Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
- What do you mean by "committed sidonist"? I probably disagree.

A person, like yourself, for whom "authenticity" is a pre-assumed and foregone conclusion; such that all, any, reality must be filtered though the conclusion that the CIQ must be the True Shroud©®™℗

What is it, then; and why do you, personally, think it qualifies the Good Professor as an "expert" in potential multi-person daring or medieval cloth repair?

- Which ones?

The ones that have been pointed out to you, multiple times. I take it you have not, then?

How sad.

Fix it.
 
Last edited:
- Thanks. You too.

- I don't know. Do you? So far, I haven't been able to find his explanation. Maybe, it had to do with cotton.

(On Jabba's current "expert witness")...

So again, we see the cart before the horse:

Jabba has no idea why the person expresses what he does, but since it is useful for Jabba's forgone conclusion, it must be good. :rolleyes:

Hans
 
- Entry #1 offers the opinion of Prof Enzo Delorenzi who was involved in the scientific studies of 69 and 73. To me, that by itself suggests a little bit of credibility. Not a whole lot, but some... And, were I on a jury judging the possibility of a repair in the sample (or, near enough to affect the dating?), I would add Delorenzi's impression to the pro pan. As things stand, I just wouldn't give it much weight.
Why would you add it to your 'pro-undocumented invisible-repair pan', when Delorenzi's quote only refers to his "impression" of the number of people involved in the actual, documented and highly visible repairs?

- M&P do provide some extra info, from those involved in 69 and 73, supportive of Delorenzi's opinion.
- In a paper trying to cover such a spectrum of info as does this one by M&P, can we really expect any more elaboration than they give?
- Though, superficially at least, M&P should have told us what Delorenzi's expertise was in, what he was looking for and what specifically led him to the opinion he offered. Maybe they didn't because it would have undercut his credibility...
Possibly. But it isn't difficult to find Delorenzi's area of expertise. On the subject of credibility, though, M&P have suggested that the repair by the Poor Clare nuns was done in 1973, and asserted that Gove invented C14 dating. Their ability to fact check and report honestly is already in doubt.

The fact that they twist a quote about the documented repairs to support their desire for there to be an undocumented, invisible, impossible repair is just another nail in their credibility coffin. All of their comments and claims in that pdf are therefore suspect.

I know Jabba won't read this, but I just wanted to thank you for your continued thoughtful efforts throughout this train wreck.

Second.
Thank you both, it is much appreciated!
 
Why would you add it to your 'pro-undocumented invisible-repair pan', when Delorenzi's quote only refers to his "impression" of the number of people involved in the actual, documented and highly visible repairs?


Jabba, please address this point.
 
- OK. Let's take one entry at a time.

Entry: #1
Date: 1976
Data Category: General possibility of repairs
Evidence: Enzo Delorenzi, a member of the Turin Commission that studied the Shroud in 1969
and 1973, wrote: ―…I should like to mention the impression I received during the course of my examination, namely, that more pairs of hands have carried out the darning than is suggested in the historical records (the four Clarissas of Chambery, the Blessed Valfre and the Princess
Clotilde).‖
Source: Delorenzi, Enzo: 1976. ―Observations on the Patches and Darns in the Holy Shroud.‖
In Doyle, E., M.Green, Fr., & V. Ossola (Trans.) Report of Turin Commission on the Holy
Shroud (pp. 108-123). Unpublished. Translation of La S. Sindone: Ricerche e studi della
Commissione di Esperti nominata dall‘Arcivescovo di Torino, Card. Michele Pellegrino, nel.
Comments: This indicates that the Shroud could have received undocumented repairs in its
history. The report describes various documented repairs in the C-14 sample area, including a
repair by the Poor Clare Nuns in 1973 after the Raes sample extraction (piece extracted by
Belgian textile expert Gilbert Raes). These repairs may or may not have appeared in part or in
whole in the adjacent sample used for the C-14 test in 1988. The person responsible for
extracting this sample, Italian scientist Giovanni Riggi, never mentions these threads as
specifically being eliminated from the sample. However, a drawing by Riggi (found in BonnetEymard,
Bruno, ―The Carbon 14 Dating,‖ Catholic Counter-Reformation in the 20th Century,
April 1991, No.238, pg. 2), and a statement by Riggi demonstrate some recognition that darning
may have overlapped part of the sample and that he attempted to cut a portion of the threads out.
(See entry number 8 in this section.)


- You accept that Delorenzi is an expert, probably a relevant expert and that he studied the actual shroud (to at least some extent). One of his conclusions was, "I should like to mention the impression I received during the course of my examination, namely, that more pairs of hands have carried out the darning than is suggested in the historical records."
- I see this as "expert opinion." I just wouldn't accord it a whole lot of weight, without more info -- i.e., the subject of Delorenzi's expertise, to what extent he studied the shroud and to what extent (if any) he explained his impression.

Why would you add it to your 'pro-undocumented invisible-repair pan', when Delorenzi's quote only refers to his "impression" of the number of people involved in the actual, documented and highly visible repairs?


Jabba, the point made by Agatha here demonstrates that your quotation from Delorenzi is irrelevant to the question of the age of the cloth and irrelevant to the issue of whether the carbon dating is reliable. Either rebut Agatha's point or abandon your "entry #1" and move on to #2.
 
Jabba,

Try returning to and addressing the topic at hand.

Do you concede that your first point from your risible pdf list of speculations is rejected as worthless?

Do you accept that Enzo has no expertise in textiles, has an authenticity agenda has not actually done any scientific examinations of the cloth and simply provides baseless "impressions"?

Do you understand that Enzo was a consultant hospital radiologist with no relevant expertise whatsoever?

Do you understand that Enzo was twice appointed by the Vatican to a papally blessed commission about the cloth in 1969 and again in 1973?

Do you understand that there is a reason that this occurred?
 
There is no reason, either, to cite the number of the rule you feel has been breached when reporting - it is sufficient to say "off topic" or "uncivil" or "attacks the arguer". For the avoidance of doubt, mods posting in this thread are posting in a non-mod capacity, and should a post be reported it would be left to a mod who is not involved in the thread to decide whether rules have been breached.

Now, could we, for the love of Meg Ryan's face cream, get back to either discussing evidence, M&P's interpretation of Delorenzi's quote, or move to Jabba's next point?

Sure we can. Everyone here has addressed point #1 from the PDF. Everyone pretty much agrees it is useless. However, until Jabba concedes that point, we must perforce remain stuck at point one.
 
Jabba, I have neither insulted you nor been disrespectful, yet you ignore my posts.

Now, could we, for the love of Meg Ryan's face cream, get back to either discussing evidence1, M&P's interpretation of Delorenzi's quote2, or move to Jabba's next point3?

1. We'll need to be provided with some.

2.
- Entry #1 offers the opinion of Prof Enzo Delorenzi who was involved in the scientific studies of 69 and 73. To me, that by itself suggests a little bit of credibility. Not a whole lot, but some... And, were I on a jury judging the possibility of a repair in the sample (or, near enough to affect the dating?), I would add Delorenzi's impression to the pro pan. As things stand, I just wouldn't give it much weight.
Why would you add it to your 'pro-undocumented invisible-repair pan', when Delorenzi's quote only refers to his "impression" of the number of people involved in the actual, documented and highly visible repairs?

- M&P do provide some extra info, from those involved in 69 and 73, supportive of Delorenzi's opinion.
- In a paper trying to cover such a spectrum of info as does this one by M&P, can we really expect any more elaboration than they give?
- Though, superficially at least, M&P should have told us what Delorenzi's expertise was in, what he was looking for and what specifically led him to the opinion he offered. Maybe they didn't because it would have undercut his credibility...
Possibly. But it isn't difficult to find Delorenzi's area of expertise. On the subject of credibility, though, M&P have suggested that the repair by the Poor Clare nuns was done in 1973, and asserted that Gove invented C14 dating. Their ability to fact check and report honestly is already in doubt.

The fact that they twist a quote about the documented repairs to support their desire for there to be an undocumented, invisible, impossible repair is just another nail in their credibility coffin. All of their comments and claims in that pdf are therefore suspect.

I know Jabba won't read this, but I just wanted to thank you for your continued thoughtful efforts throughout this train wreck.

Second.
Thank you both, it is much appreciated!

3. The floor is yours, Jabba.
 
You have presented your PDF as evidence, you have stamped your feet and demanded that it be dealt with one point at a time...

With respect to the rest of your post, which is spot-on, I believe it is we who have demanded he go point by point. Jabba erroneously considered the totality of it to stand as a "consilient" argument and opposed a detailed examination. I showed how consilience requires examination of each point individually, in isolation. And he seems to have accepted that requirement. He has consented to discuss his list of evidence point-by-point, but it was not his demand that we do so, as I recall.

Specifically Jabba wants some of these to stand as expert judgment in favor of his belief, that apparently being that the carbon-14 testing should be set aside because it was done on fabric added to the cloth in the 14th Century, the date shown by testing. Here's where his first point stands according to those criteria.

Lack of foundation. Delorenzi does not state upon what specific evidence or specific observation is "impression" is based. No evidence is presented that Delorenzi carried out the sort of examination that would ordinarily be required to observe and develop evidence supporting this conclusion. Other suitable examinations by others failed to produce any such evidence. Jabba admits this deficiency, and arrogantly suggests his critics do so on his behalf.

Lack of foundation. Determination of individualized styles or patterns in textile fabrication is not a lay skill. No evidence has been shown to establish that Delorenzi has the required training and experience. No evidence has been produced to substantiate that Delorenzi possesses any such skill -- however derived. Jabba has indicated he is aware of Delorenzi's true qualifications but indicates he wishes Delorenzi nevertheless to be given "some kind of credibility." Jabba admits he is aware of the authors' misrepresentation of Delorenzi's field, and of the likely reason for that misrepresentation being to obscure or deliberately misstate Delorenzi's credentials.

Discord. Properly qualified experts have examined the cloth in a manner relevant to this statement and have failed to observe any evidence suggesting repairs by any hand, let alone by people not already accounted for. Delorenzi's statement, as interpreted for the purpose of this point, is contradicted by the consensus of the relevant science. Jabba has not acknowledged this fact.

Irrelevant. The statement is interpreted by others in hearsay fashion to support the hypothesis that a repair was made to the cloth, by means unknown and undocumented in the accompanying historical record. Delorenzi's statement itself alludes to no such thing. No context or clarification is provided to support the authors' use of the statement. There is no rational connection between Delorenzi's statement and the authors' assertion that it supports their thesis. The authors have simply manufactured it out of whole cloth. Jabba has indicated he is aware of the authors' misuse, but he has chosen not to address it.

These injuries are fatal to the claim in re Delorenzi. Jabba has indicted little if any intent to rehabilitate the Delorenzi quote. Therefore Delorenzi's statement remains disqualified on the above grounds and we should urge him to move on to point no. 2.
 
Agatha,
- You have been one of my most respectful opponents -- if not the most respectful. But, I have read most, if not all, of your posts, and I have tried to respond at various times. I'm pretty sure that the last time, you just didn't get back to me before I felt the need to respond to someone else -- probably Slowvehicle.
- I often respond to Slowvehicle, despite his tendency to insult, for two reasons: 1) It's hard for me not to respond to disrespect, and 2) I keep thinking (or hoping) that he's turning over a new leaf...

- I'll be back.
And yet, you ignored the substantive point of the very post you quoted. Which was: why do you give credence to M&P's interpretation of Delorenzi's quote (M&P suggest that Delorenzi's quote supports an invisible, undocumented repair in the sample area) when Delorenzi only referred to believing that more than six people were involved in the work on the visible, documented repairs?
 
With respect to the rest of your post, which is spot-on, I believe it is we who have demanded he go point by point. Jabba erroneously considered the totality of it to stand as a "consilient" argument and opposed a detailed examination. I showed how consilience requires examination of each point individually, in isolation. And he seems to have accepted that requirement. He has consented to discuss his list of evidence point-by-point, but it was not his demand that we do so, as I recall.

Specifically Jabba wants some of these to stand as expert judgment in favor of his belief, that apparently being that the carbon-14 testing should be set aside because it was done on fabric added to the cloth in the 14th Century, the date shown by testing. Here's where his first point stands according to those criteria.

Lack of foundation. Delorenzi does not state upon what specific evidence or specific observation is "impression" is based. No evidence is presented that Delorenzi carried out the sort of examination that would ordinarily be required to observe and develop evidence supporting this conclusion. Other suitable examinations by others failed to produce any such evidence. Jabba admits this deficiency, and arrogantly suggests his critics do so on his behalf.

Lack of foundation. Determination of individualized styles or patterns in textile fabrication is not a lay skill. No evidence has been shown to establish that Delorenzi has the required training and experience. No evidence has been produced to substantiate that Delorenzi possesses any such skill -- however derived. Jabba has indicated he is aware of Delorenzi's true qualifications but indicates he wishes Delorenzi nevertheless to be given "some kind of credibility." Jabba admits he is aware of the authors' misrepresentation of Delorenzi's field, and of the likely reason for that misrepresentation being to obscure or deliberately misstate Delorenzi's credentials.

Discord. Properly qualified experts have examined the cloth in a manner relevant to this statement and have failed to observe any evidence suggesting repairs by any hand, let alone by people not already accounted for. Delorenzi's statement, as interpreted for the purpose of this point, is contradicted by the consensus of the relevant science. Jabba has not acknowledged this fact.

Irrelevant. The statement is interpreted by others in hearsay fashion to support the hypothesis that a repair was made to the cloth, by means unknown and undocumented in the accompanying historical record. Delorenzi's statement itself alludes to no such thing. No context or clarification is provided to support the authors' use of the statement. There is no rational connection between Delorenzi's statement and the authors' assertion that it supports their thesis. The authors have simply manufactured it out of whole cloth. Jabba has indicated he is aware of the authors' misuse, but he has chosen not to address it.

These injuries are fatal to the claim in re Delorenzi. Jabba has indicted little if any intent to rehabilitate the Delorenzi quote. Therefore Delorenzi's statement remains disqualified on the above grounds and we should urge him to move on to point no. 2.

A most excellent rejoinder that warrants quoting in full. :thumbsup:
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment

I want to congratulate everyone for abandoning the work on consilience and debating an irrelevant topic of Jabba's choosing for the past two days.

No, wait. I mean you all should be ashamed of yourselves.

Jabba, you have a list of claims. You're trying to show consilience by considering each claim in turn. The first claim has been properly discarded after due consideration. Please proceed to the next.
Prestige,
- Please direct me to the post where the first claim was properly discarded -- I didn't mean to discard it.
 
Please direct me to the post where the first claim was properly discarded -- I didn't mean to discard it.


Here it is:

Why would you add it to your 'pro-undocumented invisible-repair pan', when Delorenzi's quote only refers to his "impression" of the number of people involved in the actual, documented and highly visible repairs?
 
Hey, Jabba:


Why would you add it to your 'pro-undocumented invisible-repair pan', when Delorenzi's quote only refers to his "impression" of the number of people involved in the actual, documented and highly visible repairs?


Please, answer this or move on.
 
Last edited:
Please direct me to the post where the first claim was properly discarded

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11002001#post11002001

Address these points immediately, if you please.

I didn't mean to discard it.

You're presenting your evidence to us for evaluation. You aren't the one who decides whether it stands or falls.

Over the past 48 hours or so I have emphasized the reasons why the Delorenzi statement is disqualified. I have used the word "disqualified" several times and challenged you either to rehabilitate it or move on. Please explain why you can spend so much time in blatant self-absorption and manage to miss all the various posts that actually discuss your proffered evidence.
 
Prestige,
- Please direct me to the post where the first claim was properly discarded -- I didn't mean to discard it.

You didn't discard it, everyone else did.

The simple fact that you have failed to even realise that point #1 has been comprehensively trashed and demonstrated to be without merit clearly shows that you are wantonly ignoring what everyone, even your anointed respondents, have been saying for days.

I cannot direct you to "the post". There are a veritable multitude of them not just one. Which particular rebuttal is it that you are desirous of? Are you not reading this thread? Are you not reading the responses provided?

Let me guess. You will disrespectfully ignore this response as is your MO.
 
Prestige,
- Please direct me to the post where the first claim was properly discarded -- I didn't mean to discard it.
You misunderstand my demeanor. In fact you are not choosing me. I am choosing you.

My choice is contingent on you discarding De Lorenzi, and presenting your next claim for consideration.

If you don't mean to discard the claim, then I have nothing for you to respond to. Move on from De Lorenzi, or move on from me. Either way, move on.
 
...have been saying for days.

Let me underscore this: literally for days. During those days we have been favored with precious few posts from Jabba, none of them addressing the concerns raised regarding Delorenzi. Yet when his ego is bruised, we get post after post pursuing that.

This is insulting.

Jabba presented his first witness. In good faith several posters followed up on the testimony, researched it, drew their conclusions, and laid out lines of reasoning for Jabba to address. Against their better judgment and counterindicated by Jabba's established reputation, they took his offering seriously and presented a serious response. No material response from Jabba.

Jabba seems to think that a veneer of cordiality protects him from any culpability for disrespect. If that is what he thinks, then he should pay heed to Steven King's opinion that that Rowling's Dolores Umbridge is the scariest villain in literature. Sweetly brushing off well-considered criticism is an insult to the critics, no matter how sweetly it is done. Congenially suggesting that critics must have meant something other than what they said is an insult, no matter how congenially the suggestion is phrased.

With the moral high ground now appropriately leveled, it is high time for Jabba to quit publicly licking his imaginary wounds and pay attention to the only thing his critics have discussed before this trumped-up offense.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom