Technical Analysis Is Nonsense

Actually, it's time to accumulate cash, so you can buy when there is blood in the streets.

Yeah, so how're those Tulip bulbs working for ya?


There were TWO confirmed downturns greater than 2% (the minimum specified loss for Omen confirmation).

That makes Hindenberg confirmed accurate in 100% of the last 30-odd occurances.

Ignore that track record at your peril.
 
Ahem.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9574012&postcount=165

The minimum loss was calculated and specified at 2%. There were TWO downturns within the specified time that met or exceeded 2%, confirming the accuracy of the Omen.

At no time was it required that the maximum possible loss occur for the Omen to be confirmed.


You're actually using this to defend the accuracy of your prediction? OK...
Give Mulder his due. Between 4 June and 24 June, the Dow Jones index fell from about 15250 to 14700 - a fall of 3.6%. So that's one out of 5 he got right. ;) http://www.bloomberg.com/quote/INDU:IND/chart

ETA with a little cherry picking you can find a fall from 15600 on 2 August to 14800 on 27/8 - a fall of 5.1% so let's give him 11/2 out of 5. :D
 
Last edited:
Ahem.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9574012&postcount=165

The minimum loss was calculated and specified at 2%. There were TWO downturns within the specified time that met or exceeded 2%, confirming the accuracy of the Omen.

2%? :eek:

So the Omen is accurate for predicting stuff that happens all the time without consequences? Brilliant! It's almost as accurate as JP Morgan's famous prediction. I can see why all those Technical Analysis gurus sit atop the Forbes rich list.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, so how're those Tulip bulbs working for ya?



There were TWO confirmed downturns greater than 2% (the minimum specified loss for Omen confirmation).

That makes Hindenberg confirmed accurate in 100% of the last 30-odd occurances.

Ignore that track record at your peril.

As usual, if you aren't investing to make money on these predictions, then your statements mean nothing. No skin in game, no interest.
 
Last edited:
Technical Analysis Is Nonsense.

I would like to comment on this, that it is important to understand that a mathematical proof can be provided that it is nonsense. And that's very important.

Otherwise it is just opinion against opinion.
 
I would like to comment on this, that it is important to understand that a mathematical proof can be provided that it is nonsense. And that's very important.

Otherwise it is just opinion against opinion.

Also, it is self-defeating in an open market. If it really worked, everyone would use it, and it would stop working.
 
I would like to comment on this, that it is important to understand that a mathematical proof can be provided that it is nonsense. And that's very important.

Otherwise it is just opinion against opinion.

Can you link to that proof?
 
If everyone used it, wouldn't it become a self-fulfilling prophecy?

At first, yes. Then competition among those knowing that (or software that, in a sense, knows that) would cut the possible profit to be made, until it was down to zero for all practical purposes.

You would think microcaps with volume that is low enough to preclude serious day trading would be an exception, but even then, when the message board dummies are shouting "trend line x has crossed trend line y, therefore z", it doesn't seem to mean anything.
 
I had been using MarketXLS. It really works for me just fine.
It has instructions which can help you.
Just visit the site for more info.
They also have a live support and a forum to help you with your questions/concerns. :)
 
I had been using MarketXLS. It really works for me just fine.
It has instructions which can help you.
Just visit the site for more info.
They also have a live support and a forum to help you with your questions/concerns. :)
The technical analysis naysayers on this forum rely on Warren Buffet and his hilarious inversion paradigm.
Chortle chortle.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom