The
Stefan–Boltzmann law states that the total energy radiated per unit surface area of a black body is directly
proportional to the fourth power of temperature. The constant of proportionality is 5.67 x 10-8 W/m
2/K
4 = 2n567 W/m2/K4. In case of 1000 Kelvin, (ideal) radiation results in
2n567 ∙ 3p14 = 4p567 W/m2 = 4560 Watt per square meter. In case of 3000 Kelvin however, we get
6p46 W/m2 = 4.6 MW/m
2 (i.e. increase by factor 81).
Thus the question whether "heat rejection via radiative means is a third-order term" depends on temperature.
The
APOLLO EXPERIENCE REPORT – THERMAL PROTECTION SUBSYSTEM contains what could be considered PR. An example from
INTRODUCTION:
"The Apollo spacecraft flew on numerous earth-orbital and lunar-landing missions, and there were no problems or anomalies associated with the TPS [thermal protection subsystem]. The success of the system can be attributed to the somewhat conservative design philosophy that was adopted and to the rigorous analytical and test certification requirements that were imposed."
A quote concerning
THERMAL PROTECTION DESIGN REQUIREMENTS:
"In space, the temperature requirements for the ablator were limited to a cold temperature of -260° F [-162°C] and a hot temperature of 250° F [121°C]. The maximum initial bondline temperature at the start of entry was specified as 250° F [121°C], and the limiting temperatures at splashdown were 600°F [316°C] at the interface of the ablator and the stainless-steel honeycomb structure and 200°F [93°C] for the aluminum-honeycomb pressure-vessel structure."
A blind eye is turned to the crucial problem of reentry heat. Yet, as also our discussion vividly demonstrates:
Most people are credulous enough to believe in APOLLO even in the absence of hard evidence. All what could easily be faked with the technology of 1960s does not count as hard evidence. Ask e.g. James Randi how easy it is to mislead others.
The only relevant information for our discussion is contained in
TABLE II. – APOLLO TPS FLIGHT VERIFICATION:
Total reference heating load, Btu/ft2 is given as 37 522 for Apollo 4. Since 1 Btu = 1055 Joule, this value translates into
4p37522 Btu/ft2 / (9n3048 m/ft)2 ∙ 3p1055 J/Btu ≈ 8p426 J/m2 = 0.43 Gigajoule/m2
However, total kinetic energy of reentry per square meter heat shield is E ≈ ½ m ∙ v
2 / 12m
2 ≈
9n5 ∙ 3p54 kg ∙ 4p11 m/s ∙ 4p11 m/s / 1p12 / m2 ≈ 10p27 J/m2 = 77 Gigajoule/m2. This more than 100 times more!
Maximum heating rate, Btu/ft2-sec is given as 425. This translates into
425 Btu/ft2/s / (9n3048 m/ft)2 ∙ 1055 J/Btu ≈ 6p48 J/m2 = 4.8 Megawatt/m2. This is a reasonable result insofar as blackbody radiation of a body of 5000°F = 3033°K also results in
2n568 ∙ 30334 W/m2 ≈ 6p48 W/m2 = 4.8 MW/m
2.
However, maximum thermodynamic heating (at peak g) due to momentum transfer between spacecraft and atmosphere is
8p31 W/m2 = 310 Megawatt/m2 (see
#196). This is around 65 times more than "maximum heating rate" of the heat shield.
It cannot be denied that the whole momentum of around 5400 kg times 11 km/s
= 3p54 kg ∙ 4p11 m/s ≈ 7p6 kg m/s = 60 Mio. kg m/s is transferred via contact interaction from the spacecraft to the atmosphere. Momentum change of the entering spacecraft is exactly the same as corresponding momentum change of the atmosphere (actio = reactio). Why should only in the order of one percent of the energy emerging during this mutual momentum transfer affect the heat shield?
And even this calculation (heat shield removing in the order of one percent of total emerging heat) is based on the quite unlikely hypothesis that the heat shield works fine up to a temperature of 5000°F resp. 3000°K.
Cheers, Wolfgang
The Apollo Space Program – A gigantic conspiracy?