Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

No, it isn't. The main task of an ablation shield is to ablate. It's own heat rejection via radiative means is a third-order term in the problem.

yeah I saw the mis-terminology but was taking 'radiating' as to mean 'getting rid of heat'.

I should know better since the entire 'friction causing heat' while used in the pop-sci world is not correct and partly the subject in this thread.
 
So "gases produced in the ablation process" which are "substantially opaque to infrared" would prevent the heat shield from performing its main task, namely from radiating off heat.

No, it isn't. The main task of an ablation shield is to ablate. Its own heat rejection via radiative means is a third-order term in the problem.


The Stefan–Boltzmann law states that the total energy radiated per unit surface area of a black body is directly proportional to the fourth power of temperature. The constant of proportionality is 5.67 x 10-8 W/m2/K4 = 2n567 W/m2/K4. In case of 1000 Kelvin, (ideal) radiation results in 2n567 ∙ 3p14 = 4p567 W/m2 = 4560 Watt per square meter. In case of 3000 Kelvin however, we get 6p46 W/m2 = 4.6 MW/m2 (i.e. increase by factor 81).

Thus the question whether "heat rejection via radiative means is a third-order term" depends on temperature.


I've been researching the chemistry of the ablative heat shield itself and I'm finding this paper quite interesting.
http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/19740007423.pdf

It is, and that's the one that I thought had the quantitative analysis of the design.


The APOLLO EXPERIENCE REPORT – THERMAL PROTECTION SUBSYSTEM contains what could be considered PR. An example from INTRODUCTION:

"The Apollo spacecraft flew on numerous earth-orbital and lunar-landing missions, and there were no problems or anomalies associated with the TPS [thermal protection subsystem]. The success of the system can be attributed to the somewhat conservative design philosophy that was adopted and to the rigorous analytical and test certification requirements that were imposed."​

A quote concerning THERMAL PROTECTION DESIGN REQUIREMENTS:

"In space, the temperature requirements for the ablator were limited to a cold temperature of -260° F [-162°C] and a hot temperature of 250° F [121°C]. The maximum initial bondline temperature at the start of entry was specified as 250° F [121°C], and the limiting temperatures at splashdown were 600°F [316°C] at the interface of the ablator and the stainless-steel honeycomb structure and 200°F [93°C] for the aluminum-honeycomb pressure-vessel structure."​

A blind eye is turned to the crucial problem of reentry heat. Yet, as also our discussion vividly demonstrates: Most people are credulous enough to believe in APOLLO even in the absence of hard evidence. All what could easily be faked with the technology of 1960s does not count as hard evidence. Ask e.g. James Randi how easy it is to mislead others.

The only relevant information for our discussion is contained in TABLE II. – APOLLO TPS FLIGHT VERIFICATION:

Total reference heating load, Btu/ft2 is given as 37 522 for Apollo 4. Since 1 Btu = 1055 Joule, this value translates into 4p37522 Btu/ft2 / (9n3048 m/ft)2 ∙ 3p1055 J/Btu ≈ 8p426 J/m2 = 0.43 Gigajoule/m2
However, total kinetic energy of reentry per square meter heat shield is E ≈ ½ m ∙ v2 / 12m2 ≈ 9n5 ∙ 3p54 kg ∙ 4p11 m/s ∙ 4p11 m/s / 1p12 / m2 ≈ 10p27 J/m2 = 77 Gigajoule/m2. This more than 100 times more!

Maximum heating rate, Btu/ft2-sec is given as 425. This translates into 425 Btu/ft2/s / (9n3048 m/ft)2 ∙ 1055 J/Btu ≈ 6p48 J/m2 = 4.8 Megawatt/m2. This is a reasonable result insofar as blackbody radiation of a body of 5000°F = 3033°K also results in 2n568 ∙ 30334 W/m2 ≈ 6p48 W/m2 = 4.8 MW/m2.

However, maximum thermodynamic heating (at peak g) due to momentum transfer between spacecraft and atmosphere is 8p31 W/m2 = 310 Megawatt/m2 (see #196). This is around 65 times more than "maximum heating rate" of the heat shield.
​

It cannot be denied that the whole momentum of around 5400 kg times 11 km/s = 3p54 kg ∙ 4p11 m/s ≈ 7p6 kg m/s = 60 Mio. kg m/s is transferred via contact interaction from the spacecraft to the atmosphere. Momentum change of the entering spacecraft is exactly the same as corresponding momentum change of the atmosphere (actio = reactio). Why should only in the order of one percent of the energy emerging during this mutual momentum transfer affect the heat shield? And even this calculation (heat shield removing in the order of one percent of total emerging heat) is based on the quite unlikely hypothesis that the heat shield works fine up to a temperature of 5000°F resp. 3000°K.

Cheers, Wolfgang
The Apollo Space Program – A gigantic conspiracy?
 
TMost people are credulous enough to believe in APOLLO even in the absence of hard evidence. All what could easily be faked with the technology of 1960s does not count as hard evidence.

Do tell us how it is possible, with the technology available in the 1960s, to broadcast live TV showing a meteorologically accurate image of Earth before any complete satellite images were available to make that TV broadcast. Images that would have needed to be in colour.

Please tell us how it was possible for Apollo surface images to contain details not available in any lunar orbital images. While you're at it, kindly advise us as to why Soviet, Chinese, Japanese and Indian images all verify details in Apollo orbital images - again, details not photographed in the required detail prior to Apollo.

Please tell us how it was possible for satellite dishes in numerous countries to be pointed at a specific spot in space and get, in the correct sequence, signals from that spot.

You are claiming the technology existed, so tell us the technology, outline the procedures, the locations, the personnel. Please don't appeal to magic, or technology you can't prove exists, or you'll just be laughed at.
 
The Stefan–Boltzmann law states that the total energy radiated per unit surface area of a black body is directly proportional to the fourth power of temperature. The constant of proportionality is 5.67 x 10-8 W/m2/K4 = 2n567 W/m2/K4. In case of 1000 Kelvin, (ideal) radiation results in 2n567 ∙ 3p14 = 4p567 W/m2 = 4560 Watt per square meter. In case of 3000 Kelvin however, we get 6p46 W/m2 = 4.6 MW/m2 (i.e. increase by factor 81).

Thus the question whether "heat rejection via radiative means is a third-order term" depends on temperature.







The APOLLO EXPERIENCE REPORT – THERMAL PROTECTION SUBSYSTEM contains what could be considered PR. An example from INTRODUCTION:

"The Apollo spacecraft flew on numerous earth-orbital and lunar-landing missions, and there were no problems or anomalies associated with the TPS [thermal protection subsystem]. The success of the system can be attributed to the somewhat conservative design philosophy that was adopted and to the rigorous analytical and test certification requirements that were imposed."​

A quote concerning THERMAL PROTECTION DESIGN REQUIREMENTS:

"In space, the temperature requirements for the ablator were limited to a cold temperature of -260° F [-162°C] and a hot temperature of 250° F [121°C]. The maximum initial bondline temperature at the start of entry was specified as 250° F [121°C], and the limiting temperatures at splashdown were 600°F [316°C] at the interface of the ablator and the stainless-steel honeycomb structure and 200°F [93°C] for the aluminum-honeycomb pressure-vessel structure."​

A blind eye is turned to the crucial problem of reentry heat. Yet, as also our discussion vividly demonstrates: Most people are credulous enough to believe in APOLLO even in the absence of hard evidence. All what could easily be faked with the technology of 1960s does not count as hard evidence. Ask e.g. James Randi how easy it is to mislead others.

The only relevant information for our discussion is contained in TABLE II. – APOLLO TPS FLIGHT VERIFICATION:

Total reference heating load, Btu/ft2 is given as 37 522 for Apollo 4. Since 1 Btu = 1055 Joule, this value translates into 4p37522 Btu/ft2 / (9n3048 m/ft)2 ∙ 3p1055 J/Btu ≈ 8p426 J/m2 = 0.43 Gigajoule/m2
However, total kinetic energy of reentry per square meter heat shield is E ≈ ½ m ∙ v2 / 12m2 ≈ 9n5 ∙ 3p54 kg ∙ 4p11 m/s ∙ 4p11 m/s / 1p12 / m2 ≈ 10p27 J/m2 = 77 Gigajoule/m2. This more than 100 times more!

Maximum heating rate, Btu/ft2-sec is given as 425. This translates into 425 Btu/ft2/s / (9n3048 m/ft)2 ∙ 1055 J/Btu ≈ 6p48 J/m2 = 4.8 Megawatt/m2. This is a reasonable result insofar as blackbody radiation of a body of 5000°F = 3033°K also results in 2n568 ∙ 30334 W/m2 ≈ 6p48 W/m2 = 4.8 MW/m2.

However, maximum thermodynamic heating (at peak g) due to momentum transfer between spacecraft and atmosphere is 8p31 W/m2 = 310 Megawatt/m2 (see #196). This is around 65 times more than "maximum heating rate" of the heat shield.
​

It cannot be denied that the whole momentum of around 5400 kg times 11 km/s = 3p54 kg ∙ 4p11 m/s ≈ 7p6 kg m/s = 60 Mio. kg m/s is transferred via contact interaction from the spacecraft to the atmosphere. Momentum change of the entering spacecraft is exactly the same as corresponding momentum change of the atmosphere (actio = reactio). Why should only in the order of one percent of the energy emerging during this mutual momentum transfer affect the heat shield? And even this calculation (heat shield removing in the order of one percent of total emerging heat) is based on the quite unlikely hypothesis that the heat shield works fine up to a temperature of 5000°F resp. 3000°K.

Cheers, Wolfgang
The Apollo Space Program – A gigantic conspiracy?
The Apollo astronauts can be thankful that they did not have you designing their heat shield!
 
Most people are credulous enough to believe in APOLLO even in the absence of hard evidence. All what could easily be faked with the technology of 1960s does not count as hard evidence.

When you figure out how to fake 800+ lbs of lunar rocks and soil that have unique and distinct physical characteristics, let us know. "Radiation oven" is not the answer so don't even try that one. It fails to explain gas bubbles inside millions of year old rocks with features from cooling in a low gravity vacuum environment. Also, NASA exchanged samples with the Soviets.

Also, geologists around the world have studied the rocks for decades and not one has ever suggested the rocks have any origin other than lunar. And no, they don't need to look at "another lunar rock" to identify a lunar rock by characteristic features impossible to create on earth.
 
Thus the question whether "heat rejection via radiative means is a third-order term" depends on temperature.

No. You don't understand what is meant by "the problem." The problem is the design of a heat shield. The solution involves several factors working in concert. Rejection of heat by radiative heat transfer is a third-order term in the quantitative solution. You're trying to claim the gaseous ablation products cannot be suitably opaque as I claimed because then the heat shield wouldn't be able to radiate away heat. That's a knee-jerk response based on what you desperately want to be true, not what is true.

The rest of your post is just a mindless regurgitation of claims you've already made, which have been amply refuted.
 
When you figure out how to fake 800+ lbs of lunar rocks and soil that have unique and distinct physical characteristics, let us know. "Radiation oven" is not the answer...

Indeed, wogoga is just postulating a Magic Moonrock Faking Machine, which he declares -- with no evidence -- would be easily within the reach of contemporary technology. Yet somehow that same technical prowess can't be brought to bear to compose a viable heat shield, even when the design at the time was already a decade old and had been in use for other purposes.
 
Wogoga: Friday quiz time.

When things opaque to infrared are exposed to IR emissions, what happens? Does the object or substance
A) absorb the energy
B) reflect the energy
C) ignore the energy
D) none of the above
 
Last edited:
E) all of the above


Have to be all inclusive after all.:D

Wrong. In wogoga world, all heat is directly absorbed into the heat shield directly without exception. Since the heat shield materially cannot handle that load it must be fake.

Yea, I realise that is horribly wrong, but that is his position.
 
wogoga, if you don't believe any of the Apollo documentation explaining how and why Apollo worked, why are you citing it?

And since you claim it all could have been "easily faked" using 1960s technology, please explain exactly how it was faked - all of it. From tracking data to lunar samples to the flight hardware to the ALSEP telemetry and personal experience and peer-reviewed research and test results and everything else. Because there is an almost fractally detailed record of how it was done; since you talk so big about how superior your version is, I'm sure you've got a similarly extensive record of how it wasn't done, right? Surely you're not just bloviating without any evidence, right?

Please explain how it could fool not only the scientists and engineers of the time but of half a century hence, especially when many of the techniques and technologies are still in use.

Bonus question: please explain why actual practicing engineers in this field (like several of us here) are somehow "fooled", but you, a layman who is manifestly unfamiliar with the record, somehow perceives the truth.

No handwaving, please.
 
wogoga: A lie about the issue of reentry heat being ignored

Followed by irrelevant ignorance about physics and links to deluded paranoiac conspiracy theory web sites. And a lie:
A blind eye is turned to the crucial problem of reentry heat.
The issue of reentry heat has been researched for many decades - probably a few decades before the first space missions :jaw-dropp!

It looks like denial of and lying about the researched and working physics is all wogoga has:
The truth about ablative heat shields that wogoga denies:
We can stop there with the lie of "assumed" followed by ignorant gibberish and more "assumption" lies, wogoga.
The truth is ablative heat shields work using known physics that forms a cooler layer between the spacecraft and the hotter shock wave.
The truth is ablative heat shields have been tested in experiments for about 50 years.
The truth is ablative heat shields have been used for hundreds of mission from Mercury to Apollo to the Space Shuttle to Soyuz.
 
wogoga: Repeats ignorance about ablative heat shields

...case of 1000 Kelvin.
You are showing your ignorance still, wogoga. Ablative heat shields work because the ablation at lower temperatures as the shockwave begins to form creates a layer of cooler gas that protects them from the shockwave temperatures. There is a mixture of cooling from the escaping material and from radiation. The dominant effect is cooling from ablation, i.e. cooling from radiation is a "third order effect".

Ignorant calculations do not change the physics.
 
wogoga: A "PR" lie about the APOLLO EXPERIENCE REPORT – THERMAL PROTECTION SUBSYSTEM

That is a lie about "PR", wogoga, because that report is a technical document that includes the ground and flight-testing of the thermal protection systems. An example from the INTRODUCTION:
"The Apollo spacecraft flew on numerous earth-orbital and lunar-landing missions, and there were no problems or anomalies associated with the TPS [thermal protection subsystem]. The success of the system can be attributed to the somewhat conservative design philosophy that was adopted and to the rigorous analytical and test certification requirements that were imposed."
and CONCLUDING REMARKS
The Apollo spacecraft has flown on several earth-orbital and lunar-landing mis- sions, and the thermal protection subsystem has performed well on all missions. The success of the system can be attributed to the conservative design philosophy and rig- orous development and verification testing that was conducted. Experience with lunar missions has shown that the spacecraft crewmembers prefer short-range entries and that the command module can be guided precisely to the middle of the entry corridor. This results in a heating environment that is much less severe than that for which the thermal protection subsystem was designed. Entry down range for the manned lunar- landing missions (Apollo 8 to 16) was actually 1500 nautical miles for lunar-return entry, compared with the design requirement of 3500 nautical miles. The resulting maximum integrated heat load was 26 500 Btu/ft , compared with 44 500 Btu/ft which was used in the design of the thermal protection subsystem.
So the Apollo heat shields were designed to cope with about twice the heat load that the missions encountered.
 
wogoga: A lie about the Apollo missions being easily faked with 1960s technology

All what could easily be faked with the technology of 1960s does not count as hard evidence
A lie about the Apollo missions being easily faked with 1960s technology, wogoga.
Even with todays technology it is physically impossible to fake some aspects of the Apollo missions, e.g. their telemetry. In the 1960's it was worse. No faking of moon rocks. No faking of the videos of astronauts on the Moon. No faking of the physical fact that there are laser reflectors at Apollo landing locations. etc. etc.

There are many places where this deluded denial of the Apollo missions is addressed.
 
The only relevant information for our discussion is contained in TABLE II. – APOLLO TPS FLIGHT VERIFICATION:
...
followed by an obviously ignorant and invalid calculation because it leads to the stupidity of the Apollo 4 spacecraft failing when in the real world it worked :jaw-dropp!

The insane notion means that there is no way to verify the calculation.
 
Maybe the following hypothesis could lead to simpler explanations of our Moon's origin:

The majority of so-called "moon rocks" has been baked or cooked by NASA from a mixture of terrestrial rocks peppered with some meteorites at high temperatures and vacuum, leading by vaporization to depletion of volatile elements and enrichment of heavy isotopes.​


What I wrote here is wrong. They probably used an artificial atmosphere with at least radioactive 40Argon in order to mislead radioactive dating techniques.

A quote from Age Determinations and Isotopic Abundance Measurements on Lunar Samples, 1970:

The presence of an anomalously large quantity of 40Ar, in a sample of type C breccia precluded the calculation of its K-Ar age.
​

A simple hypothesis for such an anomalously large quantity of 40Argon is an error in the process of "moon rock" baking. The NASA bakers would have mistakenly added too much of the ingredient 40Argon.
Logically consistent creationists are pleased with lunar rocks: The Age of the Moon

It would be quite easy for an unprejudiced scientific research to decide whether Apollo moon rocks are faked, and if yes, to exactly determine how the Apollo moon rock samples were created. Some "moon rocks" are simply special meteorites (or maybe even very special terrestrial stones) which are now called "lunar meteorites". An interesting list of lunar meteorites: List

Secondary meteorites originating from a primary impact on the moon enter our atmosphere with a speed as high as Apollo reentry speed! Thus the high proportion of "lunar" meteorites among all meteorites becomes rather unrealistic. Small pieces catapulted out of the lunar surface and accelerated to more than the moon's escape velocity of 1620 m/s would mostly vaporize in terrestrial atmosphere. Reaching regions close to the poles such as Antarctica is even more improbable. So how is it possible that "0.11% of all meteorite stones found in Antarctica are of lunar origin" (Source)?

Cheers, Wolfgang

Centuries ago, those being knowledgeable and courageous enough to cast doubt on the legitimacy of the Inquisition were hated by those having naïve faith in the Holy Church
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom