does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

You surely realize by we I meant everyone, including you and all the others here.

We need an investigation that provides one and explains the observations.

Or you could wake-up, acknowledge that multiple investigations by the world's foremost subject matter experts have reasonably determined fire the most likely cause of the observed collapse, and move on with your life. The door is wide open for you now that you know you were fundamentally mistaken about how the fires in the building behaved. Get out and find purpose in something else.
 
You surely realize by we I meant everyone, including you and all the others here.

We need an investigation that provides one and explains the observations.

As I said there are three studies that I know of going on right now and not a one supports your claims so far!
 
The reason I don't put you on ignore is it is hard to believe you actually take yourself seriously. Your rants could be taken as sarcasm, and I think deep down you are probably a nice guy as that seeps through the rant on occassion.
Yay.

Ad hom after ad hom after ad hom. Any evidence of wild claim? Nope.
 
You surely realize by we I meant everyone, including you and all the others here.

We need an investigation that provides one and explains the observations.
We? You got a mouse in your pocket?
The real world already had many investigations, you ignore the FBI, NIST, FEMA, and other investigations.

How is your inside job fantasy coming?

15 years, everyone knows it was fire. You must of missed the fires, guess we need to do the next fire event at night so it looks right for you conspiracy CD fantasy believers.



Yay.

Ad hom after ad hom after ad hom. Any evidence of wild claim? Nope.
He has no evidence, what is left.

Hey, that is 9/11 truth evidence; weak attacks on others who tell CD pushers they are spreading lies.
 
Just outstanding logic on your part. Who would have thought?


Since you believe the WTC buildings were demolished with explosives, explain why demolition and structural experts do not agree with you. In fact, provide details that can be examined by demolition experts.

You make a claim, I expect you to back it up.
 
The reason I don't put you on ignore is it is hard to believe you actually take yourself seriously. Your rants could be taken as sarcasm, and I think deep down you are probably a nice guy as that seeps through the rant on occassion.

Go ahead. Step up and tell everyone what your CD scenario is. For some reason, you will not.

Why is that? Can you not fathom how it is that your current fellow traveller is proposing explosives enclosed in "aircraft black boxes"? Do you find this to be a valid claim?
 
Do you want to debate me on the 911freeforum about thermite?

I want to debate you on the 911freeforum about thermite!

I have one ground rule: Straight questions must be answered straight and honestly.

As for the rest of the rules, we can discuss that.
I propose to introduce as material to discuss all the studies on WTC red-gray chips that have been done so far:
  • "Active Thermitic Material..." (Harrit et al, 2009)
  • "Why the red/gray chips aren't paint" (Harrit, 2009)
  • Mark Basile's 2010 presentation
  • James Millette's 2012 report to Chris Mohr.
Rules: No poisoning the well. Anyone wanting to dismiss any of the data as tampered or fabricated must show proof it's tampered and fabricated.


ETA: If this thread continues to swell and explode like it did the last 24 hours or so, there's a chance I might miss your response to this. If you still have my email address, drop me a one-liner with a link to your response if you seriously consider doing that discussion on the other forum.
 
Last edited:
Go ahead. Step up and tell everyone what your CD scenario is. For some reason, you will not.

Why is that? Can you not fathom how it is that your current fellow traveller is proposing explosives enclosed in "aircraft black boxes"? Do you find this to be a valid claim?
At least the black box to protect the explosives was new, new nonsense from the "no evidence followers" of CD who cut and past 9/11 truth taglines.

The only evidence for Tony's realcddeal is stuff like this...
... it is pretty clear that they are shills who cannot admit that the buildings came down via controlled demolition no matter how much evidence is put before them.

I only come on here occasionally for the benefit of any possible lurkers who come here and might not know many of the details and be on the fence.
How much evidence has Tony presented? Zero (a term used in math for zip, nothing, etc, but math is prohibited in 9/11 truth)

We are shills to Tony. Tony has no evidence. Thus because he knows we are shills, it has to be CD.

CD is based on fantasy and paranoia - proof of paranoia, "we are shills".
 
We need an investigation that provides one and explains the observations.


Why? We have evidence that fire, in conjunction with impact damage, was responsible for the collapse of WTC 1, WTC 2, WTC 7, and the internal collapse of WTC 5.

Investigators, demolition experts, structural experts, and firefighters have concluded that CD explosives had nothing to do with the collapse of those buildings, which is backed by overwhelming evidence, so why waste additional time and money on an investigation that is going to use the same evidence and arrive at the same conclusion?

.
 
Last edited:
You surely realize by we I meant everyone, including you and all the others here.

We need an investigation that provides one and explains the observations.

Yes, i realize that is what you mean.

"Everyone" includes you, AE911truth and the entire Truth Movement, correct, Tony? <- Please answer this straight and honestly.

Since the only straight and honest answer to that question is "yes", you will have confirmed that what I said is 100% correct:

You, Tony Szamboti, finally admitted that you, AE911Truth and the entire Truth Movement have no plausible theory on how the WTC 7 building collapsed to the ground. <- Tony, please acknowledge that this is true - we can all see that this is obviously true by back-tracking three or four posts in this exchange. It just would be very nice to see you admitting something for a change, to see you being honest.



Now, you are correct that YOU "mean" that "we" don't have a plausible theory for WTC7. Alas, you are simply mistaken about this - we have several even. Your beloved CD is not among them, of course. How could it be? There exists no CD hypothesis for WTC7 after all, right, Tony? <- It would be really nice of you to answer that straight question straight and honestly - I have asked it often enough, and we all understand that your failure to respond amounts to you being painfully conscious that you can't link me to any CD hypothesis for WTC7, for if you could, you would - I asked for a URL often enough.
 
Or you could wake-up, acknowledge that multiple investigations by the world's foremost subject matter experts have reasonably determined fire the most likely cause of the observed collapse, and move on with your life. The door is wide open for you now that you know you were fundamentally mistaken about how the fires in the building behaved. Get out and find purpose in something else.

It sounds like you need to be reminded that it was I who first brought it to the public's attention that Nordenson's analysis had a fatal error which invalidated the ARUP report as a legitimate explanation for the collapse of WTC 7.
 
It sounds like you need to be reminded that it was I who first brought it to the public's attention that Nordenson's analysis had a fatal error which invalidated the ARUP report as a legitimate explanation for the collapse of WTC 7.

Sounds like you need to be reminded that you never proved Nordenson's error was fatal because Nordenson also assumed the lower floors were all pristine, which we know wasn't the case. To know whether Nordenson's error was fatal to his propagation hypothesis, we'd need to know whether, correcting for the error, propagation could still have occurred under any reasonable set of floor condition assumptions. And we know now that WAI undertook the exact analyses necessary to determine that in response to Nordenson and found, much to your chagrin, that Nordenson's error wasn't fatal at all, which is why you tried (unsuccessfully) to attack WAI's analyses with your fundamentally flawed claims re heating.

And here we are. Amazing how quickly we can run that loop if we try.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like you need to be reminded that you never proved Nordenson's error was fatal because Nordenson also assumed the lower floors were all pristine, which we know wasn't the case. To know whether Nordenson's error was fatal to his propagation hypothesis, we'd need to know whether, correcting for the error, propagation could still have occurred under any reasonable set of floor condition assumptions. And we know now that WAI undertook the exact analyses necessary to determine that in response to Nordenson and found, much to your chagrin, that Nordenson's error wasn't fatal at all, which is why you tried (unsuccessfully) to attack WAI's analyses with your fundamentally flawed claims re heating.

And here we are. Amazing how quickly we can run that loop if we try.

Get real. I showed it couldn't happen by a significant margin even with the girder below at 500 degrees C. Additionally, for the scenario you want to create the fires on floors 11 and 12 would have to track each other. That is so improbable as to be laughable. NIST doesn't even have girder A2001 at 500 C on both floor 13 and 12 at the same time. You have no leg to stand on with regard to the invalidation of Nordenson's analysis and are just blowing smoke now.

WAI's steel temperatures are extraordinary and actually impossible for the size of the fire protected beams in WTC 7 in a normal office fire. Unsurprisingly, they have no substantiation, as the analysis they are alleged to have come from hasn't been made public and I doubt it ever will be.
 
Last edited:
Get real. I showed it couldn't happen by a significant margin with the NIST steel temperature of 500 degrees C on the girder below.


I have proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that fire, in conjunction with impact damage, was responsible for the destruction of WTC 7 and I have proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that explosives had nothing to do with the collapse of WTC 7.

We have evidence of uncontrolled fires that raged for hours and impact damage on the southern wall of WTC 7, but absolutely no evidence that involved explosives.
 
Get real. I showed it couldn't happen by a significant margin with the NIST steel temperature of 500 degrees C on the girder below. Which is relatively high but still possible. Additionally, for the scenario you want to create the fires on floors 11 and 12 would have to track each other. That is so improbable as to be laughable. You have no leg to stand on with regard to the invalidation of Nordenson's analysis and are just blowing smoke now.

WAI's steel temperatures are extraordinary and actually impossible in a normal office fire. Unsurprisingly, they have no substantiation, as the analysis they are alleged to have come from hasn't been made public.

You didn't show that collapse couldn't propagate under any scenario, Tony. You claimed to have done some analyses on your end to that end, but you never shared that analysis. In any case, it sounds like the analysis you did was very simplistic (it sucks for you that I have a pretty good memory, I know), especially compared to what WAI did (a fulsome model of the floor collapses).

Everyone here can go to page Section 2.4 at page 28 and Appendix C at page C-19 of the WAI report and see what a realistic model of floor collapse propagation that corrects for Nordenson's error looks like. You can huff, you can puff, but you can't blow the facts down.
 
Last edited:
You didn't show that collapse couldn't propagate under any scenario, Tony. You claimed to have done some analyses on your end to that end, but you never shared that analysis. In any case, it sounds like the analysis you did was very simplistic (it sucks for you that I have a pretty good memory, I know), especially compared to what WAI did (a fulsome model of the floor collapses).

Everyone here can go to page C-19 of the WAI report and see what a realistic model of floor collapse propagation that corrects for Nordenson's error looks like. You can huff, you can puff, but you can't blow the facts down.

I shared the analysis with the girder below at ambient temperature and then explained that a temperature of 500 degrees C drops the yield strength down to 70% of room temperature. Since the factor of safety at room temp was about 3 to 1, then at 500 C it would still be 2 to 1 against failure. This isn't very hard to understand and you are blowing a lot of smoke now.
 
Last edited:
I shared the analysis with the girder below at ambient temperature and then explained that a temperature of 500 degrees C drops the yield strength down to 70% of room temperature. Since the factor of safety at room temp was about 3 to 1, then at 500 C it would still be 2 to 1 against failure. This isn't very hard to understand and you are blowing a lot of smoke now.

Wow, you claim you modeled a whole girder at a single temperature (which temperature you picked out of a hat)? I apologize! You definitely proved WAI's fulsome model of floor collapse propagation incorrect. Should we email Dr. Abboud and demand he resign?
 
Last edited:
Wow, you claim you modeled a whole girder at a single temperature (which temperature you picked out of a hat)? I apologize! You definitely proved WAI's fulsome model of floor collapse propagation incorrect. Should we email Dr. Abboud and demand he resign?
Like I said.
FEMbot. He has no idea what any of the stuff he does really means, or what its telling him.
But it is possibly a good model of that slice of the system at that particular time. Now he just needs to do it for the other 100's of thousands of beams, columns, trusses, and assorted structure, then put them all together...
 
I shared the analysis with the girder below at ambient temperature and then explained that a temperature of 500 degrees C drops the yield strength down to 70% of room temperature. Since the factor of safety at room temp was about 3 to 1, then at 500 C it would still be 2 to 1 against failure. This isn't very hard to understand and you are blowing a lot of smoke now.

It's a good thing only that one girder, that one component got warm then. That must mean 7 WTC is still standing because if it isn't then something is seriously wrong with your methodology.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom