... etc.

What is your hypothesis?

Do you believe that in WTC dust, there are some red/gray chips which are red primer paint on rust, and, simultaneously, there are (just by accident) red/gray chips which have the same look, thickness, composition etc., but are nanothermite instead?

Additional question: are you able to believe that some evil conspirators developed nanothermite which (intentionally) have all signatures of red epoxy primer paint (e.g. very abundant primer used for protection of WTC1/2 floor trusses), just to fool some future researchers during the investigation of the planned megacrime/disaster?
 
Last edited:
(Ducks goalposts.)

"One needs to be sure that the foil really is aluminum foil. That is, that it produces a Drano bomb."

You can state your argument over and over, but it isn't improving through repetition.

can tin foil produce a drano bomb?
 
Can someone with greater knowledge of chemistry help me out here? Is burning a substance a common part of identifying the composition of that substance? More importantly, is it possible to tell whether two substances have the same composition without burning them?

Just like semenut I am NO expert. If you read back a few posts to sunstealer,he shows how the samples are the same.

Semenut is going for the wrong chips approach, which would mean the wrong dust as the samples were both separated by magnet.

It's a sign of truther desperation.
 
Can someone with greater knowledge of chemistry help me out here? Is burning a substance a common part of identifying the composition of that substance?
No, not in the way Senenmut is suggesting because he is only interested in an arbitrary product. There is zero chemical analysis in what he is suggesting because heating the sample and looking at for an arbitary product doesn't give any analysis of the elements present in the original sample or their compounds.

For example, we know that iron and silicon rich microspheres are found in fly ash, which is produced by the combustion of coal or municipal waste in incinerators. There is no thermite reaction in their processes, but if you were to use Senenmut's criteria then you'd have to conclude that coal or municipal waste is exactly the same material as that found by Harrit/Jones etc.

Snenemut believes that a lump of coal is the same material as a red/gray chip because they both produce iron microspheres when burnt. Coal = thermite. That is obviously nonsense, but Senenmut clings to it.


More importantly, is it possible to tell whether two substances have the same composition without burning them?
Yes, it's done all the time using many different techniques

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Characterization_(materials_science)

http://www.mri.psu.edu/facilities/mcl/

Non-destructive testing (NDT) is important throughout industry. We'd be stuck if we had to destroy every sample or component to analyse that material.
 
Senenmut: After Sunstealer has clearly shown again you that Millette's chips (most of them) are strikingly similar to Bentham chips (a) to (d), what do you basically think?
i think he needs to take it to the next level and make his produce iron and silicon rich microspheres. then from there, he can describe why he thinks a thermitic reaction did not take place.
- Those Millette's chips are the same as those Bentham chips, but in all of them, there is no kaolinite; instead, these stacking platelets are some supersecret form of nanoaluminum embedded in some compound of silicon and oxygen. Just by accident, this composite with Al, Si and O looks exactly like kaolinite and has its XEDS signature.

- Those Millette's chips are not the same as Bentham chips (a) to (d). In Millette's chips, there is really kaolinite, but in Bentham chips, there is just this supersecret... blabla, which looks exactly like kaolinite and has its... etc.

What is your hypothesis?
these are the exact questions millette will need to answer when he heats his up and either finds iron and silicon rich microspheres or not!!!!

Do you believe that in WTC dust, they are some red/gray chips which are red primer paint on rust
most likely. we saw some in the nist report.
and, simultaneously, they are (just by accident) red/gray chips which have the same look, thickness, composition etc., but are nanotermite instead?
maybe, maybe not. once millette heats his up to either find iron and silicon microspheres or not, then we might be able to tell.


Additional question: are you able to believe that some evil conspirators developed nanothermite which (intentionally) have all signatures of red primer paint, just to fool some future researchers during the investigation of the planned megacrime/disaster?
you havent even proved that the compnay used electrophoretic deposition to coat the metal to begin with. ive emailed them too. no response.
 
Just like semenut I am NO expert. If you read back a few posts to sunstealer,he shows how the samples are the same.

Semenut is going for the wrong chips approach, which would mean the wrong dust as the samples were both separated by magnet.

It's a sign of truther desperation.
no, its a sign we need to right chips to even start a converstion.
 
No, not in the way Senenmut is suggesting because he is only interested in an arbitrary product. There is zero chemical analysis in what he is suggesting because heating the sample and looking at for an arbitary product doesn't give any analysis of the elements present in the original sample or their compounds.

hahaha!!! all you gotta do is split the dang chip in half. then after you react one, you got the 2nd half to analyze!!!! man, im a great scientific thinker!!

For example, we know that iron and silicon rich microspheres are found in fly ash, which is produced by the combustion of coal or municipal waste in incinerators. There is no thermite reaction in their processes, but if you were to use Senenmut's criteria then you'd have to conclude that coal or municipal waste is exactly the same material as that found by Harrit/Jones etc.

Snenemut believes that a lump of coal is the same material as a red/gray chip because they both produce iron microspheres when burnt. Coal = thermite. That is obviously nonsense, but Senenmut clings to it.
your going WAY off into the deep end. there is no need to respond.


Yes, it's done all the time using many different techniques
Non-destructive testing (NDT) is important throughout industry. We'd be stuck if we had to destroy every sample or component to analyse that material.
react one half then use those non destructive testing techniques on the other part. damn im good.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom