Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
... If Tusenfems interpretation of the data from the tail excursion is more along the lines of what Don Scott was describing in Birkeland current model, then would Alvfens warning be just a little more pertinent?
Scott not only plagiarised Lundquist's solution in his original 2013 paper, he then blundered his way forward, and in the process, completely screwed up the fundamental physical definitions underpinning Lundquist's model.

Scott doesn't have a clue as to the physics giving rise to real Birkeland Currents! The words: 'Scott' combined with 'Birkeland Currents' is cause for uproarious laughter!
 
If Tusenfems interpretation of the data from the tail excursion is more along the lines of what Don Scott was describing in Birkeland current model, then would Alvfens warning be just a little more pertinent?

I hardly think so, but the paper was accepted after very minor revision (I had to add one sentence).

Especially in the surface, coma and tail interactions? Something some where of currents closing thru the coma? Nested concentric field aligned currents, double layers, ELECTRIC field CONNECTIONS and the resulting magnetic field topology rearrangements...

Found your list again of random terms to mix together?

We can not use MHD.

And why exactly can we not use MHD? Please explain to us dumb mainstreamers.

And I hear the maths gets quite complicated, tusnfem?

Meh, you should see my calculations on wave polarization.
 
And it still has a connection to the jets, gas, dust and ice on the surface of the layered bedrock of the nucleus!

what the frak is "it"?

It’s also going to make it very problematic for the “Dirtysnowball” model to explain the feature that may be observed when a probe (Rosetta) flys radially away from the centre of the tail. I think you call that perpendicular to the z direction?

Again "it"
And radially away from the centre or the tail would be ALONG the z direction in the most used coordinate systems; shows again what you know.

I think all the other probes flew more or less parallel to z?

Think again.
 
Oh .. and Mozina seems to like criticizing professional mathematicians so much .. how about an update on his progress in acquiring some math skills of his own?

Well, as it turns out, I can report that he recently went on a massive rampage trying to convince all at another forum that his logic (on LIGO's sigma calculations) was flawless .. (never mind that it led to the stupendously tumultuous conclusion that 1=0.5! :dig: )
:jaw-dropp:
The hilarious 1=0.5 claim by MM is only the top of the iceberg. It should be noted that the "explanation" for his argument is that he is a programmer, and that, in a discussion of probability, interpreted the symbols "np" as being a single variable. In that specific discussion, where specific values of n and p were discussed, it was the case that in a single equation one could replace n and p with "np" a different variable representing the number of flips of a coin as opposed to n, a number of flips and p, a probability of 0.5, and get a result that everybody agreed upon. But sane people could then use MM's interpretation to derive that earlier equations, which MM had "accepted" implied that 0.5=1. All in all this is "only" pretty typical of the lack of even basic mathematical understanding shown by MM.

Where this gets really funny, is when looking across his many posts on various forums (there is something strangely additive about following the arguments of idiots). It becomes clear that this basic lack of algebraic understanding was in place well before his 1=0.5 fiasco. Remember this is a person who claims to have read Hannes Alfvén's 1970 book Cosmic Plasma, a quite mathematical text that of course frequently makes use of common algebraic conventions. What insane interpretation he must have of that book without being able to read the mathematics? How can he sustain his bizarre hero worship when he cannot possibly understand what he is trying to read? Why would he keep reading books that are very plainly above his level of reading comprehension?

A second rather wonderful example of MM putting his foot in his mouth, which some of you my have missed, can be found at thunderdolts (I cant post URLs but the thread is "Evidence of Gravitational Waves, or Confirmation Bias?", start of page 23) and simply confirms that for MM 0.5 being equal to 1 is the least of his logical handicaps. In this thread MM is complaining that the recently detected gravity waves from a neutron star merger happen at a rate much slower than the earlier mergers of considerably heavier black hole mergers. He is quite sure that the stupid scientists have obviously make a mistake or are working as part of a conspiracy to cover what they know deep down to false (Hail Hydra!). In his own words:
"Apparently the inspiral signal took place over a number of *minutes* [for neutron star mergers] as opposed to a fraction of a second for previous merger events [BH mergers], which seems more logical to me."
More logical to him perhaps, except he has used a large about of the thread repeating how he "accepts GR theory" (I am sure the world of real scientists are extremely grateful for his gracious acceptance - no wait, nobody cares what some lunatic crank thinks). This leads to one of his amazing foot in mouth blunders again as the very theory he accepts (GR) when applied to orbital mechanics directly implies that more massive bodies have fewer gravitational wave cycles (specifically this is the Einstein quadrupole formula). As the subsequent posts themselves make clear, he is simply not capable of accepting any modern physics theory as he does not have the mathematical ability to understand them. The mind boggles at how somebody can claim to accept a set of ideas when quite plainly they have no possible chance to understand them? This seems to transcend the Dunning-Kruger effect in that he has zero ability; I mean can somebody think they have an amazing ability to speak Swahili if they do not know a single word?

Indeed his dislike of mathematics which he refuses to "bark on command", i.e. which he is just not intelligent enough to do, suggests a world view where deductive, Modus Ponens, logic carries no weight. Again and again I am struck not just by the lack of basic understanding of the topics he is clearly passionate about, but the lack of even a child's understanding of basic philosophy of science.

Anyway, thanks for the new to me, and highly amusing magnetic reconnection thread.
 
Good find jd116!

Not quite a full digression but one that holds a critical role for the ELECTRIC COMET. So it is still on the table.

I rather think you missed the point of that link! It is to show that Falthammar is saying that MRx happens. As opposed to the EU view (and, apparently, Alfven)
That, I imagine, is due to the fact that C G-F was around long enough to see it confirmed both in the lab and in-situ. Alfven wasn't. And neither Alfven nor Falthammar believed in anything as stupid as electric comets.
ETA:
And no, it isn't still on the table. It was never on the table. No EDM (lol). No electric discharges. No rock. It is dead.
 
Last edited:
‘Magnetic’ reconnection, no. Electric field connection/s, yes.

That’s why
RECONNECTION
A special kind of violation of the frozen field condition is the process of reconnection.

Its that special ‘kind’ of violation that makes them special!

You know, just like this-
Second: Magnetic Merging as it was called at the time, magnetic reconnection as it is called now. Indeed, Alfvén was a staunch opposition of MRx, and believed that "exploding double layers" was the solution. This was based on the "explosions" that occur in large rectifiers, when the current is disrupted when they are switched off. This leads to great discharges between the two poles.

The theory of MRx was in its childhood years, when Aflvén discussed this, without any real observations of the process. Now we have had Cluster and MMS, specifically designed to study this process in the Earth's magnetosphere on different scales. And lo-and-behold, we see in the data exactly what is supposed to be seen for MRx in the magnetic and electric fields and the plasma. There is no evidence of Alfvén's "exploding double layer". He was a great scientist, but in this case he has been proven to be wrong.


There are quite powerful electric currents flowing in the vicinity of comet/s, 67p in particular, is there not, tusenfem?
 
Last edited:
If those currents are unstable and the double layer separating those currents ‘shorts’ out or explosively release the inductively flowing energy....

Magnetic reconnection dosent captture the whole show!
 
‘Magnetic’ reconnection, no. Electric field connection/s, yes.

Wrong. You've got it bass ackwards:

2. Magnetic-field aligned electric fields make possible rapid release of magnetically stored energy.

From the same Falthammar paper above.
 
If those currents are unstable and the double layer separating those currents ‘shorts’ out or explosively release the inductively flowing energy....

As there are no DLs observed, then the point is moot. I told you; it's pointless discussing something that is neither observed, nor required to explain observations. Might as well invoke pink unicorns. They haven't been observed either.
 
There are quite powerful electric currents flowing in the vicinity of comet/s, 67p in particular, is there not, tusenfem?

Not that I've heard of. However, Tusenfem will know better. I seem to recall that the one in the cavity boundary was quite feeble.
 
‘Magnetic’ reconnection, no. Electric field connection/s, yes.

That’s why

Its that special ‘kind’ of violation that makes them special!

You know, just like this-


There are quite powerful electric currents flowing in the vicinity of comet/s, 67p in particular, is there not, tusenfem?


Sol, why didn’t you include sourcing or citation information with your quotes?
 
Sol88 said:
Second: Magnetic Merging as it was called at the time, magnetic reconnection as it is called now. Indeed, Alfvén was a staunch opposition of MRx, and believed that "exploding double layers" was the solution. This was based on the "explosions" that occur in large rectifiers, when the current is disrupted when they are switched off. This leads to great discharges between the two poles.
What is this supposed to be? A back EMF?
What is the supposed relevance of this word-salad?

Sol88 said:
The theory of MRx was in its childhood years, when Aflvén discussed this, without any real observations of the process. Now we have had Cluster and MMS, specifically designed to study this process in the Earth's magnetosphere on different scales. And lo-and-behold, we see in the data exactly what is supposed to be seen for MRx in the magnetic and electric fields and the plasma. There is no evidence of Alfvén's "exploding double layer". He was a great scientist, but in this case he has been proven to be wrong.
Conflating electromagnetic induction with magnetic reconnection is what it is!
 
Wrong. You've got it bass ackwards:



From the same Falthammar paper above.

What’s happ’n To the electric fields then, one would wonder?

The basic premise of Falthammar’s paper is in certain cases, in this case at a comet, MHD does NOT apply!

The field lines are not frozen in and the currents are field aligned the coma has charge seperation, particle acceleration, particle de-acceleration and deflection.

All from solar insolation from layered bedrock! :blush:
 
What’s happ’n To the electric fields then, one would wonder?

The basic premise of Falthammar’s paper is in certain cases, in this case at a comet, MHD does NOT apply!

The field lines are not frozen in and the currents are field aligned the coma has charge seperation, particle acceleration, particle de-acceleration and deflection.

All from solar insolation from layered bedrock! :blush:

Lol. So few words, so much wrongness! The basic premise of Falthammar's paper is that magnetic reconnection happens! And of course MHD doesn't apply in that situation. MRx demands that ideal MHD be violated. And C-G F mentions nothing about comets.
The rest of that drivel is unintelligible. Once again, there is NO ROCK. Understand? Nowhere. Ever. Seen. At. A. Comet. There is no EDM (lol). There are no electric discharges. There are no double layers. There are no Birkeland currents. The electric comet woo is dead. Pushing up daisies. It is no more. There is not now, nor ever has been, the tiniest piece of evidence in its favour. It was a stupid, unscientific, mythology based idea, and has been shown to be such.
 
Samuel P. D. Birch,1‹ Y. Tang,2 A. G. Hayes,1,2 R. L. Kirk,3 D. Bodewits,4 H. Campins,5 Y. Fernandez,5 R. de Freitas Bart,2 N. W. Kutsop,2 H. Sierks,6 J. M. Soderblom,7 S. W. Squyres1,2 and J-B. Vincent6,8 Geomorphology of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

I’m going to follow there lead here and call the nucleus that is made of layered bedrock units, with a minimal amount dust of previously layered well consolidated material, ‘rock’, as a general term to describe the comet nucleus.

So if you have an issue with this terminology for the geomorphology of comet 67P then take it up with the above. Or should I refer to the well consolidated material by its correct description of layered bedrock.
 
Last edited:
Lol. So few words, so much wrongness! The basic premise of Falthammar's paper is that magnetic reconnection happens! And of course MHD doesn't apply in that situation. MRx demands that ideal MHD be violated. And C-G F mentions nothing about comets.
The rest of that drivel is unintelligible. Once again, there is NO ROCK. Understand? Nowhere. Ever. Seen. At. A. Comet. There is no EDM (lol). There are no electric discharges. There are no double layers. There are no Birkeland currents. The electric comet woo is dead. Pushing up daisies. It is no more. There is not now, nor ever has been, the tiniest piece of evidence in its favour. It was a stupid, unscientific, mythology based idea, and has been shown to be such.

No doubt there a release of energy, just mainstream (you) seem to have the cart before the horse again.

Where, in your understanding of Mrx, do electric current and fields come into play along with conducting plasma?
 
Sol, why didn’t you include sourcing or citation information with your quotes?

Sorry my bad. Gets to get a little frustrating on a iPad trying to cut n paste links!

Most of the time it’s not a problem but at others...

The quotes were from tusenfem.
 
Last edited:
Where, in your understanding of Mrx, do electric current and fields come into play along with conducting plasma?

There is a whole thread on MRx, why don't you read it? If not, then read the papers referenced by Falthammar in his paper. As far as reconnection goes, Falthammar IS mainstream. And yet he was Alfven's student. And co-author. And friend.
 
Yes I know!

New data (paper) incoming that may shed some new light on the above debate on MRx!

So we should leave it till we can have a squiz at the tail excursion data.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom