Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Along with all the other "stuff" we've observed?

Oh ok then :blush: :boggled:

Yes. Such as icy boulders. And large patches of H2O and CO2 ice at the surface. And ice exposed after a cliff collapse. And ice grains at Tempel 1. And shed loads of it around Hartley 2. Et boring cetera.
Read the papers.
 
Yes. Such as icy boulders. And large patches of H2O and CO2 ice at the surface. And ice exposed after a cliff collapse. And ice grains at Tempel 1. And shed loads of it around Hartley 2. Et boring cetera.
Read the papers.

you forgot the receding "ice" cliffs at Tempel 1. ! :D

PIA13862.jpg
Image Credit:
NASA/JPL-Caltech/Cornell
 
Which electrons?

Whooo boy! :eusa_think:

Have a crack at this little problem then, since your up to speed on the matter...

The relative timing of rising dust at the surface, the increase in gas temperature at the spacecraft, and then the increase in gas density at the spacecraft, is not yet understood.
Hofstader et al. (in preparation) explore three possible explanations for the increase in coma temperature.
The 2016 Feb 19 outburst of comet 67P/CG: an ESA Rosetta
multi-instrument study


Which one ya going for jd116?
 
Last edited:
Ahhh the ‘ol frozen in magnetic field chestnut!

I understand the plasma is quasi neutral over all but not in these cases.

How’s that concept helping you with your draped magnetic fields?

anybody using the ‘frozen’ in concept of magnetic field lines is going look like a drongo.



But I ‘spose as long as it makes your maths easier, then it’s doing it’s job, ay?

Same as using the radial outgassing, an assumption to make the maths easier... unfortunately this does not reflect observation and indeed reality.

goodgrief.gif
 
Any double layers seen during the tail excursion, Tusenfem?

no

or is quasi neutrality violated with in the tail region, Tusenfem?

no

Are there any force free filed aligned currents, Tusenfem?

??

Could Ip and Mendis be correct in relation to comet 67p's tail, Tusenfem?

who knows

or do I have to go to another forum to be able to ask question from a plasma physicist working on the RPC team at the ESA on the comet 67P??

yes, but then again, you would not understand nor like the answer you will be getting.
 
Sol88 said:
Why the the increase in brightness FIRST then GAS then DUST!
Because light is faster than gas, which is faster than dust! Duh.

Not only that, but when we SEE an outburst, we see them from the side, otherwise we cannot see reflected light. This means that Rosetta is not in the outburst proper, and thus we cannot measure the gas and dust simultaneous with the increased brightness.
 
not really sure how many electrons, just that the nucleus should have some "spare" and would like to try and "give" them to the solar wind

OK, so being "not really sure how many electrons" the number of 'spares' could be 0. Isn't the comet suppose to carry some charge in relation to the sun in the EC musing? That charge would tell you how many "spare" electrons or protons the comet "should have", in relation to the sun, to obtain that charge.

An cometary "outburst" or more correctly a discharge would be a good place to look.

Nope, that simply assumes such a charge to result in "more correctly a discharge". You assert above that you're "not really sure how many electrons" but just think that "the nucleus should have some "spare"". You can't put the discharge before the charge. You need to establish what the scope of the charge can be, if it can be detected before concerning yourself with whether or not, how or if, it can be discharged.

Let's have a little looksee ay? :eye-poppi

The nucleus is more or less at a lower potential than the local solar wind. When entering a region of different charge it will form a Langmiour Sheath around it to "protect" itself from the local solar wind. This in turn sets up a series of double layer/s some distance from the nucleus. These are current carrying double layer doing "work".

"more or less"?!? Again doesn't the EC speculation require comet carry a significant charge? So once again the "less" in the "more or less" could be 0. "more or less at a lower potential" would tend to indicate that "The nucleus is more or less" already, well, discharged.

"When entering a region of different charge"? What region? What "different charge"? Again, the level of "different charge" expected in that "region" would tell you "how many electrons" in excess the comet has there. Perhaps you're just "not really sure" about that either? Well, then you're just "not really sure" that there is or can be such "a region of different charge".

In this area quasi neutrality is violated and magnetic fields are NOT frozen in, along with photo ionisation playing a minor role.

No, local differences in distribution of ions and electrons (local charge distributions) don't violate quasi neutrality. That's specifically what the "quasi" means. However, the comet carrying a significant charge explicitly violates the neutrality part, quasi or otherwise. Also simple ionization, photo or otherwise, doesn't change ion to electron ratios. Where local distribution variations become stronger or larger ambi-polar fields are generated opposing those variations


When there is a breakdown in the electric field between the nucleus and the closest double layer you will get a "burst' of electrons as the nucleus try's to charge equalise.

"a "burst' of electrons"? the "nucleus try's to charge equalise"? once again indicative of the comet carrying a substantial charge. That ain't "more or less at a lower potential" as that would mean the comet is already "more or less" charge equalized. Once again charge is presumed simply to now presume some catastrophic (a "breakdown" and "burst") discharge while being "not really sure how many electrons" would constitute such, if any, charge.

This should show up in the instruments as different timing between constituents of the discharge.

Great, let us know when you have reviewed the instrument data and found of what magnitude and where that charge to be, well, discharged "more or less" shows up. See then you could be at least be somewhat "sure how many electrons" are involved.

Bit like lightning really!

No apparently from your assertions not at all "like lightning really" lighting isn't caused by anything "more or less at a lower potential". It is caused by sustained potential differences sufficient to breakdown the intervening dialectic and be detected.


http://www.electricalfun.com/lightning.htm
To spontaneously ionize air and conduct electricity across it, an electric field of field strength of approximately 2500 kilovolts per meter is required. However, measurements inside storm clouds to date have failed to locate fields this strong, with typical fields being between 100 and 400 kilovolts per meter. While there remains a possibility that researchers are failing to encounter the small high-strength regions of the large clouds, the odds of this are diminishing as further measurements continue to fall short.


Anywho,

This is what I would expect to see. I'll group them to make my electrical explanation a little clearer.

  1. OSIRIS WAC, OSIRIS NAC, Alice
  2. MIRO RPC LAP Spacecraft potential, RPC MIP Electron density, ROSINA COPS Gas density
  3. STR-A Brightness, GIADA Dust count rate
List from table 1 Measurement parameters at 9:00 and at maximum. The 2016 Feb 19 outburst of comet 67P/CG: an ESA Rosetta multi-instrument study

Simply

We see a "flash", then we see an increase in the electrons, then the dust is brought along with the electrons after being machined of the rocky nucleus via the focused the discharge , with a lag of course because of the mass difference. The dust of course is also charged and removing that also helps try and balance the charge within the nucleus with that of it's surroundings.

These discharges would be cyclic when the potential difference would be the highest, around perihelion, unless there was a change in the solar wind e.g CME, solar flare etc

The long version..

THE NATURE AND FREQUENCY OF THE GAS OUTBURSTS IN COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV–
GERASIMENKO OBSERVED BY THE ALICE FAR-ULTRAVIOLET SPECTROGRAPH ON ROSETTA


and

Interaction of the solar wind with comets: a Rosetta perspective


Just to start the ball rolling! :thumbsup:

Nope, the EC ball doesn't even start "rolling" till you can find your charge to be discharged. Flashes, local increases in electron density (particularly the ones you linked before related to collisional slowing of fast electrons by neutrals), gas and dust don't change that.

So far we have that you're "not really sure how many electrons" thus how large that charge can be or if there even is such a charge but it still to you seems just "more or less at a lower potential than the local solar wind" and "the potential difference would be the highest, around perihelion". So again, generally how many excess electrons does the electric comet theory propose such a comet has? If you and the electric comet crowd just don't know or can't find the detection of such in the data then there is no basis to assert such a charge let alone that charge being, well, discharged, by whatever means you would care to speculate.
 
Sol88: The idiocy of citing papers on comets made of ices and dust

Nothing except
28 November 2017 Sol88: The idiocy of citing papers on comets made of ices and dust.

28 November 2017 Sol88: The repeated stupidity of thinking that "bedrock" means rock.

28 November 2017 Sol88: The utter stupidity of a uncaptioned, not sourced image possibly of terrestrial rock or an asteroid surface.
 
Sol88: Probably lies about papers showing that quasi-neutrality is violated

quasi-neutrality is violated in this case.
28 November 2017 Sol88: Probably lies about papers showing that "quasi-neutrality is violated in this case"

28 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about a "Double Layers in Astrophysics" having anything to do with his comet delusions or probably comets at all.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Frozen in magnetic field idiocy mindlessly parroted from his cult

Ahhh the ‘ol frozen in magnetic field chestnut!
28 November 2017 Sol88: Frozen in magnetic field idiocy mindlessly parroted from his cult.

This is one of the insane delusions from the Thunderbolts cult - that magnetic fields cannot be frozen into plasma and thus magnetic reconnection (seen in labs all of the time) does not exist.

28 November 2017 Sol88: His massively deluded point 14 from a post full of delusions is quoted.
Birkeland currents are formed by the interaction of the solar wind with a body with a magnetic field. Comets have no magnetic field!
 
Last edited:
Sol88: More delusions about comets to add to his other comet delusions

not really sure how many electrons, ...
28 November 2017 Sol88: More delusions about comets to add to his other comet delusions.
A delusion that comets have "spare" electrons.
A delusion that these spare electrons would be "given" to the solar wind.
An insanely ignorant delusion that a comet outburst is an electrical discharge.
etc. etc.

28 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about mainstream papers having anything to do with his comet delusions (old or new).
 
Sol88: Insult and the repeated stupidity of referring to papers about comets made of

Get a life champ, go read the papers! ...
28 November 2017 Sol88: Insult and the repeated stupidity of referring to papers about comets made of ices and dust .

28 November 2017 Sol88: Multiple lies about "no viable mechanism for your "explosive" "jets"".
The continuing "jets" lie.
A lie about "explosive" "jets"" - there are none. There are outbursts that are not jets.
A lie about no viable mechanism when they are in the papers he demand other people read.
A lie that he has read the papers otherwise he would know about the viable mechanisms, e.g. a pocket of ices being exposed.

28 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about a problem with the source of O2.

28 November 2017 Sol88: A stupid lie about a problem with "stuff" coming off the nucleus (e.g. jets exist!).

28 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about ices being hidden - we have many observations of ices and he knows this.

28 November 2017 Sol88: The usual "ices in quotes" lie.
 
Sol88: Stupidity of posting images of receding actual ice cliffs on Tempel 1

you forgot the receding "ice" cliffs at Tempel 1
28 November 20917 Sol88: Stupidity of posting images of receding actual ice cliffs on Tempel 1.
Changes in the terrain of comets such as that are evidence of sublimating ices.
 
Sol88: A delusion about electrons in table 1 of E. Grün et. al (2016)

Read table 1, again. The 2016 Feb 19 outburst of comet 67P/CG: an ESA Rosetta multi-instrument study
28 November 2017 Sol88: A delusion about electrons in table 1 of E. Grün et. al (2016)
The 2016 Feb 19 outburst of comet 67P/CG: an ESA Rosetta multi-instrument study
"RPC MIP Electron density [cm−3] ∼440 ∼1200 2.7 10 : 37.6"
This is the electron density of the coma at the spacecraft. It increased by a factor of 3 during the outburst.
There is no mention of his delusion of electrons from the nucleus.
 
28 November 2017 Sol88: The repeated stupidity of thinking that "bedrock" means rock.

Particularly when the paper says...

Dominated by variations in local solar insolation, thermal fracturing and sublimation are the dominant mechanisms that act to erode the comet’s surface.



Heck, who cares what the papers actually say just take a word, phrase, line or whatever from all or any number and just cobble them into a claim of support for whatever you want.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom