The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've been told but I don't know. That Knox' supporters are largely:

1. a band of white knights who want to rescue the damsel in distress (as per a well-worn Hollywood script, ever since King Kong in 1947)

2. People with a 'claim to fame', such as Stacyhs, with link's to Knox' family, friends or friends of friends.

3. paid shills and PR agents. It is a fact Curt Knox hired PR agency Gogerty-Marriott (now just Marriott) even before he got a defence lawyer.

4. Those 'bleeding hearts' who automatically support the likes of the so-called Lockerbie Bomber, Lundy, Avery, Dassey, Ferguson, Bamber: all these poor people oppressed by a Kafka-esque faceless bureaucracy.

I used to be #4 and then after the Kercher case, and the A1 murder case (Hanratty), I got wise to the tactics of the defence lawyers and subtley biased 'documentary' makers who now cynically use the documentary genre to put forward subversive propaganda in the guise of 'miscarriage of justice'.

If we have a good justice system, fair, objective and cold, we don't need all this emotional blackmail crap.



"I've been told but I don't know"
?

What the hell does this piece of BS even mean?

Do you have evidence that I am "prone to hero-worship or infatuation", as you directly claimed in your earlier post, Vixen?

If you don't (and I'm very strongly guessing/suggesting you don't), then please do the intellectually-honest thing and withdraw/apologise. Assuming, that is, that you DO have intellectual honesty, Vixen.......?
 
Bill Williams said:
It's not exactly hero-worship but it is becoming obvious that Vixen is among a small a vocal group of Mignini advocates. These are the things Mignini would want to say, when he feels insulted that Cassation put a stop to his predatory prosecution.

Except for his submission with regard to alleging that Maori and Lanagan had defamed him, he's too cowardly to say it for himself. So he relies on surrogates.

What a ridiculous take.

Well, I wouldn't say, "ridiculous". Fanciful maybe. At the very least it is on par with the dozens of bizarre controversies you, yourself, fabricate.

True, there's no proof of my claim - yet I can see it in your eyes! I can read it in your mind, much like you are able to know people's very thoughts.

You could help me along by once in a while arguing something that does not originate from Mignini. Of course, this would mean ignoring Peter Quennell's TJMK and his "100s of lawyers". Quoting blindly from TJMK or the fake-Wiki will expose you to pure Mignini. (Look at all the fan-girl stuff you yourself have posted about how upright and honest he is! You'd have though he hadn't embarrassed himself at all with the Monster of Florence or the Kercher Murder trials.)

Remember Marasca/Bruno's term? "Amnesiac investigation"? I bet Mignini loved that one.

Tell you what - quote evidence from the Massei trial which Massei derived not from Mignini. There's plenty of it. Do you realize that Massei in 2010 wrote that this was Rudy's crime, and that he could not see why Knox would urge Rudy to do anything violent to Meredith? That the bad-urges were all Rudy's?

Quote evidence from Crini and the second conviction.... Crini mailed that one in, and won anyway. Why is that?
 
Last edited:
As it is an established fact (so sue me!) that Knox was present during the murder at the scene of the crime (Marasca, Florence) then she could have rung the emergency services or banged on the door of a neighbour, immediately. A good 12-15 hours earlier, when the time of death could be established exactly and the crime scene sealed off and rendered untampered with by persons galloping around the scene, as they did.


Give us all a good laugh, Vixen, and remind us exactly how/why it came to be an "established fact" (an established judicial fact, that is - you seem unable to differentiate between an empirical fact and a judicial fact.....) that Knox was present at the scene of the murder.

(Hint: you'll have to refer to Knox's criminal slander conviction :D )
 
Millions of dollars of other people's money.
Not sure, what that remark about other people's money means. Oh well, Raffaele has family money. So?
When will the obknoxious Knox pay Patrick his €42K as ordered by the court?
Obnoxious? And you said you don't dislike Amanda? You've never met Amanda and yet you refer to her that way. Why? If Patrick wants money. Why doesn't he deal with the morons that put him there, the Perugian authorities? In my view, Amanda doesn't owe him a dime.

I note she never mentions her conviction and rightful four year's in prison concerning this big gentle Congolese man who was like an uncle to her and never hurt a fly.
Nothing right about it. And how do you know that about Patrick? You don't. Just like the rest of it. You pulled it out of your backside.
She only got a column in West Seattle Herald because of the 'novelty value' in having a mu notorious criminal from Seattle writing for them, and the newspaper owner's son got to get his leg over.
You don't know that. For someone who says they don't dislike Amanda, you sure make lots of petty remarks about her. Yes Amanda has a well known name. And she wouldn't be well known if publications worldwide didn't write stories about her. I guess the only person who shouldn't profit from her own name is Amanda? Amanda wanted to be a writer BEFORE she went to Italy. If you don't like Amanda so much, why read every article she writes?
 
After all these years of "analysing" this case, you're STILL unaware of the fact that since the mid-1990s Italy has used the adversarial system of criminal justice (though some reactionary types such as Mignini and many judges still seem to wish it was the inquisitorial system, and appear to act as such)?

Oh dear.

It's all rather revealing. If people wouldn't have the urge to defame random Seattleites they might actually notice other more core things.
 
It is a fact Knox wrote rape/murder fantasies before she even arrived in Italy.
You say 'it is a fact' all the time. Which usually means it is not. This entire thread for the last 3 years has been you posting untruths and fabrication after obfuscation and calling them facts.
It is a common observation that her grammar, syntax and spelling are appalling. You can see an alarming improvement when it is polished up - obviously by an editor when published by a glossy magazine or a proper newspaper, such as LA Times.
Common observation by the NUTJOBS over at TJMK and PMF? Can't you see, that you are desperately seeking out reasons to insult Amanda? I've been reading her columns and while I'm not always interested in her subjects I have found her grammar syntax and spelling to be just fine.

The stuff about philosophy, political theory and literary references obviously come from Party Rock, largely.
Another out of your ass deduction. How many ways must you find to insult Amanda? Anything valuable had to come from someone else as opposed to the graduate student who speaks three languages and is a voracious reader?

As an aside to your usual anti-Christian swipe, homosexuality is not considered a 'sin', it is homosexual sex that is said to be so, according to the scriptures.

You don't think I know this? But it is a lie practiced by smarmy better than thou Christians all the time. They make me want to vomit. It's like you saying you don't dislike Amanda, you just dislike everything she does says and writes. It's disingenuous crap.
 
Last edited:
After all these years of "analysing" this case, you're STILL unaware of the fact that since the mid-1990s Italy has used the adversarial system of criminal justice (though some reactionary types such as Mignini and many judges still seem to wish it was the inquisitorial system, and appear to act as such)?

Oh dear.

The link below is to a study by John Head, where his original intent was to argue that the transitions in Italy's criminal system did not have any direct bearing on the Kercher murder trials.

http://law.ku.edu/sites/law.ku.edu/files/docs/comparative-criminal-procedure-essay-john-head.pdf

Yet even the "Author's update" of Feb 2015 - a month prior to the eventual exonerations - provide an important commentary on the Knox/Sollecito case as it related to the system-transitions.

It's an interesting read - probably because it is obviously NOT biased towards Knox/Sollecito, while at the same time being able to listen to defence advocates like Michael Scadron.

Yet another criticism regarding the handling of the Amanda Knox case
suggests that members of the Italian judiciary – or specifically those
members of it involved in the case – have intentionally subverted the proper machinery of justice in order to cover up a seriously compromised and mishandled procedure . . . or, expressed more simplistically, that the system itself is broadly corrupted by a sense (among some or many members of the judiciary) that “patriotism prevails over justice”. (I am indebted to S. Michael Scandron for drawing my attention to this criticism.) If there is some validity to this criticism, then it would support not only an abandonment of the conviction(s) and corrective action in Italy; it would also serve to highlight the sort of difficulty that I emphasized in my article. My
centerpiece proposition in the article (see pages 8-13 and 19-20, below) is
that any “transplantation” of elements from one legal system into another
legal system is bound to create discomfort and dissent. Indeed, Italy’s
adoption a quarter-century ago of an American-inspired accusatorialadversarial
approach to criminal procedure has created a great deal of such
discomfort and dissent, even to the extent of requiring a constitutional
amendment to overcome strenuous objections.​

Yet with this said, Head is of the opinion that these transitions did not, in themselves, create the problem Knox/Sollecito-defenders claim:

What I believe would not warrant close attention – and this is
my main purpose in using the Amanda Knox case to illustrate some key
themes I developed in my article – are those criticisms that rest on a
misunderstanding of certain fundamental differences between criminal
procedure in Italy (and civil law countries more generally) and criminal
procedure in the USA and other common law countries. While there are
undoubtedly several immutable principles of criminal procedure – fair
treatment of persons under investigation, competent handling of evidence,
adequate opportunity to mount a defense, independence and integrity of
judges, and the like – the existence of some structural and ideological
differences among various countries in their response to criminal conduct is
natural and legitimate.​
What I am NOW looking for is anything he's written since March 2015 and the exonerations.

I found this while looking for another paper written by a woman about the legal-transitions begun in 1989 in Italy, where she, too, used the AK/RS trials as a case in point. That one was far more favourable to innocence for AK/RS and how the transitions played a part in skewing the search for truth in Italy.

But you think I can find it?
 
Last edited:
Give us all a good laugh, Vixen, and remind us exactly how/why it came to be an "established fact" (an established judicial fact, that is - you seem unable to differentiate between an empirical fact and a judicial fact.....) that Knox was present at the scene of the murder.

(Hint: you'll have to refer to Knox's criminal slander conviction :D )

To repeat - even Judge Massei in his 2010 motivations report said that there was no forensic evidence, none at all, to support the notion that Knox had rubbed Meredith's blood from her hands. Even Stefanoni supported this notion in conceding that trace-DNA by definition cannot have its origin known.

Massei plainly said in 2010 that he came to this conclusion on other grounds, mainly that that notion was "compatible" with other evidence, which in turn was "compatible" with the overall thesis he thought of as valid.

Massei built his thesis on compatibilities, not on evidence. And of note was that the compatibilities Massei found persuasive DO NOT ORIGINATE from the case Mignini brought - yet, Mignini surrogates here and at TJMK comtinue to argue Mignini's theories as if they'd ever been deemed as factual.
 
Last edited:
ROFLMAO

This is the epitome of ignorance of how forensics can help crime investigators."

This is your response to Welshman writing "People who believe that someone's DNA being found in their own bathroom is incriminating are not in a position to accuse people of being stupid."

So Vixen, please explain how finding Amanda's DNA on Amanda's bathroom sink was so obviously helpful to the forensic investigation. I think there's a huge opportunity here for all of us to learn something because I'm pretty sure most of us here are of the opinion that Amanda's DNA should have been there, and since DNA can't be dated we don't really understand how it helped. Obviously we're all displaying a bit of "epitome of ignorance" here, so please help us out...
 
The point is, they were not going to. Ask yourself why the Carabinieri were sent out to arrest them. Because Vecchiotti & Conti corruptly produced a DVD which they prepared to help the defence .

Vecchiotti was later convicted of gross negligence in another murder case where she refused to test the DNA of the murderer for 19 years until ordered to. She and Pascali were ordered to pay €150,000 each to the murder victim's husband. This is a woman who abuses her office to help murderers avoid prison.

This is untrue. Why do you make up facts?

It was a civil case so there was no conviction. It was negligence not gross negligence. The respondents in the case were Pascali, Arbarrello and Vecchiotti.

Vecchiotti et al were brought into the case in 2007, the murder occurred in 1991, the DNA of the murderer was identified by the carabinieri using LCN testing (a technique that Vecchiotti did not have access to) in 2011. So at most the period was 4 years, not 19 years. The big failing was that the police / prosecutor failed to listen to / transcribe an intercepted telephone call from 1991 in which the murderer admitted the murder until 2011. In Italy you cannot sue the police / prosecutor for incompetence, so Vecchiotti et al are a surrogate for the police failure over 19 years. The husband is quite clear who he blames in his posts.

The payment was ordered to be made to a charity. The money partly funded scholarships at La Sapienza university, where Vecchiotti works, an implication that there was not strong animosity between the husband and Vecchiotti.
 
This is your response to Welshman writing "People who believe that someone's DNA being found in their own bathroom is incriminating are not in a position to accuse people of being stupid."

So Vixen, please explain how finding Amanda's DNA on Amanda's bathroom sink was so obviously helpful to the forensic investigation. I think there's a huge opportunity here for all of us to learn something because I'm pretty sure most of us here are of the opinion that Amanda's DNA should have been there, and since DNA can't be dated we don't really understand how it helped. Obviously we're all displaying a bit of "epitome of ignorance" here, so please help us out...

Amanda lived in the cottage which means it was perfectly normal for Amanda to leave DNA in her own bathroom and DNA would have been deposited before the night of the murder. DNA can’t be dated which makes it impossible to establish when DNA has been deposited. When Guede murdered Meredith he carried Meredith’s blood into the bathroom which resulted in Meredith’s blood being mixed with Amanda’s DNA which was already in the bathroom. PGP posters can’t grasp this simple notion. To suggest Amanda’s DNA being found in her own bathroom is incriminating is ludicrous and anyone who believes this notion is not in a position to call anyone stupid.
 
I would have thought that what was done to Mez was something deviant, perverted, dirty, etc.

You have to admit Knox is not the sharpest knife in the tool box, automatically blaming 'the black man' and claiming amnesia for the night of the murder.

How dumb is it to believe the prosecutor fancies you.

In view of how Vixen has attacked Amanda for not being the sharpest tool in the box, the gross stupidity of PGP posters deserves to come under scrutiny. Instances of stupidity displayed by PGP :-
• PGP posters constantly and viciously attack Amanda and Raffaele for telling numerous lies. Below are some of the posts from Vixen containing falsehoods and details of the numerous instances where PGP have condoned and ignored the lies of others. PGP don’t understand the simple concept that it is hypocritical to attack someone for lying when habitually lying yourself and condoning the lies of others.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=11938562#post11938562
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11942852#post11942852
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11598412#post11598412
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11427461#post11427461
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11951893#post11951893
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=11333243#post11333243

• Vixen constantly brags about the overwhelming evidence against Amanda and Raffaele. The conduct of the prosecution and the methods they had to resort to detailed below completely contradicts this. Basic common sense dictates a prosecution with a mountain of evidence and a slam dunk case don’t need to resort to suppressing evidence, destroying evidence, telling numerous lies, smear tactics etc. The conduct of the prosecution made it blatantly obvious the prosecution had a weak case, a lack of evidence, the facts didn’t support their case and there were major problems with the prosecution’s case. PGP can’t understand this simple concept.

http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/raffaeles-kitchen-knife/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/contamination-labwork-coverup/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/meredith-kercher-perjury-corruption/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/evidence-destroyed/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/blood-evidence-downstairs-apartment/
https://knoxsollecito.wordpress.com...old-about-amanda-knox-and-raffaele-sollecito/
http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/myths.html
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11071314#post11071314

• As can be seen from Vixen’s posts, PGP constantly have to resort to falsehoods to argue their case. If the prosecution have a slam dunk case, PGP don’t need to resort to lying to argue their case because there should be plenty of genuine evidence to argue your case on and the facts on your side. Having to resort to lying indicates there is a lack of genuine to argue your case on and the facts are not on your side. PGP don’t understand that having to resort to lying to argue their case contradicts the notion there was a mountain of evidence against Amanda and Raffaele and a slam dunk case.
 
Millions of dollars of other people's money. When will the obknoxious Knox pay Patrick his €42K as ordered by the court?


I note she never mentions her conviction and rightful four year's in prison concerning this big gentle Congolese man who was like an uncle to her and never hurt a fly.

She only got a column in West Seattle Herald because of the 'novelty value' in having a mu notorious criminal from Seattle writing for them, and the newspaper owner's son got to get his leg over.

I've seen a lot of nasty, sick, and disgusting posts but this one literally made my jaw drop. And you have the audacity to claim you "neither like nor dislike" Amanda. I'd have a lot more to say if it weren't for the mods who would probably ban me for the language I'd use.
 
You really don't know the difference between justice as served in a court of law (no, the kids were not prosecuted 'because Mignini didn't like them', as you claim), satire (as in wry social observation, whether it be Trump or Knox), opinion: a comment on national and global news and personal attack (ad hominem based on hatred.

In the world of Stacyhs, any criticism at all of her darlings is 'a personal attack' and this makes her very angry.

Quote me where I have said Mignini prosecuted them because he "didn't like them". Go on, Vix. Back up your claims (for a change). Of course, you won't because you can't. Par for the vixen course.

In the world of Vixen, writing

She only got a column in West Seattle Herald because of the 'novelty value' in having a mu notorious criminal from Seattle writing for them, and the newspaper owner's son got to get his leg over.
is only showing dislike for Amanda's "behavior" and not directed toward her personally. Really?

Personal attacks on Knox and Sollecito don't make me angry. I expect them from years of reading them from PGP. It's what they do. It's all they have left.
 
ROFLMAO

This is the epitome of ignorance of how forensics can help crime investigators.

This is your response to Welshman writing "People who believe that someone's DNA being found in their own bathroom is incriminating are not in a position to accuse people of being stupid."

So Vixen, please explain how finding Amanda's DNA on Amanda's bathroom sink was so obviously helpful to the forensic investigation. I think there's a huge opportunity here for all of us to learn something because I'm pretty sure most of us here are of the opinion that Amanda's DNA should have been there, and since DNA can't be dated we don't really understand how it helped. Obviously we're all displaying a bit of "epitome of ignorance" here, so please help us out...

The presence of DNA can almost NEVER tell us anything but the probable presence of the person that DNA comes from. It doesn't tell us how or when or why. So when Vixen mocks the dismissal of finding Amanda's DNA found in her own bathroom as the epitome of ignorance of forensic investigation, she is demonstrating her own ignorance, not exposing someone else's.

Very Sad.
 
Vixen said:
She only got a column in West Seattle Herald because of the 'novelty value' in having a mu notorious criminal from Seattle writing for them, and the newspaper owner's son got to get his leg over.
I've seen a lot of nasty, sick, and disgusting posts but this one literally made my jaw drop. And you have the audacity to claim you "neither like nor dislike" Amanda. I'd have a lot more to say if it weren't for the mods who would probably ban me for the language I'd use.

Vixen's post is slutshaming, but with a twist. That sort of post used to be part of the tittering and smirking at the PMF's when posters there went after Knox for the purpose of simply having a laugh. They'd often compete in making the most outrageous claim - the laugh at the expense of their victim was what they were going for.

It's the core of bullying. The problem is, it's a tired-tactic, meant to build group cohesion on that side of the fence. There simply is not enough of them any more for this sort of bullying to gain traction. Yet Vixen pulls it from her bag of tricks. (What it's got to do with the name of this thread, is beyond me. But that's just me.)
 
Last edited:
I have sent you the law citation and the list of US states federal law in this matter on at least two previous occasions. I shall not do it again.

What you sent does not support your claim. But, hey-ho...

What about obstruction of justice? You're guilty of obstruction if you do anything that hampers an ongoing case—destroying documents, intimidating witnesses, or lying under oath, for example. (Some courts have ruled that lying under oath is not sufficient for conviction on its own, though.)

Generally, obstruction charges are laid when it is discovered that a person questioned in an investigation, other than a suspect, has lied to the investigating officers.

Note that Amanda was not under oath and she was a suspect at the time as verified by the Supreme Court in 2008.

Please don't post the law citation and the list of US states federal law in this matter as they do not support your claim.

You've been asked many times before...and repeatedly failed...to present a criminal record for Amanda in the US.
 
This is a bizarre case with what I call reverse groupies. Usually you get someone obviously guilty (Like Scott Peterson) that has a few oddball groupies or desperate family members denying the obvious and saying he must be innocent and it was a series of extremely unfortunate coincidences that lead to his conviction and the real killer is still out there etc.

In this case you have someone obviously guilty (Rudy Guede) but the oddball groupies aren't obsessed with him, they're obsessed with the random girl that happened to live at the same address he burglarized, and obsessed in the negative sense of wanting her punished. But the denial of the obvious (guy with a history of window climbing break-ins found at scene of a window climbing break-in - gee I wonder what happened) and the emotional obsession clouding all sensible reason is the same.
 
In the "author's notes" page in the back of "Waiting to be Heard", Amanda writes this:

" I wouldn't have been able to write this memoir without Linda Kulman. Somehow, with her Post-it Notes and questions, with her generosity, dedication, and empathy, she turned my rambling into writing, and taught me so much in the meantime. I am grateful to her family-Ralph, Sam, Julia- for sharing her with me for so long."

Amanda, who has a degree in Creative Writing, did not need Kulman to write her book for her. She needed someone to help her organize and refine it. But, of course, when one needs to disparage and belittle anything and everything Knox related, this cannot be acknowledged. No. That would just never do.

Sorry, I recently quoted this without realising you had already done so.
 
It's all rather revealing. If people wouldn't have the urge to defame random Seattleites they might actually notice other more core things.

Looks like they will have another urge since Rolling Stone published an interview with Amanda today.

I thought this paragraph was perfect for Vixen.

What are your thoughts about your doubters?

I feel like they probably have some kind of life experience or fears that they project onto me. That sounds so clinical, but what I mean is that all of us view the world through the lens of our own experiences and our own desires. If someone wants to think of me as a femme fatale for whatever reason or wants to think that I am guilty, then they are going to see that. There is nothing that I can do to change their minds, unless say, I happen to stumble upon them and interact with them in some way and they realize, "Oh, crap. She was a real person all along." Maybe then I can change a person's mind. But I'm not setting my heart on doing that, because I don't feel like that's my job. I feel like my job is to live my life and to heal from what happened to me. I don't owe an explanation to people who still think I am guilty. It was crazy enough that I had to prove my innocence in the first place.
http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/amanda-knox-on-life-after-wrongful-conviction-w497051
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom