Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
374 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 16 November 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
  1. 16 November 20107 Sol88: Lies about what he quotes as an answer to a question.
  2. 20 November 2017 Sol88: The repeated idiocy of writing the title only of a paper.
  3. 20 November 2017 Sol88: The repeated idiocy of citing papers on comets made of ices and dust.
  4. 20 November 2017 Sol88: The insanity yet again that a description in quotes is a model.
  5. 20 November 2017 Sol88: A part truth for once - more "cherry picking and buzz words" and lies and delusions on the way and already added to his signature.
  6. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Electric fields lies about the mainstream and his comet delusions.
  7. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Deluded "double layer" lie about Deca et. al.
  8. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Double "plasma boundary" lie - not a double layer, not in the paper.
  9. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Question derailing yet again from his comet delusions.
  10. 20 November 2017 Sol88: A link to the insanely deluded Thunderbolts cult.
  11. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Idiocy and lies about highly collimated dust jets, etc.
  12. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Confirms how gullible he is by linking to the totally insane Thunderbolts cult again.
  13. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Lies again about an ambipolar electric field being a double layer.
  14. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Lies again about Deca et. al. containing double layers.
  15. 20 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about "bloody pages arguing about" electric fields on comets, including ambipolar electric fields.


Are there double layers at a comet, Reality Check?
 
Sol88: Stupid question for me to derail from his comet delusions

Are there double layers at a comet, Reality Check?
21 November 2017 Sol88: Doubly stupid question for me to derail from his comet delusions.
I was the one who emphasized the lack of literature on cometary double layers.
389 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 16 November 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!) includes your lies about cometary double layers.

You are the one with the delusion that there are cometary double layers.
21 November 2017 Sol88: Cite your sources for your assertion of double layers at a comet.
I expect more spamming of the thread with insanity from the Thunderbolts cult or lies about papers.
 
Last edited:
21 November 2017 Sol88: Irrelevant question to derail from his comet delusions.

21 November 2017 Sol88: Idiotic and irerlvant link to a deluded Thunderbolts cult "prophet". (D . E. Scott)
As soon as we see "Birkeland" we know this is the Thunderbolt cult inane delusion of Birkeland currents doing magic.

21 November 2017 Sol88: A lie - his delusion of cometary double layers is being pointed out yet again.

It is ok to say "I dont know" Reality Check. If you dont know you dont know, ay.

But that's science eh?

No you know!

Along with all the lurkers :jaw-dropp
 
@Tusenfem, what strength are the electric fields that are set up between sunlit and shadowed areas?

You are aware it will set up an electric field? :confused:

Zero when the solar wind is not reaching the nucleus. See the Nordheim paper. Anything else, or should we move right along, given that Sol is seemingly incapable of understanding either the Wang or Nordheim papers? What exactly are we doing here? I thought David Talbott told us that we were going to get all sorts of electric woo. Where was it? You know, all this EDM nonsense? Wandering electric arcs? Lol. Didn't happen, did it Solly boy? You are now reduced to trying to misinterpret mainstream papers to include anything that has the suffix electro, yes? Sad.
It was going to be so much more spectacular than this, wasn't it? And, when it wasn't, you have been reduced to this! Very, very sad.
Do not blame me, or RC, or Tusenfem, or Tim Thompson, and many others who told you that this was unscientific garbage. Blame yourself for believing such garbage. Now give it up. Nobody is interested. It's dead. Kaput. Finito. Shuffled off its mortal coil. Gone to meet its maker. It is an ex stupid idea. Nobody is listening.
 
Are there double layers at a comet, Reality Check?

Err, no. Is that a sufficient answer? Please show us, including a plasma astrophysicist, who has access to the data, where this occurred. Please advise us of your qualifications and previous publications on this matter. Or,on the other hand, ................well I don't want to risk a ban, so I won't say it. Better come up with something good, though. Other than 'Wal said it would happen'. Lol. Anything else, Sol? Have we answered your questions? You do realise that you are probably the only person on the planet who still believes in this lunacy. Yes? I doubt T & T ever believed it. However, once they have conned enough people into believing their nonsense, and shelling out for books and DVDs, they really aren't bothered. You've been taken for a mug, sunshine.
 
Sol88: A lie that I do not know that there are no cometary double layers

It is ok to say "I dont know" Reality Check.
21 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that I do not know that there are no cometary double layers after I emphasized the lack of literature on cometary double layers.
 
And what effect would this have on the double layers we are discussing?

As the density it probably high enough in the coma to carry this current, there is no need for double layers. And please note that I am talking about a tail detachment event in that section, not something that happens often, and has nothing to do with the previous discussion about the ambi-polar electric field.
You can keep on screaming double layers, but unless you come up with an actual description of what you think is happening, it ain't gonna happen.
And descriptions like

Sol88 said:
So we have energetic electron and ions doing all sorts of wonderfully complex, for the mathmagicians, behaviours that surprise scientists according to the “Ivey dust Ball”. This is achieved thru the ambipolar double layers set up that ARE coupled to the solar wind.

I will let the ivey for what it is, but then the bold, where we suddenly have ambipolar double layers!
So, Sol, show us what this is supposed to mean, show a model, and not some word salat, if you know everything so well, what "us scientists" surprises so much.
 
Last edited:
Charged dust, electric fields (locally very strong), global electric currents, spikes in the magnetic field, double layers, massive charge seperation, suprathermal electron, dust showers arriving in ‘beams’, bedrock hard surface, visible granular dust, nm size dust both compact then as aggregates and larger (m??) , stratified and cracked “well consolidated surface” (bedrock), lack of any dust to be entrained in sublimating gasses, complex hydrocarbons and organic .....

We’ll start there. Paint me a picture on sublimating ‘ice’ and I mean all molecular species det4cted so far and how there in the “ice/s”...
 
Or how bout we start on your statement in my signature below, jd116?
 
Charged dust, electric fields (locally very strong), global electric currents, spikes in the magnetic field, double layers, massive charge seperation, suprathermal electron, dust showers arriving in ‘beams’, bedrock hard surface, visible granular dust, nm size dust both compact then as aggregates and larger (m??) , stratified and cracked “well consolidated surface” (bedrock), lack of any dust to be entrained in sublimating gasses, complex hydrocarbons and organic .....

We’ll start there. Paint me a picture on sublimating ‘ice’ and I mean all molecular species det4cted so far and how there in the “ice/s”...

And away we go again. Rinse and repeat. Ad nauseam. And still zero attempt to explain how any of that is lifting dust when there is a diamagnetic cavity in place. There is nothing electrical going on in that cavity, otherwise it wouldn't be called 'diamagnetic' would it? So, for the umpteenth time, explain what is lofting dust, and how it could form within that cavity.

The charged dust is within the coma. Due to processes in the coma. There are no electric fields within a diamagnetic cavity. There are no currents within a diamagnetic cavity. There is no charge separation within a diamagnetic cavity. There are no suprathermal electrons within a diamagnetic cavity. There are no spikes in the magnetic field within a diamagnetic cavity. By definition. There are no double layers, as you have been repeatedly told. The dust is lofted by gas, and may or may not be collimated. The surface is not bedrock hard, as has been repeatedly pointed out to you.
Frankly, you are just wasting everybody's time with your inane claims, when it has been repeatedly explained to you, with links to the relevant science, that your claims are wrong. Demonstrably and without any doubt.
If you want to carry on your religious belief in this particularly idiotic, unscientific and evidence-free woo, then fine. I just wish you'd take your nonsense somewhere else, and leave the good people of this forum alone, and save them from having to continually correct your idiotic claims.
 
Charged dust, electric fields (locally very strong), global electric currents, spikes in the magnetic field, double layers, massive charge seperation, suprathermal electron, dust showers arriving in ‘beams’, bedrock hard surface, visible granular dust, nm size dust both compact then as aggregates and larger (m??) , stratified and cracked “well consolidated surface” (bedrock), lack of any dust to be entrained in sublimating gasses, complex hydrocarbons and organic .....

We’ll start there. Paint me a picture on sublimating ‘ice’ and I mean all molecular species det4cted so far and how there in the “ice/s”...

  • Charged dust: and so what?
  • electric fields (locally very strong): care to elaborate what "very" strong means here, and where this "locally" is?
  • global electric currents: Guess you know more than the mainstream scientists. yes there are currents, mainly because of Ampere's law, curl B ~ J
  • spikes in the magnetic field: what spikes are you referring to here? it is not really special for magnetic fields in space plasma to be spikey through e.g. turbulence
  • double layers: what about double layers?
  • massive charge seperation: basically impossible in a natural plasma, of course I don't know what you mean by "massive", and where you get your "massive" values from
  • suprathermal electron: supra thermal electrons are nothing special, they exist in every natural plasma

Naturally, you are mixing up stuff, in order to confuse the reader. All the plasma stuff is not ice. As soon as the volatiles escape from the comet they are interacting with the solar wind and solar radiation, will get ionized and will start to interact with the electromagnetic surroundings they will find themselves in, mainly the IMF and the convectional electric field. This gives rise to all kinds of interesting plasma physical phenomena, that we mathemagically can describe very well.

The last part of your listing about dust and bedrock and whatevers is also gathered to confuse the reader. You might as well ask why you find dust and stones and rock and ice and water all mixed together here in the Austrian Alps. It cannot be, man, it has to be either one or the other.
 
Sol88: Doubles up on a lie when he knows that is a lack of literature on cometary DL

Lack of literature you say...
22 November 2017 Sol88: Doubles up on a lie when he knows that is a lack of literature on cometary double layers.
Search ADS for 'comet double layer' and get only 46 results out of 13.4 million records :eye-poppi!

21 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that I do not know that there are no cometary double layers after I emphasized the lack of literature on cometary double layers.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A stupid demand to derail from his comet delusions

Charged dust, ... Paint me a picture on sublimating ‘ice’ and I mean all molecular species det4cted so far and how there in the “ice/s”...
22 November 2017 Sol88: A stupid demand to derail from his comet delusions.
The repeated stupid demand that we waste time teaching a person who
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A possibly lying by quote mining signature (no context)

Or how bout we start on your statement in my signature below, jd116?
22 November 2017 Sol88: A possibly lying by quote mining signature (no context). But let us see...
No post with that quote in this part of the thread...
In part II we have 27th August 2016, 01:36 PM jonesdave116[/B]
A new paper out regarding the observation of an outburst at the comet. As luck would have it, most of the relevant instruments were looking at the area in question at the time:

The 19 Feb. 2016 Outburst of Comet 67P/CG: An ESA Rosetta Multi-Instrument Study

http://mnras.oxfordjournals.org/cont....full.pdf+html (free access)

From the abstract:
"On 19 Feb. 2016 nine Rosetta instruments serendipitously observed an outburst of gas and dust from the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko. Among these instruments were cameras and spectrometers ranging from UV over visible to microwave wavelengths, in-situ gas, dust and plasma instruments, and one dust collector."

Goes without saying that nothing electrical happened.
Thus:
22 November 2017 Sol88: A lie in his signature by quote mining an obviously true statement by jonesdave116
A paper about the light defected by Rosetta instruments from an outburst of gas and dust on 67P is not about any of Sol88's electrical comet delusions.

That Sol88 would be ignorant, deluded or lie about that sentence is hinted at by the next posts
tusenfem: HELLO!! Spoiler alert!!!
jonesdave116: Damn you! You should know by now that people are awaiting the fulfilment of Wal and Dave's hypotheses. How dare you cut them off at the whatsits!!!!
Sol88 does not disappoint - posts follow that lie about the mainstream model of comets (this was 2016 - he had 7 years to learn about real comets).

One of the many Thunderbolts cult delusions is that astronomers think that there is nothing "electrical" in the universe. Posters here other than Sol88 are not that stupid. For example, ee know that the solar wind interacts with the neutral gases from sublimating ices on comet to give ions and electrons, i.e. "electrical" stuff but not as in Sol88's comet delusions. There have been many mainstream papers on that subject cited here even by guess who :eek:!
 
Last edited:
  • Charged dust: and so what?
  • electric fields (locally very strong): care to elaborate what "very" strong means here, and where this "locally" is?
  • global electric currents: Guess you know more than the mainstream scientists. yes there are currents, mainly because of Ampere's law, curl B ~ J
  • spikes in the magnetic field: what spikes are you referring to here? it is not really special for magnetic fields in space plasma to be spikey through e.g. turbulence
  • double layers: what about double layers?
  • massive charge seperation: basically impossible in a natural plasma, of course I don't know what you mean by "massive", and where you get your "massive" values from
  • suprathermal electron: supra thermal electrons are nothing special, they exist in every natural plasma

Naturally, you are mixing up stuff, in order to confuse the reader. All the plasma stuff is not ice. As soon as the volatiles escape from the comet they are interacting with the solar wind and solar radiation, will get ionized and will start to interact with the electromagnetic surroundings they will find themselves in, mainly the IMF and the convectional electric field. This gives rise to all kinds of interesting plasma physical phenomena, that we mathemagically can describe very well.

The last part of your listing about dust and bedrock and whatevers is also gathered to confuse the reader. You might as well ask why you find dust and stones and rock and ice and water all mixed together here in the Austrian Alps. It cannot be, man, it has to be either one or the other.

Charged dust: and so what?
5. Summary and Conclusions We present theoretical and observational evidence that electric forces play an important role in dust lifting on Earth, Mars, Venus, the Moon, and asteroids. We found that near-surface electric fields larger than 100 kV/m can occur in terrestrial dusty phenomena. These electric fields play an important role in saltation, and can even be large enough to directly lift particles from the surface (Kok and Renno, 2006, 2008). A detailed numerical model of saltation (Kok and Renno, 2008) predicts that electric fields in Martian dusty phenomena affect both dust lifting and atmospheric chemistry. Indeed, there is evidence that they dissociate water vapor and produce large amounts of hydrogen peroxide (Atreya et al., 2006). Moreover, saltation on Mars might produce electric fields large enough to produce electric discharges. Finally, there is evidence that electrostatic fields generated by the removal of electrons from sunlit areas and the deposition of free electrons on shadows and the night side creates large electric fields in shadow boundaries and at the terminator. Theoretical evidence suggests that this process can electrostatically lift dust particles from the surface of the Moon and asteroids. Electrostatic dust lifting might also be responsible for dust lifting in other celestial bodies. This hypothesis can be tested with measurements of particle size and electric fields at the surface with a miniature electric field sensor or from low orbit with “picosatellite sensors.”
Electrical activity and dust lifting on Earth, Mars, and beyond
Nilton O. Renno1,2,* and Jasper F. Kok1,2


electric fields (locally very strong): care to elaborate what "very" strong means here, and where this "locally" is? =
The theory proposed by Kok and Renno (2006) and summarized in section 2.2 suggests a mechanism for the lifting, transport and ejection of fines from the surface of asteroids. As on the Moon, soft solar X-rays with wavelengths smaller than 25 Å can remove electrons with energies of 500 to 1500 eV from the surface of asteroids and create cm-scale electric fields of ~50-150 kV/m. Fig. 7 shows that electric fields of about 2 kV/m are necessary to lift solid dust particles from the surface of asteroid Eros (even smaller electric fields are required to lift dust from the surface of asteroid Itokawa, because it is smaller and thus has reduced gravitational forces). Moreover, it shows that mm-size particles can be most easily lifted from the surface. As these particles are lifted, they dislodge smaller, harder to lift particles. 10 Once dislodged, and free from the strong interparticle cohesion forces, the smaller particles can be accelerated upwards by electric forces and can possibly escape the asteroid. The larger particles, on the other hand, are trapped by the asteroids’ gravitational field, but can migrate from sunlit areas to shadows. During these migrations the larger particles can get trapped in topographic lows, as observed (Miyamoto et al., 2007). This hypothesis can be tested with measurements of particle size, kinetic energy, and electric fields at the surface of asteroids (Renno et al., 2008).
Same Paper


More later from your paper Tusenfem, Current in Cometary Comae
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom