Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sol88: A mainstream & math lie and stupidity to derail from his comet delusions

The maths has got the mainstream by the short n curlies!
15 December 2017 Sol88: A mainstream & math lie and stupidity to derail from his comet delusions.
No math has "the mainstream by the short n curlies". The math supports the rational conclusion that comets are made of ices and dust, etc.
The stupidity is emphasizing yet again that all he has is ignorant delusions about comets with no math at all :jaw-dropp

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :eek: !
 
Sol88: Unsupported assertions and insults as answers to 7 year old questions

1. How exactly does the EC nucleus get charged ...
15 December 2017 Sol88: Unsupported assertions, comet delusions, a lie and insults as answers to 7 year old questions!

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.

The lie is that no electric field at comets means no electric comet delusion. He is lying about his delusions where there is an electric field between the Sun and comets!
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
What do you think the ELECTRIC COMET idiots think the ELECTRIC FEILDS do?

What do you think the “dirtysnowball” mainstream Demigod’s think the ELECTRIc fields do?

Where in the standard dirty snowball model do the ‘lectric fields fit in?

apparently at the EC electric fields discharge, do EDM, create water and other impossible stuff
but who knows, not even the gurus of thunderdolts actually have an EC model, it's only an idea, as one of them stated here on ISF
 
1. How exactly does the EC nucleus get charged? just like EVERYTHING ELSE immersed in flowing plasma.

The "surface charging" seems to be an abstract of a talk. In the end I think this was the paper that came out of it.

You are a plasma physicist are you not, Tusenfem? That's a pretty basic even for this mug!

Is it really so "basic"? Would there not be a reason why comets are not mentioned in the abstract?

Do the plasma parameters change of the course of it's orbit?

Parameters cannot change anything.

2. What makes that on the charged surface EDM can take place? (aparently it is not in balance with its surroundings, the one fact that seems to be charging the nucleus).

Very strong local surface 'lectric fields. As observed the surface of a comet. the rock is charged along with the dust, which funnily enough happens from the same electric fields breaking the rock at the molecular level.

"strong" electric fields have not been observed on the surface of the comet. You are probably thinking of Tom's paper, which was a simulation.

3. this EDM works out the oxygen from the minerals which build the EC. your onto it, long with all the other "stuff" seen in the coma. There is stuff going on in there that no mathmagical formula is going to 'splian.

Just because you don't mathmagical, does not mean that other peeps can.

4. this oxygen combines with the solar wind protons to generate water, which is then released as the EC tail that is observed. https://www.thunderbolts.info/wp/2016/01/06/evidence-of-electrical-activity-on-comet-67p-towards-an-electrochemical-framework-for-cometary-phenomena/

Dranariba does not understand plasma physics. Is it even energetically possible for released O and solar wind H to recombine?

So ELECTRIC FIELDS are very important for the ELECTRIC COMET. No electric fields no electric comet!

No, this should read, "EC-electric fields are very important for the electric comet. No EC-electric fields no electric comet." And guess what, the EC-electric fields do not exist.
 
apparently at the EC electric fields discharge, do EDM, create water and other impossible stuff
but who knows, not even the gurus of thunderdolts actually have an EC model, it's only an idea, as one of them stated here on ISF

:thumbsup:
 
No, this should read, "EC-electric fields are very important for the electric comet. No EC-electric fields no electric comet." And guess what, the EC-electric fields do not exist.

Beginner! :boxedin:

TUSENFEM THE SUPER SUPER PLASMA physicist say NO ELECTRIC FIELDS at COMETS. :eek:
 
Identification of comet Hyakutake's extremely long ion tail from magnetic field signatures Geraint H. Jones*, Andre Balogh* & Timothy S. Horbury

The presence of a coherent structure so far from the nucleus
suggests that the plasma tails of comets may persist as discrete
entities for many astronomical units. As the tail of Hyakutake
persisted to Ulysses, it is likely that this structure, ultimately
produced by an object only ,2.4 km across23, survived to reach
the edge of the heliosphere
.
:eek:

there's the answer to my question to you SUPER DUPER PLASMA physicist


The structure seen in the tail is the same as in your paper @550 million kilometres! and the diameter of the tail is larger than the Sun!

The mighty dirtysnowball!!!!!

I wonder if the currents in the comets tail radiate in the microwave?
 
Last edited:
So any real electric fields at any real comets tusenfem, super duper plasma physicist?

Don’t be coy now.
 
no
tusenfem the super Duper plasma physicist says no EC electric fields at real comets
you really cannot read, can you?


Tusenfem, are you familiar with Harri Laakso work on the Halley's comet data?

Do you think he is a crank?
 
It's not like we sent a spaceship to a Comet packed with experiments, sensors and cameras to have a look.

Hang on a minute ...

and did that spaceship confirm the "dirtysnowball" hypothesis?

I'd say, you are just as ignorant as you were before you sent the probe!

it was expected to find a "dirtysnowball" :blush:

Are there and unexpected and significant findings from the Rosetta mission?
 
Originally Posted by Sol88 View Post
4. this oxygen combines with the solar wind protons to generate water, which is then released as the EC tail that is observed. https://www.thunderbolts.info/wp/201...ary-phenomena/

Dranariba does not understand plasma physics. Is it even energetically possible for released O and solar wind H to recombine?

Do you think they are just whizzing around recombining?

You poor misguided soul!

Dranariba does not understand plasma physics, like you understand electro chemistry!

that's the threat the mainstream has against the EU, it's interdisciplinary.

And that's a threat to the status quo.
 
Tusenfem, are you familiar with Harri Laakso work on the Halley's comet data?

Do you think he is a crank?

no he is a very nice and clever colleague
and as usual you d not read, i say no EC electric fields at comets that do magical stuf
 
Do you think they are just whizzing around recombining?

You poor misguided soul!

Dranariba does not understand plasma physics, like you understand electro chemistry!

that's the threat the mainstream has against the EU, it's interdisciplinary.

And that's a threat to the status quo.

is this supposed to be an answer? and if yes, to what?

i asked if recombination csn ocur, as you, sol, write it seems to happen (apparently in the tail from your quote :
Originally Posted by Sol88 View Post
4. this oxygen combines with the solar wind protons to generate water, which is then released as the EC tail that is observed. )
 
Last edited:
Dranariba does not understand plasma physics, like you understand electro chemistry!


Dr Anariba doesn’t understand electrochemistry if he thinks it occurs in the absence of an electrolyte, e.g. under the environmental conditions on or near a comet. But this has been pointed out to you before and I expect you will ignore or forget it now, as you evidently did then.

My suspicion here is that Anariba misapplies the term “electrochemistry” to EC woo for the usual woo reasons, in hopes it will make EC nonsense seem scientific.

Somewhat OT: While looking into Anariba's bacground, I found an interesting page of student evaluations of his teaching.

Dr. Anariba is right now leading my list as the worst teacher I have had at Cal Poly. He gives three tests a few quizzes and two papers to be done as a group. The papers were a complete waste of time and on the first one he wrote on our paper that it was poorly written then proceeded to give us full points for it. He also is the only teacher I have ever had who seemed as if he didn't know the material he was teacher. On one occasion we spent ten minutes trying to point out a mistake he made during a calculations and when we finally got him to see it be brushed it off like the assumption he made we should take for granted even though it was wrong! He was also surprised by something he saw on the periodic table and he said "In my 3o years of chemistry I have never seen that before" but we had all known about that particular quirk on the table since high school chem! Moral of the story if you want a teacher who breathes incompetence take Anariba other wise you are better off waiting a quarter or finding a different section.

http://polyratings.com/eval.php?profid=2820
 
@fred

Are you aware of proton implantation into to silica wafers is semiconductor manufacture?

Local vibrational modes of weakly bound O-H complexes in Si. B. Bech Nielsen, K. Tanderup, M. Budde, K. Bonde Nielsen, J. L. Lindström, R. Jones, S. Öberg, B. Hourahine, and P. R. Briddon, in "Defects in Semiconductors 19", edited by G. Davies and M. H. Nazaré, Materials Science Forum Vol. (Trans Tech, Aedermannsdorf, 1998), p. 391.

Same thing happening at a comet

OH is formed in this way to be released as a highly reactive radical, later forming water which also becomes ionised becoming all the water group ions we observe.

And if the energy is high enough nuclear transmutation can occur.

Which just need something to accelerate ions to high energies.....mmmmmmm

And just like that, we are back to double layers and electric fields!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom