The ballad of the 911 shill

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think it is probably pretty true. There has to be some rationalization for the deviation from reality.

The problem of course is that if you don't know what reality is you can't make good decisions, and ultimately that will hurt a society.

100% agreement :thumbsup:
 
You didn't prove anyone wrong. Most of the heating of fire protected structural steel that could take place would be by direct radiation and that can only happen when the fire can see the item. Convection won't do much in the case of insulated structural steel so there won't be much preheating.

NIST's fire simulation temperatures are on the high side with preheating exaggerated, although apparently not nearly as much as the analysis by Beyler must be.
Anyone who has some idea about heat transfer and fire protection of structural steel will understand what I am saying above and it can be shown mathematically, so you really can't win.

People like Abboud and Beyler who do it for a living.
Or Quintere or any of the others you claim you are more expert than
 
You didn't prove anyone wrong. Most of the heating of fire protected structural steel that could take place would be by direct radiation and that can only happen when the fire can see the item. Convection won't do much in the case of insulated structural steel so there won't be much preheating.

NIST's fire simulation temperatures are on the high side with preheating exaggerated, although apparently not nearly as much as the analysis by Beyler must be.

Anyone who has some idea about heat transfer and fire protection of structural steel will understand what I am saying above and it can be shown mathematically, so you really can't win.

Then show me on the graph where 99% of the heat transfer occurs, Tony. From when to when? And tell me exactly how hot the beams were at 4:30. NIST already did the math to show us the answers to these questions, and it is you and Korol who claim your ridiculous theory is based on their work. Do you not understand it, or are you lying about it?

Everyone, including you, knows you and Korol are wrong about the 25-30 min heat transfer model.
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 452.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 452.jpg
    34.1 KB · Views: 0
  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    33.2 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
Then show me on the graph where 99% of the heat transfer occurs, Tony. From when to when? And tell me exactly how hot the beams were at 4:30. NIST already did the math to show us the answers to these questions, and it is you and Korol who claim your ridiculous theory is based on their work. Do you not understand it, or are you lying about it?

Everyone, including you, knows you and Korol are wrong about the 25-30 min heat transfer model.

The 99% was a figure of speech. I have been telling you that the vast majority of heating that can take place with fire protected structural steel will occur with direct radiation (not convection) and it only occurs with the fire being able to see the item being heated and its effect decreases with distance. So, the 25 to 30 minutes of active fire under fire protected structural steel in a building is when it would have most of whatever heating it experiences occur.

The NIST fire simulations are on the high side due to an exaggerated fuel load. The NIST report has been proven invalid due to other issues so its credibility is shot to begin with as it is clear it is embellished in favor of the conclusion. The interesting part here is that even an embellished report trying to reach the same conclusions that Weidlinger did doesn't provide the extreme steel temperatures on the 9th and 10th floors that the Weidlinger report wants to claim. I would call those super embellished and in fact surreal.
 
Last edited:
The 99% was a figure of speech. I have been telling you that the vast majority of heating that can take place with fire protected structural steel will occur with direct radiation (not convection) and it only occurs with the fire being able to see the item being heated and its effect decreases with distance. So, the 20 to 30 minutes of active fire under fire protected structural steel in a building is when it would have most of whatever heating it experiences occur.

A specific, mathematical claim was a "figure of speech"????? Come on, Tony. This is so sad.

You keep making claims about how the fires would have pre-heated the beam, but you do understand that we don't have to guess about that, right? NIST built a comprehensive model to take into account all of those factors and they showed around 400 C of pre-heating. It's right there in the chart I've posted like 20 times and am posting again.

What math have you done to know you are right and NIST is wrong? What specifically did they do wrong, in your estimation?

How hot was the beam on floor 13 before the peak burn fire reached it?

Where's the math, Tony?

Or you could just admit that you and Korol have been conflating peak burn time and heating time and thus made a fundamental mistake. It's already obvious to everyone else. No need to keep lying.
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 452.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 452.jpg
    34.1 KB · Views: 0
  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    33.2 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
A specific, mathematical claim was a "figure of speech"????? Come on, Tony. This is so sad.

You keep making claims about how the fires would have pre-heated the beam, but you do understand that we don't have to guess about that, right? NIST built a comprehensive model to take into account all of those factors and they showed around 400 C of pre-heating. It's right there in the chart I've posted like 20 times and am posting again.

What math have you done to know you are right and NIST is wrong. What specifically did they do wrong?

How hot was the beam on floor 13 before the peak burn fire reached it?

Where's the math, Tony?

Or you could just admit that you and Korol have been conflating peak burn time and heating time and thus made a fundamental mistake. It's already obvious to everyone else. No need to keep lying.

Korol et al already gave you the math.

Where is your math to prove them wrong?

Oh, that's right you can only point to the proven to be invalid NIST report and an assertion from a report that has not been publicly released (Beyler 2010) that nobody has seen. You also naively claim that if gas temperatures are higher that extreme heating would be taking place, not understanding heating of protected structural steel by convection away from an active fire without a view is minimal.
 
Last edited:
Korol et al already gave you the math.

Where is your math to prove them wrong?

Oh, that's right you can only point to the proven to be invalid NIST report and an assertion from a report that has not been publicly released (Beyler 2010) that nobody has seen. You also naively claim that if gas temperatures are higher that extreme heating would be taking place, not understanding heating of protected structural steel by convection away from an active fire without a view is minimal.

The source the Korol cites proves him wrong, Tony. It proves you wrong too. Here are the graphs again.

You and Korol made a fundamental mistake by conflating peak burn time with heating time. You thus attempt to ignore a very substantial period of heating, which NIST's simulation demonstrates increased the temperature of the beam to around 400 C. It's right there in the chart. That's your source. That's Korol's source. Do you not understand it, or are you trying to misrepresent it?
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 452.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 452.jpg
    34.1 KB · Views: 2
  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    33.2 KB · Views: 2
We know plenty about fire, including the fact that it has never caused the complete straight down collapse of a steel framed high-rise building.

Now we have suspicious people telling us it did three times, ...

You should take that up with Richard Gage who claims the opposite for the twins - that they collapsed anything but straight down, rather were flung violently and wildly and far into all directions.

Unless of course you knew already that the phrase "straight down collapse" means nothing and you added it only with an intent to fluff-up the bloviation.
 
Figure 9–9 displays hourly snapshots of the upper layer temperatures predicted by the model. The simulations indicated that the clusters of workstations burned out in about 20 min to 30 min.

O my God! Tony! This is utterly utterly stupid!!!

You actually pretend that "cluster burning out in 25 minutes" translates 1:1 to "steel heated for 25 minutes"?!? Seriously?

I could explain to a 5 year old the several reasons why this is stupidly false. For starters:
There are many clusters in an office compartment
Hot gases do not stay confined to the area directly above the cluster
 
Now you are just being plain silly. Figure 9-9 shows several workstation clusters and the fire moving over time. Steel which is 50 to 75 feet away from a fire is not being heated in any significant way by that fire. ...
When you get the Beyler analysis let me know. Until then good bye.

We know that Beyler says the exact opposite - that WTC7 beams were indeed heated to as much as 200-300 °C before the fires arrived there. And that this is a major reason why the peak temperature exceeded that of fires in buildings (or test sites) with more conventional compartment sizes.
 
I would remind everyone here that Benthamitemetric is famous for being the first to post the Aegis Insurance Co. expert reports ...

Everybody can see that you painted yourself in a corner, and you know exactly that benthamitemetric has you by your balls.

And in that situation, you throw the goal posts out the window.

This is acually the moment of benthamitemetric's victory and triumph over you. You admit at this very point that no Cardington test, nothing NIST has produced, and no other fire science in the world can salvage your false claims and Korol's false methodology re: air and steel temperatures in large compartment fires.
 
I worded my post rather badly--
The case i told of was not me being an Expert Witness (I was involved and therefore couldn't be) but the advice of the lawyer during the discussions was that my attitude makes me a bad witness, and while at the time I had the credentials, I should not ever try to be an expert witness. Which is why they chose a colleague of mine to present. As I said, it never got to the point of actual testimony.
Even being right doesn't make one a good witness in court...
Understood thanks.
Not sure if I posted my experience - on a 2003 tour in Scotland - coach tipped over due to road collapse. Me, as the 2IC tour guide and gopher, sitting in front "crew" seat. Qualified roads engineer, licensed in AU to drive Tour Coaches and had law degree. The Scottish lawyer's eyes lit up - looked at me and said "our own expert witness". Joking of course - I was a party to the action. BTW no "class action" under Scottish law.
 
No, I believe the Korol analysis is the closest to reality ...

Korol's analysis re-inevts the wheel with made-up premises and computing from first principles, arriving at some surprisingly low peak temperature.

The 1993 large compartment Cardington test measured peak temperatures in excess of 700 °C in protected steel beams.

If it doesn't agree with experiment...


Korol's analysis is on an intellectual level of fire sience scarcely higher than the back-on-the envelops I love doing an many issues, from estimating project cost to population effects of deseases to minimum size of explosive charges to propel large steel members to 60 mph.
The difference is of course that I know I am just an amateur in most pf these fields, and wouldn't dare submitting those for publication. I know to be skeptic of myself.

You however ... just believe what you desire to believe.

(The Korol paper in large part appears similar to the kind of work Frank Greening likes to do - I have a feeling that Greening did the bulk of the work, and that Korol appears as lead author because of his seemingly more relevant credentials.)
 
O my God! Tony! This is utterly utterly stupid!!!

You actually pretend that "cluster burning out in 25 minutes" translates 1:1 to "steel heated for 25 minutes"?!? Seriously?

I could explain to a 5 year old the several reasons why this is stupidly false. For starters:
There are many clusters in an office compartment
Hot gases do not stay confined to the area directly above the cluster
It reminds me of the occasion when I said the same thing - and actually used my 5yo grandson to prove it. Let's see if I have the link.

Try this http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=9418049#post9418049

Ooops - he was 6yo - does that invalidate the comparison? :o

BTW that example was NOT directly Tony - it arose out of a simple comment I made to Tony and another truther got on the bandwagon.
 
Last edited:
You are talking like a lawyer working for a client trying to nitpick and make your case no matter what the reality is. ...

OMG.
You haste from low point to low point at break-neck speed.

YOU, Tony Szamboti, justified your 25-minutes claim by citing NIST - a specific figure.
When Benthamitemetric shed light on the context, and asked you many times to use YOUR own citation to back up YOUR claim, you evaded, and turned around, and claimed that YOUR citation contains unreliable information.

benthamitemetric merely reminded you that it is YOUR citation that YOU pretended supports YOUR argument has been discredited by YOU.
That is not lowly laywer talk - that is an inescapable and damning fact!
 
You are trying to defend the indefensible.


Like noiseless CD @ WTC?! You can only push the laws of physics just so far, Tony.


Simply put there is currently no valid analysis showing WTC 7 came down due to fire that is publicly available.


You should have thrown in the towel when it was made clear to you that not one WTC video depicted CD explosions as those buildings collapsed.

It is also apparent that you lack the understanding to debate the collapse of WTC 7 because you do not understand the significance of structural pre-weakening, structural load redistribution, structural buckling, and the effects of fire on structural steel. You may think that you are an expert but you can't be ignorant of the facts and continue to still think of yourself as an expert.

I knew that you were trying to push CD @ WTC by the way you were ignoring the facts and evidence and your failure to answer questions posed to you, which made me suspicious. The temperature level of my suspicion was raised even further when I found your name with that of Steven Jones, the person who was caught pushing doctored photos as evidence of molten steel @ ground zero.

9/11 CONSPIRACY GETS SUPPORT FROM PHYSICISTS’ STUDY

Europhysics magazine report finds Twin Towers brought down by ‘controlled demolition’ Europhysics Magazine, the respected publication of the European physics community, has published a report by four experts who say “the evidence points overwhelmingly to the conclusion that all three buildings were destroyed by controlled demolition.”


Who Wrote it?

Four authors are listed, Steven Jones, Robert Korol, Anthony Szamboti, Ted Walter...

http://www.skeptical-science.com/critical-thinking/scientific-proof-911-inside-job/


Tony, being a well-known 9/11 Truther helps explain why you continue to ignore facts and evidence as you continuously try to push your square CD theory into a round hole of reality where it obviously doesn't fit and it doesn't make any sense to try to pull your moth-eaten blanket over the eyes of those who know better.

You have to face up to the fact that the truth movement had lost the war a long time ago and there is nothing left for you to debate because you made it clear to me that you had made a wrong turn onto a dead-end street of denial.
 
Last edited:
You didn't prove anyone wrong. Most of the heating of fire protected structural steel that could take place would be by direct radiation and that can only happen when the fire can see the item. Convection won't do much in the case of insulated structural steel so there won't be much preheating.


How much insulation can you point out in the following photo of WTC 7 structural steel?

b7_debris1.jpg



You should have also noticed that WTC 7 did not collapse within its own footprint, which debunks the claim of AE9/11Truth
 
Last edited:
Tony what evidence do you have that this was not done by the NIST
https://www.nist.gov/el/faqs-nist-wtc-7-investigation
13. Did investigators consider the possibility that an explosion caused or contributed to the collapse of WTC 7?
Yes, this possibility was investigated carefully. NIST concluded that blast events inside the building did not occur and found no evidence supporting the existence of a blast event.
In addition, no blast sounds were heard on the audio tracks of video recordings during the collapse of WTC 7 or reported by witnesses. According to calculations by the investigation team, the smallest blast capable of failing the building's critical column would have resulted in a sound level of 130 decibels (dB) to 140 dB at a distance of at least half a mile, if unobstructed by surrounding buildings. This sound level is consistent with a gunshot blast, standing next to a jet plane engine, and more than 10 times louder than being in front of the speakers at a rock concert.
For the building to have been prepared for intentional demolition, walls and/or column enclosures and fireproofing would have to be removed and replaced without being detected. Preparing a column includes steps such as cutting sections with torches, which produces noxious and odorous fumes. Intentional demolition usually requires applying explosive charges to most, if not all, interior columns, not just one or a limited set of columns in a building.

So what is your evidence that a CD took place?
 
The study I provided the link too is publicly available for a price, and lends support to NIST and shows Tony wrong.

It is only a matter of time until Tony self destructs, chocking on his own words.


I agree! I find it peculiar that Truthers who imply they are experts have claimed the destruction of the WTC buildings was due to explosives and/or thermite/nano-thermite. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that their claims are baseless especially when considering that explosive detonations create a lot of noise.
 
I agree! I find it peculiar that Truthers who imply they are experts have claimed the destruction of the WTC buildings was due to explosives and/or thermite/nano-thermite. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that their claims are baseless especially when considering that explosive detonations create a lot of noise.

When the noise argument comes up, I always think of this video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QL1mqlquZ3g&t=0m13s

That's the only video I could find of explosive noise abatement. That's 1980's company patented technology, in which 800 cubic feet of foamy material (9.28 ft edges, 16 ft diameter) was simply placed over 4 pounds of C-4. 4 pounds of C-4 was reduced to the sound of a quiet growl.

more info: http://www.aquafoam.com/BlastingExplosions.html

Collapse or Explosion? A Discussion of the WTC “Sounds of Explosions” Issue by Adam Taylor

That's proof enough to me that the sound issue is simply something that can not be known for sure. Nobody has even produced any way of knowing exactly how loud the WTC collapses were.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom