The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis

jeffreyw: Basically a lie that "all stars shine in the visible spectrum"

all stars shine in the visible spectrum.
19 June 2017 jeffreyw: Basically a lie that "all stars shine in the visible spectrum".
Main-sequence stars have temperatures so that the majority of their light is in the visible spectrum. Other stars can emit little visible light, e.g. neutron stars with a surface temperature around 600000 K. Brown dwarfs can have temperature down to between 500 and 600 K. Stellar black holes are also considered stars.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: More ignorance - stellar black holes are stars that do not shine

If it doesn't shine then it cannot possibly be a "star".
19 June 2017 jeffreyw: More ignorance - stellar black holes are stars that do not shine!
Currently white dwarf stars have temperatures of a few thousand K and so emit visible light ("shine") but they are cooling down so in the future they will not shine but will still be stars.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance about stars - they get hotter as they age

Yet, according to the law of conservation of mass and energy, if something loses mass and energy, as do stars, then they will be less massive and less energetic.
19 June 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance about stars - they get more energetic as they age.
Stars get hotter because fusion converts hydrogen to helium, their core gets denser, pressures and so temperature increases. The usual reaction (p-p) becomes more efficient and the additional CNO cycle starts up. As an example the Sun has got about 15% hotter during the last 3.5 billion years (since life began).
The loss of mass is insignificant.
 
Last edited:
I've been trying to tell them. The main paper has 3,024 unique I.P. downloads so there has to be something happening. But really, I've been reading the Structure of Scientific Revolutions by Thomas Kuhn, and I wholeheartedly agree that the new paradigm that I am working on is already in "normal science" mode, and it is incommensurable, to the outdated paradigm full of counterinstances.

The main incommensurability is in the definitions of the words offered. For instance to the dogma, all stars shine in the visible spectrum. If it doesn't shine then it cannot possibly be a "star". Yet, according to the law of conservation of mass and energy, if something loses mass and energy, as do stars, then they will be less massive and less energetic.

Therefore we should expect the evolved stars to be less massive and less energetic, to the point that they no longer shine and are very small. This is very straight forward, though incommensurable. I have now defined stars that are "alive" and still evolving via chemical equilibrium. When I say "star" I mean all stages of a star, even dead ones such as Mercury. When astronomers say "star" they think objects that shine in the visible spectrum. We will talk past one another. This is partly due to them not being well-rounded and ignoring history of these types of paradigm shifts.

Stellar evolution (planet formation) is now defined in terms of chemistry, which has never been done before. It is also only natural to define planet formation as centered on the central science, chemistry. Without mentioning large scale chemical principles in reference to the old stars (which contain vast amounts of chemicals), then the theories/models used to explain the processes concerning their formation are misguided at best.

So in short, all stars can now be defined appropriately, not just from the 18-19th century assumption that they all shine brightly in the visible spectrum.

So the incommensurability is this: I refer to stars in terms of chemistry, and the dogma refers to stars in terms of nuclear reactions and planets absent chemical principles, regardless if planets are GIANT balls of chemicals and crystalline/liquid structure formed from chemical, (thermochemical/electrochemical/photochemical) reactions. I have outlined this fact in this paper:

http://vixra.org/pdf/1706.0373v1.pdf

We have two very different world views. One is situated in the early 20th century based on a plethora of assumptions that have no statistical significance (none of the early assumptions knew of stars in intermediate stages of evolution such as brown dwarfs, or the most ancient stars, mislabeled "planet/exoplanet"), and the other situated in a currently fast growing statistical analysis of the objects observed, which show a continuous pattern of mass loss, diminishing radiation, diminishing gravitational fields, changing chemical composition, shrinking atmospheres and even growing internal structure as the central object forms, as evidenced by the very ground we are walking on.

So its up to the people here. Work on the new paradigm with me, or ignore it and call me a pseudoscientist. I don't really care anymore. People do their own convincing. I'm just here to point people in the direction astronomy is headed, because I'm leading it, without approval of academics.

How can you lead when no one is following? Its a rhetorical question.
 
jeffreyw: The astrophysics community does not read a crank site

I've been trying to tell them.
19 June 2017 jeffreyw: The astrophysics community does not read a crank PDF upload site or do science by YouTube video!

If you were trying to tell the astrophysics community then you would publish your paper in an astrophysics journal or the arXiv preprint site. There is no evidence of that - not even rejections - which shows that you are not brave or competent enough to do this.
 
How can you lead when no one is following? Its a rhetorical question.

No one is following? Right. I have totaled the views on my vixra.org page and it is a little over 28,000 Unique I.P. downloads. People are paying attention. As to "following" I know they like many of the ideas I have presented. They have told me that lots of what I am mentioning makes sense, as opposed to the dogma.

That is one thing I've learned about scientific discovery, you can be a great scientific leader and not have many followers. All I need is about 10 people to fully comprehend the theory, and I think there are roughly 25 who have set aside the time to read it and understand what it means.

As well, some people might accept some of the ideas I have, but reject others, so it is a mixed bag for the most part. I wouldn't want people accepting all my ideas, because they need to think for themselves. The fact though is that unless they think for themselves, then its no use. They will repeat whatever the authorities say and remain stagnant in thoughts and in spirit. Essentially by not thinking for themselves they cease being a scientist.

As well, this is human insight, and leadership with insights works much differently when your ideas stretch over many decades/centuries and even millenia. This all means that if you think leadership in science amounts to giving orders and having "followers" you are mistaken. A simple, insightful idea can stretch across the entire Earth almost instantaneously, and its effects can be felt well beyond the originators life.

I expect this idea to be accepted well beyond my own death. I have already come to terms with that. Knowing that I am going to die without full recognition of the insight I come to peace with. With that being said, I must continue work to the best of my ability.
 
jeffreyw: Repeats the delusion of astronomy being dogma

No one is following?
No one from the astrophysics community follows a crank PDF upload site. People accidently reading the delusion that planets are old stars in your PDFs will mostly be laughing at you, not following you. The rest are too ignorant or deluded to recognize the obvious ignorance or delusion in your PDFs as shown in this thread.

jeffreyw: 112 items of ignorance and delusion since 15th January 2015 :eye-poppi!
  1. 8 June 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorant delusion of water being created in stars at temperatures of 1000s of degrees.
  2. 8 June 2017 jeffreyw: Repeat of the "establishment dogma" lie.
  3. 8 June 2017 jeffreyw: Lies about astronomy not having mechanisms to explain water oceans - one is seeding by comets!
  4. 8 June 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorance about the possible origins of water for oceans (it is not only comets).
  5. 8 June 2017 jeffreyw: A fantasy ("prediction") that is wrong - we have not detected any ocean worlds.
  6. 16 June 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorance of the solved angular momentum problem leads to a fantasy about the nebular hypothesis being falsified.
  7. 19 June 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that "objects between 3-15 Earth masses are very, very common".
  8. 19 June 2017 jeffreyw: A deluded "Neptune is a Star" PDF on a PDF upload web site.
  9. 19 June 2017 jeffreyw: A deluded "Uranus is a Star" PDF on a PDF upload web site.
  10. 19 June 2017 jeffreyw: A deluded, lying "TRAPPIST-1" PDF on a PDF upload web site.
  11. 19 June 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance about astronomy -"nebular disks" are galaxies outside of the Milky Way, not stellar systems in formation inside of the Milky Way!
  12. 19 June 2017 jeffreyw: The 2011 article is that the theories of gas drag alone cannot explain the number of exo-Neptunes. So migration through planets interacting is added.
  13. 19 June 2017 jeffreyw: Kuhn's book is not that science is interrupted by obscure and ignorant delusions such as an idea that planets are old stars.
  14. 19 June 2017 jeffreyw: Repeated delusion of astrophysics being dogma.
  15. 19 June 2017 jeffreyw: Basically a lie that "all stars shine in the visible spectrum".
  16. 19 June 2017 jeffreyw: More ignorance - stellar black holes are stars that do not shine!
  17. 19 June 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance about stars - they get more energetic as they age, e.g. the Sun.
  18. 19 June 2017 jeffreyw: The astrophysics community does not read a crank PDF upload site or do science by YouTube video!
19 June 2017 jeffreyw: Repeats the delusion of astronomy being dogma.
 
jeffreyw: A lie about a "great scientific leader " not having many followers

That is one thing I've learned about scientific discovery, you can be a great scientific leader and not have many followers.
19 June 2017 jeffreyw: A lie about a "great scientific leader" not having many followers (with the implied delusion that he is one!).
A scientific leader in any field has many followers - that is practically the definition of a scientific leader. They publish their discovery. It is seen as correct and quickly spreads through the scientific community gaining many proponents. A sign of a "great scientific leader" is that they can convince the majority of the scientific community that their scientific discovery is correct.
 
Last edited:
A pop science article?
Is there a research article accepted by 'mainstream' science you can cite? And provide evidence that it is widely accepted?

:)

https://www-n.oca.eu/morby/papers/P177.pdf

On another note, I have redefined Chthonian planets in light of the principle of atmospheric thinning inside of GTSM.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1706.0383v1.pdf

The formation mechanism of Chthonians (as referenced to be hypothetical objects according to the dogma) is irrelevant in light of GTSM, as the atmospheres thin on all stars, thus ALL rocky worlds with differentiated interiors and iron/nickel cores are Chthonians. This meaning there isn't a separate class of objects at all. The separate class simply means they have mistaken the formation mechanisms of all evolved stars as being somehow mutually exclusive of planet formation.

Planet formation is stellar evolution. No separate class of Chthonians is needed.

Heck, even Neptunes can be considered Chthonians, as they have also had a large amount of their hydrogen and helium disintegrate away, regardless if they are in late middle stages of stellar evolution.

Neptune%2BCommon.JPG
 
Jeffrey's manner of stating his assertions reminded me of a series of old Calvin and Hobbes cartoon strips. Calvin's process and the reception his ideas received are quite similar to jeffrey's. I like to think Calvin learned from his experience; I wish I had more hope that jeffrey will.

http://batsrock.blogspot.com/2011/02/inspired-quote-why-bats-are-not-bugs.html

That's what confuses me about this forum. The ideas I present are not only mine. Two other people before me have drawn this understanding up before I did.

Alexander Oparin:

http://www.valencia.edu/orilife/textos/The%20Origin%20of%20Life.pdf

Anthony Abruzzo:

http://gsjournal.net/Science-Journals/Research%20Papers-Astrophysics/Download/1160

I asked Mr. Abruzzo why he hasn't continued working on the theory, and he stated that their are interests involved that are beyond his control. To summarize it, I think he wasn't interested in working on the theory simply because it was out of his control as to the acceptance of it. Fact is, he kept it secret for a long time, afraid someone would "steal" the idea before he could claim priority.

Turns out that's not how it was going to go down. The truth is that if you have a great idea, you cannot even force people to look at it or try to understand it. It doesn't matter how great of an idea it is. People will refuse it and call you names, trying their best to place you in a an invisible box with labels attached. That's human nature I guess, place things in a box with a label if it is beyond us. Its too much work to actually think. It is much easier to ridicule.

With Mr. Oparin, he simply was neglected by his own peers, when it came to astronomy/astrophysics related matters. Miller and Urey gave him the time of day though to test his hypothesis, of abiogenic life, only because they were chemists. Not only that but he worked in Soviet Russia back in the day, so there was a huge wall between western ideas and themselves. Who knows what we would know these days if biology and astronomy were not doubly compartmentalized (Soviet Russia and turf wars among academics).

If anything, I'm just taking up the torch for Mr. Oparin (because he's dead) and Mr. Abruzzo, he's much older now and is more concerned with his own life. I'm much younger, so I have more energy and time to work on this, and will continue to do so, even when other people jump on board, which I expect to happen slowly as it currently has.
 
No one is following? Right. I have totaled the views on my vixra.org page and it is a little over 28,000 Unique I.P. downloads. People are paying attention. As to "following" I know they like many of the ideas I have presented. They have told me that lots of what I am mentioning makes sense, as opposed to the dogma.

That is one thing I've learned about scientific discovery, you can be a great scientific leader and not have many followers. All I need is about 10 people to fully comprehend the theory, and I think there are roughly 25 who have set aside the time to read it and understand what it means.

As well, some people might accept some of the ideas I have, but reject others, so it is a mixed bag for the most part. I wouldn't want people accepting all my ideas, because they need to think for themselves. The fact though is that unless they think for themselves, then its no use. They will repeat whatever the authorities say and remain stagnant in thoughts and in spirit. Essentially by not thinking for themselves they cease being a scientist.

As well, this is human insight, and leadership with insights works much differently when your ideas stretch over many decades/centuries and even millenia. This all means that if you think leadership in science amounts to giving orders and having "followers" you are mistaken. A simple, insightful idea can stretch across the entire Earth almost instantaneously, and its effects can be felt well beyond the originators life.

I expect this idea to be accepted well beyond my own death. I have already come to terms with that. Knowing that I am going to die without full recognition of the insight I come to peace with. With that being said, I must continue work to the best of my ability.

People pay attention to all sorts of nonsense, such as flat Earth vids, Kim Kardashian. However, popularity ain't no barometer to scientific truth. Your kajones are big grasshopper.
 
jeffreyw: Repeats his lie abut Alexander Oparin stating that planets are old stars

Two other people before me have drawn this understanding up before I did.
20 June 2017 jeffreyw: A lie about Alexander Oparin stating that planets are old stars.
The biologist Oparin compares the "cooling" of stars to the cooling of planets: "Thus a study of the different heavenly bodies gives us an idea of the different stages of the cooling of our own planet". The problem is that we know today (maybe not in 1924) stars do not actually cool - they get hotter. The Sun was 75% cooler 3.8 to 2.5 billion years ago.

23 February 2017 jeffreyw: Lies about Alexander Oparin, "The Origin of Life" (a 1924 booklet).
23 February 2017 jeffreyw: A lie by cherry picking Oparin (1924) when there are 1936 and 1956 editions of "Origin of Life"
 
jeffreyw: An ignorant crank citing another ignorant crank (Anthony Abruzzo)

20 June 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant crank citing another ignorant crank (Anthony Abruzzo)!

The PDF is "Are Planets the End Products Rather than the By-Products of Stellar Evolution?" by Anthony J. Abruzzo, M.Phil.
Anthony J. Abruzzo is a philosopher, not an astronomer or scientist. This shows up in the rather deep level of ignorance of science in that and other papers.
This is basically a fantasy. The main idiocy is that proton decay could transform stellar objects into the sub-stellar objects that we see today. The experimental results are a half-life greater than 1.67×1034 years. That is 1034 years for half of a star to decay. The age of the universe is 13.8 billion (109) years which he knows :jaw-dropp! That is where the fantasy is obvious - he hopes that the age of the universe is between the debunked Steady State theory (infinite!) and the established Big Bang theory.
That "paper" was published in the general science journal in 2008 so he should have known better. His other papers are worse, e.g. in "Formation and Age of the Solar System" he essentially accuses scientists of faking data to get similar dates.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
jeffreyw: A PDF lying about the hypothesis of Chthonian planets

On another note, I have redefined Chthonian planets ...
20 June 2017 jeffreyw: A PDF lying about the hypothesis of Chthonian planets.
They are a hypothesis: Chthonian planet
Chthonian planets (/ˈkθoʊniən/, sometimes 'cthonian') are a hypothetical class of celestial objects resulting from the stripping away of a gas giant's hydrogen and helium atmosphere and outer layers, which is called hydrodynamic escape. Such atmospheric stripping is a likely result of proximity to a star. The remaining rocky or metallic core would resemble a terrestrial planet in many respects.[1]
They are not rocky planets. Rocky planets are not Chthonian planets.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom