Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dust charging and transport on airless planetary bodies



Sublimation? Gas drag?

You will note that this is a process that is being invoked for the lunar horizon glow. It is not, nor has it ever been suggested to be, capable of causing an outburst in a very localized area! An area that just happens to resemble a vent, and is icier than its surroundings. Why would it? How would it? That is what you can't explain. And you never will be able to explain it, because nobody would be silly enough to write a paper suggesting such a thing, when we already know that previous outbursts have been caused by gas release.
So, no, you haven't got a mechanism that makes any scientific sense.
 
Tusenfem may be able to comment on this extract from the paper:

We report the results of a series of comparative experiments of dust transport with and without secondary electron or photoelectron production. In the first set of experiments, dust particles were exposed to a thermal plasma with an electron temperature of ~2 eV or a plasma and a 120 eV electron beam by placing the hot filament below or above the dusty surface, respectively. Note that the observations of dust transport and the measurements for the vertical electric field (Figure 2b) and horizontal potential (Figure 2c) profiles were all carried out in exactly the same plasma with the bottom or top filament setup. Dust transport including the hopping motions was only recorded when exposed to both the plasma and electron beam (Figure 3a), while exposure to plasma alone did not result in the mobilization of the dust particles, consistent with previous experiments [Flanagan and Goree, 2006]. The vertical electric fields generated in the plasma sheath above the dusty surface were kept approximately constant (~16 V/cm) in both experiments (Figure 2b).

Dust charging and transport on airless planetary bodies
Wang, X. et al
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/2016GL069491/full (paywalled)

In particular whether the experimental set up is applicable to a comet at ~3.5 AU.
Not that it matters, as this will not do what Sol wants it to. Particularly when we consider that the bulk of the outgassing occurs when the solar wind has no access to the nucleus.

ETA:
I just noticed that Eberhard Grün was a co-author on the above paper. He has been involved in a number of papers related to 67P, and was lead author of the Feb 19 outburst paper. He also was a co-author on the Agarwal paper that has got Sol so exercised! So, if he's not suggesting explosive, localised electrostatic levitation, we can be pretty damn sure that it isn't an option.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A lie that Birch et. al. are incorrect.

Reality Check,...
16 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that Birch et. al. are incorrect.

16 November 2017 Sol88: The abysmally deluded idea that "bedrock" means Birch et. al. are saying comets are rock.

16 November 2017 Sol88: Usual idiocy of citing a paper (Birch et. al.) about comets made of ices and dust.

Geomorphology of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
AbstractWe present a global geomorphological map of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (67P/C-G) using data acquired by the Rosetta Orbiter’s OSIRIS Narrow Angle Camera. The images used in our study were acquired between August 2014 and May 2015, before 67P/C-G passed through perihelion. Imagery of the southern hemisphere was included in our study, allowing us to compare the contrasting hemispheres of 67P/C-G in a single study. Our work also puts into greater context the morphologies studied in previous works, and also the morphologies observed on previously visited cometary nuclei. Relative to other nuclei, 67P/C-G appears most similar to 81P/Wild 2, with a topographically heterogeneous surface dominated by smooth-floored pits. Our mapping describes the landscapes of 67P/C-G when they were first observed by Rosetta, and our map can be used to detect changes in surface morphologies after its perihelion passage. Our mapping reveals strong latitudinal dependences for emplaced units and a highly heterogeneous surface. Layered bedrock units that represent the exposed nucleus of 67P/C-G are dominant at southern latitudes, while topographically smooth, dust covered regions dominate the northern hemisphere. Equatorial latitudes are dominated by smooth terrain units that show evidence for flow structures. We observe no obvious differences between the comet’s two lobes, with the only longitudinal variations being the Imhotep and Hatmehit basins. These correlations suggest a strong seasonal forcing on the surface evolution of 67P/C-G, where materials are transported from the southern hemisphere to northern hemisphere basins over multiple orbital timescales.
 
Sol88: Stupid post when shown the evidence for ice yet again

Ha ha ha...ice :blush:
16 November 2017 Sol88: Stupid post when shown the evidence for ice yet again.
An honest person would reply "whoops I forgot about all of this evidence - comets do contain ice".
 
Sol88: The delusion of ""jets" on a cometary surface"- jets exist

What we are discussing is "jets" on a cometary surface and the failure of sublimation to produce ANY of the observed effects on a comet nucleus, in particular this "jet" ...
16 November 2017 Sol88: The delusion of ""jets" on a cometary surface"- jets exist and are seen above the surface (emitted from on or below the surface).

16 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that the plume or outburst in the ESA blog and paper is a jet.

16 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that sublimation fails to explain the outburst.

16 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that Gunella et.al describe a mechanism for the outburst or even any jets.
 
Last edited:
362 items of ignorance, idiocy, delusion and lies from 29 Aug 2016 to 16 Nov 2017

A spate of delusions and lies from Sol88 over the few days. For example, Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko is about grains 150 kilometers from the comet and Sol88 lies abut the paper being about the comet surface. 8 years ago that would have been a mistake but now we gave
331 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 13 November 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

Nearly every Sol88 post lately contains at least 1 lie, mostly about comet science.
  1. 13 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about what he replies to - what a surprise!
  2. 13 November 2017 Sol88: An inane remark since he and his cult have been in denial of basic arithmetic for over 8 years now!
  3. 13 November 2017 Sol88: Lies again about yet another 67P paper.
  4. 13 November 2017 Sol88: An "ice" lie when comets are made of ices and dust.
  5. 13 November 2017 Sol88: A "non existent (CONCERT) chambers thru vents (not observed)" delusion.
  6. 13 November 2017 Sol88: A "Leaves mechanical cliff collapse and crack propagation as your ONLY plausible means" lie.
  7. 13 November 2017 Sol88: Looks like the insanity that we do not know 100% about comets so his delusions about comets are correct.
  8. 14 November 2017 Sol88: The 5 November 2017 deluded, lying video from his cult (one of many).
  9. 15 November 2017 Sol88: Lies and delusions about scientific papers in jonesdave116's post.
  10. 15 November 2017 Sol88: A lie of "collimated" dust in the Nordheim paper.
  11. 15 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about electrostatic surface charging of comets causing jets.
  12. 15 November 2017 Sol88: The lie and delusion that a single outburst is dust jets.
  13. 15 November 2017 Sol88: His new delusion that we could detect "pressurised gas pockets" inside 67P.
  14. 15 November 2017 Sol88: A new delusion of "DARK ICE"
  15. 15 November 2017 Sol88: The usual lie about there being no ice on comets.
  16. 15 November 2017 Sol88: An inane post to avoid addressing his comet lies and delusions.
  17. 15 November 2017 Sol88: Lies abut yet another paper (Gunella et.al)
  18. 15 November 2017 Sol88: Yet another irrelevant question to derail from his comet delusions
  19. 15 November 2017 Sol88: A lying question to derail from his comet delusions and other lies.
  20. 15 November 2017 Sol88: Insult and stupid irrelevant question to detail from his comet delusions
  21. 15 November 2017 Sol88: The repeated lie of "ice" when we have over 60 years of evidence that comets are made of ices and dust.
  22. 15 November 2017 Sol88: Another lie in a question to derail from his comet delusions.
  23. 16 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that Birch et. al. are incorrect.
  24. 16 November 2017 Sol88: The abysmally deluded idea that "bedrock" means Birch et. al. are saying comets are rock (I recall seeing this idiocy before).
  25. 16 November 2017 Sol88: Usual idiocy of citing a paper (Birch et. al.) about comets made of ices and dust.
  26. 16 November 2017 Sol88: Yet another lie - over 60 years of data showing that comets are made of ices and dust does exist.
  27. 16 November 2017 Sol88: Stupid post when shown the evidence for ice yet again.
  28. 16 November 2017 Sol88: The delusion of ""jets" on a cometary surface"- jets exist and are seen above the surface (emitted from on or below the surface).
  29. 16 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that the plume or outburst in the ESA blog and paper is a jet.
  30. 16 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that sublimation fails to explain the outburst.
  31. 16 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that Gunella et.al describe a mechanism for the outburst or even any jets.
 
Last edited:
You will note that this is a process that is being invoked for the lunar horizon glow. It is not, nor has it ever been suggested to be, capable of causing an outburst in a very localized area! An area that just happens to resemble a vent, and is icier than its surroundings. Why would it? How would it? That is what you can't explain. And you never will be able to explain it, because nobody would be silly enough to write a paper suggesting such a thing, when we already know that previous outbursts have been caused by gas release.
So, no, you haven't got a mechanism that makes any scientific sense.

Gaseous counterparts in 67P dusty outbursts. VIRTIS did not detect any increase in the H2O and CO2 column densities during the 13–14 Sept. outbursts. This means that the trigerring mechanism is not related to a large internal gas pressure, a mechanism proposed by Prialnik et al. (1993) for explosive outbursts. As already discussed, these outbursts were very likely caused by cliff collapse as for the one studied by Pajola et al. (2017). The lifetime of 0.11 µm icy grains is ∼ 300–800 s for dirty grains, and > 104 s for pure ice grains (Beer, Podolak, & Prialnik 2006; Gicquel et al. 2012). These long lifetimes may be one of the reasons why H2O vapour was not detected in the VIRTIS-H outburst spectra. On the other hand, abundant release of organics is suggested by the detection of the 3.4 µm band in outburst spectra, possibly related to the thermal decomposition of complex organics present in grains, or to volatile organics originating from the collapsed wall.
Comet 67P outbursts and quiescent coma at 1.3 AU from the Sun: dust properties from Rosetta/VIRTIS-H observations

That’s another one where lots of dust and no gas, JD116!

So are we going to go down the same road again?

Mainstream are very quickly running out of plausible excuses.
 
Sol88: A lie that Bockelée-Morvan et. al. states there was no gas in the outbursts

Comet 67P outbursts and quiescent coma at 1.3 AU from the Sun: dust properties from Rosetta/VIRTIS-H observations
Here we go with the same road of multiple lies in a short post!
362 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 13 November 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

16 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that Bockelée-Morvan et. al. states there was no gas in the outbursts.
Comet 67P outbursts and quiescent coma at 1.3 AU from the Sun: dust properties from Rosetta/VIRTIS-H observations
D. Bockelée-Morvan, G. Rinaldi, S. Erard, C. Leyrat, F. Capaccioni, P. Drossart, G. Filacchione, A. Migliorini, E. Quirico, S. Mottola, G. Tozzi, G. Arnold, N. Biver, M. Combes, J. Crovisier, A. Longobardo, M. Blecka, M.-T. Capria

This is analysis of dust properties from Rosetta/VIRTIS-H observations :eye-poppi! The authors explicitly state that comets emit gas to form their coma: "inner coma gases and dust". There is an entire section in the paper on the gaseous counterpart to the dust component.
5 SPECTRAL SIGNATURES: H2O, CO2 AND ORGANICS
...These numbers set an upper limit to the contribution of a possible gaseous counterpart to these dusty outbursts. The determination of upper limits on the gas loss rates is beyond the scope of this paper.
...We postpone the analysis of this band to a future paper, when data with an improved calibration will be available. The VIRTIS data suggest abundant release of organics during 67P outbursts. In 9P/Tempel 1 Deep Impact ejecta, enhanced C2H6 infrared emission was observed, higher than for CH3OH and H2O lines (Mumma et al. 2005; DiSanti et al. 2007).
This is Bockelée-Morvan et. al. postponing analyzing any gas in the outbursts to a later paper.

16 November 2017 Sol88: Lying highlighting in a quote from Bockelée-Morvan et. al.
Him and his cult might be ignorant enough to think that every outburst from every comet has the same cause but other people know that a variety of mechanisms will be responsible for outbursts. Bockelée-Morvan et. al state that one of the mechanisms is not evident in these 2 outbursts, and that another mechanism is likely.

16 November 2017 Sol88: Usual idiocy of citing a paper on comets made of ices and dust.

16 November 2017 Sol88: Extra idiocy of citing a paper stating "Gaseous outbursts with no dust counterparts were also observed (Feldman et al. 2016)"!

16 November 2017 Sol88: Lie about working comet science failing.
 
Last edited:
Some good science as a break from cult comet delusions.
Surface changes on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko suggest a more active past by Pajola M., et al.
Abstract
The Rosetta spacecraft spent ~2 years orbiting comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko, most of it at distances that allowed surface characterization and monitoring at submeter scales. From December 2014 to June 2016, numerous localized changes were observed, which we attribute to cometary-specific weathering, erosion, and transient events driven by exposure to sunlight and other processes. While the localized changes suggest compositional or physical heterogeneity, their scale has not resulted in substantial alterations to the comet's landscape. This suggests that most of the major landforms were created early in the comet's current orbital configuration. They may even date from earlier if the comet had a larger volatile inventory, particularly of CO or CO2 ices, or contained amorphous ice, which could have triggered activity at greater distances from the Sun.
 
You will note that this is a process that is being invoked for the lunar horizon glow. It is not, nor has it ever been suggested to be, capable of causing an outburst in a very localized area! An area that just happens to resemble a vent, and is icier than its surroundings. Why would it? How would it? That is what you can't explain. And you never will be able to explain it, because nobody would be silly enough to write a paper suggesting such a thing, when we already know that previous outbursts have been caused by gas release.
So, no, you haven't got a mechanism that makes any scientific sense.

We have shown that charged dust grains with radii o50 nm may be electrostatically ejected from the nucleus at most SZAs. Using profiles of the cometary outgassing rate at the surface scaled to the actual observations of cometary activity by Rosetta, we have provided an estimate for the flux of charged nanograins (agrain 2 nm) that are emitted from the surface. While these dust particles are too small to be observed by the dust instruments on the Rosetta orbiter, we have shown that the fluxof charged nanograins above the dayside and near-terminator nucleus is sufficiently high to be detected by the RPC–IES instrument. We have also shown that the flux of charged nanograins from the shadowed areas within the comet’s plasma wake is insufficient to yield a significant count rate in RPC–IES instrument.
Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity

Not levitated but ejected, JD116! Electrostaticly at that :blush:
 
Sol88: The idiocy of citing a paper not about comet outbursts (Nordheim et. al.)

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity
16 November 2017 Sol88: The idiocy of citing a paper not about comet outbursts (Nordheim et. al.) in reply to a post about comet outbursts.

16 November 2017 Sol88: An implied lie that Nordheim et. al. is the detection of electrostatically ejected dust.

16 November 2017 Sol88: The idiocy of citing a paper on comets made of ices and dust (Nordheim et. al.).

16 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about his cult comet delusions being about electrostatic dust charging.
It is working mainstream science that is researching the electrostatic charging of dust by the solar wind and the possibility of cometary dust being ejected from nuclei by this mechanism.

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity ()15 December 2015) was model results about dust being ejected from the surface of 67P.
We have investigated through simulation the electrostatic charging of the nucleus of Comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko during periods of weak outgassing activity. Specifically, we have modeled the surface potential and electric field at the surface of the nucleus during the initial Rosetta rendezvous at 3.5 AU and the release of the Philae lander at 3 AU. We have also investigated the possibility of dust acceleration and ejection above the nucleus due to electrostatic forces. Finally, we discuss these modeling results in the context of possible observations by instruments on both the Rosetta orbiter and the Philae lander.

ETA: Hypocrisy from ignorance or just laziness?
Sol88 has citing Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko by Skorov, Yu. V.; Rezac, L.; Hartogh, P.; Keller, H. U. That paper cites Nordheim et. al. :eek:!
 
Last edited:
We have shown that charged dust grains with radii o50 nm may be electrostatically ejected from the nucleus....

Ahh Jeez Sol. Stop making an eejit of yourself. Eh? What do you think nm means? Just for a clue, try nanometers. Yes? Then look at the Agarwal paper. How many times do you need to show your ignorance in this thread? It doesn't bother me, but it ought to bother you, I'd have thought.
Just for a laugh, tell me how the outgassing is happening at perihelion. When there is a shed load of dust around? Remember the diamagnetic cavity, dear? And where was the solar wind? Well, not within 1500 km. Eh? So, what is your mechanism? Let's hear it.
 
Ahh Jeez Sol. Stop making an eejit of yourself. Eh? What do you think nm means? Just for a clue, try nanometers. Yes? Then look at the Agarwal paper. How many times do you need to show your ignorance in this thread? It doesn't bother me, but it ought to bother you, I'd have thought.
Just for a laugh, tell me how the outgassing is happening at perihelion. When there is a shed load of dust around? Remember the diamagnetic cavity, dear? And where was the solar wind? Well, not within 1500 km. Eh? So, what is your mechanism? Let's hear it.

Mmmmm...wake up!

Another possibility is the impact of nano dust on very large grains, such as the objects with diameters in the 0.14–0.50 m range observed by the OSIRIS

I assume you do know the difference between nm and m?
 
Are you saying gas drag can accelerate 10nm dust to 10km/s?

Ahh of course the "rocket" effect... hah aha ha little dust rockets :)
 
Sol88: Irrelevant question to detail from his comet delusions

Are you saying gas drag can accelerate 10nm dust to 10km/s?
16 November 2017 Sol88: Irrelevant question to detail from his comet delusions.

16 November 2017 Sol88: Lies with a gas drag question that he knows the answer to.
Acceleration of ions and nano dust at a comet in the solar wind
Abstract
A quasi-neutral hybrid simulation of the interaction of the solar wind with the atmosphere of a comet is used together with a test particle simulation of cometary ions and dust to compute trajectories and velocity distribution functions of charged particles, starting outside the diamagnetic cavity at 150 km cometocentric distance. The simulations are run with parameters suited to make predictions for comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko when it is at a heliocentric distance of 1.45 AU. It is found that the shape of the ion trajectories depends on the location of the source, and that a velocity distribution that is observed at a given point in space is influenced by the spatial structure of the source. Charged dust grains with radii in the 1 – 10 nm range arerated from the nucleus to a distance of 2.9 × 10 4 km in between 15 minutes and 2 hours approximately. Dust particles smaller than 10 nm in radius are accelerated to speeds over 10 km/s.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom