Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.

2. Modeling cometary dust activity

Snip

Snip

In the following, this detailed model is referred to as the thermophysical model.

So not the ‘dirtysnowball’ then? Can we call it the thermophysical model, tusenfem?

The calculations were performed for H2O ice, CO2 ice and CO ice. Each icy material was treated by a one-species model, which means that all available energy was consumed by the sublimation of this particular icy species. To derive the largest dustaggregate size, a radius of 2km (Lowry et al. 2012) and a density of 470kgm−3 (Sierks et al. 2015) were used for the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko. Furthermore, we used a Bond albedo of 0.04, which is a typical value for comets (the geometric albedo of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko is 0.05; Sierks et al. 2015).

Which is a dirtysnowball, yeah?

But

The presented model of the gas-driven dust activity cannot explain the release of the particles found in populations 2 and 3. The release of small dust aggregates (below the blue areas shown in Fig. 3) or of micrometer-sized monomer grains is not possible because of the relatively high tensile strength required to detach these particles from the surface

But B. Gundlach1, J. Blum1, H. U. Keller and are incorrect, are they not jd116?

Because Y. V. Skorov is in the bad books already , Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko with that paper.

http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016Natur.538...72F

So what’s happening there jd116 with the charged organic, refractory, dehydrated ‘dust’ from the nucleus? ‘Ice’ is looking less and less likely.

Sublimation is having a harder and harder time ‘splain’n the ‘dust’ release from the nucleus of a comet....


On the other hand a strong electric field will do it with ease and would be expected too!

Now all we need to find is electric currents supporting current carrying double layers and i’d Say we could close the book on that chapter and go to the interesting stuff. What if we mimic a comet?
 
Last edited:
Hear that phone ringing? Don’t get your hopes up, it’s not the Nobel Committee. It’s the Purple Prose Acamedy calling to say you’ve been awarded the prize for Most Overwrought Metaphor In Support of Pseudoscience. But heads up-they might revoke it for gratuitous sexism; that doesn’t play too well these days.

Seriously, since you admit math is not your strong suit, why not at least try to put together a logical narrative based on evidence for an aspect of the EC idea? Not name dropping, not JAQing, but a consilient case. Probably doesn’t mean much coming from a non-expert but I’d give sincere respect to an honest effort.

Ring ring....oh gday mum! :D better than a nobel prize hands down!

Little home work to bring you up to speed, papers available via the usual sources.

1. Is the dust charged?
2. When does it become charged? (how close to the nucleus)
3. Does that charged dust ‘couple’ to the surrounding plasma?
3. Are there electric fields at a comet?
4. How are the electric fields formed and sustained and Where do they start and end, what size and strength are they?
5 what happens to the dust from the time it ‘leaves’ the surface till we no longer detect it?
6 the composition of the dust


Should give you some idea, if you care to look thru the telescope, at what maybe going on beside sublimation of ‘ices’.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Idiocy of a model of dust activity being a comet model

6 December 2017 Sol88: Idiocy of a model of dust activity being a comet model.

High-molecular-weight organic matter in the particles of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko Nicolas Fray, Anaïs Bardyn[…]Martin Hilchenbach is a Nature paper behind a paywall.

So where did this his "Modeling cometary dust activity" quote come from? The answer is:
What drives the dust activity of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko? by B. Gundlach, J. Blum1, H. U. Keller1, Y. V. Skorov.
This is the paper with a model of sublimating ices explaining large grains ("ranging from 2cm to 1m in radius"), "decimeter-sized aggregates" but not "particles smaller than ∼ 1mm".

6 December 2017 Sol88: Lies by omission of a citation for a "Modeling cometary dust activity" quote.

6 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about sublimation having a problem.

6 December 2017 Sol88: Repeats his ignorant delusion of electric fields explaining what sublimation already explains.

6 December 2017 Sol88: Repeats his double layer delusion.
His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Inane post to derail from his comet delusions.

6 December 2017 Sol88: Inane post to derail from his comet delusions.

6 December 2017 Sol88: A lying list of questions because they are not about his comet delusions.
For ferd burfle:
  1. Charged dust grains have been detected.
  2. Neutral dust grains get charged when they are ejected rom the nucleus into the coma.
  3. There are electric and magnetic fields at comets.
  4. There are electric and magnetic fields at comets!
  5. Unlike Sol88 I assume that you have a high school science education and know how electric fields are caused, etc.
    He highlights how deluded his comet delusions are since he should be telling you how strong the electric fields are at comets to produce the results he wants.
  6. An irrelevant question about dust.
  7. It is the composition of the dust (not hydrated = not the insanity of being blasted from Earth) that is one of the many things that make Sol88's comet ideas into delusions.
His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
Ring ring....oh gday mum! :D better than a nobel prize hands down!

Little home work to bring you up to speed, papers available via the usual sources.

1. Is the dust charged?
2. When does it become charged? (how close to the nucleus)
3. Does that charged dust ‘couple’ to the surrounding plasma?
3. Are there electric fields at a comet?
4. How are the electric fields formed and sustained and Where do they start and end, what size and strength are they?
5 what happens to the dust from the time it ‘leaves’ the surface till we no longer detect it?
6 the composition of the dust


Should give you some idea, if you care to look thru the telescope, at what maybe going on beside sublimation of ‘ices’.


Thanks, but no need, I’ve been here long enough to see your schtick never changes; witness the JAQing above. Foolish of me to think I might coax you out of it. I may not be conversant in the details of the science but I sure know enough to recognize the EC nonsense for what it is. Can’t imagine what I might have said to make you think I don’t.
 
For ferd burfle:
  1. Charged dust grains have been detected.
  2. Neutral dust grains get charged when they are ejected rom the nucleus into the coma.
  3. There are electric and magnetic fields at comets.
  4. There are electric and magnetic fields at comets!
  5. Unlike Sol88 I assume that you have a high school science education and know how electric fields are caused, etc.
    He highlights how deluded his comet delusions are since he should be telling you how strong the electric fields are at comets to produce the results he wants.
  6. An irrelevant question about dust.
  7. It is the composition of the dust (not hydrated = not the insanity of being blasted from Earth) that is one of the many things that make Sol88's comet ideas into delusions.



Thanks, RC, breaking it down like this is helpful. I have a BSc and did well in my physics and chemistry classes, so I follow this pretty well at a conceptual level. More to the point, thanks to 40 years working in technical and analytical support for manufacturing operations I’ve developed a pretty good nose to tell when someone’s slinging scientific ********. EC gives off an unmistakable stench.

Cheers!
 
Ok, no worries.

Moving along...jets on a comet, the death of the dirtysnowball.
 
Ok, no worries.

Moving along...jets on a comet, the death of the dirtysnowball.
One has to wonder just how long Sol88 will keep this drivel up .. and whether or not he knows that its perfectly obvious to observers that he has a clear obsession with trying to gain Tusenfem's attention? (I think its called 'stalking' ..)

His pititful attempts at trying to 'refocus' Tusenfem on the various incarnations of his EC delusion are quite hilarious. Thank goodness Tusenfem is open to scientific arguments (and not EU Acolyte led Liturgies).

Thanks to Reality Check also .. I find RC's posts summarize nicely the long and sordid history behind Sol88's delusion. They're quite handy for newcomers to the thread.
(I 'get' RC's date format too .. its a Southern Hemisphere convention thing ... Mozina at cult HQ was wrong about that, also).
 
Everything is back on the table! All the "it can never happen", slowly changed to "it might happen" to eventually "well of course it happens", why wouldn't it!

No, not "everything is on the table", there is draping, but not in the classical way that Alfvén described, which also did not incorporate nested draping.

Because of the pick-up of the cometary ion, and them being accelerated in the direction of the convective electric field of the solar wind, the solar wind plasma has to react by moving into the opposite direction (I guess you did not read the Deca paper). The IMF is still frozen into the solar wind plasma flow, and thus in front of the comet the draping is "upward" (Koenders et al., 2016). This effect extends into the region behind the comet in the near tail, and beyond ~500 km it reverts/rotates to more classical draping.

Just got the acceptance email.

So here we are with charge separation back in the fore!

Do you actually read what I write to explain stuff to you?
What charge separation????
 
In that case your beloved current carrying double layers may be created

Why would you not expect a double layer when for instance Charged particle signatures of the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

And a double layer would not be expected because....?????

Because of the magnetic field. In my humble opinion, the field is way to turbulent and the particle motions, to set up a double layer, which will have a size of tens of Debye lengths, which for n=100 cm^-3, and 100 eV ions would be: lambd_D = 50 m. (taking the values of the Nemeth paper, you might want to give the links too, so that people know what paper you are talking about)

Now we have to compare this to other important quantities like gyro radii of ions and electrons, in a magnetic field of ~20 nT, which for 100 eV are 1 km for electrons and and 50 km for protons!

oh..MHD will not allow it and that will make the maths just too hard, so therefore it MUST not happen.

This has nothing to do with using MHD or not. Plasma physics is indeed a bit more complicated that MHD, but if that would keep us from doing our job, we would all be like you.
 
Because Y. V. Skorov is in the bad books already , Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko with that paper.

http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016Natur.538...72F

Skorov is not in the bad books, he just says that HIS models cannot explain gas drag lifting off small dust.

On the other hand a strong electric field will do it with ease and would be expected too!

Now all we need to find is electric currents supporting current carrying double layers and i’d Say we could close the book on that chapter and go to the interesting stuff. What if we mimic a comet?

How strong is strong?
But of course you got no answers.
 
Little home work to bring you up to speed, papers available via the usual sources.

1. Is the dust charged?
2. When does it become charged? (how close to the nucleus)
3. Does that charged dust ‘couple’ to the surrounding plasma?
3. Are there electric fields at a comet?
4. How are the electric fields formed and sustained and Where do they start and end, what size and strength are they?
5 what happens to the dust from the time it ‘leaves’ the surface till we no longer detect it?
6 the composition of the dust

How about you teach us MS peeps something?
 
Ok, no worries.

Moving along...jets on a comet, the death of the dirtysnowball.

Why? Surely the jets were the death knell for this EU idiocy, no? Such as the highly energetic CO2 jets at Hartley 2. Which were entraining H2O ice grains. When said ice grains were visible in the images from that comet.
I think that what you meant to say was that the total lack of any electrical woo on the comet nucleus, as predicted on this very forum by D. Talbott, was the death of the electric comet woo. Not to mention the total lack of rock. You are still batting zero. No amount of diversion, obfuscation or gish galloping is going to alter the fact that the electric comet woo is dead. Provably so. Predictably so.
 
But B. Gundlach1, J. Blum1, H. U. Keller and are incorrect, are they not jd116?

Because Y. V. Skorov is in the bad books already , Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko with that paper.

http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016Natur.538...72F

So what’s happening there jd116 with the charged organic, refractory, dehydrated ‘dust’ from the nucleus? ‘Ice’ is looking less and less likely.

Sublimation is having a harder and harder time ‘splain’n the ‘dust’ release from the nucleus of a comet....


On the other hand a strong electric field will do it with ease and would be expected too!

Now all we need to find is electric currents supporting current carrying double layers and i’d Say we could close the book on that chapter and go to the interesting stuff. What if we mimic a comet?


Wrong. Firstly, there are no current carrying double layers. Two years of observations by an in-situ spacecraft failed to find any such thing. To keep prattling on about such unobserved phenomena is not going to make them suddenly appear. They do not exist.
Secondly;

Conclusions. Our model can explain the large grains (ranging from 2 cm to 1 m in radius) in the inner coma of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko that have been observed by the OSIRIS camera at heliocentric distances between 3.4 AU and 3.7 AU. Furthermore, the model predicts the release of decimeter-sized aggregates (trail particles) close to the heliocentric distance at which the gas-driven dust activity vanishes. However, the gas-driven dust activity cannot explain the presence of particles smaller than ~1 mm in the coma because the high tensile strength required to detach these particles from the surface cannot be provided by evaporation of volatile ices. These smaller particles can be produced for instance by spin-up and centrifugal mass loss of ejected larger aggregates.

What drives the dust activity of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko?
B. Gundlach, J. Blum, H. U. Keller and Y. V. Skorov
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2015/11/aa25828-15/aa25828-15.html
 
One has to wonder just how long Sol88 will keep this drivel up .. and whether or not he knows that its perfectly obvious to observers that he has a clear obsession with trying to gain Tusenfem's attention? (I think its called 'stalking' ..)

His pititful attempts at trying to 'refocus' Tusenfem on the various incarnations of his EC delusion are quite hilarious. Thank goodness Tusenfem is open to scientific arguments (and not EU Acolyte led Liturgies).

Thanks to Reality Check also .. I find RC's posts summarize nicely the long and sordid history behind Sol88's delusion. They're quite handy for newcomers to the thread.
(I 'get' RC's date format too .. its a Southern Hemisphere convention thing ... Mozina at cult HQ was wrong about that, also).

They have been engaging in the same blather rinse repeat for quite a while.
:)
 
Sol88: A "jets on a comet, the death of the dirtysnowball" lie

Moving along....
More adding to a litany of lies:
7 December 2017 Sol88: A "jets on a comet, the death of the dirtysnowball" lie.
Cometary jets are evidence for comets being made of ices and dust because they contain gases from sublimated ices, icy grains and dust grains. We have images of jets issuing from inside of pits on 67P. We have traced jets back to fractured cliff walls and plains.
Cometary jets are one way to measure the density of comets. They change the comet orbit (Newton's laws!). That change allows the mass of a comet to be double, triple or quadruple checked from other methods! Divide by the volume of the comet and we have its density.

What we will get is repeated delusions that have been debunked for many years in this forum alone, e.g. that the jets are electrical discharges. Or the idiocy of imagined flaws in working science = insanely ignorant delusions have to be right.
 
Last edited:
No, not "everything is on the table", there is draping, but not in the classical way that Alfvén described, which also did not incorporate nested draping.

Because of the pick-up of the cometary ion, and them being accelerated in the direction of the convective electric field of the solar wind, the solar wind plasma has to react by moving into the opposite direction (I guess you did not read the Deca paper). The IMF is still frozen into the solar wind plasma flow, and thus in front of the comet the draping is "upward" (Koenders et al., 2016). This effect extends into the region behind the comet in the near tail, and beyond ~500 km it reverts/rotates to more classical draping.

Just got the acceptance email.



Do you actually read what I write to explain stuff to you?
What charge separation????

No charge separation, ok got it!

The Super Duper Plasma Physicist says NO!
 
Figure 9. AA: The crossing of a current sheet on 6 June 2015. In the gray box the cone angle of the magnetic
field changes strongly over more than 100
◦. This rotation of the field coincides with a minimum in
total magnetic field and a maximum in electron density, indicating the crossing of a current sheet. (See also
Volwerk et al. [2016b]) BB: The signature of a magnetic flux rope in 67P/CG’s magnetosheath. The data in
minimum variance coordinates show the characteristic signature of a flux rope. (Taken from Edberg et al.
[2016a])
Currents in Cometary Comae

'cos i'm so dense, my ANY plasma physicist care to try and tell me what a MAGNETIC FLUX ROPE is in this circumstance?

This means that the induced magnetosphere around a comet consists of a complex geometry of magnetic fields, as if a large amount of different kinds of curtains have been draped around the nucleus. One of the consequences of these rotations of the magnetic field is that there will be current sheets generated in the coma.

5 Harris and co. In a region where oppositely directed magnetic fields meet, a current sheet will be generated, by necessity of Amp`ere’s law:
bit like "magnetagic" reconnection.

When a comet enters the region inside the orbit of Jupiter, the solar irradiation is strong enough to start heating the nucleus and for the volatiles to start sublimating. In order to model the outgassing of a comet at a rate of Qn [molecules s..1], a spherical expansion is assumed where the gas moves away from the nucleus at a velocity of Ve [m/s]. The neutrals gas, escaping from the comet will get ionized by solar UV radiation and/or collisions with the solar wind at a rate of . [s..1]. Using this, the radial dependence of the neutral gas density Nn can be formulated by the Haser [1957] model : The number of ions that are implanted per second into the solar wind is then given by Qi = .Nn [see also, Huddleston et al., 1990].
Well that's completely wrong but as long as it make your maths easer.

no real point to the post, just for m information everytime i think there might be something going on plasma/electrical wise.
 
nicecherry picking quote mining, sol

if you actually would read my papers you would see that i give a reason why there is no magnetic reconnection
the flux tube seen by edberg is from solar wind origin if i am not mistaken

now start answering questions please, explain your model above fully for us dumb ms peeps

i am off for the long weekend
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom